Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Another look at LET THE RIGHT ONE IN - & why the Academy's Policy for Considering BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM is broken!

Hey folks, Harry here... I'm broken hearted. You see, LET THE RIGHT ONE IN is my pick for best film of the year - and yet... because its country of origin didn't offer it up as the film representing its country, it will not even be considered for BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM, which at the very least... it is. This is why that award in the Academy Awards is broken. When you depend upon a host nation to offer up a film for consideration for BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM, you are forced to consider only the films that the nation in question feels artistically represent their country. As a result, films critical of their current country's policies and politics - won't be offered up. A film in a genre that is, perhaps, not a genre that the host country deems as being "proper" - goes unappreciated. At the very least the Academy needs to expand the nominating field to the films released domestically in the United States under the same rules as the rest of the English Speaking films. It is fair, it allows for the truly BEST films to even be considered. However, to have a film that has won the acclaim that LET THE RIGHT ONE IN has, and have that film go completely ignored for even the nominating process... frankly, it is unjust and beneath the standard that the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts & Sciences purports to endorse. It is, of course, too late to do anything this year, but the governing board should seriously look at changing and reexamining the rules for this category.

Meanwhile, more of you need to seek out and experience the brilliance of LET THE RIGHT ONE IN, like this fellow... who was profoundly taken with the film.

If you should run this, you can call me Chance Gardener. I like to watch.

I seldom write online reviews of films, though I love movies and see a lot of them. I regularly read your site, and consider it my frontline link to fresh news about films.

I'm a full time freelance Disney artist/writer, and am fairly discriminating when it comes to story. The last film that really knocked my socks to the degree that the the subject of this review does was Peter Jackson's "The Lord of the Rings"...so this movie is really something special to me.

It's a little film. It lacks the huge budget of LOTR and is directed by some guy I never heard of in Sweden with two first time twelve year olds in the lead.

But you know what? "Let the Right One In" is an instant classic; one of those rare masterpieces that come out of nowhere, and is going to be remembered, I think, as one of, if not the very best, vampire movies of all time.

This is a seriously great film, not only in the horror genre, but compared to any movie.

This is the story of 12 year old bullied Oskar, who is angelically blonde and fair, and his newly moved in friend, Eli, who is raven haired, dark and mysterious.

These two tweens are kindred spirits. Oskar is very alone, with no friends. He is brutalized daily in school, his parents separated with problems that leave him quite without any meaningful relationships. He acts out getting revenge on his tormentors with a knife, but at the same time we see he is intelligent and very, very sensitive.

Eli has problems of her own. She has the confidence that Oskar lacks, but is even more desperate than poor Oskar for human understanding and companionship.

See, as Eli says in understated fashion, she has been 12 for "a long time".

This film is unique. It offers the viewer about as wide a breadth of feelings, of questions on the human condition, as any film in recent memory.

It does this with a touching, fragile and quite beautiful relationship between this hurt boy and this achingly lonely ageless girl.

The scenes between these two offered to this viewer the finest portrayal of the angst of growing up ever seen on the big screen.

These haunting and sad scenes are set between horrorific moments of mayhem and bloodshed. The resulting impact on the viewer is a mix of emotions. We find ourselves rooting for the protagonists, even if one of the them is a monster, and we are chilled even as we are sucked into their believable and poignant relationship.

This is a seriously difficult film.

I have not found myself pondering so many difficult and various conundrums, the likes of which this frankly brilliant film tasks me with, in a very long while.

In a world where awards programs aren't reliant on Hollywood glitz and big name actors, this movie could...actually, deserves, to win a many, many top awards.

The cinematography is isolated, geometric and stark. The shots are beautifully worked out, and often the more "action" oriented pieces are shot in ways surprising and original.

The CGI work is especially clever, subtle and unsettling, with the lead character, Eli's eyes sometimes seeming larger than they should, and her movements seem sometimes unearthly.

The sound work for Eli is among the finest horror work I've ever witnessed, with brilliant cat like stomach weirdness when the little girl is unfed. She is almost a muttering vampire-Popeye of Fleischer Studio's fame....with her underpinning of subtle growls, teeth grinding, smacking and general understated otherworldly noises escaping her left me afraid and breathless.

One has to give huge credit to Swedish director Tomas Alfredson for his brilliant handling of this material. The snow and ice laden setting seems to simplify the backgrounds, allowing us to more easily focus on the two protagonists. He relies heavily on their expressions and sounds in lieu of a lot of dialogue, which, of course, is the way real people actually communicate. This adds greatly to a feeling of their relationship being real.

The film builds over time, with both Oskar and Eli giving little bits of themselves to each other. A bond forms that seems sweet and doomed, until Oskar saves Eli, and Eli saves Oskar...or did they?

Are they cursed, or blessed? The real greatness to this wonderful, objectionable, no holds barred masterpiece of horror cinema is, there is no answer to the questions laid at our feet.

We each are forced into considering the plight of Eli and Oskar, and there is a great deal to think about. I've never felt this way before.

A priceless, uniquely sad movie on what it is to be a human being.

Guillermo del Toro describes "Let the Right One In" as 'as delicate, haunting and poetic a film as your ever bound to see'.

The Best Film of 2008.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

First?
by Xandar1977
Jan 13th, 2009
03:49:17 PM
Man, I always hate douchebags that post First
by Xandar1977
Jan 13th, 2009
03:49:46 PM
IS IT BETTER THAN TWILIGHT?
by BADBOYBROM HC
Jan 13th, 2009
03:54:25 PM
for real: see this movie.
by Gatsbys West Egg Omlet
Jan 13th, 2009
03:55:28 PM
and yes,
by Gatsbys West Egg Omlet
Jan 13th, 2009
03:56:41 PM
The recommendation from del Toro...
by 11ZOMBIES
Jan 13th, 2009
03:56:54 PM
It was good but not that good
by horvak
Jan 13th, 2009
03:58:02 PM
Fantastic Film
by ScottinDC
Jan 13th, 2009
03:58:21 PM
art VS genre
by Gatsbys West Egg Omlet
Jan 13th, 2009
04:00:02 PM
The thing is...
by NoLaw4000
Jan 13th, 2009
04:00:13 PM
My favorite of 2008... But the CGI Cats...
by stlfilmwire
Jan 13th, 2009
04:00:58 PM
I Hope This Lives Up To The Hype
by Broseph
Jan 13th, 2009
04:04:29 PM
Saw this a couple of weeks ago...
by PsimonSez
Jan 13th, 2009
04:05:49 PM
Not Eligible This Year - Eligible Next Year
by YND
Jan 13th, 2009
04:05:51 PM
"nothing new" horvak?
by PsimonSez
Jan 13th, 2009
04:08:59 PM
This film is overated ...
by can-D
Jan 13th, 2009
04:18:48 PM
Ahhh, a post that feels like old-school, classic AICN
by D.Vader
Jan 13th, 2009
04:20:13 PM
Well the Oscars have been broken for years.
by DigitalDong
Jan 13th, 2009
04:21:33 PM
Chance has chosen Let the Right One In and here why...
by Shepard Wong
Jan 13th, 2009
04:24:12 PM
Great, great film
by SpawnofAchilles
Jan 13th, 2009
04:25:27 PM
the book reminds me
by SpawnofAchilles
Jan 13th, 2009
04:26:44 PM
Great film- tragedy disguised as romance.
by Flim Springfield
Jan 13th, 2009
04:29:24 PM
anyone else who saw it confused...
by SpawnofAchilles
Jan 13th, 2009
04:32:36 PM
Can-D did you even see this movie?
by ScottinDC
Jan 13th, 2009
04:34:12 PM
Academy!
by laraz
Jan 13th, 2009
04:34:13 PM
Can anybody explain to me this movie's appeal?
by MyManD316
Jan 13th, 2009
04:49:14 PM
harry, have you seen the swedish nomination?
by lex romero
Jan 13th, 2009
04:49:27 PM
Gomorra
by FraDolcino
Jan 13th, 2009
04:51:10 PM
Lex romero
by NoLaw4000
Jan 13th, 2009
04:59:38 PM
Isn't Harry being condescending to Sweden?
by MyManD316
Jan 13th, 2009
04:59:41 PM
wait, is YND right?
by filmfanatic1
Jan 13th, 2009
05:03:53 PM
filmfanatic1
by NoLaw4000
Jan 13th, 2009
05:06:32 PM
people won't get onboard with this film...
by IAmLegolas
Jan 13th, 2009
05:07:05 PM
i agree mymand316
by soup74
Jan 13th, 2009
05:09:29 PM
Am I the only one
by starmand
Jan 13th, 2009
05:12:04 PM
Harry please delete the spoilerific post by MyManD316!!
by BadMrWonka
Jan 13th, 2009
05:16:55 PM
YND isn't right...
by MyManD316
Jan 13th, 2009
05:17:56 PM
BadMrWonka...
by MyManD316
Jan 13th, 2009
05:19:25 PM
i might be kicking in an open door but
by Basehead
Jan 13th, 2009
05:29:29 PM
A great little film
by mcordy
Jan 13th, 2009
05:35:06 PM
its good - but its not that good
by Cedar_Room
Jan 13th, 2009
05:36:22 PM
On a completely unrelated note
by jmyoung666
Jan 13th, 2009
05:37:09 PM
Indy Indy Indy...
by ScottinDC
Jan 13th, 2009
05:40:39 PM
Sweet Love Story??
by Lang The Cat
Jan 13th, 2009
05:41:35 PM
YND is right
by Ditch Brodie
Jan 13th, 2009
05:41:47 PM
Well it's not Eckhardt's opinions that matter- it's Nolan's
by D.Vader
Jan 13th, 2009
05:42:09 PM
this was a good movie, but not a masterpiece
by bluetunehead
Jan 13th, 2009
05:45:51 PM
also
by bluetunehead
Jan 13th, 2009
05:47:14 PM
Harry - Questions plus SPOILERS
by toshiro-solo
Jan 13th, 2009
06:02:37 PM
THIS is why Gus Van Rant's Canadian documentary on Tony Danza wa
by Chief Redcock
Jan 13th, 2009
06:14:19 PM
wasn't nominated . . .
by Chief Redcock
Jan 13th, 2009
06:14:40 PM
Toshiro-Solo-- POSSIBLE SPOILERS
by Kirbymanly
Jan 13th, 2009
06:15:04 PM
Kirbymanly
by toshiro-solo
Jan 13th, 2009
06:28:00 PM
Their Music catagory is FUBAR too
by blindambition238
Jan 13th, 2009
06:36:48 PM
Oskar's dad: gay or...
by Some Dude
Jan 13th, 2009
06:40:21 PM
Some Dude... SPOILER
by Kirbymanly
Jan 13th, 2009
06:58:23 PM
MyManD316
by BadMrWonka
Jan 13th, 2009
07:14:04 PM
dont know how dark knight came up..
by soup74
Jan 13th, 2009
07:23:05 PM
Harry, you're completely wrong on why it is not nominated
by Kirbymanly
Jan 13th, 2009
07:30:29 PM
Playing in Boulder on January 30th and 31st
by jimmay
Jan 13th, 2009
07:35:25 PM
so...
by kaspianwithak
Jan 13th, 2009
07:44:42 PM
Why does anyone care about Oscar?
by matthooper8
Jan 13th, 2009
07:50:06 PM
KirbyManly
by Some Dude
Jan 13th, 2009
07:54:57 PM
Better than the DArk Knight!!!!
by aportee
Jan 13th, 2009
07:57:29 PM
BadMrWonka...
by MyManD316
Jan 13th, 2009
08:29:49 PM
Great movie
by Berserkr
Jan 13th, 2009
08:39:49 PM
I really want to see this
by quadrupletree
Jan 13th, 2009
08:43:51 PM
Let the right one in Playing in Normal, Ill...
by aportee
Jan 13th, 2009
08:48:56 PM
Some Dude
by Kirbymanly
Jan 13th, 2009
08:49:25 PM
So what you're saying is, the academy won't...
by SilentP
Jan 13th, 2009
08:49:57 PM
SPOILER! What I really liked about the movie...
by Organs
Jan 13th, 2009
08:52:08 PM
oskar's dad, cont. *SPOILERS*
by vaudeville villain
Jan 13th, 2009
08:59:48 PM
This movie is the shit's tit!
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 13th, 2009
09:00:10 PM
oh, and about the old man *SPOILERS*
by vaudeville villain
Jan 13th, 2009
09:04:55 PM
great movie
by thecrimsoncurse
Jan 13th, 2009
09:17:56 PM
Not even playing in L.A.
by landosystem
Jan 13th, 2009
09:41:25 PM
a few points (and a few SPOILERS)
by maxwell's hammer
Jan 13th, 2009
09:47:17 PM
Am I the only one...
by FuryofthefilmFan
Jan 13th, 2009
10:00:12 PM
So overhyped
by schnipple
Jan 13th, 2009
10:04:09 PM
one more point (and one more SPOILER)
by vaudeville villain
Jan 13th, 2009
10:04:47 PM
What is Magnolia doing?
by rainbowtrout1265
Jan 13th, 2009
10:05:29 PM
it was a cop-out
by rainbowtrout1265
Jan 13th, 2009
10:08:48 PM
FuryofthefilmFan
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 13th, 2009
10:25:55 PM
vaudville...
by maxwell's hammer
Jan 13th, 2009
10:36:17 PM
a gay love story
by FuryofthefilmFan
Jan 13th, 2009
11:19:38 PM
A good movie, but I don't know about the best...
by robertkent.net
Jan 13th, 2009
11:42:54 PM
FuryofthefilmFan
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 13th, 2009
11:46:37 PM
I thought The Dark Knight was way better
by robertkent.net
Jan 13th, 2009
11:51:46 PM
robertkent
by maxwell's hammer
Jan 14th, 2009
12:08:00 AM
Don't worry, Harry
by My friends call me Killjoy
Jan 14th, 2009
12:18:54 AM
FuckMichaelBay
by aportee
Jan 14th, 2009
12:20:03 AM
Maxwell's Hammer
by robertkent.net
Jan 14th, 2009
12:24:41 AM
Maxwell's Hammer Part 2
by robertkent.net
Jan 14th, 2009
12:42:16 AM
Maxwell's Hammer
by My friends call me Killjoy
Jan 14th, 2009
12:43:21 AM
Yeah, those CG cats unsettled me alright.
by BenBraddock
Jan 14th, 2009
12:53:30 AM
I agree Aportee
by FuryofthefilmFan
Jan 14th, 2009
01:08:39 AM
So.... when is Harry going to suck it up and admit
by Kirbymanly
Jan 14th, 2009
01:33:03 AM
Bacci40...
by Kirbymanly
Jan 14th, 2009
02:58:51 AM
And now I shoot myself in the foot....
by Kirbymanly
Jan 14th, 2009
03:01:45 AM
And be forced to deal with their Horrid Crap
by PTSDPete
Jan 14th, 2009
03:23:28 AM
Cats, Crotch and Booze
by stonejackit
Jan 14th, 2009
04:17:51 AM
wHY ISN'T IT ELIGIBLE FOR best fim
by workshed
Jan 14th, 2009
04:26:04 AM
This piece of shit Microsoft keyboard is garbage...
by workshed
Jan 14th, 2009
04:28:11 AM
Best Film Oscar..?
by workshed
Jan 14th, 2009
04:45:56 AM
also
by FuryofthefilmFan
Jan 14th, 2009
06:01:50 AM
Does it really matter...
by BiggusDickus
Jan 14th, 2009
06:13:43 AM
Why does he keep holding the boy underwater?
by Prior Walter
Jan 14th, 2009
06:41:17 AM
i know prior
by Basehead
Jan 14th, 2009
06:54:59 AM
It's good...it's really good...
by sonnyfern
Jan 14th, 2009
08:16:30 AM
the most interesting thing of the whole film...
by RockLobster800
Jan 14th, 2009
08:48:21 AM
Batman is dead.
by most excellent ninja
Jan 14th, 2009
09:38:56 AM
One of the best lines from an an oscar loser..
by emeraldboy
Jan 14th, 2009
10:12:37 AM
Let the right one in will not be nominated...
by emeraldboy
Jan 14th, 2009
10:19:26 AM
FuryofthefilmFan / Aportee
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 14th, 2009
10:34:06 AM
FuryofthefilmFan / Aportee
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 14th, 2009
10:35:36 AM
It is quite a good film
by MontyPigeon
Jan 14th, 2009
12:04:58 PM
emeraldboy
by most excellent ninja
Jan 14th, 2009
12:18:36 PM
FkMichaelBay
by FuryofthefilmFan
Jan 14th, 2009
12:36:49 PM
Maria Larsson's Everlasting Moments
by TheNorthlander
Jan 14th, 2009
02:12:17 PM
To all of you discussing if Eli's a MAN or not
by atomride
Jan 14th, 2009
04:29:29 PM
FuryofthefilmFan
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 14th, 2009
04:45:07 PM
atomride
by FuckMichaelBay
Jan 14th, 2009
04:49:40 PM
A masterpiece, really
by cifra
Jan 14th, 2009
06:54:34 PM
It's not just a "friendship"
by rainbowtrout1265
Jan 14th, 2009
07:37:46 PM
Thanks for playing
by atomride
Jan 14th, 2009
09:18:02 PM
by the way
by atomride
Jan 14th, 2009
09:34:50 PM
cifra...
by maxwell's hammer
Jan 14th, 2009
10:20:57 PM
I am in the group of people who thinks that
by emeraldboy
Jan 15th, 2009
06:42:25 AM
In the baftas 2009...
by emeraldboy
Jan 15th, 2009
06:46:33 AM
Read "The Stolen Child"
by Chakalak
Jan 15th, 2009
11:28:33 AM
OVER-FUCKIN-HYPED
by ToughGuyRizzo
Jan 16th, 2009
07:03:17 AM
Someone said the cats looked fake... not true.
by Mt. Top
Apr 9th, 2009
09:00:09 AM
Ignore the hype and don't wast your time
by HateDragon
Apr 21st, 2009
08:32:22 AM
Listen to Hatedragon, only his opinion matters
by Orcus
Apr 21st, 2009
02:53:13 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.