Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Grib Sees Dakota Fanning And David Morse In HOUNDDOG

Merrick here...

Grib sent in this look at HOUNDDOG.

There's a lot of controversy swirling around this film -- one sequence features the rape of 12 year old Dakota Fanning.

This isn't the first time a film's taken us here, but...even so...it's always an incendiary, disquieting, and haunting path.

Here's Grib to talk a bit about how it's handled this time around...

Grib here with a review of "Hounddog," a film elevated by a searing performance by Dakota Fanning:

"Hounddog" is a deeply moving film that generated a lot of pre-Festival controversy due to a scene in which the young actress Dakota Fanning is raped. Although that scene would be repulsive due to its subject matter alone, it is handled as tastefully as possible: the camera focuses on Fanning's face, hands, and feet, and the scene does not linger exploitatively. It is as brief as it could be while still getting its impact across.

The film centers on Lewellen (Fanning), a young girl of about eleven growing up in a rundown shack in the 1950s South with her beer-gutted, leering father (David Morse), just up the road from her maternal grandmother (Piper Laurie). Coming from a town of 400 in the poor rural South, I generally object to cinematic depictions of this region (with the notable exception of "Junebug"), and I must say that director Deborah Kampmeier lays it on thickly here: the paint is peeling off of Lewellen's shack, and all the screen doors squeak.

Abandoned cars lie around all over the backyard; only the slow progress of history keeps satellite dishes from sprouting from every available roof space. All the characters sport a sheen of sweat, and beer is consumed 24/7. But if this must be where the film is set, so be it. It's the acting that matters, particularly the blistering performance of Dakota Fanning, who has one hell of a future ahead of her if she's taken the requisite don't-become-the-next-Lindsay-Lohan courses.

I won't reveal the exact circumstances of the controversial scene, as it is central to the film's power. I will say that the handling of the inappropriate way that Lewellen's father behaves around and toward her is well-done. It is not over-the-top, but it exposes issues that are still with us today. The performances are all excellent. I wish that Laurie's character had been developed beyond the shrill, one-note racist Bible-thumper that we're left with, but she does a good job nonetheless. Also left underdeveloped for reasons more plotbound is the mother figure who hovers around the edges of Lewellen's life without ever really stepping in. Robin Wright Penn, asked to deliver yet another rough-hewn, chain-smoking character, gives a wonderful portrait of a woman unlucky enough to fall in with the likes of Lewellen's abusive father.

But the real reason to see "Hounddog" is Fanning. She does things in this film that would challenge an actress twice her age. Her emotional range is limitless, and her wonderfully expressive face and saucer-like eyes are incredible assets. Lewellen worships Elvis, and often breaks into song as a means of escaping her painful world. Fanning handles these scenes admirably, fully embodying Lewellen's fleeting reveries.

There is a motif involving snakes that is interesting. Lewellen befriends a local stablehand, an African American man who respects the poisonous snakes of the region and bleeds them of their poison to use in antidotes. He tutors Lewellen on the proper regard for these creatures, and he notes that she has a rare and special ability to turn the potential badness in snakes into good. He also introduces her to the blues roots of Elvis' music (which creates a nice cameo opportunity for gospel/pop diva Jill Scott), a lesson that serves her well later in the film. The snakes work on several levels, with obvious Biblical significance in addition to the practical dangers they represent to the characters.

I'm sure "Hounddog" is going to have a hell of a time with the MPAA, with or without revised rules. There just aren't a lot of precedents for this movie, and however deftly handled the subject matter is, there are still folks who aren't going to let it in their theaters. I hope it makes it into one near you.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

I See Dog
by BannedOnTheRun
Jan 23rd, 2007
04:40:56 PM
FINALLY! Preteen rape on the BIG SCREEN!
by Baron Karza
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:09:43 PM
David Morse GOTTA EAT Dakota Fanning!
by Triumph poops!
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:10:47 PM
Will the African American man be blamed?...
by jimmy_009
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:12:03 PM
You gotta love the Sundance Kid
by Mr Bonefish
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:29:14 PM
WHY this movie is totally creepy...
by Triumph poops!
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:29:22 PM
I'm seeing this wearing nothing but a trenchcoat!
by CTU Mole
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:45:47 PM
LMAO! "Robin Penn, asked to deliver another rough..."
by Triumph poops!
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:49:04 PM
?
by knight_2_bishop_7
Jan 23rd, 2007
05:55:39 PM
To: Triumph Poops
by jimmy rabbitte
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:12:43 PM
Schindler's List and Roots?
by jimmy rabbitte
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:20:55 PM
I wonder...
by jollysleeve
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:22:09 PM
jimmy rabitte: Actual children aren't raped!
by ETI
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:26:29 PM
...at the risk of posting too much too quickly
by jimmy rabbitte
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:27:15 PM
HOW LONG TILL THE SNAKES ON A PLANE JOKES...
by THE KNIGHT
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:28:15 PM
To: ETI
by jimmy rabbitte
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:34:19 PM
I don't see anything wrong with rape...
by veebeeyes
Jan 23rd, 2007
06:41:08 PM
Just wait until PJ's Lovely Bones comes out --
by comedian_x
Jan 23rd, 2007
07:12:36 PM
i just got off the phone with dakota fanning
by crashbarbarian
Jan 23rd, 2007
07:18:21 PM
Okay, poor choice of words.
by veebeeyes
Jan 23rd, 2007
07:23:28 PM
How does it compare with Pretty Baby?
by Gorrister
Jan 23rd, 2007
07:31:42 PM
So?
by radjac33
Jan 23rd, 2007
08:32:30 PM
Dakota Fanning is going hard-edged even faster than
by CreasyBear
Jan 23rd, 2007
08:43:53 PM
TOO SOON
by Pageiv
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:03:21 PM
Fanning is a brilliant actress
by Bronx Cheer
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:05:26 PM
I JUST GOT OFF THE PHONE WITH A VENEMOUS SNAKE
by Hella
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:16:59 PM
My favorite pastime
by Bronx Cheer
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:19:49 PM
I DONT SEE ANYTHING WRONG WITH TERRORISM
by Hella
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:26:12 PM
And I don't see anything wrong with Ethnic cleansing...
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:35:35 PM
I also don't see anything wrong with cannibalism...
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:36:45 PM
I don't see anything wrong with mass murder.....
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:39:59 PM
........come on people jump all over this...
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:42:03 PM
I don't see anything wrong with Harry sliding down....
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:44:06 PM
.......and for a megamix.....
by Kai_Mah'gra
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:49:34 PM
I love how everybody keeps referring to "Hollywood"
by DocBosch
Jan 23rd, 2007
09:49:59 PM
Two words, people: TAXI DRIVER
by FluffyUnbound
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:03:34 PM
Yep, definately the conservatives fault...
by runfoodrun
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:03:43 PM
runfoodrun...
by veebeeyes
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:18:17 PM
Who cares how good the performance is.
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:18:47 PM
"Says a lot about those that feel uncomfortable" - WTF?
by Triumph poops!
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:23:19 PM
"Challenging" role = traumatic to a 12 year old.
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:32:53 PM
veebeeyes
by runfoodrun
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:37:36 PM
And to any excuse makers
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:38:02 PM
Superninja
by runfoodrun
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:41:34 PM
This is why the terrorists attack us
by Omegaman
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:42:43 PM
And Fanning plays a 9 year old in the film.
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:46:18 PM
Maybe Kampmeier's working on a "Child Rape Trilogy"...
by Flim Springfield
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:54:47 PM
A line has been crossed...
by veebeeyes
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:57:07 PM
Her mom and agent never talked Oscar
by ETI
Jan 23rd, 2007
10:59:19 PM
Dakota Fanning learns how to handle deadly snakes...
by Orbots Commander
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:01:46 PM
ETI, how old was the teenager playing the teenager
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:08:05 PM
Symbolism
by Bronx Cheer
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:08:19 PM
Gosh, that didn't take long
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:14:59 PM
Relax Bronx, I just heard about this flick.
by Orbots Commander
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:15:20 PM
Of course everyone is bothered by the fact they have
by superninja
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:17:29 PM
Recognition in any form is still recognition...
by S-Mart shopper
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:19:42 PM
Too soon for a hymen joke?
by S-Mart shopper
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:24:14 PM
Yeeesh.......
by Jimmy Jazz
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:29:25 PM
This isn't exploitive...John Landis beheading kids is
by Doctor_Sin
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:34:38 PM
Hannity's opinions are good ones...
by Dr Gregory House
Jan 23rd, 2007
11:42:38 PM
Decent review Grib, except for your irresponsible line:
by half vader
Jan 24th, 2007
12:00:03 AM
Oh and contoversy notwithstanding Morse is a great
by half vader
Jan 24th, 2007
12:08:54 AM
Get your facts straght Dr. Sin:
by Barry Egan
Jan 24th, 2007
12:26:00 AM
Egan, I'm not splitting hairs w/ you
by Doctor_Sin
Jan 24th, 2007
12:41:42 AM
Dr. Sin, my comment about the beheadings
by Barry Egan
Jan 24th, 2007
12:47:38 AM
Snakes on a Fanning
by LittleDudes
Jan 24th, 2007
12:52:18 AM
If Alison Lohman played this role when she was 18...
by wackybantha
Jan 24th, 2007
01:21:51 AM
Will BIG MAMA THORNTON get a shout out?
by wackybantha
Jan 24th, 2007
01:23:47 AM
grib responds
by grib
Jan 24th, 2007
02:13:45 AM
Lilo & Stitch 4?
by Mako
Jan 24th, 2007
02:42:04 AM
Can someone explain to me why...
by ScienceMan
Jan 24th, 2007
02:44:41 AM
A rape scene with Dakota Fanning?
by Vicenzo
Jan 24th, 2007
02:52:01 AM
Searing! Incendiary! Fanning the flames!
by BannedOnTheRun
Jan 24th, 2007
05:21:05 AM
hmmm...
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
05:39:33 AM
ugh...
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
05:41:35 AM
Yeah....... no thanks.
by Roguewriter
Jan 24th, 2007
06:45:50 AM
let's see
by just pillow talk
Jan 24th, 2007
06:52:47 AM
Is the rape the focus of the film?
by Affleckwasthebomb
Jan 24th, 2007
07:02:28 AM
Sorry, Egan - the whinings of others had gotten to me
by Doctor_Sin
Jan 24th, 2007
07:16:21 AM
But does it deliver the goods?
by WildcatWildcat
Jan 24th, 2007
07:57:18 AM
Idiocy
by CaptDanielRoe
Jan 24th, 2007
08:01:25 AM
I hope not, but...
by Lou Stools
Jan 24th, 2007
08:08:55 AM
Dakota Fannings on a Plane
by boba_rob
Jan 24th, 2007
08:15:01 AM
Sorry, Ole Gravy Leg...
by Roguewriter
Jan 24th, 2007
08:18:42 AM
No...
by CaptDanielRoe
Jan 24th, 2007
08:27:34 AM
Elvis To The Rescue
by PoopAgoose
Jan 24th, 2007
08:30:21 AM
Snakes on the Plains
by Snookeroo
Jan 24th, 2007
08:41:49 AM
This rape scene doesn't sound nearly as bad as...
by TheTerminator
Jan 24th, 2007
09:28:03 AM
Entertainment or art?
by Malik23
Jan 24th, 2007
10:56:58 AM
nobody is 'chastizing' dakota fanning...
by RKDN Del Sol
Jan 24th, 2007
11:05:53 AM
Fanning is so money.
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
11:36:09 AM
I dare tell you it MIGHT be art. You and I don't know.
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
11:48:37 AM
if you go back to caveman days..
by just pillow talk
Jan 24th, 2007
12:03:12 PM
Ill pass
by Knobules
Jan 24th, 2007
12:23:18 PM
"no Bryan Singer Apt Pupil nonsense"
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
12:27:11 PM
Get a grip people
by the_pissboy1
Jan 24th, 2007
12:32:01 PM
Read for yourselves...there's nothing to the scene
by the_pissboy1
Jan 24th, 2007
12:36:33 PM
LAZY DAKOTA!
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
12:37:01 PM
Bubba HoundDog
by Dr Gregory House
Jan 24th, 2007
12:47:09 PM
Sorry, gotta name drop....
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
01:03:56 PM
aw crap, you right pissboy sir
by just pillow talk
Jan 24th, 2007
01:11:52 PM
RE: men feeling uncomfortable [Triumph Poops!]
by DocBosch
Jan 24th, 2007
01:20:58 PM
Rape Is No Laughing Matter...
by NoProblem2
Jan 24th, 2007
01:22:06 PM
Level of depiction
by Malik23
Jan 24th, 2007
01:24:55 PM
RE: nobody is 'chastizing' dakota fanning[RKDN Del Sol]
by DocBosch
Jan 24th, 2007
01:36:07 PM
Cameron1
by Malik23
Jan 24th, 2007
01:39:19 PM
Malik23
by DocBosch
Jan 24th, 2007
01:46:07 PM
BSB, what can't David Morse do?
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
01:49:37 PM
DocBosch, Malik
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
01:54:07 PM
Just because some people get off watching
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
01:55:39 PM
ALIEN 5 Script/Project
by Edward Brock
Jan 24th, 2007
01:57:25 PM
Why was it done at all?
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 24th, 2007
02:16:28 PM
Sounds like a cool date movie
by Itchy
Jan 24th, 2007
02:20:18 PM
I just got off the phone with Jodie Foster
by la_sith
Jan 24th, 2007
02:56:52 PM
Oh silly silly people.
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
03:00:01 PM
Oh and hairy...
by Cameron1
Jan 24th, 2007
03:05:49 PM
New movie theater game!
by BillyPilgrim
Jan 24th, 2007
03:17:33 PM
I just got off the phone with an Asian distributor...
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
04:01:35 PM
Linda Blair's teen years...
by idahomer
Jan 24th, 2007
04:12:38 PM
I just got off the phone with David Morse's dick...
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
04:17:17 PM
If you are outraged by this, you are a moron.
by Bob Cryptonight
Jan 24th, 2007
04:18:21 PM
LET ME KILL THE OSCAR BUZZ...
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
04:21:20 PM
More...
by idahomer
Jan 24th, 2007
04:22:27 PM
Exploitation and children.
by Barry Egan
Jan 24th, 2007
04:26:33 PM
I remember the exact day I first saw...
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
04:37:16 PM
DocBosch
by Malik23
Jan 24th, 2007
04:39:37 PM
Unripe Cherry Popping...
by idahomer
Jan 24th, 2007
04:40:53 PM
Context, people, context
by dcervera
Jan 24th, 2007
04:53:28 PM
It's just a movie.
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
04:54:23 PM
Nothing new here, move along everyone...
by Ironmuskrat
Jan 24th, 2007
05:00:27 PM
Malik
by the_pissboy1
Jan 24th, 2007
05:02:38 PM
This will lead to child rape?
by the_pissboy1
Jan 24th, 2007
05:08:01 PM
Scorcese's balls! Scorcese's balls!
by BannedOnTheRun
Jan 24th, 2007
05:15:50 PM
HELLO?
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
05:22:05 PM
HELLO? HELLO?
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
05:23:26 PM
*69
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
05:30:53 PM
Quit blaming it on Religion
by crashbarbarian
Jan 24th, 2007
05:43:49 PM
Dakota...
by sillymary
Jan 24th, 2007
06:05:25 PM
crashbarbarian
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
06:09:43 PM
Hypocrisy
by kevred
Jan 24th, 2007
06:36:01 PM
This is not fucking porn.
by Nachokoolaid
Jan 24th, 2007
06:58:38 PM
THANK YOU CAPTBOULDER!
by The Ghoul
Jan 24th, 2007
07:13:01 PM
BSB I disagree with most of your posts
by half vader
Jan 24th, 2007
07:25:09 PM
God you people are morons...
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 24th, 2007
07:36:06 PM
"morons"
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
07:44:11 PM
God I need a proofreader
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
07:45:33 PM
FUCKING SNOBS
by GiftedInThePants
Jan 24th, 2007
08:22:13 PM
I own
by GiftedInThePants
Jan 24th, 2007
08:28:24 PM
Yep, it's a good thing...
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 24th, 2007
08:46:59 PM
Done before...
by sillymary
Jan 24th, 2007
09:09:27 PM
"everybody knows"
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
09:21:44 PM
Hairy nutsack...
by veebeeyes
Jan 24th, 2007
09:28:01 PM
Dakota Fanning Gotta Get An Oscar
by AllPowerfulWizardOfOz
Jan 24th, 2007
09:38:49 PM
What if...
by wackybantha
Jan 24th, 2007
10:19:01 PM
Shades of gray?
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 24th, 2007
10:19:52 PM
And another thing....
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 24th, 2007
10:33:58 PM
pointless
by fenario80
Jan 24th, 2007
10:57:19 PM
SUPERNINJA - my reply
by ETI
Jan 24th, 2007
11:01:58 PM
I'd Hit It
by topaz4206
Jan 24th, 2007
11:26:36 PM
I've had friends who were murdered...
by veebeeyes
Jan 24th, 2007
11:35:46 PM
ETI That is an important point ...
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
12:25:44 AM
Fenario80, thy name is creep.
by Mr Bonefish
Jan 25th, 2007
12:53:24 AM
Pix from premiere of Hounddog
by SkinJob69
Jan 25th, 2007
07:40:17 AM
Call me cynical
by sambrook
Jan 25th, 2007
08:09:07 AM
Fanning exploited
by JohnRevik
Jan 25th, 2007
08:10:40 AM
FANNING ASKED FOR IT...
by The Ghoul
Jan 25th, 2007
08:25:38 AM
That's not a one-liner
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
08:35:54 AM
sambrook - statistics
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
09:09:13 AM
Fenario
by sambrook
Jan 25th, 2007
10:06:34 AM
5and5
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
10:09:52 AM
Hey sambrook
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
10:18:21 AM
fenario80 go drink your chi and make a freaking poem
by crashbarbarian
Jan 25th, 2007
10:34:19 AM
hey crash
by fenario80
Jan 25th, 2007
10:51:49 AM
Chai is so money.
by The Ghoul
Jan 25th, 2007
11:48:45 AM
Ghoul... the answer is... uh i don't call people fags
by crashbarbarian
Jan 25th, 2007
12:02:39 PM
and im pretty sure that repubs don't rape people
by crashbarbarian
Jan 25th, 2007
12:03:53 PM
if only i could let my future self meet you presently
by crashbarbarian
Jan 25th, 2007
12:10:03 PM
LAZY DAYDREAM
by The Ghoul
Jan 25th, 2007
12:17:25 PM
If you have a problem with Hounddog...
by SkinJob69
Jan 25th, 2007
12:22:19 PM
EyeGuyNY....
by Hairy Nutsack
Jan 25th, 2007
01:09:37 PM
@Cameran...
by RKDN Del Sol
Jan 25th, 2007
01:39:18 PM
A few years from now, Dakota will be hangin' with Lohan
by wackybantha
Jan 25th, 2007
03:39:11 PM
Don't give them any ideas, Hairy...
by SkinJob69
Jan 25th, 2007
03:42:38 PM
The Smoking Gun...
by JohnRevik
Jan 25th, 2007
05:00:03 PM
Yes, geniuses. The scene has Fanning pretending to be
by superninja
Jan 25th, 2007
05:20:16 PM
What??? no beanpole comment?
by Russman
Jan 25th, 2007
05:49:09 PM
child abuse?
by RKDN Del Sol
Jan 25th, 2007
07:11:53 PM
Garbage
by Damer1
Jan 25th, 2007
08:07:01 PM
"If the actor were anyone other than Dakota Fanning"
by chrth
Jan 25th, 2007
09:03:38 PM
Here's a thought...
by andyny29
Jan 25th, 2007
09:27:47 PM
Morse wasn't in the rape scene
by ETI
Jan 25th, 2007
09:35:42 PM
Chrth, I third on "A Time To Kill..."
by NC Blue
Jan 25th, 2007
09:47:38 PM
Oh, and one other thing...
by NC Blue
Jan 25th, 2007
10:18:35 PM
Dogapeandman2, of course...
by NC Blue
Jan 25th, 2007
11:04:21 PM
Child pornography
by Barry Egan
Jan 26th, 2007
02:11:46 AM
Fanning is very angry at the reaction to the film
by BannedOnTheRun
Jan 26th, 2007
03:13:03 AM
FADE OUT: (apparently) the film is now dead...
by Triumph poops!
Jan 26th, 2007
06:01:52 AM
Chew on this and spit it out......
by BillyPilgrim
Jan 26th, 2007
12:48:19 PM
Dakota Fanning just might be...
by Sheriff_Hoyt
Jan 26th, 2007
12:49:11 PM
Is she crying all the time?
by Judge Dredds Dirty Undies
Jan 26th, 2007
01:21:16 PM
Why do movies have to be so gosh darned nasty?
by Sepulchrave
Jan 26th, 2007
01:43:42 PM
I'd like to hear Hairy's reply to NC Blue
by half vader
Jan 26th, 2007
07:28:42 PM
I'm a commie lesbian stem cell eater
by fenario80
Jan 27th, 2007
12:30:14 PM
get over it
by wrikent3500
Mar 6th, 2007
05:20:34 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.