Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Monday’s STUDIO 60
Better Than The Pilot??
Our Critic Says Yes!!

I am – Hercules!!

Actually, at least two critics find tonight’s installment of “Studio 60” better than its pilot, because USA Today’s TV critic agrees with our guy.

One hears “Studio 60” airs in Canada the Sunday before we Americans get to see it on Monday, so we’ll hopefully make these Monday morning reviews a regular feature here in AICN’s pretty blue Coaxial box. (And hopefully our Monday-morning reviewers will start sending their reviews as Microsoft Word attachments so Herc doesn’t have to spend an hour formatting.)

Here’s “Daniel Kurland” with all the grisly details on 1.2:

What's It Called?
"The Cold Open"

Who Wrote It?
Aaron Sorkin

Who Directed?
Thomas Schlamme

What's it about?
Matt stresses over writing an amazing show (particular stress is on the opening) after Jordan sets the bar incredibly high for Matt and Danny at a press conference. Matt also tries to cope with the writing staff. And Harriett stresses over the fact that Matt may be dating another cast member.

What's new?
The show doesn't have a title sequence like West Wing did, but rather just a a title card and bit of music. They are also putting the title on the screen at the beginning like West Wing did. Evan Handler and Carlos Jacott are also seen as fellow writers (Possibly Ricky and Ron, it's not clarified). Also, the introduction of Jeanie "With the light brown hair" Whatley played by Ayda Field takes place, who seems like she'll be sticking around for a while.

What's good about it?
In spite of how many people were simply amazed by the pilot, this episode is much, much better, and any worries I may have had (which were minimal) are now gone. The dialogue is much quicker and wittier, the characters have more room to breathe, and the fact that we all ready know everyone's motivations makes it much more fun to just watch them all interact. Matt and Danny really seem to be the next Casey McCall and Dan Rydell. Especially with Danny's Rydell-like honesty at possibly inappropriate times. The skit Matt does come up with to open is not only a pleasure to watch, but is brilliant
in my opinion, and a nice nod to a certain musical that Sorkin has referenced before on The West Wing. Nate Corddry and D.L. Hughley's characters get a lot more screen time. "Was she calling us Hollywood liberals, or was she calling us gay?" "It’s a fine distinction." "Were you aware of Danny's drug problem?" "I can't recall, I was high when he told me." "It was turned off. How does it still know what time it was?" "It has batteries. Don't give the clock special powers."

What's not good about it?
Sarah Paulson still isn't clicking with me, but she's better than she was in the pilot. Jordan and Jack are only in a bit of the first half of the episode, and Cal doesn't get much time either. This isn't a huge deal, and really not that unexpected due to the huge size of the cast, it's just interesting to see how they are managing it.

Rating (out of 5)
Four (possibly 4.5, but I don't want to seem TOO eager too fast) And I would have given the pilot 3.5

”Owwwwwww My God!! Oh Dear Lord, Oh God, Mother of All Things Holy!! Please Let This Nightmare Stop!! My Ass Is Fire!! My Ass Is Fire!!!!!! Owwwwwwww!!!! My Ass Is No More; It Has Been Replaced By Fire!!!!!”

Twenty minutes into last Monday’s “The Howard Stern Show” Howard played a cut from Norm Macdonald’s new comedy album that made me laugh so hard I nearly passed out. It starred Will Ferrell (doing his Harry Carey voice) and Norm re-enacting the first time two men decided to have sex with each other. It just builds and builds and builds as the two fellows try to overcome a seemingly endless litany of obstacles. Kindly seek it out and listen. It costs $11.97 and is worth twice that price for “World’s First Two Gay Guys” alone.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

i want to see this show
by maluquiro
Sep 25th, 2006
01:48:42 AM
y'know...
by maluquiro
Sep 25th, 2006
01:49:09 AM
sera?
by maluquiro
Sep 25th, 2006
01:49:37 AM
rapaz!
by maluquiro
Sep 25th, 2006
01:51:26 AM
see herc, this is how you preview a show
by Bob C. Cock
Sep 25th, 2006
01:59:46 AM
I want to see
by Drworm2002
Sep 25th, 2006
02:00:28 AM
Helluva show
by marcus torrance
Sep 25th, 2006
02:00:58 AM
I agree with the review
by jarodvhale
Sep 25th, 2006
02:31:22 AM
UK airing?
by Mr_Sleep001
Sep 25th, 2006
03:35:37 AM
hokeybutt
by Hokeybutt
Sep 25th, 2006
04:58:54 AM
Mr_Sleep001
by Grando
Sep 25th, 2006
05:46:17 AM
Thanks for the support...
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
07:15:14 AM
this episode is amazing
by nalapou
Sep 25th, 2006
07:33:32 AM
Gotta say, last weeks pilot didn't live up to the hype
by Regenhund
Sep 25th, 2006
07:39:40 AM
Chayefsky! Penzance! Kubrick!
by rockgolf
Sep 25th, 2006
08:58:11 AM
I really like this show
by ChorleyFM
Sep 25th, 2006
08:59:24 AM
And the 2nd network reference in 8 days to..
by rockgolf
Sep 25th, 2006
08:59:37 AM
Mr_Sleep001
by ChorleyFM
Sep 25th, 2006
09:02:34 AM
All very impressive, but...
by Boxcutter
Sep 25th, 2006
09:14:59 AM
Mr_Sleep001
by newc0253
Sep 25th, 2006
09:46:41 AM
Paulh and Hayden Panettiere
by jmyoung666
Sep 25th, 2006
09:48:23 AM
newc0253
by Mr_Sleep001
Sep 25th, 2006
10:13:51 AM
Another error on my part....
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
10:16:56 AM
hasn't touched me yet, but I'm giving it time
by oisin5199
Sep 25th, 2006
10:31:04 AM
Anchorite, is there any show that reflects your views?
by Billyeveryteen
Sep 25th, 2006
11:39:45 AM
actually Sorkin really pioneered the walking...
by jarodvhale
Sep 25th, 2006
12:01:54 PM
Anchorite
by jmyoung666
Sep 25th, 2006
12:35:11 PM
Hallway walking and talking
by Big Jim
Sep 25th, 2006
12:42:14 PM
THIS SHOW SUCKS
by jackinitraw
Sep 25th, 2006
12:46:17 PM
Was it supposed to be funny?
by Domi'sInnerChild
Sep 25th, 2006
01:58:55 PM
Yes, Kubrick was doing the steadicam much earlier...
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
03:15:31 PM
Anchorite is a fucking nut
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 25th, 2006
03:26:26 PM
Anchorite calls Bullshit, and I agree
by Quin the Eskimo
Sep 25th, 2006
03:42:45 PM
Industry Killer
by Quin the Eskimo
Sep 25th, 2006
03:49:20 PM
You gotta love this anchorite guy.
by Orbots Commander
Sep 25th, 2006
04:33:34 PM
Wildly off topic but...
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
05:17:59 PM
OrbottsCommander, I agree with you, but...
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
05:24:39 PM
Opening Credits
by Jinxo
Sep 25th, 2006
05:27:25 PM
again with the walking
by gredenko
Sep 25th, 2006
05:50:18 PM
Use of title cards
by jmyoung666
Sep 25th, 2006
05:50:40 PM
Quin the Eskimo
by jmyoung666
Sep 25th, 2006
05:53:23 PM
The walking
by jmyoung666
Sep 25th, 2006
06:00:16 PM
credits and anchorite
by oisin5199
Sep 25th, 2006
06:18:29 PM
oisin5199 and Anchorite
by ChorleyFM
Sep 25th, 2006
06:52:47 PM
I watched Ep 2. last night
by Karmakin
Sep 25th, 2006
06:53:57 PM
DON'T FORGET TO WATCH SMITH TOMORROW NIGHT ON CBS
by jackinitraw
Sep 25th, 2006
07:47:02 PM
I hope Amanda Peet doesn't smirk her way thru this one-
by FrogDaddy
Sep 25th, 2006
07:53:46 PM
Here's a joke I'd like to see on the upcoming SNL:
by Flim Springfield
Sep 25th, 2006
08:01:00 PM
Watched the pilot...
by Killah_Mate
Sep 25th, 2006
08:26:42 PM
The sketch pitches are distractingly horrible.
by McGsStepson
Sep 25th, 2006
09:26:14 PM
Smith was dissapointing tonight...
by BigTuna
Sep 25th, 2006
09:30:32 PM
Second ep disappointment
by zacdilone
Sep 25th, 2006
09:57:59 PM
Pilot was much better
by Logo Lou
Sep 25th, 2006
10:05:14 PM
Just finished watching it. It was okay.
by Orbots Commander
Sep 25th, 2006
10:13:42 PM
Surprised at the episode two backlash...
by DanielKurland
Sep 25th, 2006
10:17:06 PM
We answered so fast it was scary!
by Zarles
Sep 25th, 2006
10:20:21 PM
I loved it.
by Eaglet1138
Sep 25th, 2006
10:28:49 PM
Amanda Peet=Michele Rodriguez, LOST, Season 2.
by Orbots Commander
Sep 25th, 2006
10:41:43 PM
For the record, oisin5199...
by Regenhund
Sep 25th, 2006
11:03:32 PM
uh, nevermind-
by Regenhund
Sep 25th, 2006
11:11:39 PM
Sarah Paulson=Maggie Grace, LOST, Season 1
by Logo Lou
Sep 25th, 2006
11:22:02 PM
corrections and praise
by oisin5199
Sep 25th, 2006
11:39:20 PM
The problem with every show-within-a-show
by eg4190
Sep 25th, 2006
11:46:31 PM
What does Sorkin want, a cookie?
by Mechakong!
Sep 26th, 2006
12:18:48 AM
Mechakong
by BadMrWonka
Sep 26th, 2006
12:41:35 AM
Great episode, but...
by polyh3dron
Sep 26th, 2006
01:25:52 AM
Some nutjob upload every simpsons episode ever
by Orionsangels
Sep 26th, 2006
01:56:30 AM
Sketches
by Rybock
Sep 26th, 2006
03:13:36 AM
Harriet = the star?
by The Selecter
Sep 26th, 2006
06:05:43 AM
i have to say ......
by kmw4121
Sep 26th, 2006
06:50:54 AM
Is everyone else unable to see...
by The hoff
Sep 26th, 2006
09:02:28 AM
anchorite
by nushustu..
Sep 26th, 2006
09:38:39 AM
The "sports" in Sports Night
by LilOgre
Sep 26th, 2006
11:12:33 AM
Show's awesome
by R.C. the "Wise"
Sep 26th, 2006
11:26:46 AM
I gave it a 2nd chance.
by Dragulf
Sep 26th, 2006
12:38:05 PM
But anchorite, it's NOT
by critch
Sep 26th, 2006
01:14:13 PM
Still great...
by Billyeveryteen
Sep 26th, 2006
01:29:59 PM
anchorite...
by -guyinthebackrow
Sep 26th, 2006
01:58:45 PM
Holy shit, this show is terrible
by Doc_McCoy
Sep 26th, 2006
02:19:44 PM
Comedy is harder than drama.
by jbum
Sep 26th, 2006
02:46:06 PM
Studio 60 is anti-anchorite
by oisin5199
Sep 26th, 2006
03:12:56 PM
i think we should forget the ....
by kmw4121
Sep 26th, 2006
03:33:53 PM
Mistakes in the Bible...
by NapoleonDynamite
Sep 26th, 2006
03:40:44 PM
I found that musical number really lame.
by NapoleonDynamite
Sep 26th, 2006
03:44:37 PM
Ratings
by supertoyslast
Sep 26th, 2006
03:54:42 PM
The high price of being in power
by KanekoFan
Sep 26th, 2006
04:50:18 PM
Anchorite, that's bullshit
by underscore_only
Sep 26th, 2006
04:53:37 PM
God...Do I Hate This Fucking Show
by Rebeck
Sep 26th, 2006
05:36:23 PM
anky, you're not really watching this show, are you?
by oisin5199
Sep 26th, 2006
05:51:04 PM
what's with this self-importance criticism
by oisin5199
Sep 26th, 2006
05:54:15 PM
problematical
by oisin5199
Sep 26th, 2006
05:58:58 PM
Demonizing the majority is essential
by KanekoFan
Sep 26th, 2006
06:04:00 PM
I love this show, and I really liked the pilot...
by Russman
Sep 26th, 2006
07:17:08 PM
Religious debates + AICN TB=
by nemesisdarkside
Sep 26th, 2006
10:16:51 PM
I wonder who REALLY needs to get over themselves?
by oisin5199
Sep 26th, 2006
11:55:57 PM
Anchorite you are seeing what you want to see
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 27th, 2006
02:38:32 AM
They made this Huge Deal about...
by chromedome
Sep 27th, 2006
10:37:17 AM
refrence chromedome's comments
by kmw4121
Sep 27th, 2006
11:00:03 AM
The sketches
by KanekoFan
Sep 27th, 2006
12:20:15 PM
Franken
by KanekoFan
Sep 27th, 2006
01:25:36 PM
Yeah because Sean Penns career peaked with Spiccoli
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 27th, 2006
01:26:09 PM
Farrakhan and Robertson = Evil hacks
by R.C. the "Wise"
Sep 27th, 2006
01:40:14 PM
Sean Penn
by KanekoFan
Sep 27th, 2006
01:48:22 PM
Oh please Anchorite
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 27th, 2006
03:15:54 PM
Anchorite you are the one who needs to back up your
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 27th, 2006
03:31:51 PM
Can a person be an evengelica Cchristian fundamelntalis
by Quin the Eskimo
Sep 27th, 2006
03:40:50 PM
Quin
by nemesisdarkside
Sep 27th, 2006
05:37:20 PM
well, let's see...
by oisin5199
Sep 27th, 2006
06:31:41 PM
citation
by oisin5199
Sep 27th, 2006
06:38:21 PM
Give it up anchorite
by IndustryKiller!
Sep 27th, 2006
07:07:48 PM
One area where I have to side with anchorite
by KanekoFan
Sep 27th, 2006
07:32:51 PM
I hope you are right kmw4121...
by chromedome
Sep 27th, 2006
07:57:29 PM
one last comment
by oisin5199
Sep 27th, 2006
11:11:41 PM
List of Segments From the Show
by Spuncho
Sep 27th, 2006
11:35:18 PM
achoritie...
by -guyinthebackrow
Sep 28th, 2006
02:59:25 PM
Way too many political/social digs
by JackieJokeman
Sep 28th, 2006
05:47:24 PM
Actually, West Wing felt more even-handed
by KanekoFan
Sep 28th, 2006
05:56:55 PM
anchorite...
by -guyinthebackrow
Sep 28th, 2006
06:27:27 PM
Thumbs Down.
by HaveCameraWillTravel
Oct 1st, 2006
07:01:19 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.