Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Our First, And Maybe Last, GARFIELD Review!!

Hi, everyone. "Moriarty" here with some Rumblings From The Lab...

I remain resolutely amazed that any adult with an IQ in the triple digits would want anything to do with this film. The comic strip is a piece of corporate vomit that has been rehashing the same three unfunny jokes for 20 years. Maybe it’s just that I think cats are Satan’s emissaries on Earth. Maybe it’s that I am older than seven. Whatever the case, this mystifies me, and it sounds like the film has lived down to its enormously limited potential. Check this out:

Hello Harry,

I attended an advanced screening of this film in ATLANTA this past weekend and have an early review for you guys...

First off, this film probably would have succeeded ten years ago. However, this is 2004 and GARFIELD is not the most recognized, or beloved, character anymore. So, the filmmakers were obviously hoping to revitalize this dying franchise. Well...GARFIELD is dead.

Never before I have I been forced too sit through such a God awful train wreck of a movie. Burp and fart jokes might have been humorous in 1990, but today they just seem kind of lame. It is the same principle as if they decided to make a new TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES movie... the same formula in the first three could not work in 2004, so many years later.

The story revolves around John Arbuckle (Breckin Meyer), who brings home a new dog, Odie, much to the dismay of his spoiled and pathetically overweight feline, Garfield. There is automatic tension between the two. However, Odie is soon kidnapped and it is up to Garfield to save the day and return the pooch to John. I kind of felt like I was watching BEETHOVEN, with a cat instead of a dog.

One of the most bizarre aspects of this film is the way Garfield has romantic interest in Liz (played by Jennifer Love Hewitt). The way this romance is portrayed is borderline disgusting. Who wants to think about a cat and a woman making love? Not me.

Bill Murray does his best with the voice, but he seems as disinterested in his work as we do in watching the film. Coupled with the mediocre special effects and the always unpleasant acting of J-Love, GARFIELD bombs in a major way, and I expect it to bomb miserably at the box office. This franchise is just not what it use to be, and reviving it with a big budget film was not the right step to take.

So, the cat's out of the bag, and GARFIELD isn't worth a bag of cat nip.

Blue Meanie

Even that review gives me hives. Ugh.

"Moriarty" out.





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

WHERE ARE THE FIRST POST PEOPLE ? " SLOW NEWS DAY... GARFIELD S
by el zar
Jun 7th, 2004
03:10:25 AM
ugh
by Mr_Sinister_31
Jun 7th, 2004
03:11:06 AM
I'm not disgusted that they used a real Odie, but that they used
by SmarkJobber
Jun 7th, 2004
03:23:37 AM
Needs A Neo-Type Hogan Ethnic Character
by groovemonk
Jun 7th, 2004
03:26:09 AM
Obvious Plant
by Darth_Inedible
Jun 7th, 2004
03:58:37 AM
Yeah, well...
by halcyonseven
Jun 7th, 2004
04:02:39 AM
It does indeed look like big pile o' poo, but...
by Nexus-6
Jun 7th, 2004
04:08:37 AM
Halcyon7...
by TheRealMoriarty
Jun 7th, 2004
04:35:34 AM
This movie may suck, but it will make money
by pogo on my own
Jun 7th, 2004
04:51:43 AM
PLANT
by FoodChannel
Jun 7th, 2004
05:53:42 AM
Regarding the saw post
by proper
Jun 7th, 2004
06:47:25 AM
What, the Garfield film sucks? Impossible! Who could have predic
by SalvatoreGravano
Jun 7th, 2004
07:24:30 AM
I don't like coke...
by Rob_Graves
Jun 7th, 2004
03:10:14 PM
This movie comes out in only four days, and I still haven't seen
by Osmosis Jones
Jun 7th, 2004
11:01:55 PM
Great! Bill Murray REFUSES to ever do a cool modern Ghostbuster
by YotzVonFrelnik
Jun 7th, 2004
11:55:37 PM
mr sinister
by darth veda
Jun 8th, 2004
12:55:58 AM
They Didn't Stay True to the comic!!
by Bananas
Jun 8th, 2004
03:22:09 AM
THE COMIC STRIP ROCKS, BUT THE MOVIE SUCKS!
by omegaman20
Jun 8th, 2004
04:34:36 AM
The comic strip "rocks"?
by AndrewWanKenobi
Jun 8th, 2004
05:52:24 AM
Harry has a beer and cheats on Moriarty
by LargoJr
Jun 8th, 2004
08:11:20 AM
This person could NOT have seen this movie...
by pdj
Jun 8th, 2004
08:13:48 AM
"Who wants to think about a cat and a woman making love?"
by Judge Doom
Jun 8th, 2004
09:26:11 AM
you all
by mastermike
Jun 8th, 2004
11:16:03 AM
It won't do good YEAH RIGHT
by TaureanTwilliams
Jun 8th, 2004
11:27:15 AM
Sounds great!
by NiceMarmot
Jun 8th, 2004
12:41:23 PM
This entire film should be CG
by tnizzle
Jun 8th, 2004
12:42:16 PM
Zzzzzzz? Huh? What? GARFIELD? Ennnnh, wake me when CALVIN &
by SpyGuy
Jun 8th, 2004
01:35:18 PM
Who wants to think about a cat making love to a beautiful woman?
by magusreno
Jun 8th, 2004
01:39:46 PM
Bob Sagat
by Torgol
Jun 8th, 2004
03:46:33 PM
You know that line about 'with great power comes great responsib
by Stan the Bat
Jun 8th, 2004
07:10:48 PM
The comic was the greatest fucking thing since sliced bread....
by ComicBookGeek77
Jun 8th, 2004
08:37:25 PM
Ph and I realize it's JIM Davis assholes, I was testing you.
by ComicBookGeek77
Jun 8th, 2004
08:40:37 PM
hot pussy on pussy action
by empyreal0
Jun 8th, 2004
09:53:29 PM
I'm gonna have to defend the first TMNT movie!
by crackerfarmboy
Jun 8th, 2004
10:42:58 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.