Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Stephen King's ROSE RED!! Talk Back!!

I am – Hercules!!

The reviews are in for the latest Stephen King-penned miniseries – and they are scary!

The mini airs Sunday, Monday and Thursday at 9 p.m. on ABC.

The Hollywood Reporter says:

If horrormeister Stephen King can give demonic powers to an innocent-looking car ("Christine"), then why not a house? That's the basic premise behind "Stephen King's Rose Red," a spooky three-part ABC miniseries that comes together quite nicely only to frantically and disjointedly unravel at the end.

… The first two parts nicely blend thrills, chills and comic relief. Sunday's opener includes a history of the mansion, and the second part Monday includes a lengthy tour of the place, both of which could have been trimmed. Nonetheless, the combination of eclectic characters and the judicious but effective use of special effects make the time pass quickly. Not so with the conclusion, which doesn't come until Thursday. In the third part, the characters lose most of their humor, undergo personality transformations and do enough obviously stupid things to turn it into just another haunted house screamfest.

Variety says:

… the same tech crew that brought viewers the haunting, highly effective "Storm of the Century" forgot to include the mojo this time around.

… "Rose Red," the second story King has written specifically for TV, is a far cry from the kind of scarefest his fans have come to expect. Clocking in at six (very long) hours and minus any top-tier stars, "Rose Red" is what they would call in the world of parapsychology a "dead cell." ABC isn't exactly giving the mini a big vote of confidence considering only the last of the three installments will air within the sweeps period.

… All of the elements that make a King story so accessible and entertaining are missing from this production. The working-class bravado of an unlikely hero, the rich character development and remote setting are displaced in favor of a downtown haunted house that is explored by a bunch of opportunists and outcasts. Filled with a few minor jolts and jumps, "Rose Red" actually loses a good deal of tension and credibility with each passing hour.

USA Today says:

Stephen King has too much time on his hands. Only a man with no need for time management could devote six hours to a haunted-house story — particularly one as lifeless as Rose Red.

… You could forgive the plodding start if King were headed somewhere worthwhile, but all he has to offer in Rose Red is a numbingly predictable series of seen-it-before jolts. In the guise of a new movie, King has simply recycled a collection of his own greatest hits, played at exceedingly slow speed.

… Any horror story would have trouble maintaining tension over three nights, but Rose Red is particularly ambling and pointless. There are no secrets to learn, because King spells out the plot for you in the opening minutes (house bad; people die). And there's no emotional connection because nothing and no one matters: The house chooses its victims at random from a crew of interchangeably dull characters. And six hours later, it's over — though like most King TV projects, Rose Red doesn't so much end as run out of time. Run the other way.

The Los Angeles Times says:

As unoriginal as haunted house stories get, "Stephen King's Rose Red" is his "Carrie" and "The Shining" meets "Ghostbusters," "Night of the Living Dead" and the Psychic Hotline. Written by the prolific King, this overwrought, overacted three-parter on ABC is campy, not scary or even stomach-turning.

In Humans vs. House, you may find yourself pulling for the house. If only Rose Red had eaten the script, the real spooks here being its author and those at ABC that decided to drag this chalky cadaver across three nights.

I am – Hercules!!





To order coffee mugs and boxer shorts adorned with the image of a green, handicapable “Buffy” fanatic, click here.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

No Interest
by jvoves
Jan 27th, 2002
06:44:24 PM
Why aren't we talking about tonight's new x-file?
by SkiffyPup
Jan 27th, 2002
08:10:51 PM
comments by a watcher....
by rubby
Jan 27th, 2002
09:46:41 PM
Stephen King movies you think will be crap but are actually grea
by Cash Bailey
Jan 27th, 2002
10:05:55 PM
Remember when Grimace had four arms, and Hamburglar was a bad gu
by St Buggering
Jan 27th, 2002
10:33:45 PM
EnemaBagJones
by St Buggering
Jan 27th, 2002
10:37:00 PM
EnemaBagJones: nevermind, yes it was
by St Buggering
Jan 27th, 2002
10:39:03 PM
X-Files was warmed over Clive Barker
by Windy City Blue
Jan 27th, 2002
10:43:46 PM
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say THE SHINNING mini-serries
by Tall_Boy
Jan 27th, 2002
11:05:50 PM
"You got the SHINNING!" "You mean SHINING" "Shhhh, you wanna get
by Tall_Boy
Jan 27th, 2002
11:09:16 PM
You shouldn't be scared of the Hamburglar
by Jack D. Ripper
Jan 27th, 2002
11:28:19 PM
Nothing can kill The Grimace
by MCVamp
Jan 28th, 2002
12:00:44 AM
Garris's THE SHINING would have been more than decent, excep
by Cash Bailey
Jan 28th, 2002
12:08:50 AM
I wanna eat Mayor McCheese!!
by spiderblood1969
Jan 28th, 2002
12:09:19 AM
I think this website is haunted!
by Regis Travolta
Jan 28th, 2002
12:24:10 AM
So far there's been only one part that kept my interest.
by vroom socko
Jan 28th, 2002
01:01:15 AM
I agree with The Hollywood Reporter.... So far.
by Ted Striker
Jan 28th, 2002
02:38:38 AM
Bad House of Leaves rip-off
by critical_theory
Jan 28th, 2002
03:20:37 AM
critical_theory and HOUSE OF LEAVES
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
04:55:44 AM
But, In Fairness To Evil Reader....
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
05:00:15 AM
Rose Red
by TheMinusMan
Jan 28th, 2002
05:26:13 AM
What if you posted a spoiler and nobody cared?
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 28th, 2002
06:00:39 AM
Hey, Boo's Mommy....
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
06:24:39 AM
EricAlan69- re: Blackhouse
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 28th, 2002
06:45:52 AM
to keep with the mcdonald's subject, and my love for kevin s
by sweet_caroline
Jan 28th, 2002
07:43:45 AM
Boo's Mommy vs. Mr. Gray....
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
07:56:34 AM
I can't even remember who Mr. Gray is.
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 28th, 2002
08:31:40 AM
Re: House of Leaves
by Rosie_Cotton
Jan 28th, 2002
08:52:34 AM
Night Flier Was Pretty Good
by holidill
Jan 28th, 2002
09:55:41 AM
Julian Sands
by AutomaticMachine
Jan 28th, 2002
10:10:52 AM
OK, so it's "Carrie goes to the Overlook Hotel." Still...
by Saucy Jack
Jan 28th, 2002
10:54:30 AM
King TV Movies
by Knobules
Jan 28th, 2002
11:10:25 AM
Stephen King hate-fest
by lycanthrope
Jan 28th, 2002
11:30:33 AM
I've seen this before
by pulpculture
Jan 28th, 2002
11:44:21 AM
King should know better than to present crap like this...
by Roguewriter
Jan 28th, 2002
11:53:35 AM
Can anyone say Plagerism?
by Halloween68
Jan 28th, 2002
12:09:29 PM
Boo's Mommy, please PLEASE stop now, PLEASE I'm dyin her
by Roguewriter
Jan 28th, 2002
12:19:38 PM
You people are stoned!
by Halloween68
Jan 28th, 2002
12:26:26 PM
Hit and miss.
by hudsucker
Jan 28th, 2002
01:27:03 PM
"The house is growing on its own."
by Roguewriter
Jan 28th, 2002
01:52:09 PM
Charles Fort, c'mon down!
by lycanthrope
Jan 28th, 2002
04:08:20 PM
Bravo, People!
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
08:05:18 PM
Oh, And If You're Wondering....
by EricAlan69
Jan 28th, 2002
08:08:26 PM
My thoughts
by kwolfhard
Jan 28th, 2002
08:35:08 PM
King Bashing
by Dijonase
Jan 28th, 2002
11:59:42 PM
King Bashing
by Dijonase
Jan 29th, 2002
12:09:01 AM
King's Miniseries
by Dijonase
Jan 29th, 2002
12:28:27 AM
King's Short Stories Are Awesome
by MikeSal222
Jan 29th, 2002
12:52:37 AM
I hope Frank Darabont stops wanting to be Frank Capra so he can
by Cash Bailey
Jan 29th, 2002
02:18:21 AM
King Retiring Soon
by MikeSal222
Jan 29th, 2002
03:06:39 AM
Copyright & Miss Jackson
by hyperboy
Jan 29th, 2002
03:08:41 AM
loads better than The Langoliers
by magic_ninja
Jan 29th, 2002
03:09:17 AM
Krackle was my favorite.
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 29th, 2002
03:11:31 AM
Got it wrong, perhaps
by hyperboy
Jan 29th, 2002
03:33:42 AM
rose red
by norn23
Jan 29th, 2002
09:01:58 AM
A few things...
by Halloween68
Jan 29th, 2002
10:09:26 AM
I *Knew* I'd Get More Entertainment!
by EricAlan69
Jan 29th, 2002
10:55:22 AM
The prof is looking for proof of psychic phenomena right? Isn
by RobRed1
Jan 29th, 2002
11:12:46 AM
Wake up, Big Steve!
by lycanthrope
Jan 29th, 2002
11:53:41 AM
I think Grimace was designed to represent a thickshake.
by Cash Bailey
Jan 29th, 2002
03:40:44 PM
from the director of "Action Jackson"....
by Fatal Discharge
Jan 29th, 2002
04:40:28 PM
Even Stephen King knows it's over...
by hudsucker
Jan 29th, 2002
04:44:23 PM
Read all about it yourself...
by hudsucker
Jan 29th, 2002
04:45:12 PM
Rose Rediculous
by ReglarJoe
Jan 29th, 2002
04:49:26 PM
It's amazing that Talkbackers even read books...
by magic_ninja
Jan 29th, 2002
06:14:41 PM
Could have been better ....
by cooper2000
Jan 29th, 2002
06:52:56 PM
Loaded. Excellent.
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 29th, 2002
10:26:04 PM
Sigh. No "Rose Red" Tonight....
by EricAlan69
Jan 30th, 2002
12:05:41 AM
You know who else is great to listen to when you're waiting
by Boo's Mommy
Jan 30th, 2002
06:51:48 AM
RRA
by EricAlan69
Jan 30th, 2002
07:55:55 AM
Sorry EricAlan
by Dijonase
Jan 30th, 2002
11:16:35 AM
Julian Sands and Dohmersimpson
by Halloween68
Jan 30th, 2002
11:17:12 AM
Haunted McDonalds...
by Almost Sexy
Jan 30th, 2002
01:26:57 PM
Best King-inspired movie?
by ReglarJoe
Jan 30th, 2002
05:08:47 PM
No One Will Ever Read This....
by EricAlan69
Jan 31st, 2002
07:41:51 PM
As a hula dancer, my skin needs to look it's best.
by Boo's Mommy
Feb 1st, 2002
06:22:00 AM
C'mon... this was damned entertaining
by Yeroc7890
Feb 2nd, 2002
05:41:39 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.