Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

Weird.
by GiveMeAnFinBreak
Jun 30th, 2009
11:14:29 PM
This is the last property I'd ever expect to make a comeback. Then again, I wasn't ever much of a fan, in the first place.
Ugh. "Syfy"
by Iron-kong
Jun 30th, 2009
11:25:18 PM
Remaking V is enough. We don't need this too.
by ShabbyBlue
Jun 30th, 2009
11:38:31 PM
And just like with V, I would have preferred a continuation of the original plot/characters instead of "rebooting" the whole concept. Ugh.
District 9 Will be better than this
by Monkey Butler
Jun 30th, 2009
11:41:17 PM
But then, most things will be better than this.
THIS SOUNDS PROMISING
by Mullah Omar
Jun 30th, 2009
11:41:25 PM
And honestly, I did not expect to write that after reading the tagline. I liked the idea of the ALIEN NATION film better than the execution, and what little I saw of the series didn't really leave an impression. But this is the sort of source material that I think can benefit from an overhaul like what Minear is proposing. I have higher hopes for this sort of "reboot" than I do for the upcoming V remake. It would be nice to have some worthwhile science fiction on TV.
I liked the series
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 30th, 2009
11:41:27 PM
In fact, that might have been the earliest time I was sorely disappointed by a show's cancellation. I know it's stupid, but that pilot episode plot about the monster hidden inside the Newcomers scared the SHIT out of me at the time. Christ, what a pussy I was then...

Anyways, if this is set 20 years later, why not bring back some of the original show's cast?
The original show got FIVE tv movie follow-ups
by ShabbyBlue
Jun 30th, 2009
11:57:40 PM
That's pretty damn impressive for a low-rated scifi cult tv show on FOX! Other scifi shows with huge fan follows never got tv movies after their cancellation. Not Quantum Leap... not Angel... not anything that I can recall, EXCEPT Alien Nation. For some reason Alien Nation got plenty of bonus attention well into the 90s. The last tv movie aired in 1997, which really doesn't feel that long ago to me, so I don't understand why this proposed new series can't just pick up where everything left off at 10 or 15 years later with as much of the original cast as they can get. Yet another rebooted concept of a movie/tv series just doesn't interest me.
if anyone can do it, Minear can
by oisin5199
Jul 1st, 2009
12:04:03 AM
I thought the movie was decent and the original show was cute and had a good concept behind it. Seeing AN updated would be interesting. And I'd love to see Minear return to smart sci-fi. Sorry, SyFy. I'll never get used to that stupid change.
Well, at least it's not on FOX
by DeadlyPorpoise
Jul 1st, 2009
12:10:32 AM
I thought Tim and Whedon had entered into some sort of diabolic agreement with Satan's broadcaster of choice
Glad to see this isn't the case...maybe this time, he'll get a series that's allowed to run. I'm still annoyed that DRIVE got cancelled...that show had promise. AND Captain Tightpants.
eh, sure, why not
by WickedJacob
Jul 1st, 2009
12:24:56 AM
As good an idea as any that gets a greenlight.
i'm guessing the success of "true blood" ...
by Toe Jam
Jul 1st, 2009
12:30:52 AM
has something to do with this. the whole vampires/aliens-as-gays/minori ties metaphor is similar, no?
Loved the series. Why not a loose continuation?
by JediRob
Jul 1st, 2009
12:31:13 AM
As opposed to a total reboot. If it's 20 years later you can do whatever you want anyway, and then you're also not ignoring the history. Just have George or Sikes make a cameo or 2.
Hollywood is seriously trying to harsh my mellow
by Greggers
Jul 1st, 2009
12:49:02 AM
This is going to sound like all kinds of philistinism, but fuck it:

I'm burnt out on mirrors being held up to society and the human condition. (All right Hollywood, I get it -- we suck. Well, okay, we suck, but with occasional flickerings of beauty, compassion, and transcendence. But *mainly* we suck.)

I know I getting way ahead of things here when it comes to this project, but with ALIEN NATION, I feel a lecture coming on. And although BATTLESTAR GALACTICA kept me rapt for a good long time, right now, I'm just not in the mood for that kind of thing.
Uck Quantum Leap remake is probably next, sci-fi already trashe
by iownyou
Jul 1st, 2009
01:26:43 AM
no originality
District 9 is a complete rip-off of this...F that movie
by Ash Talon
Jul 1st, 2009
01:30:21 AM
How can anyone look forward to District 9 knowing at the same time it's a comlete rip-off of Alien Nation. I guess intellectual property just doesn't matter to some people.

I think it would be wise to not ignore the original movie & series. Still set it in the same world. Just move the timeframe forward like they're doing. I hope they don't erase the past. Like JediRob says.

Wow...
by codymr
Jul 1st, 2009
01:34:08 AM
Kenneth Johnson is having a good year... first V, now Alien Nation.
Just continue it.
by Baked
Jul 1st, 2009
01:36:50 AM
It's been about 20 years since the movie, so why reboot to a point in time that is exactly where the series would be at this point?

With a population of 3.5 million, it should be easy to find new stories and characters in the same universe as George and Cykes.

Using the aliens as stand-ins for Muslims?
by photoboy
Jul 1st, 2009
02:17:00 AM
Recent projections of Muslim birth and migration rates has suggested that in 20 years they will be nearing the primary religion in a lot of Western countries. Sounds like this show could be tackling that in a way that cannot directly be accused of being racist.
If I'm recalling correctly from the series
by Dingbatty
Jul 1st, 2009
02:33:14 AM
the aliens required a third party rare type of male to get pregnant, so I imagine they couldn't increase their population that quickly.
13 Eps of The Inside make him a "veteran" of cop shows?
by crayotic
Jul 1st, 2009
04:08:30 AM
That one was a bit of a reach, even by the Herc Hyperbole meter. Although, I guess he couldn't really do the "Sci-Fi Cop Shows" punchline afterward, without the using it as a lead-in.
Speaking of Minear
by The McPoyle Clan
Jul 1st, 2009
04:52:54 AM
did the unaired episodes of Drive every surface anywhere?
Emily Francisco grew up into a hottie.
by V'Shael
Jul 1st, 2009
05:12:46 AM
It'd be great if they could cast some of the familiar faces.

What ever happened to Terri Treas, who played Cathy? Does anyone know if she aged well at all?

Minear craves spoiled milk
by ls420
Jul 1st, 2009
05:41:26 AM
love the idea
Maybe with Tim's Influence...
by puto tenax
Jul 1st, 2009
06:31:07 AM
...this has a chance, but given the new "SyFy", approach I'm not hopeful. Again, are all new ideas gone from Hollywood? C'mon, Tim, we'd rather see something original from you.
So a combination of an Alien Nation retread
by Fa_Tass_DinoMolester
Jul 1st, 2009
09:06:24 AM
and District Nine: The Series. I never thought I'd say this, but the time have actually come when we have TOO many aliens on our movie and TV screens. I'm sick of aliens...come up with something else to milk the hell out of, Hollywood...
Is George the spokesman for Shredded Wheat??
by Billyeveryteen
Jul 1st, 2009
10:16:59 AM
WTF, please hire him back.
Keep them away from the sour milk!!
by Banditmania
Jul 1st, 2009
10:56:47 AM
I'm just sayin'.
Kenneth Johnson...
by Henry Fool
Jul 1st, 2009
11:26:48 AM
Being the Whedonite that I am, I certainly consider Tim Minear worthy of stepping into Ken Johnson's shoes. But I hope they use some of the original cast such as Gary Graham and Eric Pierpoint. It'd be cool to have their characters be the older mentors to a new generation. I used to watch the series when it alongside 21 Jump Street on Fox. I always liked it and its spinoff TV movies when I was growing up and still feel it was a precursor to some of the better sci-fi that would later come along, like Firefly and the Holy Galactica.
Not really a surprise...
by dogrobber
Jul 1st, 2009
11:39:18 AM
...as 'District 9' seems (to me at least) to be taken from/built around the same basic idea as the original 'Alien Nation' movie/tv series/movies, so if 'District 9' is a success Syfy can attempt to milk that success by producing their own alien immigration series with something of a built-in audience and no real worries of copyright (trademark?) problems. Setting the series in modern times should make the show no more expensive (not including prosthesis - is that the correct word/spelling?) to produce (I'm guessing) than the average episode of 'Burn Notice','In Plain Sight', or 'Royal Pains', and possibly less expensive than the 'Stargate' franchise. (Yes, I just realized I'm writing the obvious. I'm an idiot.)
What's next? Lucan? Manimal? Jason of Star Command?
by Uncle Stan
Jul 1st, 2009
11:48:19 AM
"I'm burnt out on mirrors being held up to society and the human
by oisin5199
Jul 1st, 2009
12:20:56 PM
yeah, fuck the whole purpose of contemporary literature and science fiction. No more of that!
Thank God
by Flyingcircus
Jul 1st, 2009
12:29:06 PM
Finally something new and original. Wait, what?
It just occurred to me
by Flyingcircus
Jul 1st, 2009
12:30:07 PM
that maybe these thumb-dicks like Wampa1 and NielF post the same thing over and over because they're just caught up in the remake trend. Discuss.
Next up: Knight Rider! Oh, wait...
by MrMysteryGuest
Jul 1st, 2009
01:40:26 PM
How about Sam Diego?
by DeCypher44
Jul 1st, 2009
02:02:49 PM
Sam Juan Capistrano
Sam Luis Obispo
Dallas Ft Worth
Detective Reno Nevada?
where is my SOMETHING IS OUT THERE remake!?!?
by KentButabi
Jul 1st, 2009
02:17:13 PM
I don't remember it all that well, but I remember thinking it was awesome.
Det. Chevy Chase Marylin
by KentButabi
Jul 1st, 2009
02:20:21 PM
sounds like somebody saw the district 9 trailer
by thedude2010
Jul 1st, 2009
02:21:07 PM
and said hey...that looks like Alien Nation, let's make a new alien nation just like that trailer
oisin5199
by Greggers
Jul 1st, 2009
03:23:12 PM
Glad to see you're on board!

But I think you might have missed my point; but that's okay, I don't think I made it very well. It's not that I'm against holding a mirror up to society and the human condition per se. I'm against holding a mirror up to society and the human condition to the extent that "holding a mirror up to society and the human condition" is actually a euphamism for exercising (but never exorcising) liberal guilt. I'm ready entertainment with a little more self-esteem. At least for this week. Ask me again next Tuesday and I might feel a little different.
The hammiest line in tv history
by ides
Jul 1st, 2009
03:39:07 PM
Never actually watched The Inside (I remember it getting terrible reviews), but I still constantly quote Peter Coyote's breathlessly dramatic line from the commercials, "That girl has a gift FORGED in pain."
I can't get into aliens with weird heads
by felwithe
Jul 1st, 2009
04:34:00 PM
Love Mr. Minear, but "aliens with weird headS" syndrome just turns me off and makes it impossible for me to take the show seriously. It was like that for Star Trek and every other show that's done it. Maybe that's why Firefly and BSG turned out so well-- no prosthetic ears.
thank god it's not on fox
by johnnysunshine
Jul 1st, 2009
04:51:33 PM
this sounds pretty cool. Tim Minear has an excellent track record and since this show won't be on fox, there's a chance we'll get to see more than 4 episodes of it too. The original alien nation movie and show were pretty good and, if I remember correctly, ran in pretty heavy rotation on the SciFi channel back before they aired much original programming.
FUCK YEAH!!!
by Hint_of_Smegma
Jul 1st, 2009
05:18:02 PM
A sequel series to the movie OR the tv series is welcome as far as I'm concerned (although I prefer to think of both as seperate entities). The movie was a great '80's scifi, and the series was a brilliantly fucked up slice of tv. A sequel set this far down the line could have real potential.
Alien Nation is Canada!
by Naughty
Jul 1st, 2009
06:14:53 PM
Where all of SyFy's shows are filmed! With their stupid, fucking foreign casts! Hire some real American actors, you stupid fucks!!
I wasn't really into the original
by _Maltheus_
Jul 1st, 2009
08:24:18 PM
It wasn't ever something that I considered all that good. They could do an alright job with it I suppose, but it's not something that excites me. How about a series based on They Live. Or even better, something original.
They live is one thing i think would rule as a series.
by notspock2
Jul 2nd, 2009
11:36:28 AM
Just have James Caan shoot everything in sight
by twogunjames
Jul 2nd, 2009
01:48:03 PM
and you will have a big hit. I always thought it was funny how he called them potato heads off camera.
How did I miss this posting?
by Shut the Fuck up Donny
Jul 2nd, 2009
02:30:31 PM
Now I'm three days late to the party...

Oh well...Color me intrigued as I sincerely adored the movie and the tv series.

Maybe than can even bring back David Faustino as the one Tenctonese who inexplicably had facial hair!

The Original kind of bored me
by lockesbrokenleg
Jul 2nd, 2009
02:50:39 PM
Everyone watched it, but I thought it was just too heavy handed. Nice concept, but it was just too weird even for me.
Man, it must suck...
by TommyGavinsEgo
Jul 2nd, 2009
06:39:34 PM
... to be Kenneth Johnson this year! First he tried to re-launch "V" (his by far best acheivment) with a 20-years later follow up... That gets hijacked and retooled from the bottom up.

Then his other series, which the guy clearly put a lot into, gets taken up by someone else.

Never really cared for Alien Nation, as someone above said, it could be very heavy handed at times. But that's also true of his original "V" (which I still love), but man... Guess he's just gonna have to set back and watch other folks run with all his ideas!

(That said, anyone read "'V': The Second Generation"? His intended 'proper' sequel to the original miniseries? Fuck - it ain't good, sad to say.

They Live: The Series!
by TommyGavinsEgo
Jul 2nd, 2009
06:41:16 PM
Great idea! But yes, even better, something original please? It can't be THAT hard to come up with a new alien invasion pitch, for crying out loud.
If its on The Syphilis Channel it will suck.
by Fareal
Jul 2nd, 2009
08:08:23 PM
Sorry, but I've completely lost confidence in Minear.
by CatVutt
Jul 2nd, 2009
10:29:37 PM
Between the God-Awful 'Inside', 'Drive', and the half-assed 'Dollhouse', I just don't get enthused when I see his name anymore.
Alien Nation one of my all-time favorite shows
by symphy
Jul 3rd, 2009
01:39:59 PM
Even the five TV movies were quite decent. Most of the cast is still acting, so I'd love to see as many of them back as possible. Sean Six (who played Buck) never did anything after Alien Nation (or before, actually), and Terri Treas (Cathy) hasn't worked since the last Alien Nation movie. (She's a bit of a larger woman now, hehe.) Lauren Woodland, who played little daughter Emily, is a KNOCKOUT now. (Look at the pics on her IMDB page. WOW. Let her be the new star.) :) It's neat how well the cast gets along, too -- if you watch the little get together hangout session of the cast (it's a DVD extra on the tv movie collection, I think), they're all really funny and have great chemistry off-set, too.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.