Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

Not enough explosions
by Trannyformers_Apologist
Jun 19th, 2009
05:31:44 PM
When I think Sherlock Holmes

I think action packed blockbuster with slow mo fist fist and lots explosions and toilet humor

Movie posters have gotten so boring and sterile
by RobertBaron
Jun 19th, 2009
05:32:40 PM
I can pretty muc imagine the Dr Watson poster
by Castlemonster
Jun 19th, 2009
05:34:22 PM
thanks
Michael Caine was the best Holmes.
by lockesbrokenleg
Jun 19th, 2009
05:34:54 PM
But RDJ could be cool, too.
Twilight
by vadakinX
Jun 19th, 2009
05:38:29 PM
That Holmes poster...it reminds me of Twilight for some reason...not a pleasant thought.
Just can't get excited about this. Hope it's good.
by Mr Nicholas
Jun 19th, 2009
05:38:45 PM
This movie locks boring.
by ganymede3010
Jun 19th, 2009
05:40:48 PM
Sherlock Holmes was cool, back when I was 9.
Posters Are Nothing Special, But...
by William Ashbless
Jun 19th, 2009
05:41:32 PM
...I think this movie will be a ton of fun. I'm looking forward to it.
The idiots have seized on Holmes
by panfolk
Jun 19th, 2009
05:42:14 PM
and given him bedhead.
trailer killed it for me
by GoDFaDDa42
Jun 19th, 2009
05:44:13 PM
I was completely stoked for this picture as a concept (Downey as Holmes, Law as Watson, Ritchie, etc.), but the trailer portrayed a movie so bad that I'm not just disinterested, I actively hate it. The Law poster looks nice at least.
Giant Head, Little Body
by Lance Rocke
Jun 19th, 2009
05:46:08 PM
is it just me, or does he look out of proportion?
More slow motion punching please!
by landosystem
Jun 19th, 2009
05:47:35 PM
Guy Ritchie also needs to have a scene with Sherlock Holmes with a silver Grille and a shotgun...
It's COOL.
by BillyMayesHere
Jun 19th, 2009
05:54:01 PM
Saw the trailer for this
by emeraldboy
Jun 19th, 2009
06:02:53 PM
Fucking rocks. this movie looks great.
Seriously, these heads
by UndeadRabbitZombieJim
Jun 19th, 2009
06:07:21 PM
are out of control. What happened there?
does anyone know...
by codymr
Jun 19th, 2009
06:07:50 PM
if this film is based on any particular Conan Doyle work? Or, is the an "original" adventure?
Donald Clark in the irish tmes
by emeraldboy
Jun 19th, 2009
06:14:37 PM
Ticket supplement, Destroyed Transformers two revenge of the fallen. Here it is enjoy. it does contain spoilers. TRANSFORMERS: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN Directed by Michael Bay Starring Shia LaBeouf, Megan Fox, Josh Duhamel, Tyrese Bigson, John Turturro, Peter Cullen 12A, gen release, 147min IT IS ONLY right that I confess to having enjoyed the first film in this already monumentally tiresome franchise. Written by the same team that later brought us the Star Trek movie, Transformers – robots in disguise! – offered us quite a few decent Spielbergian gags about suburbia before descending into the usual morass of digitally generated, barely coherent inter-robot mayhem. Have the Transformers outstayed their welcome? Like negative equity. Like Big Brother . Like leprosy. Clocking in at an aching two- and-a-half hours, the pompously titled Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen abandons the modest wit of the first film for a relentless assault on those parts of the brain that register noise, volume and inanity. Even Donald Rumsfeld would have trouble euphemising this as anything other than cruel and unusual punishment. Beginning several thousand years before the birth of Christ and apparently playing out in real time, the film supposes that the Decepticons (bad transforming robots) and the Autobots (good transforming robots) had some role in the achievements of ancient civilisation. Back in the present day, Shia LaBeouf, sometime vanquisher of the Decepticons, is preparing to say goodbye to his girlfriend (Megan Fox) and his talking car as he heads off to college. LaBeouf remains passably charming. Ms Fox, clearly an actor of no small ambition, has moved from leaning semi-nakedly over cars to leaning semi-nakedly over motorbikes and has somehow made her lips swell noticeably. While Shia is packing away his stuff, he uncovers a shard of magic material that melts through the floor and turns all the kitchen appliances into savage beasties. It seems that the item is one part of a relic that will help enable a weary robot named The Fallen – who has, I think, been orbiting Saturn for millennia – to return to Earth and use the pyramids to annihilate the sun. Do I have this right? Never mind all that guff. All you need to know is that, a few clumsily comic moments aside, Transformers 2 consists of nothing but explosions, fights and, most peculiarly, dubious right-wing propaganda. This may be paranoia on my part, but, when the milquetoast from Washington invites disaster by ordering the soldiers to stand down their war while they attempt to negotiate with the Decepticons, I detect a non-too-subtle dig at the Obama administration and its supposed antipathy to the war on terror. Michael Bay, the film’s notoriously unrestrained director, has said little about politics, but neither Pearl Harbor nor Bad Boys strike me as particularly liberal entertainments. Anyway, none of this would matter if the action sequences were a little more engaging. It would, at least, be bearable if one knew where one was supposed to be looking and what it is one was supposed to be looking at. Sadly, the over-reliance on computer graphics and the unnecessarily complicated robots – every corner has another corner – make the fight scenes almost impossible to follow. As the film progresses, it begins to take on the quality of an avant-garde experiment in which computers fires pixels at one another while generating random snatches of dialogue composed entirely of imperatives. “Get down!” “Watch Out!” “Cover me! “Destroy Michael Bay!” Now that I think of it, the last line is entirely my own.
There's a charming scene where
by Castlemonster
Jun 19th, 2009
06:17:05 PM
Watson is humped by an amorous bull mastiff while Holmes is in a drug stupor.
RDJ would make a great Sandman
by teethgnasher
Jun 19th, 2009
06:17:25 PM
Just sayin'.
Hi everyone in America
by Lemure_v2
Jun 19th, 2009
06:18:14 PM
I'm writing this from England. Yep. Just thought I'd let you know what I thought of Transformers 2...it's not released over there yet? Oh dear. Well...you'll just have to wait. Might see it again tomorrow, just for fun. It was good to see Jetfire XXXX with XXXX XXXX though, that was cool - everyone in the cinema cheered at that. Can't believe XXXX survived, but hey, oh and Soundwave was completely XXXXXX, which was odd, but he was essential.
The slogan on the poster should be: Whattup Holmes?
by AzulTool
Jun 19th, 2009
06:29:35 PM
I can't wait for Indiana Jones to get his new look...
by Snake Foreskin
Jun 19th, 2009
06:31:58 PM
that goes out of its way to avoid the brown leather jacket and fedora hat. I mean, why should Indy wear his iconic outfit in any further outings?

The point is, I don't appreciate the new, hip version of Sherlock Holmes that eschews the meerschaum pipe and iconic detective hat. What's so uncool about the Basil Rathbone look? Totally iconic. Put it in!

Big ball of fun?
by Logan_1973
Jun 19th, 2009
06:32:34 PM
That it may be, but Holmes was never such (far be it for me to be a purist haha). But I do like the Holmes poster. But I am looking for the traditional cap tho...
Excluding the fact that the movie might be good or bad
by Continentalop
Jun 19th, 2009
06:34:04 PM
These posters are boring as hell.
Bad font
by Holy Hell
Jun 19th, 2009
06:38:33 PM
Sherlock Holmes and the Goblet of Fire
by Vic Twenty
Jun 19th, 2009
06:38:51 PM
Looks like a Potter poster.
I like how "Nothing escapes him" is across his cock
by MattmanReturns
Jun 19th, 2009
06:39:57 PM
Makes sense.
And "Crime will pay" is across Jude Law's cock
by MattmanReturns
Jun 19th, 2009
06:42:25 PM
Nuff said.
At least RDJ knows all about cocaine...
by ZombieHeathLedger
Jun 19th, 2009
06:42:57 PM
which Holmes was addicted to in the books.
Is this a parody of Sherlock Holmes?
by FUCK_YOU_GEORGE_LUCAS
Jun 19th, 2009
06:44:14 PM
Because that's the impression I'm getting. Doesn't look interesting at all.
His haircut
by HoffmanPasander
Jun 19th, 2009
06:45:11 PM
is FUCKING DIST-RACT-ING. Seriously, what 19th Century London Gentleman got his hair coiffed at Toni & Guy?
Pretty sure they've ditched the cocaine, Heath
by OGoncho
Jun 19th, 2009
06:46:47 PM
RDJ made a joke about it in some interview months ago and Joel Silver pretty definitively ruled out any drug-fueled subplot. Something about it being PG-13 and thus inappropriate. Go figure, huh?
"House" is still the best interpretation of Holmes
by MattmanReturns
Jun 19th, 2009
06:49:14 PM
Because without the drug addiction, you pretty much lose the spirit of the character.
RDJ looks a little BRUNO-y...
by TheBLIGHT
Jun 19th, 2009
06:55:54 PM
Hmmm... amusing. Ok, the posters do look good. Though, it makes me miss the late 80's stylings of Holmes & Watson... I think I will watch Michael Caine & Ben Kingsley in Without A Clue... Sigh, real humor.
oGoncho, Holmes shot up with cocaine in the books
by ZombieHeathLedger
Jun 19th, 2009
07:01:42 PM
Downey is the same in every movie. He milks the "irreverent smartass" for every role.
Seriously, those heads are frickin' GIGANTIC!
by Thugsnarf2001
Jun 19th, 2009
07:02:03 PM
How did no one catch that? It looks totally ridiculous! Someone should be slapped. And it looks like a Harry Potter poster for poop's sakes.
remember those big-head baseball cards from the 90's?
by Thugsnarf2001
Jun 19th, 2009
07:03:22 PM
That's what these remind me of.
Where the hell is AVATAR?!
by DrPain
Jun 19th, 2009
07:08:14 PM
Not even a damn teaser. Perhaps Its not looking that great.
It looks like Young Sherlock Holmes
by lockesbrokenleg
Jun 19th, 2009
07:26:14 PM
God, did that movie suck.
Downey miscast, Ritchie overrated
by Kobaal
Jun 19th, 2009
07:28:35 PM
Enough said. Well, not quite enough. RocknRolla was pretty good but not great. His best movie is still Lock Stock (and that was 10+ years ago!).

Law as Watson, however, looks brilliant.

emeraldboy - fucking awesome review!
by Kobaal
Jun 19th, 2009
07:29:35 PM
Loved it :)
Jude Law looks incredibly badass as Watson there
by cyrent
Jun 19th, 2009
07:30:11 PM
not sure if that's part of the character... but I'm not sure if I care
Looks like ass. old ass.
by Mysterious_Volvo
Jun 19th, 2009
07:30:26 PM
Sso guarded about the film
by growltiger
Jun 19th, 2009
08:04:29 PM
I like Downey and Law and I was intrigued by their casting as Holmes and Watson.

But the trailer makes the film seem like a sprawling action adventure with quips galore, which in my opinion is so wrong. To me, Holmes' adventures are cerebral and inventive and not warmed over Buffy.

I'm surprised and dismayed
by panfolk
Jun 19th, 2009
08:09:59 PM
that there is so little backlash for this bullshit when GI Joe remakes merit so much attention.
Kind of hoping this tanks...
by Liberty Valance
Jun 19th, 2009
08:16:28 PM
Just so we don't have to suffer through endless reboots of The Thin Man, Poirot, Charlie Chan et al. Originality in cinema grows more scarce every year.
Gee Quint , here's an easy one!!
by BrashHulk
Jun 19th, 2009
08:58:54 PM
The reason why people are opining, and almost unanimously at this point, that the trailer shows a preview of a movie that looks like its going to both suck AND blow...is because it does.
Worst photoshop job in years
by ackack
Jun 19th, 2009
09:28:41 PM
They look like bobbleheads.
Sherlock Holmes will pugilize you will his logic!
by WillFerret
Jun 19th, 2009
10:05:37 PM
What? He was never a turn of the century boxer. Gimme a break. And it was ungentlemanly to not wear hats back then, fuck off. Don't give me no video game version of Sherlock Holmes you ass Guy Ritchie. Fuck, the bastard took Madonna for every dime he could, now he can make any movie he wishes, you're nothing better than Uwe Boll you fucking monkey!
Not having seen the film
by BenBraddock
Jun 19th, 2009
10:50:54 PM
I cannot say, but it looks kind of like they're using the Sherlock Holmes "brand" for the recognition factor (i.e. ticket sales) only, whereas the original characters have been revamped to the point where they are unrecognizable. Why not just give us all-new characters and be done with it? If you change every aspect of an icon, well, it's no longer an icon, is it? Ugh.
GIANT FUCKING HEADS
by Andyrooskie
Jun 19th, 2009
10:57:55 PM
What is this, Bratz 2??
more like
by frank cotton
Jun 19th, 2009
11:01:26 PM
MIDDLE-AGED SHERLOCK HOLMES
God, I miss PAINTED movie posters
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 19th, 2009
11:31:18 PM
John Alvin is rolling over in his grave...
Nice Modern Haircut
by hayt43
Jun 20th, 2009
12:05:14 AM
....
Law looks good, Downey DOESN'T.
by TheGhostWhoLurks
Jun 20th, 2009
12:27:41 AM
Sorry, but nothing about the trailer, RDJ's mannerisms or look in the film identify as as being Sherlock Holmes, other than the fact that people call him by the name. The guy's a good actor, but this was poor casting.
gay vibes
by TheExterminator
Jun 20th, 2009
01:48:06 AM
Laws Waton Chemistry
by Toilet_Terror
Jun 20th, 2009
01:48:12 AM
Evil laboratory that uses Voodoo Chemicals to create film that is imbued with Satan's magic - when children watch it they start dressing and talking like late-19th-century Londoners.
The trailer was godawful
by AsimovLives
Jun 20th, 2009
05:37:46 AM
Man, the trailer made me want to vown never watch this movie. i guess i 'll end up watching it, maybe my freinds will drag me to watch it, but really, i suspect this movie will really suck ass! I wish it's just a case of "terrible trailer for a good movie", but man, i'm doubtful.
WillFerret
by The Dark Shite
Jun 20th, 2009
05:47:12 AM
Holmes was a practitioner of Bartitsu in the books, a genuinely existing & batshit crazy Gentleman's Martial Art, involving shit like blinding your opponent with your cape, before using your cane to smash his teeth out.

I think Arthur Conan Doyle mispelled it as Baritsu, but it did exist & if Holmes used it, he would have been pretty fucking badass.

& I know he's fictional..
by The Dark Shite
Jun 20th, 2009
05:53:17 AM
But what I mean is, while we tend to look back at Sherlock Holmes as quaint & old fashioned, he was written as a pretty modern character.

The guys who were really using shit like Bartitsu at that time were not to be fucked with.

I'm loving Jude Law as Dr.Watson
by bigmoney
Jun 20th, 2009
07:23:17 AM
I'm Watsonize Will be there Christmas Day
Holmes as '80s rocker?
by rctowns
Jun 20th, 2009
08:13:04 AM
Looks like it to me. Think Moriarty will shake in his shoes when confronted with members of ABC?
Hey Jude, Don't Make it bad, take a bad movie...
by ZombieHeathLedger
Jun 20th, 2009
08:31:48 AM
and make it better... Seriously, give us SKY CAPTAIN 2!
I hate this casting - why not a Brit as Holmes?
by johnnyangel
Jun 20th, 2009
09:08:52 AM
I'm from Texas so I'm pretty familiar with horrible accents from Hollywood actors. And believe me when I tell you, no one outside of Texas can do a Texas accent right. This is even more true of a British accent. I already shudder at what Downey is going to do to that.
I take exception
by Tin Snoman
Jun 20th, 2009
09:40:20 AM
to this fim, not because of it doesn't look like a big ball of fun, but because it says Sherlock Holmes and it pretty clearly isn't. I'd just like to see a straight-up accurate film adaptation of Doyle's stuff, but until then at least I guess we have the Jeremy Brett Holmes tv show. This film looks like fun to watch, but also like the kind of film where Moriarty will try to take over the world with a steampunk laser cannon or something.
Why do I have the horrible feeling...
by Kid Z
Jun 20th, 2009
09:42:20 AM
...that this is going to end up being Wild Wild West set in old London?
Details, Details...
by Rathbone
Jun 20th, 2009
09:50:32 AM
I love all the traditions associated with Sherlock Holmes...even the apocryphal ones like the deerstalker cap and meerschaum pipe. But I'm also open to new interpretations. More than anything, I'm just happy to see Holmes back on the big screen after such a long absence. By the way, I think Holmes' drug use is one of his least essential character traits and has been massively overplayed in most modern adaptations.
Guy Ritchie movie = has me money.
by Judge Briggs
Jun 20th, 2009
10:04:14 AM
Lock, Stock, Snatch, and RocknRolla are fookin classis. I hope he does a follow up to RocknRolla!
johnnyangel
by AsimovLives
Jun 20th, 2009
11:37:35 AM
How was the texan accents in No Country For Old Men?
Rathbone
by AsimovLives
Jun 20th, 2009
11:39:25 AM
"I'm just happy to see Holmes back on the big screen after such a long absence."

They did that with Indiana Jones and Transformers and look how it turned out.
I really like RDJ and loved 'Snatch'
by Dr Gregory House
Jun 20th, 2009
01:52:12 PM
but this will NOT be a good Sherlock Holmes movie! And, I'm sorry, but, Jude Law just flat out sucks.
AsimovLives
by Rathbone
Jun 20th, 2009
01:52:17 PM
I've seen every Holmes adaptation I can get my hands on including some awful ones like "Sherlock Holmes in NY" starring Roger Moore and "The Crucifer of Blood" starring Charleton Heston. Even the worst of them holds a certain kind of charm. I certainly hope the new movie is good. But I'll be interested even if it turns out to be little more than a curiosity.
looks like random adventure movie . . .
by readyoufool
Jun 20th, 2009
02:19:12 PM
. . . with "sherlock holmes" slapped on it as a title. I see nothing about this other than the character names that evokes Sherlock Holmes.
Movie Posters Do Suck These Days
by Autodidact
Jun 20th, 2009
02:21:57 PM
It used to be such an art form. Almost any great movie from before ten years ago has at least one poster that would be worthy of framing and hanging on the wall. These days you may as well just go buy (in this case) a Robert Downey Jr. poster and come out of the closet.
Rathbone
by AsimovLives
Jun 20th, 2009
02:44:19 PM
I'm with you, brother. I really wish the movie is really good. But the trailer put the fear in me.
AsimovLives
by johnnyangel
Jun 20th, 2009
02:55:52 PM
The Texas accents in No Country were good. Tommy Lee Jones is a Texan, and the Coen Brothers lived in Austin for a while when they were younger (Blood Simple was filmed here). The big surprise was how well Kelly MacDonald did, who is, I believe, Scottish. She and Josh Brolin were not totally authentic but they made a decent effort. I was born in West Texas, in Odessa, and the accents out there are so bad it's ridiculous, a really bizarre nasal drawl.
AsimovLives
by johnnyangel
Jun 20th, 2009
02:59:52 PM
I just realized that every one is familiar with the West Texas accent now because of W. The unfortunate effect of the West Texas accent is to make people assume one an ignorant dumbass the moment one open one's mouth, although, in some cases, obviously one is.
Our Sherly it aint
by McBegbie
Jun 20th, 2009
03:11:37 PM
Ok, I'm an RDJ fan, and I enjoyed Lock Stock and Snatch but expectations are low. Jude looks the part but Sherlock Holmes this is not. I'll go see it and it may well be entertaining but it's got feck all to do with Conan Doyle's creation.
Downey's haircut seems
by cromwell1666
Jun 20th, 2009
03:28:30 PM
time period-inappropriate. I am all for director discretion, but that reeks of a group of studio marketing douchebags trying too squeeze the younger demographics at the expense of a classic chracter.
At least this movie looks better than a bag of dicks
by Outlaw
Jun 20th, 2009
03:58:59 PM
Who the fuck gave him his haircut, David Bowie's hair stylist circa 1984?
Shelock Holmes with Dragon Ball Evolution hair
by ricarleite2
Jun 20th, 2009
04:04:21 PM
Nice
I hope this is good, but unless they have really
by southafricanguy
Jun 20th, 2009
09:45:13 PM
improved the script I read (of which I doubt as I recognize all the mments in the trailer from the script) then this movie will have serious problems imho....
This shit is gonna fail competing with Avatar
by fisheater
Jun 20th, 2009
10:44:57 PM
Ritchie's career is FUCKED CONFIRMED
Years from now, people will still bereading Conan Doyle
by Sepulchrave
Jun 21st, 2009
04:58:59 AM
..and this will seem like another chunk of embarrassing cultural detritus, like Ken Russell's gruesome interpretations of the lives of Tchaikovsky and Gaudier Brzeska: a supposedly hip, now horribly dated attempt to foist your decade's values on something eternal. These movies will be like MC Hammer, like Tamagochis. Quaint.
Oh and Baritsu was just a fictional Japanese style of wrestling
by Sepulchrave
Jun 21st, 2009
07:43:49 AM
..regrettably it had nothing to do with capes or canes. Or cutting someone's head off with a razor blade concealed in the brim of one's top hat. Alas.
no money for Jude Law from me
by mrbong
Jun 21st, 2009
08:41:30 AM
Jude Law is a complete and utter cock. why does he keep getting film work? i will not pay to see this as much as i love Robert's films, shall just wait for it to turn up on TV. now had they cast Clive Owen as Watson, what a winner that would have been.
no Rachel McAdams no $
by Jesiah
Jun 21st, 2009
08:47:25 AM
Know Rachel McAdams know $.........at least for me anyway. Heck, we gotta make sure Ritchie stays in the game, to show he's better off without that hag ex wife of his.
He needs a cute robot sidekick
by Mgmax
Jun 21st, 2009
09:03:19 AM
And maybe a scene where he disguises as a black woman and has to sing Motown hits with a gospel choir. Honestly, this looks like the biggest Shite Holmes ever, if you don't get why, maybe READ THE STORIES, fanboys?
League of Extraordinary Detectives
by Disco_sucks
Jun 21st, 2009
08:43:18 PM
Really, why bother? Is this going to add anything to either the character or cinema in general?
Yikes
by carraway
Jun 22nd, 2009
06:12:49 AM
"Hip" minded film execs plus giant mound of coke plus Guy Ritchie equals... welll I haven't seen it yet but much dread and nausia nad bad feelings for the Conan Doyle heirs.
I'm Looking Forward To This
by kevinwillis.net
Jun 22nd, 2009
08:56:05 AM
I will see it as soon as it comes out on DVD.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.