Ain't It Cool News: The best in movie, TV, DVD, and comic book news.

DOCTOR WHO??
TV Actor Matt Smith!!

Just so no one can say by Crow3711	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:43:38 PM
the word we all know people usually say.
London? Please... by mooli_mooli	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:48:27 PM
It's the Manchester Guardian.
Ejiofor would be a dream 11! by AnnoyYou	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:51:28 PM
I think his role in Serenity proves he would be a great (and deadly) Doctor. However, I think he is too high-profile for the role, unfortunately. I hope they don't cast Patterson Joseph - he's almost as bad as James Nesbit (and just as inexplicably popular in the UK) and would be a huge disappointment after the terrific Tennant. The Guardian also mentions Ben Wishlaw as a possible Eleven, which is weird, although he would appeal to the bloodless skinny hipster audience. I dunno. I wanted Kevin McKidd (Ginger Doctor!) but actually anyone would be better than Joseph or Nesbit. ::shudders:: The idea of either taking the role makes me sick. I'll stop watching if either of them takes the part.
i can dig that by ls420	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:53:02 PM
but tennant only has 3hrs left according to the creator, so wouldnt the new doc be in the first few episodes of the new season?
That's right... by mooli_mooli	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:55:38 PM
Change the article, make me look like I'm talking crazy :D
please don't let it be ejiofor by Toe Jam	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:55:52 PM
doing drivel like "doctor who" would be a waste of his talent. keep him in great entertainment. this guy has quickly become one of my favorite actors, and he deserves better vehicles than "doctor who."
I want him to Degenerate by Rumpel Tumskin	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:57:09 PM
and give Paul McGann the screen time he deserves. But he has to grow hi Roger Daltery hair back out
Ejiofor would be much better than Paterson Joseph by SpyGuy	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:58:24 PM
And anyone who deems DOCTOR WHO as "drivel" seriously needs their head examined.
His resume looks a little too good. by Kurutteru Yatsu	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:58:37 PM
I only really know him from 'Inside Man' so I looked him up. I'm afraid we'll have another Doctor who only sticks around for a season or two.
Remember when Robot Chicken was funny? by Jodet	Jan 2nd, 2009 03:59:39 PM
That was a long time ago. And yes, Ejiofor would be a DREAM COME TRUE for the new Doctor.
They're going to go the "diversity" route by jdb1972	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:00:37 PM
And for once, I can't object. We've had enough weird, young, skinny white guys for now.
Tardis says no by NinjaChampion	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:02:57 PM
I'd like to see David Walliams as the next doctor
Ignorance by NudeandAroused	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:03:05 PM
I am willing to admit it. I am ignorant. I cannot pronounce this guy's name to save my life. i think he would be a great Doctor.
Can Nathon Fillon guest star? by Manos	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:07:51 PM
That would be cool
Matt Smith by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:15:29 PM
will be the next Doctor Who. Matt Who?
Yay for Paterson Joseph by Brendon	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:21:43 PM
He has it. You know it. And, no, he won't appear in the 2009 Xmas special - but the episode AFTER that. The next Xmas special is the penultimate remaining Tennant story. Interesting to see Joseph being lined up for a Gaiman script again, after Neverwhere. That's the role that basically confirms how he could ace the Dr.
Betfair says different by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:24:00 PM
http://www.betfair.com/Index.d o?mi=21313290&ex=1&rfr= 3013
The 2009 Christmas Special will feature the regeneration by SpyGuy	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:26:43 PM
So yes, the Eleventh Doctor will appear in it, just as the very end as the cliffhanger for Series Five in 2010.
Catherine Zeta Jones please by c4andmore	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:27:35 PM
guest starring Michael Douglas as Methuselah
Richard Coyle by mooli_mooli	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:34:23 PM
Gets my vote. He and Moffat have history.
Ejiofor won't be the next Doctor by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:45:56 PM
I mean, come on now! Why would a guy who has clearly made it in Hollywood turn around to star in a BBC show?
It will be Paterson Joseph by supertoyslast	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:47:30 PM
I'm willing to give Joseph a chance, but I really want Chiwetel Ejiofor for just one series. As for when the 11th Doctor will appear, Tennant has four more specials (all still to be filmed). It seems likely that at least 2 of these will be shown over Christmas and New Year 2009/2010. So the Christmas Day episode could be the penultimate Tennant episode and the regeneration would then be in the fourth special around New Year. This is pure speculation based on the strongest rumours as I last heard them.
Here is a list of the potential nominees.. by emeraldboy	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:51:34 PM
Patterson Joseph, Catherine Zeta jones, Lesley Sharp, Tom Chambers and there is another bloke called Russell whose last name I cant remember but Russell T davies tipped him to be the next dr. RTD said he didnt know who it was going to be. bullshit.
PHENOMENAL IDEA: But he may be too good for it by Stormwatcher	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:54:18 PM
C'mon he rocks! Might actually watch due to this. But only if it happens.
Whoever it is........ by The Handsome 12th Doctor	Jan 2nd, 2009 04:59:33 PM
I reckon I'm gonna be pleased with them. Based on the evidence that the Beeb have made two outstanding choices so far since bringing Who back. What I love most about Eccleston and Tennant is neither were on anyone's 'Guess list'. Both choices made everyone go "Oh, I never thought of them.... but they'd be good!" I'm hoping for a similar name tomorrow. Saying that if Chewy is announced I'll be fupping ecstatic. Though there's no way they could get him to commit to a 13 ep series nowadays. I'd be happy with Mooli's selection of Richard Coyle. Or, if we're throwing out names, then I'll stand by my previous idea of Mark Heap. But ideally I want to go "Oh, I never thought of them......"
I can't follow Dr. Who at all, and stopped trying to by blindambition238	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:01:52 PM
But if he does indeed become the new star I'll give it another shot (12th times a charm, right?). This would be really wierd though cause I've never seen him do anything outside of serious work. It'll be kinda weird to see him joking around and stuff though...
Isn't that guy black? by punto	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:04:27 PM
I thought the chick from ER already met the current doctor in the future, wasn't there supposed to be a bunch of episodes with them before he switches? Unless they jump over that whole arc, which wouldn't be a bad thing.. I'm not really looking forward to see "I'd follow him to the end of the world" all over again.
How many doctors are left? by Alkeoholic77	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:06:27 PM
I don't know shit about Dr. Who but I know that he can only change his body so many times...
Dr Fop by Aeronaut	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:06:47 PM
During the last christmas special confidential show, RTD seemed to go out of his way to praise the 'best Doctor who never was' - Hugh Grant! I think RTD winked at the camera also as he said it....sleep well! But seriously, the bookies have stopped taking bets on Paterson Joseph.
Please remove Ejiofor's name from the headline by supertoyslast	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:09:47 PM
I briefly got excited when I thought that Herc knew something I didn't. The Guardian don't have a clue and are just taking names from Outpost Gallifrey. Hint that it's Ejiofor and a lot of people will be disappointed when it's not (including me). I thought it must be Paterson Joseph because he has given non-denial denials. But current fave on betfair is Matt Smith from Party Animals: http://www.imdb.com/name/nm174 1002/
Awesome choice, if it is true. by 24200124	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:13:52 PM
I think he can pull off both the serious side (watch "Serenity" for that) and the goofy side (see "Kinky Boots"). Yay Chewie!
KINKY BOOTS by Sebilrazen	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:14:07 PM
Don't forget Chiwetel Ejiofor was Lola in "Kinky Boots" and did his own singing.
punto: the River Song conundrum by danowen	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:14:53 PM
Apparently The Doctor/River Song relationship was going to form a big part of Steven Moffatt's fifth season, but he's had to rethink things now that Tennant is leaving. The River Song storyline may still be there, but in altered form, perhaps. Anyway, River Song could very easily have known the Twelfth Doctor and not the Eleventh. Or, thinking ahead, I'm sure The Doctor will be given extra regenerations at some stage, anyway.
Black Doctors by Mr_X	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:19:04 PM
My current Dr, Dr Yesufu is black, He's alright. I don't expect him to turn out white any time soon though
RAY STEVENSON?? by Alkeoholic77	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:21:03 PM
Isn't he the guy who wrote "The Streak?"
Question? by codymr	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:28:55 PM
Forgive my lack of DW knowledge, but how many times can the Doctor regenerate? Is he like a cat and with "9 Lives" (I guess at least 11 in this case) or are Time Lords immortal and regenerate forever? Just curious.
who would we like? by DrLektor	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:34:41 PM
My dream Doctor would be either Stephen Fry, Hugh Laurie, Chris Barrie, Richard E Grant, Richard O'Brian or in a nice twist, a returning John Simm. Who's it more likely to be? Patterson Joseph or Russell Tovey, those seem to be the names coming up the most, I guess we'll find out tomorrow.
How about Jason Statham? Crank 2 is wrapped. by Stuntcock Mike	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:35:32 PM

Vinny Jones by papabendi	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:35:51 PM
no one else makes sense.
If it's Paterson Joseph then I'm done. by thecomedian	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:36:46 PM
And I'm a Black Whovian so please don't think I'm racist. He's a shitty actor with zero range. He's the idiot who refused to believe the Daleks were real until he was staring down one. I laughed, almost cheered when he was exterminated. If they cast him then it's just a stupid token gesture and he'll be a one off. The one Black Doctor they cast out of 14 just so they could pat themselves on the back and feel good about themselves at the franchises expense. He'll be terrible, The Colin Baker of this new era. All this fan wanking for him just proves that some British geeks are just as short sighted and tasteless as their American counterparts. If it's not Chiwetel Ejiofor then it should be someone who's actually talented and has gravitas like Colin Salmon. Either way, I don't need Doctor Who to be Black to feel good about myself or feel included in the franchise. This isn't the POTUS. I just want the stories to be good and for the Doctor to be played by someone actually talented.
He'll be black. by Loosejerk	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:37:39 PM
And The Master will be an Alaskan hoochie. Change we can believe in.
If not Vinny by papabendi	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:38:16 PM
Jimmy Nail. There I said it.
Doctor can regenerate 12 times by lex romero	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:38:32 PM
I think it is. So that's 13 Doctors. The next will be the 11th. So they have a couple to go before they need to think up some way for him to get another 12 regenerations. I'm thinking the time lords will get brought back at some point and he borrows one of their bodies or something.
If he's black by papabendi	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:40:44 PM
then it's Lenny Henry.
As much as I would like to see Richard Coyle by dogrobber	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:42:51 PM
(I wish) or Paterson Joseph (isn't he doing another season of 'Survivors'?)as the new Doctor I just got a text saying the new Doctor is Hermione Norris. (who? - I'm probably being messed with)
More like by Fat and Curious	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:48:28 PM
Dr. JiggaBoo
Fat and Curious by thecomedian	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:49:34 PM
Go eat a bag of dicks.
thecomedian by dogrobber	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:50:43 PM
I didn't realize that was Joseph in 'Bad Wolf' - I was thinking about his work in 'Neverwhere' - I may have to rethink my support for him as the Doctor (like my support matters).
thecomedian - Well said! by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:52:17 PM
"Either way, I don't need Doctor Who to be Black to feel good about myself or feel included in the franchise. This isn't the POTUS. I just want the stories to be good and for the Doctor to be played by someone actually talented." So say we all! Nothing wrong with shaking up the format - a black or female Doctor would be a nice twist on the format, but it HAS TO BE the BEST actor for the part - but after watching JONATHAN CREEK: THE GRINNING MAN the other night, I'd like to see the series go all Tom Baker Jr and cast Alan Davies. And Frankie Boyle for The Master. Again. Won't happen, but how great would it be if they did?!?
by Mvraiment	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:54:32 PM
Are Doctor Who and Samantha Who related?
papabendi by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 05:54:53 PM
Actually, I wouldn't hate Lenny Henry as The Doctor - could be some int3eresting left-field casting, and he can act, so... why not? If we must go down the young skinny weird white guy route, give the ladies some sugar and cast Tom Chambers. He's a solid actor, and can also dance....
lex romero by Alkeoholic77	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:00:59 PM
Thanks man! I knew they were getting up there...
Ejiofor? THAT WOULD ROCK! by SkidMarkedUndies	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:05:06 PM
But how will it explain River Song's comments?
thecomedian by Fat and Curious	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:05:44 PM
I really enjoyed your Cracked article on FOX and look forward to more dick-consumption burns in the future!
More like by Fat and Curious	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:06:08 PM
Mr. Who, black people can't become doctors!
Please don't be Paterson Joseph by Lloytron	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:07:34 PM
Not that I have anything against the guy, the opposite in fact. It's just that to me he is Johnson from Peep Show and I wouldn't be able to watch Doctor Who without thinking of his carrot made of stick :D
He would be great. by mr.brownstone	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:07:51 PM
Too bad it'll never happen/
A Degeneration is a good idea by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:12:05 PM
Or something totally unexpected, like a former Who extra who was really a future incarnation all along. It would be fun to find out that a former supporting character is really the timelord, or even a Villain (with the reasons for his or her actions being explained). I liked the idea of the Doctor meeting a future version in the Xmas special (even though it wasn't) and I hope they do something similar in the upcoming specials. With the successor looking in the mirror and saying "I Know You!"
Spud... by thecomedian	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:13:06 PM
They already had Tom Baker Jr. His name was Christopher Eccleston and he was fantastic! I hope he comes back one day. He'd be a total bint not to. I mean he played Doctor Lazer Rage on the Sara Silverman program but somehow he's too good to come back to Doctor Who!?! They could easily bring him back for a crossover and not have to worry about bringing Billy back too. At the end of 'Rose' he could have gone off and had literally years of adventures between the time the Tardis dematerializes and rematerialized "did I mention it travels through time?" Come back Chris! Russell's Gone! So you don't have to worry about him trying to make you toss Captain Jack's salad.
it's Patterson joseph I expect. by earlfist	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:17:15 PM
Shame as "black dude from serenity" would be fucking awesome, not a bad choice as also Richard Coyle would be.
Please either be... by XoanonTORN	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:18:02 PM
Colin Salmon (I know him and can work in a set visit..) or James Nesbitt...I watched 10 mins of Jekyll and thought 'He;d be an awesome Doctor!'.. Ejofor is a good choice too...loved him in Serenity.. I'm just WAY too excited for this...been a Who fan since I was 11
Christopher Biggins confirmed.... by rizla	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:22:12 PM
as the next James Bond :)
River Song by Lloytron	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:28:15 PM
I know she mentioned that the Doctor she knew was older, but she never specifically stated it was an older version of Tennant... she knew about Rose and a lot of other things, she may have known about his tendency to regenerate.
I know I'm going to be disappointed by kuryakin	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:39:41 PM
No matter who they announce. I'm going to get excited and then it will be someone shit. In my humble opinion, the best name that was seriously mentioned (for like, two seconds) was Aiden whatsisface, Tommy Carcetti from The Wire. He's handsome enough for the new audience, relatively unknown so the commitment wouldn't be a problem and a good enough actor to handle the weird lurches between drama and comedy that the new series' do seem to love. Instead of that Patterson Joseph from Peep Show they should go for the infinitely better David Mitchell, I'd love to see him squaring up to The Master. And as for Nesbitt, the only good thing about him was the unintended comedy in Match Point of him and Ewen Bremner as Northern Irish and Scottish police in London sitting around trying to make Woody Allen's NY intellectual dialogue sound remotely plausible "Yes, I'm torn..." Yeah that's how the cops here talk Woodster. Actually, Ewen Bremner would be a left-field but hilarious choice for the Doctor
If it somehow turns out River Song by kuryakin	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:40:52 PM
Is the Doctor, I shall be most displeased
If Chiwetel Ejiofor by Series7	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:41:09 PM
Maybe I'll start watching this show.
Another vote for Paterson Joseph by CZ	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:43:28 PM
Ejiofor would be great also, but Paterson Joseph is less well known and wouldn't have as much baggage. And I want Ejiofor to keep doing offbeat things like Lola in "Kinky Boots."
If it is Stevenson... by AnnoyYou	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:46:14 PM
...I will faint dead away. He would be so great as Eleven! As would his Rome compatriot Kevin McKidd. Or Richard Armitage. Or Idris Elba. Or Ejiofor (although I haven't a hope of that happening. But if it's Joseph or Nesbit, this series is DEAD to me. Why do the Brits love these scenery-chewing hacks so much?!
January 2009 by Smashing	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:47:08 PM
SpudMcSpud said "I wouldn't hate Lenny Henry as The Doctor" This will never be forgotten C.E was on Richard & Judy after Serenity came out and he called it sci-fi nonsense, is he really going to want to play The Doctor?
Just remember what Steven Moffat gave up for this gig by palimpsest	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:49:06 PM
For a UK TV writer to turn down Spielberg and Jackson's TINTIN trilogy specifically to helm this AND to get the chance to re-cast the lead actor; do't think for a second that it'll be a half-assed choice. Whoever is coming (see what I did there?), there'll be both direction and purpose to it. Make no mistake, WHO isn't some geeky niche market material; right now this is the UK's number one non-soap drama, and the biggest role in UK television. No pressure then...
Ejiofor would be so perfect, it's.... by gotilk	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:55:29 PM
unlikely.
About regenerations.... by question83	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:58:37 PM
...i really wouldn't expect, that BBC will kill it's cash cow, because of some rule created back in 1976. The BBC's Series 4 FAQ suggests that now the Time Lord social order has been destroyed, the Doctor may be able to circumvent the limit on regenerations; it says: "Now that his people are gone, who knows? Time Lords used to have 13 lives."
how many times can the doctor regenerate by jccalhoun	Jan 2nd, 2009 06:59:33 PM
http://is.gd/es5k
David Knijnenburg by magnius	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:00:23 PM
There were rumours a while ago that David Knijnenburg was secretly flown in from Oz to meet the Who production crew...it would be a massively outside choice....
they missed their chance by FamousEccles	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:04:32 PM
I think David Morrissey would have been perfect. Even his costume was good. the tie and reeboks are getting stale.
it won't be Patterson Joseph by Cedar_Room	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:04:33 PM
coz he's already been in Who as another character. I think its likely to be someone Moffat has worked with before - after all RTD had worked on series with both Eccleston and Tennant before he cast them as the Doctor. So for me that makes Richard Coyle, Jack Davenport and Matt Smith (who apparently has worked with Moffat??) I have no problem with a black Doctor, but think that would be the only reason to cast Patterson Joseph. Just don't think he's a strong enough actor. Ejiofor would be brilliant but think he's happy doing films. So how about Irdis Elba? Doctor Stringer Bell....sweet.
Cedar_Room by magnius	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:05:41 PM
So? Colin Baker was in an episode of Doctor Who before he got cast as the Doctor.
Why all the Patterson Joseph hate? by gotilk	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:06:57 PM
It wouldn't in any way be disappointing. He was great in Survivors, which was better than it should have been.
Chiwetel Ejiofor would make a fantastic Doctor by Shub-Wankalot	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:24:28 PM
After seeing him in Dirty Pretty Things, I have complete confidence that he would capture the essence and quirks of the Doctor, jelly baby and all.
Smashing by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:27:07 PM
You can hold me to that. Tell me you don't think Lenny Henry would make a fun choice for the 11th Doc! And he can do serious too... Hey, at this point pretty much ANY other black actor other than Paterson Joseph would be preferable - PJ is fucking AWFUL. But given the choice, I'd love to see Chiwetel get the role :D
Tilda Swinton should play the Doctor by KnightShift	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:32:09 PM
Anyone else think she'd be great in the role?
"British geeks are just as short sighted and tasteless..." by Kurutteru Yatsu	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:35:26 PM
"...as their American counterparts," he posted. On the American geek website he must visit fairly often if he went so far as to make an account for it. Fuck you, pal.
Chiwetel Ejiofor??? by Golden_God	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:38:47 PM
Does that make the name of the show Doctor Was'sup? hey hear they're casting Daniel Craig as Kunta Kinte and Jacky Chan as the 2009 version of the incredible hulk revisited, reborn and regurtitated. Ballocks, dr who is white, Kunta Kinte is black and the hulk is green and crap
How do you pronounce Chiwetel Ejiofor? by Clavius	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:40:24 PM
I've seen his name in print countless times but never heard it spoken. Interesting choice if true.
Kurutteru... by thecomedian	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:44:32 PM
I said "some" not all. And I'm American so don't think I'm some brit ripping on "stupid yanks". Some geeks are short sighted and tasteless. The people who wanted Crispin Glover to be the Joker because he's weird and skinny. The people who to this day still think Lucy Lawless should play Wonder Woman just because of Xena. That's what I'm talking about and that's how I group the people jizzing over Patterson Joseph simply because he's Black and he's on another sci-fi fantasy show.
KnightShift by gotilk	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:47:55 PM
I'm with you. She can do anything. And I'm FOR stirring the whole thing up to make it fresh and surprising.
Clavius... by banville	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:49:07 PM
You pronounce it: Chew-E-Tell Edge-E-Oh-For
Richard E Grant by TheTaf	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:52:31 PM
YOu heard it hear first!!
Please do not throw hands at me, but... by MediaGold	Jan 2nd, 2009 07:52:40 PM
I think the Doctor should stay caucasin. The Doctor is our hero, and by "our" I mean pasty, pale-as-the-driven-snow, skinny dweebsticks. Would you cast Rowan Atkinson as Dolemite or Hugh Laurie and Richard Grant as the leads in Bad Boys III? Uh uh. With the rumors of James Bond going black and Will Smith or The Rock being casted as Superman, which whiteys will we waxen wimps be able to idolize as our pretend heroes? I mean really, Doctor Who is kind of an imperialist white man's show. I can't for the life of me remember a Who fan of African descent and the only cool black character I can remember from the original show was the one that spoke the subject line quote to this post and he was D84 - an art deco robot.
Tilda Swinton would be AWESOME! by Logo Lou	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:02:59 PM
KnightShift is right. As far as the Patterson Joseph hate, mine comes from Jekyll. I remember really enjoying that show except when he came on screen (and the final episode which really fell apart). His performance in that was AWFUL.
ok...here's one...James Callis by vadakinX	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:09:03 PM
Yeah...Gaius "Fraking" Baltar. I know I know, seems strange when you first see the name but think about it...he's British, fairly young, or at least young enough to fit in with the latest incarnation of the show, he has great comic timing (if you ever see him at the Cons, he's actually pretty funny) and has finished Battlestar Galactica so I assume he is unemployed. In fact, while Who is one of the biggest shows in Britain, it's still fairly niche in the US and Callis could be enough to bring BSG fans over to watching Who. Heck, if not the Doctor, he would be an awesome Master.
Nah,..the Doctor's not pure as the driven snow...so by Shub-Wankalot	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:14:15 PM
a dab of color won't hurt his image...'cause he's the Doctor! So Chiwetel Ejiofor...for the win!
I'd love it to be Alan Davies by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:15:25 PM
He's great in Jonathon Creek and can do eccentric in his sleep.
Doesn't matter who they get for the Doctor. by Amy Chasing	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:17:22 PM
They'll get a decent enough actor (because the show is big enough to warrant it). The main thing is that Moffat is going to be writing for it - so forget the RTD season finale letdowns and prepare yourself for some well written Who!
Lemming, don't get your tail all in a twist by MediaGold	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:17:41 PM
My post was in jest. Somewhat. If an actor who isn't a pasty white guy can bring some balls and sorely lacking brains back into Doctor Who, I'm all for it. But if you could jump off your politically correct cliff for a mo' and actually elaborate why "the Doctor has nothing to do with being pasty or white" since the dozen plus actors who've assumed the role over the decades have been just that and "nor is it anything like casting a white guy as a lead for Bad Boys". Ummmmm, yeah it would.
Joseph and Nesbitt are mediocre actors. by AnnoyYou	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:18:28 PM
Plus Nesbitt is waaaay unattractive. Neither has the personal magnetism OR the acting chops to succeed Eccleston or Tennant. It would be analogous to...well, choosing an actor like Marc Blucas as Buffy's hero and love interest instead of, say, James Marsters. Or, similarly, going with an actor like Teddy Dunn as Veronica Mars's hero and romantic interest, and not, say, FRICKIN' JASON DOHRING. Yes, I still have issues with these shows - why do you ask?
Chiwetel could be The Master by performingmonkey	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:19:42 PM
I think if Paterson Joseph is the next Doctor (very likely, and he WOULD be a good choice) Chiwetel would make a great Master opposite him. Somehow it would just feel right for The Master to regenerate into a black guy if the Doctor was now black. There's no way Chiwetel is the Doctor anyway. He would have to sacrifice his ever-growing movie career to do it. Who knows, Doctor Who may be a role he desperately wants to do. Paterson Joseph IMO fits the role very well. If you see him in Neverwhere you can understand how he would play the Doctor. He would bring some mystery back to the character, which is something that Steven Moffat (the new showrunner as of mid-2009) enjoys doing also in his scripts. Paterson also appeared in a past Moffat show, Jekyll, so that's another plus point for him. I can't see it being anyone else tbh.
Not Tilda but by ThrowMeTheIdol	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:22:11 PM
a woman would be a great idea. As a sometimes/casual viewer, I'd definitely watch. You know, as long as it isn't Jennifer Saunders or someone like that.
I REALLY don't want it to be a woman by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:24:18 PM
I'm not being sexist in that statement, it's just a personal preference for a male Doctor. I've been a Who fan since the eighties and I believe casting a woman would be a change too far. The Doctor has always been a male and, as a man myself, it's helped me identify with the character. It would be like Smallville getting rid of Superman and replacing him with Supergirl. Some things don't need to change in my opinion.
James Marsters would be great by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:26:00 PM
Is he working at the moment? He's been in Torchwood and so he's obviously known to the people behind the scenes...
Remember back when... by Leto III	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:35:54 PM
...Robert Carlyle was supposedly one of the front-runners? Yeah. Good times. That said, Richard Coyle would be an insane, yet awesome, choice for the 11th Doctor, particularly given his past working history with Moffat.
I'd like to see... by HollywoodBob	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:36:19 PM
Paul McGillion, as the new doctor. I know his character was a bit timid on Stargate: Atlantis, but I think he'd do a fine job as The Doctor. Also if we were to consider a woman as an incarnation of The Doctor, I think Sarah Alexander would make a fine choice. She's lovely, and can do both comedy and drama well. What I want to know is where's our Doctor's Daughter spin-off damn it! Genny was HOT! and she's not on Code-9 anymore.
Also... by Leto III	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:37:17 PM
...they should do that final Paul McGann regeneration-story, like, pronto, while he's still able to take on the role. Or at least do a frigging "Time War" novel series, for crying out loud. SOMETHING to finally give us some closure on that storyline.
Tilda gives me a semi by BrandLoyalist	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:41:03 PM
Get it? Punctuation humor. Babe is like 5'10.5"! (Ooo, I've been waiting to use this one - sure didn't think it'd be in a Dr. Who article.) There are Time Ladies, though, you know. Romana? It'd certainly be cool to have another Time Lady companion. But I've never heard of a Time Lord/Lady regenerating into a different gender. Would that be transregenderation? I'm totally ready for a different skin tone, though. Maybe it would help to see Gallifrey again, eh, to confirm the existence of different skin colors among their people? Hmm? (F'in Time War, grumble grumble...)
Lemming by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:44:36 PM
"The Doctor is a half-human alien who is eccentric, energetic charismatic and very, very old and mysterious. There is nothing there that suggest he should be any particular (human) race at all." You mean, apart from the fact that every previous incarnation has been male and white, and of an obviously human appearance? Casting black or female WILL require some explanation, if only to explain how if the Doctor ISN'T only limited to being white and male, he HAS BEEN for EVERY INCARNATION of his existence! The Doctor should have SOME continuity in his character - so if he isn't white or malke in his next incarnation, we need at least SOME technobabble to explain why. Any less than this would expose this for the token PC box-ticking exercise that I secretly fear it is (especialy if Paterson Joseph gets the role despite his extremely limited acting ability). It's not racist or sexist to wonder why a supposedly near-immortal character that has been male and white for ten of his allotted thirteen incarnations would suddenly change sex or colour - it's whether or not a writer can give a good enough reason for said change. And yes, it IS EXACTLY like imagining that BAD BOYS II were remade with Fry and Laurie or those Peep Show boys or any other Caucasian duo in the lead - you'd wonder why, and you'd be right to do so. Characterisation and continuity and absolute devotion to writing the very best stories they can for Doctor Who should ALWAYS be considered far above any issues involving colour-blind casting, casting to fit ethnic / gender-based / sexually-oriented quotas and other assorted PC nonsense - because it is a TV SHOW FIRST!!!
spud by vadakinX	Jan 2nd, 2009 08:48:51 PM
I agree...but come on...a Fry and Laurie version of Bad Boys would be awesome :P
giving the role to Chiwetel Ejiofor will set back race relations by smackfu	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:05:37 PM
because he has zero charisma, and it will be a big news thing because it's the first black Doctor, except this guy is boring as shit and the ratings will plummet, and black people will notice that all the white people stopped watching Doctor Who when the role was taken over by a black man, and they'll be like 'you're racist' and we'll be like 'hey, it's not like that, this guy's boring as shit and doesn't fit the role' and then Obama will be like 'holy Christ BBC you are fucking up my shit'
David Walliams? from Little Britain? hell yeah by smackfu	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:16:23 PM

smackfu by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:18:38 PM
As always, your fu is strongest. We have to agree to disagree on Chi's charisma (he's fucking AWESOME in SERENITY as The Operative - "Somebody FIRE!")but as for all the rest, including fucking up Obama's shit, I have to bow to. Baracka wins! Flawless victory.
Vadakin by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:21:44 PM
House and Kingdom in BAD BOYS III? Hell yeah you'd better believe it! Shame this didn't occur to Pegg and Frost when they made HOT FUZZ... because watching two lower-middle-class lovable white suburbanite slackers fighting zombies was every kind of AWESOME, but two lower-middle-class lovable white suburbanite slackers being Bad Boys? In a merket town? Every kind of AWFUL, I'm afraid. Fry & Laurie's BAD BOYS 3 > HOT FUZZ. You know it's true.
MARKET, not MERKET... by spud mcspud	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:22:52 PM
...unless their exclusive output consists solely of blue-rinse pubic wigs, anyway.
If you want to cast a black Doctor Who by smackfu	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:23:19 PM
you need to do it right and get Cornel West. That cat IS Doctor Who.
He will be black by EyeofPolyphemus	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:23:39 PM
The question is how realistic will his travels to the past be portrayed? Martha had to be a maid in 1913 during the third season, but rosita was running around in Victorian times without anyone batting an eye. It will be doubly strange if he has a white companion of either gender. There is an opportunity here to explore racial issues honestly, but will Moffat just overlook it for the sake of convenience?
Lex Romero by medicinaluser	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:24:30 PM
I thought the Time Lords imposed the 12 regneration limit upon themselves as a way of keeping them in check or something. As this Dr is the last of them all there really is nothing stopping him from adandoning that limit and continue on for as long as he pleases to do so. I think people get a little bent out of shape over the whole how/why/what will happen once he gets to the 12th but really there need not be some outrageous fix all just that rather than stop he choose to go on as he can and most likely will do.
And yes, Cornel West has a SAG card by smackfu	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:24:55 PM
He was in the Matrix trilogy.
Robbie Coltrane by kdoc13	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:27:02 PM
Why not an old fat Doctor?
Jack Davenport by ThrowMeTheIdol	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:29:20 PM
Why not? He'd be perfect and he has worked with Moffat.
I will for the first time watch Doctor Who.. by eggart	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:46:11 PM
..if this is true.
Kanye West? by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:48:56 PM

How about Eddie Izzard? by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 2nd, 2009 09:52:13 PM
His tv show in America has been cancelled and I'm sure he's in the UK doing stand up at the moment. Get him in there, Moff!
I predict.... by JackNF	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:11:39 PM
Carrot Top! Then 5 minutes later (after whoever his companion is at the times beats him to death) we'll get #12!
I'd love Tilda by I am the most horrible	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:20:10 PM
She's plenty charming for my tastes. Jane Horrocks too. I don't understand the hate for Jospeh and Nesbitt. I thought Nesbitt was HAWESOME in Jekyll...wish the series was a s good as its first 2 episodes. It kinda shot its wad early.
Will Dr. Who remain celibate once he turns black? by Leafar the Lost	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:27:15 PM
Hey, I am all for Dr. Who becoming black, but the next hot, white-girl he picks to be his "companion" in the Tardis had better hold on to her pussy...
black doctor is nothing like white dolemite by jccalhoun	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:32:27 PM
One of the points of the mythos is that the Doctor changes what he looks like. Other examples of changing the race or gender are recasts or remakes that aren't exlained within the stoyr. The Doctor changing is explained. As far as never having been any color but white before indicating that he can only be white, well Romana "tried on" a body of a blue woman in Destiny of the Daleks which indicates that Time Lords aren't bound to staying just one color.
Name change to Dr, "What's Up?* by cookylamoo	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:32:36 PM
Serious, this guy was great in Talk to me, as long as he doesn't have to fake age.
Tara Reid's gut as Davros by Loosejerk	Jan 2nd, 2009 10:54:47 PM
high five
One last call for Henry Ian Cusick as the Eleventh Doctor by SpyGuy	Jan 2nd, 2009 11:05:46 PM
"I'm gonna reverse the polarity of the neutron flow, brotha!"
AMERICAN NERDS DEMAND AMERICAN SCIFI NICHE ACTOR by reflecto	Jan 2nd, 2009 11:06:12 PM
GIVE ME A FUCKING BREAK, JAMES CALLIS? JAMES MARSTERS? FUCK OFF PEOPLE.
Danny John-Jules by BurnHollywood	Jan 2nd, 2009 11:29:35 PM
Holy shit...can you imagine how cool The Cat from Red Dwarf would be? Shit, the wardrobe alone would make it worth tuning in. Nothing against Mr. Ejiofor, but he's kind of a somber guy, at least in every movie I've seen him in. I wonder if WHO is entering another "serious" phase...man, those were deadly last time around. They need to tread cautiously.
Who the FUCK is Dr. Who? by Pissed Off And Bitter	Jan 2nd, 2009 11:44:11 PM
I've heard about it since I was a kid but never saw anything about it on tv. I guess it's not popular enough to put on network television here in America. Shit, all the other crap we get does, however....
That pretty much... by Capt. Murphy	Jan 2nd, 2009 11:51:42 PM
kicks ass. I hope this is true.
Ejiofor is GREAT, but. . . by ides	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:22:59 AM
As much as I love Who, it would be a demotion from his movie career, which is red hot - he'll be up for Oscars, soon. Can't wait for Moffat to take over, though. Tennant picked an awful time to leave. This show varies more in quality from writer to writer than any I can think of, short of an anthology series. The highs are as high as ANYTHING on television, but the lows are very amateurish, rescued often only by the actors. I hope they choose well.
Dear God I Hope Not by The Funketeer	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:24:30 AM
Because then I'd have to start watching and I hate Dr. Who.
Stephen Fry by Bumpasses Dawg	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:25:36 AM
Would be perfect. So it of course won't be him. What about David Thewlis? Would love to see Rowan Atkinson doing it straightish... he was great in the comic version. Or Jonathan Pryce for that matter. What happened to Moffat saying he wanted an older, odd Doctor? Is 40 supposed to be old???
David Warner by AD_Skinner	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:51:07 AM
The Doctor needs to be a crotchety old guy again. And get his fucking face in the title sequence again moffatt. And change the fucking tarids to look less like shit.
PO'ed and Bitter... by TheGhostWhoLurks	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:23:42 AM
Apparently you've never watched PBS. Doctor Who was practically a staple of the Public Broadcasting System from 1978 to the early 90s. Either that, or you're so young that you simply missed out.
If Bob Hoskins was younger by Rumpel Tumskin	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:42:39 AM
nuff said
ABOUT THE TARDIS by Ray Gamma	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:56:47 AM
Is it just me, or does the current version of the Tardis interior seem really cold and uncomfortable? I imagine it being really chilly with no comfortable place to sit. Tom Baker had a much more comfy looking Tardis, where I imagine he spent many a night kicking back with a spliff and gently making love to Romana.
Jason Statham by cineninja	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:17:31 AM
why not? Vinnie Jones could play the Master
Ray Gamma... by MediaGold	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:32:04 AM
Hmmm that SNL skit about the creepy lovers in the hot tub comes to mind. If anything they sat around and discussed the secrets of the universe whilst the Doctor played with his yo-yo. He never seemed too interested in making that TARDIS a rockin'. And yes, the TARDIS interior sucks. It's like a nasty old coral reef that's been drained. Bring back that futuristic spaceship feel and so what if it looks dated in 20 years.
Mr. T for role of The Doctor. by Dingbatty	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:00:49 AM

James Callis would be an OUTSTANDING choice by King Sweyn Forkbeard	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:19:44 AM
Guy's young enough to carry off the action parts, and anyone who's watched anything of Galactica would know he's got the acting chops too. Plus he's a Brit and he's unemployed.
Jason Issacs by VoldemortWearsPrada	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:22:47 AM
Just putting one last vote (given that I accept that Daniel Craig's going to be Bond for at least a couple more films). Although I'm quite taken with the idea of David Walliams.
If they go female then Jessica Hynes by mooli_mooli	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:55:21 AM
Gets my vote.
If he can bring the same intensity he brought to Serenity... by alucardvsdracula	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:58:46 AM
Then Chiwetel Ejiofor would be an amazing Doctor. Can't think of a better choice right now. Yep a Fine, Fine choice if you ask me. But let's just see shall we, 'cause you never know.
It's Matt Smith by Nice Mr Death	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:09:12 AM

David Warner, huh? by gotilk	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:36:16 AM
Interesting idea. MCP!!! The LOBE!(oh helllooooo Lobey yes hellooooo lobey! I guess you had to be there) Jack the Ripper!! The Doctor seems like the next best thing for him. He's done it all. But could he reign in the sinister? Can he be playful and curious? Hmm. It'd be a fine experiment. The man IS getting up there in years though.
David Warner as the Lobe. by gotilk	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:40:49 AM
Maybe proof that he's perfect? http://tinyurl.com/6uyb3t
Will It Be Movie Actor Chiwetel Ejiofor?? by evil twin	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:57:33 AM
No it will not be. Oh and why do some people insist on capitalising every word in a headline? It looks terrible.
why would Ejiofor do it, when... by DC Films	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:02:47 AM
he's got a great movie career? Be amazing if he did though (his turn in Dirty Pretty Things was up there with some of DeNiro's best, understated work). If the show weren't chasing teeny viewers then Michael Gambon would have been great - he's got the perfect mischievous, other worldly quality. If it's a woman, then Helena Bonham-Cater gets my vote (between Merchent-Ivory and Fightclub she has great range and eccentricity. Does anyone ever bother reading these talkbacks after the first dozen?
Yeah David Warner would own the role by photoboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:02:52 AM
He even has the right initials for the part!! I just hope it's not a black actor, because Doctor Who is supposed to be adventures in time and space and I just know the politically correct BBC will not be able to resist doing stories about racism with all the subtlety and appropriateness of a large penis shaped hammer. Doctor Who should remain a light hearted sci-fi adventure show, not an adult drama trying to be all clever and progressive by dealing with "issues". They did it right with Martha Jones, but who knows if Moffat will be able to resist with an ego the size of his?
David Warner! He could do the cranky old Time Lord by HarryBlackPotter	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:50:45 AM
ala William Hartnell. But it won't be. I'd love Richard E Grant personally, but I think it's either Paterson Jospeh or CheiweBakka Ejiofor.
"Pick vaguely British actors we saw on crap American shows!" by reflecto	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:59:19 AM
Brilliant logic, that.
lex romero by kwisatzhaderach	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:06:45 AM
In 'The Five Doctors' the High Council of Gallifrey offered The Master a new set of regenerations, a complete new life cycle in exchange for rescuing The Doctor. So when it comes time for the 13th Doctor to regenerate it won't be a problem at all. And yes, this may well be the geekiest thing i've ever posted on here.
thecomedian is right by Lloytron	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:33:42 AM
Patterson was already in one of the previous episodes of Doctor Who (The one with the Big Brother house and The Weakest Link IIRC) and he wasn't particularly good, and I was glad he got exterminated!
To: Clavius--The Pronunciation Of Ejiofor (Edge-Jew-For) by Media Messiah	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:09:25 AM
The guy is a genius actor, and an incredibly old soul. You should see Serenity, that is his statement movie...he stole the film!!! He should be a James Bond or Batman villain also. If I was Ejiofer, and I was going to accept this role, they would have to at least up the budget for Dr. Who to be on par with American series television. With Red One Digital Cameras, and a serious infusion of cash, about 1.5 million per episode, they could finally make Dr. Who, not only a hit elsewhere in the world, but a hit in America for once.
Tori Amos as the next Doctor... by tangcameo	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:15:34 AM
...and me as the next Companion. Just for my own selfish naughty Tori-loving reasons.
Mr. Zeddemore by Media Messiah	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:19:48 AM
I love the British...and I love the British look, yes, but I see all these American shows that, thanks to their budgets, look like movies now--and some are shows that don't even deserve to look that good, as their scripts and direction are not on par with the look, often times. I would just like to see what Dr. Who could be like with a higher budget. I think ultimately the "quirk factor" is in its stories and delivery...and that will not change.
They should pick an Indian actor by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:27:39 AM
After all, most of the doctors in England are of Indian decent anyway. :)
kwisatzhaderach is right... by FexFX	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:28:25 AM
kwisatzhaderach you are correct, and you have a great user name! I have personally JUST finished watching every episode of Doctor Who in existence, including the 66 lost serials that painstakingly (and painful to watch) reconstructioned using production stills and audio cassettes made by uber fans in the 60's. This is a vailid way to get around the 13 regenerations. Personally however I think this has ALREADY happened. When we "first meet" the Doctor in 2005 he is freshly regenerated (as evidenced by the way in which he admires his new face in the mirror) so that means he recently died...probably during the destruction of Gaillfrey in the "time wars"...an event or saga that I had HOPED would be ellaborated on during the season finale of the same name, but alas no...My personal Theory is that at some point during the Time Wars, either the High Council granted him a renewal, or, being the former President of Gallifrey(as seen in The Deadly Assassin WAY back in season 14 with Tom Baker), and having already held the Key of Rassilon he was able to access the Eye of Harmony (which according to the 8th Doctor movie is now onboard the Tardis) and grant himself a renewal. Of course it is also possible that when he received the Key he was also given a renewal without realizing it. In any event, I hypothesize that at the VERY LEAST this could be his 6th regeneration of a new set (assuming the counter was reset back in season 14), and at the VERY BEST this could be his 3rd (4th?? Does the regeneration in the season finale count or not? discuss) regeneration having been freshly reset near the end of the Time War. Thus kwisatzhaderach You may now feel like less of a geek as I believe my inimical knowledge of all things Doctor Who has indeed made your post look startlingly less geeky.
I can imagine the first scene if it's a black actor by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:28:56 AM
Doctor touches face, looks at hands and then peeks down his trousers DOCTOR: "Well, that's a nice surprise!"
Just over four hours until.... by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:31:21 AM
Either this TalkBack or a new one explodes with people shouting "Noooooooooo!" because you know 70% of us won't be happy with whoever gets chosen.
Doctor "Who dat" by Stalkeye	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:35:58 AM
This would be great if Ejiofor got the part as he is a great actor who can obviously trancend the race debacle.I can give two shits about the whinners who complian of a black man taking "white" roles as it's not an issue of affirmative action casting, but quality.No one objected to Jake Gylenhaal as the Prince of Persia, riight? However I second the idea of Jason Issacs for Dr. Who as well.It was breifly suggested that Colin Salmon would be cast as the new James Bond before Danny Craig, and yes I supported that idea as well.Salmon has great potentual as an actor and I hope he gets a breakthough part that would put him into the spotlight.
Why don't they just reboot the whole show? by I am_NOTREAL	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:37:35 AM
? Go back to the old-man first doctor, even recreate swinging London in 1963? Why has no one thought of this? It's not like continuity has ever really been Who's strong point anyway.
Richard E Grant please! by DanboJohnJ	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:38:06 AM
He was my first choice way back to play the Joker,but i also think he would make a Fantastic Dr Who,perfect infact.He's a very underused actoe imo.
Richard E Grant please! by DanboJohnJ	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:38:11 AM
He was my first choice way back to play the Joker,but i also think he would make a Fantastic Dr Who,perfect infact.He's a very underused actor imo.
Matt Smith by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:41:26 AM
I say again.
Its looking like Matt Smith by FatherTed	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:59:57 AM
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm174 1002/ also favourites with bookmakers in Eng;and with odds of 1.5/1
People aren't ready for that by MilesGloriosus	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:24:53 AM
Don't everyone yell at me, but people aren't ready for a black Doctor any more than they're ready for a female Doctor (though Joanna Lumley was terrific in "The Curse of Fatal Death").
If the Doctor is black by DrLektor	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:35:54 AM
Storywise it'll put him at a disadvantage. In all his previous incarnations he's been white (simply because it was unheard of to cast a black guy in a leading TV role during the early 60's and follow up stories have stubbornly stuck to the rule) and so historically he's easy to fit in. Future stories are fine, we all dream of a time when the colour of your skin isn't remarked on as being "different" but the moment the TARDIS materialises in the past, he's going to lose a little something, no longer can he simply waltz into an adventure and claim he's a "scientist, a doctor, a magician" from looking at our own history the Doctor will have to behave in a more subdued manner or just be relegated to the role of a servant. Personally I think it's an outstanding move that takes Doctor Who away from the "see? everyone is gay so it's okay whahey" farce into a more racially conscious drama. They touched on it briefly with Martha being laughed at and dismissed for being a black doctor, if they go the route we're all thinking they will, Moffat can open a few people's eyes to how idiotic we used to be (and dare I say it, a few people are still stuck in that belief). Onwards and upwards, bring on #11.
My brother is a life long dr who fan... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:50:20 AM
He emailed a couple of times. Their. As for a woman dr. His suggestion is TILDA SWINTON.
EvilWizardGlick, I wasn't watching then by I am_NOTREAL	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:55:47 AM
I outgrew this show around the time Colin Baker's Doctor made it to PBS. I was just wondering from the standpoint of sidestepping the whole "how many reincarnations does he have left" business. Just restart the clock at one and go for it.
Swinton is a great actress... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:58:33 AM
I have just thought of someone else and we havent seen her in a while. Jane Horrocks. but I think Swinton would make a great dr. She has already done a major film. lion witch and the wardrobe. Swinton has this androgenous thing going on. Which would make her perfect for the role.
Tom Wilkinson by RaveX	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:10:36 AM
yes please
Dr. Who has to be a white male or any time travel story... by Leafar the Lost	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:12:46 AM
...he ends up in has to be changed around. A black man would be seen as a servant/slave. A white woman who have to be accompanied by a male. Of course, if he went to ancient Egypt it may be a different story. Anyway, lets keep him white, male, and British.
Melvin_Pelvis by offput	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:13:41 AM
they also didn't show any black vulcans until tuvok. that's really a meaningless argument. also, who gives a damn?
in that case... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:52:49 AM
I was going to suggest Dominic Monaghan or Mackenzie Crook. but one name that did pop into my head there was Martin Stephenson. Tim from the office.
Leafar the Lost...I agree... by CloneRangerUK	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:53:42 AM
..if they change gender or race this far down the line, I am out. The speculation on making the doctor a woman or black everytime there is a regeneration p*sses me off - if that was the original intention, they should have done it earlier on, like at the 3rd or 4th regeneration - it would just jar too much now we are at the other end of the regenerations.
dont like it by aestheticity	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:55:38 AM
dr who is white and british. That's the end of it. Doesn't even make any sense in terms of the stories it tells if the Dr is black. How's he going to get anywhere prior to the late 19th century at the earliest. Soon as he steps out the tardis a gang of white men would chain him up and sell him or lynch him for wearing smart clothes, let alone when they see a white female companion. It's a stupid politically correct idea.
A thought on this casting madness by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:08:53 AM
A good choice WOULD HAVE been Hugh Laurie. This role needs an actor who can do several kinds of comedy and also be dramatic in a believable way. Cris was a touch too grim, David a tuch too slapstick. Best alternate...Bill Nighy
Now you bints are making want a Black Doctor.... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:11:08 AM
Uh...he'll get lynched. This is a clever cunning fellow whose outsmarted Daleks, Cybermen, Sonatorans, The Master, The Rani, The Last of the Jagoroth and countless others. I think he can handle himself around a bunch of racist nimrods in any century. The Doctor is always landing The Tardis in situations where as soon as he walks out it's doors there's a gun being pointed at him. That's the danger of leaving the Tardis that goes all the way back to An Unearthly Child. The Doctor is perfectly capable of working his way around the race thing in any century. This is the kind of short sighted geekism I keep talking about.
It's Saturday by Jodet	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:18:23 AM
Who is it?
Richard E. Grant, Mark Heap, Matt Berry or Patrick Stewart... by workshed	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:23:40 AM
Ken Stott would be the best but he doesn't stand a chance. I, personally, would like to see an older Doctor in the Hartnell/Pertwee mould.
I dont know if he is still alive... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:35:37 AM
but I am young enough to remember a show called Erasmus Microman. I refer to the utterly barkingly mad genius that is ken campbell. He died in august of this year.
Jodet by ElPaw	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:38:07 AM
We will know in an hour (5.35 GMT)
No Way. by Magnum Opus	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:48:29 AM
Ejiofor is waaaay to good for a B television series. No way in hell would he take this role. That's like saying Don Cheadle will be the new robot in a Small Wonder re-boot.
and the dr is ............. by mikeyone	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:50:29 AM
matt smith. well done sir.
Ken Campbell by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:52:34 AM
He founded the Sci-fi theatre in liverpool, was artisic director of Everyman theatre and was professor of ventriliquism From 1999-2008. untill his death. I have heard rumours that Stewart was going to be involved in Dr. who as the meddling monk. about Ken campbell....Auditioned in 1987 for the role of the Seventh Doctor in Doctor Who, but was turned down, apparently due to his audition performance being considered too disturbing for television. And we got slyvester McCoy!?!
I have a bad feeling it will be... by Brody77	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:53:12 AM
Paterson "I can't act" Joseph, as they seem to have a habit of re- casting folk who have previously been on the show (Colin Baker, Freema, Eve Myles..) I want Sean Pertwee for the doc, but it'll be someone pish. Oh, I was one of the many who sent the bbc article to Herc.. I'll get published on here one day!
Has to be white for time travel? by jccalhoun	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:56:05 AM
Yes, because the Doctor can only travel back to European or North American countries. (Yes of course because of budgetary reasons the likelyhood of doing a storyline is filmed in Africa or Asia isn't very high but to argue "OMG a black guy travelling back in time will get lynched!" is a very narrow view of history.)
We will know... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:00:19 AM
who it is in 35 mins. As it is nearly 5 in the uk/ireland.
The race arguments are stupid. by offput	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:02:00 AM
The Doctor is not white. He's a british character, not a white british character. And you don't need to go to pre-20th century england for every time travel story, and even if you did that wouldn't change anything. The american election this year taught us that when things get really fucked up even racists and bigots don't care who's saving the day. A black doctor would have the advantage of saving the world.
This is a really off the wall.... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:02:59 AM
candidate. Richard O brien. or it could be Anthony Stewart Head. Richard O brien. could be a bonkers dr who. or James Marsters. I have no idea.
As far as race changing goes in Regenerations... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:03:29 AM
They hinted that The Master was actually Ghengis Kahn in one of his previous incarnations in the TV movie when he was lying to the Chinese kid about everything horrible the Doctor had done in history when really he was talking about himself. Now there's a well RTD was too stupid to go to. There are 11 earlier versions of The Master we've never seen who could be great villains if they ever decide to bring the character back. Since he was such a maniac who supposedly burned through a few of them you could have him regenerate 3 times in one story kind of like Wylie Coyote to The Doctor's road runner.
the election last year, that is by offput	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:03:33 AM
damn arbitrary temporal delineations...
offput- by Regenhund	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:05:13 AM
"The american election this year taught us that when things get really fucked up even racists and bigots don't care who's saving the day." I'm going to assume that that statement was just poorly worded instead of incredibly insulting.
Dr. Kinky Boots? Really? I was hoping for David Beckham! by Snake Foreskin	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:06:02 AM
Or Sean Connery, George Lazenby, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, or Pierce Brosnan.
Don't matter if you're black or white by mulberry	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:08:52 AM
Posted this before, but my blood is up tonight: One thing that gets on my tits more than hopelessly unrealistic revisionist portrayals of racial har-mo-nee in historic settings is bolshy, white-man-as-victim pig-headed ignorance which seems to reckon that non-white history in the Britain began in the 1950s, that you can extrapolate current US/UK racism backwards in a straight line, or that being black meant you got treated much worse by those in authority than if you were Irish or Jewish or Catholic or a woman or simply poor or dressed funny. London was centre of the world's largest empire for centuries, a power based on naval and trading strength, with a good dose of slave trading mixed in. By the mid 18th Century, London had 700-800,000 people, of whom 20-40,000 were black. http://tinyurl.com/9kpphw http://tinyurl.com/9zo9t7 Population spiked again in mid-19th century when slavery was abolished in Britain, but still held in the US. You'd be a lot more likely to be abusive a white man with sticky-up hair in a 20th century lounge suit and raincoat than black person in period dress, particularly round the docks or slums. Don't base your knowledge of how ye olde time really were on "whitewashed" films from the 30s, 40s and 50s. They knew a damn sight less about it than we do now, and were in no ways inclined to make an effort to represent what they could have found out. It'd be like someone from 2050 complaining that a film about Texans in the 80s didn't match the portrayal in "Dallas".
Black check... by Dazzler69	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:08:59 AM
now let's make him gay and all the demo's are covered! White people watch all sci-fi anyway.
Hmm...Narrated by Simon Pegg by 2LeggedFreak	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:11:04 AM
So Peggy is doing the narration for this reveal is he....could this be a typical Davies twist...and the new Doctor is....ME!!!
Its the Archnishop of Canterbury by 2LeggedFreak	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:12:06 AM
Bishops love Sci-fi !!!
Its not to late to get Dylan Moran...... by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:13:39 AM
Is it???????
He lied? by lostbat	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:17:51 AM
SIMON Pegg has ruled out playing the next Doctor Who – he just wants to watch it. The Hot Fuzz star, 37, who played the Editor in a 2005 episode, said: “I’m too much of a fan to actually play the Doctor. “I think my head would explode.”
Chiwetel Ejiofor THE BEST ACTOR FOR ANYTHING by g-ride9000	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:26:19 AM
that man can carry a show or movie or theatrical production in his sleep.
Considering that its Steven Moffat... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:26:44 AM
who is taking over. It would not be a huge leap to suggest Dexter Fletcher. After all He nad moffat worked together on press gang over twenty years ago. He did a ver very passable american accent. I actually thought he was american. he is an east end boy.
Either Way... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:28:53 AM
We all know in a few mins. but Chiwetel Elijfor is a good bet.
who is it? by sitchin	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:31:24 AM
Somebody post it here as soon as it's revealed, please and thanks
new doctor by LordMaker	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:34:06 AM
The new Doctor is............................ .............................. .............................. ............................Gi ve it a few minutes
John Hannah by Mahaloth	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:35:17 AM

Anyone in the UK by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:36:50 AM
Since the DWC starts 5:30, now, UK time, could someone in the UK be so kind as to let the american Doctor Who fans know who is the next Doctor and you opinion on the choice? Thank you.
Wtf>??? by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:37:42 AM

John Hannah? by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:38:26 AM
The guy from the Mummy movies?
WTF???? Mackenzie Crook?? by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:38:38 AM
:D
and can someone record TV burp for me?.. by MattsSwellHouse	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:38:54 AM
because i"m away at the moment. cheers
Seriously, it's Matt Smith by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:39:47 AM
No need to watch this to find out.
Holy shit its Jason Statham! by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:40:42 AM
Not really.
Mackenzie Crook would be genius by scratcher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:40:57 AM
That would be worth watching.
Steven Segal? didn't see that coming? by jccalhoun	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:43:16 AM
But I'm sure Vern did.
emeraldboy by RenoNevada2000	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:43:22 AM
O'Brian would be the absolutely most freaky Doctor in the show's history! I would love it, but I think he'd scare the kiddies too much!
Come on, Guys by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:44:07 AM
Quit fooling around. Who is it? spud mcspud, The Handsome 12th Doctor, one of you regulars let us know, thank you.
I was gonna ask for a Brit spy report.... by Bill Clay	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:44:11 AM
But knowing the smart arses around here, they'll claim that Jennifer Saunders was announced.
As soon as it's announced by Regenhund	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:45:22 AM
the fanboys will be tripping over their bits to be the first to announce it here. Patience, grasshopper.
Don't worry. Not announced yet by LordMaker	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:47:16 AM
At this time, in this second, the program is on. It has not been announced yet.
It is now 5: 47 PM.... by Darth Pants	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:47:59 AM
Brits? Anything? Anything? Please?
It's on now? by I am the most horrible	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:49:41 AM
Man, my math sucks. I'll never be a Timelord I guess. They won't announce it til near the end, especially if it's anything like a US show.
It's COLIN SALMON!! by XoanonTORN	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:50:18 AM
That's what I'd say if he were announced...ziing!
"The waiting..." by Bill Clay	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:50:21 AM
"...is the hardest part." - Tom Petty
They're looking at previous actors by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:50:55 AM
Have patience.
what time does the show go over? by NinjaChampion	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:50:57 AM
I'm guessing they will wait until the last few seconds to announce it.
most likely mat smith by LordMaker	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:51:26 AM
announced that he is 26 years old.
Ok, ok......... by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:51:42 AM
We american fans are waiting. It seems strange they would pick the new Who this early, but, I guess the new people in charge have to start early.
It's on now. by theyetiiswaiting	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:51:57 AM
The next doctor is Matt Smith. Should have gone with James Callis. Devo.
Paterson Joseph is now walking into BBC studio's by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:52:14 AM
At least that is what the radio said.
Regenhund by offput	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:53:44 AM
I don't know what's ambiguous about that statement. There were many people who said in interviews for the media that they didn't like black people and other equally racist and bigotted statements but were still going to vote for Obama because they wanted things to get better. I'm not saying that everyone that voted Obama was racist and bigotted. And I am most definitely saying that people that acted according to society norms of the past were racist and bigotted, because I don't believe in that "it's in the past so we should forgive their sins" bullshit. I don't think that's insulting, it's simply the truth.
They're also dropping huge hints. by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:53:50 AM
nt
the wrestler ripped off I Like to Hurt People by jccalhoun	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:54:25 AM
I Like to Hurt People meets Grunt! The Wrestling Movie
announced that he is 26 years old? by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:54:58 AM
Well, that lets out a lot of actors I want. Still waiting.
Is it Bowie? by sitchin	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:55:50 AM
He's been 26 for a long time
There are saying the actor is 26 years old. by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:56:39 AM
on the radio.
There are saying the actor is 26 years old. by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:56:40 AM
on the radio.
Just checked my drivers license by I am the most horrible	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:56:41 AM
I'm out dammit.
EvilWizardGlick by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:58:27 AM
Exactly! And since When we're introduced to the Delgado Master he's already on his 12 regeneration they've set up the previous versions as this sort of enigma. The current Doctor fighting the pre-Delgado Masters would be brilliant. It IS a show about time travel after all.
Matt Smith Confirmed by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:59:08 AM
Let the Fanboys rage......
New Doctor... by theyetiiswaiting	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:59:21 AM
...is Matt Smith: http://tinyurl.com/82sjvo
It IS........ by welshguy	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:59:23 AM
...MATT SMITH.Let fly the comments
And the New Doctor is... by ManEatingFish	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:59:27 AM
Matt Smith
Matt Smith seems sorta dull by scratcher	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:00:46 PM
I've never seen him in action, but a younger doctor is less interesting. The best have been more character actor types.
Who the fuck by montimer	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:00:46 PM
is matt smith?
Looks like a boxer, not a doctor by vadakinX	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:04 PM

But he is not Black!!???? by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:22 PM
WTF???
Confirmed: It's Matt Smith by reaper28	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:30 PM
First reaction: meh!
photos by scratcher	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:37 PM
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm10 06408960/nm1741002
Never heard of the guy by bravogolfhotel	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:43 PM
...but he'd have to be an idiot not to know that the part could swallow his career whole, so I'm sure he'll give it all he's got.
It's 2 o'clock eastern standern time......... by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:51 PM
Do you Brits know who our next Doctor is?
Oh, Matt Smith by sitchin	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:01:51 PM
Never heard of him.
David Tennant/Matt Smith = Tom Baker/Peter Davison? by SpyGuy	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:02:13 PM
Good luck, Matt. And thank Rassilon you weren't Paterson Joseph!
Looks like Frankenstein's monster by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:02:18 PM
more like. I bet all of England just went WTF? in unison. Whatever. Not the end of the world. We'll see what happens next. At least we didn't get James Nesbitt. Or David Walliams.
So the New Doctor... by Ckuouka	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:02:18 PM
is Franknstein?
this is the choice that's going to 'shake things up'? by oisin5199	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:03:01 PM
Really? God, I was hoping at least for the Jekyll guy, hell, even Paterson Joseph, but some unknown kid? Disappointing. With Tennant, he's got some mighty big shoes to fill.
Who the hell is this new guy? by Bill Clay	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:03:06 PM
Us Yanks don't have a clue about Matt Smith.
AdmiralNeck by Ckuouka	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:03:15 PM
I didn't even see your comment when I wrote that. Damn. That man is freakish.
imdb link inside by cyrent	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:03:26 PM
http://tinyurl.com/8lphy8
"Curious Onlooker" by scratcher	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:03:27 PM
Great character name.
Sorry.......... by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:04:13 PM
1 o'clock eastern standard time.
Matt Smith by Ray Gamma	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:04:32 PM
Matt Smith will suit Moffat's "serious sci-fi" re-invention of Doctor Who perfectly!
You Mean, 'Fuck, Matt Smith is The Who!' by MattsSwellHouse	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:04:43 PM
and congratulations for british national treasure dr.who (above described as drivel by our american cousins) establishing 2009 talkback record.
Seriously by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:05:19 PM
Walliams and Nesbitt would have killed the show dead. Anyway, I was pissed when Tennant got cast and now I love him, so I am going to be optimistic. These showrunners know what they're doing. When they're not making shitty spin-offs with the worst actors in Britain, that is.
But he is not Black!!???? by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:05:43 PM
The BBC pussied out.
Brilliant by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:06:03 PM
Pick an actor with NO ACTING EXPERIENCE. What a true shame. Guess the Moff got saddled with the BeeBs choice.
Matt who? by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:06:09 PM
Who he?
Ckuouka by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:06:42 PM
We hit send at the same time. Great minds, dude.
Nesbitt rocked by I am the most horrible	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:07:30 PM
Don't understand the hate. Is it some kinda hate on Irish dudes? I loved him in (the first couple) episodes of Jekyll
They really should have cast someone older... by Darth Pants	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:07:39 PM
Too many pretty boys in a row. Say what you will about JNT, but al least he cast the role with a modicum of diversity. I really would have loved to see Paterson Joseph in the role. The BBC is not a commercial enterprise, so they really can't use the ratings excuse, can they?
how would Nesbitt have 'killed the show dead by oisin5199	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:08:11 PM

New doctor .. no eye brows :( by kingoflight	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:08:32 PM
i hope he's good but i really only catch a few episodes of doctor who anyway. So grow some eye brows next time i see you boy !
Did Stan Lee write this? by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:08:34 PM
Activate whiney teenaged angst!
archaementon by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:08:41 PM
Do some research before you post. Theres a good boy.
damn, it. not done yet. by oisin5199	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:08:54 PM
What's wrong with Nesbitt. He was fucking amazing in Jekyll.
It's MATT SMITH!!! by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:09:44 PM
WOW!!! An actor I know absolutely FUCKING NOTHING ABOUT?!?!? And he's by far the ugliest Doctor so far. Looks like someone put out a fire on his face with a shovel. That said... (1) Looks eccentric enough to hark back to the Tom Baker era. H4e's got that mad gothic hair that Noel Fielding and Russell Brand have, and a very odd-shaped face. He's quiet, intense, yet looks mischievous too. Young enough to last a few years in the role, and I'm sure he'll give it his all. But knowing how awesome some of Moffat's casting decisions have been in the past... Hey, let's give this guy a go. Three years ago I didn't know who the hell David Tennant was either, and look what happened. I'm VERY interested in how Matt Smith's Doctor will turn out...
First impression by LordMaker	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:09:49 PM
You know, I think he'll be quite good.
So they went younger and prettier.... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:10:08 PM
Kinda dull and predictable but I can live with it. I can see why they'd want to keep the demos they've been attracting with Tennant. I just hope they don't repeat this pattern yet again in 3-5 years. If RTD were still in charge I would hate this choice because we know where he would take it. But it's Moffatt so I'm okay with this. Thank God it's not Patterson Joseph.
Donkey by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:10:38 PM
I did research him. STAGE acting is a world apart from TV acting. The guy quite frankly doesn't have the gravitas,real or feigned to pull this role off.
oisin5199 by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:10:54 PM
Well, he was very "large" in that. There was a lot of acting in it, and the lack of subtlety didn't bode well for playing the Doctor, but Nesbitt was really good in Bloody Sunday. Really really good. It's when he does funny that I wince a lot.
As well all know now and kudos to the talkbacker.. by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:11:01 PM
who was spot on. Matt smith is the eleventh. dr.
Hold on WTF wheres the new episode ? by kingoflight	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:11:11 PM
why announce the the new doctor then say he'll be back in a YEAR ! ! ! ! fuck i got bent over and done like a kipper !
so we're getting an even younger skinny white guy by jccalhoun	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:11:51 PM
wow. that really is a shock... Here's the BBC's article on him http://is.gd/euma
jccalhoun, lex romero, kwisatzhaderach & FexFX by codymr	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:12:06 PM
Thx for the info on regeneration... I always waned to know more details. I had no idea it was so complex!
Ok, so, we now know who the new who is? by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:12:12 PM
Matt Smith? Time to google.
Hmmmmm by Lloytron	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:12:45 PM
I've not seen this guy in anything so I have no idea if he is going to be any good or not, so best to reserve judgement. That said, seeing that it was someone I had never heard of was quite an anticlimax.
bbc link by lostbat	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:13:08 PM
Offical BBC statement & Pic with Tardis. Looking dark.... http://tinyurl.com/9dt4af
Doctor Meh by Stuart-Renton	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:13:53 PM
My first response: meh. Another Tennant clone. But I'm sure he'll be quite brilliant.
Matt Smith = non-famous Jason Flemyng by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:14:00 PM
Sorry, I know I can't stop going on about his face, but that's one UGLY motherfucker. The goth-loving Russell Brand Twilight-reading fath goth brigade may LOVE him, but the rest of us are thinking -- If you're casting an UGLY Doctor, why not an established ugly? Dexter Fletcher? Jason Flemyng? I know Flemyng fucked up as Quatermass, but he's generally okay. Ah, let's give the Matt SMith boy a chance, guys. With a face like that he needs all the breaks he can get...
Knowing Brits from single shows... by jccalhoun	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:14:28 PM
It might have something to do with the fact that a lot of these people are barely known in the USA and many have at most only been seen in one or two shows.
from across the pond! by Jonny_boba	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:15:32 PM
for all you yanks the new doctor has been announced as Matt Smith!
He looks like by Street	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:15:52 PM
an ugly frankenstein's monster. when they started mentioning 26 year olds a twigged and got on the old wiki and shock horror it was him. I wanted Kris Marshall, he would have ruled.
Jekyll and Graham Norton Show by I am the most horrible	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:16:06 PM
yeah.
Chewy by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:16:47 PM
Lloytron, I know what you mean, even though Matt Smith was a name bandied about a while back. Still, I had a whole day of imagining a series of Who with Chiwetel Ejiofor as the Doctor. Has everyone here seen Redbelt yet? The man is pure gravitas. Okay, Total Pure Wipeout or whatever the hell it is is even stupider than Hole in the Wall. Oh BBC, you schizophrenic public service broadcaster.
Have faith in the Gran Moff Steven by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:16:55 PM
Matt Smith will be brilliant. But (as Smashing will NEVER let me forget) I'd have liked to have seen Lenny Henry's Doctor...
Matt Smith. Does he have the acting chops? by HarryBlackPotter	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:17:34 PM
I was shocked. Big time. I thought it would be Paterson Joseph. He's certainly not an actor who's been on my radar. I hope he can pull it off because he has HUGE shoes to fill. It could be a 1 season disaster or...he could be the best we've ever seen. WHO knows. Brave casting that's for sure. He looks weird enough though. But I'd love it if they dyed his hair GINGER!!! Then he'd be really, really weird and alien looking.
who is this dude? by Miguel De Barioz	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:17:36 PM
MAN oh man - why do they do this? I was the number one doctor who fan in the PLANET man - so why the fuck would you change doctor who from this guy who is cool to this guy who is not cool. We just read about this fool on AICN everyone in my town is around here and we can not believe it. Why did they not follow my instructions and cast Christian Bale, maybe aaron eckhart, or Daniel Craig. Although I did hear this man was in the Sally Lockhart Mysteries and was rather good for a Limey.
Matt Smith stands next to Tardis by oisin5199	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:18:04 PM
makes him seem more doctory. http://news.bbc.co.uk /1/hi/7808697. stm
Who is he? by banville	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:18:32 PM
Who is Matt Smith, has anyone out there seen him anything? Was hoping for someone sexy. Dr Who The Unhandsome Years have just begun. Bah.
The Doctor is Benjamin Button! by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:18:57 PM
He started off as an old man and, with only exception that i can think of, has been getting progressively younger with each regeneration! He'll be a ten year old in his last regeneration! Now to take a look at this Matt Smith guy...
Fucking hell, he looks about 12 years old by Steve Rogers	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:18:59 PM
This "younging down" of the Doctor may have just passed the point of absurdity. Yerrrrgh.
AdmiralNeck - Wipeout by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:19:38 PM
I know Richard Hammond gotta EAT (even though he's one trick less than a one-trick pony) but this shit is just insulting. Feels like the Beeb just reached into my frontal lobe and sucker-punched my taste and decency area into unconsciousness >:p
Dr Emo by mulberry	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:20:04 PM
As long as it doesn't turn into teen-angsty Smallville nonsense, it might be cool. He has a freaky, funky, deep face. And seems like a charming mugglefugger.
So, is this Matt Smith from........... by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:20:44 PM
"Party Animals" (Danny Foster)?
Matt Smith by carefulsilly	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:21:39 PM
Well I for one am rather excited about it all! RAH! Imagine the BBC managing to keep THAT a secret! Even though he did get a mention on here quite a few times this afternoon, have we got a BEEB sneak on here?????? Steven x
Party Animals by carefulsilly	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:22:21 PM
It sure is!
Well if he gave the best audition ... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:23:45 PM
...and was truly the most Doctor-like then they made the right choice. The picture of him in front of the Tardis is cool though I don't think that's gonna be his costume. It's too close to Eccleston unless their going for 20 something Hipster Doctor.
clarkson would make a funny doctor. by kingoflight	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:25:05 PM
I've installed a new dodge viper engine in the tardis so it goes that much faster. fuck doctor who anyway, TOTTAL WIPEOUT/ takashi castle rip off is so much more fun.
hair by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:25:08 PM
grand moff mentioned his hair several times, please don't tell me that they cast him based on how they can manipulate i.e style like tennant his hair? Seems like they didn't have the balls to get anyone out of left field - he'll last one season.
Oh.................... by axcel1	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:25:13 PM
Ok
spud mcspud by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:25:49 PM
I'm ashamed to admit I laughed like an idiot at the guy who took 15 minutes to finish, and this girl who keeps singing and talking about big fat balls is some kind of hero.
Spud I just googled a picture of Lenny Henry.... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:27:43 PM
Ah, what could have been http://barryfitzgerald.files.w ordpress.com/2008/07/lenny_hen ry_1.jpg
I think the actor should be old enough by Steve Rogers	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:27:47 PM
that they could actually BE a doctor! (and not a trainee one). We'll have to give the Moff the benefit of the doubt for now, but my first reaction is not a good one. Tennant was in his early/mid 30's when he got the part; that's as young as they should go, IMO.
Quality Television by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:27:51 PM
You Yanks don't know what you're missing.
Matt Smith by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:30:37 PM
His face reminds me of that weird neanderthal playing a sparkly vampire in The Twilight. Is this what the girls like now? But he could be good. I'm not going to be bitching about this guy on no information. He could be the best Doctor ever and make us all eat our words and/or a bag of dicks. Wipeout rules!
Davison was 29 when he took on the role by sambrook	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:31:26 PM
and he was one of the best. And I think Moffat is a strong enough writer to make a point about the torment of being a 900 year old authoritive demigod trapped inside the body of someone who looks like they might still get ID'd for alcohol. But he has an odd, quirky look, he's not an obvious pretty boy - if he can act and has a decent costume who knows?
I get that, Zeddemore... by Steve Rogers	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:31:32 PM
I'm not one of those Bill Nighy supporters who wants a really old Doctor - I know there are a lot of action scenes to get through. I just don't think the Doctor should look like he's eagerly awaiting his first shave.
The State of Who by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:32:08 PM
I am very disappointed in this choice. Moff's writing is so beyond this kids range that it's kinda sad for him. Having said that I will watch this trainwreck. I watched them cast a Scottish Yoda and with Ace he made Who fun again. Sadly I also saw them cast a former Who villain and he burned out my color controls.... But seriously this is a huge gamble. I may pay or fail. We shall see.
About this picture by question83	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:32:36 PM
He looks like an emo kid with cancer. Well i have no expectations, have to watch some stuff with the guy. I'll bet that Harknes will try to rape him or something :D
He is only signed for one series correct? by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:32:59 PM
Then the next actor to be cast will be black.
He is only signed for one series correct? by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:32:59 PM
Then the next actor to be cast will be black.
My first reaction was a WTF moment!! by football	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:33:10 PM
When that skinny, odd-looking dweeb came on screen I almost did a double-take. No, tell me you're NOT the new Doctor? Oh, fucking jeezus titty christ he IS the new Doctor!! After all that build-up and the flashbacks to previous Doctors they then go and blow a huge raspberry in the faces of all Doctor Who fans worldwide. So if I've got this right, the new Doctor is Quasimodo Jnr dressed as a Goth? I just hope this Matt Smith is a good actor!!
It's another white guy. Matt Smith. by mr.brownstone	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:34:58 PM
Yay?
MY HAT IN THE RING by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:35:17 PM
For many years White men have played..ethnic roles in movies.They played indians, put on black face,played chinese men, hell even now with Goku ( iknow supposed to be an alien..but was made in japan) is white. Prince of Persia is white..and nobody says a thing,But the minute a Non-white actor might play a white role the klan pokes their head out of there ass. point is people are people and sometimes change is good
Juat watched this clip by TheTaf	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:35:28 PM
and I can kinda see him as the DOC. http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v= QyEU1Qwlg3A
So they picked a "Twilight" emo kid... by Bill Clay	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:36:21 PM
...for the new Doctor. At least the teenage girls will be happy.
AdmiralNeck - WIPEOUT RULES! by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:36:55 PM
Like pizza and beer on a Saturday night, you know it's awful for you but it's sooooooo GOOD! Yep, loving this crap ;D
Doctor Twilight by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:39:37 PM
"I know what you are. I've seen you go inside that blue phone booth and not come out for days. You're pasty and British. You always use that little lite-brite tired gauge thing on the vending machines in the cafeteria at lunch. In history class you always know more than the teachers. You're always grabbing my hand and making me run down the hallways with you. You keep offering me jelly babies." "Say it." "Timelord."
Really Zeddemore by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:39:44 PM
IT'S EASIER for you to say that then admit there is still a divide in hollywood or any media place by that matter
Bright Side by Mr Lucas	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:42:03 PM
At least we don't know if he's good or bad. Unlike some of the 'actors' mentioned above. Lenny Henry (slightly funny 30 years ago - PITA ever since , along with his talentless wife), Kris Marshall - thanks for the laugh! As for all the film actors mentioned - well the BBC doesn't have enough money to pay them for a start. For another, most of them are too far up their own arses to take the part. Personally I would've liked someone older but then maybe that's because I'm 38.
facepalm.jpg by Kurutteru Yatsu	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:42:13 PM
I'm 31. The Doctor should _not_ be younger than me. Moffatt better have some fanfuckingtastic scripts on hand for this to not turn this into 90Who10.
Its Doctor......Who???? by Gabba-UK	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:42:57 PM
All I'm saying is that someone at the BBC must have made a fucking fortune when they went down to Ladbrooks and put 20 quid on him being the new Who... Still, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt till I see him in it.
Boring Choice by Playhouse	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:43:20 PM
Should've went older. Instead we're getting three relatively young guys in a row with a generally similar look. (Granted, Smith and Tennant are more similar than Eccleston.) One thing I used to like about Doctor was that the regenerations were distinctly different from the previous version. Hartnell to Troughton to Pertwee to Baker to Davison to C. Baker to McCoy to McGann. Hell, even to Eccleston. There was a distinct difference in look and certainly personality between all of these men. I liked Tennant in the role and his personality was different than Eccleston but I couldn't help but feel too much of a familiarity with the change. And now Smith feels like much of the same. You get the feeling that the producers were surprised by Eccleston leaving (despite their assertions to the contrary) so they cast Tennant to carry out the plan they envisioned by bringing the Doctor back. And now with Tennant leaving, it feels like the same thing. Doctor regenerations in the past brought about shifts in direction of the whole show. My only hope is they do that this time or the regeneration doesn't mean much more than a change in actors.
GOOD ONE TALLBOY66 by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:43:48 PM

Dr 90210? by DanboJohnJ	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:45:17 PM
Why? first impression is that DrWho's gonna turn into a teenybop high school/buffy fest? The guy is too young,they were pushing it with Tennant but 26?plus he looks like he just butted an anvil.
Ah Fuck off! Matt Smith? A goddamn kid? by Brody77	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:45:33 PM
I take it Moff etc just watched Twilight then? Sorry, no, not watching. The guy comes across as a right wanker.
RE: zeeddemore by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:47:37 PM
How many times do you think a non white actor has been passed over to keep the status quo.your telling me they could not find one middle eastern looking actor..to play PoP.. and don't even tell me jake gyllenhall a good actor...or i'll get the NAACP to come to your house(just joking)
I need to lie down. by Smashing	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:51:09 PM
He is seriously hot, like I need him to take my temperature, all you people calling him ugly are mentaloids, this doctor is shagadelic.
hey scratcher by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:51:31 PM
what exactly is a "character actor"?
Fans turn on Moffatt in 5, 4 ,3, 2, 1... by Smashing	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:52:19 PM
At least wait until he writes an episode before decrying your so called saviour, it looks a little gauche otherwise.
knowledge1027 by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:52:48 PM
Oh, for fuck's sake. You'd rather they cast a black Doctor because he's black rather than that he's the best actor? Do you think a black person who is cast for their COLOUR more than for their TALENT is going to THANK you for that shit? Political correctness is condescending, goes for quota over story and narrative and is generally one of the worst, most insidious things to happen to the BBC. If you want to argue about white guys playing Othello, fine - in this day and age that's not cool any more. But I don't hear shit from guys like you when Eddie Murphy decides to play some old white dude in whatever fatsuit comedy he's doing this week. Bottom line - you want your agenda put ABOVE all consideration regarding story and narrative. As someone who DOES write drama, I put my story ABOVE ALL ELSE - including proportional representation, political correctness, agendas of all kinds, and any of this PC bullshit. Would you have liked to see half of the slaves in ROOTS played by white people - in order to even up the quota of whites in that series? FUCK NO! Firstly because it would have looked fucking ridiculous, and secondly because the story took place in a time and a place that necessitated black actors playing black roles. The role of Doctor Who is one of a Time Lord who can regenerate twelve times, for thirteen incarnation - and it appears 11 of the 13 have been white males. WHY THE FUCK SHOULD THAT CHANGE NOW? Setting aside your one-sided, PC-obsessed ideas on how to cast a story acording to some racial quota system ABOVE the requirements of the story's 46 year backstory, WHY should the character - who has been established to be white and male for over 900 years of his life - CHANGE NOW? Oh, that's right. Because you'll throw your toys out of your pram and cry "Racist!" if they don't. The STORY specifies a white male - or has done for 900+ years of this character's life so far - and it'd require a pretty fucking hefty reason for why all that shit should change now. It's a STORY - and it should place STORY ABOVE ALL ELSE! Jesus. How hard is it to understand this?!?!?
I agree on that one Zeddemore by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:53:10 PM
Plus i don't even watch the show so i do'nt really care..and trust even i think some char.should stay the way they are...like making superman black would be really bad
Here's a novel idea... by zacdilone	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:53:28 PM
...let's wait until we see him as the Doctor BEFORE we decide if he's the best thing ever or an abomination with legs.
11th Doctor announced-youngest ever by tubuku69	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:54:46 PM
http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho /s4/misc/news/index_new_doctor .shtml Matt Smith 26, theatre background, did (coincidentally) 2 mysteries with Billie Piper (Sally Lockhart mysteries) as her assistant...
If anyone with hair under 30 by gotilk	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:55:21 PM
makes you immediately think of Twilight, then your generation is sad, not theirs. I have to trust them on this until I see the guy work. They wouldn't hand this to an empty-headed snot while Moffat is in charge. A challenging choice, sure. But not a bad one.
Told you by Magnum Opus	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:56:08 PM
Ejiofor was waaaay overqualified for a cheesy sci-fi show like Who. Great move by them bringing his name up, though. Articles like this probably got a lot of hits by people who were incredulous of such a great actor doing a lower-tier TV show.
Smashing by spud mcspud	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:56:10 PM
You think he's HOT? We could have had Tom Chambers (if I were on that team, Tom would be all I'd wnat in a maaaaan, baby!) but we get THIS munter? It takes all sorts, Smashing. I think Moffat just made your Saturday nights a little more shagadelic though, yeeeeeeah!!!
give them a chance by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:56:17 PM
they haven't even written any scrpits yet. this Smith guy did annoy me in those Sally Lockhart films but they were shit anyway. only watched them to see Billie Piper. I'll wait and see, but I hope they dye his eyebrows because the hair is so light it looks like he doesn't have any!! a British James Woods!!!
So being in Sally Lockheart... by CloneRangerUK	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:57:17 PM
...makes him the assistants, assistant? Doesnt help him achieve that gravitas required for the Doctor really , does it?!
Can the wisdom of centuries be conveyed by a 26 yr old? by kevred	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:57:34 PM
None of us really know. I hope so. I'm also skeptical. But I suppose it comes down to what each person's priority with Who is. Me, I don't really care for the recent Who, which seems to be lots of special effects and a semi-incompetent Doctor always being shown up by regular people. Give me a Tom Baker or Jon Pertwee--those guys could really nail the humor, the drama, but could also go somewhere that the recent actors absolutely cannot--to a place where you almost feel unsettled by their alienness. It's subtle, and for all the merits of the new revival of Who, I haven't felt any subtlety or depth in the acting. Davison was only 29, but he got it. It seems as though the producers know where the money is. It's Who meets Harry Potter & Twilight, and heck, they can always change it later, right? I'm tired of a Who that tries to be cool. Hip, modern attire and trendy hairstyles. It's dumbing it down. I hope everyone who enjoys the current show keeps enjoying it, and I hope this new guy is great, but to me it just seems to keep getting thinner.
spud mcspud by knowledge1027	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:57:56 PM
Would you feel the same way if they changed oh let's just say blade to a white actor for example. would you still have that narrow-minded thought process then?
I'm happy with this by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:58:26 PM
Took a few looks at some clips of the guy in action and i believe he'll pull it off. He seems to be able to play both comedic and dramatic, and i'm looking forward to seeing what he can do in the role. I'll make futher judgements when i see the costume he gets given.
Matt Smith by Northstar UK	Jan 3rd, 2009 12:59:40 PM
Mighty fine actor! And get ready for Sally Sparrow!
gotilk by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:00:09 PM
It's not just the big floppy hair that reminds me of Thingy Patterson, it's the long long face with the features clustered in the middle, like a man in the moon. There is more than a passing resemblance, though Patterson has an overbite, I think. I really hope this screaming jerk doesn't win Total Wipeout Pure Forever. Is it only me and spud watching this outrageous car crash?
They got the wrong Matt Smith... by Alonzo Mosely	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:00:29 PM
They should have gone for this guy instead http://www.campmeeting.org/emm anuel/images/smlmatt.jpg Remove spaces, adn imagine what could have been... God I love Google image search...
Please refrain from calling him Matty Smith. by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:01:04 PM
He is young enough already.
Sally Sparrow, eh!! by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:03:12 PM
she was quite the fetch!! is there rumours she will return!!! what about the Doctor's daughter?
Is Matt Smith still on Facebook? by Yoda's Ball Sack	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:05:40 PM
Like harry?
The Doctor's Daughter.... by CloneRangerUK	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:06:07 PM
...won't that look a bit strange if she resurfaces, there can only be a couple of years difference between them in age, surley?
AdmiralNeck by Brody77	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:07:09 PM
I think he was directing the twilight dig at me, not that I care! And yeah, I'm watching Total Wipeout too!! Hehe, cheered me up a bit after the Dr Who 90210 announcement. And NO,, I'm not giving him a chance, ok? To me it seems the final stage of making Who a 100% kids show. Do you think when he regens the first line will be "fuck me, I look like a cunt?"
England pussied out. by Stalkeye	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:08:08 PM
Bloody bitches.
in regards to his shag-worthiness.. by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:09:22 PM
I've questioned some females and Number 11 gets thumbs up. there is a MILF door doors down the street. I might go ask her later, but the Queen of Sheba has just returned with a bag of greasy chips. Later.
CloneRangerUK by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:10:35 PM
there is potential for comedy in that.
Doubling down by jdb1972	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:11:36 PM
...on the "weird, young, skinny white guy" choice. Bleah.
his costume will have to be bonkers by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:12:33 PM
Last two were drab.
Matt Smith must been shitting bricks!! by football	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:13:09 PM
Besides Ejiofor has already been in a cheesy scifi shitfest called Serenity, has he not cunthead? This show might be having its Sylvester McCoy moment under the much heralded Moffat. Oh dear!
btw, the MILF is TWO doors down by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:13:36 PM
got a distracted
what became of McCoy's companian Ace by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:14:57 PM
in show and in life?
OK, now how about a new companion? by MediaGold	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:21:29 PM
Because you can't have this kid travel around the universe with that middle aged chick they have now. It would have a weird mother/son vibe going on. Hopefully they'll cast a hot slab of jailbait with some nice Perpugilliam sized breasts. I'm not familiar with British actresses, so who would be the likely choice for a new companion?
Sally Sparrow by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:23:06 PM

I wish they'd gone female by Oknight	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:25:17 PM
It would have been a wonderful transition scene "OH NO! THAT'S NOT SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN!" -- It would have carried hilarious story stuff for the entire run-- 900 years as a male and now...
I googled Ace by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:26:23 PM
she is a MILF. also the Queen of Sheba saw my post about paying a visit on Mrs. O'Leary so now I won't be. plus her Highness said meh to Number 11 until he spoke and then she changed her mind.
how many of you had heard of Tennant before he was cast? by earlfist	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:29:38 PM
Interesting choice. Seems charismatic. This and Moffatt in charge.......I will tune in!
Rosamund Pike would be a great companion... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:30:19 PM
Or a great Romana when they bring the Time Lords back. But she's too busy trying to be a C level American Movie star.
Matt Smith Esquire by codereduk	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:35:06 PM
I used to work with this guy! http://www.facebook.com/home.p hp#/profile.php?id=510499622&r ef=nf
Tennant was more well-known than Smith by Steve Rogers	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:36:51 PM
He had starred in a few ITV dramas, and Blackpool and Casanova for the Beeb. He wasn't a household name by any means but if you saw him you'd have said "ah, it's that bloke off the telly".
I'll give him a chance by the grev	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:42:18 PM
As soon as I saw Matt Smith revealed I thought Oh No! They've gone for kiddie appeal. Then I calmed down and figured maybe he'll surprise us at the doc. Moffet cast him, he must know something we don't - as did RTD with David Tennant
How well known he is/isn't makes no difference by the grev	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:44:30 PM
'Sides both Tennant and Tom Baker were unknowns - in fact Tom Baker was completely fucking unknown - working on a building site when he was cast!!!
FamousEccles: character actor by scratcher	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:45:48 PM
A character actor is someone a bit off, not a standard lead actor. Usually gets the more interesting, distinctive roles (like the Doctor). I'd say that all the Doctors were in this category through Baker, up until Davidson. I think that was one of the appeals of the series, that the Doctor was sort of off in one way or another, similar to Sherlock Holmes.
actors play characters - that is what they doq by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:51:48 PM
unless they're tommy lee jones, in which case they keep potraying that one guy in the hope that they'll get another Oscar
I mean that is whay by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:52:27 PM

GOOD GRIEF I'VE LOST CONTROL by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:52:57 PM

Character Actor. by Mostholy	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:54:42 PM
Quit being an asshole. It's not like scratcher invented the term. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C haracter_actor
I like the idea that the Doctor seems to be getting younger by Manos	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:55:15 PM
as he goes through his (final?) regenerations. Maybe this is the way timelords age.
serious question by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:55:39 PM
did the oft mentioned Time War occur between the McGann and Eccleston Doctors
serious question by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:55:40 PM
did the oft mentioned Time War occur between the McGann and Eccleston Doctors
I sent my brother 2 emails about matt smith.. by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:56:50 PM
and he sent two replies. one saying billie piper connection. and another one after I sent pics. which said Jeez. exterminate!!!!!
Smith might end up good but by ThrowMeTheIdol	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:57:51 PM
I don't dismiss the possibility that he could end up being very good but my first impression is: how generic.
easy Manos, no need to get aggressive by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:58:16 PM
the question was directed at scratcher who seems to have taken no offence Did I offend you, scratcher?
Demons by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 01:59:39 PM
Looking at the Guardian page for this story just now, they mentioned that ITV show Demons, the one with the chap off Life on Mars. Did anyone see it? I completely forgot it was on.
thank you Mr. Zeddemore by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:01:56 PM
I was told this happen in the Baker era by a supposed fan. I was a casual viewer for the McCoy years and missed a lot of Eccleston episodes.
Demons! by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:03:10 PM
Forgot about that one. I'm dying to see the Life On Mars guy play an American! To the torrents i shall go!
This is what they call... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:05:43 PM
Teasing. you have the actor you want but you dont want to reveal who it is. so you plant stories in the press claiming otherwise. Russell T has been in the business for a long time that he knows that a big part of the game is Bullshit. I either thought it was going to be ben Wishaw or Ben Barnes. Ben Wishaw is too young and Ben Barnes is a very bland actor. He played Brince Gaspian. that is how he pronouced Prince Caspian.
dammit - the Gene Genie!! by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:08:04 PM
I can't make out the listings!!! will Demons be repeated - will it be on iTunes - I chance buying it based on Glenister apperance?
Mr. Zeddemore by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:10:08 PM
" a good memory when it comes to TV continuity " - Dude, apply for a writing job on Heroes!!
Demons by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:11:21 PM
shit - I don't have ITV2
Steven Moffat, you let me down here... by lynxpro	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:11:57 PM
I really don't get this choice. It would've been better simply to recast Paul McGann. Younger is not better, especially when the actor brings no fan base with him. This smacks me of the casting of Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy back in the Classic Series days which ultimately killed the show along with RTD quality scripts mixed with no budget for effects. The only thing that's going to save this is if Moffat himself writes every damn episode. At least he has a year head start to get that pen in gear, or his keys on the keyboard while banging away with Final Draft.
Interview vid: http://tinyurl.com/6tddmt by Kurutteru Yatsu	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:12:44 PM
This kid's hair is making me rage. I honestly don't know how interested I'm going to be in Doctor Who by way of Hot Topic.
Who the Hell typed this press release? by Stuart-Renton	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:14:07 PM
It's filled with blatant errors. Hasn't anyone heard of a spellchecker?!
never mind Number 11 by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:15:18 PM
somebody get me Demons
Cheweitel OuijaBoard would've been better... by RyanMurray	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:23:09 PM
So say we all.
Guardian article by AdmiralNeck	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:26:51 PM
At the end of the article I just mentioned, the writer says this: "for one series at least - the next maelstrom of giddy speculation can begin in earnest: the identity of his new companion. The smart money's on Gina Bellman. Or Michelle Ryan. Or…" Gina Bellman is the worst actress in the world. Worse than Saffron Burrows. She'd be like a mom to the Doctor. Could anything else be worse? Fuck it, bring back Sally. Carey Mulligan is 24ish, so the age thing would make some sense. Plus most Who fans fell for her. They'll go for an unknown, of course, just to baffle us, or someone who played Put-Upon Orphan No. 4 in Little Dorrit or something.
demons by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:29:50 PM
was fucking awful.
I don't care if it is awful - its got Glenister by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:38:47 PM
and its on Saturday evenings. just watched a trailer on YouTube - why put make up and prosthetics on Mackenzie Crook?? it just makes him look less ugly!!!
Oh, please - of course they'd go younger. by AnnoyYou	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:38:58 PM
You fanboys are NOT their demographic - they saw the numbers for Twilight, the Jonas Brothers movie and HSM3, and they made the correct choice for A TEA-TIME SERIES AIMED AT CHILDREN AND TWEENS. Sheesh. He's not who I would have gone with, but the little girls understand. I'm willing to give him a chance, but he's going to have an uphill battle after Tennant, whom people adore. Who knows, he might only last a year (like Martha Jones). Not the end of the world.
do the actors on that BBC Robin Hood know its rubbish by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:42:05 PM

I didn't like Martha Jones nor by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:43:21 PM
the actress playing her
Chiwetel Ejiofor would have been a better choice by palewook	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:43:56 PM
oh well, hope it doesnt turn into doctor 90210. he's a little on the young side.
I should've written my post better... by lynxpro	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:44:05 PM
I wasn't trying to infer that Colin Baker or Sylvester McCoy were young; I was inferring that their casting was simply bonkers on the part of JNT. If Moffat wanted to go younger with the casting, me thinks he should have picked Jamie Davis. Yes, I know he was on the Sarah Jane Adventures already as a villain but that doesn't count. At least he's attractive enough to keep the ladies (and the gay males) watching which is important for sustaining the ratings. The official casting does neither. Maybe this announcement is misdirection on the part of Moffat. Now that would be cool; but too cool for the BBC. Sigh.
Michelle Ryan or Jemima Rooper please... by lynxpro	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:45:29 PM
...Either would make great new companions regardless of who is cast as The Doctor.
Not into a youthful doctor. by TinSpider	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:45:45 PM
He looks more like Sarah Jane Adventures fodder than Doctor Who. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt until i see him in the role. This could be the nail in the coffin for me though. Moff or not.
Great... the Doctor's gone EMO. >:( by TheGhostWhoLurks	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:45:54 PM
Let's just go DORKIER with the character.
and lol at the ad on this page for amazon blu-ray by palewook	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:45:59 PM
the prices expired a few days ago. "Hurry--this offer is only valid through December 31"
famouseccles by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:49:08 PM
glenister was awful.
new doctor looks like richmond from the IT crowd by palewook	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:50:46 PM
Noel Fielding
FIRE YOUR AGENT by Mr_X	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:53:46 PM
he's only put two crappy pictures of you on imdb. Good luck mate. i' don't know who the fuck you are, nor understand all the secrecy behind your unveiling. Too be honest it was like the unveiling of the masked magician. who the fuck is that anyways. i'm sure you'll do a great job.
Mr. Zeddemore - I jest not by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:57:20 PM

Give it time by Lloytron	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:58:20 PM
I've no clue who this Matt Smith guy is or what he is like, but I know what Steven Moffat can do and to my knowledge he has never disappointed (me, at least). Give them 3 episodes and judge then. BTW seeing as this new guy is about 12 (yes I know he is 26 IRL and 900 odd in the show), he's totally going to have a bonk on for any companion, and Captain Jack will be sniffing around him more than ever! Curious observation. When I was a kid The Doctor was getting on a bit. Now I'm getting on a bit, and the Doctor is a kid. Perhaps he is Benjamin Button.
Okay, jacksparness - but was it awful like by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 02:59:56 PM
BBC's Robin Hood or awful like Primeval - wait they're both on the same end of awful aren't they!!!
Doctor Who AND The Joker=Matt Smith by spidermanfreak20	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:00:11 PM
Tell me that guy is not a shoe in to replace Heath Ledger as The Joker for possibly a cameo in the upcoming Batman sequel. Come on he reeks Heath.
http://tinyurl.com/6tddmt by Mr_X	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:00:57 PM
having watched the interview. I like this kid. he has the sam,e manic energy the other dr's have. good choice.
shite - I thought Captain Jack was finished with by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:01:28 PM

Re: how many of you had heard of Tennant before he was cast? by jdb1972	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:01:55 PM
Er, he had already been cast as the villain in a Harry Potter movie at that point (though it wasn't released until a while after that). It's not like he was living under a bridge or something.
actually he was living under a bridge!! by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:03:41 PM
I remember he used to get right pissed at the billy goats.
With Moffat & this guy, we're entering a far better time for Who by Kubla_Khan	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:04:53 PM
...At least this kid is quirky, not too fuckin' handsome, and he's got this kind of weirdly energetic, off-kilter way of talking. He's an oddball, exactly like the Dr should be. I like the choice. Moffat said he was originally skewing far older, but basically this 26-yr-old came in and nailed the fuck out of the part. Moffat knows what he's doing, and the good news is that the high camp and fart jokes reign of RTD is almost over! FUCK YEAH!
when is RTD gone?? by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:07:32 PM
I hate him and I hate that I liked his Christmas special.
can the Doctor have two chicks by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:08:26 PM

In the Moffat we trust by Aeronaut	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:14:08 PM
Looking forward to see how this is going to work out. Interesting skewing to youth - will Moffat create some deeper meaning to this new appearance as the Doc gets towards his final regenerations? I vote for no assistant, just a different alien love interest every so often as per Kirk. On that subject, youthful 'regenerations' are the in thing.
Excellent! by zer05um	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:16:43 PM
I'm stoked as to see Matt as the New Doctor. He's got... that otherness about him that's needed and no baggage. Good choice.
River Song by Lloytron	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:20:06 PM
So this news kinda screws up some of the River Song theories for a while - she knew him when he was 'older'. Still, he knows that he marries her, leaves her and that she is doomed to spend her life in a virtual world, so he probably isn't really looking forward to getting together with her. :D
Clearly this doctor is a fan of Earth circa the 1980's... by slder78	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:21:25 PM
judging from his FLOCK of FUCKING SEAGULLS haircut. Dude gotta get some clippers.
It's a year away by vadakinX	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:23:11 PM
I'm with you guys, at first glance he doesn't scream "Time Lord" in fact he kinda looks like a cross between Ricky Hatton and Wayne Rooney with emo hair. But he's not gonna be The Doctor for another 12 months...we won't see him in the role until next Christmas and that will probably just be a brief appearance at the end following the regeneration. So he pretty much has a year to work with Moffat to figure out how his Doctor is going to look and act.
an old soul in a young body.. by Deak the Geek	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:24:01 PM
the kid must have had a killer audition to change moffs mind in casting a younger doctor. if he's good enough for moff he's good enough for me. good luck matt smith!
famouseccles by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:30:53 PM
tough one there, as you say they are on the same level of awfulness. It was closer to Primeval, maybe ITV sci-fi/horror doesn't agree with me. By the way I love the Gene Genie, but he seems miscast - though I'll probably stay with it as I need my Saturday evening fix! However, you can judge how awful the show was not just by Glenister accent but also by the overuse of the "cool" soundtrack. Character called Ruby in trouble, cut to lead actor running down the street with the Kaiser Chiefs "Ruby" playing. Oh dear.
so it's _not_ a black guy by punto	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:32:38 PM
I'm offended.
are the the Kaiser Chiefs still in?? by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:36:59 PM
I thought all the youngsters read from The Script these days. also I went tio see INKHEART today - bloody good - plus it carried trailers for WATCHMEN, ALIENS VS. MONSTERS and STAR TREK (hadn't seen them on the big screen before) - fucking awesome - as is that hamster from BOLT!!!
James Bond is blond?! by Antifanboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:37:18 PM
OMFG! They cast a blond guy as Bond... it's going to be shit... I'm going to boycott it and never watch it... let's start a petition to get the guy removed... wah wah wah wah wah wah wah wah wah... Sound familiar? The Moff has spoken. 9/10 of you were convinced it was going to be Paterson Joseph or Chiwetel Eijofor simply because of a rumour AICN picked up from The Guardian. The Moff has already confounded expectations in his first act. I think the actor is weird looking, has odd mannerisms and talks funny. Just like Tom Baker. Silence, fools, the Moff has spoken.
I hereby promote him to The Grand Moff by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:41:51 PM

I hereby promote him to The Grand Moff by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:41:53 PM

The Script? by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:42:51 PM
Manufactured to the hilt, they were mentioned on the 5live "next big thing for 2009" music show. Maybe i'm being naive thinking there's anything orginal in music anymore. INkheart eh? Mark Kermode likes it so it pretty much means I'll like it!
Its gonna be... by Thunder Child	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:43:10 PM
Doctor Wholly Oaks (only Brits will get this)
I'm tired of by palpatinefuckedmydog	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:44:35 PM
all these white doctors. Can't a timelord be black?
Ah, he has the wacky look by ls420	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:45:34 PM
i can live with this, I thought Tennant was gonna suck, but he surprised me.
HMMMMMMMMMMMMM...... by SISKOKID	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:45:58 PM
....this Smith guy DOES look a bit weird (Playdoh face), young (26? looks 20) and comes across as a bit of a luvvie too-But Moffatt is no fool and if this is his choice it would be unwise to rubbish it. I do have inital misgivings though-the poor guy is going to have an uphill battle to win fanboy hearts-if he plays him young and hip, (allied with a same-age companion)to me that is just not the Doctor Who I want to see, even for the odd story. I am sure Moffatt had his choice but I wouldn't be surprised if the yoof-obsessed BBC management didn't push for a young doctor.....we'll all just have wait and see what happens in SPRING 2011!!(sigh)...
And.. by palpatinefuckedmydog	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:46:17 PM
call the tardis his "crib"?
by palpatinefuckedmydog	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:47:59 PM
or his "ride" Theys spinnin mutha fuckas,Theys spinnin.
heard an interview on the wireless wireless by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:48:45 PM
they seemed like nice fellows (for Dubs anyway)
anyWhos this is is all eating into my Saturday night by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:49:58 PM
laters
Demons by Donkey_Lasher	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:50:14 PM
I'm willing to give it a chance after the first episode. Crook was okay I suppose, and I like the look of the monsters. I think this will be more imaginative than Buffy, but being just 6 episodes I think it will fail. Gene's accent just doesn't sound right. Why couldn't they just stick with his own straight British Accent? (he doesn't sound like the Genie in real life)
"Carefulsilly" by Ray Gamma	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:50:37 PM
has nobody else here noticed that Steven Moffat himself posted in this thread today?
donkey_lasher by jacksparness	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:52:15 PM
sorry, are you saying demons will be more imaginative than buffy? seriously?
just one more thing by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:56:14 PM
if anybody finds out if Demons will be repeated post that info here please
Dear Steven Moffat... by Ray Gamma	Jan 3rd, 2009 03:58:14 PM
PLEASE... Can we have less of the silly "Bonnie Fucking Langford" moments (such those stupid nuns with cat faces etc.) BUT Please might I humbly suggest, more disturbing/creepy "Sapphire & Steel"-type stories would be the right way to go...
What Ray Gamma said... by DC Films	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:03:51 PM

Mr. Zeddemore by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:13:57 PM
I do not have ITV2 - alas alas river fucking song was neither the best of season 4 nor in any way good - that actress is a twank - now seriously I've got to get out of here good night and HAPPY NEW YEAR
I Really Wanted A Black Actor... by ericinwisconsin	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:18:07 PM
... Just so I could hear the Doctor say "Feets, do yo' stuff!" when the Daleks showed up. Or I was hoping for William Shatner. With his Unholy Acting Ability(TM) they could have signed the Shat to play the next THREE Doctors...
There ARE black TimeLords. by vadakinX	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:18:14 PM
There is a scene...uh...can't remember the name of the episode...it's from the end of season 3 (Tennant vs The Master season) where The Doctor is explaining to Martha and Jack who The Master is and they flash back to show a young Master about to look into the Time Vortex. Behind him is a black Time Lord.
I think what they will do is... by emeraldboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:21:41 PM
go back to the other drs. They will balance things out a bit. Here is where I think the moff played a blinder. Young actor, physically strong to do action scenes and yet Smith is possibly very mature for his age. I liked tennants manic energy but that is all he could do and after a while I got really irritated by the wide eyed shots, the tonils shots etc. The Hired Matt smith after the auditions because he can act. They spoke to everyone. Apart from the tv work, he has done stuff on stage. So the moff and piers wenger must have spoken to people In the young vic. While he is a suprise to us, cause we dont know him. He is known to the people in the biz. He has talent. that is why he was cast. demographics are also a factor. I look at him as the prince harry dr who. Bit of a bruiser, bit of a party animal. in fact I was thinking along the lines of Nicholas Hoult. star of skins. They are aiming for that audience.
Uh . . . looks like they're going TEEN lovable loser by kabong	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:21:54 PM
geek. With heavy emphasis on comedy.
Remember Tennant said he wanted to outlast Tom Baker? by Its a LION	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:35:51 PM
What happened?
It's a Lion by EyeofPolyphemus	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:41:42 PM
the fans drove him crazy. He had to leave Catherine Tate's stage showa few months ago because the crowd started singing the Doctor who theme song. He and Georgia Moffet have to hide out in order to get any privacy in their relationship. I imagine he just could not handle it.
Tennant came very close to Tom Baker's record by reflecto	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:42:46 PM
He's only off by a year or so, I think; he has about the same amount of time in the role as Jon Pertwee, who also went longer than the standard "three years." It was a long, very respectable run.
Shake off the kiddie shackles!!!! by SISKOKID	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:43:39 PM
...Just watches the 'Doctor Who at the Proms'...interesting how WHO is very much portrayed as a lil kiddies programme on the whole by the BBC (lots of shots of 5 year olds looking scared as WHO baddies mingled in the audience). The whole concept of the Doctor has so much more to offer then this. I always thought that modern WHO could do with having a few later (post watershed) episodes for grown-up only (y'know, no fucking alien babies made out of human fat) but instead more intense, intricate stories, and Moffat is just the man for the job-anyone agree?
To my understanding DT still loves Who by reflecto	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:44:16 PM
They had to stop him going to Who cons when he started. He is a mad fan. I think he COULD handle it if any man could, but with the creative handover it was the right time.
Tennant - Baker by mooli_mooli	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:47:10 PM
He didn't want to outlast him as Who - just outlive him. He's been gradually poisoning his cornflakes for some time now.
SISKOKID by reflecto	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:47:14 PM
WHO has always been a children's show with adult elements. RTD's Who was no different. He had his silly episodes, yes, but after such a long hiatus from TV, I will wager no other production team could have made DW reemerge as the proud British institution it once was, critically acclaimed and beloved by the audience. He also spawned successful spinoffs, something WHO has never had before. By most standards RTD's Who has been a smashing success, with both humor and drama. Will I not miss certain tics he had? No, I won't miss them, but I think he deserves his due. Am I excited about Moffat's spin? Yes, very.
We will NEVER see River Song again by performingmonkey	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:47:27 PM
People seem to forget that River Song knew the Doctor from WAY in his future, i.e. beyond what we're ever gonna see on the show unless it runs for another 50 years or something. Who we are going to see, I imagine, is his daughter, Jenny, who's played by an actress only a couple of years younger than Matt Smith. I'm sure they'll handle that in a funny way. Probably his current assistant will think Jenny is his ex-lover!
Is it possible for the Doctor to regenerate off his feet anymore by Its a LION	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:54:14 PM
Imagine the 4th Doctor trying to stand up with half the bones in his body broken. Or the 6th after that terrible accident with the exercise bike.
reflecto by kwisatzhaderach	Jan 3rd, 2009 04:57:00 PM
Tom Baker was the Doctor for seven series. Tennant has done three series.
Emeraldboy by VoldemortWearsPrada	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:14:13 PM
Funny you should mention Skins - I wondered if a new companion might be found in their female cast. Which would mean they are REALLY planning to skew younger.
Donkey Lasher by kuryakin	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:19:03 PM
Good call with this Smith kid
Okay now that I've seen the extended interview on Youtube.... by thecomedian	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:20:35 PM
I'm perfectly fine with this choice infact I'm actually a bit enthusiastic. He IS The Doctor and he seems like he'll make it his own in the way that people here have been talking about the ones from the original series. I hope he won't have that Flock of Seagulls hair when they shoot but other than that I'm pretty excited and happy for the guy. He sounds like Pertwee and has the quirkiness of Tom Baker. Since he's so young he could in fact play the character as long as Baker did or longer. We'll see.
Hey has anyone watched the Sarah Jane adventures by kuryakin	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:23:49 PM
I caught one episode (the one with The Brigadier) and thought it was pretty good for a kids show. Is it worth torrenting them do you know? Also, have you seen the 'animated' Dr Who with The Doctor and Martha? Fucking awful, there's one on the iPlayer now if you're in the Uk and want to see some of the shoddiest animation in years
wait a minute by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:24:07 PM
Tennant is dating Moffett. ewww, reeks that peter/claire thing dirty old men
River Song by kuryakin	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:36:32 PM
I guess they could explain her away pretty easily, if unsatisfactorily for the viewer. I mean we've no idea how much time passed between The Doctor ditching Donna and the just-shown Christmas special. Without a companion to anchor it timewise it could have happened years later. So they could chuck in some references to her over the next few specials and make out that it all happened off-camera
oh no! by Candy ass monkey suit	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:40:32 PM
What a terrible choice.i was horrified to see someone so young play the doctor..he is just way way too young for the role. He doesnt have a particulary good voice either? note that nearly all the other doctors had great voices..tom baker,jon pertwee,patrick troughton,chris ecclestons northern twang and the smooth tones of mr tennant!! It should have been someone aged between 35-45..but i thought tennant was iffy when i heard he was cast, so i'll give mr smith a chance to be fair, but it's gonna take something spectacular to overshadow dave tennant. Although i've been a firm critic of russell t davies,i have to give him credit for a) casting 2 great leads in the role and B) keeping the show grounded on earth..something the older post the pertwee era didnt do and suffered for in my opinion. Although im a huge fan of Moffat i'm worried by this casting choice and also hope that he doesnt overhaul the show radically from what Davies has re-created since bringing the show back. It would be good to have a familiar anchor like rose tyler ,capt jack,martha jones etc to continue being a part of the show to a degree. We'll see in 2010 but we still have 4 more glorious 1 hr specials with mr tennant to look forward too!!
Carefulsilly = the Grand Moff?? by Steve Rogers	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:42:44 PM
If so, the very best of luck sir, with the new chap and the new series. Though I have to say I remain absolutely gutted that we won't get at least one series of Tennant's Tenth Doctor as stewarded by yourself. It's a tragedy!!
His haircut is bigger on the outside by BrandLoyalist	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:43:26 PM
Dude looks like he has a wig on sideways. I wonder if the {crotchety, clownish, dandy, playful, dashing} cycle of personalities will continue? We'd be due for crotchety.
What A Pedestrian Choice??? by Media Messiah	Jan 3rd, 2009 05:52:58 PM
If not Ejiofor, they should have gone with a woman. This announcement is the "Who cares moment of the year???"
oh no part 2! by Candy ass monkey suit	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:00:07 PM
My 2nd post hear today. After reading some of the earlier new doctor suggestions some were rather good..especially james callis and malcolm mcdowell..i wouldnt mind seing a wrinly mcdowell in the role and he is a great actor. Maybe in the future. Someone earlier aslo said that smith is a proper actor who can act!!?? so tennant can't fuckin act!!!..get real the mans a genius and i bet it's not too long before some hollywood film snaps him up? also he has been gaetting rave reviews for his portrayl as Hamlet at the RSC since last summer. The clips shown of smiths past work didnt inspire much confidence beyond an extra from Eastenders frankly. I pray this just isnt the fuckin train wreck for hell. Fingers crossed.
River Song by supertoyslast	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:01:54 PM
Why does everyone assume that River Song had met Tennant's Doctor previously (in her timeline)? It's clear from the episode that she has met several different future incarnations of the Doctor, but no definitive statement that she had met Tennant's Doctor before.
A few thoughts... by Darth_Tarantino	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:21:33 PM
As long as Matt Smith brings his own identity to the role whilst honouring what has gone before him at the same time (a tough gig for any actor), then he'll be a great Doctor. My initial reaction was how he has a strange facial similarity to Peter Davison! I couldn't care less about his age, personally. Whether he's 26 or 56, as long as he's got the acting chops then he'll do just fine. And I've looked up a few clips of his acting in other things and he seems to have versatility - and that's an important asset for anyone playing The Doctor to have. I look forward to seeing what he'll bring to the role. Let's see if we can't do something about that hair though :P
Matt Smith...uhm...not overwhelmed nor underwhelmed...just indif by Shub-Wankalot	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:27:00 PM
Gah! Young is tne new "it." And Matt comes across as...young...no denying that. It had to happen sooner or later, and the target audience should be pleased, in the wake of Twilight's theatrical release. Boo-yah! That is all.
It makes sense by mukhtabi	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:38:57 PM
Steve Moffat came on board Doctor Who the first time with Peter Davison, makes sense he would find a genetically similar man to do the job. Hopefully his adventures will wow me more than Davison's did.
Moff = change we can believe in? by Antifanboy	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:39:14 PM
Just like Obama, Moff seems to have unanimous support for taking over, but also like Obama, he has the curse of ridiculously high expectations. People seem to be under the impression that now Moffat's in charge the show's going to become some dark adult show and will switch timeslots to after the watershed. Um, no, the remit from the BBC remains the same. Two thirds of the Doctor Who audience are kids (the 5-6 million that Torchwood loses from audience figures). I wouldn't be expecting a radical shift if I was you. It'll be more of the same, just with someone else's ideas for monsters, characters and plots guiding it.
Dean Stockwell by AD_Skinner	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:39:35 PM
Should have been Doc 11.
SERIOUSLY??? by Maniaq	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:40:36 PM
how the hell is this kid gonna convince ANYONE he knows a damn thing about anything but how to make a playlist on his ipod? Ejiofor would have made an interesting choice but I guess he was too OLD? Are they really going for the Doc getting younger and younger, a la Mork and Mindy???? Nanooo fucking Nanooooooooooo
Famouseccles by Manos	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:42:15 PM
Um, I think you have me confused with someone else.
He's only 26? by R L S	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:50:26 PM
Jeeeeeeeeez, that's a bit young. Even Peter Davison was older than that when he took the part, and he's always been my favorite. I did kind of like Smith when I saw his interview. He seems like he could pull of a good 'quirky'. I do like the fact he was very fidgety with his hands, maybe he can put a little bit of that into his Doctor.
Heh.... by R L S	Jan 3rd, 2009 06:51:58 PM
I basically said he should put some of his fidgety hands in the Doctor. Heh.
ok, I'm a bit reassured by oisin5199	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:06:02 PM
thanks for the interview link, Mr X. I did like his energy and it seemed appropriate for the doctor. I even found myself smiling a bit. I hope that the 'getting younger' thing is played on in the writing and they use it to make a point. But since my favorite episodes are those written by Moff, I have some faith. Don't fuck this up!
He sounds a bit like Pertwee by I am the most horrible	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:15:06 PM
And I am predicting we're skipping the crotchety and clownish and going to dandy on this one. His haircut is crying our for dandy duds. If that IS his haircut, and not a duck decoy on his head. I am cautiously optimistic.
Dr Who should be eccentric by Hardboiled Wonderland	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:31:17 PM
Funny clothes, eccentric, daggy, not cool. The first reaction normal people have is, "Who the hell is this nutcase?" Sorry, but the Beeb is making Dr Twilight/Buffy. So Moffat was telling the truth, he really has shaken things up -- by pissing on everything we've ever loved about Dr Who to make it all Gen Y. Fuck off.
I Urge You To Wait / Carefulsilly Ain't Moff by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:32:52 PM
For those who are already haters of this new actor, I urge you to wait until we see what he looks like in costume. He may even have some sort of facial hair when he begins filming the summer. Wait for the pictures when they emerge and then you can judge if he looks like 'The Doctor'. Also remember that Moff turned down Spielberg for this gig. I doubt he would have made this casting decision without due thought. And...on the subject of the Moff: it's not Carefulsilly. You only need to read the guy's previous posts to know this: "I was bored. Very bored. Martha is back and is instantly sidelined and appears to be more wooden than ever. I have no idea why people love her so much. I am sick and tired of the 'pink lighting effect equals aliens.' Sometimes I think it looks like a CBBC family drama. Cheap. And what sort of cliffhanger was that? Millions of people under threat! What do we get? Some people in a car park running around. So, I'm afraid yet again Helen Raynor has bored me to tears. Nice CGI though." - Carefulsilly on April 27th 3:18 during the Talkback for 'The Sontaran Strategy' Does that really sound like something the upcoming showrunner of Doctor Who would be writing?
Lawrence Miles nailed this... by Scuzzy	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:41:08 PM
He was disappointed with Moff forgoing with the "safe" choice to follow up Tennant. He made an excellent point that if Smith would never been chose to follow Eccleston. It's all kind of a wait and see for me. Today is the first day I've ever seen, heard of or heard this guy speak. I hope he's generally more articulate than he was the BBC confidential interview. He still seemed all starry eyed geeked out by being chosen in that clip and he's obviously known for a while
Manos, my humblest apologies, sir!! by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:46:24 PM
I was too eager to lash back, and I've hurt an innocent bystander!! How can I rectify this? Here, have a jelly baby!!
Hey, Mostholy!!! No need for vulgarity!! by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 07:49:37 PM
If scratcher has a problem with the question I asked him/her, then scratcher will let me know!! So whoa, horsey, and relax!!
It's sad that they've announced the eyebrowless little git... by Moribundman2000	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:04:23 PM
...because now the septics won't be allowed to throw around the names of the only 5 or 6 British actors to have made a significant impact Stateside; "its gotta be Benny Hill", "I'll bet my life it's John Cleese!", "I don't see anything in Ricky Gervais' schedule for... um... a while"
holy shit, the doctor's accent is fake? by punto	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:04:58 PM
I just saw the "confidential" thing, why would he fake the accent?
which doctor is faking it? by FamousEccles	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:24:46 PM

He's an actor by palimpsest	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:27:00 PM
That's what they do. Acting. Like pretending.
Demons by Noddy93	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:32:52 PM
silly show fairly well done for what it's supposed to be. Gene Hunt isn't very good at faking an American accent tho
Yes, David Tennant is Scottish by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 3rd, 2009 08:59:39 PM

Surprised but Excited! by WolfpupNX	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:19:17 PM
I know a lot of people seem worried by the choice of Matt Smith (how ironic btw - last name Smith ^.^; Maybe Moffat just couldn't resist the irony?), but c'mon people - let's give him a chance along with our best wishes for success! I was surprised by the choice (like a lot of others, due to the River Song references, I was expecting someone a bit older), but I also have a lot of faith in Mr. Moffat. The fact is, as much as I enjoy Doctor Who in general, I can truthfully say Moffat's episodes are CONSISTANTLY my very favorite, and I always audibly "ooOooHhh" when his name comes up as I know I'm in for a real treat. My first Doctor was Eccleston. When I found out he was leaving and saw his successor and how different Tennant was, I honestly was pretty sad and thought my favorite show had ended and it would never be as enjoyable again. And I grew to love Tennant within a few short episodes just as much as Eccleston (they're both "my doctor"). This regeneration, after watching Smith's introduction on Confidential (had to Youtube it as I'm in the US), I'm definitely giving him, and Moffat, the benefit of the doubt and expecting amazing things and to fall in love with this Doctor as well. Couldn't be happier with the hands the show is in and can't wait to see what Moffat does as showrunner! It should be one helluva ride!
Good Choice I reckon. by MMacKK	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:30:08 PM
That interview shows he has some manic energy, you know, before he is actually acting. I'm optimistic.
Just watched 'Parting of the Ways' again. by Kurutteru Yatsu	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:33:15 PM
I forgot how good Eccleston was and was reminded, even with only three lines, of how great Tennant is. I think I may be even more bummed out now than I was earlier.
Matt Smith's First episode title!!! by archaementon	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:38:19 PM
"The Cure of Puberty"... 'nuff said
Good choice by proper	Jan 3rd, 2009 09:46:45 PM
I was a bit freaked when the new doctor turned up but I could see the level after about 10 seconds,and in my opinion that's the way the Doctor should be,this can run ;>,you lot are silly for real.I'm glad I delayed Clone wars on Sky+1 to be involved with the excitement.I hope the last doctor doesn't let the door hit him in the arse on the way out,nu era,let's go....Glad all that silliness is over with.More monsters & horror to disturb children and less camp silliness in 2010 please.
demons by RaveX	Jan 3rd, 2009 10:17:27 PM
downloaded via torrent. watched first 20 minutes (and I'm quite proud I made it that far) removed/deleted data. did format C: dropped HDD from top floor. so yeah, um, that's not a good sign about the future of the series, is it?
Eccleston should play Dr. Who again... by Pissed Off And Bitter	Jan 3rd, 2009 11:47:51 PM
Just promise them women.
Anyone else think by Purgatori	Jan 4th, 2009 12:00:27 AM
he looks like Crispin Glover with an even more oversized head? God I already miss TENnat. And to rub in the fact ASH isn't going to be 11 by having him do the voiceover on the conf episode is just plain mean.
a better choice...Julian Rhind-Tutt by lynxpro	Jan 4th, 2009 01:23:18 AM
...if not Paul McGann (again), Jamie Davis, James Callis, or Colin Salmon. I'm serious...we better get a hot companion like Michelle Ryan or Jemima Rooper to make this more digestible. Man, if the Grand Moff is posting here, I'm sure he's having quite the time around his stomping grounds of Outpost Gallifrey. Sir, I worship you as a writing god, but this is making me shake my head. But based upon Moff's writing quality, we could have a George Lazenby in the role and it would still be top notched.
Antifanboy by lynxpro	Jan 4th, 2009 01:26:46 AM
...uhm, The Moff has talent and experience, unlike Obama. But thanks for bringing in American politics to a Whoniverse discussion. Obama will end up being a Harold Saxon; hopefully for our sakes he won't dance to The Scissor Sisters while ushering in the Apocalypse...
is Lemming the Grand Moff? by lynxpro	Jan 4th, 2009 01:30:58 AM
Just thought I'd ask. The Moff posts under his own name at Outpost Gallifrey.
Looks like John Tesh mixed with Kevin Bacon, by Dingbatty	Jan 4th, 2009 01:36:17 AM
Lurch (of the Addams family), and Stephen Morris of New Order.
Lynxpro by Bumpasses Dawg	Jan 4th, 2009 01:57:43 AM
Nice pointing out no politics and then going on a rant. heh. As to saying maybe Moff was posting, I'd say that Donkey_Lasher has the edge on being the insider with his early call on the Matt Smith casting.
Bumpasses Dawg by lynxpro	Jan 4th, 2009 02:05:20 AM
Hey, he started it so since this is a Whoniverse discussion, I felt it proper to bring up the uncomfortable analogy that basically states that Obama is Harold Saxon. Think about it. People voted for the guy because it made them feel good. They don't know much about his past - much of it manufactured - and they had the hypnotic drums (the tap tap tap) going off via cell phones and other devices brainwashing them into voting for him [just as the media picked up on the meaningless "change" mantra that the candidate himself repeated every chance he got. Just re-watch those episodes and pay attention to Martha and Captain Jack explaining why they voted for Saxon. Still, that was coincidental since I don't think RTD is talented enough to be a soothsayer. That's quite a bit different than the upcoming History Channel special on the Apocalypse (which is available OnDemand now on Comcast) where the author of the Left Behind books describes how he thinks the Antichrist will be and it matches the POTUS-elect to a tee. I had a laugh at that. But never mind. And evilwizardglick, you omitted mention of Professor Chronotis, the Meddling Monk, and the Time Lord agent who met the 3rd Doctor to warn him that The Master was coming. So there's more than a few Time Lords that venture beyond the Kasterborus system.
Getting younger...the next Doctor will be by Dingbatty	Jan 4th, 2009 02:08:20 AM
Freddie Highmore. And then an aborted fetus (explaining away the rebirth of new regens).
Whoever it is can't live up to Tennant by FrodoFraggins	Jan 4th, 2009 02:49:15 AM
Tennant has surpassed Tom Baker as my favorite doctor. It's really a shame that tennat couldn't have stuck around for Moffetts first season. I think Moffett could have added some depth to Tennant's Doctor and made better use of his acting abilities. I'm not sure what to think of this new Doctor, but I don't have high hopes.
OMG what is... that!!! by quintana007	Jan 4th, 2009 03:47:22 AM
I hate little kids talking with the mouth of old wise men...
Two Words OH DEAR. by alucardvsdracula	Jan 4th, 2009 04:00:34 AM
What a load of wank.
When you're older than the Doctor you're in trouble... by alucardvsdracula	Jan 4th, 2009 04:06:54 AM
Shit I feel old, even the BBC's Merlin series has him as a sixteen year old kid. What is going on? Need to sleep now.
Been thinking about it...he somewhat fits the bill by Dingbatty	Jan 4th, 2009 04:08:00 AM
of past Doctors, apart from his age: fugly, ridiculous hair, half-charming/half-creepy. I sense the stages of grief; everyone's on step two -- anger. The Brits will end up at step 5: acceptance (like they did with Catherine Tate), eventually, as they venerate all things DW, even the aspects they hate.
Full of it! by DC Films	Jan 4th, 2009 05:43:37 AM
On the TV reveal they went on and on about how age doesn't matter when it comes to who plays the Doctor. So does that mean we'll one day see another doctor over the age of 40? No way - Who is now all about terrified ratings chasing Execs doing whatever they think it takes to keep the Tweenies watching. Who used to be a kid's show for everyone, but it looks as though they're turning it into just a kids show for kids. I'd like to be wrong, but i bet the 2010 scripts will aim exclusively at the Tweenies, with 'soapy', love-struck story arcs that are more Hollyoaks/90210 than Who... RIP. It's Moffat i feel sorry for - they get the best Who writer (maybe ever) running the show and the Execs handicap him a Tweenie Who that will force to write about 'Young Who', instead of 'Doctor Who'. Execs really suck...
The BBC had a terrible year... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 06:34:02 AM
but it eneded up by having all its shows in the top ten. It has nothing more to lose or gain. 3 years from now the analog system is being switched off. if this series bombs and the ratings go through the floor. then in 2011 they can look at DR who and make a decision about whos future. It took a huge gamble by hiring an unknown. We will see whether it pays off. Moff created Press gang, one of the best youth dramas of the 1980s. He has a track record. with young actors.
Best of Britain 2008 by Stalkeye	Jan 4th, 2009 07:22:30 AM
Dead Set (Brilliant Zombie apocolypse miniseries) and The Damned's recent CD; So Who's paranoid.Other than that.....
I think tennant walked because he was... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 07:23:36 AM
beginning to feel that the character was beginning to retstrict his acting career. Over the last year, all the dr had become was ticks and mannerisms. I think that was the reason why Freema left also. I cannot say for certain. but her role was 1 dimensional and flat as a pancake. she must have felt that she her career was becoming restricted. I have a feeling that Chris eccelstone felt the same way which is why he bailed early. If you look at the way the whole thing was written from day one of RTDs tenure, the one criticism I have is that all the episodes were written with a beginning middle and end. Some were two parters. RTD was not good at those. Part one was always the best. part two was a let done. In the earlier Dr whos they used more outside locations as well as elstree studio. RTD used Cardiff. But used it over and over and over. I would like moffat to use more of wales. not just cardiff.
The Curious Case of John Smith by palewook	Jan 4th, 2009 07:33:10 AM
someone had to say it.
modern tv... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 07:41:41 AM
can be summed up thus. Episode one All characters are introduced and we get set up of the story. As we the viewer follow the story, it gets expanded, so we meet more characters, which may or may not develope the story. Each character has his or her own plot dynamic. The Dr is the main character in dr who. at some point he is given an assistant. But in RTDs tenure, we just had dr plus assistant and no other cast of characters that ever lasted more then one episode. They introduced torchwood to get that spin off series off the ground. More often the dr would turn fight some villain. new episode. new villain. even the master episodes were badly handled. Though I loved the quiet sinister way they re-introduced the character. Then Russell T davies, killed him off. and turned the Dr into Dobby the house elf, oh and a jesus figure to boot in the same ep. He killed off the daleks at the end of season 4 and Killed off the cybermen a couple of weeks ago at christmas. Good luck to the moff. I hope he gives Matt Smith better scripts to work with than Tennant had is his final year!
That is very true... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 09:04:31 AM
and it did take all of them to save the world. I agree with that. I found the nature and the manner of tennants departure really odd. and I was theorising on why he left. I know there was all that speculation at the start of season 4 which wasnt helped by catherine tate. I can undertand his itchy feet to move on and the raves he got as Hamlet. but wasnt there some talk that he got he the biggest deal of any dr who dr to stay. somewhere in the region 1.5 million. It was clearly his decision to leave and that is obvious. But a little rushed no? they way they announced his successor gives me the impression that he left them in the lurch. So they had to hurry to find his replacement. But kudos to the bbc for doing it the way they did. Normally in these things. the dr regenerates. there used to be a break to find his replacement. That would be announced on blue peter. the dr would regenerate into the new dr and by that stage we knew how it was. Tennants departure was very clusmisly handled. but on the paw as parsley says they probably did know and they begged him to stay which is why the offered him all that money. They did not want a repeat of the Chris eccelstone affair. so who knows what really happened. He is going to be a very hard act to follow.
But on seeing the dr who confidential... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 09:12:07 AM
The elevnth dr. There was a the statement on the BBC that Smith got the role at christmas after tennant made his decision to stand down seems a little too rushed.
Top Ten 2008 Doctor Who Episodes by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 4th, 2009 09:48:13 AM
Well, seeing as everyone else that you don't care about is doing a top ten, here's another top ten from someone you don't care about! 10. THE DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER 9. THE DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER 8. JOURNEY'S END 7. THE FIRES OF POMPEI 6. THE SONTARAN STRATEGEM 5. THE STOLEN EARTH 4. THE UNIVORN AND THE WASP 3. MIDNIGHT 2. SILENCE IN THE LIBRARY 1. FOREST OF THE DEAD
Ooops by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 4th, 2009 09:49:01 AM
10 should be TURN LEFT.
Ooops (Part 2) by IAmMrMonkey!	Jan 4th, 2009 09:50:44 AM
I have no idea what a Univorn is. Probably a cross between Vern and a Unicorn.
Don't approve... by Midwinter77	Jan 4th, 2009 10:00:16 AM
... I have pubic hair older than this kid, for christsake.
a good point about smith by captain_kirk	Jan 4th, 2009 10:38:47 AM
At the age of 26, assuming he's not half bad, he could play the role for a lengthy period of time without whining about the role holding him back. Plus the producers can dodge the impending and unavoidable "gee, did we say a timelord only gets TWELVE regenerations? That was a typo" conversation. Cause, after all, we all know that's coming.
It's Christopher ECCLESTON not ECCLESTONE by Clavius	Jan 4th, 2009 11:08:46 AM
I'm gonna personally disembowel the next person who spells it with an "E" at the end. Sorry, I know that was a bit pissy of me, but for some reason it just drives me nuts when certain words and names are constantly spelled wrong.
So the "Doctor Who getting younger" idea is confirmed... by Royston Lodge	Jan 4th, 2009 11:18:43 AM
I still would have preferred Rupert Grint, but this looks like almost exactly the idea that people were thinking about when Grint's name came up as a possibility. The only problem with this casting choice is that it sends such hugely obvious signals about what going to come in the future. It's a little too "on the nose". The future plot-lines almost write themselves.
Re: Time Lords' 12 regeneration limit... by Royston Lodge	Jan 4th, 2009 11:37:31 AM
While it's true that canon has set that a Time Lord can regenerate 12 times, and the show has shown what happens to a Time Lord when they've reached their final regeneration, there is still plenty of ambiguity within canon to the limit. For one thing, The Master and other nefarious characters attempted underhanded and villainous methods to circumvent the limit. Presumedly, The Doctor wouldn't stoop to such depths but still it opens the door to the possibility that there are loopholes. More importantly, it was never established in canon whether the 12 regeneration limit was a function of a Time Lord's physiology, or if it was a limit enforced by Time Lord law (a la Logan's Run). Since the Time Lords are all gone, there is no Time Lord council on Gallifrey to enforce any Time Lord law on The Doctor. Regardless of what happens, when we do get to The Doctor #12 canon still gives the writers lots of room to maneuver. In fact, if it's done well there is lots of opportunity for dramatic tension. Does The Doctor even WANT to regenerate past #12? Do The Doctor's enemies (read, the Daleks) KNOW that a Time Lord can only regenerate 12 times, and are just waiting for him to use up his tickets before they can dominate the Universe? Or, what if it is just a Time Lord law and not physiological? On the one hand The Doctor is suffering from depression because he's the last of his kind, but on the other hand he can rest easy knowing that the proverbial crystal in his palm is never going to start glowing. What if he THEN finds out that he's NOT the last of his kind? What if there's still a Time Lord "government" hiding somewhere? Well, one would think The Doctor would be relieved that someone will be there to protect the Universe once he's gone for good. But then, what if that Time Lord government don't honour the same values that The Doctor holds dear? He was always a maverick amongst his own people, after all. There's lots of opportunity for great story-telling there, so I hereby throw cold water on those out there that think breaking the 12 limit is just a cop-out to save the BBC's cash cow. On the other hand, it could also be treated really really badly, by hack writers and shit producers. Luckily, I'm pretty used to that as a genre fan. I'll deal...
eccleston by Candy ass monkey suit	Jan 4th, 2009 11:51:13 AM
Emeraldboy Ecclescake didnt bail out early coz he was getting itchy feet,he only agreed to do the show for a year when he took the role - davies and the bbc knew that from the start. That is why tennant was offered the role before any of ecclestons episodes had aired. Tennant said that he had 3 years in mind when he started the job,which is about the average length of time the previous actors had served in the role(sans tom baker of course) As Tennant said with russell t davies and julie gardner leaving after the specials this was a natural stepping off point for him..the same thing happened after jon pertwee left and tom baker took over,barry letts was pertwees producer and head writer and when letts and pertwee left together a whole new production team took over with baker in the role so thisisn't uncommon in who lore. I'm still very nervous about Matt smith..not since colin baker have i had these feelings about someone in the role and we all know how colin baker turned out!..Just hope this isn't one of many future mistakes the Moff will make. Still think also they shouldd have carey mulligan back as sally sparrow..by far the assistant in waiting out there!! Also has anyone thought that tennant could re-enter the show at some point in a multiple doctors storyline or his half human offshot living with Rose? I woander if Davies wrote that in mind with an idea to a back door for tennant to come back in some capacity in the future?
Well by question83	Jan 4th, 2009 11:57:45 AM
If Time Lord really are getting backi in series 5 (or ealier even, is Gallifrey "Planet of the Dead" ?), they could be pissed that The Doctor wiped them from the existence. And it could be a great opportunity to show something more about Time War. (if IDW series "Doctor Who: The Forgotten"is in cannon, Doctor used something called De-Mat Gun to wipe both Time Lords and Daleks from time and space)
Nothing outside the TV series is officially 'canon' by Steve Rogers	Jan 4th, 2009 12:29:23 PM
as far as I know. That's why stories from novels that starred one Doctor can be reworked into TV stories for another (as with Human Nature in season 3).
The biggest worry: Who becomes Robin Hood by Steve Rogers	Jan 4th, 2009 12:34:12 PM
Another BBC show where they cast a lead actor who is clearly too young for the role - but who would have the girly appeal - and as such has no real gravitas or authority. Plus Robin Hood as a show is a total shower of fetid dogshit.
Matt Smith has got to go New Romantic... by BiggusDickus	Jan 4th, 2009 12:36:32 PM
...seriously, just look at the bloke. That foppish hair and pouty lips. Slap a bit of eyeliner on the bloke and give him the pick of Adam Ant's old wardrobe and turn him loose! Interesting choice, Mr. Moffat, I'm officially excited to see how it pans out. Still think you shoud've asked Bill Nighy though... Whatever happens, can we PLEASE have no more Billie Piper, ever? Thank-you. Oh, and bring back the Zygons. And the Sea Devils. Ta.
I am nervous about.. by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 12:38:05 PM
matt smith too. but who knows they could be looking for a much darker dr. They might be trying to make him more militant.
Remember at the end of series 4.. by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 12:44:25 PM
The dr was on his own. all the assistants had gone to do other things. He entered the Tardis alone. This new dr is going to be more rebellious. he is young, free spirited, but at the same time is a very cynical dr, edgy and a little bit battle hardned. He is a dr for the modern times. bit of a risk.
This idiot by mr.brownstone	Jan 4th, 2009 01:04:11 PM
wins the award for most irritating hairstyle in Earth's history. Also his mannerisms remind of Jeremy Davies.
C'mon people by Mr Gorilla	Jan 4th, 2009 01:05:40 PM
I know people are rightly passionate about Dr Who because he's a wonderful character etc, but this is a BBC1 Kids' Show. Battlestar Galactica it most definitly ain't.
yes, I know he's an actor by punto	Jan 4th, 2009 01:09:03 PM
but what's the point of faking the accent? why not just speak with his own accent? is it a class problem? is his real accent not "posh" enough for the doctor? to me it's just switching one funny accent for another.
McGann by lynxpro	Jan 4th, 2009 01:23:36 PM
Why is it that RTD and Moffat go out of their way to say great things about McGann's performance yet neither opted to hire him to continue the role? That's really douchie in my opinion. Especially RTD's comment about "a shame that we didn't see more of him" yet when RTD took over, he hired his favo(u)rite actor Eccleston instead. McGann would've been perfect to reprise the role and then be sent off at the end of S1. It would've had more meaning too because you would've had the war torn persona for an entire series to counter balance the last time we had seen the Doctor so exuberant with life. Mark my words, in ten years time, more people will think of RTD just as they did JNT. As much as I like Tennant, I really think McGann was perfect in the role for his limited engagement and he could have been the best Doctor ever had he continued in the role. I seriously hope The Doctor stops pining for Rose because it was absolutely ridiculous that she was the best companion ever. She was not as smart as Grace was, who was probably the smartest human female The Doctor ever had as a companion. I'm also tired of The Doctor being the last Time Lord. Bring back the Time Lords and make The Doctor a renegade once more. I think the regeneration rule is no longer in effect and the Time Lord High Council lifted it during the Time War. As it had been presented before, it was meant as a check against any Time Lords rising to Rassilon's stature and going batshit insane while in position of supreme authority. That's not to say that I want to see The Doctor regenerate all the time. I want consistency and I want it to feel like The Doctor doesn't have a get-out-of-jail-for-free regeneration card...I want a sense of danger that he may not survive even if he is near godlike. I like flawed godlike characters because it reminds me of the Greco-Roman and Norse interpretations of divinity. I want the new series in HD because if I am to spend $100 on a box set of 14 episodes, it better be on Blu-ray and in 1080p. And for gosh sakes, get a new Console Room that stands up to the fantastic Console Room from the TVM because the current one sucks. And new titles!
New Doctor by chaoslover01	Jan 4th, 2009 01:35:32 PM
I'm sure this new guy will be all right, but this casting is fairly uninspired. If they had actually cast Ejiofor in the part, it would have been interesting. Still, time will tell. If teh doctor is bad, I simply won't watch the show.
Hey, like someone said in an earlier post.......... by axcel1	Jan 4th, 2009 01:38:22 PM
with him being so young and so little work under his belt, he may not want to leave the role early. So, if the Moff-Master General, The Moff-Almighty thinks this guy is the best thing since sliced bread, then, everybody say, AMEN!!!
Ed tudor pole.. by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 01:44:06 PM
that is who he reminds me of. def new romantic vibe of them. This guy is going to be all windswept, like heathcliff from wuthering heights.
They cast Matt smith because everyone else by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 01:48:44 PM
was rubbish. If he was the third auditionee. then think of how bad everyone else must have been. It was all top secret. He must have something special. or he would not have been cast.
it could and may well be that... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 01:55:56 PM
Matt Smith was the best in a bad bunch. AS these audtions went on the worse they became. Matt stood out a mile. I got from the Dr who confidential the eleventh dr. We dont know what they were looking for as it was all hush hush. But the casting directors knew what they the makers were looking for and he fit the bill.
The more I look at matt smith he reminds me of... by emeraldboy	Jan 4th, 2009 02:01:39 PM
Prince Harry.
Baker by palpatinefuckedmydog	Jan 4th, 2009 04:50:15 PM
looked like Chico and Harpo Marx's lost brother.
he looks like by Mr Cairo	Jan 4th, 2009 04:55:27 PM
a young fergal Sharkey
Smith looks like by palpatinefuckedmydog	Jan 4th, 2009 04:58:41 PM
gay love child of Crispin Glover,Tarantino,Flea,Henry rollins and KD lang. whoo..that's a giant noggin ya got there boi.
lynxpro by kuryakin	Jan 4th, 2009 06:38:50 PM
I agree with you about the McGann thing kind of. He was let down, as were Colin Baker and Sylvester mCCoy, by shit scripts and direction. I mean flying around on motorbikes, kissing ladies - it's just not done. Well I mean, it is now, but you get my point. It actually annoyed me that they showed so little of him, as if they were ashamed, yet went out of their way to praise him. There was a lot of talk at one pount of having flashbacks to the Time War with McGann as a fucked up and angry warrior type (which would lead nicely into the new stuff with the almost-happily-genocidal Eccleston) but RTD and that lot apparently said Aw Hell No. Too bad, I like him as an actor and actually, I kind of like Eric Roberts as The Master It's not as if McGann wants to distance himself from the character, they have him playing the Doctor on the BBC7 radio dramas. Dunno if there are any still on the iPlayer but there was a particularly weird one a while back which seemed to be based around the lyrics of Everyday Is Like Sunday
Matt Smith as the Doctor by smeagol2	Jan 4th, 2009 08:16:06 PM
I am not amused.
Lynxpro/Kuryakin by Royston Lodge	Jan 4th, 2009 08:27:51 PM
I'm pretty much agreeing with everything you guys are sayin' here. Here's a fantasy: Make a big-screen Doctor Who: Time War movie directed by a bad ass action director and starring McGann.
Dr. Who 60210 by Akira Cowabunga	Jan 4th, 2009 09:07:29 PM
What the fuck is it with this ugly fucking kid? I don't need a fucking kid in this fucking show. Tenant was young enough. This is shit. I liked Christopher Eccleston, the best. The show hasn't been as good since he left. Tenant was good enough for me, but I just can't see liking this ugly fucking kid. Who the fuck spread the fucking rumor about Ejiofor and got me all excited? I'd like to fuck you in the ass with a baseball bat wrapped with barbed wire, you motherfucking, baby raping, cousin-licking, no-good nun-defiling pile of runny, corny shit. You build up my expectations and then we get this ugly fucking kid? Screw you.
Of Course, I Meant 90210 by Akira Cowabunga	Jan 4th, 2009 09:08:49 PM
Goddamn, I'm so furious I can't even type. FUCK!
Cowabunga! by Bumpasses Dawg	Jan 4th, 2009 09:40:38 PM
Don't pull your punches, tell us what you really think.
Bumpasses Dawg by Akira Cowabunga	Jan 4th, 2009 10:35:27 PM
I'll try to be less tactful next time. Love your name.
Akira by Bumpasses Dawg	Jan 4th, 2009 10:55:08 PM
Thanks pal :-D Keep up the colorful work!!
BTW, when will "The Next Doctor" Air in USA?? by Bumpasses Dawg	Jan 4th, 2009 10:58:51 PM
Come on someone!!! We need info!!!
bruce campbell was made to play the doctor! by postalpez	Jan 4th, 2009 11:17:58 PM
still say he would be the best for the part
The new guy.... by Blackguard	Jan 4th, 2009 11:20:04 PM
seems ok. I watched the Doctor Who Confidential episode "The Eleventh Doctor" and they showed clips of some of his other acting. I can see how he can portray the Doctor. I'm not sure about the emo hair though. I was not happy when I heard Eccleston was leaving but now I'm even sadder seeing Tennant going. He is now THE Doctor in my mind. Again, I will have to watch the 11th Doctor before I make up my mind. Also I had NO idea Tennant was Scottish. I heard him on the "Confidential" and was shocked.
why don't they improve the look of this show? by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 12:37:02 AM
I watched a few episodes of the current guy and its fucking atrocious. And not bad in a kinda cool/retro cheap sheik sorta way-- just really video/soap opera horribly diffused lighting British dog shit. Why would anyone watch or give a fuck about this? Its like if Americans were still raving about Quantum Leap.
and I didn't like Eccleston's hair.... by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 12:40:30 AM
....Tennant had much better hair and much better crazy eyes.
why watch it?!! by oisin5199	Jan 5th, 2009 01:07:58 AM
I'll tell you why. Last season's finale with Tennant and Tate was just one of the most heartbreaking things I've seen this year. Just really amazing stuff. If you're not a total douche, you'd see that. Tennant is fantastic and this kid has big shoes to fill. But if he was able to blow away Moffat (which apparently he did in the audition), I'm willing to give him a chance.
UK TV vs. US TV by Blackguard	Jan 5th, 2009 01:19:49 AM
The British aren't afraid to take chances unlike American TV. I grew up with the A-Team and Knight Rider. Cookie cutter shows where nothing really happened. Even today when they do something "shocking" it's more for ratings then to tell a story. I mean they stop playing new episodes the week before a holiday. I would have LOVED a special X-Mas episode of "The Master" (anyone else remember THAT show?). But now thanks to the PC world we can't have a X-Mas special. It would be a "winter" special or something. The BBC has balls. I may need to move. Or get a faster connection to torrent all the great shows.....
the BBC has balls to air shows with that quality of CG... by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 02:03:43 AM
....fuck me is that some fucking terrible shit. Alex Mack had better effects.
Doctor Who has never been about the effects. by Its a LION	Jan 5th, 2009 03:13:57 AM
.
Who's effects are gorgious Dickblood by David Cloverfield	Jan 5th, 2009 03:33:47 AM
Especially considering how ambitious it is. Have you ever seen an American TV show attempt anything on the scale of "giant steampunk robot destroying old London" or "Huge building sized Devil inside asteroid" or whatever crazy shit they come up with. (different CGI creatures and settings week after week) No. We only see the same three spaceship CGI models in every fucking episode. Really cutting edge there Battlestar Galactica/Stargate/Farscape. The writing may be crap sometimes on Who, and it is cheesy as fuck (which is a good break for me)but the effects and designs are awesome.
Just ignore DannyGlover, David... by Ghostball	Jan 5th, 2009 03:53:52 AM
...he never gets any sex, on account of always being angry about movies and TV shows. It's a vicious circle.
DannyGlover's right on this one by comedian_x	Jan 5th, 2009 04:45:16 AM
the CG is fucking atrocious as well as the overall production values. They need to shoot at 24 frames second with FILM or a higher def camera and they need to stick to episodes like Girl in the Fireplace that was all practical and avoid shit like the werewolf episode. There is a reason that American shows don't rely CG -- they know they don't have the money to do it well.
Shame about Tennant by cinemaniac	Jan 5th, 2009 06:47:24 AM
Best Who since Tom Baker, no question. Frankly, it's annoying there's another change. ...And why not go for a female doctor? That would make for some interesting storylines, especially if she/he met up with past companions like Billie Piper... let's get some simmering lesbo action goin'! lol
Episodes like Blink by kwisatzhaderach	Jan 5th, 2009 07:12:26 AM
and Human Nature shit over 90% of cinema releases. Go watch Blink now. Be amazed.
Zeddemore by David Cloverfield	Jan 5th, 2009 08:08:57 AM
I dunno, I fucking love the CGI the mill does for them. That werewolf was great for a TV show. Granted, right now I don't own big ass HD tv to make the faults obvious. To each his own I guess.
He sure looks like a Doctor.... by DarfurOnTheRocks	Jan 5th, 2009 08:29:45 AM
I think that he will do just fine. I am sensing a Tom Bakeresque portrayal of the character.
Please stop with the brooding Doctor by DarfurOnTheRocks	Jan 5th, 2009 08:31:49 AM
Ok, I understand that he is the last Timelord.... Now go get the Key of Time and unlock the Time Lock and bring back your peeps at Gallifrey.
Oh the 90210 joke is already worn completly out. by Smashing	Jan 5th, 2009 10:00:11 AM
Do some of you not actually read the talk back before posting? Do you think your words are so important that we should all hear them 3 or 4 times?. Or like a lot of haters are you just thick? Someone even misspelt 90210 above, hello?, that's retard levels of dumbness. He is young actor, we got it, please deal, or reveal your true hater nature and be done with the fib of being an open minded science fiction fan and let us all see your really just action movie fans pretending to like sci-fi to get chicks.
Matt Smith will be just fine as the Eleventh Doctor by SpyGuy	Jan 5th, 2009 10:34:04 AM
If you've watched the DOCTOR WHO CONFIDENTIAL interview, you can tell Smith has a natural quirkiness that should serve his Doctor well. And yes, he's young (about 7 years younger than Davison was when he started) but at least he seems enthusiastic about the gig. Following a definitive Doctor like David Tennant's is hard enough as it is, but with Steven Moffat handling the majority of the scripts as showrunner, Smith has a decent shot at greatness. I'm rooting for him and I hope others do the same.
I hope he wears quirky clothes by Cap'n Jack	Jan 5th, 2009 11:00:48 AM
Like a 12 foot multi-colored scarf.
Only Two More Incarnations after this fella.... by DarfurOnTheRocks	Jan 5th, 2009 12:52:26 PM
That is unless the powers that be give him a fresh set of lives a la The Master...
Blackguard - THE MASTER! by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 01:18:22 PM
You mean that Lee Van Cleef ninja series?!? Fucking MARVELLOUS!!! I used to watch it back in the mid-to-late 80s on UK TV about midnight, midweek (I think Wednesdays). Fucking awesome stuff! WHY ISN'T IT OUT ON DVD YET?!?!?!?!? As for the Christmas vs Happy Holidays thing... the thing that REALLY pisses me off about THAT particular PC bollocks is that the people that the right-meaning-liberals don't want to offend AREN'T FUCKING OFFENDED! The only person I have EVER met in all my working life who was offended by Christmas was... drum roll please... An Indian Jehovah's Witness. Yep. One solitary person. I have Muslim friends who celebrate Christmas (most people aren't aware Jesus Christ is kind of a minor big deal to the Muslims: he's a prophet in Islam), Hindu friends who do, Mormons, Seventh Day Adventists, Catholics, Christians of all denominations, and even a Satanist (who does so because he enjoys it, but more importantly, so does his wife). But no, some self-important moral guardian-type middle-to-upper class suffering post imperialist guilt white person will have come up with this let's-kill-Christmas idea, so as not to offend people who aren't fucking offended to begin with (and it never crosses the mind of these bleeding-heart liberals to actually ASK ANYONE IF THEY ARE OFFENDED - might offend 'em, see), and the idea gets taken up because there are more of these morons in Government than there are sensible people, and so a huge swathe of the population gets to miss out on the full glory of THEIR religious festival, because in the West these days political correctness seems to mean bowing to and accomodating every religion EXCEPT Christianity! GAAAAHHHHHH!!! How is it okay to offend Christians but obody else?!?!? GAAAAHHHHH!!!! As you can tell, this particular point bothers me somewhat. On a lighter note, I think Matt Smith will do just fine, although I hope Moffat was joking when he mentioned the hair as something he should ACTUALLY FUCKING CARE ABOUT! I thought that's what hair and make-up were there for? Ah well. Peace. And DannyGlover - we in the UK have a long and proud history of doing world-shattering sci-fi drama with no fucking SFX bidget whatsoever. See THREADS, the original SURVIVORS, THE STONE TAPE, SAPPHIRE & STEEL, The QUATERMASS CONCLUSION - any number of awesome UK SF TV programmes from the 70s. The SFX may be shitty, but the drama therein isn't even close to being surpassed, even today...
DGDB - Why Story > SFX in sci-fi TV by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 01:19:41 PM
Because if you flip-mode-back-and-reverse it, and say that SFX > Story in SF, what do you get? THE STAR WARS PREQUELS. Case closed, nailed, and blown into the Outer Darkness from whence it came.
spud mcspud by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 01:38:47 PM
Give me a break. I hate CG overkill as much as the next guy and I can't stand greenscreen environments. No one is saying thats what it should become. I'm just saying for fuck's sake-- show a little compassion to the eyes of the audience and make your shit look somewhat presentable. Do they have Sarah Palin's retarded infant doing the visual effects? I mean, seriously I have seen CG in student thesis projects thats better. I'm not bullshitting. I can't believe these are professional effects houses doing this work. Like the CG of that giant Wasp/Bee or whatever it was.....oh my GOD!! I'm not saying add more CG. I'm saying write around your resources. In fact, have LESS CG because these fucks obviously don't have taste to judge what is and isn't broadcast quality.
Yes spud mcspud, Lee Van Cleef. by Blackguard	Jan 5th, 2009 01:45:39 PM
That show was GREAT! I watched it every week hoping they would use Ninja Stars. It will be on DVD eventually.... On a side note, I think the effects on Doctor Who are fine. It's a TV show not a blockbuster movie. I think it works.
A plea to Mr Moffat... by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 02:05:32 PM
Dear Steven Moffat.. A know that you have taken a big risk in casting the new dr who. Matt Smith. I loved Press Gang. and I have no doubt that you have what it takes to be a great dr who Writer and team leader. Which Is why I was shocked when I read that you were tipping the Singer and media/talking gob Lilly Allen. Please, Please, Please Mr moffat though you might think it might be fun to have someone like lilly as the dr assistant it would be anything but. I do know it is now your show and you can cast anyone u like. I would urge that you dont cast lilly Allen.
here is the link where it says lilly allen is tipped.. by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 02:08:35 PM
to be dr whos new assistant. God I hope not. http://www.rte.ie/arts/2009/01 05/allenl.html
SpyGuy by kwisatzhaderach	Jan 5th, 2009 02:11:37 PM
Smith is only three years younger than Davison was when he started.
Lilly by NinjaChampion	Jan 5th, 2009 02:32:11 PM
I'm a fan of hers, but don't think she would do something like this or even take it serious.
Moffat by NinjaChampion	Jan 5th, 2009 02:35:13 PM
Someone said that he started in the 80s on Who, that was Peter Moffat. I think Steven's first Who was the comic relief special in the late 90s.
Dr whos assistant will be someone we dont by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 03:25:18 PM
know. Before the weekend we had never heard of Matt smith. The reaction has been mixed. SO i think his new assistant will be someone we dont know. so Sally sparrow fans, I wouldnt get your hopes up. They are going to wipe the slate clean so to speak.
But if he does pick lilly allen... by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 03:28:01 PM
which I doubt. Lets hope she brings the allen fire with her.
DGDB - Yes to less CG by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 03:28:49 PM
I'll meet you in the middle there Danny - I think new Who could benefit from less CG and more practical FX. The best episodes such as BLINK and HUMAN NATURE seem to be the ones where more is either left to the imagination or done with ezxcellent prosthetics and/or costumes - which are things the Beeb does waaaaaaay better than SFX. They don't have either the budget or the time to do SFX on a par with BSG, LOST or even something like BUFFY, so I'm never going to expect brilliant SFX from Who unless there's a movie made some time. But yeah... the wasp was shit, though not half as shit as the pink-light-plus-hammy-acting-e quals-transformation shite that happened just before said wasp appeared at the end.
I take it Mr Zeddmore.. by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 03:30:03 PM
You are a fan of keiths Daughter, then?
Mr Zeddemore - Daleks by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 03:31:13 PM
Sorry Zedd - I have to disagree on the Daleks. Whenever you see them in fleets, they're too geometrically correct to look as if they have independent intelligence, and when they act completely uniformly it's as if the SFX crew couldn't be arsed to program them with any independent thought. Contrast the Dalek fleets with the sort of stuff we saw on the FIREFLY TV show (awe-inspiring stuff from Zoic) or the fantastic battles on BSG (again, nice work Zoic) and it all falls down. In fact... sack The Mill. Hire ZOIC!!!
Lily Allen?!?!? by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 03:31:55 PM
FACK OFF! FACK RIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGHT OFF!!!!!
Yes to MICHELLE RYAN as Companion by spud mcspud	Jan 5th, 2009 03:33:17 PM
Bring dat hotness!!!
which old Dr. Who season was good? by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 03:55:28 PM
I've only seen the last episodes of the last two. Which old one was the best....and are they available on DVD?
The Firefly effects in the pilot were great.... by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 03:56:15 PM

the producer of Phil Collinson should have been cast... by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD	Jan 5th, 2009 03:59:44 PM
....as The Doctor. He fits the part.
Michelle Ryan... by emeraldboy	Jan 5th, 2009 05:20:36 PM
In a low cut black t-shirt. Tight fitting jeans. I could live with that. and make her a little ambigous. ie her character good be either good or bad. that would be a new departure. so if Smith doesnt work out, he could be betrayed by her. and then have another regeneration. may be ben wishaw. He is a really talented young actor. His macbeth got raves.
I give the kid ONE episode to make good by Maniaq	Jan 5th, 2009 05:37:04 PM
or I'm out - like I was when they brought on the screaming bitch from hell in that Christmas episode that had me throwing things at the TV and I haven't watched an episode since - that includes this River Phoenix episode everyone keeps raving on about (isn't he dead??)... RTD leaving gave me hope the show may yet still come good but they obviously STILL don't know dick about casting - and that shit can make ALL the difference between loyal fan and... meh... couldn't give a toss... I give em ONE episode to get rid of the fat whore and show me that the kid who knows nothing about War except what he's seen on the TV, who's never seen Hard Times like, say Thatcher's England, can deliver a Doctor who's out the other end of a Time War that saw the complete destruction of his entire race and worse... Maybe he's got the acting chops - shit maybe he's the next Johnny Depp or something - but he better bloody deliver or this show will have lost ALL appeal! (and yes I know it's a kid's show but I would hope the producers understand making it JUST for the kids - like the SW Prequel/Clone War crap or, say, the Thunderbirds movie - that shit don't please anyone and it ain't gonna fly)
Old and Young by Amity75	Jan 5th, 2009 05:53:22 PM
Prefered choices for "old" Doctors: James May, Rick Mayall, John Lydon. "Young" Doctors: Ben Whishaw, The guy who plays Merlin on BBC1, The guy who played Sean in Eastenders - A British Heath Ledger if ever there was one.
That Wasp thing by kuryakin	Jan 5th, 2009 06:39:21 PM
Never mind the crappy CGI, the important thing about that episode was that that chick fucked a giant wasp. She fucked a giant wasp I mean come on, we've all been drunk but Jesus
2 days later the no eybrows thing is starting to bug me.... by thecomedian	Jan 5th, 2009 07:24:36 PM
And everybody I talk to outside the internet have all said it's strange too. I keep trying to use "well he is an alien" excuse but in my heart I know it just looks weird. I does lend itself for a great post-regeneration moment. Maybe the Doctor will look in the mirror and say "Well, I guess that's what I get for making fun of the Mona Lisa." You "City of Death" fans get the joke I'm sure.
Matt Smith by manikman	Jan 5th, 2009 07:54:27 PM
is a brilliant actor. I have seen him on stage (in the most successful play of last year) and on screen and met him in person. He will be great. Emeraldboy, before you go naming people, know what the f*ck you're talking about. Ben Whishaw was in HAMLET 3 years ago. Macbeth? ffs, grow a brain before you express an opinion. Much like a lot of the kneejerk idiots that have surfaced recently.
Seth Green eyebrow darkening... by lynxpro	Jan 5th, 2009 10:40:22 PM
Me thinks they'll darken up his eyebrows like how Seth Green has to do in everything post-Buffy.
MICHELLE RYAN OR JEMIMA ROOPER by lynxpro	Jan 5th, 2009 10:41:19 PM
Or both at the same time. You have now peered into Lynxpro's mind...and throw in Monica Bellucci for good measure.
@ DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD by Amy Chasing	Jan 5th, 2009 10:51:19 PM
Best season of old Doctor Who has to be season 14. With the episodes: Masque of Mandragora, The Hand of Fear, The Deadly Assassin, The Face of Evil, The Robots of Death, & The Talons of Weng-Chiang. The best Doctor (Tom Baker) with the best stories. Should be available on DVD I'd think (since the episodes are still aired).
Season 13 was good too... by MediaGold	Jan 6th, 2009 01:29:21 AM
With dark, moody, brainy beauts like Pyramids of Mars, Brain of Morbius, Terror of the Zygons, and Seeds of Doom but I believe Mr. Dicksblood was asking about previous Who decent stories in this meterosexual-revamp-kiddie-int elligence insulting travesty of which there are none.
I would have gone with... by emeraldboy	Jan 6th, 2009 04:16:57 AM
Ben Wishaw. or nicholas Hoult. or at a future juncture. Micheal Sheen.
I knew ben was in a major... by emeraldboy	Jan 6th, 2009 04:20:01 AM
Shakespeare play, I just couldnt recall which one it was.
One of the two dr movies... by emeraldboy	Jan 6th, 2009 08:19:12 AM
With Peter Cushing is Channel 4. The one with bernie Cribbins. Invasion Earth. The production values on it are outstanding. possibly explains why the bbc havent made a full length feature film. It must have cost them a fortune to make these films.
David Tennent was the second best Doctor by Curious Jorge	Jan 6th, 2009 09:05:23 AM
Word.
the Peter Cushing Dr. Who films... by lynxpro	Jan 6th, 2009 09:15:30 AM
They do look fantastic, even on the DVDs. I would love to have them restored and on Blu-ray. I think they were shot in Technicolor. But they aren't canon since they were remakes of already existing television episodes. A cinematic Doctor Who film today would have to be within continuity featuring either the "current" Doctor or a popular former Doctor.
Imagine... by emeraldboy	Jan 6th, 2009 09:34:55 AM
How terrified viewers must have been at the openingshot in black and white of the first daleks emerging from the river thames. I know they looked rubbish. William Hartnell was 55 at the time when he made Dr. who. Apparently he was very tempremental man. The BBC found him very difficult to work with.
So John Merrick is the Eleventh Doctor? by Klytus_I.m_Bored	Jan 6th, 2009 09:46:01 AM
That's a fugly motherfucker with a huge noggin. God DAMN! Not that previous Doctors haven't been ugly but he's gotta have some kind of charisma to make me not get sick when I watch the show. Fuck.
He does have eyebrows. by Smashing	Jan 6th, 2009 09:57:26 AM
What an odd thing to stress about, oh no his eyebrows, pff. http://tinyurl.com/9dwq6q
DANNYGLOVER'S DICKBLOOD by kwisatzhaderach	Jan 6th, 2009 10:21:14 AM
Amy Chasing was spot on in picking season 14 as the best Who season. Watch The Robots of Death and The Talons of Weng-Chiang. The best Who story of all time is The Caves of Androzani, from Season 21, Peter Davison's final story.
Smashing - No eyebrows by spud mcspud	Jan 6th, 2009 12:48:49 PM
In fairness, no eyebrows is a bit of a weird look for ANYOE to have, let alone this dude. But to each their own. On the upside, the Spud will reserve judgment until seeing the man in action. He has that weird, intense-yet-playful charisma going on, and that strange heed... I dunno, maybe we have our first properly alien-looking Doctor! Knock yourself out, Smashing. I think you may enjoy this season even more than I know Axcel1 will ;P
His eyebrows are like mine. by Smashing	Jan 6th, 2009 02:31:50 PM
There sort of wispy towards the ends and blonder making them appear not there. Roll on the Smith.
The Caves of Androzani was the best episode... by lynxpro	Jan 6th, 2009 09:01:49 PM
I think Moffat's episodes so far actually topped it though. Moffat is the new Robert Holmes.
"Battlestar Galactica it most definitly ain't" by Steve Rogers	Jan 7th, 2009 11:02:02 AM
Fuck off, mate. See if BSG is still running in 45 years!
That picture just shows by Steve Rogers	Jan 7th, 2009 11:03:20 AM
That he doesn't have any eyebrows. He has maybe two thirds of one eyebrow, if you add up what he does have.
emerald boy by manikman	Jan 7th, 2009 01:51:04 PM
Nicholas Hoult? I hope you're joking. Possibly the most dead-eyed, useless actor around. Have you seen Wah-Wah? Ruined the movie through his rubbishness. Ben Whishaw would be great, but he and Sheen are both off to hollywood.
Guys.................... by axcel1	Jan 7th, 2009 08:16:07 PM
The proof in the pudding is in the eating, which we will all be doing in 2010, 'nuff said.
They should get Mischa Barton to be the companion for one season by thecomedian	Jan 7th, 2009 09:08:45 PM
She IS English and her American Film & TV career is kinda in limbo right now. I've got no problem with the Doctor falling in love yet again and she's aces over Lilly Allen or some eastenders reject. Call her agent BBC!
re: lilly allen.. by emeraldboy	Jan 8th, 2009 07:31:05 AM
The bbc will not hire her after her comments about taking cocaine. Which she said it was her right do so.
After after those comments by emeraldboy	Jan 8th, 2009 07:34:14 AM
Her fledgling acting career is bust.
My opinion on the best previous season of Who: by kevred	Jan 9th, 2009 08:08:19 PM
...is that it's largely personal taste. The "classic" actors who played him have each had such distinctive styles. I'd recommend to any Who fan renting one story from each Doctor, and you'll know which one you want to follow. It seems to be fashionable these days to bash the old Who in favor of the "sophisticated" new Who, but I've never bought into that. Dogging the old Who for its primitive effects or costumes is kind of like saying "I, Claudius" is poor because it had a small budget and was filmed on video. Sure, there are plenty of "monster enters, girl screams" moments, but there's also some incredibly imaginative stuff and some wonderful acting, too. Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker, especially, breathed so much life into the character, and could go from playing it broadly to a nuance that no one since has managed. Speaking of Baker, I've been annoyed at all the recent big parts he's been in the running for and not been given. I think he could have been a wonderful Gandalf (nothing against McKellen, who was brilliant) and an even better Dumbledore (he stands head and shoulders above the actors who've played the part in terms of his range from whimsy to unnerving alienness).
Matt smith was part of the original cast members... by emeraldboy	Jan 11th, 2009 03:22:44 PM
of the history boys which also included James Cordon and Russell Tovey. Tovey was hyped By RTD as a potential Dr who. That play changed the life of that cast beyond measure.
they were by emeraldboy	Jan 11th, 2009 03:31:46 PM
Sacha Dawan, 24 James Corden, 30 Andrew Knott, 29 Jamie Parker, 29 Dominic Cooper, 30 Samuel Barnett, 28 Russell Tovey, 27 Samuel Anderson, 24 and matt Smith 26... also part of the original cast was the boring ben barnes whose decision to quit was met with fury by the national . Here is a little more about smith.... succeed David Tennant as Dr Who, becoming the youngest actor to take the part. Toby Whale, who picked Smith to play Lockwood in the first cast change of The History Boys, said he was a "terrific" choice for the 11th Doctor. "I was thrilled for him," Whale said. "I know how hard he works, I know how he good is, and I have every confidence in him." Smith had ambitions to be a professional footballer, but gave up because of a back injury. He joined the National Youth Theatre, acted at the Royal Court and went on to the National Theatre. Has returned to the Royal Court in the award-winning That Face and starred opposite Christian Slater in Swimming With Sharks in the West End. His TV work includes The Ruby in the Smoke and The Shadow in the North, and lead roles in the Bafta award-winning The Street and the political drama Party Animals
Jus to explain further... by emeraldboy	Jan 11th, 2009 03:37:07 PM
the national is the national theatre, which is based on the south bank of london and is home to the olivier Theatre. and is also home to the nation film school. That is where I saw Sir Paul Schofield in john Gabriel bjorkman and its one of The impressive theatre buildings I have been.

Talkbacks

DOCTOR WHO??
TV Actor Matt Smith!!

User login

Quick Talkback

Talkbacks

Talkbacks

DOCTOR WHO?? TV Actor Matt Smith!!

User login

Quick Talkback

Talkbacks

DOCTOR WHO??
TV Actor Matt Smith!!