Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

i loved that show as a kid
by deanbarry
Nov 17th, 2008
12:55:08 AM
cool...
Lets hope
by ghunz
Nov 17th, 2008
01:01:02 AM
They keep it close to the show, one of the only cartoons to show killing and death
Thats too bad
by Bass Ackwards
Nov 17th, 2008
01:01:10 AM
I always thought this show had a great concept that'd make for a blast of a film, though I'm not sure these two are up for it (though I did enjoy the Shanghai flicks, but that's a lighter fare). What happened to Kasdan?
Woot
by Paul T. Ryan
Nov 17th, 2008
01:02:57 AM
Woot! Robo-Emo angst ahoy!
by Paul T. Ryan
Nov 17th, 2008
01:03:47 AM
...From the creators of Superman: The Emo Years. Pass!
Fuck they did mummy3 as well?
by lex romero
Nov 17th, 2008
01:04:11 AM
Running smallville into the ground and down to teh centre core of shittiness was bad enough but they also gave birth to that abomination? Can we expect witty comedy such as "the yak yakked" through robottech then? Will the young pilot be an annoying cunt who's meant to be "cool" 'cos he's young? Will he fall in love with some girl after 5 minutes of screen time?
Expect Exploding Trucks and Characters being Knocked Out
by godmechcog
Nov 17th, 2008
01:04:19 AM
Because that seems to happen all the time on Smallville. People on that show should all have brain damage being knocked out that much.
I trust these guys
by rpalompo
Nov 17th, 2008
01:05:30 AM
They've done some good work in the past. I wish them will w/ Rick Hunter and co.
Uhhh, stop me if I'm wrong...
by worldofwarcraft
Nov 17th, 2008
01:08:06 AM
but I thought this series was about humans trying to survive a hostile race in outer space, while trying to get to earth? Never really followed the show, but I liked the few parts I saw, and I loved that it was one of the first cartoons I ever saw that was serialized. It was so cool to see a story running through the show, and it seemed to be leading up to something. Never did follow it, though.
so the movie will start off strong
by prunkhaft
Nov 17th, 2008
01:10:47 AM
and then fall apart
by prunkhaft
Nov 17th, 2008
01:12:24 AM
it sucks that I don't even care to see the end of a show I once loved.
Uwe Boll as the director ....
by Miyamoto_Musashi
Nov 17th, 2008
01:46:47 AM
And the cast from the new 90210.

If we are going to screw this up, lets make it a complete disaster.

Yeah hoping with those two on board the project gets cancelled.

hang it up
by goodguy
Nov 17th, 2008
01:48:22 AM
Zahler's script sucked, so they gave it to Kasdan. Apparently, his attempt was so bad they aren't even sending it out. Enter SMALLVILLE team. For all Robotech and Macross fans everywhere, I hope somebody at WB finally shelves this thing.
speaking of Smallville, DOOMSDAY finally appears this Thursday.
by Mike_D
Nov 17th, 2008
02:08:25 AM
The actual monster this time
worldofwarcraft...
by MediaGold
Nov 17th, 2008
02:11:02 AM
STOP, you're wrong! You're thinking of Space Cruiser Yamato, which was known as Star Blazers here in the States.
Wank
by TroutMaskReplicant
Nov 17th, 2008
02:20:52 AM
Is it just me or are all the Anime adaptations falling into the hands of genuinely bad screenwriters? Even the guy who's writing Akira doesn't strike me as an enormous talent.
Uh, Robotech is an American bastardization
by Roketopunch
Nov 17th, 2008
02:54:42 AM
The show was a butchery of 3 great shows. SDF Macross, Southern Cross, and Genesis Climber Mospeada. Carl Macek took the three, chopped and censored the 3 shows to mold into a trilogy that have nothing in common with each other. All 3 shows stand alone are great, smashed and watered down together, suck. This is in the hands of fucking crap writers. It's not going to be any good. It's kind of depressing because Smallville is the one of the shittiest shows in the first place next to their resume of fucking crap. Really, look at the list. The writing is bad. I won't see this movie and Macross is one of my fave animes.
You can get super stoned and still follow the plot
by Funk4America
Nov 17th, 2008
02:55:37 AM
lots of hot chicks and buff bods
These Guys Are Good Plotters!!!
by Media Messiah
Nov 17th, 2008
03:02:25 AM
Smallville has produced some episodes that are better than movies on the big screen and most certainly better than Superman Returns. Don't confuse the title of the show or the theme, with low quality, simply due to the title of Smallville being goofy, a mistake that Warner Brothers has made, or they would have cast Tome Welling as Superman, or looked at the pilot episode of Smallville and said to themselves, "Let's turn this thing into a new Superman movie!!!" That meteor strike opening sequence was worthy of a block buster film!!! Remember, this was the first non-costume, super hero show of any import, not "Heroes", and that alone is a breakthrough!!!
We went from the man who wrote Empire Strikes Back...
by Lyghthouse
Nov 17th, 2008
03:06:38 AM
to the guys who wrote The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor???? Oh, man that is a real fucking downgrade.
Kasdan used to be good....not now
by masteryoda007
Nov 17th, 2008
03:14:55 AM
I would rather have the guys who did the story for Spiderman 2 rather than Kasdan. Name me one thing he has done since of any note?
I watch Smallville IN SPITE of Smallville
by malificus
Nov 17th, 2008
03:16:37 AM
That show has some of the clunkiest dialogue this side of George Lucas. I watch with my wife and we howl at some of the ridiculous things that come out of Chloe's mouth. "Since I interfaced with Braniac my hacking skills have gone from analog to digital!" and what's with Jimmy calling Clark C.K. all the time? It's like he's on a silent film set: "Whatever you say C.K.! Let's get the ball rollin' C.K.!" Absolutely horrible, yet still I watch. Mostly for Green Arrow and the fact that Lois is so freaking hot and that tiny-headed Lana Lang is gone, though I miss Lex, Lex kicked ASS, especially when he did a Commedian on Lyle.
Smallville always took me to Sleepytown. This steamer will do th
by Zeotron
Nov 17th, 2008
03:20:23 AM
Unless it has more CG Yeti's!!!!!
e same. (cough)
by Zeotron
Nov 17th, 2008
03:21:30 AM
From The Writers of Herbie Fully Loaded..
by Redfive!
Nov 17th, 2008
03:45:50 AM
and The Mummy 3 Comes the groundbreaking anime-epic that will TRANSFORM your opinion about EVERYTHING....TOBEY MAGUIRES ROBOTECH!
From The Writers of Herbie Fully Loaded..
by Redfive!
Nov 17th, 2008
03:45:50 AM
and The Mummy 3 Comes the groundbreaking anime-epic that will TRANSFORM your opinion about EVERYTHING....TOBEY MAGUIRES ROBOTECH!
So funny he said it twice!
by masteryoda007
Nov 17th, 2008
03:53:40 AM
Touche
The show became a lot better
by David Cloverfield
Nov 17th, 2008
04:01:41 AM
without them. There are rumors about "mysterious red and blue boyscout" in Metropolis. Things have consequences. They show actual monsters and shit.
Mummy 3 trailer...great. The actual MOVIE...
by Big Dumb Ape
Nov 17th, 2008
04:01:59 AM
...Painfully dull to sit through and a TOTAL story mess and cluster fuck from start to finish. With some truly stomach churning dialogue tossed in for good measure that even a daytime soap would be embarrassed by.

I agree with Lyghthouse's point above: The producers went from the guy who wrote THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK to the guys who hacked out HERBIE RELOADED?

Wow, this already sounds CRAPTACULAR!

Screw Robotech, bring on Exo-Squad!
by iamnicksaicnsn
Nov 17th, 2008
04:06:03 AM
I had been told the shows were similar, but never watched Robotech. God, I would give so much to see a well-done Exo-Squad movie, a kick-ass Exo-Squad live-action TV show, or at the very least, the damn episodes on DVD. MAKE IT HAPPEN UNIVERSAL! PLEASE!!!
Will this have robot urination humor?
by Xiphos_2
Nov 17th, 2008
04:09:03 AM
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
by drturing
Nov 17th, 2008
04:28:40 AM
fucking a seriously there has to be some actual talent out there
what happened to Lawrence Kasdan?
by drturing
Nov 17th, 2008
04:29:36 AM
He was working on this... How the fuck do you go from the writer of Empire Strikes Back to the douches who brought you Curse of the Dragon Tomb?
And all hope is lost...
by Kirbymanly
Nov 17th, 2008
04:32:47 AM
...it's been proven that if you can fuck up Superman, you can fuck up anything. Oh... and Superman Returns rules!
Oh Well, Thats The End Of That
by LaserPants
Nov 17th, 2008
04:57:08 AM
Smallville is a steaming pile of shit, ergo...
A Live Action Version Of An American Bastardization By The Guys
by LaserPants
Nov 17th, 2008
05:00:09 AM
...
Who Ruined Superman?
by LaserPants
Nov 17th, 2008
05:00:35 AM
...
Well screw this noise...
by HBO
Nov 17th, 2008
05:20:31 AM
How in the hell do you go from the dude who wrote Raiders and EST to these douches? I mean really, anything Kasdan wrote will be better than anything these retards will? From the writes of SMALLVILLE and Herpies Reloaded comes this piece of shit movie? It really sounds like they are trying to make this a kids movie, otherwise they wouldn't have thrown out Kasdan's writing. This is sad because Robotech/Macross was so much more than a kids show, and it even deserves to be respected for not being a kids show. They should stop this shit right now, but we all know they won't. Fucking suits have to ruin all the good shit.
Ah shit
by HBO
Nov 17th, 2008
05:24:06 AM
Excuse me, ESB not EST. This is still a fucking downgrade though.. Also who gives a shit if Kasdan hasn't written anything in a while, he still wrote raiders and empire strikes back. That easily puts him leaps and bounds above two dipshits who wrote some of the worst movies we have ever seen.
"From the dynamic duo that gave you The Mummy: Tomb of the Drago
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 17th, 2008
05:38:58 AM
Wonder if that will go on posters? Hey, the Myspace teenagers probably liked that "movie", so it might as well.
HEY HEY LET'S GO KINK-AH ZU!
by J-Dizzle
Nov 17th, 2008
06:19:55 AM
Tight set sunah muno Protect my balls! Bookah gaweh nooweh So let's fighting, Let's fighting loooove! Let's fighting loooove! Sorry, I just felt like breaking that out as soon I watched that Robotech intro.
Media Gold & WorldofWarcraft
by G8kpr
Nov 17th, 2008
06:45:58 AM
Ok, let's fix these misconceptions once and for all. Media Gold, WoW is mostly right in what he belived Robotech was. If you didn't see all the episodes, i can see how he was mislead

Robotech starts off on Macross Island where an Alien Ship is renovated over 10 (15?) years by humans, who don't even understand all of it's complexities. On it's launch day, the island is attacked by aliens called Zentraedi.

In the insuing battle, the captain orders a "space fold" operation (sort of like warping, but more like teleporting). The destination is the far side of the moon. If the aliens want the ship, he wants to take the ship away from earth.

The ship materialises on the far side of Pluto instead, and the warp drive engines are gone (warped away. It's never clearly explained. However the book series my Macek gives some lame ass reasoning for it).

So for 80% of the Macross Saga has the SDF1 and it's crew slowly heading back to earth, all the meanwhile battling the Zentraedi.

They eventually make it, but are then not allowed to land anywhere, or have of it's civilians let off the ship. Basically Earth wants nothing to do with them, since the Zentraedi left them alone after they dissapeard.

Finally the "Ontario" quadrant agrees to let them land and disembark the civilians.

So they SDF1 flies over there, and of course is once again attacked by the Zentraedi, the SFI implements a new "barrier point system" to defend itself, and it overloads and basically nukes the entire area, killing massive amounts of people. Needless to say, no one else wanted the SDF1 after that.

Reminds me of how us TF fans had to endure Bay
by moondoggy2u
Nov 17th, 2008
06:47:18 AM
And one day, after much lamentation, pulling of the hair and gnashing of the teeth, Harry decided to chime in, saying that he was fine with the entire mess of Bay and Orci and Kurtzman because he felt that it would mean a Macross movie...

Right now, I'm feeling like Paul Sheldon in Misery, telling some overzealous fat troll,"YOU WANTED IT? HERE!!! EAT IT!!!!"

Yeah, I'm making the same derranged facial expressions, too.

Way to fuck up a great potentional movie...
by Der-Rabe
Nov 17th, 2008
06:48:09 AM
I just cant understand that a piece of piling shit like smallville has already been greenlighted all the way to its eight season.. WTF?.. Is this is all they can come up with...I feel dirty
As for this news
by G8kpr
Nov 17th, 2008
06:50:22 AM
I'm not sure if I'm happy or sad. I'm happy that they are not accepting crap and are heading to new writers to get a better script. However I am not exactly excited over the prospects of the guys that wrote the 3rd Mummy and a Herbie movie to be doing Robotech.

The fact that they had some credit with Spider-man 2 doesn't mean much. It just says they helped, if they wrote one little scene, they would get a story credit. What if that scene was the worst scene in the movie?

I hope this movie gets done right. Transformers was ok, but it could have been SO much better. I was dissapointed in parts. it became a mindless action movie with cliche after cliche. Good popcorn flick I suppose, but nothing about it makes me want to consider it a "classic", or "ground breaking"

Wow
by kwisatzhaderach
Nov 17th, 2008
07:25:54 AM
These guys are giving Kurtzman and Orci a run for worst screenplays ever written.
Had it been the CURRENT Smallville showrunners....
by M Bison
Nov 17th, 2008
07:30:48 AM
...I would have had more hope. The current season of Smallville so far has been far better than the previous seasons.
Epic piece of shit
by GodMars
Nov 17th, 2008
07:34:55 AM
If you're a 30-something and still a Robotech fan, you have issues.
yikes
by vaterite
Nov 17th, 2008
07:43:53 AM
could they have a less impressive resume?
well, color me cautiously optimistic
by VAWitch
Nov 17th, 2008
07:46:00 AM
First several seasons of Smallville at least attempted to make sense (and I enjoyed them); last 3 I've barely watched. So, perhaps they can do well - after all, it's not like they don't have plenty of source material to work from.
Watch the YouTube Trailer for this week's SMALLVILLE
by IndoorPlumbing
Nov 17th, 2008
08:08:20 AM
They show Doomsday. First time he's ever been portrayed in live action. Must give 'em credit for that.
Episode is titled "BRIDE"
by IndoorPlumbing
Nov 17th, 2008
08:08:38 AM
yep
I...
by Half-Baked-Goggle-Box-Do-Gooder
Nov 17th, 2008
08:27:36 AM
...could not give less of a fuck about this.

Why don't these dirtclods get out of Hollywood and just start packing dogshit directly into cans? Apparently there's a fortune to be made there, if crap like THIS will make money...

spider-man 2
by palewook
Nov 17th, 2008
08:29:57 AM
might be my favorite superhero movie of all time. so this could be a good thing.
What? They could not get Orci and Kurtzman?
by conspiracy
Nov 17th, 2008
08:45:15 AM
Gough and Millar’s prior big-screen credits include screenplays for “Made Men” (with Jim Belushi), “Shanghai Noon,” “Shanghai Nights,” “Showtime,” “Herbie: Fully Loaded,” and “The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor.” WOW! THAT IS SOME BODY OF WORK! I Smell a Razzy in this films future. These are the only writers WORSE than Orci and Kurtzman...Too bad...as Robotech is actually a pretty good Anime.
Herbie: Fully Loaded ... Well... thank God we're safe
by YotzVonFrelnik
Nov 17th, 2008
08:52:36 AM
On the other hand: Spider Man 2 and Shanghai Knights isn't so bad. Always wait and see.
Smallville Improved after they left
by veritasses
Nov 17th, 2008
08:57:31 AM
Of course it's on a relative scale and it's still got a long way to go, but there are promising signs that the show is headed in a positive direction. I would've had some faith if Macross were being made by the current show runners and not Gough and Millar.
This could be cool...
by GeorgieBoy
Nov 17th, 2008
09:00:11 AM
Make the first movie about the SDF-1 crashing and the initial battles with the Zentraedi. Have the movie end after they jump to Pluto and Rick & Minmei see the city construction inside. Movie #2 is the journey back to earth, Rick & Lisa captured, etc, etc. Movie #3 is the return to earth and the final battle with the Zentraedi. Make it happen script monkees.
Why is this deemed "cool news" but not...
by I_am_not_the_droid_you_are_looki ng_for
Nov 17th, 2008
09:07:32 AM
Christopher McQuarrie signing on to write two new flicks, one which is The Champions with Guillermo del Toro? And del Toro is teaming with The Henson Co. for a stop-motion Pinocchio? Surely both those are "cooler" than two fucking hacks signing onto a Robotech movie!
Ratner to direct
by yomomma
Nov 17th, 2008
09:10:16 AM
Someone needs to...
by Anna Valerious
Nov 17th, 2008
09:35:10 AM
...Lock them in a room and force them to watch all of "Macross". Because not locking them in a room to read history and folklore caused them to screw up the third "Mummy". (Well, partially.)
Blech
by I am_NOTREAL
Nov 17th, 2008
09:36:29 AM
The success of "Transformers" is now officially a curse.
Special request...
by Darth Macchio
Nov 17th, 2008
09:40:14 AM
Hey anime fans! I'm not a big fan like you guys and gals but I do like me some good old-school Asian animation before we in the states called it 'anime'.

So, in the spirit of celebrating similar interests, I do have just one friendly request. Please, when you elect to read the latest issue of your favorite anime GN at the bookstore...can you please go and find a seat instead of just sitting in the aisle? If it's at the mall and there are no seats, can you at least find a spot that doesn't put you in the way of any and all foot traffic in that aisle? Perhaps you can simply stand?

Thanks! Signed: everybody else.

Ah, the poor man's Elliott & Rossio.
by epitone
Nov 17th, 2008
10:36:29 AM
May they continue to make millions by making us feign interest.
Doomsday on Smallville.
by TJ Donkey Show
Nov 17th, 2008
11:10:16 AM
This is what's going to happen. Davis turns into Doomsday, Clack shows up and gets the ever lovin' shit kicked out of him. Doomsday continues his rampage, until Chloe confronts him. And we get awesome dialog that will go something like this. Chloe: Davis I know you're in there, please stop (Boo-Hoo). Doomsday: No worry, Hulk no hurt Betty. Doomsday turns back into Davis and everyone agrees that he's to dangerous to bet set free. So he either kills himself or gets sent to the Phantom Zone. Ta-Dah the end.
Screw this
by DeadPanWalking
Nov 17th, 2008
11:28:31 AM
Where's my William Shatner's TekWar movie?!?
Here's Hopin'
by lovecraftian
Nov 17th, 2008
11:43:59 AM
I just want it to be more Spiderman Two (which is probably why producer Tobey Maguire thought of them to begin with) than say Mummy III or Shanghai Knights.
Just be glad its NOT Elliott & Rossio!
by Raymar
Nov 17th, 2008
11:54:13 AM
Or else Rick Hunter would be a charming thief with a heart of gold who falls in love with a woman above his station. Same damn plot, every frickin' movie! Seriously though, I want this to be good even more than Leo's Akira movie.
One more thing
by lovecraftian
Nov 17th, 2008
12:07:08 PM
For those of you who absolutely hate Robotech (maybe because you prefer each original series in tact, or those who think it's terrible and doesn't hold up) I should note two things: 1) If it wasn't for Voltron, Tranzor Z, Starblazers, Voltron and most of all, Robotech, we wouldn't have nearly the exposure to anime and manga we have today. Sorry, but Astroboy and Speed Racer weren't quite going to do the trick. Also, it should be noted, without American influence Manga and Anime wouldn't even be here. 2)While it is a point of contention among creators and fans, there are even creators of SDF Macross, SDF Southern Cross, and Genesis Climber Mospeada, that actually believe the story (which was released in the States but Canadian in origin) was better than the original Japanese conception. It should also be noted the "bastardization" was done out of necessity, because without the required thirteen weeks at five episodes per week, Macross could not have been released at all. The result was supplement provided by the other two series which became a multi-generational war epic, the likes of which North American kids had never seen before.
I hope they do a good job.
by NivekJ
Nov 17th, 2008
01:43:03 PM
I just want a good Robotech movie. I'll settle for good. Three out of four stars. Just make it good. At least that.
This is great news for fans of movies that don't follow the sour
by slder78
Nov 17th, 2008
01:53:18 PM
"Hi, i'm Rick Hunter and you two are?"

"I'm Scott Bernard and this is my fiance Lynn Minmei. So what do you do here?"

"I fix the planes. One day I hope I can fly one of these things, but they won't let me. I can't even put on the tight flight jacket."

"Really? No tights or flights?Why"

"I never get a good answer to that"

"Excuse me, sorry to interrupt, I'm looking for Admiral Gloval."

"And you are?"

"Marlene Regis. I'm the CEO of Invid Industries."

Meanwhile in the theater watching all this unfold on the screen sits a middle aged asian man shedding a solitary tear muttering under his breath, "Bastards."

Don't follow the source material
by slder78
Nov 17th, 2008
01:53:56 PM
is the full title
Do you ever read someone's credits...
by lsleelee
Nov 17th, 2008
02:22:45 PM
...and say "uhh...you should probably keep that a secret."? I'm sure the fear is that if the press release reads 'Lawrence Kasdan' instead of 'Lawrence Kasdan (Empire Strikes Back)' we retarded Americans won't know who he is. But that only works for GOOD credits! If it's gonna say 'Al Gough & Miles Millar (The Mummy 3)' you gotta ask yourself : is people not knowing who our writer is worse than people knowing our writer is an idiot?
Dear Hollywood, please leave anime alone.
by Kurutteru Yatsu
Nov 17th, 2008
02:52:29 PM
You have no idea how to handle it. Transformers proved that beyond the shadow of a doubt. Just drop it. There's plenty of other geek friendly genres for you to fuck up. Can you say Warhammer movie? Go fetch!
slder78! "This is great news"
by lb_12
Nov 17th, 2008
03:38:54 PM
That is the funniest post I've read in a long time.
not a fan but
by Wyrdy the Gerbil
Nov 17th, 2008
05:27:21 PM
im confused from what ive seen isnt the show about flying these warcraft around and blowing shit up...how can it be about robots if the machines piloted by a human???? wouldnt that make them powered armour at best
necgray
by Kurutteru Yatsu
Nov 17th, 2008
05:32:17 PM
No, I will not blow you, though I appreciate that you at least bothered to say "please." Now, are you a credited screenwriter? If so please, point us to the fruits of your labor and then tell us how these guys are going to do a decent Robotech film, especially taking into account all the legal wrangling surrounding this property and what can and can't be used character/storywise.

PS: You're not going to tell me you actually liked the Transformers script, are you? I mean come on...

Whoa! Lawrence Kasdan told me HE was doing that!
by Genghis Von Doom
Nov 17th, 2008
06:06:01 PM
Seriously, I talked with Larry Kasdan last month at the Austin Film Festival. I asked him about what he's been working on and he said over the summer he'd written the scripts for the Clash of the Titans remake and for the live-action RoboTech movie! (I sent Quint an e-mail about it.)
Wyrdy the Gerbil
by yomomma
Nov 17th, 2008
06:25:24 PM
Yup, powered armor. Imagine a cross between transformers and gundam...
This is one of those properties
by yomomma
Nov 17th, 2008
06:31:26 PM
I would love to see this done right, but have low expectations no matter who is making it. Movies based on kid's cartoons from the 80's usually suck. Excuse me, always suck: Transformers, Scoobie Doo, speed racer, and so on. Kasdan may have written an awesome script (and the story IS awesome, even the hacked together american version, read the novels), but the studios would still ruin a live action movie version. However, there are several excellent Macross anime already available on DVD.
Robotech 90210
by Itto Ogami loses Daigoro
Nov 17th, 2008
06:36:33 PM
or something like that
Robo-blech
by Staldo
Nov 17th, 2008
06:42:45 PM
It's been a long time since I've seen it, but I remember Robotech as being one episode of ass-kicking robot/dogfighting action per five episodes of whiny soap Opera BS. Is the Japanese version of the series better? I feel like this is one property where I want to see more 'splosions and less character development. the zentraedi deserve better mecha as well. the two-legged shooty chicken walker things always seemed a bit lame.
This will probably be about as good as...
by wash
Nov 17th, 2008
06:47:44 PM
that live action Thunderbirds movie, remember that? No? Exactly.
The only thing "wrong" with Harmony Gold's version...
by Royston Lodge
Nov 17th, 2008
08:26:10 PM
... is the voice acting and the narration. If someone was to take the time and re-record all the sound (re: kick-ass Akira DVD vs. crappy Akira VHS) it would stand up as a great show today.
Gough and Millar are AWFUL writers
by zooch
Nov 17th, 2008
10:13:45 PM
Seriously bad. Michael Rosenbaum as Lex Luthor was the only good part and it was despite the writing.
GIANT SQUID = GIANT GOLDFISH
by ArcadianDS
Nov 17th, 2008
10:17:49 PM
Will it have the scene where Minmei and Roy (was it roy? its been too many years) are below deck and he swims out into space and nabs a 200 foot goldfish for them to eat?

If there's no squid in watchmen, then no goldfish in Robotech!

Also the 3rd act (with the cycles) would make a far better movie - the storyline there (cross-gender popstars notwithstanding) is much stronger. And I still have my 15 inch fully transformable Rick Sinclaire w/ motorcycle action figure. envy me now.

omg someone said Starblazers
by ArcadianDS
Nov 17th, 2008
10:19:05 PM
Starblazers > Robotech.
Why can't Harmony Gold make peace with the world?
by MurderMostFowl
Nov 17th, 2008
10:31:52 PM
And just release a MACROSS movie? I grew up loving Robotech, and I still respect what it did for bringing Anime to the USA ( well, keeping it here I should say )
BUt its time to drop the facade, Harmony Gold. Please just let Macross be Macross. I even went and saw Shadow Chronicles in the theater, and it was a really good attempt to make your own story.
It still failed miserably because in the end you all are not the writers of this story. You are ones who have retold a story.
It's just a fact that you can't retell it better again on the big screen.
Please help bring a *real* big budget treatment of Macross. Reach across the isle here. Please
Staldo... they got rid of those
by MurderMostFowl
Nov 17th, 2008
11:26:12 PM
For the Macross Movie "Do you Remember Love" and for all future incarnations of Macross they got rid of the chicken walkers. :) Even later in the original series, they start using more "body suit" looking mecha. Those units must have been the soldiers that drew the short straws.
oh but Staldo...
by MurderMostFowl
Nov 17th, 2008
11:34:07 PM
The Japanese verison is not any better on the melodrama part. In fact, it's probably worse. Some of it makes some more sense, but if you've seen the "restored footage" of robotech, that clears up some things that were forced to be cut by censors here in the US.
Macross Plus tones down the melodrama considerably. Macross 7 decided that that ws no fun and upps the meldrama and "music will solve all the world's problems" quotient up by a factor of 10.
If you survive Macross 7 ( I didn't! ), then Macross Frontier will be easy as pie to swallow. If it weren't so otherwise impressive, animation, and even musically ( and filled with homages to the other series ) it would have been tougher to watch.

OK I'll shut up now.
Smallville this season is greatly improved
by runrun
Nov 17th, 2008
11:42:10 PM
because these jokers left
Shanghai Noon/Knights
by Dominic-Vobiscum
Nov 18th, 2008
12:43:04 AM
Supposedly Owen Wilson rewrote all of his dialogue, so they can't even REALLY take credit for those.
Please don't fuck this up...
by Johnno
Nov 18th, 2008
12:51:10 AM
Although given all the lawsuits in Japan and Harmony Gold's asshattery, we were never going to get Robotech/macross as we knew it... I just pray they don't make this a meaningless teen comedy... but I bet they'll fuck this up and find a way to cast Owen Wilson, Chris Tucker and Jackie Chan in this one...
What happened to Kasdan's script?
by Monkey_King
Nov 18th, 2008
04:35:50 AM
WTF?
Joe Jonas as Rick Hunter...
by Monkey_King
Nov 18th, 2008
04:36:55 AM
Only because he's a dead ringer for Rick aka Hikaru Ichijo
Wow thats going to end up sucking. =(
by wowsucks
Nov 18th, 2008
08:32:37 AM
Lets guess.. Hmm. A love triangle the should have died 5 mins after starting throughout the whole movie while ignoring what the public actually wants, or even material merits. Brilliant! I have seen their work, ideas, and frankly I would rather watch the happening tied to a chair for a week with a glass of water right out of arms reach.
Hope the Kasdan version ends up on the internet somewhere
by drewlicious
Nov 18th, 2008
01:13:12 PM
I'm curious to see what his take was. I wouldn't mind seeing his Clash of the Titans either.
Smallville is the biggest
by Phategod2
Nov 18th, 2008
03:47:44 PM
Pile of Emo crap on TV I watch it with Morbid Facination But being a writer on Smallville is nothing to be proud of.
Will Hikaru become white again?
by tip
Nov 18th, 2008
10:20:12 PM
Speed Racer, Battle of the Planets, Dragonball Z (the movie), Robotech: Macross, and the list goes on. Yeah, let's take creativity from other countries and paint it white.
Roketopunch
by smackfu
Nov 19th, 2008
07:43:55 AM
I was wondering how long it would take before someone would interject that piece of information, blissfully unaware that every Robotech fan in the world already knows it. That was news about 15 years ago. And I'm sorry, but the stand-alone series are not superior to Robotech. The original voicework, music and unedited content of individual original episodes were superior.
continued
by smackfu
Nov 19th, 2008
07:50:20 AM
but the overall tone of the Robotech series was far more epic and apocalyptic than any of the 3 original series were able to achieve
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.