Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

NICE!! Get rid of your two "best" writers! THIS SHOW BLOWS!
by FuckMichaelBay
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:16:21 PM
Wow, Jeph Loeb?
by iamnicksaicnsn
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:16:24 PM
That's hardcore.
Can it save the show?
by iamnicksaicnsn
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:17:37 PM
I actually don't think the show is bad, but I can see how it's maybe too confusing for the average Joe The Plumber Six-Pack.
Oh well
by BoboHead
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:17:56 PM
At least Jeph Loeb can still mooch off of Lisa Loeb.
This show has writers?
by Vic Twenty
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:23:13 PM
Bout time their asses got fired. Money for nothing.
Uh oh
by Jinxo
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:24:15 PM
The show has big problems but that's a way to likely make them worse. Once I start watching a show I usually try and stick with it to the end but this sounds like a good reason to be to get out now. Nice work NBC!
Jeph? Short for Jehosephat?
by Vic Twenty
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:24:20 PM
How quaint.
GREAT news!
by crashcow
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:27:55 PM
Considering I never watch that over-hyped show, maybe Jeph will start getting his comic books out on time again and keep his "day job."
Sadly, can't say I'm surprised...
by Paul T. Ryan
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:34:50 PM
This show desperately needs fresh blood on both sides of the camera...
Loeb is terrible.
by JonQuixote
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:38:10 PM
That is all.
Don't know if this is a good thing, but....
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:39:08 PM
Don't know if this is good or bad, but if the show's writing is horrible, the blame should go to the showrunner and the head-writers. Maybe this will improve things. All I know is that LOST and Heroes Season 1 are pretty great (LOST is better of course), so I won't knock them for that. But this season's writing for Heroes has been horrendous.

PS: I'm back!!!

If Jeph Loeb is one of the best writers...
by jccalhoun
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:39:54 PM
If Loeb is one of the best writers then Heroes is in worse shape than I could have ever imagined.

Here's hoping that Heroes starts to be good now that Loeb is history...
Loeb was too good for that show.
by nyj_et
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:40:00 PM
Maybe he could go save Smallville. I hope to see him go back to writing comics at DC. I thought his Superman/Batman series, "Public Enemies" was really good. I've stopped watching Heroes.
My take on Jeph Loeb.....
by Jobacca
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:49:34 PM
Hes a great writer but a piss-poor storyteller. Hes written some great dialogue through the years but not ONE of his stories has ever had a beginning,middle,and an end(that made sense). The last issue of HUSH couldnt have punched me in the balls any harder if Batman had broken the fourth wall and told me to drink Ovaltine!
This is how much it matters:
by JimCurry
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:49:36 PM
0
I don't know who to blame and, frankly, I
by Itchy
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:58:55 PM
don't care ... I'm not sure they can do anything to pull this series out. They've so screwed the pooch with logic and continuity, it's almost beyond salvation. The time travel, the "uber heroes", the fact the main 'hero' (Peter) is a fucking feckless fey retard ... not sure how to pull this plane out of the tail spin. It's truly amazing - I never imagine anyone could ruin a super hero themed show, but these turds did it.
What's Heroes?
by Warcraft
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:59:28 PM
never heard of it.
Now they can hire better writers
by zooch
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:59:37 PM
This is good news for everyone that wants this show to be good.
What floored me was *this* comment from the Variety story;
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
07:59:40 PM
"The show is also said to have been grappling with hefty budget overruns this season, that are going well beyond its already sizable $4 million per-seg pricetag."

BSG has a pricetag of less than half of that per episode. Four million per?? And for VFX like that? Damn.

My thought on last week's episode
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:04:55 PM
Are there ANY frakkin' guards left in Primatech's underground jail? Everyone comes and goes so effortlessly now. Stupid.
Nice!
by fishpillow
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:06:32 PM
Now we got a 50/50 shot at getting some good writers.
For anyone who has read...
by maxwell's hammer
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:10:52 PM
...Loeb's "Ultimates 3", him leaving "Heroes" isn't necessarily a bad thing.
Good Move. Loeb's a hack.
by catlettuce4
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:10:58 PM
Looking at the crap he vomits up in "Superman/Batman," "the Ultimates," and "Hush," just to name three examples I can pretty much guarantee that all the crap in Seasons 2 and 3 of "Heroes" that people hate, the hackneyed junk, was his.
Loeb penned 'Unexpected' and 'Powerless'; Alexander
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:15:32 PM
wrote last week's Eris Quod Sum, which was an epi that I enjoyed a lot.
Could Some There Be Crazy Enough To Hire Me, Please???!!!
by Media Messiah
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:27:33 PM
Heroes needs to be altered to a format that includes stand alone episodes with a villain our villains of the week, and a bookend story arc...season for season ala Buffy, which reveals a greater over all story as the season progresses--but each episode should be able to stand as a separate entity for viewers.

This will help to get rid of all of the convoluted B, C, D, E, F, G arcs. All we need is A thru C story arcs with a emphasis on the A arc...each episode!!!

If you guys are looking for a writer/muse to help revamp the show, hire me, I'm more than available and have a ton of good ideas.
All I know of Jeph Loeb is his Batman work with Jim Lee...
by Rupee88
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:32:43 PM
...and that was very lazy, lame, uninspired writing.
@Pennsy
by epitone
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:33:00 PM
Well, to be fair, BSG saves a lot of money by being all-Vancouver, all-the-time. But still, you're right, there's scarcely a single episode of BSG that isn't 10 times more visually impressive than Heroes.
I love how this show still gets a weekly Coaxial entry
by Amy Chasing
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:34:27 PM
but while other Coaxial entries are usually about this weeks episode, for Heroes it's instead about their woes. You gotta laugh.
I quit watching
by Unnatural
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:34:41 PM
Three episodes this season. That was it for me. Heroes blows. The first season was interesting, until the Watchmen rip-off. They don't need writers, they are just copying popular comic books. Why pay writers when you can just steal shit?
Well I'm glad Herc does it
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:35:29 PM
He's given up on the show but still finds ways for us to vent our frustration or (minority) slam everyone else and declare this show to still be awesome.
And the walls come tumbling down
by Wheel99
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:35:44 PM
Delete this from your tivo rotation and pick up fringe. Good schtuff.
Good riddance
by nytivofan
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:39:06 PM
Two fewer crappy writers isn't going to miraculously turn this show into something worth watching again but at least they're acknowledging they need to try something different/bring in some fresh hacks.
too early to tell if these were the guys who needed to go
by chromedome
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:52:45 PM
but ANY changes in the writing could hardly hurt matters....

Unless these the only two trying to right the ship, that is. But since they were around for S2, hard to give em the benefit of the doubt. Whoever thought up the Runnin Siblins and Claire using her power to get on a cheerleading squad in S2--BOOT those MUTHAS for sure.

It's a start...
by veritasses
Nov 2nd, 2008
08:53:34 PM
But Kring's got to go too. They also need to take particular care on who they hire to replace them. They need people who understand the Super Hero myth (not just the run of the mill "hero" myth as super heroes are a specific category...) and the cream of the crop, top tier writers that can realize the vision. Filling each episode with 20 characters and budget sucking sfx and stunts is not the aim here. Neither is finding people who would just transfer comics to the screen... Writing for comics is a different skill set then writing for TV... Finding people who understand character and relationships as they pertain to the Super Hero Myth in a mature, intelligent manner and who have the experience writing good dialog and action is key. This won't be easy. The folks responsible for Avatar: The Last Airbender have done a remarkable job. I'd start there and see where tha goes.
Release Bryan!
by Amy Chasing
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:03:07 PM
Heroes, run by Bryan Singer, written by Bryan Fuller, music by Brian Eno, starring Bryan Brown.
Mark Verheiden is on the show so it might improve
by jccalhoun
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:03:32 PM
Verheiden was one of the writers of Battlestar and he has joined Heroes as "Writer/Consulting Producer" of Heroes starting with the second story arc of this season so hopefully he can help the show
feh, i blame Kring more than these guys
by newc0253
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:05:04 PM
one worked on Alias and they both worked on Lost. and last week's ep of Heroes wasn't the worst either.

Kring, otoh, doesn't sound like he knows what the frak he's doing.

He has? Verheiden is an INSTANT upgrade.
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:05:54 PM
And the news keeps getting a little bit better.
Surprise, surprise...Media Messiah wants a handout.
by FuckMichaelBay
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:07:07 PM
As the late-great John Houseman would say:

"EARN IT!"
re: Last Airbender
by Amy Chasing
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:13:46 PM
Yes, one of the best animated shows to come out of the US, ever. Heroes doesn't have half the charm Avatar has. If Shyamalan is still serious about doing it, he has some big shoes to fill.
still talkbacks for heroes,
by ashhole
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:22:24 PM
but nothing for "life on mars" since the pilot? what gives?
FuckMichaelBay: No...I Want A Job!!!
by Media Messiah
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:24:03 PM
There is a difference between a hand-out and a job. There is a report out about some guy working as a janitor or something, just two weeks ago, and now he's in the NFL. So things like this, although, rare, do happen. A similar thing happened to the Rams old quarterback, so Dude, stop trying to rain on somebody else's parade!!! Trust me, if they did email me, and I'm not fit to write for them, they won't hire me n that case, but if someone over there thinks outside the box and gives me a try, and I do get hired, be happy for me, I'd do the same for you, that is, be happy for you!!!
Well, the show needs SOMETHING to shake it up
by Mockingbird Girl
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:34:01 PM
I've not been very impressed this season, though Robert Forster and Kristen Bell are doing wonders with what they've been given.
One more name hits the trifecta
by Xiphos_2
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:34:26 PM
Tim Kring I'd start paking your office up Bubba.

After two years of joking about the TPTB reading the TB and not meaning it, I guess they really do read AICN TB.

This show is WAY to far gone to save. I like looking at the train wreck aspect of Heroes now. I hope they go batshit insane with it in a last ditch effort at survival. It won't work but it might be interesting. Time to roll out Lesbo scenes. The Ice Princess, Cheerleader, Cheerleaders ReCockulously hot white trash biological mom, Veronica Mars. Anyone double Xers can get it on, I don't care who. Oh and kill off Peter and Sylar etc.

Xiphos! :)
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:39:15 PM
I was part of the Two Million Fan March Friday - AKA the Phillies' victory parade, to take this offtopic a bit. Biggest victory parade crowd for any team in U.S. history outside of NYC. Unreal, batshit insanity all its own.

So if Kring goes, who's the showrunner, then? Who would you and anyone else offer as nominees?

fire two, hire back Fuller!
by BadMrWonka
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:44:48 PM
he can let someone else run Pushing Daisies!
Fuller may be available in a few weeks...
by FuckMichaelBay
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:48:00 PM
...PD is not doing well.
Fuller may be available, if PD doesn't get out of its ratings ru
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:48:36 PM
I can't Damn You Wonka!, since there's no episode tomorrow.
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:49:09 PM
;)
If I were The CW Network......
by gusborwig
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:52:31 PM
I'd pay whatever Jeph Loeb is asking for and have him come back to Smallville. He wrote some great, fan favorite episodes of both Smallville and Heroes. NBC must be on crack to allow this to happen.
But I can say KB will be in the next 3 episodes
by Pennsy
Nov 2nd, 2008
09:56:01 PM
Her third, fourth and fifth this year, and she's supposedly only signed up for 5. Which means her farewell from the show COULD be the Monday before Thanksgiving. ON TV w/o Pity, there's a TV Guide interview with Kring floating around that suggests she'll be in *every remaining episode of the Villains arc*. Mucho encouraging, or he's gotten so much positive pushback from Bell fans that he's willing to shoot around her movie schedule.
Good Lord, Jeph Loeb is awful.
by Johnny Smith
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:06:42 PM
SPOILERS FOR ULTIMATES 3: The butler did it. The robot butler. Who happens to be Ultron, given sentience by a single touch from the Scarlet Witch. Ultron, who also happens to inexplicably be Yellowjacket. END SPOILERS. Loeb blows.
Wait, Verheiden?
by Johnny Smith
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:08:05 PM
That guy's awesome. Maybe this show will be good now for the first time since its inception.
Well,I suppose
by KCViking
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:31:29 PM
something had to be done.Whether this saves or sinks the show remains to be seen.Time will tell.

Pennsy congrats to your Phillies.

Here's a tip for the new head-writers
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:39:15 PM
Remember to remember logic, and remember to incorporate it into your scripts.
Pennsy
by Xiphos_2
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:41:30 PM
I was going to ask you if you went to too the Phillies parade but you beat me to it hoss! Congrats by the way.

Have you seen that youtube video of the guy on a light pole during the parade who got nailed right in the melon by a Vodka bottle? Funny Stuff.

Melvin_Pelvis
by Xiphos_2
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:48:10 PM
I don't want to see fanFic on Heroes, there's too much already. I want the writers to go nuclear with the insanity, but make it fresh nuttiness.

Super power Lesbo! Maybe a cross over with Knight Rider. Have pyro mom light that chunk of wood on fire that's the lead and have computer kid scramble Kitts CPU. Show over.

Or maybe a crossover with LipStick Jungle. I'd like to Brooke Shields and the cheervarine get to "know" each other, if you get what I mean. I mean have sex, just in case you didn't understand.

4 fucking million?
by Gorehog
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:57:09 PM
OK, someone said BSG saves money by being Toronto all the time. Well, I doubt that Heroes leaves SoCal or wherever that shit is shot. When they were at the bank in "Poughkeepsie, NY" I'm pretty sure that was not Poughkeepsie, NY. I live there. Does not look like that. Now...wasn't Firefly one million per ep? Everyone thought that was extravagant at the time. Turns out that it was a great value!
THE problem with heroes IS:
by orange cinema
Nov 2nd, 2008
10:57:18 PM
they shot themselves in the foot by making the 'save the world' story arc happen in the first season. had they been intelligent, they would have stretched it out over 3 or more seasons, and had in depth character and min-crisis arcs throughout. now that they have already saved the world in one season, each time they have to 'save the world', we roll our eyes because we think "oh jesus, not again..." what crisis is bigger than 'save the world'? NONE. they really should've seen this coming, i don't know what the fuck they were thinking. i blame whoever was involved in making that story arc solved in 1 season. LOST is on the same island for 6 seasons, yet it is still gripping and compelling because the major arc wasn't solved in the first season.
Buffy solves the major arc each season
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:00:48 PM
But the people behind Buffy knew how to make each season compelling. And each season's major arc wasn't to "save the world".
"I'm pretty sure that was not Poughkeepsie, NY"
by Mockingbird Girl
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:06:33 PM
No kidding. Why would anyone go to Poughkeepsie if they didn't have to? :-P
Saving Heroes re:Itchy
by Gorehog
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:08:08 PM
You know, I was sincerely hoping that the guy who could produce voids was going to be carried on a time trip by Hiro to go fix the timeline...
apparently they should hire me as a writer..
by soup74
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:13:56 PM
for the last two seasons i had said loudly in these talkbacks that the show has two main problems.

1- they didnt understand their audience... that to make their audience happy they should start making the heroes embrace their powers instead of having them all feel like they were a burden. Thats why hiro was such a popular character, because hes the only one that did.
AND
do something with ali larter's character. she should have already had geek cred, but they made her character only likable to other 'single mom serial killer'-types, so the fans started turning on her.

well, both of those issues have been fixed in this season, so even if there are a few imperfections and a few leaps of logic, they won me over.
The problem with Heroes is BORING CRAPPY FX!
by HappyHamster
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:14:37 PM
The writing sucks sure, but let's face it - it's never going to be Lost or BSG. they'd do a lot more for the show by increasing the effects budget rather than dumping the writers.
I liked Micah's cousin
by D.Vader
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:18:24 PM
She had a cool power with great potential (kinda like in the Matrix, able to download any talent just by watching it), and unlike everyone else on the show, she embraced her power and actually tried to use it to do good.

And what happened to her? Did she get blown up or did she survive? Why isn't she on the show anymore? Why have they not even bothered to merely mention her? Another FAIL.

Perhaps the people behind Heroes should stop
by Amy Chasing
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:23:30 PM
trying to please the audience. Make some sort of art-house superhero show. It'd get shit ratings, but might at least be interesting. Did Alan Moore think "what would the audience want" before writing Watchmen? Then again Alan Moore is creative, while the people behind Heroes don't seem to be.
I think I've officially won a bet...
by Ravetin
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:39:01 PM
...with someone who claimed Heroes would always be awesome back when Lost had a bit of a rocky third season.
Fleeing a sinking ship
by Geekgasm
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:40:05 PM
They're probably not sorry to be gone.
Standalone episodes are the way to go...
by Bob Loblaw Law Blog
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:52:59 PM
One of the things I love about LOST is each season has had one major theme. When you see a rerun, as long as you know which season you're in, you have a good idea of where everything is in the story (i.e. "Oh, this is the one where we find out how Hurley won the lottery," or "Oh yeah... this is where we see how Locke ended up in the wheelchair.")

Sure, LOST has a pretty complex overall story... but, each episode generally focuses on a couple characters, making pretty much everybody important to the story (and thus, the audience).

Every time I watch HEROES, I just want to skip the scenes with my least favorite characters -- namely SchmoHinder, Ali Larter -- because I just don't give a damn about them.

I've pretty much stopped watching HEROES, but I'd be willing to give it a shot again if they step away from the convoluted mess they've made of a storyline.

D.Vader, You're Are Right About Buffy!!!
by Media Messiah
Nov 2nd, 2008
11:57:21 PM
Sometimes Buffy was about saving a friend from the enemy, or saving a friend from their own hand, and in that saving everyone else. It was about saving a Sister, or sacrificing one's self for the greater good...and there was a moral, a theme, beyond just a plot twist for plot twist sake. Often times the plots were thinly veiled or openly played narratives on sexual awakening, date rape, domestic abuse, drug abuse, homosexuality, sexual experimentation, sexual politics, hypocrisy, social mores, star-crossed love, faith, and just the hard realities of becoming an adult.

Joss and Marti were often writing about themselves or their loved ones, and in Joss' case, a lost loved one, and several found loved ones, like his Mom, his wife, Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Marti Nixon..the show runner.

The fact that they made the series personal, gave it resonance...and life therein. The problem with Heroes is that they are now too focused on cliches and overly bysantine plot lines...often, with too many characters to go around, and this only works to confuse the audience and slows the plots from progressing and evolving. We have only loosely been allowed to see the characters explore love relationships, or friendships, as they are only really surface relationships designed to solely service the plot for a brief time...then those relationships are abandoned, save for one example on the series. Therefore, we never get to really know the characters on a deeper level or those whom they love? What's worse, with all the various plot twists, the characters are all scatter shot, thus we never get a chance to really say, this is Clare's true personality, or Sylar's true personality, or Peter's true persona. No, all the characters are written like schizophrenics. Thus the need to pair down the characters, and make amalgams of them. Reveal that Peter is not Clare's uncle, and have them fall in love. That gives you a chance to explore them both in a tighter fashion. Have Nicki hook up with Sylar as a villainous and hs lover, etc. We need set relationships, and set friends, lovers, and enemies!!!

Look at Buffy for instance!!! Save for the rarest occasion, you always knew who Buffy was, or Willow, Xander, Giles, Buffy's Mom, her Sister, Tara, Angel, Spike, etc., and you didn't have to guess epsode to episode, and when there was a change, it was promptly explained and dealt with, no "Lost" like Chinese Box plots carried on a half a season beyond their shelf life!!!
Bryan Fuller.
by The Outlander
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:04:48 AM
Any one else notice that Heroes went down hill after Bryan Fuller left the show to go and do Pushing Daisies? Now that it looks like Pushing Daisies is coming to an end, will Bryan Fuller come to the rescue? Probably not.
BONO IS A PEDOPHILE :
by PTSDPete
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:50:31 AM
They should've hired Jane Espenson...
by glodene
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:09:36 AM
But her contract expired with Universal. Now she's back with her old Mutant Enemy Crew at Fox. Not only could she have infused Heroes with a little much needed humor, but could've taught Kring and those amateurs a thing or two regarding story structure and dialog. Oh well....
Are you listening, Marvel Comics?
by sean bean
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:23:27 AM
Ditch Jeph Loeb. He's just awful. Everything he touches turns to shit - just look at Hulk and the Ultimates. Ultimatum looks like it's going to be a rip-off of ten-year old Authority stories.
AICN TBers have spoken!
by The McPoyle Clan
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:39:52 AM
Did all the persistent calls for their heads here lead to the dismissals? Perhaps, perhaps not. Will this help the show? Perhaps, perhaps not. But at least it's an effort to shake things up.

Here's another suggestion to cut the cost of the episodes -- stop adding to the cast, and fire the ones with the lame stories! That means you, JessNikkiBarbWhatever, Parkman, Mohinder and Maya! Maybe ImPeter, too.
NBC = Nothing But Crap
by Mr Spork
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:20:07 AM
I've quit watching NBC, except for football.
I really hope this improves things
by mhennessey7
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:24:17 AM
I'm not yet ready to say goodbye; I just hope in the end there is a payoff where I can go back to seasons one and two and say; "ok... I get it, there was a plan all along..."
Are you listening JJ Abrams?
by kwisatzhaderach
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:29:43 AM
You can still save your cinematic career by ditching Kurtzman and Orci.
Jeph Loeb is more miss than hit
by Gozu
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:49:09 AM
Some of the stuff he's done has been great, but most of it's been garbage (oh, and he fucking ruined the "Ultimates" as well). Sadly, I don't think this show is going to last. They dropped the ball, but the first season is still great (and actually has a complete arc!). Bring on a show actually based on a comic (like "Runaways" or "Hellblazer")
They should have stuck to the original plan..
by CeejayNightwing
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:00:23 AM
and made each season about a completely different bunch of Heroes and villains with a new story arc. The fact that these guys got popular from season one and they decided to continue their stories into a contrived Season two, only makes for an even more contrived and pointless Season three. The show puts too much on spectacle rather than characterization, it concentrates too much on plot twists instead of plot development. Once you write a story than relies too heavily on time travel, everything becomes an endless myriad of possibilities that usually always leaves the viewr thinking "what if?", "why didn't?" or simply "What?". Jeph Loeb has ruined The Ultimates comic line for Marvel with that hack Joe Maduiera, he ruined a great ongoing Batman plot by derailing it and introducing HUSH to utterly no avail. Now he's made so much damage to a series that had so much potential that it's impossible to save it from the fleeing viewers. Just end this show quickly and move on while you still can afford the spectacle!
..also NBC...
by CeejayNightwing
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:06:07 AM
Should have had more faith in Journeyman last season, it was developing into a really great show and needed to be on schedule before Heroes, not after. I really miss Moon Bloodgood on my screens.
A few suggestions.
by gotilk
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:18:30 AM
1. Never ever let anyone in the cast ever talk about being mom's favorite again. Cheese, aged and smelly.

2. What everyone else says about logic, unless you have a clear plan for working it out later that does not involve anyone waking from a dream, finding out it was all an alternate reality or anything even remotely similar to those things.

3. Get this guy on as a consultant and sometimes writer, if he's willing (Ben Edlund)
http://tinyurl.com/5dwqc5
He seems to have saved a show I never liked before and made me and others want to watch it when we said to ourselves "never". (Supernatural)

4. Convince Tim that just because he created the thing does not mean he knows what's best for it from that point forward. Thank you for creating something we could all geek out over at first, but take a cue from George Lucas. Remember, it's "his baby" and he'll do what he wants to it , even if it means it all goes down in flaming digital banthas. Remember than when you're looking at advice from others about YOUR show.

5. Sit all the "star" actors down and explain to them that the show that launched their careers is going down in flames. Something has to give, if it's a temporary pay cut agreed upon contractually or a writing out of the show.

6. We all want cool effects, but honestly spend the money for great writing instead. Worry about the coolness of how it'll look later. Include the budget restraints in the show's bible. Interesting, logical stories and characters will go much further than a halfway(and I'm being so nice by saying halfway) decent shot of Peter flying or a nuke destroying Rancho Cucam.. I mean feudal Japa... I mean Costa Verde or whatever it was.

7. Never, ever do a pre-show premiere special thing again. It felt like a boast. No matter how proud you are about the new season, don't ever do that again.

8. Don't always listen to what we say, but if you listen to anyone, listen to the geeks. A lot of average viewers don't even know what they want until they get it and hate it anyway. Seriously. For instance, the fans might say something like "More Sylar" and you give it to them and take all the mystery and danger of the character away, making them sick of him. Sometimes what makes a character special is when you don't see him or her every week or you don't spill his whole back-story.

9. Don't necessarily listen to the people who say "stop introducing new characters". Just don't feel like you're obligated to bring them back all the time or follow them every week.

10. That guy that did "Company Man", yeah.. do you best to keep him on. Oh, what? He's already on another show? Ooh, bummer. Yeah, get him back, too. If you can. If not, try to replace him with writers you have to give sizeable checks to in order to get them to write for TV. Kill off a major character to pay for it if you have to. It'll be worth it. A good or great writer can transform a crappy show into something not to be missed. I've never missed an episode of Heroes, but I have to say these days it sits on the DVR longer than it did at the beginning of the season. So your die hards are starting to lose interest. That's scary.

Lastly, to those that want to budget cut this baby into looking like the last season of the 4400? Just commit or kill it. Don't do that. (even though I have the say that show improved the more it was threatened)
The Long Halloween
by CuervoJones
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:22:14 AM
That was a good one. The Dark Knight stole a lot from that comic book. Jeph Loeb wrote it.
I'm still watching Heroes
by bender7
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:48:57 AM
Because this season has been a lot better than series 2. But I have to agree with a lot of the opinions of the fans. The show is going downhill fast in a mangled mess of confusing storylines and useless characters. I hate to be a backseat critic but I too have some opinions on what would help bring this show back to life. Firstly, scrap the idea of a long term plan. I love Lost, but one of the problems it's having is losing sight of the smaller picture for conspiracies and mysteries. Take each show back to basics. Each episode should be a story with a beginning, middle and end. I'm not saying to destroy continuing plotlines, but not so much that it overtakes the point of actually entertaining audience. Secondly, pick a small number of characters that are required and are effective in telling that story. I know actors contracts may make this difficult, but making each character appear in an episode just to earn their pay makes for cluttered and confusing storylines. Re-examine the characters. Look deeper and see what conflicts and themes could be explored. And don't be afraid to explore outside the main 'plan'. For a simple idea, take Parkman. What if with his powers he accidentally gleans a thought from a crowd that they have a bomb and are going to detonate it. He becomes obsessed with finding this person and starts hunting after everyone who was in the crowd to find the person, invading all the other people's thoughts. Other characters become concerned that he is going to far. Hiro sensing that as well, goes to the future, and finds that no bomb has gone off and tell Parkman that nothing happens. Parkman becomes convinced that it is because he stops him, and so the conflict goes until the resolution. Sorry went a bit fan-fictiony there but there is so much potential with these characters that it's hard to understand why the writers are having these problems keeping the show above water.
Herc, you sneaky sunova...
by onezeroone
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:01:07 AM
So, you no longer gonna post a proper Heroes talkback, but you've ben posting such *news* every week just in time for new Heroes episode just to get Heroes fanboy talkbackers?

Why? don't give shit about caring for talkbackers or the show. It's all about traffic and moolah.

Warren Ellis.
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:09:41 AM
I remember a while back that a Talkbacker came up with the idea that Kring should hire Ellis as a writer/consultant.

I think he'd be just as much of an upgrade as Brian K. Vaughn was to Lost when he was picked up to write some episodes last year.

Loeb is an awful, awful writer.
by kiddae
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:21:31 AM
So yay for Heroes? I guess it's harder to keep a job when you can't hide behind the sales your A-List artists generate (I'm alluding to his comics work, here).
Gotilk
by Xiphos_2
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:24:15 AM
Please stop with the Ben Edlund jibber jabber. He needs to stay with Supernatural. Nothing and nobody should mess with Supernatural. This season has been kicking ten different kinds of ass.
Were Loeb and Alexander actually fired?
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:03:36 AM
Or did they simply move on to greener pastures (another project, either a pilot for a series or a movie deal)? They were the best writers on the show -- and, well, frankly, that's not saying much.

Another Talkbacker above said that Micah's cousin and her power were pretty cool, and I agree. But the writers totally wasted the potential with her character. I wouldn't have minded seeing her return. Or Micah. Imagine a storyline that focuses on Micah, Molly, Monica and Claire teamed up (with Claire leading this group). It could be an homage to Marvel Comics' Runaways or NYX. This is another example of wasted potential with this show.

Why not hire Garth Ennis...
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:41:51 AM
Then we can get see Peter Petrelli using his powers to sodomize his brother in a comedic manner, while a grotesquely obese, decrepit, and possibly racist Jesus Christ watches on, masturbating with the decapitated head of the Japanese guy who loves superhero comics so much.
Burn Notice Talkback
by Captain RawBeard
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:42:38 AM
Why waste time on this failing show, why can't there be a talkback for Burn Notice?? this show needs more attention.

Heroes is seriously pissing me off - how many times has Sylar and Peter lost their powers now or been put into a coma? taking them away almost every episode is lazy writing, oh look Peters lost his powers again, no he has got them back only to lose them again gee fucking whizz
Tim Kring needs to go - it's as simple as that
by ian216a
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:44:48 AM
Hey, is Ron Moore looking for a job right now?
Now Loeb has more time to write shitty comics
by Steve Rogers
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:03:31 AM
Woo-dee-fuckin-doo.

Ultimates 4, YAY!!

JEPH LOEB IS ONE OF THE WORST WRITERS ALIVE
by Laserhead
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:14:18 AM
Motherfucker can't write a decent story to save his life. All he does is set up a "mystery" for which he has no real or satisfying resolution, then use that mystery to instigate a bunch of disconnected scenes that add up to jack+shit. LOEB SUCKS AND SHOULDN'T EVEN BE ALLOWED TO WRITE COMICS, GODDAMNIT!
re: Warren Ellis, Burn Notice and Kath & Kim
by Amy Chasing
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:36:39 AM
Warren Ellis would do things to Heroes that would be both glorious and frightening. The suits wouldn't know how to handle it.

Burn Notice isn't on at the moment, is it? If it is, there should be a talkback. If there isn't, there should be a talkback.

Oh, Kath & Kim just got a full season order. NBC has now officially lost whatever remaining cred they had. Like I said, you gotta laugh.

The Long Halloween is a great epic mystery
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:11:37 AM
It's so artfully crafted by Loeb that there are mysteries within the actual mystery. For example (SPOILERS):

1. How did a frail waif of a lady like Glida Dent manage to single handily murder several of Gotham's finest thugs and mobsters with a pistol?

2. When she was hospitalized, how did Gilda manage to unhook herself from that life support machine night after night, sneak out of the hospital unseen past her sleeping husband and hospital staff, murder said mobsters, then return unnoticed?

3. Why the hell was the water red when Alberto faked his own death, considering that there was absolutely nobody on the ship in proximity to watch him, and that at night it would have been impossible to see anything in the water anyways. Unless... Alberto knew that the reader was watching him! Oh that diabolical genius.

And the most impressive TLH mystery:
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:13:51 AM
How the hell did an insane, but otherwise unimpressive housewife and twenty something mobster wanna be manage to elude the "World's Greatest Detective" for over a year?
Oh snap!
by kingoflight
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:18:28 AM
Just thought i'd start off with that seen as i was watching my name is earl. So heroes lost two writers, maybe they should get jobs filling in the parts of lana and lex in smallville as they have quit the show it seams. Not 100% sure but i thought it was the last season and they just left a massive plot hole of where the fuck is lex. These people in my opinion have been taking the piss for a very long. At least the team on heroes has the talent and a shit script, smallville is lacking the talent and still has a shit script lol. Is it wrong that i am watching the gilmore girls and liking it?
Heroes needs a reboot. Blow up the world.
by theycallmemrglass
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:21:24 AM
Or scrap it and bring back fucking Journeyman.
first off: Damn you Pennsy!
by just pillow talk
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:25:45 AM
I didn't realize you were a Phillies fan. Damn you.

And this is too little, too late.

NO-- the long halloween is third rate rip-off
by Laserhead
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:30:30 AM
of "Presumed Innocent" and "The Godfather". That's called hack writing.
Guess the sarcasm in my post wasnt obvious enough
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:33:00 AM
Fuck that "reboot
by Mr Spork
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:33:56 AM
Fuck that "reboot" shit.
by Mr Spork
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:35:41 AM
It's not the answer for everything.
I was sarcastic
by theycallmemrglass
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:45:41 AM
heroes was rebooting every fucking season anyway
by theycallmemrglass
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:49:06 AM
That "Company Man" episode...
by theycallmemrglass
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:53:57 AM
Was written by a Bryan Fuller (according IMDB) and only did 2 episodes all in the first season. I think everyone agrees that episode was an absolute stand-out.
This Bryan Fuller is also Co-producer
by theycallmemrglass
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:58:04 AM
So he is always on the team but as co producer.
50-75 Comments...
by Aquatarkusman
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:14:59 AM
... and no mention of their invaluable work on the multiple Oscar-winning "Teen Wolf Too" (not the number, the word meaning 'also')? Jason Bateman's finest hour and a half? Francis from Pee-Wee's Big Adventure? JOHN FUCKING ASTIN?!?
Jeph Loeb's creative well has run dry
by DEX
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:16:01 AM
I enjoyed a number of his works - Batman - The Long Halloween and Dark Victory, Superman - For All Seasons was great, Batman/Superman - Public Enemies was entertaining.... but have you seen how he's ruined Mark Millar's The Ultimates and his silly Red Hulk storyline in the Hulk? I don't know how much he's to blame for Heroes but he hasn't written anything good for a while...
Supernatural + Bunny from The Wire
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:25:21 AM
Last week was a really good episode of Supernatural... especially when the man who started Hamsterdam on The Wire showed up as a badass! That show keeps getting better and better each season...
Glad to hear this.
by mrfan
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:28:41 AM
Maybe now it can get better.
Sorry, blindambition--
by Laserhead
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:36:38 AM
should have read closer. Apologies. Good on.
Woo-Hoo, Way to go NBC!
by _Maltheus_
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:47:07 AM
I really couldn't understand why no heads were rolling. This was once an uber-hit for NBC, who knows how much money the current producers cost the network. Yes, the new guys might be worse, but given how far the show has plummeted, I would guess that anyone else can do a better job. I'm glad to hear that NBC recognized the core of the problem, instead of merely trying to tweak the storyline. This is the best Hollywood news I've heard in a year.
Maybe the show will get better sans hack Loeb
by chien_sale
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:53:29 AM
we need guys that have more imagination
The poster "Orange Cinema" is right on the money
by chien_sale
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:59:09 AM
Heroes is in deep shit because they had a great idea but killed it in one season thinking they would have other great ones. Wrong.
Remember this early comment from Kring?
by ArcadianDS
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:14:05 AM
I recall Kring saying very very early on, that the plan for the show was that some heroes would come and go and that the cast would constantly revolve. I think the problem with some of the characters is that they were never designed to stay resident. They were designed to be one season toss offs that, for whatever reason, wound up being brought back for seasons 2 and 3.

I think the show needs to ditch Peter and the cheerleader, and should give Hiro a season hiatus.

Thinking about it more, I suppose the reason for this is that all, and I do mean all, of the new heroes we found early in season 2 were bad - really bad. So instead of them migrating into the spotlight, they were quickly buried alive in the sand.

Great news, now bring in Warren Ellis!
by SpyGuy
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:25:42 AM
Jeph, you haven't written a damn thing I've liked since DAREDEVIL: YELLOW and Stan Lee originally wrote the bulk of it. Please start writing for TWO AND A HALF MEN so we can finally bury that show instead.
Supernatural shits on Heroes from a great height.
by Cameron1
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:52:30 AM
Supernatural convert right here. Hated the first few eps of season 1 then caught some of season 3 a while back and loved it After that I bought the season 2 and 3 dvd's. The whole going to hell arc was fantastic even if it was butchered due to the writer's strike. It has really fun schlocky writing that can also do pathos and sometimes be genuinely scary, Jensen Ackles seems to be hugely underrated by everyone but fangirls who think he's hot - he does some brilliantly layered acting he reminds me a little of Alexis Denisof in the last 2 Angel seasons. And yeh Bunny fucking Colvin showed up last week as an Angel wanting to rain sulphur on a small town, pretty fucken cool.
A Cluster Foxtrot
by Roboteer
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:08:02 AM
It took skill to royally screw this up so bad. This season's opening was like an English 102 exercize done badly. We don't have any ideas, so let's totally insult our audience by making all the characters direct opposites to what we wrote before. Yeah, THAT's the ticket. They bring back the tough chick, slightly pyscho Elle (Kristen Bell), only to make her a powerless wimpering girrl. I don't see everything, but two shows that are soooo much better than this are Terminator, the series and CHUCK. The later already had heart and now that Terminator stopped treating its human heroes as cyborgs, it has presented some of the best stuff going on TV the last 3 episodes.... PS: Does everything have to be on Monday night?
Yes, use the "It was all a dream," angle to reboot...
by Leafar the Lost
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:09:41 AM
...Heroes. I remember when "Dallas" used it to wipe out an entire season by saying that it was all a dream. Start next season by having the Cheerleader wake up and realize that season 3 was just a bad dream.
"Zombie + Ghost orgy? THAT'S IT, I'M TORCHING EVERYONE"
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:18:36 AM
Supernatural genuine gross out moment: The guy who was coughing up razorblades... disturbing as hell!!! And you gotta love the kid that got pulled into the crypt by the zombie last week, followed by the huge explosion of blood gushing from the hole in the wall. This show pulls hardly any punches, has great writing, an awesome cast, is able to blend standalone plots with an overarching storyline each year, and yet it's virtually ignored.

People really need to start watching this show...

meh. reboot is easy when you have TIME TRAVELLING MORONS
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:25:11 AM
No need for "it was all a dream". Papa Petrelli is cool and all, but at this point he is basically a god with all the powers he should have. Does he even know about all the crap he absorbed from Peter? I don't see how anyone can take him down, aside from going back in time and cutting his head off, or having the Hatian come in and fuck him up.
Patrick Duffy in the shower
by ThrowMeTheIdol
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:25:23 AM
It was all a dream, Claire. You're still in mid-season 1 when the show was fun.
Wow.
by phool2056
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:40:28 AM
This doesn't strike me as them getting the boot so much as rats sinking an abandoning ship. Also, all those comics you mentiones are not Loeb's best. His cool stuff is way better represented by The Long Halloween and Hush. Not to be a comic book dick, but it's a bit of a mischaracterization of the guy to talk about his sentimental mediocre Marvel stuff rather than his actually groundbreaking and awesome Batman work.
Don't even get me started on Hush...
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:47:48 AM
The less said the better...
Great, now axe the show
by performingmonkey
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:55:59 AM
Give it a great big boot up the ass and send it flying. Shows like Heroes will damage TV for years if people don't show their disdain. We'll get even worse copycat shows, cheaper but with the same bullshit dialogue and just a reliance on the fact that some girls who watch are in love with Peter Petrelli.
Wait, Loeb sucks now?
by MattmanReturns
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:08:48 AM
Another talkbacker memo I missed. So let me get this straight... Long Halloween, Dark Victory, and Hush sucked?

by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:11:47 AM
Long Halloween and Hush were terrible. Long Halloween's ok, but unbelievably overrated.
Oops. Meant to say
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:32:26 AM
Dark Victory and Hush were terrible...Long Halloween is alright if you can ignore the fact that the plot makes no sense.
It made sense to me
by MattmanReturns
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:35:57 AM
What didn't make sense to you?
One thing they could do
by ChocolateJesus
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:43:44 AM
Is make at least ONE character that I like to watch. Every single character is boring, stupid, and unlikeable to the point that I really don't care what happens, no matter how exciting the events may be. Even the characters I liked in the first season (Bennett, for example), I'm fucking sick of. The only character I like right now is Arthur Patrelli, and that's only because Robert Forster is cool in anything.
Just started watching Supernatural, season 1.
by V'Shael
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:46:42 AM
Mostly because of all the talkbackers who were CONSTANTLY singing its praises.

I'm about up to 1x18 by now, and it's okay. It's not great or anything, but it's very watchable. Neither as good as Heroes season 1 (in the early days) was, but definitely not crap. And by some accounts, it gets a lot better as the seasons go on, unlike Heroes and BSG which got shittier and shittier.

Off topic, but I saw a funny comment on slashdot earlier about BSG. "[i]ts like an old dying dog you have, and you just can't bear to put him down"

Maybe NBC could bring in a great TV writer like David Milch
by Orbots Commander
Nov 3rd, 2008
11:58:22 AM
...to help save Heroes. The first few seasons of NYPD Blue (up until the end of Jimmy Smitt's run), where Miltch was on, were fantastic.
MattmanReturns (spoilers, obviously)
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:20:57 PM
I listed my gripes several posts up, but they mainly have to do with the fact that the ending, and in effect the entire story leading up to that point (since this is a mystery), revolves around us having to accept that the culprits behind the series of murders which drove the story were perpetrated by the story's 2 most improbable suspects.

And when I say 'improbable' I don't mean in the traditional genre sense of "the author cleverly used red herrings and misdirection so that I couldn't see past the smoke and mirrors and arrive at the correct and logical conclusion", but improbable in that with the way the characters were written, and the story had played out before us, it is pretty much impossible that they could have done what they did, much less elude the combined efforts of the World's Greatest Detective, Gotham's finest Cop, and the city's most resourceful D.A. if not for the fact they all were eating a big box of stupid every morning that whole year.

Now cancel the show
by AlwaysThere
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:24:30 PM
And free the airwaves for other programming.
Got a feeling that the "alternate universe" plotline...
by dihay
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:26:59 PM
was mostly Loeb's idea considering some of his past comic book storylines. The "AU" ideas were one of the complaints that I had heard from various people as to why they had lost interest in the show.
Jeph Loeb has always sucked, this can only be good
by Psynapse
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:27:24 PM
Seriously, of the 5 stories I let myself get suckered into buying and reading NOT ONE made me think anything other than "I want my money back".
GOOD, NOW GET RID OF THE SHOW!
by Darth_Kaos
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:30:03 PM
This show has been OVERRATED from the get-go. People only followed this show, cause it gave them some kind of gravitas attitude and exclusivity. No one knows what's going on on that show including the NETWORK. GOOD RIDDANCE!
Meanwhile, SMALLVILLE has actually gotten better
by SpyGuy
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:30:04 PM
I know, I'm surprised by this as well, but it has. Couldn't be because Kristin Kreuk is only in five episodes this season, could it?
Where's the Election Talkback?
by CrazyGnome
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:35:07 PM
It's tomorrow. Obama is going to win. Where is the forum for us to say how much we hate Republicans? Obama says there is one America...there will be once we get rid of the Elephant heads. Don't disappoint, this forum has the best fellow anti-Republican posters.
V'Shael Re: Supernatural season 1
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:45:22 PM
You're up to 1x18... you're in for a treat with the last couple of episodes as they deal directly with the show's mythology. The season 1 finale cliffhanger will definitely have you clamoring for the beginning of season 2!
Overall I don't think Long Halloween is crap
by blindambition238
Nov 3rd, 2008
12:51:54 PM
It's just a sloppily written but entertaining 'epic', with fantastic art, and some snappy dialogue/ character interactions. I just think it's status as one of the 'definitive' or classic Batman stories is grossly undeserved.
More from Kristin dos Santos of E!
by Pennsy
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:05:25 PM
http://tinyurl.com/5lhljg

Money quotes: "Someone had to take the fall." This is what a reliable inside source on Heroes tells me of the firings of Loeb and Alexander. "NBC is not happy with the current status of the show, and there had to be a visual and tangible change in the course of action."

Also, the Entertainment Weekly cover story turned out to be basically ambush journalism that did not go over well at NBC AT ALL. And Loeb is one of the writers on 'War', the midseason finale, Kristin says.

So, I should just delete the show off the DVR
by wcme
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:18:20 PM
Like I did KNIGHT RIDER and SARA CONNER? I actually tried to watch 4 episodes of each of those, and lost consciousness. Season 2 of HEROES did little for me, and I have yet to watch any of the season 3 stuff, yet hear no end of the same yuckness. I have slews of things new to sample, like ELEVENTH HOUR, FRINGE, PUSHING DAISES and so on - and am fighting just dumping HEROES as a lost cause. hasnt been any good since just PRIOR to season 1 finale. (Seriously - 22 hours of build up for THAT?!)
What to watch then INSTEAD of Heroes?
by wcme
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:26:03 PM
SUPERNATURAL may just be the single best network show on currently. SMALLVILLE has gotten a lot better, and thats coming from a standpoint of phoning it in with utter and total illogic for 2 entire seasons.
NBC is lost
by ZoeFan
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:47:50 PM
Who they need to fire is Zucker and Immelt. Excluding their sports coverage, this network is a mess and they are main reason.
bacci40
by MattmanReturns
Nov 3rd, 2008
01:51:00 PM
Yeah, every time I check a talkback, I find out that some beloved property is actually a piece of shit, and I am stupid for liking it.
ZoeFan, what about Ben Silverman?
by Pennsy
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:08:13 PM
If anyone needs to be thrown under the bus at NBC, it's him.
Took the words...
by Johnnie Walker
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:13:24 PM
Right out of my mouth, Pennsy
by Johnnie Walker
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:16:32 PM
Silverman is the real cancer here. The guy only got his job because he scoured the earth for other shows to bring to the US, which other than The Office have totally failed. Knight Rider full season?

Check out this amazing article on him from CNN:

http://tinyurl.com/5jmjyr

This makes me laugh...
by exie
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:27:58 PM
...at all you brain dead nubes who used to come in here during season 1 of this crap to debate that it was better than Lost. Lost fans, like myself, would tell you repeatedly this series won't last and didn't have the story or characters to persevere and now in season 3 it's falling apart. Season 1 of Heroes was fun in a dumb pulpy way. Season 2 was abysmal. Season 3? I wouldn't know. I haven't watched 1 episode of it. I knew it had petered out. The only way they get me back is by giving me some full frontal Hayden nudity. Short of that, Heroes is dead in my world.
Suggestion
by NoHubris
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:30:27 PM
There are so many unproduced, unsold scripts floating around that are long on cool ideas, plot, action sequences and so forth, but are short on strong dialogue and character development. The producers should buy those scripts and bring in the pros to polish.

Consider DS9 and Star Trek: TNG. Those two shows likely lasted so long in their day because they bought pitches and stories from outside talent.

exie, i remember those days as well
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
02:49:13 PM
I don't want to turn this into Lost vs. Heroes because the two shows are very different, but I remember it was such a stupid debate. Hell, I remember the "didn't like the episode" threads on some Lost forums, namely The Fuselage, where some posters would cry about how bad Lost season 3 had gotten and heralded Heroes as the second coming, and urged people who were dissatisfied with Lost "not giving answers" to tune into the superior Heroes, which actually seemed to be "going somewhere".
People blame Kring because he's the only name we see every ep
by BurgerKing
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:24:04 PM
Kring is the only person who dares to plop his name at the beginning of every episode. So every time an episode sucks, who do people blame? The only guy they remember the name of, fuck that guy!

Really I think there are more people to blame than fucking Kring. Damnit people.

As for these writers, I don't know if it will help the series. Probably will though.

in a weird reversal of fortune.
by Mr_X
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:24:35 PM
smallville this week was actually pretty darned good. i actually mean season 1 good. well played, kal el.
NOT THE WRITER OF TEEN WOLF TOO?!?
by eoneon
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:42:07 PM
ROTFLOL!!!! OMG! sorry,but i think i threw up after laughing so hard. seriously? Teen Wolf Too! wow,no wondwr Heroes sucks. RIP Heroes. A one season wonder.....
BurgerKing RE: Kring
by Xiphos_2
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:45:19 PM
He created the show, he's the show runner and if I'm not mistaken the head writer. Everything goes through him. He should be held responsible.

Its no big surprise though, his history didn't bode well for success.

TEEN WOLF TOO
by turketron
Nov 3rd, 2008
03:46:43 PM
Yeah I laughed at that too. Hell, whenever brought up among friends, the mere mention of the TITLE of that movie causes laughter. TEEN WOLF TOO lmfao. The cinematic masterpiece, of which no other movie has matched since!
Season 1
by Unnatural
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:03:31 PM
For all you that say Season 1 was good, I think you are sniffing glue. Good? Yeah, right up until the ripped dialog right out of The Watchmen. I can't believe Kring hasn't been sued...
sigh
by vaterite
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:21:40 PM
well, Heroes certainly can't get any worse, right?
This show has been shit since Day 1, fire Kring and co.
by reflecto
Nov 3rd, 2008
04:34:29 PM
Loeb is a good start. Bring in WARREN FUCKING ELLIS for a total revamp. Carte blanche. Stop relying on Internet fandom to decide how to tell your story. "Oh, you like Sylar? OK HE WILL BE IN EVERY EPISODE AND NEVER DIE!"
DVR Deleted
by joegiant
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:01:19 PM
Maybe the producers saw that I just deleted Heroes from my DVR series list, after being a loyal viewer since ep 1. Finally realized the show was going nowhere, and going there in 5 minute increments at a time. The writers just REFUSED to follow a storyline long enough to actually establish some drama and tension. An interesting idea first season, ultimately unfulfilled. I'll be surprised if it gets another season.
Seriously, Warren Ellis?
by Amy Chasing
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:05:02 PM
I'd like to believe that man has more class and common-sense to be touching Heroes. If he was going to write for TV (and he doesn't need to because his other work is doing just fine for him) he should start his own thing, not continue on from someone else's shit.

That, and the studio execs would have no idea how to market or handle Ellis' style. Think we'll ever see Doktor Sleepless on the big or small screen? Not unless your average suit starts believing that there's even an audience out there for it.

Always wanted to see Warren Ellis write an episode
by Amy Chasing
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:07:00 PM
or even a series of Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex. Now _that_ would be a series worth watching.
For Hating Heroes so much Herc,
by jimbojones123
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:13:33 PM
You find even more tricky ways to add a talkback each week. Bless you for doing so.
Unfortunately, now Loeb will have more time for comics.
by Smerdyakov
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:15:49 PM
I loathed his Superman/Batman. Not to mention his Challengers abortion.
Hush=Overrated.
by jimbojones123
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:18:58 PM
Yeah, I said it. Crossover mess.
Right idea, WRONG WRITERS.
by flickchick85
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:30:15 PM
Well, I don't know about Loeb, but I thought Alexander was one of the strongest writers they had left. NBC, aim your sights a little higher. The problem has always be Kring himself.
The Long Halloween...
by -guyinthebackrow
Nov 3rd, 2008
05:32:10 PM
... is the best BATMAN story ever written.
i agree, smallville is actually watchable now.
by Warcraft
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:35:42 PM
as in, i can actually watch it in the backround as i play warhammer online. i absolutely love smallville's lois lane, she's beautiful, and so much better than the actress who played lois in superman returns, kate bosworth. also, i think so far, that smallville has been nailing the relationship between lois and clark. kudos to them.
oh and yeah, kristin kruek sucks.
by Warcraft
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:36:28 PM
just wanted that out there.

by tranpkp1
Nov 3rd, 2008
06:57:54 PM
This shows been incredibly disappointing since the 'epic fail' that was the Season 1 finale. Yr 2 was nearly unwatachable, while more 'interesting' this year, its full of holes. The last episode almost was the last straw...these characters are morons and EVERYTHING any character did was stupid the last ep. Its approaching smallvilles crappiest eps.nathan forgets he could fly after shuresh, claires repeatedly oblivious, elle runs gittily into building after they toss peter, daphne cant stop killing cause it 'just happened so fast', matt reads minds but cant see getting duped, peters powers of mimicky trumped by haitian and papa...wtf
one more thing, all should watch supernatural for sure.
by Warcraft
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:01:01 PM
it's a fantastic show, been watching since season 2.
Bulletin: Bryan Fuller is on the replacement list for
by Pennsy
Nov 3rd, 2008
07:47:56 PM
Loeb and Alexander, per Kristin dos Santos of E!
Jeph Loeb and Warren Ellis are both terrible
by Guy Who Got A Headache And Accidentally Saves The World
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:03:29 PM
The Long Halloween is terrible, Ellis just writes the same shit over and over. Transmetropolitan was about 70 some issues longer than it needed to be.
Did McCain just plug Hereos?
by buffywrestling
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:04:21 PM
Am I in some alternate dimension? What the fuck was that?? The stench on NBC's depseration is overpowering McCain's.
More stench from NBC: Kath & Kim; full season pickup.
by Pennsy
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:23:44 PM
http://www.thrfeed.com/2008/10 /kath-kim.html
Warren Ellis would bring badassery
by Hercules
Nov 3rd, 2008
08:26:22 PM
Read Global Frequency or The Authority or his combat-magician Gravel stuff. Or NewUniversal. Or Ocean. Or Jack Cross. Or Red.

Warren Ellis could turn Noah Bennet into a sci-fi Jack Bauer.

Grant Morrison (All-Star Superman) and Mark Millar (The Ultimates) would be incredible choices to help out as well.

But really, I say fuck "Heroes." Wait till Bryan Fuller has a spare minute and hire him to start a new superhero series. Put Ellis, Millar and Morrison in his writer's room. That's your TV show.

110% behind Unnatural's comments....
by ColloquiallyBorn
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:23:10 PM
I also saw three episodes this season, and they blew it big time..

I watched a couple of minutes out of the next couple of shows but never got back into the whole story line...

It sucked big time.

I mean when are we going to see something good like the first season where we got to learn about the characters?

For me this season just went downhill...

Firing people is never good, but for this show, it just can't get worse...

G.W.G.A.Headache And Accidentally Saves The World
by Amy Chasing
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:27:04 PM
G.W.G.A.H.A.A.S.T.W.
by Amy Chasing
Nov 3rd, 2008
09:39:33 PM
Have you read Ellis' Next Wave? Not like his other stuff. Also Doktor Sleepless has some serious panache going on. Saying he writes the same shit over and over is like saying Debussy always sounds the same. Doesn't stop him from being brilliant.
Pennsy
by Ribbons
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:15:25 PM
Damn, that's kind of fucked up, considering "Pushing Daisies" hasn't even been cancelled (although it sadly probably will be soon). How is Bryan Fuller supposed to take the news that NBC is hoping his baby gets the axe so they can absorb him back into the fold?
hey man, the recyling needs to stop
by The cunning linguist
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:24:27 PM
we've all read X-men comics...come on now. Originality is whats called for...no more recycled Xmen plots. Do these guys justice.
Ribbons
by Xiphos_2
Nov 3rd, 2008
10:24:29 PM
I would wager that Bryan Fuller is relieved that he has a paying gig waiting for him when Pushing Daisies gets canned.
Remember when Heroes fans were laughing at 24?
by Cotton McKnight
Nov 4th, 2008
12:55:08 AM
They were apparently beating 24 in the ratings or at least giving them a good run. NEVER underestimate the power of Jack Bauer, bitches. He just laid low until you guys imploded on your own. Look for him to put it out of its misery in January. And this time you will STAY dead!
Xiphos
by Ribbons
Nov 4th, 2008
01:01:46 AM
Fuller would probably be talented enough to get a "paycheck" regardless of what happens; I just meant the fact that NBC is openly broadcasting the fact that they hope his show is cancelled.
Question for Herc: Heroes' failure - writing or fx?
by HappyHamster
Nov 4th, 2008
01:03:47 AM
You can argue writing of course, which is definitely mediocre at best. But I still say if they went overboard with the special fx, we'd all forget about the mediocre plotline.
Hey, it works for Michael Bay.
by Amy Chasing
Nov 4th, 2008
01:54:36 AM
fx that is.
Kring Intends to "Simplify"
by _Maltheus_
Nov 4th, 2008
01:11:22 PM

from scfi wire:

"Kring has reportedly assured NBC and Universal Media Studios, which produces the series, that he intends to focus on simplifying what's been criticized, even by ardent fans, as an overly complex storytelling structure to get back to the show's comic-bookish good-vs.-evil themes and to emphasize character development more than plot twists."

Character development sounds good in theory, let's see if he pulls it off. Although I hope that simplify doesn't mean stupidfy.

Heroes to focus on character development and comic-book-ish-ness
by Amy Chasing
Nov 4th, 2008
04:29:35 PM
What could possibly go wrong?
Here's hoping Marvel follows Universal/NBC's example regarding L
by faelon
Nov 4th, 2008
05:01:01 PM
Yeah, The Long Halloween was a wonderfully crafted story, and he has had a few decent ones since. But everything he has touched in the past few years has turned to feces. And no it's not just fanboy bitching. Read Ultimates 3. It is awful on almost every level. It's like some weird deviant sexual fan fiction. One of the more telling examples of how bad his writing is is the just released Ultimate Captain America Annual. Some preview pages were released just showing the art, without any dialogue yet. They were fantastic, and were in and of themselves telling a great story silently. Then they added Loabs words, and they turned to garbage. Once you read and see what he did to Ultimates with Ultimates 3, it is easy to recognize almost the exact same patern of character abuse going on in Heroes. He may have once been a decent writer. But apparently his muse died years ago. he probably strangled it in some weird incestuous psycho-robo-sexual fantasy play.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.