Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

Love James Stewart
by mrfan
Aug 2nd, 2008
04:32:18 AM
Thanks Quint
by Bloo
Aug 2nd, 2008
06:24:09 AM
I know you probably feel this was halfassed but dude you've done how many days now, I lose count, I think most of us expectedthis to go the way of One Thing I love Today or something where it would fade away pop up once or twice and fade away, glad you kept it up even during the heavy comiccon week and now your own personal heavy week, good work, keep it up

As for Spirit of St. Louis, yeah Stewart was too old, it has a bunch of filler and it's still an amazing movie, can't go wrong

Apparently Lindberg hated Jews.
by rbatty024
Aug 2nd, 2008
07:20:08 AM
I used to really like the history of aviation when I was younger and even watched this movie long before I had the attention span for it. I was disappointed to learn that Lindberg was an unapologetic anti-Semite. It's a shame when a supposed American hero turns out to be just an everyday asshole.
Quint, you've never seen the Spirit of St. Louis?
by jae683
Aug 2nd, 2008
09:31:08 AM
Really?! Man, you do need some catching up to do.
Stewart's Weird Screech
by Dave Bowman
Aug 2nd, 2008
09:56:50 AM
Whenever Lindy tries to call to someone from his plane, he emits this dire, high-pitched wail that goes on and on. The poor people on the ground must have thought a Nazgul was after them.
Lindbergh REALLY hated Jews
by JackRabbitSlim
Aug 2nd, 2008
10:03:53 AM
There were a couple of speeches that came to light fairly recently that depicted what a racist piece of offal he was.
Just Do It, Q-man,
by Napoleon Park
Aug 2nd, 2008
10:58:31 AM
Now I like writers who put their personalities and a little autobiography into their writing.

On the other hand, to cite an irrelevant example, during the final year or so of james Dean Smith's brilliant failed comic Boris the Bear, his text pieces were all these one note rants on how he wans't making enough money on the comic to print t-shirts, buy ads, or, eventually, even keep publishing the book. Never heard from him again and a great talent was lost, but that's not the point.

AMAD is a great series - I read it ever day - or sometimes catch up on two or three at once, but never miss it either way. If you're under the weather, strapped for time, have a headache, whatever. Just give us what you got. Even if it's a couple paragraphs dashed off.

I hope this message isn't too contradictory. Autobio is good. Tell us about how you related to the movie, how it fit into your life, how it affected you personally and why. fine. But writing about the actual process of writing the reviews... a bit less interesting. We get it, it's a huge commitment and something of an occasion ordeal to keep up with. I worked in a comics shop for eight years and even your dream job gets to be a bit of a bore eventually.

Even stuff like "this movie derserves a more in depth review but I'm falling asleep" is okay... just not day after day, okay? I hope that was diplomatic enough and taken in the spirit of constructive criticism it was meant as.

Billy Wilder's parents were killed at Aushwitz
by Tacom
Aug 2nd, 2008
12:06:06 PM
And he was able look past any of Lindbergh's political leanings to make a movie about him because he did something none of you guys would have the stones to do.

by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Aug 2nd, 2008
01:38:10 PM
A really good little seen Stewart movie is
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Aug 2nd, 2008
01:41:32 PM
Carbine Williams. It's about a guy sent to prison after allegedy shooting a government agent when moonshing operating came under attack. I don't think they did ballistics back then. Anyway, guns are a hobby of his, and he ends up making a gun in prison not to escape, but just for ha has. When the warden finds out he's actually given permission to continue. He ends up making a weapon used by the US military, and is eventually paroled. I'm looking forward to the Von Ryan's Express review. I liked that movie even though I don't like Sinatra.
And Stewart didn't need giant robots or
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Aug 2nd, 2008
01:42:33 PM
Michael Bay's things that go boom. Keep up AMAD Quint, but take it easy on yourself.
VON RYAN'S EXPRESS!
by palimpsest
Aug 2nd, 2008
03:53:39 PM
Man, I loved that movie when I was a kid. The kinda war movie that seemed to be ron perpetual Sunday afternoon showings in the UK. Not seen it for a loooong time. And SPIRIT OF ST LOUIS is great straightforward hero-worship cinema, from a time when people were allowed to have heroes amd ideals.
TomBodet, I got it, Carbine Williams' gun
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Aug 2nd, 2008
06:20:31 PM
comes in contact with the allspark and becomes the new Megatron.
"Lindberg"?!
by BurnHollywood
Aug 2nd, 2008
10:57:30 PM
It's "Lindbergh" who flew the Spirit Of St. Louis...Charles LindBERG was the enterprising Brooklyn Deli proprietor who invented the Everything Bagel. What else could he do? Mrs. Lepkowitz kept holding up the line trying to make up her mind between poppy and sesame seeds.

You know it's true 'cause you read it on the internet!

Harry Comments!
by karlchilders2000
Aug 2nd, 2008
11:27:39 PM
HeadGeek, you may not be able to hold your tongue at a half-written deadline driven piece, but some of us have held our breaths for scattershot "regular" columns that never materialized from other contributors here. Good on Quint for having posted, period. "Harry's DVD Picks" could take note.
Harry's comments...
by My friends call me Killjoy
Aug 3rd, 2008
12:50:15 AM
Should be in a black box, and not within the article. I love the passion on the page, but it doesn't belong in Quint's AMAD, it belongs down here with the rest of us who respond to his opinions. We value your views, Big Guy, but if I were Quint, I'd be a bit put off.
And for Quint...
by My friends call me Killjoy
Aug 3rd, 2008
12:51:41 AM
Congrats, man! You seem like one of the good guys. Best of luck with the flick.
Not the real Charles Lindbergh! Brilliant cinema!
by heathencomics
Aug 3rd, 2008
02:15:07 AM
I love this picture. And you know what? It's a fantasy. It's not a document of the life of Lindbergh. It's a movie movie! Wilder crafts wonderful nuanced characters and moments but the idea that this in any way represents the real man is absurd. This is a movie that I return to again and again. I love the world of it. I agree with Harry about the magic of early aviation as portrayed in the movie. I'm a sucker for it. I'm a huge Stewart fan. I'm a huge Wilder fan. Though he's not usually thought of as a visual director, the Roosevelt Field lift off sequence is filled with suspense and elation. Every shot is perfectly chosen. It gives Spielberg in his prime a run for his money. The ECU of Stewart's eyes is hardcore. It's great moviemaking but you can't conflate movies with real life. It's all fake! Gabriel Hardman
You miss the point quite spectacularly, Memories-Of-Murder
by palimpsest
Aug 3rd, 2008
02:40:22 AM
Well done.
Read this, and It'll help
by palimpsest
Aug 3rd, 2008
02:42:47 AM
http://www.sheilaomalley.com/ archives/003291.html
Stop trying to steal Quint's thunder, Harry.
by Knuckleduster
Aug 3rd, 2008
09:15:46 AM
Start your own fuckin column.
Bacci
by JimBobCooter
Aug 3rd, 2008
10:58:04 AM
No need to insult Wilder. Now HE is a true American hero. An immigrant who fled his country for the US, became a citizen, and subsequently revolutionized his industry, making movies and Hollywood (and noir and comedy genres) infinitely better.
M-O-M
by JimBobCooter
Aug 3rd, 2008
11:07:05 AM
I agree with your point to a point. I hated "The Patriot" for the very reasons you bring up.

Do you think you are ever allowed to have a biopic stand for something greater than the man or woman? For an act to be a symbol for a larger story?

It's an interesting problem, and something writers have always struggled with. Now, white-washing a Nazi sympathizer is more clear cut as offensive, obviously. But is there a point where you can just tell a story without delving into facts that are irrelevant to the story -- which is the trans-Atlantic flight and the bravery it took to fly it?

Case in point
by JimBobCooter
Aug 3rd, 2008
11:10:33 AM
"Amadeus" - great movie. Historically inaccurate. Should it be burned in effigy as propaganda and lies?
An innocent man was not executed for the kidnapping
by Chewtoy
Aug 3rd, 2008
11:26:33 AM
I've never been one for conspiracy theories, and the idea that an innocent man was executed for the Lindbergh kidnapping is definitely up there. Yes, media involvement made the case a mess (hell, reporters posed as connected criminals offering to serve as intermediaries for Lindbergh, and subsequently got their hands on and published the ransom notes... including the identifying marks that were supposed to allow Lindbergh to tell a real kidnapper's note from a fake.) There are conflicting eyewitness reports about most anything that you can question... Was Bruno Hauptmann at work or not the days in question?... that kind of thing. But all of the hard evidence points to him, and still does upon forensic reexamination today. The homemade ladder found under the child's bedroom window was made from the wood of Hauptmann's attic floorboards. He had $15,000 of the traceable ransom money hidden under his garage, and was found after passing some to a gas station attendant, who thought Hauptmann was acting suspiciously (the attendant suspected the money might be counterfeit) and so wrote his license plate number on the bill. A ton of handwriting experts, then and now, say he's the one who wrote the ransom notes. He had the address of Lindbergh's contact for the ransom delivery written in his closet (which he admitted to writing down himself because he was following the case.) And he had a history that included burglarizing homes and armed robbery. Oh, sure... if he were rich enough he could have gotten a lawyer to point to all of the interference from the press and pressure on the police and created some reasonable doubt just like O.J. did... but without a *very* sympathetic jury, he would still have been convicted today.
Two AMAD in the top ten
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Aug 3rd, 2008
12:53:55 PM
Plus Black Hole was top a couple weeks ago. This just goes to show we love the classics along with the Bayified movies of today
Spirit Rocks
by Nerves69
Aug 3rd, 2008
12:54:14 PM
This movie is an inspiration to those who push the borders of " what's possible". People like Roz Savage, trying to cross the Pacific. Also, for more on classic flicks, check out my brother's blog WWW.CINEMAFIST.COM. Thanks!
A total Whitewash...but a great film...
by Bones
Aug 3rd, 2008
12:54:49 PM
This is one of those great, old-time HOllywwod biographical films that basically invents the character of a real person in order to make it a good movie.

But it works...and is yet another triumph for Billy Wilder. Jimmy Stewart is great as always, playing the fictional Charles Lindbergh, as opposed to the Aryan Moron "REAL" Lindbergh, who like many people, bought into the whole idea of Eugenics and that there were higher and lower physical classes of people. From what I hear, his little trip accross the atlantic was supposed to be a superiority trip, to be used all around the world to show what a WASP can do, as opposed to what he no doubt considered "mongrel" races.

Who knows what kind of man he might have been in a world with Genetics, Ancestral Mapping and the Human Genome project...he might have understood that all people are descended from a common ancestor and that that origin point was most probably Africa...or it is possible he would have remained as in-the-dark as a lot of people today, using their hate and ignorance as shields so they don't have to think for themselves or change their traditions of violence and fear.

Still, it is a great movie.

Bones and Memories-Of-Murder
by heathencomics
Aug 3rd, 2008
01:15:37 PM
Well said Bones. More articulately than I could have put it. M-O-M: I'm not disagreeing with you about the real Lindbergh. He most likely was a nazi fuck head. That just doesn't change the fact that "Spirit" is a very entertaining, well crafted movie. I'm not going to pretend that its not just because real man it's based on had disgusting personal views. - Gabriel Hardman
Spreading disinformation as usual,
by LewisWetzel
Aug 4th, 2008
01:35:28 AM
aren't you, M-of-M? Lindbergh was given a pass, huh? As a response to Lindbergh's isolationist activism, Roosevelt had the FBI investigate his personal life. When Lindbergh tried to reactivate his commission in the Army Air Force after Pearl Harbor, the Roosevelt administration blocked him. He had to shop himself around to the aircraft companies as a civilian consultant, and was eventually able to take part in combat missions in the Pacific. It seems to me that risking one's life in the fight against the Axis is a pretty good indicator of where one's loyalties lie, and is a pretty good argument against charges of "treason." And as far as poor innocent Oppenheimer being victimized for being "sympathetic to socialist ideals," he was probably a member of the Communist Party USA for a while in the 30's; at least, he attended cell meetings where every other participant was a party member. If so, he was part of an organization that was taking orders from Stalin; Oppenheimer, and every other CPUSA member, was more closely aligned with that particular murderous totalitarian ideology than Lindbergh was with Nazism. Who's the hypocrite, M-of-M?
what would jimmy stewart know about fly?
by chipps
Aug 4th, 2008
06:36:27 AM
huh? Just kidding. you know, you're all right. Everyone, let give it up for that guy.
America's Favorite Nazi Sympatico: Charles Lindburgh
by ArcadianDS
Aug 4th, 2008
10:35:02 AM
oh and In Ernest Goes to Camp, he confessed to stealing the Lindburgh baby. Case Closed.
I stole the lindbergh baby
by chipps
Aug 4th, 2008
04:14:42 PM
then I shot J.R
Where exactly did I apologize for
by LewisWetzel
Aug 4th, 2008
07:25:06 PM
Nazism? Where I praised Lindbergh for joining the fight against the Axis, perhaps? Or perhaps you mean Nazi in the good old '40s Popular Front sense of "not a Communist." If so, I'm guilty as charged. As for persecuting "socialists or syndicalists," plenty of socialists, union types, and other members of the non-Communist left cheerfully and of their own free will testified AGAINST the Communists during the House UnAmerican Activities Committee hearings. They remembered how the Communists had tried to subvert their organizations, and knew what we were up against better than most. The Communists called Roosevelt a warmongering fascist all during the period of the Nazi-Soviet Pact - just as they were told to do. They only changed their tune when their country was attacked - and I'm talking about Operation Barbarossa, not Pearl Harbor. Compared to this, how exactly was Lindbergh a traitor? Let me repeat this, since you clearly have reading comprehension problems: after his country (the United States, in his case) was attacked, Lindbergh made every effort to join the war effort and finally succeeded in serving on active duty. Before the war, there's no evidence he did Hitler's bidding in the same way that CPUSA members, as a matter of course, did Stalin's. So once again: you would convict Lindbergh of treason...why? As usual, freedom in a radical leftie's version of a "true democracy" would not extend to people you disagree with. Whether or not I've shown my true colors, you've shown yours, "mate." Say hello to Stalin and Mao when you see them.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.