Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

Yikes!
by fishpillow
Jul 14th, 2008
02:39:53 PM
The pilot sucked! I hope they fix it up before it airs.
This is bad news...
by andtheflesh
Jul 14th, 2008
02:41:34 PM
Abrams having his mitts all over the show is an awful plan. He's an idea guy, not a great writer or director. Additionally, making the show more episodic and with less story threading is a terrible idea. The pilot was decent but this new info is quickly lessening my anticipation.
3rd?
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
02:43:15 PM
wwoooooootttt
LOST
by Thunderbolt Ross
Jul 14th, 2008
02:44:24 PM
Whatever happened with Lost, it worked out really well. Maybe he should abandon this show too.
"A Show with Geniuses Solving Problems"
by Squashua
Jul 14th, 2008
02:44:42 PM
So, Fringe is Monk with Blood?
"not a great writer or director."
by Hercules
Jul 14th, 2008
02:46:03 PM
so I gather you didn't enjoy the universally acclaimed "Alias" and "Lost" pilots?

by andtheflesh
Jul 14th, 2008
02:46:34 PM
Fringe appears to be the X-Files with more production value and less aliens. They keep trying to distance the show from that description but I've watched the pilot, that's what the show is no matter how much they deny it.
Dy-No-MITE!!!
by holyguacamole
Jul 14th, 2008
02:47:58 PM
I love J.J.
Fix it like this
by Diagnostic
Jul 14th, 2008
02:48:16 PM
Have a hot FBI agent solve
mysteries with the www.GreatGlam.com girls.
fringe=X Files + House
by j2talk
Jul 14th, 2008
02:49:14 PM
Herc
by andtheflesh
Jul 14th, 2008
02:49:54 PM
I was not a big fan of Alias, no. As for Lost, the pilot was great but not for it's writing. The dialogue in that episode is not of the same caliber as the show went on. Now maybe that's not Abrams fault, could be the actors were still settling into their characters, but I would argue that the plot layout and the idea behind the pilot was better than the actual writing of it. Seriously, go back and watch the pilot again, it's amateurish (flame on) compared to even the end of that season.
I only watched Alias and Lost...
by CrazyGnome
Jul 14th, 2008
02:54:04 PM
because the story was epic and was built episode by episode. The new X-files movie will fail. Why? Because we want to know about the freaking aliens. Not a random thriller mystery. Hell, he has created enough great stuff, how can I not give the series a real shot. I owe JJ more then that for all the great entertainment.
Leaked episode...
by viranth
Jul 14th, 2008
02:56:02 PM
is not going to be the same that's aired this fall? I bet you my soul that it'll be the exact same episode that's aired. Might be minute changes, but it will not make any difference. The show has TONS of potentional, but episodic content isn't very good for this show.
The pilot has me interested in watching more
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
03:09:56 PM
The lead actress is hawt... the story has potential, but... it's on FOX.... so who knows what's going to happen
he didn't say which night stalker
by RaveX
Jul 14th, 2008
03:12:32 PM
and for his own sake, I hope it because it goes without saying...
People get so hung up...
by aversiontherapy2
Jul 14th, 2008
03:14:54 PM
on comparisons. This ISN'T the X-Files, sure there are things in common but there are things in common with a ton of other shows as well. I liked the Fringe pilot and I think it can easily stand on its own without all these cheap and easy, but fallacious comparisons.
"I hope IT'S because it goes"
by RaveX
Jul 14th, 2008
03:15:49 PM
WTB edit button.
Inspired by The Night Stalker... just like Chris Carter!
by tonagan
Jul 14th, 2008
03:33:07 PM
"But really, it's not like the X-Files at all. Now let me tell you about my show. Her boss is named Skiller, and she gets help from a trio of goofy characters called the Grassy Knoll Gang..."
It can't be the same version, viranth
by GregoryHarbin
Jul 14th, 2008
03:52:13 PM
It wasn't the right length. Fringe is going to be fifty minutes per episode, and the leaked episode was around 83 minutes. Either they're going to cut 33 minutes (not crazy, it was a little slow), or they need to add another 15 or so. But bottom line, I assumed when I watched it that it wasn't final, just based on the length.
The teaser commercial has me intrigued
by skimn
Jul 14th, 2008
03:57:31 PM
even moreso than the X Files movie. My only concern is Joshua Jackson. Even though I've never seen one episode, I can't think of anything but Dawson's Creek when I see him.
Of Course they leaked the Pilot
by SamBlackChvrch21
Jul 14th, 2008
04:09:47 PM
Same thing with Heroes a few years back. They leake it on purpose and gauge response from the truly dedicated viewers, which mainly comprise these boards and forums.
GregoryHarbin
by viranth
Jul 14th, 2008
04:12:11 PM
Interesting, didn't notice it was 83 minutes, but I agree, they should have no problems cutting it down, making it a bit more fast paced. If anything, it could become even better.
you guys are fucking morans sometimes
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
04:18:25 PM
it was 83 minutes because it will be a 2 hour pilot... just add commercials
Abrams is the most overrated guy working today.
by Holeman
Jul 14th, 2008
04:19:56 PM
They pull LOST out of their ass on a weekly basis and have no fucking idea where it's going or how to get there and as a result, I'm not surprised it feels fucked up and boring as it does. "Alias" was among the convoluted bullshit ever to air on TV. I saw the pilot for "Fringe" and it looks like more of the same shit.
RokurGepta
by Inglorious Bastard
Jul 14th, 2008
04:24:34 PM
Fringe, along with Dollhouse, is airing with limited commercial interruption, as was highly publicized already. 37 minutes of commercials in 2 hours isn't limited. In comparison, Lost, which has waaaay too many commercials, clocks in at around 10-15 minutes of ads. Therefore the finished episode must be either shorter or longer.
Great Glam is blowing it's ad budget.
by Quin the Eskimo
Jul 14th, 2008
04:28:08 PM
Unless this transitioned into a tranny board when I wasn't looking.
ok with limited commercial interruption....
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
04:28:29 PM
lemme think hey look a 90 minute pilot.... 83 minutes of show, with 7 minutes of commercials, seems like very limited commercial interruption to me...
now from what I understand, the leaked pilot isn't the final product that is going to eventually be the pilot that airs on tv, but i can see them cutting 20+ minutes out of what we've already seen, so unless they add more footage, i'm going with a 90 minute pilot....
Holeman
by MetiphisLabs
Jul 14th, 2008
04:28:31 PM
Please go back to whatever planet you came from.
So is Abrams taking our advice from these Talkbacks?
by Jim Jam Bongs
Jul 14th, 2008
04:37:52 PM
My honest constructive criticism: The pilot doesn't need to be two hours (82 minutes). JJ, edit the whole thing down to 41 minutes -- you know you can do it, because the actual plot is 41 minutes stretched out. There are several scenes which could be cut out completely, and character backstory (especially the lead FBI agent's) which should be held off and would be better revealed in future episodes. You can put this deleted stuff as bonus features on the Season 1 DVD box set.

Fringe already has potential problems (not retaining a significant potential female viewership, being the primary one). But, really, the biggest one is that the pilot should not be two episode hours long.

But i like the insane, absolute dedication
by newc0253
Jul 14th, 2008
04:41:32 PM
Alias was only worth watching when it demanded that kind of attention. It began to suck when it lost that from season 4 onwards.
"Limited" commercial interruptions doesn't mean "less" commercia
by Jim Jam Bongs
Jul 14th, 2008
04:45:16 PM
It means, literally, fewer breaks for a commercial. But the number of commercials (the total running time of them) could be the same -- just that there are fewer breaks to a commercial. The Fringe pilot (the not for air, given out to industry people version) is 83 minutes long. That is the standard runtime now for 2 hours of programming on network television.
Holeman
by billypilgrimisunstuck
Jul 14th, 2008
04:55:34 PM
Constructive criticism please. You're just bitching.
Nuked the Fringe.
by mrfan
Jul 14th, 2008
05:21:15 PM
Whoops. My bad.

It really doesn't look that bad. Probably give it a few episodes to see if I will continue to watch.

Lacked the originality and ambition of the Lost pilot..
by brolly
Jul 14th, 2008
05:34:23 PM
There wasn't one new idea in the pilot of this show, felt like an empty mishmash of other shows with to flaw to the script of storyline. It felt a lot like that pilot a couple of years ago, THRESHOLD I think it was, 'cept that had more gore and a sarcastic midget in it. This has nothing.
"Deeply Involved" placates FOX
by G100
Jul 14th, 2008
05:37:24 PM
After all it's not like FOX have a reputation for cancelling shows or anything...

No doubt he is doing all he can to ensure this gets a full season run and beyond. Retooling the Pilot would seem to indicate this too.

There's easily room for a show like this and he seems to want to make it far less arc based so it may be interesting indeed to see how it turns out episode by episode.

threshold
by Dradis Contact
Jul 14th, 2008
05:37:28 PM
Didn't that also have Carla Gugino in it?
John Noble and Lance Reddick are all Win
by G100
Jul 14th, 2008
05:43:14 PM
Can't underestimate that part of the show either.
Not the version...
by the_patriot
Jul 14th, 2008
05:47:12 PM
"Abrams said the version that was leaked online is not the version to be broadcast this fall..." YEAH, RIGHT. We're gonna make changes! Seriously! Make sure you actually watch it with all the commercials and all the other bullshiat because we didn't mean to leak it so early and have our entire audience see the damned thing already. PLEEEEEEEEEEASE! (ahem) After watching this pilot, I'm not so much interested in what they do or don't change with the pilot - I'm more interested to see the 3rd or 4th episode - and see what kind of budget/production value/storyline they create past the premise. While it was an entertaining show, it's hardly original - here's hoping they do something that IS original with it...outside of the floating interstitial titles...
Nuked the Fringe...
by br1947
Jul 14th, 2008
05:50:01 PM
Someone had to say it. Besides, Fox + sci-fi? We know where this story is going.
JJ is a deceitful liar.
by V'Shael
Jul 14th, 2008
05:54:16 PM
When some paymaster waves a giant wad of cash in front of his face, he will hightail it out of there like he's just remembered that Jennifer Garner is still naked in his basement.
Fox is heading back to genre TV from reality crap
by Yeti
Jul 14th, 2008
06:01:10 PM
TSCC, Fringe, and Dollhouse are all good signs. Have some faith people.

Constructive critisism my ass. What's wrong sweetie? Bitter cause your script for a pilot you've been shopping around since graduation in the mid 90's still isn't getting any nibbles?

JJ
by snowpuff
Jul 14th, 2008
06:02:19 PM
Why are you shooting yourself in the foot? If this show lasts more than a couple of seasons... you'll be deeply involved??? While you're shooting motions pictures?

C'mon. I don't blame you for letting Alias go adrift - let's call that a learning experience. But saying you're going to be "deeply involved" on this show... I just don't know why you're committing to something that you're going to find almost impossible to fulfill...
I agree that the pilot should be cut to 1 hour
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Jul 14th, 2008
06:12:37 PM
There were industry reports where the producers boasted that the plot/act structure of the pilot was unique, because it had 4 or 5 acts instead of the 8 or 10 that a usual two-hour programming time typically uses. Well, guess what? The Transformer writer guys did a crap job of it. It IS just a one hour episode that has been doubled in running time. So many of the scenes drag, character backstories which are awkwardly shoehorned in, a number of scenes could just be dropped entirely -- even the cool 3D graphics interstitial location text feel like they run longer than they should. Fox should write off the extra money they paid for an 83 minute pilot, and accept that this can all be cut down to 41 minutes and would work far better. This new series must open with a bang, and not be a drawn-out premiere.
"Geniuses solving problems"
by photoboy
Jul 14th, 2008
06:21:12 PM
If they want to do a show about geniuses, using Kurtzmann and Orci is about the worst choice they could have made. Their scripts are more along the lines of retards solving a join-the-dots puzzle.

I'm not surprised Abrams is trying to pretend the leaked version isn't near what the final episode will be like, because the leaked version was a derivative, boring X-Files knock-off. Most of the X-Files rip-offs from the '90s were better than it. Especially Dark Skies, mainly because of Megan Ward...
Commercials: you guys must have missed all the news
by GregoryHarbin
Jul 14th, 2008
06:24:40 PM
Here's just one of many articles about the longer episodes:

http://tinyurl.com/592atr

I know you're sorry for calling me a moron, Roker.

For the record: each episode will be around 50 minutes in length. That, plus five minutes of national commercials, and five minutes of station commercials, makes an hour of TV.

'Fringe' is premiering as a two-hour premier, so the 83 minute screener will need to be expanded to 100 minutes for broadcast.

It's not that complicated.

John Noble better stay on this show
by performingmonkey
Jul 14th, 2008
06:46:09 PM
He elevated the pilot. He needs to stay and he'll be the show's lifeblood. If only Sarah Conner Chronicles had anyone with his class.
No Star Trek at ComicCon????
by Bones
Jul 14th, 2008
06:51:10 PM
What is up with that? I mean, wouldn't you think that JJ and everyone would want to promote that film to the fans? This is the only time (well, I guess Wondercon and the NYCC) that they have to promote the film before it comes out next spring.

Doesn't show a lot of confidence, does it?

GregoryHarbin
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
07:53:34 PM
83 minutes would be perfect for a 90 minute pilot... 5 minutes per hour of commercials right. only 2 extra minutes of commercials needed to fill up the 90 minutes... the math sounds about right....
Rokur
by GregoryHarbin
Jul 14th, 2008
08:06:11 PM
It's not a 90 minute pilot. It's a two hour pilot. Do I need to do a Google search to find you a link to that well-spread press release as well?
GregoryHarbin
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
08:10:34 PM
yes please
nvm
by RokurGepta
Jul 14th, 2008
08:25:26 PM
found it
They need to keep jaw-falling-off guy.
by Christopher3
Jul 14th, 2008
08:43:35 PM
I'm not watching if they ditch that scene!
After 4 months, 14 days, Kristen Bell is officially with Heroes
by Pennsy
Jul 14th, 2008
09:00:26 PM
for a third season. http://tinyurl.com/5f9vtp. It was February 27 when TV Guide reported she was still not under contract. The negotiations took over one-third of a year, but now, it's finally resolved. She'll only be on for 5 (?) episodes, but it shouldn't have taken that long for Kring and NBC/Universal to get her on board. WTF took so long, in your opinion?
Yeti, TSCC, does give some hope
by br1947
Jul 14th, 2008
09:00:28 PM
but the rest you listed have yet to air. The way I'll believe Fox at this point is somewhere around season 3.
"They pull LOST out of their ass on a weekly basis"
by Thunderbolt Ross
Jul 14th, 2008
09:05:31 PM
If this were true, I'd be pretty impressed.

Also, "nuked the fridge" is a terrible, terrible catch phrase.

I Was Deeply Involved In How Much CLOVERFIELD Sucked Ass
by LaserPants
Jul 14th, 2008
10:10:15 PM
Worst faux documentary movie EVAR! When the characters do things nobody would do in real life, when physical reality is bent out of all recognizable shape, it ceases being a believable event and takes on the aspect of unintentional comedy. Yeah, GODZILLA has all kinds of ridiculous stuff in it, but its not supposed to be really happening, whereas CLOVERFIELD begs us to stretch the suspension of disbelief to the breaking point, and then breaks it, and then theres still like 45 increasingly insipid minutes of movie left. TERRIBLE. After the first attack, which was really cool, really scary, and really well done, it steadily went down the shit slide to hell. People in the theatre I was in burst out laughing at the end. No joke! Clearly NOT the directors intention. I'd nominate it for one of the worst movies of the year, if only because it had so much promise and fucked it up so badly. Then again, it did make a mint, so clearly I do not understand the psychology of your average retarded teenager (the only people who liked it).
Bell's character Elle will be killed off...
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Jul 14th, 2008
10:13:40 PM
That's my prediction, which is admittedly a cynical one. She's been signed for 5 episodes, so I doubt her character lives beyond the fifth appearance. It would be cool if they didn't kill her off and instead came up with another (and more creative) way to put Elle on indefinite hiatus (putting her into a coma, for example).
And The Sad Thing Is It Could Have Been Good, Nay, GREAT
by LaserPants
Jul 14th, 2008
10:16:21 PM
If it was done from multiple perspectives, shifting viewpoints, from frantic news broadcasts to hand held cameras to phones to surveillance cameras and beyond; a truly post-modern giant monster epic where the event itself becomes the main character, Imagine that! Imagine if Abrams actually had the balls and brains to do such a thing? Sadly, in these troubled times, mediocrity is praised for some friggin' reason that escapes me utterly. Oh well. De-evolultion is very real apparently.
I Know A Way To Put Kristin Bell On Hiatus
by LaserPants
Jul 14th, 2008
10:20:27 PM
She suddenly is overcome with an uncontrollable nymphomaniac passion for me, LaserPants, and decides that she wants to fuck me for the duration of her hotness (I reckon she has a good 2 to 5 years left in her). And not just regular fucking, but deeply transgressive hardcore shit that would make Larry Flynt blush. So, yeah, she walls herself up in my house and just becomes my sex slave for the next 5 years.
83 minutes??? what version did you people download?
by Holodigm
Jul 14th, 2008
10:32:54 PM
i got mine off the torrents and it clocks in at 121:50. and as much as i hate to rag on JJ, it was pretty boring. the first part was pretty awesome, but once john noble showed up it turned into the same old "ooh look at the weird guy!" crap. plus dream sequences suck balls.
83 minutes = 1 minute of end credits
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Jul 14th, 2008
10:56:36 PM
People are assuming that the finalized end credits will run under 1 minute. Anyway, I just don't see how they can shoot and add more footage to this, because at 82 minutes, it's already kinda dull, which is why they should just cut it down to less than an hour.
Published on Wednesday, December 31, 1969 - 7:00pm
by couP
Jul 14th, 2008
11:40:28 PM
that's what i get for this dark knight link that's in my AICN rss feed
FUCK THIS!!! Bring back Miracles, dammit!!!
by Han Cholo
Jul 15th, 2008
01:47:56 AM
Now that Jericho is on the fringe, pun intended, they should bring back Skeet Ulrich and that hot latina chick, with Angus McFadyen to revive Miracles. That show was badass!!!
MI:3 was utter shit
by kwisatzhaderach
Jul 15th, 2008
03:13:04 AM
and a box office disappointment. So they give Abrams control of Star Trek. Yeah, way to go Paramount.
Kurtz and Orci
by kwisatzhaderach
Jul 15th, 2008
03:14:20 AM
Can anyone give me one piece of memorable dialogue these two have penned? Apart from "We must find the Allspark!" obviously.
Then I'm deeply uninterested
by gruntybear
Jul 15th, 2008
10:05:58 AM
I've had my fill of the masturbatory excess that is "Lost."
kwisatzhaderach
by Boborci
Jul 15th, 2008
01:17:34 PM
You'll see. I'll go through our scripts and find a good line before the summer is over. We'll show you!
Twilight Zone and Night Stalker...inspirations?
by brokemart
Jul 15th, 2008
04:50:23 PM
Well, if TZ and Night Stalker are shows the creators really liked, here's hoping they actually take some inspiration from them. It's good to hear Abrams say you can actually miss an episode and not be hopelessly lost when you do sit down to watch it. I'm sick of having to watch a show religiously for two years just to get familiar with the characters (Lost, Alias). Everything's getting to be like a damned soap opera. Give me a good anthology any day.
holodigm.. um...
by soup74
Jul 16th, 2008
02:01:16 AM
do you really think the version you got from the torrents is 121.50 minutes long? try opening it again..it's 1 hour, 21.5 minutes. (basically 83 minutes)
Yeah ummm... Lost and Alias were horrible?
by claytron5000
Jul 16th, 2008
01:56:09 PM
Who are these tools? I'm so fucking sick of these supposed "scifi" fandoms that basically rip anything that isn't directly spawned from some obscure graphic novel or an homage to a Romero film. Go away, get a job and enjoy life and try not to leave your jizz on the floor during The Dark Knight.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.