Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

this is my fav hitch movie.
by TooWhippy
Jul 10th, 2008
07:14:49 PM
No, four posts in a row...
by LordPorkington
Jul 10th, 2008
07:16:19 PM
Makes you a stupid cunt. You should ask kevinwillis.net what that means, he's an expert. By the way, that black & white screen-grab looks like The Munsters, if they were just a regular family.
Kiss me!
by MistaSparkle88
Jul 10th, 2008
07:26:54 PM
Kiss me in the shadow of a doubt.
Great movie
by mrfan
Jul 10th, 2008
07:43:25 PM
Love Hitchcock
Haven't read every one of these reviews but..
by Aeghast
Jul 10th, 2008
07:43:51 PM
..it's good to see how you're keeping up with it, unlike some other cool lists in other sites, that are just left alone after a couple of items.. cough cough chud cough
one of my favorites
by Carey N.
Jul 10th, 2008
07:47:43 PM
"Shadow of a Doubt" isn't necessarily my favorite Hitchcock, but it's one of my favorites. I love it as sort of the inverse of what we think of as the traditional Hitchcock picture. Instead of a falsely accused man going on the run to exotic locations, we have a killer coming home to Anytown, USA. Plus, Joseph Cotten is one of my favorite unheralded actors.
Chilling scene
by Ricky Retardo
Jul 10th, 2008
07:48:32 PM
Charles: Women keep busy in towns like this. In the cities it's different. The cities are full of women, middle-aged widows, husbands dead, husbands who've spent their lives making fortunes, working and working. And then they die and leave their money to their wives, their silly wives. And what do the wives do, these useless women? You see them in the hotels, the best hotels, every day by the thousands, drinking the money, eating the money, losing the money at bridge, playing all day and all night, smelling of money, proud of their jewelry but of nothing else, horrible, faded, fat, greedy women. Charlie: They're alive! They're human beings! Charles: Are they? Are they, Charlie? Are they human or are they fat, wheezing animals, hmm? And what happens to animals when they get too fat and too old?
Do Gremlins 2! Do it or I'll kill you myself!
by theredtoad
Jul 10th, 2008
07:50:45 PM
I can haz Gremlins 2 review?
Hitchcock made the film you wanted to see
by Nathaniel W
Jul 10th, 2008
07:58:48 PM
He made Suspicion two years earlier and it sounds pretty much like the movie you wish Shadow of a Doubt was. But yeah, I love Shadow of a Doubt. The gallows humor between Hume Cronyn and Henry Travers is wonderful and Joseph Cotten is terrific.
Suspicion
by mithrandir16
Jul 10th, 2008
08:09:40 PM
You're dead right Nathaniel W. Cary Grant's character in Suspicion was successfully ambiguous until the very end. Of course, the last 2-3 minutes suck hard enough to leave a bad taste in your mouth. Not bad enough to negate the awesomeness of the rest of the picture, but almost.
This is easily one of Hitchcock's best
by depalma25
Jul 10th, 2008
08:30:07 PM
The almost incestous relationship between Cotton and Wright is disturbing. She's more than enamored by her uncle. She's clearly attracted to him. This is, of course, one of many ways Hitchcock presented taboo subjects but doing it just subtly enough get around the Hollwyood codes. Gender bending in Psycho as being the most famous example.
i always spell "Hollywood" wrong. And i live there.
by depalma25
Jul 10th, 2008
08:32:56 PM
Or here. Hmm? Would it be "here" or "there?" Spooky.
Director's Cuts.
by fiester
Jul 10th, 2008
08:56:07 PM
I've seen theatrical releases and director's cuts of various movies, along with your special editions, unedited versions, etc. and I cannot recall more than a handful of films that are actually significantly different/better in the alternate version than they are in the theatrical release. Honestly, I usually don't even notice. Usually there's an extra scene here or there, but unless you've seen the movie multiple times you probably won't even realize that that one shot went 30 seconds longer on this version, etc.

The only really significant one I can think of off the top of my head is "Brazil" and that's only because it had two totally different endings.

Anyway...I think the whole thing is overrated. I'm not saying editing isn't important, but I just don't see much difference of any significance in these alternate versions. So if anyone can list a few movies they think are significantly different/improved, please list a few off. Thanks.

Feister
by depalma25
Jul 10th, 2008
09:09:19 PM
Kingdom of Heaven, Alien 3, Blade Runner, to name a few.
Saw Vertigo on the big screen a few years ago
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Jul 10th, 2008
09:10:17 PM
They restored the movie, and the theater is an old theater, not a multiplex. It was great. I saw the restored version of Yellow Submarine in the same theater. I love CGI as much as the next guy, but movies like this are proof you don't NEED computer imagery to make a classic.
Love this movie...
by DarthCorleone
Jul 10th, 2008
10:01:03 PM
I want to watch it with my niece one day.

Black Hole, huh? I'll have to make sure I read your take on that one.
Strangers on a Train sucks
by Rupee88
Jul 10th, 2008
10:16:57 PM
I can't remember why, but the 2nd half of it was just stupid. I'm not sure if I've seen this one or not. Hitchcock was great overall though.
Definitely my favorite of Hitchcock's
by Midnight Thud
Jul 10th, 2008
10:21:37 PM
I need to watch this again, but...
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jul 10th, 2008
10:22:33 PM
...my first viewing left me cold. I don't really know why. The performances are fine, but that classic Hitch tension and black humor are both in short supply. Decent film, but not a favorite.
'Strangers on a Train sucks'
by Negator76
Jul 10th, 2008
10:28:51 PM
.... is as common a sentence in the english language as: 'Take your mouth off my dick or else!'
Hate to be pedantic, but...
by Darkman
Jul 10th, 2008
10:30:27 PM
There's no 'p' in Tiomkin.

Otherwise, fine write-up.
I really liked it when I saw it
by CherryValance
Jul 10th, 2008
10:49:15 PM
but I'm a little fuzzy on it right now. I do remember thinking it was one of the best Hitchcock movies. Joseph Cotten was superawesome in it. My favorite Hitchcock is on your list there, Frenzy. I don't know if other people love it or hate it, but it's definitely different.
Perfect, if not for one aspect
by deathbird
Jul 10th, 2008
11:02:45 PM
That relationship between Charlie and the agent was truly wretched, among the more shoe-horned I've seen in film. Damn near torpedoes the last act.
Kingdom of Heaven
by Wed Vid Guy
Jul 11th, 2008
12:11:04 AM
I envy you that you get to experience the director's cut for the first time. There is a tremedous difference in quality. Just you wait.
you rock quint
by blonde redhead
Jul 11th, 2008
01:18:05 AM
but for a film dork i am absolutely amazed at the sheer number of films you HAVEN'T seen. i ate slept and breathed all this shit since i was about five, and i'm not saying that to be an asshat. you're a great reviewer, and i trust you--i guess you have a natural instinct for film. :)
It's Cotten, not Cotton!
by alynch3
Jul 11th, 2008
01:22:25 AM
Don't get me wrong, Quint. I love that you're doing this series, but you just spent an entire review incorrectly spelling the name of the leading actor, a fairly well-known one at that. Furthermore, your review contains three posters that spell the name correctly. Please correct this. It's driving me nuts.
give me the DVD!
by nusilver
Jul 11th, 2008
02:06:15 AM
Quint, if you don't love it, send it my way. It's my favorite Hitchcock film...well, after Rebecca.
Director's Cut of 4400 series finale
by DS9-4ever
Jul 11th, 2008
02:38:07 AM
Not a movie but a really interesting case of how editing changes everything. Almost nothing has been added or cut, just reordered and that weird music from the broadcast replaced (I remember at the time thinking it was an odd choice. They replaced it with the original theme music and the whole tone of the finale shifts - it feels more like the tone of the entire show. The broadcast version ended rather ominously, with Billy Campbell looking like a zealot, but the director's cut has that feeling of wonder and hope, with Billy Campbell leading the way, a good guy. The 4400 once again are a symbol of hope for the world, which is more fitting as that is how the show began. The new cut just fit the tone of the show better. And it is all editing and music.
Best column on AICN
by m_reporter
Jul 11th, 2008
03:46:37 AM
Kudos Quint for that.

This really makes me relive movies I saw long ago and makes me want to watch them again. And on top of that I get reviews of movies I haven't seen, but always knew I should. It makes me seek them up and give them a watch.

Also, I agree that the concept of DC's is a bit overrated, but there are true exceptions like Blade Runner and Kingdom of Heaven. The latter being a film I truly despised when I saw it in the cinemas, but also a film that completely changed my mind when I saw the DC. Now I think of it as the best modern epic, a trend started by Gladiator and ironically ended by KOH, both whom are works of the great Ridley Scott.

love shadow of a Doubt
by Sailor Rip
Jul 11th, 2008
07:41:41 AM
And yes, Uncle Charlie monologue at the dinner table is chilling.
Nice!
by Abhimanyu
Jul 11th, 2008
07:53:23 AM
I love this movie - but what I am really digging now is Quint's take on established (or not) and already-reviewed titles. I really appreciate the fact that I can read reviews of movies I may have seen many times and still enjoy the point of view of a movie lover examining them for the first time.

Small point though - can't you guys at AICN get a better spellcheker or something? It seems to be getting worse by the day - between this piece and the Hellboy reviews, I've been exasperated afew too many times. When one is reading, an error like "Tereas" or "Cotton" breaks the flow and takes you right out of it. It's a shame because it's sort of like constantly pausing and rewinding a dvd when watching a good movie for the first time. Unless you're into that kind of thing, I suppose...

Still, good work, great column and I look forward to many many more days like this.
*ahem*
by Abhimanyu
Jul 11th, 2008
07:59:36 AM
"SpellcheCker"

It's an irony mine!
agree with quint
by TerryMalloy
Jul 11th, 2008
08:02:14 AM
I would have liked to have seen more ambiguity until the end, ala Suspicion. The fact that Charlie knows her uncle is a killer and IS TRYING TO KILL HER makes me me inclined to believe she would really try to get him arrested or at least kicked out from the house. I understand she didn't want to upset her mother, but damn. She'll get over it. It also would have been nice to see the subtle hints of incest have some sort of payoff. Not in a sex scene obviously, but something. All in all though, I really enjoyed the movie, the Joe cotton monologue, and the witty murder banter
Nice one.
by Knuckleduster
Jul 11th, 2008
08:07:03 AM
That was a very mature and balanced review, Quint. Keep it coming.

I'll admit, I'm also a bit tired of the Director's Cut trend. The entire concept is being exploited simply to sell more DVD's. I can appreciate a good Director's Cut when it's obvious that a director has been treated like shit (Brazil and Blade Runner are good examples), but it's sad that such a thing as a Director's Cut has to exist in the first place. When someone asks me if I've read The Old Man And The Sea, I don't have to ask "which version are you referring to?". Granted, filmmaking is a collaborative medium, but someone should be in charge of the final creative decisions and that person should be the director.

Agree that SUSPICION covered the "ambiguous" theme
by Tacom
Jul 11th, 2008
10:36:01 AM
Anyway, my all time favorite Hitchcock movie is REAR WINDOW but this is a pretty good one too. Joseph Cotten is terrific as Uncle Charlie. And I love anything with Theresa Wright in it, Best Years of Our Lives, Pride of the Yankees, and this movie.
Where I disagree is
by elab49
Jul 11th, 2008
10:40:37 AM
that rather than humming and hahinh ourselves wondering if Uncle Charlie is the murderer we get to watch it through Charlie's eyes and I think our fears for her - because we KNOW - are heightened so there is no impact on the suspense in the film. This has been my favourite Hitchcock since before I knew it was his - North by Northwest is his most perfect but when he plumped for this one - small town America and the worm within - he knew what he was talking about.
Would you say this was a precursor to
by skimn
Jul 11th, 2008
11:17:04 AM
Blue Velvet? Except that evil came as a force from the outside instead of the inside. And upon Uncle Charlie's death, life could return to "normal".

BTW, I would say my all-time favorite Hitchcock is North By Northwest. Cary Grant is at his charming best, Eva Marie Saint is at her lovliest, James Mason made the perfect "gentleman villian". And it is one of my favorite Herrmann scores. My second favorite is perhaps Frenzy, which showed the master still had it, late in his career. But there are so many too choose from it's like a kid in a candy store.

Niece. Niece. Niece.
by epitone
Jul 11th, 2008
11:28:31 AM
Niece. Niece. Niece. Niece. N-I-E-C-E.
What up with Kingdom of Heaven Director's Cut?
by Dogmatic
Jul 11th, 2008
11:34:51 AM
Can someone tell me if it is worth buying? They dont have it to rent unfortunately. WHAT EXACTLY about it makes it so much better than the original (which I liked but ultimately found just this side of really good)??? Also, I heard that the Troy Director's Cut also changes the movie for the better quite a bit. Is that true?? If so, Why?
I agree with elab49
by Big Jim
Jul 11th, 2008
01:04:19 PM
The suspense came from knowing he's a bad man. We knew he was capable of anything we just didn't know what exactly he was going to do.

Suspicion lost me at the end. I mostly enjoyed the "is he, isn't he" aspect of the film but when the climax comes it is quite the let down. It's akin to "oops, my bad, how silly of me". Where's the payoff of thinking your husband is trying to kill you, regardless of whether or not he is? Do you just keep allowing yourself to be put in situations that could be the end of you hoping he doesn't off you?

I agree
by SuckLeTrou
Jul 11th, 2008
03:57:08 PM
with elab and Jim. The story isn't really about Uncle Charlie at all, but about little Charlie growing up and gaining some traumatic exposure to the big bad real world. Playing "is he or isn't he" with Uncle Charlie's character would significantly weaken the whole point of her story arc; and she's the main character.
Arguably Hitchcock's Best Film
by Prague23
Jul 11th, 2008
04:43:34 PM
I've heard it argued, and after hearing it, I couldn't say 'nay.' But you could argue that point with 6-8 other films he's made. You could break it down into 'periods,' and what not, etc.. Great film, anyway way you look it at.
dogmatic
by depalma25
Jul 12th, 2008
05:46:46 AM
the director's cut of Kingdom of Heaven is ifinitely better than the theatrical version. Althoughe,one has to really be a fan o historical epics to really appreciate how different and better the new version is. IT's a different film. If you like great epics, watch the directors cut, it's a complteley different experience. I don't want to give anything away, but Edward Norton's character plays a pivotal role.
dogmatic...
by depalma25
Jul 12th, 2008
05:54:22 AM
I am a student of ancient Greece and Rome. The story of Helen of Troy has always been one of my favorites. The Directors Cut, is bloodier and more true to the legend. But, let's face it, the movie is a pretty weak interpertation of that war. It actually lasted decades, and Petrocules was not the cousin of Achilles, but his lover. The sacking of Troy in the director's cut is more accurate.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.