Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

Cloverfield, BEEYOTCHES!
by Pennsy
Mar 31st, 2008
09:52:05 AM
Which is eligible for an MTV Movie Award for Best Movie, BTW...
god cloverfield sucked
by Mr Gorilla
Mar 31st, 2008
09:52:16 AM
i'm all for having unknowns play the leads in these films, but they have to be unknown actors, not just, you know, unknowns.
Awesome! I'll buy it.
by nascentia
Mar 31st, 2008
09:55:20 AM
Both times I saw Cloverfield, I convinced my friends that we needed to stay for the entire credits just for this song. And both times, they thanked me. Now if we could just get the damn Sunshine soundtrack released somehow...
That may be true, Mr. Gorilla...
by acorvey25
Mar 31st, 2008
10:03:53 AM
But the song was fucking awesome.
nascentia
by Sailor Rip
Mar 31st, 2008
10:05:34 AM
Ughh. Imagine being with this guy in the theatre? You just want to to leave after the movie and hit the bathroom while this dude's like "No, No, we have to stay and listen to the end music!" Then proceeds to sit there for ten minutes with his eyes closed making those conductor movements with his hands.
already bought!
by Roderich
Mar 31st, 2008
10:09:47 AM
... but only when it appears on iTunes!Giacchino = Incredibles = Pixar = Apple = iTunes!
I've checking every tuesday since the flick came out for it.
by logicalnoise01
Mar 31st, 2008
10:12:42 AM
I never stayed for the credits and I heard that is quite a epic song.
Just make a midi file.
by SkeletonParty
Mar 31st, 2008
10:16:23 AM
I've been looking for this, too
by flickchick85
Mar 31st, 2008
10:18:44 AM
I had just about given up on this (since the last time Giacchino had mentioned it was January). I didn't love Cloverfield, but that song was worth the whole trip. Thanks for the heads-up, Scorekeeper! This news made my day.
CLOVERFIELD 2: WHEATFIELD
by leobloom
Mar 31st, 2008
10:21:40 AM
The world will never tire of Cloverfield news.
this was awful
by snowtires
Mar 31st, 2008
10:21:45 AM
My roommate and I, both composers, stayed after the movie (which he thought was great, but I didn't really like) because someone on here said that the music was this mind-blowing piece of film score brilliance that absolutely had to be heard. We stayed for about thirty seconds of the music, heard the ridiculous female choir vocals come in, got up and left. Maybe it gets better, but the part I heard was generic and shitty.
Listen here....
by MarcsOnFire
Mar 31st, 2008
10:51:50 AM
http://www.seeqpod.com/search/ ?plid=704afcd5ce
OVERRATED
by Sithdan
Mar 31st, 2008
10:54:51 AM
IT was entertaining, but definitely not good enough to own on DVD. Man, my head still hurts from that jerky camera.
Cloverfield prequel: Super 8
by ricarleite
Mar 31st, 2008
11:04:58 AM
yeah but what film did that score belong in?
by knowthyself
Mar 31st, 2008
11:05:16 AM
Not in Cloverfield.
cloverfield 3: poppyfield
by ironic_name
Mar 31st, 2008
11:10:46 AM
poppy Montgomery stars.
first time I stayed for a song
by ironic_name
Mar 31st, 2008
11:18:17 AM
i figured we might get something cool at the end, but halfway through the music i knew they do something shitty, and just decided to listen to the music.
cloverfield: the series
by ironic_name
Mar 31st, 2008
11:19:08 AM
NEWMAN!
SCOREKEEPER...!
by ConanBaltar
Mar 31st, 2008
11:49:45 AM
Please write an update once this piece of music is released somewhere. I'll forget about it if someone on AICN doesn't remind me. That's right, I'm a lemming.
snowtires
by Mort Meyers
Mar 31st, 2008
11:55:33 AM
As an artist, self proclaimed or not, you should try taking in the entirety of a piece before making your overall assessment. It is impossible to critique something you've never heard. Your post makes you come across as a hack. Sorry to be so bold.
Giacchino can be really good...
by Christopher3
Mar 31st, 2008
12:12:42 PM
But his "overture" for this film was -- probably intentionally -- hammy.
Anyone know where I can get the interview for free?
by me_so_horny
Mar 31st, 2008
12:48:29 PM
I dont want to sign up. I cant afford it.
Stupid haters...
by Kasch
Mar 31st, 2008
01:18:25 PM
Probably never saw a Godzilla movie in their life. If you're a wannabe film composer, maybe you should, y'know, actually study music styles. Giacchino perfectly nailed that old Toho music.
Yeah but snowtires is...
by Sailor Rip
Mar 31st, 2008
01:31:08 PM
...a composer. And so is his roommate. And they live in a loft in Soho.
mort meyers
by snowtires
Mar 31st, 2008
01:33:23 PM
The first rule of writing a good song is to make the song immediately grab your attention and make the listener want to hear the piece in its entirety. If the first minute of a song is God awful, why on earth would I want to sit through another twelve minutes of it? I mean, do you need to listen to an entire Celine Dion song to know that it sucks or can you figure it out within the first 30 seconds?
to everyone with a big mouth
by snowtires
Mar 31st, 2008
01:35:14 PM
Could you kindly explain to me what makes a non-musician a better judge of musical content than someone who has been writing music for longer than they can remember?
Just saying...
by rutgersjaffo
Mar 31st, 2008
01:55:59 PM
Cloverfield kicked ass. Loved it, will see the sequel. Just saw The Mist this weekend. Not sure why they felt the need to end it like that. Pretty sure I don't really care for that needless change, but it didn't completely ruin the film for me either. Meh...
snowtires
by Sailor Rip
Mar 31st, 2008
01:56:44 PM
If I turned off some Rush songs after only one minute I would have missed out on some rockin' good times.
Tribute, or partially (or completely) lifted?
by Hikaru Ichijo
Mar 31st, 2008
02:14:06 PM
I thought the score was interesting as a sort a textural recap of the film, but at first I was offended by the obvious passages ripped out the Ifukube book. Very retro, and unlike what you usually get after a big budget horror flick. Then I realized it should have been shitty, dropped tuning Metal (if you buy into how they market such films,) and began I appreciate what I was hearing. I hope more filmmakers start seriously considering how soccer mom rock negates the thrills and chills they're going after.
Cloverfield TNG: Strawberry Fields Forever
by Geekgasm
Mar 31st, 2008
02:17:19 PM
"a groundbreaking overture"??? What the hell was "groundbreaking" about it? The fact that it wasn't in the rest of the movie? THAT makes it "groundbreaking"? I'm so fucking tired of people jizzing all over their shirts about every aspect of that moderately entertaining movie.
My question is....
by Snarky2
Mar 31st, 2008
02:20:32 PM
Snowtires said.....Could you kindly explain to me what makes a non-musician a better judge of musical content than someone who has been writing music for longer than they can remember? My response would be, if you've been writing music your entire life (longer than you can remember), why is it that you have time to post here? You must have made millions by now and be constantly fielding phone calls from producers and studios. Yes, as someone who's only been playing for 40 years (and didn't start before I can remember), I'm aware of the rule that songs must "grab your attention" in the first 30 seconds. It's a secret they tell us the day we get our super-secret musician's card. Creating tension in music is for pussies, right?
snowtires
by Mort Meyers
Mar 31st, 2008
02:21:29 PM
What makes you think you are the only musician posting on this site? Feel free to post a link to your music. I promise I will give it a full listen and give some feedback and criticism where it is warranted. I'm sorry if I offended you in any way with my previous post, I just don't think that by not giving the entire piece a chance you have allowed yourself any credibility. I think I do reserve the right to not like a song within the first 30 seconds, but if I do not give it a full listen, then I do not have the right to offer my thoughts to the public. I also get the feeling you don't like Celine Dion. She sort of rocked not to long ago. P.S. Sailor Rip, I want to hang out with you. Please live in Texas.
Anyone who refers to film cues as "songs"...
by Osmosis Jones
Mar 31st, 2008
02:46:47 PM
...is an idiot.
Mort Meyers
by Sailor Rip
Mar 31st, 2008
03:12:36 PM
NJ. Born and raised.
Creative "rules"
by flickchick85
Mar 31st, 2008
03:43:14 PM
I'm not a musician, so I was unaware of the "30 second rule" snowtires brought up, but I know there is a similar rule in screen writing (and no, I'm not a screenwriter, either, but screenwriting classes were part of my college curriculum and I did retain a couple of things) that says all your exposition should be out of the way (and the 1st turning point should occur) within the 1st 20 minutes of your movie. Does that mean every movie that doesn't follow that rule is bad? To me, these creative "rules" are more like standards. And there are plenty of people who do things outside of the standard methods. And as a non-musical expert, while Giacchino's Cloverfield suite may have defied the "30 second rule," my untrained ears really enjoy listening to it.
Finally, ROAR! news...thanks ScoreKeeper!
by BuffaloDrummer
Mar 31st, 2008
03:46:29 PM
Thanks for stayin on it. Nice to know we'll have this fabulous score piece to hear whenever we want! And I agree with logicalnoise01..I too was checking iTunes first thing every Tuesday morning to no avail.
How quickly did cloverfield vanish from
by emeraldboy
Mar 31st, 2008
03:52:43 PM
Us theatres. It only opened in the UK and ireland in Feb and yet by March it was gone! no really it tanked that fast.
Although I'm sure Snowtires would be pissed off
by half vader
Mar 31st, 2008
04:26:24 PM
if people listened to his stuff and subjectively wrote it off after 30 seconds, especially as he's been doing it for "longer than they can remember" (does that mean you're senile?).

And don't talk about yourself in the third person. You come off like a prat and it makes people doubt your objectivity, thus defeating your point.

Sure you've got an informed opinion, but by your own argument it doesn't make you the ideal critic either, can you concede that? To get REALLY ironic, wasn't it Bob Dylan that said "you don't have to be a weatherman to know which way the wind blows"? You're probably just pissed off that he's had so much success after coming from (ugh!) videogames! ;) by the way.

Getting back to this music, why was it even an issue? I would have thought that putting it online rather than on a physical disc would have been par for the course. Although I do hate compression. Would it have been any more complicated than your average CD single? In all seriousness Snowtyres, maybe you can help us out there. Do you know that side of things? Also, is tyre really spelt with an 'i' where you are?

Osmosis
by half vader
Mar 31st, 2008
04:34:32 PM
First the stupid stuff about the Muppets and now this. Anyone who belittles people for referring to the 'songs' or likewise those who call ships boats is anal retentive. Ignorance doesn't actually mean you're stupid, it just means you're not informed. Having said that one doesn't rule out the other (referring back to the embarrassing Muppet thing). Lighten up mate.
release it as a CD single
by The Amazing G
Mar 31st, 2008
04:37:59 PM
and I sure hope this isn't April Fools or something
Cloverfield 12: A Fistful Of Little Miss TermiMuppets
by performingmonkey
Mar 31st, 2008
05:25:14 PM
God I would pay to see that. Even if it was Bay at the helm.
Shouldn't this be done by The House of Lions?
by TomBodet
Mar 31st, 2008
06:24:23 PM
Or, isn't that a French group, Le Maison de Lyons?
Homage = Groundbreaking???? WTF???
by Lenny8
Mar 31st, 2008
06:40:04 PM
Huh?
Michael Giacchino did The Incredibles right?
by Amy Chasing
Mar 31st, 2008
07:31:28 PM
which was wonderful. Ratatouille was nice too. Mission Impossible 3... why does the recording of the theme sound like it was done by a high school orchestra?
ROAR!
by theycallmemrglass
Mar 31st, 2008
07:44:21 PM
I so wanted this track since hearing it at the cinema that I repeatedly listen to the horrible cinema capture knowing that they will probably never release it. So glad that there are significantly more like me that they will release it officially. Its awesome. And I cant wait to buy this 13 minute cersion. I have all of Michael Giacchino's Lost soundtracks which are absolutely brilliant, there is such a distinct signature to his work yet so varied from the dark scary thumping tracks to the searing heart wrenching ones.
Skillful Toho tribute...whoopde fuckin...
by quantize
Mar 31st, 2008
07:48:06 PM
Not a particularly memorable piece when you compare it to any classic theme or cue... I never heard it in the cinema because I was OUTTA there asap!.. I felt i'd been violated enough by JJ and his box of repetitious shitty magic tricks..
how could you not love "ROAR!"?
by The Amazing G
Mar 31st, 2008
09:15:42 PM
fucking TBers
how could you not love "ROAR!"...
by quantize
Mar 31st, 2008
09:40:41 PM
because you might be an informed film music listener and can appreciate the skill involved in a tribute style monster track but also identify a pretty ordinary tune... fucking TBers
snowtires I wirte music too
by logicalnoise01
Mar 31st, 2008
10:04:40 PM
but your opinion is as valid as the rest. Like I said I haven't heard the piece yet but I intend to give it a good listen when I can(in a decent format). I'm "the bad one andy" my stuff is on amazon, itunes and rhapsody.
This song was BEST thing about Cloverfield
by CENOBITE
Mar 31st, 2008
11:13:02 PM
Sometimes a good score will make a mediocre movie above average. Too bad this came late in the show! Can't wait.
Akira Ifukube's ZATOICHI ?!?
by CENOBITE
Mar 31st, 2008
11:15:55 PM
And where the HELL IS THE FREAKIN ZATOICHI COMPILATION?!?!?!? Some of my favorite music by Akira are for Shintaro Katsu's Zatoichi. Too bad Japan has limited printing of anything.
The Best Thing About CLOVERFIELD...
by LaserPants
Apr 1st, 2008
05:39:35 AM
Was how awful it was. How hilariously awful it was. An unintentional comedy, really, who's conceit runs out of steam in the first 15 minutes, and spends the rest of its running time getting more and more ludicrous. Then again, if I was 10, or a mentally retarded adult, I would've loved it.
T4: CLOVERFIELD 2: GED DOO DAH INDESTRUCTIBLE CHAHHPPAH!!!
by LaserPants
Apr 1st, 2008
05:42:03 AM
AN DOND FORGED DOO BLING DEE INDESTRUCTIBLE CAMERA!!! WHERE DID YOO GED DAT CAMERA?! EVEN I CANT TERMINATE ID!!!
ROAR! Female vocalist
by Padface
Apr 1st, 2008
06:30:21 AM
Is it just me or does the female vocalist's style on the ROAR overture sound vaguely familiar? To me it sounds like someone warming up for the STAR TREK original series theme tune, which im guessing will be making atleast a fleeting appearance in the new movie. Just a thought.
I will get soundtrack when it comes out
by Dazzler69
Apr 1st, 2008
06:38:01 AM
I am surprised it was not released at time of movie and then overfill it up with current hip hop shit versions of songs.
Who gives 2 shits....
by JimmyJingles
Apr 1st, 2008
08:36:55 AM
really.
you do
by logicalnoise01
Apr 1st, 2008
09:03:33 AM
since you clicked and then posted in the talkback.
Heh
by DocPazuzu
Apr 1st, 2008
10:42:23 AM
I know it shouldn't, but the lion thing still cracks me up.
But when is the Lost Season 3 soundtrack out?
by the ageless stranger
Apr 1st, 2008
11:23:35 AM
That is the question Michael.
LOST Season 3
by ScoreKeeper
Apr 1st, 2008
03:00:50 PM
LOST Season 3 is being released by Varese Sarabande on April 29, 2008. It's going to be 2CDs too!
Just heard the Cloverfield overture!!!
by BigTexas42
Apr 1st, 2008
03:50:31 PM
It was awsome!!!
Lovely stuff Scorekeeper
by the ageless stranger
Apr 2nd, 2008
05:03:55 AM
Cheers.
Snowtires...
by jerseycajun
Apr 23rd, 2008
04:35:41 AM
The music builds slowly from beginning to end, and as someone else pointed out, it's a great homage to the genre. If you really are a student of the medium, you should be aware of the motifs inherent in the classic city-stomping monster flicks. This music brought all that back in spades, refined it, and then released it in a slow burn that builds up to an intense inferno.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.