Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

If they kill off Desmond, I'll be very angry
by Pongo
Feb 28th, 2008
07:42:45 AM
It will make the Penny storyline completely worthless.
WOOHOO!!
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
07:44:51 AM
more lost
FIRST !!!!!
by B2
Feb 28th, 2008
07:45:57 AM
UGH !!! THird .. no FOURTH it is :P
by B2
Feb 28th, 2008
07:46:36 AM
"and what if they didn't?" "there might be side-effects"
by newc0253
Feb 28th, 2008
07:53:03 AM
woo hoo!
Top Ten
by ECUPirate71
Feb 28th, 2008
07:56:17 AM
Lost is back in a big way. I can't wait for tonight, spoiler free of course.
Should be good....
by Desmondo
Feb 28th, 2008
08:02:42 AM
The first episode of the season that really intrigues me. The sneak peeks got be exicted (spoilerly as they were) - and usually they are just filler scenes of no real merit. Hopefully therefore the rest of the ep must be pure gold.

And we have been lacking in Desmond this season. I'm missing him, brother.

Lost is
by ForkTongue
Feb 28th, 2008
08:02:52 AM
just a slight appetizer while I await the Wire. Pongo, I totally agree. Don't kill off Desmond. He's the best character on that island.
Well....
by Anton Chigurh
Feb 28th, 2008
08:03:39 AM
....*disclaimer*.... Ben is definately in the coffin!
Although with regards to Flashes Before Eyes...
by Desmondo
Feb 28th, 2008
08:05:33 AM
Don't get me wrong I loved that episode. The one thing I really felt uneasy about was when the woman showed up at the ring store, and started going on about fate and so on.

It was way too much like the Oracle in the Matrix movies. I just hope it doesn't turn into the philsophical pretentious mess of the last 2 films.

Love this show.
by Heelboy
Feb 28th, 2008
08:06:24 AM
This is my First post on these talkbacks. I have been reading this site for years and finally decided to join.
killing desmond..
by Jonah Echo
Feb 28th, 2008
08:08:14 AM
at this point in the story might be one of the few things that would make me tune out of Lost. I sincerely doubt that will happen though. His story seems way to integral to the overall plan here. He has to be destined for something great, right?
This is the first time
by biffy88
Feb 28th, 2008
08:17:01 AM
I'm watching an episode this season completely spoiler free. The excitement is killing me. I LOVE THIS SHOW.
Lost Fatigue
by Thunderbolt Ross
Feb 28th, 2008
08:17:41 AM
A couple friends seem to be growing impatient with this show still, even though it's moving faster than ever. I used to try and argue the point, now I just say "Maybe you should stop watching, sounds like you've hit the wall" and that's a lot easier. Highly recommended.
Lost is still strong.
by Jonah Echo
Feb 28th, 2008
08:26:46 AM
In some ways this is a weak season, and in other ways it isnt. I agree with the fact that there isnt the same emotional resonance, but at the same time, the ride is wilder than it has ever been I think. We are back to getting interesting and surprising twists every episode and that hasnt really been the case since season one.
Matrix-iness
by redtom
Feb 28th, 2008
08:28:54 AM
Yeah, there's definietly some sort of Matrix-y vibe about Lost, but I don't think there's any danger of "philsophical pretentious" arising seeing as the Matrix was simple tale of a guy realising he's carrying around the answer to a problem and takes it upon himself to do what needs to be done to solve the problem... or did I see a different story than everybody else...

Welcome Heelboy
by jeandubacher
Feb 28th, 2008
08:31:03 AM
This is my first post too. I've been reading all the lost talkbacks since last years season finale. Finaly I decided to join. Hello everybody.
I agree
by ForkTongue
Feb 28th, 2008
08:35:03 AM
Lost is still pretty strong. Something about this seasaon seems a bit thin though. Could be the fact that they intro'd more characters with more backstories. Also one thing that always bothered me was how easily they can track and find eachother on this island. The island always seemed so much bigger in the first 3 seasons. I understand that you need to edit something out in order to condense the storylines but when everyone walks through the jungle and they so easily track or stumble upon eachother, it sort of breaks the illusion. Just a thought.
A Desmond episode...
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
08:42:33 AM
Let's all prepare to have our minds completely screwed with again.

and ForkTongue, they find each other so easily now because they are going to specific places. If you have to wander around and find someone it takes a long time, but if you know that they are likely at the beach or at the barracks you go directly to that location and it's no big deal.

Welcome Heelboy and jeandubacher
by gotilk
Feb 28th, 2008
08:43:32 AM
It's an addiction. And misery loves company. So.. good to see you!
Tracking and finding each other
by Thunderbolt Ross
Feb 28th, 2008
08:44:31 AM
I think it's just that they stick to certain areas on the island, more or less
Jack at the trial
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
08:49:35 AM
I don't get why people are whining about Jack being asked if he loved Kate. He was supposed to be a character witness and was talking about how wonderful Kate was, so the prosecutor was trying to point out that he had every reason to say things to get Kate out of trouble. It's not like she could say, "Look Jack, we all know you're full of crap because more than 8 people survived the crash." She really had no way to combat his testimony other than that. Sure, it was not the most realistic trial ever, but you know what there's a dude who travels in time and a giant monster made of smoke that comes out of the ground and beats people to death, so I'm willing to let the legal realism slide a bit.
Oh, and one more thing
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
08:52:06 AM
It's nice to be able to post on here again. For quite a while everytime I tried to log in to post in a Lost talkback, it just asked me to log in again and again and again. I felt like I was stuck in some sort of screwed up loop like Des in FBYE.
thanks gotilk
by jeandubacher
Feb 28th, 2008
09:03:15 AM
I'm already addicted to read all the posts every single time. It can only get worse now. but I couldn't care less.
HERC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Chevron_Engaged
Feb 28th, 2008
09:05:13 AM
Please gop back to the old way you wrote the LOST posts, it was much better.
Desmond is Sick
by The Ender Smites Foes
Feb 28th, 2008
09:05:17 AM
This episode will kick ass. I still avent seen eggtown from last week, so I ahve to go watch that on my computer right now. 24 in January 2009. Jesus fucking christ..
I got that too, fount
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
09:05:34 AM
Ended up clicking the login button rather than hitting enter.

Go figure.

I think it was
by ForkTongue
Feb 28th, 2008
09:07:18 AM
That scene where they all met and Jack pulled the gun on Locke that really bothered me.
"Jack pulled the gun on Locke"
by newc0253
Feb 28th, 2008
09:11:16 AM
i didn't have a problem with that. after all, the last time they all met up, Locke killed Noemie in full view of everyone. Jack was understandably pissed.

as for Eggtown, i thought the dwelling on Kate's legal problems was reasonable enough: it'd have been lame if they didn't deal with it as a significant obstacle. plus i thought the final flashback redeemed any water-treading elsewhere in the ep.

This show is just TOO FUCKING GOOD
by turketron
Feb 28th, 2008
09:12:52 AM
Even when you get an episode last week like "Eggtown" that is weak by LOST standards, you know that the next week will be cock-explodingly good. The preview for this episode that aired after last week's ep has me very excited.
Great season so far
by kwisatzhaderach
Feb 28th, 2008
09:31:18 AM
Let's hope they can keep it up.
FOUNT OF USELESS INFO
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
09:34:58 AM
I agree with you about letting the legal realism slide, but your argument brings up an interesting point. I feel that the "real" things in lost (human emotion, situations, etc.) are ESSENTIAL to this story, in fact, it's the POINT. Everyone in this show has lost their way in their lives, and through their trials on the island, they find themselves. The reason the island and everything on it and how people react is all juxtaposed against the REALNESS of everything else - that's why it works. Granted, I thought the trial WAS realistic, but I'm no expert. Regardless, it's ESSENTIAL that the real things feel real so we get that contrast, and understand the seriousness of every character's life.
Regarding the death of Desmond...
by Anton Chigurh
Feb 28th, 2008
09:37:05 AM
...I'm sure he's not dying anytime soon, he's too awesome. But at the same time, I'm I the only one who thinks that his (Henry Ian Cusick) talent is being wasted on this show. He's too good for bit pieces here and there!
Even if Desond does die...
by Chevron_Engaged
Feb 28th, 2008
09:40:47 AM
People on the island who die have a way of sticking around. Christian, Mikhail, Charlie, etc. But even taking that into account, I do not think he will die.
AdrianVeidt
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
09:50:00 AM
Oh no doubt about that, the devil, as they say, is in the details. I just don't think that the trial itself was really all that big of a deal. It wasn't there to show us the legal drama, the outcome was a done deal long before it ever started. Its purpose was to show us around 4 things: (1) That, yes, Kate went back and had to stand trial, but there was no way they could convict her because of the circumstances surrounding who she is. (2) The lies that the O6 are telling. (3) That Kate has a kid who happens to be Aaron, and she will do anything for him, even if it means giving up Jack. (4) That while Kate probably has a golden pass for Oceanic Air, she is willing to accept a deal that says she won't leave the state, because she doesn't want to go baaaaack. (I'm guessing she won't grow a crazy Jackbeard either, but that has more to do with personal preference than fear.)
Today's gonna be a good day
by The_Squid
Feb 28th, 2008
09:51:08 AM
first class is cancelled and Lost is on tonight. I fucking love thursdays.

by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
10:03:59 AM
Been reading Valis, awesome stuff, of the top of my head a real Lock/Jack duality in the split personna of horselover/dick; it discusses theology and philosophy being one and the same in some ppls respects and applies this to ideas of matter and reality all around them. Sorry if this is pretentious bollocks im just v excited! exagerate: Real inference to a kind of matrix empire constantly revised (though this being all of reality not just a specific place). The different theological arguments are what really give me wood though, and the relationship between drug influenced and more socially conditioned construction; they highlight the differences in perception between all of the key players in lost, and the very ppl on this talkback! They also might point out strong ideas in these differet theologies of what the smoke monster is in relation to the island and a concept of god, for example the blind god (sm) who exploded from the black (Dark Tower Myrlen again), and now appears before us and claims ultimate divinity, while from afar and all around the real divinity tries to interviene and rescue people stuck in our entire reality contructed by this dark being in his narsasistic vision, but then thats only one theological side of the argument, along with say the creationism story of doaism/two sourcecosmogony (which Dick refers to as Fats facbrication, tsc not doa, writing inbetween work here au so sorry if crap spelling etc.) that bears a sticking resemblance to the Jacob/Essau? story, that might point to the idea some of dark force (sm) is tipping ppl more to the darkers, premature 'apparant' favouring of god, Jacob i.e himself. And so given the repeated motives/metaphors in all these ideas, are all these different theologies the same or alternate expressions of the same spiritual/intellectual conscious, or do they represent the maelstom of choas and indiffenrence? Back to Valis, all the while these characters trepidate or tightrope between drug addled insanity/indifference/false constuction, or enlightment in the face of society/the 'others' being craz..oh go read valis if you havnt aarleady its pointless to make these comparisons because a) im hack-cod-stoner, badly grammered, overly excitable info-sponge and B) there synonimous? with and yet completely trancends all the ideas put across in lost so far! Great stuff, bring on the next ep. Oh Red Tom, btw way many saw the myth/philosophy of Platos Cave and socraties in the Matrix. But the more it delved into this and dropped the ball on what it (in the sequels) presented on the surface arguably the more it sucked. I really like lost because it holds that line, even if whats on the surface here isnt kung-fu, bullet time and anime aethetic!
newc0253
by ForkTongue
Feb 28th, 2008
10:05:52 AM
No I meant that scene bothered me because everyone seemed to stumble on that spot in the jungle seemingly by accident. Not the actual Jack pulling the gun bit. Sorry I should have worded that better.
Jack is the final Cylon...
by irrelevntelefant
Feb 28th, 2008
10:09:12 AM
If LOST is stupid enough to kill off Desmond, I hope...
by SpyGuy
Feb 28th, 2008
10:12:09 AM
...DOCTOR WHO casts Henry Ian Cusick as the Eleventh Doctor (David Tennant's replacement) for 2010. And if Steven Fucking Moffat ends up as the new showrunner, holy crap will that be glorious....
do not mistake coincidence for fate
by turketron
Feb 28th, 2008
10:13:36 AM
maybe?

Hell, I thought the oddest thing about it was that they were by the cockpit, which we haven't seen since season 1. Shouldn't there still be months old bodies in there?

BROTHER!
by Frodo T. Baggins
Feb 28th, 2008
10:14:39 AM
Has Desmond LOST his catchphrase this season? He said Brother more times than the Hulkster before....BROTHER!
Lost Video Game (SPOILERS)
by Youguysgotanymilk
Feb 28th, 2008
10:17:23 AM
I'm not sure if anyone else picked this up but I did and I started playing it last night. The game is supposed to be split up into 7 or 8 episodes like the show. I played through the first two (complete with previously on lost recaps, and "cliffhanger ending"). It only took me an hour to complete the first two episodes and probably should have took 15 to 20 minutes, but I was playing around.

While it is fun to be in the Lost universe, this isn;t really a game. All you do (so far) is walk around and pick things up and talk to people.

The character models range from dead on to completely laughable, most being the later. Only a few of the actual actors did voice work (i think Ben, Juliet, Sun,Desmond, and Claire) are original voices, the rest do not really sound much like the characters.

The game involves a guy named Elliot who wakes in the jungle with amnesia. He was on 815. His goal is to remeber who he is and get home. He experences some visions (like Jack and Hurley) of a girl he knows but doesnt know how. He is a journalist, so your first goal is to find your camera to jog your memory.

You walk around and ask different characters if they know you or if they know where your character is. You can ask them other stuff (using a list of prescribed questions) but you dont really get any answers. You do meet Kate and it launches your first flashback. You have pieces of a memory of Kate boarding the plane and you have to relive the scene and take a picture of the event to jog your memeory (this being Kate being in handcuffs. After you take the right photo you go back to present time and remeber that kate is a fugitive.

SPOILERS At the end of the first episode a guy approaches you in a suit and tie and asks for your camera, when you say you dont have it he punches you and says "I'm going to destroy that photo then kill you". He thens stomps your head and you black out. LOST End of first episode.

Episode 2 starts with Kate, Jack, and Charlie returning from the cockpit and being scared by the monster. You figure that your camera is in the cockpit but Jack wont let anyone go into the jungle. You play another flashback and realize that you have to lie to Jack to distract him. Once in the jungle Locke tells you about hiding in a thicket of trees which you will later use to escape from the smoke monster. You find Michael near a cave and he gives you a lighter. After traveling through the cave (and finding a dead polar bear) you make it out and reach the cockpit. After searching the cockpit and doing a stupide mini game you get your camera.

When you leave the cockpit you run into Ben and Juliet. They say something about "he might him or the one" and when you ask them who they are Ben replies "We're the good guys." Then Tom sneaks up and clubs you over the head and Juliet injects you with a needle.

LOST Episode two is done.

Overall the game is kinda boring so far, it was fun to talk to some characters but that gets old quick. I did manage to Gary Troupe myself by getting to close to the plane. As mentoined earlier there isn't much action yet, hopefully it will pick up. I'll keep ya posted if anything good happens.

Darkocity...
by redtom
Feb 28th, 2008
10:17:28 AM
"Oh Red Tom, btw way many saw the myth/philosophy of Platos Cave and socraties in the Matrix. But the more it delved into this... "

Where did the Matrix ever mention anything whatsoever to do with Plato and Socrates? That was just typical, contemporary "seeing things that aren't actually there" angst from philsophically pretentious types...

Ah HA!!
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
10:28:12 AM
I mentioned last TB there would be an auction for Hanso's logbook from the Black Rock. Looks lke we et said auction tonight!!!!!!! DOC JENSEN: Last season, you touted the Desmond-centric episode ''Flashes Before Your Eyes'' by saying that it ''uses the flashback device in a way you've never seen before — and will never see again.'' Does tonight's Desmond-centric outing, ''The Constant,'' uphold that pledge? DAMON LINDELOF: '''The Constant' upholds that pledge, unpledges it, then repledges it. Also, there's a really cool auction in it.''
Redtom watch the origional scene with the the oracle. Or read Sl
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
10:30:42 AM
Fuck that. Go and read Polis, or Platos cave. Then go watch the matrix. Aint nothing pretentious about it, if by pretentious you mean saying something you dont really mean. If ur still not convinced ill dig out some papers i got that actually cover this and quote them.
Locke Box
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
10:33:32 AM
Wouldn't it be ironic if Locke was in the coffin? And the only person to show up at Locke's funeral was Jack, who cries? I imagine if Locke had a funeral in the states, no one would attend. We still don't know who the last 2 of the Oceanic 6 are, do we?
Fount of Useless Info & RedTom
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
10:36:31 AM
Fount: I completely agree and am 100% on board with you - it was all exposition on how Kate is in the real world after the crash. In fact, except for how she got Aaron, there is no real other mystery surrounding her. We need episodes like this and I enjoyed it a lot. REDTOM: Teh Matrix is Philosophy 101. Seeing the light after being shielded in a cave your whole life??? It's Plato Plato Plato. TO ANYONE: Does anyone else think that the producers/writers are going to kill off someone that is actually one of the Oceanic 6 BEFORE they get off the island - just to fuck with us?
Cheers Youguysgotanymilk
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
10:36:35 AM
please do keep us all updated, because a) then we dont have to buy the bloody thing! and b) who knows theres might be a moment in this that is to the entire game as ep13 was to the entire mini-sodes!
And please help me with formatting...
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
10:36:59 AM
How the hell do I make different paragraphs in a post???
Rolling Stone
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
10:38:34 AM
Yes we know, but I won't spoil it if you don't want to know.
Desmond doesn't die.
by PirateEmery
Feb 28th, 2008
10:44:30 AM
I've seen... flashes... bits and pieces of the future...

What I can tell you is that Desmond does NOT die.

Paragraph formatting...
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Feb 28th, 2008
10:49:23 AM
Put the letter "p" inside the "lesser than" and "greater than" characters (which are the two keys to the right of your keyboard's "M" key). It is simply the standard HTML code for a paragraph break. Type this out once to do a carriage return -- like this...

Type this out twice to do a carriage return and to insert a space between the two paragraphs -- like this...

And that is the fabled secret of the TB paragraphs.

So Claire, Sawyer, Jin, Sun, Desmond, Juliet, or Dan die.
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
10:50:00 AM
We know ONE of these SEVEN will die according to the promos. I am guessing Claire dies??? In which case Desmond is safe (YES!!!). OR they could pull a fast one on us and kill someone we didn't expect like Jin or Juliet (please no!)

by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
10:55:47 AM
Oops - thank you!
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
10:56:35 AM
I've been wondering that my whole life.

Now I know.

Now I feel like I REALLY know.

Spoil me, Adrian, Spoil me!
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
11:13:24 AM
I'd be ok with them killing Juliet off. Ever seen "Running Scared" with Paul Walker? Ever since that flick, I can't stand that actress. She just creeps me out now. Plus, she was an Other, right? Jack can live without her. OK, AdrianVeidt. Spoil me--who are the other 2?
Regarding Spoilers
by duckie445
Feb 28th, 2008
11:16:02 AM
Um... Can we NOT have spoilers as part of the actual headline, please? I get that AICN prides itself in having the first scoop on most things and generally takes care not to spoil things for those that don't want to be spoiled - but these LOST headlines are getting out of hand.
Spoilery theory
by Youguysgotanymilk
Feb 28th, 2008
11:16:04 AM
I've always thought that it would be interesting if they killed someone in a flash forward. We would have to watch them alive on the island knowing that their death was eminent. Sort of like the Cjarlie and Desmond thing only there was chance Charlie would still live. Keeping this in mind, I believe Jin is in the coffin. Based on the info that one of those people die, it has to be Jin. If they went to the states they wouldn't know anyone, hence why no one was at the funeral. Also, they wouldn't have much money so hence, the poor black neighborhood. Why no other O sixers are there, I don't know. I guess Sun and Jin would have to die to make it work.

I dont know. Still waiting/ hoping for that future death.

Node
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
11:17:54 AM
First, a warning to all reading this, there are no spoilers, but a lot of conjecture that could theoretically be spoiler-ish.

I've been assuming that Jin gets off the island along with Sun. That would add up to the right number of people in the O6. We've been told that we will know all of the O6 before the end of the first group of episodes. Of the episodes remaining in that group, only Sun and Jin have -centric episodes and were on the plane. To me, that sounds like they are the last two.

Then again, they could totally screw with us and have them get off the island and show us Jin dying during a flashforward. That would be weird. He'd still be on the show and still be around on the island, but we'd know he's dead later. I don't know if they'd do that or if my logic is correct about completing the O6, but it's an interesting idea.

Rolling Stone
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
11:18:01 AM
Jin and Sun, if everything we've been hearing is correct. We get their story in episode 7.
Yes Frodo T. Baggins...Desmond needs to say Brother more!
by StudioPlant69
Feb 28th, 2008
11:18:06 AM
Everything he says should be followed up with "brother". I'm gonna take a piss brother. You have cancer brother. Does this look infected brother? See it makes everything better...brother. gfy.
Remaining 5 episodes
by Youguysgotanymilk
Feb 28th, 2008
11:26:44 AM
Anyone care to speculate on who will get flah backs/flash forwards in the next five eps.

I'm assuming Jack, Locke, and Ben. Are safe bets. Maybe a Locke flash forward when he is still on the island?

I would love for a Richard or Danielle Russuo (god I cant spell). Or maybe Widmore, Abbadon, or other Dharma figure, would be cool.

It will be interesting which five they decide to use for the rest of the season. Knowing what the producers have said about the point of this season, we probably wont get Richard or any other crazy flashbacks this season. We shall see...

Yes, for the love of Christ, just tell us already!
by I Dunno
Feb 28th, 2008
11:29:52 AM
I've been with the show until the last episode, when even I said, "For fuck's sake, just someone tell someone else what the fuck is going on!".
Adam and Eve
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
11:31:19 AM
So if time travel is a definate, then it's probably locked in that Adam and Eve are current cast members, right? Are Jack and Kate too obvious? And weren't there game pieces found alongside those dead bodies?
I don't think they'd kill Desmond
by Jor-El23
Feb 28th, 2008
11:31:33 AM
The Des/Penny story has sort of become the underlying theme for the show. It's not the central story but it's the most important story I think. It's a redeeming story too and the show is all about redemption. Desmond didn't really do anything wrong, he's just on a bad luck streak courtesy of Penny's father. Desmond and Penny will be reunited on this show and Desmond will not die.
Darkocity
by gotilk
Feb 28th, 2008
11:32:14 AM
Talk about unbridled enthusiasm. We gotta party, brother. Seriously, your post made me crack open VALIS this morning. I was planning on waiting just a few more days.
Still no direction.
by EvilWizardGlick
Feb 28th, 2008
11:37:34 AM
LOST makes it up every season.

It's like Bushco throwing out whatever sticks then pretending that was meant all along.

Locke is still a closet Mo. He did have Miles in Gay sex cuffs. And he actively pursued the young males of the show. And the FBI honeytrapped him with a young man.

Locke still GAY
by EvilWizardGlick
Feb 28th, 2008
11:38:01 AM
Read previous post for "clues".
Desmond needs to say BOLLOCKS.
by EvilWizardGlick
Feb 28th, 2008
11:38:39 AM
Just sayin.
Bi-Locke?
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
11:39:23 AM
But wasn't he nailing Al Bundy's wife for awhile?
Its Not Lookin Good.....
by Chevron_Engaged
Feb 28th, 2008
11:42:41 AM
For Claire Bear!

It's a bummer, she's the only hott one left.....well Kate, but whatever.

New lost game trailer...
by Novaman5000
Feb 28th, 2008
11:44:14 AM
Aside from the fact that they didn't get some of the cast to come back for the voices, it's looking pretty sweet.

http://tinyurl.com/3ayyrt

Click "Trailer (HD)"

Bad men
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
11:44:16 AM
If this is all one big test experiment, wouldn't guys like Sun's dad, Penny's dad, and Jack's dad be the kind of guys to take part in it? We got a lot of rich asshole daddies to content with here.
DON'T FORGET ABOUT THE NEW IRON MAN TRAILER TONIGHT!!
by Lanceloco
Feb 28th, 2008
11:46:20 AM
Jack's Lying Under Oath
by bythehairofsanjaya
Feb 28th, 2008
11:47:08 AM
What if Jack and the rest of the returnees have been "tampered" with and actually believe there were only 8 survivors and are not consciously lying?
Is That Really THE Aaron...Brother?
by Frodo T. Baggins
Feb 28th, 2008
11:51:47 AM
Is he a hand me down kid cause momma got the axe? Or is this a tribute baby from Sawyers loins? If he was a hand me down I dont think Jack would have a problem seeing him Brother. God I want to get off work from this shitty job and go home and watch last episode again Brother. Alright Des. Bring the pain with your I'll Rearange Any Consistant Thought Or Story Line This Season flash back Brother. ............BROTHER!
I miss....
by Chevron_Engaged
Feb 28th, 2008
11:53:11 AM
Charlie.

The shows dynamic seems a little of with otu him.

Nova
by Youguysgotanymilk
Feb 28th, 2008
11:54:48 AM
I got the Lost game yesterday, read my post above. I have played through the first two episodes, and it is a little underwelming. Hopefuly it picks up. Let me know if you have any questions on it.
Had that idea myself node
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
11:55:01 AM
Saw the episode names, and thinking back to what they said about the person in the coffin being someone we had already "met", then #7 is where we meet someone..........

Could be a coincidence, I guess.

If they are going to go crazy with Time Travel...
by Desmondo
Feb 28th, 2008
11:56:31 AM
I forsee Jin appearing from the future with a cool american accent.

And a samurai sword.

What if....
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
12:00:18 PM
it's impossible for some people, due to whatever Des was shooting up with or whatever else they come up, cannot leave the island. That if they do they die. That might tie into Walt's mom dying suddenly.
NODE
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
12:05:31 PM
However, keep this in mind:

Her psychic said "This child cannot be raised by another." Which can also be seen as "This child cannot be raised by an OTHER." Think about it.

At the very least, it gives the writer's an out for why Kate can raise the baby just fine.

So far
by Series7
Feb 28th, 2008
12:05:51 PM
I really don't care whats going to happen, because the main thing I know is that Linus is still alive, and why no one just got it over with and killed him on the Island is just pathetic. The little kids with Flies had more balls then the survivors.
Hair of Sanjaya:
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
12:07:40 PM
Then what the hell is jack "sick of lying" about?
Look, we know they survive because of the
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Feb 28th, 2008
12:08:54 PM
Sayeed in the future clips, so knowing that, plus the fact this is a Desmond-centric episode means it's going to be great.
Series7
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
12:10:55 PM
...or maybe they have a sense of fairness, responsibility, humanitarianism, are grown up and don't behave as children, respect life, perfer trial by jury rather than execution, realize a good story line when they see it, understand plot development and character advancement......

But killing a main character that a lot of the story revolves around... that's good too.

geeeeeeeeezzzzzzzzz

Well he pushes Claire out of the Copter...
by ElectricDreams
Feb 28th, 2008
12:11:26 PM
...of course he'd feel guilty about seeing the kid! OH WAIT...you guys haven't seen that happen yet...nevermind
hairofsanjaya
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
12:17:02 PM
I think Kate's statement about "hearing that story so often, I'm starting to think you believe it" kind of kills that theory.
Also since
by Series7
Feb 28th, 2008
12:18:48 PM
There seems to be no other TV talkback right now, what ever happened to talk backs about the Sarah Coner Show? I think its been a lot better then Lost, better special effects and the story moves forward. Also Breaking Bad is the best show on right now. I am amazed at this point in the show that Lost has managed to stay on.
Cool Node, I hear that
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
12:20:01 PM
so thanks ill take that into account. Next post anyway. The problem though is that its far too excitable to write about all this, in far too short a space of pockets of time. I'll try and make more time...this isnt some cunning allusion to lost i mean in a working day! Enjoy it Gotilk; its a militant but rewarding read so far ive found, compared to other PKD books. And Cheers whoever keeps pointing out all the book titles for the sake of all those who don't have say a 21" hd moniter! Or do i just need glasses?
Adrian re: Claire, Aaron and the psychic
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
12:22:40 PM
The problem is that had the psychic never interfered, Aaron wouldn't have had a chance of being raised by an Other. It was his freak out about being raised by another, followed by his lie about the couple in LA that would adopt the baby and keep it safe that caused Claire to be on the island and Aaron to be in the prescence of Others. I have thought from the first season (and still think) that Aaron is either the ultimate good or ultimate evil in this show and that how/by whom he is raised makes all the difference.
What?....Time Travel You Say?!!!
by Cheif Brody
Feb 28th, 2008
12:28:39 PM
That's all fine and dandy...but I pray to God there's no "mechanism" shown...no "DeLorean" if you will...a device that makes this "time travel" possible.

I'm hoping they keep in relegated to the island's mysterious make up...and they stay away from scenes like a room with a chair in the middle and lots of technical gizmos attached to the person in the chair (ala The Matrix)...or blinding flashes of electricity that forms a ball around the subject (ala Terminator)...

I would just like the time travel to be organic...and not explained by sci-fi mumbo jumbo.

God, I wanna read those spoilers!! Is it 9pm yet?!

this is the fallout
by imageburn13
Feb 28th, 2008
12:29:42 PM
Ive been enjoying this season enormously. I liken this season to seeing the aftermath to a hurricane, with so much chaos, confusion, and fear. Charlie dying summized the first three seasons perfectly. S4 has become painfully serious and its working.
Testing
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
12:30:31 PM
RED DOG RUN,

RUN DOG RED

RED RUN DOG

DOG RUN RED

REDRUM

REDRUM

MURDE-

Brody: Time Travel
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
12:31:59 PM
We've alredy seen time travel. It was Desmond in Flashes Before Your Eyes and it basically was just him (or his current consciousness, if you will) going back and reliving his life. No special mechanism required. (other than that super-imploding hatch, that is.) Since tonight is Des again, I'm guessing it's pretty much the same thing.
Drrghhh so close! Because of the comma?
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
12:32:34 PM
I think Desmond is ALREADY dead...
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
12:36:46 PM
I think he died in the hatch explosion, but came back to life as the island or something else incarnate, and that's why he was found COMPLETELY naked after the hatch explosion. I'm sure there are other details to this theory I'm working out, but let's go with this for now... thoughts?
The Psychic
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
12:37:50 PM
I agree, he might have been lying - but he definitely wanted Claire to crash land, I think they wanted us to know that much.
the psychic (again)
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
12:40:27 PM
I always thought that the implication was that he told Eko he was a fraud to get him out of there. He claimed that the whole issue with his daughter was made up, but she then gave Eko a message from Yemi that seemed to prove that the story was real.
Naked Desmond
by Cheef Beef
Feb 28th, 2008
12:40:32 PM
Could it be possible he was naked because he really did time travel? Just like in Terminator movies when they time travel they arrive naked
An Already Dead Desmond?
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
12:43:18 PM
Now that idea makes my head hurt.
"Chahlie, yur gunt a dyee, brutha!"
by slone13
Feb 28th, 2008
12:49:59 PM
I love Desmond. And miss Charlie.
They're all cylons. That's the spoiler.
by uss cygnus
Feb 28th, 2008
12:51:55 PM
What? It works for BSG, why not "Lost"?
Psychagain
by AdrianVeidt
Feb 28th, 2008
12:56:39 PM
Based on that, and maybe they deleted it since it isn't true to the plotline, but perhaps the others planned the whole crash - they WANTED to bring people to the island. Clearly, this is a well-researched theory, but this supports it...
Yes Node...
by Cheif Brody
Feb 28th, 2008
12:57:36 PM
But why would he cough up all that cash by telling Claire, "YOU...and You alone must raise this baby"?

Seems to me he DID have a true psychic vision...that possibly even surprised himself...It's possible he NEVER had any real psychic ability until Claire walked into his office.

My money's on Jin or Sun.
by PirateEmery
Feb 28th, 2008
01:02:35 PM
Apparently the death that occurs before the end of Episode 7, is one of the Oceanic 6. Which means it happens in a flashforward. And seeing as the next flashforward up to bat is Jin and Sun, odds are one of them is going to bite it in the future.
Charlie dying
by chutneylix
Feb 28th, 2008
01:09:59 PM
was the saddest few moments of this show and many I have seen over the ears. The music, desmond, the water and everything perfectly put together. Charlie & Desmond are by far the most popular characters it seems and for good reason. They're decent, but flawed people who deserve better than fate gives them.
I meant years
by chutneylix
Feb 28th, 2008
01:12:38 PM
not ears. Oh and I'm not ashamed to admit I cried at the end of Through The Looking Glass 2. Every time I watch it.
Aaron & Walt
by chutneylix
Feb 28th, 2008
01:14:49 PM
Lost needs to bring these two stories back again and give us the next piece about why these two children were (are) so important. For awhile, children seemed to have such an emphasis in stories that I thought in the end the central story would have something to do with them. But like those pesky detractors have said, the show seems to have dropped that thread. I hope they pick it up again.
Calling your bluff, ElectricDreams
by slone13
Feb 28th, 2008
01:14:56 PM
C'mon, spill it. Why does Jack push Claire out of the helicopter? At least try to come up with something somewhat plausible please...
7 Hours
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
01:16:18 PM
Until bliss. And answers. I hope.
Because..
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
01:20:21 PM
as Chaaaalie found out, Claire is a pricktease. "I'm only your HALF brother Claire! Now get down on your rescuers manhood, bitch! No?" Thump....."Happy landings, pricktease"
If you are in need of the Ep
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
01:29:44 PM
tonight, I will have it up under edshrinker on The Pirate Bay by 11pm. torrent will be created in wmv, no commercials, and seeded immediately by me. For ALL of you immensely intelligent lovers of LOST. That's 11pm eastern.
Watching the sneak peaks...
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
01:33:25 PM
I think Des' conscience has traveled fom the past to the future. For example, once on the boat he doesn't recognize Sayid or Frank and is clueless as to how he just appeared on a boat. Could this be a past Des having a flash forward to the freighter???
High school mock trial ruined courtroom scenes for me forever.
by phool2056
Feb 28th, 2008
01:34:31 PM
The ones last week were pretty off. You can't approach the witness without permission from the judge--the bailiff will TACKLE you. Prosecution makes its case first, meaning prosecution witnesses are called before defense witnesses, so Kate's mother would have been up before Jack. "Do you love her" as a question may be relevant, but the actual objection there would be "vague ad ambiguous" because there's no clear legal definition of "love." Obviously some creative license is fine, but except for the order of witnesses thing, a lot of these could have been fixed with an extra line or two of dialogue. A quick "permission to approach" isn't so hard, and forcing the prosecutor to come up with a more clinical definition of love could have actually improved that moment: "Do you love her?" Objection! "I'll rephrase. Is the well-being of the defendant important to you?" etcetera.
God damnit...
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
01:45:49 PM
... you get Lost arriving at the time your bloody country finds it acceptable to be awake!

Its not enough that you get stuff like The Daily Show...err, almost Daily. Were lucky if Armando Ianuuci gets off his very talented arse or pursuedes the new bbc execs to put down the coke and the pretty boys (no offense to them, we love them, its the context etc...) and listen to reason twice a year for example.

Worm- sorry, Torchwood? To quote one of 'The Thick of It's characters, "it is, as my dear old mother would say, double-wank and chips!".

'Primeval'!? Your a lucky bunch at the mo.

you fuckers ready to get LOST...
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
01:46:42 PM
(poom)
one question only..
by Lone_Gunman
Feb 28th, 2008
01:46:52 PM
following on from last week TB re. what to send to ABC if they cancelled Lost, how about a another Q. In the LOST Universe, what single Q would you like answered above all?

Mine would be what the deal with the four toes statue.

anybody got a idea of just one Q that want answering.

Lone Gunman.
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
01:49:52 PM
good topic. the four-toes statue would be high on my list. let's see, to choose only one I guess I would ask a two part a)what's evangeline lilly's cell phone number and b)would she fuck me? I jest. but seriously, this is prolly too obvious, but i NEED to know what is going on with Cerberus the Smoke Monster.
What/Who is the Smoke Monster?
by Shigeru
Feb 28th, 2008
01:53:39 PM
That would be mine.
Or wait.. maybe "who are the natives?"
Node
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
01:55:00 PM
i actually agree with you. pisses me off too.
The Natives.
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
01:57:05 PM
was there a specific comment on the show that referred to "the natives." if so, who said it and when. i know there is evidence on the island of people there very early on (the ruins and the 4 toes) but can anyone help me on anything said about "natives" specifically.
the "natives"
by Shigeru
Feb 28th, 2008
01:58:14 PM
were mentioned a few times in Ben's flashback where he offed the dharma initiative. They were "the others" to Dharma.
Led by
by Shigeru
Feb 28th, 2008
01:58:46 PM
Richard Alpert. Apparently.
shigeru
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
02:02:42 PM
i know but i thought they were more specifically the "hostiles" I guess what I am asking is, was there ever a time when the natives were referred to seperately from the hostiles that were fucking with dharma. because the hostiles, imo, were mos def NOT the Islands original inhabitants. MAYBE they were descended from the natives, but I don't think the Hostiles are the Natives
I'm not sure
by Shigeru
Feb 28th, 2008
02:07:21 PM
But I believe in the Ben flashback both "hostiles" and "natives" were used. And Kelvin Inman definitely used one of those words too... shit I'm confused as to who said what. Someone wanna check?

I don't see why we can't assume Alpert's people aren't the original inhabitants of the island/descendents of the 4 toed statue builders/natives. We do know that Richard has been around for a LONG time and doesn't age.
Jack will push Claire out of the helicopter because...
by turketron
Feb 28th, 2008
02:13:24 PM
She's a genetically engineered cyborg...

with a bomb...

IN HER RIBCAGE!!!

Node
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
02:22:00 PM
I'm officially disowning you as a fan of this show for that. It's unacceptable to pretend to be a true fan when you're really a shipper in disguise.
Back to the psychic again
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
02:27:29 PM
So, was he paid to get Claire onto a plane and sent to LA or onto *that* plane and sent to LA. If it is the latter, perhaps the Others knew of Claire and the crash and planned ahead. (Indicating that he is a fraud who had one true prophecy, maybe) Or maybe it was just him talking and trying to convince Eko to leave his family in peace. Or as someone else suggested, maybe the scene was cut because it went against the canon of the show. I don't know.
shipper?
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
02:32:51 PM
As in relationship. A pejorative referring to people who (using wikipedia's words) "support a fictional romantic relationship, usually on the internet." You know, Jaters and Skaters. (I feel dirty having just typed those terms.)

Besides, we all know the important question is whether Jack ends up with Juliet.

Stop it.........
by rbrog77
Feb 28th, 2008
02:38:02 PM
According to the last 2 weeks of TV Ratings published in USA today, LOST ranked 7th overall and 6th in the 18-4o whatever demographic.

Thsi show will not be cancelled with numbers like that.

They're making it painfully obvious that Claire's in the coffin
by Sick Fixx
Feb 28th, 2008
02:40:28 PM
Painfully obvious?
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
02:46:38 PM
If Claire is in the coffin, that would cause several problems. (1) That puts Through the Looking Glass before Eggtown. If that's the case, Jack has made a remarkable recovery from his bearded oxycontin days and has stopped saying that they need to go back. (2) That also would make it odd for anyone to believe that Aaron is Kate's son, since he would have been with his mother when they came back until she died. (Plus, Kate took her baby, but refused to go to the funeral?)

While Claire may be dead, I'm pretty sure she's not the one in the coffin.

Sick Fixx is still here, BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
02:47:59 PM
ROFL... hey Sick Fixx, I thought you were "done" with LOST a few weeks ago, hehe. Chump.
Node
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
02:48:10 PM
Too late. Sorry.
Node32774
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
02:49:31 PM
What the heck. You've never heard of the term 'shipper'? Man, I guess you totally never watched "The X-Files" in the 1990s.
Btw as a true "LOST" fan I am a shipper.
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
02:51:06 PM
No, not a Skater or Jater, but Desmond + Penelope!!!!!!
Ashoko
by Sick Fixx
Feb 28th, 2008
02:51:49 PM
Who said I'm watching tonight? Kate's arrest was very underwhelming. No leg irons, no shackles. Just flimsy handcuffs. But nothing short of a ballgag would have satisfied me.
Damnit is slang
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
02:52:33 PM
people at least i know use it alot in noteform. Its like saying whathefuck. But i did not know ppl here were so humble about spelling, punctuation and grammer so ill try not to provoke from now on. Kylegass, your willing indifference pisses me off.
Fount
by MrCleanAZ
Feb 28th, 2008
03:01:37 PM
Sorry, to partially disagree, but the flash-forward in 'Looking Glass' does take place after 'Eggtown'. In fact it's after all the other flash-forwards, except possibly Sayid's.

However, I do agree that Claire ain't in the coffin - although she might die.

Coffin = Locke or Ben
by Frodo T. Baggins
Feb 28th, 2008
03:07:17 PM
I say Locke. Clair doesnt get off the island. Clearly there is people left behind. I shall dub them. The Left Overs. Kate has a misscarrage. Clair prolly dies. Kate addopts Aaron. IE the forshadowing from last episode about How Shes Not So Good With Kids...."You should try it sometime". And I would like to think Sawyer dies in some heroic way by saving a few people. Or just Kate. And she sucks him off during his last few moments. Desmond watches from a far and says "Brother, its aboot Tyme. Im outa here now brother." And poof hes naked again and dives into the water to his magic sail boat and drifts away. Oh and Hurley fucked Clair and squished here. Goes crazy because hell never have a dime like that again. & Charlie keeps appearing to him at convienant stores saying "Whyd you fuck me gurl?"
Coffin
by MrCleanAZ
Feb 28th, 2008
03:08:22 PM
Didn't the obituary say "he" somewhere in it - meaning it's a man?

My guess is that the man in the coffin is either Ben, Locke, or Michael.

Ben has changed before, evidenced by the several passports, and we know he makes it back. Maybe he dies after what we saw in Sayid's flash-forward - who would want to go to his funeral? That's right nobody.

Locke fits the original obituary better and nobody would go to his funeral either.

I think Michael has changed his name and we will soon 'Meet' him again. He could used another name as well and again nobody, but Walt would go to his funeral.

Now, someone please tell me I'm wrong - cause that's the point of these talkbacks right?

Mr. Clean
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
03:10:40 PM
I agree that TTLG is likely the latest flashforward. What I was saying was that *if* Claire is in the coffin, *then* that meant that TTLG had to be before Eggtown, which makes no sense. Sorry, I wasn't clear.
Mr. Clean (again)
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
03:12:43 PM
The obit definitely indicated that it was a man. What we don't know is if the obit was meant to be seen and is canon or if it was simply a prop made to look like an obit and the propmaster had no knowledge of what was supposed to be there. I don't think we've heard confirmation either way from DL/CC.
Coffin part II
by alex138
Feb 28th, 2008
03:12:56 PM
Possible Spoiler********** I read somewhere that whoever was in the coffin hailed from New York and left behind a teenage son. Strong evidence for Michael. Also I'm pretty sure that it is not Claire because Kate would actually care about her dying and going to her funeral.
Xiphos
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
03:16:10 PM
Nah, I'm sure you were a true fan, brother. It's just, the Mulder and Scully shippers were throwing the term "shipper" around in every fan magazing, fanfic, convention, BBS and forum you could shake a stick at. Seems wild to never hear the term once between 1993-2002. It'd be like watching LOST from 2004-2010 without ever hearing the term "Jater".
Fount
by MrCleanAZ
Feb 28th, 2008
03:17:27 PM
That makes sense, and I agree with you now 100% on the Eggtown/Claire thing.

I've also thought about the obituary, and agree that it might not be canon. At the same time they could have ensured nobody could read it at all instead of just the little snippets that were visible - just my two cents.

Deselope
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
03:29:59 PM
Best of the bunch. I picture it being pronounced with a long "o" and silent "e" at the end like "antelope".
Darkocity
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
03:34:49 PM
indifference. i don't know what you're talking. anyway i don't fucking care...
Death, Spoilers, EW Article
by 4we8have15to16go23back42
Feb 28th, 2008
03:37:20 PM
Don't worry no spoilers in my post. But This morning I posted an EW Doc Jenson Article on the previous weeks Talkback. (Im to lazy to cut & paste it here and put in the breaks. So heres the link to last weeks Talkback. Its at the very bottom. Also for those interested about 10 or 15 posts up from the bottom theres 3 spoilers That narrow down who the death could be. Im still going for Sun in the future and shes in the casketand that the newpaper clipping is ether a red herring or that like the lost people said, the prop people often just throw in random things when it comes to newpapers, magazines and other props.
Forgot the link
by 4we8have15to16go23back42
Feb 28th, 2008
03:38:52 PM
http://www.aintitcool.com/talk back_display/35684
Claire
by 4we8have15to16go23back42
Feb 28th, 2008
03:40:49 PM
DarkUFO has already confirmed that the rumor that Claire gets thrown out of a helicopter is %100 false.
wow darkocity.
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
03:42:59 PM
i only skimmed your above message about my "willing indifference" when i wrote my last post, but i just read the post fully. that really pissed you off, huh? you gonna squirt some?
Fight All You Want
by Frodo T. Baggins
Feb 28th, 2008
03:46:40 PM
You really love each other. Like Hurley & Sawyer. Awww. Yall cute
Sick Fixx!
by maxwell's hammer
Feb 28th, 2008
03:49:24 PM
Thanks for stopping by, old sport, and classing the place up a bit!

If LOST is my guilty pleasure, i have to balance it out by watching some Japanese Surrealism and raeding the complete translated works of Nabokov! You inspire me!
heheheheheh
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
03:50:25 PM
just ribbing you in the playground kyleglass. Was being ironic, wanted to see if what i wrote struck a chord!
damn sick fixx.
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
03:51:45 PM
does everyone on here hate you?
darkocity
by thekylegassproject
Feb 28th, 2008
03:53:42 PM
all is well. now let's gang up on sick fixx. i jest, i jest
Cool KG. Um..well i have to be honest
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
04:32:33 PM
but i'm not quite sure i fully understand the deal with Sick Fixx; what he origionaly did or said thats got everone so riled; and therefore all the subsequent post between him & you guys has been kind of like wondering up to people gathered & heated around a crime scene & the perpetrator debating it heavily in terms without actually mentioning what the crime is, so to speak. And thats not meant as irony believe me! Either that or im completely ignoring the rest of the community and its posts here, but...the 10k thread was eye bleeding for christ sakes you couldnt possibly read everything from beginning to end!
poor Sick fixx
by chutneylix
Feb 28th, 2008
04:34:11 PM
if the show itself didn't turn him off, you guys sure have now :) i'm almost feeling bad for him. almost...I remember the nuttiness from a few weeks ago
You guys are Room23 from the beginning then node?
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
04:50:37 PM
Room 23 has something to with Sick Fixx?... I'll leave it but im paying more attention to everyones posts from now on.
Room 23 was the...
by Cheif Brody
Feb 28th, 2008
05:06:09 PM
node # for the LOST talkback we had that lasted from May 07 to what was it Node...Dec 07...or Jan 08?
I have always thought it was Ben in the coffin...
by StudioPlant69
Feb 28th, 2008
05:12:42 PM
Ben to me fits better, no one would go to his funeral. Jack went because he discovers that Ben was right about the island and the people on the ship.
Ahhh
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
05:13:37 PM
Room 23
by Maximus Prime
Feb 28th, 2008
05:29:02 PM
lastest from the season finale in may (24th if memory serves correct)2007 until January 2008 when it was shut down due to hitting the big 10k...but luckily the discussions and debate continued on anotehr Lost talkback just opened concerning a Matthew Fox interview, and we were able to jump homes until the season premier...

in those 8 months of glorious Lost debates, general geeking out and numerous fantastic theroies we were free of assholes mostly...every now and again a hater landed in shouted something about Heroes and buggered off again, but the discussions stayed on topic and lost centric..then when season 4 started these talkbacks were (are) flooded with assholes,,,,i'll name no names(CapJack) who decide to try and spoil episodes for everyone; and other people no names again (SF); who just talk shit and try to start mundane arguments and take the focus away from this great show...the days of room 23 are long gone...

to my room 23 pals, sorry aint been about, my constant battle with poor(not seroius or anything) health mixed with band commitments and work(U know all to well Big E) has made my post count severly drop...I try to read what everyone says but am not able to contribute as much as I can......but its good to see the old gang, Node, RB, PB, Big E and others still fighting the good fight....

I'll hopefully get to see the episode somestage tomorrow(god bless the internet) and will hopefully be in to get ur views on it...

oh and its a Des episode
by Maximus Prime
Feb 28th, 2008
05:31:03 PM
means only one thing 'Brutha'..

more 'HOLY FUCK' moments...I love that man....namaste

We had an occurance
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
05:43:39 PM
of pompous, name-dropping, culture-flouting, nonsense that went on for 50 or so worthless posts by one individual. Then the usual "the show sucks, I'm above it, won't watch it, but spend 3 hours posting here" type behavior. So I ask you, would you welcome said poster back gleefully?

Desmond Hume...and...Penelope Widmore

Hummore? Deselope would be my favorite. Jacket (Juliet and Jack) is a close 2nd.

Can't be Claire in the coffin.
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
05:43:45 PM
If Claire was in the coffin, surely the other Oceanix Six would have attended her funeral. Not to mention her aunt would have been there. It's got to be someone else. I say Michael or a character we aren't familiar with like Dan or Minkowski.
Damn I love Des
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
05:48:12 PM
Our Brutha was a Brother. Oh irony. Soldier, Yachtsman, Monk, button-pushing hermit, stud to a rich cutie pie, time-traveler....brutha has lived full life so far! All glory Desmondo!
Okay CB, MP
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
05:54:25 PM
enjoyed alot of those posts too but loined a bit late i think cos Room 23 ref and the sick foxx stuff went over my head. Or im just stupid.
Kate
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
05:56:53 PM
would never get away with Aaron as son if Claire made it back to the world with her baby. Mum and baby do not make it back together. And remember Kate's reaction when Jack asked about her going to the funeral "why would I go???"

Real shit would have to occured to make Kate despise Claire so much she wouldn't consider going to her funeral. NOT Claire. Same with Ben, but in this case, why would Jack even SUGGEST Kate go? Has to be a person of importance to them, but there was a faling out. Sawyer is not an O-6er. Michael made it back and has an alias (maybe Kevin Johnson???). SO would Walt. Hoffs-Drawler Funeral home was in that neighborhood for a reason - we know this about our writers. Gotta be Michael. Kate wouldn't react that way about Walt. Locke would never come back and I doubt you'd see Jack cry over him. It's a he, that and the neighborhood and no turnout - can't be Juliet.

Process of elimination folks. Gotta be Michael.

loined? joined
by Darkocity
Feb 28th, 2008
05:57:50 PM
2 hours
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
05:58:27 PM
"touches self"
Beauty is
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:04:11 PM
Darlton promised...WE WILL KNOW who is in the coffin before this season is over.

My one question: explain the science behind the Orchid video from comic-com (BUnny 15..."don't let them touch!!!) That would go a long way to solving the biggest island mysteries.

My question from before - thanks for all the answers. I couldn't think of anything more clever than you guys. I like the generic food drop (with little dharma symbols drawn on). Maybe print up a shitload fake Oceanic golden tickets to litter ABC's lawn with.

JUST FINISHED THE LOST GAME
by nrn
Feb 28th, 2008
06:10:23 PM
Turns out the island is really an Alternate reality. When you leave it changes your reality for the person that you've become on the Island. Very very weird. at the end of the game you leave the island only to wake up back on the island RIGHT after the crash, but things going on around you are different. Similar to desmond's flashes.
nrn
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:15:17 PM
I'm not quite sure I understand. So there is really no payoff for leaving the island? YOu just wake back up like its groundhog day? Mirrors some theories bounced around here about the show originally being called "The Circle" and the plot device described therein. So glad the show has not taken that direction. How much you wanna guess that WAS a rejected plotline though??
Peter Watts is in the coffin.
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
06:19:26 PM
Would that be freaky or what?
100% Certainty - The Man in the Coffin
by Dapper Swindler
Feb 28th, 2008
06:29:28 PM
The man in the coffin is John Lantham. How do I know this? Because the newspaper article says so. If you guys would stop wasting your time theorizing and start wasting your time looking at screencap websites then you would know this. Here is what the article reads:

"The body of John Lantham of New York was found shortly after 4 am in the 4300 block of Grand Avenue. Ted Worden, a doorman at the Tower Lofts complex, heard loud noises coming from the victim's loft. Concerned for tenants' safety, he entered the loft and found the body hanging from a beam in the living room. According to Jaime Ortiz, a police spokesman, the incident was deemed a suicide after medical tests. Latham (sic) is survived by one teenaged son. Memorial services will be held at the Hoffs-Drawlar Funeral Home tomorrow evening."

So who the fuck is John Lantham? Probably Michael.
* Michael is from New York
* Michael has reason to use an alias
* Michael has a teenage son
* No one would attend the funeral because everyone who knew Michael thinks he is dead.
* Jack would feel like attending the funeral because it fits his character. Kate wouldn't because it fits her character.
* Jack says he is neither friend nor family because Jack is somewhat famous and an investigation to Jack's relationship with Lantham might reveal he is Michael to the public, which is something Jack does not want.
* Whoever is in the coffin is not what drove Jack to suicide. He was clearly distraught even before reading that article. But it did seem to affirm whatever bad feeling he had and need to go back.

The other possibility is that the man in the coffin truly is John Lantham. A character yet to be introduced.

So can we stop the whole Locke is in the coffin/Ben is in the coffin insanity? Those theories make very little sense.

I'm afraid, in the coffin lies...
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:30:17 PM
Eddie Dean of New York.

Raise a Nozz-a-la for the fallen gunslinger.

Poppins will be served at the wake.

Polar Bear in Tunisia...
by micturatingbenjamin
Feb 28th, 2008
06:36:32 PM
If you were to time travel, one of the tricky bits would be to travel to a time where the Earth was relative in position to where you are when you leave the 'present'.

Because of its hurtling through space, it wouldn't necessarily be in the same position that it was when you left. The entire galaxy spins in a big circle, so if you were trying to send an object into the past, you'd have to find a space AND time that corresponds to the time you left. So a sending yourself back a year ago to the second, and you might be on the other side of the planet if you couldn't direct yourself.

Say the polar bear was sent into the past, but the first 'Earth' space/time it could interact with was waaaaay back when the 'Earth' was in the same position it was when it was sent. Just an idea about how the polar bear ended up in the past.

Dapper
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:38:07 PM
Don't be an ass with your tone. That will get you nowhere around here and I'd hate to see Node get frothy. To take the snideness off your comment, TPTB have stated the newspaper article was a prop and not intended to be read. Any clues therein MAY be written into the show now, but it was not a hint to be analyzed. It was very much a red herring. However - now that clever ones have managed to draw all that out of the prop, our wonderfully creative LOST team may very well give us a payoff. Or just explain it away as a cover story. Or ignore it altogether as a red herring. I am moderately polite - I hope you suffer not the wrath of others that, well, dislike your tone. Just friendly advice - enjoy the TB.
you know who is in the box?
by maxwell's hammer
Feb 28th, 2008
06:41:13 PM
Zombie Luciano Pavarotti. Season 5 will be all about they fit him into that coffin.
Ben
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:41:58 PM
would actually make sense - if Jack felt Ben was his only way Baaaack to the island. Kate's reaction would be spot on - though why Jack would even ask if she went would be weird. We know Ben is around playing dangerous games with Sayid. No friends. Hoffs-Drawler maybe just has a contract with the city for unclaimed corpses. It IS possible, though not likely.
The Statue and Claire
by BigMick
Feb 28th, 2008
06:43:38 PM
Ok, first off, take this first part with a grain of salt because it's something my brother told me regarding the statue with 4 toes. My brother said he saw an interview with JJ Abrams on tv at the end of s.2 and Abrams said that the statue was just something he put in the ep. to throw people off and fuck with 'em. I've never seen this interview so I can't say if it's for sure, but it sounds like something Abrams would do, since he's kind of a pretentious prick like that.

The business with Aaron being with Kate. I don't know why everyone assumes that Claire is dead and Aaron is with Kate voluntarily. Keep in mind that everything in the flash forwards we still don't know what's happening with them and how the storylines on the island play out to get the characters from the present to their storyline in the future. I think 1 of 2 things are happening with Kate and Aaron, either Kate was leaving the island and Claire gave Aaron to her in order to give him a life off the Island. This would explain why Jack does not want to see him, b/c it's a visible reminder that they left everyone behind. OR Kate stole Aaron from Claire before she left and Jack never agreed with this decision and thus never wants to see him. It's just a thought and is obviously unfounded but so is everything else in this TB.

Let me know what you guys think about this, love everything you guys are saying about the show though, giving me lots to think about/anticipate for tonights episode.

Fair Enough
by Dapper Swindler
Feb 28th, 2008
06:48:45 PM
I was going for a kind of joking or facetious tone. Sorry if it came out snide. I'm the last person who would get nasty over something as trivial as this.

Anyway, if the article was just a prop then I would need to see the source where that was confirmed.

Maxwell
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:49:07 PM
Maybe Dexter crossover ep.

He'd cut hm up into 5 hefties - distribute neaty into wood box.

Fuck I love that show. Knew NOTHING about it. Downloaded seasons one and two on a whim after seeing it on CBS. THAT is awesome serialized TV...hooked me in like Angel season 3. And is close to Lost as far as really getting me hyped for the next ep. God how I yearn to be able to just download LOST Seasons 4-6 and just take a weeks vacation, whitecrosses, Diet Mountain Dew, a piss bucket and frozen pizzas. Once again - touching self.

Lost lovers - I HIGHLY recommend UNEDITED/Showtime version of Dexter. 9/10.

Dapper
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:51:39 PM
Good man. I've learned the hard way one must be cognizant of tone or things can escalate...and that's no fun, hey? Guys - can we help Dapper out? Links? I will begin my search. Gotilk, 4we8 - I know you guys have something...
Off of Lostpedia
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:56:30 PM
"The Truth about the Newspaper Clipping Producers have said over and over to disregard the newspaper clipping, as they are going to re-write it. " All i got for now
Lost and other great shows...
by micturatingbenjamin
Feb 28th, 2008
06:59:15 PM
I agree with edshrinker...Dexter can be bought relatively cheaply now on DVD, and the first season is just brilliantly done. Even the watered down CBS series is better than nothing on that network...

If you want something that the Lost producers loved and decided to sort of emulate, should look at an old BBC show called The Prisoner. FANTASTIC show with a really BAD ending. Patrick McGoohan should do an ep of LOST.

LInk
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
06:59:17 PM
http://tinyurl.com/22862j

Just scroll down a little bit to The Truth about the Newspaper Clipping

One Hour
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
07:06:48 PM
Hmm. Pre-cum. I'm shuddering. Maybe a little enhanced EggyTown for fun,

THANKS micturatingbenjamin!!! I seed so much good TV, I'll turn around and download some for a change. Looking forwad to it! Pass the time between Thursdays. Don't forget - if any of ya'llcan't get the ep by 11 pm US/Eastern Time...The Pirate Bay. Edshrinker. wmv (small file size/moderate quality) file. Or just search Lost s04e05

I do this for NO OTHER REASON but for the love of the show and my wish to share to those who can't access it as early as I can. Good Karma. I've been doing the same things with Green Bay Packer games this year - share the, albeit aborted, joy.

micturatingbenjamin
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
07:10:57 PM
Have you seen Dexter season 2 yet? A little different- but IMO jst as engaging as season 1. And Lila. GoodGOdAlmightyGooglyMoogly. British, darkhair, sexy beyond belief. "Pardon my tits" Beautiul line. Best Lila line - after Dex asks "What step was that?" after a scrogging.......

(W/gloriously sexy acccent)"The naughty one".

Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

"hooked me in like Angel season 3"
by Ashok0
Feb 28th, 2008
07:22:58 PM
Alright... first off I have't seen and UPN/WB/CW shows such as Angel. I always assumed they were just teeny bopper monster-of-the-week shows. As a fan of quality serialized TV, I love Twin Peaks and X-Files which are sadly deceased --- and LOST, Dexter, and BSG. Is this show Angel REALLY up to those standards? In all seriousness, is Angel serialized and does it have well done cliffhangers and good writing or is it just another corny diet-serial like Heroes and Prison Break?
Does anyone else think suspect that . . .
by Buffan
Feb 28th, 2008
07:28:08 PM
Ben's man on the boat is Michael?
Buffan
by a rolling stone
Feb 28th, 2008
07:31:16 PM
Wow. That would actually be pretty fucking cool.
I'll say this again about VALIS
by jakelael
Feb 28th, 2008
07:33:20 PM
This time I'll type it as well
by jakelael
Feb 28th, 2008
07:34:36 PM
PKD mentions CS Lewis and Minkowski in the book. He mentions a place where time turns into space. He mentions a black iron prison that is seen when the past, present and future are superimposed on each other.
My VALIS Story
by jakelael
Feb 28th, 2008
07:38:43 PM
I was walking to the SCI-FI Section at Barnes & Noble and on my way a black book with the word 'BORGES' was on the cover. It caught my eye and I stared at it while walking by.

I got to the sci-fi section and the first PKD novel I pulled out was VALIS. On the back it said something about the US having their very own BORGES on their hands. One of the themes in the book has to do with coinciences just like I had just experienced.

Get this. The book Saywer was reading was written by a good friend of Borges and the first cover used for the book was illustrated by Borges' sister.

Is the universe fucking with me? Or am I tapped in? Probably just crazy like PKD. Can't wait for Desi's episode tonight!!!
LOST and good film/tv in general
by jakelael
Feb 28th, 2008
07:46:16 PM
Great article here about how the Cinema has replaced the church in moder culture.

http://tinyurl.com/353ym5
My Theory - and it's actually a good one.
by Yeti
Feb 28th, 2008
07:47:20 PM
Anyone see the 1979 Disney flick "The Black Hole"? I suspect that the island is in essence like the spaceship Cygnus in that movie, literally perched at the edge of..something. Whether it's a wormhole, a "wrinkle in time" or some other type of temperal anomoley, it explains why many of the some of the "others" don't seem to age among other things. Thoughts?
"The Black Hole"
by Yo Yo Ma
Feb 28th, 2008
07:49:24 PM
Good theory Yeti. What is really amazing about it is that you made a reference to "The Black Hole" i thought I was the only person to have seen that movie.
Ashok0
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:01:27 PM
Let me say it this way. I love these shows (past/present NOT distinguished). IN the late 90's - today, my top shelf stuff(no particular order):

Lost, X-Files, B5, Farscape, BSG, 24, Firefly, Arrested Development, Angel, several seasons of Buffy....and I'm CERTAIN one or two will opo in my head as boarderline top shelf. So that gives you my "tastes". Lots of Sci-Fi. What I guess for being raised on Star Wars, Star Trek, Space 1999(SO Underrated tho unrealistic).

So is Angel worth your time? Putting a personal Whedonbias aside, ABSOLUTELY. By season 3, they had surpassed the mothership (Buffy)and began a mytharc that went on for the next two season or or less. And what a ride. Season 1-3 is absolute bliss. 4 was just ok, a little annoying with a character in particular that will just grate on you. Season 5 is a game-changer, enter Spike and exit annoying characters, and the best wrap-up season I could ever imagine. Wanted it to go on - but as it is a WONDERFUL job tying it all up. Whew. Any questions? Would download it - and have - just to re-watch it. I would buy the box set if I had the disposable cheddar for such things.

FAmmit
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:04:02 PM
GodsDamn it NO edit button
Sigh, the problem with these episodes...
by DanielKurland
Feb 28th, 2008
08:04:40 PM
where the entire series is actually a dream, is they always have some open-ended winking-at-you ending, that always has some guy saying, seasons later, "it's all just Desmond's dream!"
What happened before the Title came up?
by Mr. N
Feb 28th, 2008
08:06:00 PM
Just missed the opening, anything big besides the helicopter going down, what was desmond yelling?
aww shit
by instruction
Feb 28th, 2008
08:06:14 PM
my aww shit was supposed to be beFORE the iron commercial, not after it, but,after having seen that, not bad
Mr.N
by Lashlarue
Feb 28th, 2008
08:07:09 PM
You are truly fucked now.
Iron-fucking-Man
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:08:08 PM
plus an hour of Lost. awesome.
Did they rework the tank scene in the Iron Man ad?
by Shermdawg
Feb 28th, 2008
08:08:23 PM
The cg looked better.
Holy FUCK!
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:08:58 PM
Body swapping!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i dunno but the timing of the tank
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:09:41 PM
and the IronMan chord was fucking perfect
THIS is unexpected
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:09:50 PM

by Mr. N
Feb 28th, 2008
08:11:33 PM
No I've figured it out, time is weird, he can't remember the island and is now traveling around in time...
Des
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:12:38 PM
In the past knows what's going on (kinda). Des on the freighter is (in his mind) Army Des and has NO CLUE what is happening to him. Consciousness has switched between the 2 Desmonds. THAT IS FUCKING AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !
How far off course did they go...
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:12:43 PM
wondering if since Desmond was on the left side and Siayd was on the right, did that part of the chopper pass outside of whatever 'time corridor' that they were supposed to be following? consequently unsticking him in time?
IRON MAN looks like shit
by Pipple
Feb 28th, 2008
08:12:51 PM
that's all
This is weird.
by Lashlarue
Feb 28th, 2008
08:13:03 PM
Iron Man trailer was kinda of a mixed bag.
Huh, kinda like the Butterfly Effect
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:14:02 PM
swapping conciousness
Now we need Obama. It's time for a change.
by Lashlarue
Feb 28th, 2008
08:15:55 PM
Man, the election can't get here soon enough. I'm sick of these ads.
Ashok0....
by DanielKurland
Feb 28th, 2008
08:17:37 PM
My favorite TV shows are probably Twin Peaks, Sports Night, Arrested Development, Seinfeld, Lost, and Angel. I consider Angel season 3 and 4 to have some of the best season long arc stories ever seen. Yes, Angel does get a bad rap for the genre, and being associated with Buffy which was associated with teen girls to begin with, but Angel is fantastic. Very, very good. Also, this episode of Lost is fine so far, but it doesn't feel like a season four episode, if that makes any sense, and with Cuse and Lindelof writing, that's unusual

by Mr. N
Feb 28th, 2008
08:20:10 PM
nevermind, body swap it is.
Oh fuck me, it's the Koopa cousin
by Pipple
Feb 28th, 2008
08:20:31 PM
Iggy, right? I didn't know he was still alive. cool.
Ashok0
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:21:33 PM
We have too much beautiful LOST to tool with now so I'll just say this re: Angel. Like most shows, it took a bit of time season 1 to get its legs and to establish their identity apart from Buffy.

It took until they killed off a main character, brought in others (God I love Julie Benz), to really get in flow. They fall victim to a silly alternate reality mini-arc, but that was only a couple eps. When Darla (Julie B.)turns up - this show becomes completely addictive.

ah hell... multiverse theory anyone?
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:23:50 PM
1996
by edshrinker
Feb 28th, 2008
08:23:51 PM
And a look of "uh-huh, exactly" by Danny. Hey Des - drop by the next time you are in 1996. How cool is that.
What?!
by Heelboy
Feb 28th, 2008
08:23:54 PM
Because I need You to find me.
"I need you to find me"
by Fount of Useless Info
Feb 28th, 2008
08:24:57 PM
Brilliant.
br1947I was thinkin crisis on infinite earths
by instruction
Feb 28th, 2008
08:25:14 PM
that would work
by br1947
Feb 28th, 2008
08:25:49 PM
br1947
by instruction
Feb 28th, 2008
08:25:57 PM
I was thinkin crisis on infinite earths