Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

first
by catman
Mar 16th, 2007
10:32:29 AM
guess this is better than more GG
So help me out here.
by savagexp
Mar 16th, 2007
10:43:33 AM
I've just started watching these DVDs. It's obvious to me that this is a serialized show with at least one main "case" being worked on at all times.

My question is, is this show like MURDER ONE, where each season has a different "case"? Or is it more X-FILES with an over-arching "conspiracy"?

I'm asking becuase, as much as I've liked the first three episodes, I don't want to invest if I'm not going to get closure to at least the current "case."
savagexp
by darthuser
Mar 16th, 2007
10:51:01 AM
Structurally, the show is closer to X-FILES than MURDER ONE. In terms of quality and bringing a real sense of closure, MARS is closer to MURDER ONE than X-FILES.

Keep watching. Closure will be yours, my friend.
Jim Rockford Smile Says It All?
by Darth Fabulous
Mar 16th, 2007
10:51:05 AM
Versus the Larry Sander dejection? Is this some kind of Herculean subliminal mindfuck? Let's just cross our fingers and bow our heads that VM survives this bullshit, because this no knowing is killing me.
Not a bad idea
by rockgolf
Mar 16th, 2007
10:51:14 AM
Veronica as an FBI cadet. Could open a realm of new possiblities. Maybe they could rename it "Mars on Life".
FBI thing would be awesome.
by zabu 123
Mar 16th, 2007
11:01:01 AM
I'm just sayin.
glimmer of hope
by Atomik Steve
Mar 16th, 2007
11:02:42 AM
better than nothing i suppose.
SAVAGEXP
by wackybantha
Mar 16th, 2007
11:06:48 AM
This cool show is like MURDER ONE for the first 2 seasons in that each season covers one big case. The 3rd season followed that format for the first half but will supposedly now shift to one mystery per episode....assuming they're not canceled. I hope there's more life to VERONICA MARS: The FBI years. Will she run into Fox and Dana out in the field?
TEAM HER UP WITH SPECIAL AGENT DALE COOPER...
by DanielKurland
Mar 16th, 2007
11:11:47 AM
And then you have the best show that was ever created. Ever.
Kristin is not a cunt.
by Hercules
Mar 16th, 2007
11:13:41 AM
She's actually been incredibly cool to me and this site and a lot of other parties over the years- and she doesn't fuck up a lot.

What I think may have happened? Some of her sources may have been agents or managers or publicists or execs alerted to the fact that a lot of VM cast members of actors were not getting asked back for next season. Her sources may have leapt to the conclusion that the show itself was definitely finished.

I'm guessing if the show comes back at all, it will come back under the FBI plan.
Still hope
by radjac33
Mar 16th, 2007
11:15:31 AM
I just left a message on her My Space.
I find the fast foward thing interesting...
by erichaislar
Mar 16th, 2007
11:20:58 AM
I kinda like the idea.
Let's just split the difference and have a show about
by Hyperion Consul
Mar 16th, 2007
11:39:56 AM
a fresh young cunt solving crimes for the FBI. her partner could be assy mcgee. "assy and the cunt: the two holes of justice"
Wait...make that...
by Hyperion Consul
Mar 16th, 2007
11:45:10 AM
TWO HOLES OF GREAT JUSTICE
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
by RaveX
Mar 16th, 2007
11:54:22 AM
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSS

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSS

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSS

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSS

Damnit!
by supergary452
Mar 16th, 2007
11:57:15 AM
I was SOOOO hoping it was true. Jeez. It's because of the dumb UPN shows like Mars and Everybody Hates Chris and the overly-extended WB shows like 7th heaven and One Tree Hill that cool stuff like Mercy Reef/Aquaman wasn't aired and other cool shows weren't made.
Get the fuck out of here with that homo Mercy Reef....
by Mr. Profit
Mar 16th, 2007
12:04:32 PM
Nonsense. Gimme a fucking break. Mars is an excellent show. And Chris is another good show that suffered from neglect by The CW. Remember that Chris got high ratings for UPN and it even beat Joey. Now it's nowhere near the ratings it got because The CW decided to put it on a Sunday night. The CW is retarded. And Supergary focus your hate toward 7th Heaven or Runaway of the Badussy Cat Whores. Don't hate on Mars.
FBI is a great idea
by Fabulous Freak
Mar 16th, 2007
12:33:20 PM
Move it foreward. Bell's hot ass and Thomas' wicked pen are all the show needs as far as i'm concerned. Keeping Keith written in would be sweet though.
First Shia LaBeouf is NOT in Indy IV, and now this!
by YackBacker
Mar 16th, 2007
12:43:39 PM
Not AICN's fault, alls I'm saying is that we ought to expect nothing in terms of concrete accuracy to any "insider" news we read on the internet.
you know, I'm ok with this
by oisin5199
Mar 16th, 2007
12:57:19 PM
As long as her Dad's still in the picture somewhat (he's my favorite character on the show). Maybe a guest spot for Logan, Wallace, Mac and Weevil every now and then. But they don't need to be regulars. And they have to come up with some excellent new supporting characters that they'll actually use. I kinda hope it's the academy setting and not the full-fledged agent thing. I just think it will be more interesting and believable.
I think you miss the point
by Don Lockwood
Mar 16th, 2007
01:09:37 PM
"Would it be the same show without Mac, Wallace, Weevil and daddy Mars?" No, of course it wouldn't be. And The Powers That (w)Be want it that way. That's why they're pushing for a format change. They want a different show. They want a show that gets ratings AND critical appeal. My idea? Have Veronica Mars stay the same and become the first original series for the Sleuth channel.
Kristin
by NudeandAroused
Mar 16th, 2007
01:16:47 PM
Is way cool and the person who called her that should be reprimanded. To the matter at hand, I truly hope the show stays on the air.
DanielKurland
by nalapou
Mar 16th, 2007
01:25:24 PM
Special Agent Dale Cooper and Veronica Mars together... probably the best idea i have ever heard in my life. Good job.
she might not be a cunt
by punto
Mar 16th, 2007
01:35:09 PM
(and I have nothing against personally), but she's not an ethically responsable journalist. We've seen her pull some shit before, reporting some unfounded rumor and then act like "oh noes, they lied to me, I'm the victim" when she knew it was bullshit 10 minutes after she posted it. I don't know if this is the case, since this just came out and we know nothing about it, but I don't trust her.
Give it up already!!
by jojo-pimp
Mar 16th, 2007
01:58:05 PM
even if its not 100% cancelled, they probably will only do half a season at most, and that will be it!! this show has been on its way out and limping along for like 2 years now.....time to give it up. at least smallville has increased its raitings this season
I still like the show, but this 3rd season is
by MrFloppy
Mar 16th, 2007
02:12:14 PM
missing the point. And Mac/Wallace? Where are they? I love them, but with their current status, they won't be a big loss. I'm dying to see that trailer!
the FBI idea seems cool:
by newc0253
Mar 16th, 2007
02:21:01 PM
but it'd be a shame if Rob Thomas is only doing it for the sake of keeping the network happy, rather than as an organic development of the story and the characters. somehow it seems like the former, rather than the latter.
Ethically responsible journalist?
by Novaman5000
Mar 16th, 2007
02:41:02 PM
Kristin is an entertainment news reporter and gossip "disher". She's totally allowed to print gossip or rumors, if they apply, and these did. Besides, she seems cool enough, and everyone once in a while she has a really good scoop.
though isn't it interesting
by oisin5199
Mar 16th, 2007
03:08:25 PM
that so many shows fall apart in the college years? It seems like no one ever finishes college in teen shows. Same with Buffy.
Thomas and the FBI...
by DanielKurland
Mar 16th, 2007
03:11:16 PM
What I interpreted this as is that he fully expected Veronica to be at the FBI in four years, and would have had it happen over four years, but now that he sees that the show wouldn't last that long, he's going to jump to the conclusion. I don't see this as a "Hmm, let's put her at the FBI?" type of thing, it's more like "Well, we're going to be gone soon. Let's jump to the FBI"
I like Kristen
by fatsackowind
Mar 16th, 2007
03:16:47 PM
And I like Veronica Mars F.B.I too if it has Mac working as a tech, and daddy mars moves out to Va. with Vro. I can lose the rest, and meet a whole new set of characters. Rob could contrive ways to get the other characters involved at some point, but I wouldn't mind the microscope to land somewhere besides Neptune.
keith moving to quantico
by punto
Mar 16th, 2007
03:29:10 PM
No. Keith, as a small time local sheriff, finds the dead body of a local girl. the FBI sends one of their agents, the young Veronica, to investigate the murder, in relation with a serial killler they've been tracking for a while. What secrets will Veronica unearth in the mysterious town of Neptune?
Hmm
by Demosthenes2
Mar 16th, 2007
03:52:21 PM
I don't know about the jump ahead, but I'll take whatever Veronica I can get in this state. PLEASE STAY. This and The OC (I can't believe how great the last season was after an abominable third) were the only teen shows I've liked since Buffy went bye-bye and Gilmore Girls lost the Palladinos and subsequently went lame-o, and now I might be losing them all in one fall sweep. BWAH! What's even going to be on the CW next season if this gets canceled? I don't think any of their dramas are doing so hot, except heavyweight Gilmore, and there's no way the execs could've gotten the leads to stick around without the Palladinos; what were they thinking? CW should've picked up OC too. But regardless, VERONICA. I don't know how they think canceling their only critically acclaimed show that also has that coveted diehard cult fanbase for DVD sales is a justifiable move.
Either way, Season Three is still terrible.
by Freakemovie
Mar 16th, 2007
04:29:47 PM
People can say what they want about Lost losing quality in its third season, but the show that really shot itself in the foot was Veronica Mars. I was a diehard viewer of the first two seasons, but I finally gave up on the third season about 11 episodes in. A lot of it had to do with the necessary move away from the great setting of Neptune High, but: the stupid rape plot, the sporadic month-long disappearances of favorites like Wallace and Mac, the decidedly non-compelling new characters, and the achievement of actually making Veronica and Logan boring drove me away for good.

Obviously Rob Thomas has an inkling of the nose-dive in quality if he's planning on jumping ahead past Hearst College and into an FBI-training setting. It will turn it into a completely different show, but it's really not a bad idea; I'll be willing to give it another shot. If it gets renewed, that is.
Veronica is an actual agent...
by filmfanatic1
Mar 16th, 2007
04:32:30 PM
This latest from http://community.tvguide.com/t hread.jspa?messageID=800085381 � "And while we're clearing up false rumors, let me set the record straight about all this Veronica Mars fourth-season flash-forward business. Contrary to reports, Rob Thomas' retooled Mars would not take place at an FBI Academy, with Veronica serving as a trainee. Our favorite snarky sleuth would be an actual agent. Personally, I love the idea — even though it would probably trigger a major cast purge."
"Veronica Mars, FBI"
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Mar 16th, 2007
05:36:30 PM
So the premise would probably be: Sassy Veronica Mars, a green FBI agent, returns to her hometown of Neptune, CA to solve a crime. Her father is either the sheriff or a PI. (I'm banking that Thomas will have Keith remain the sheriff, under this format change.) Veronica gets reacquainted with her high school love, Logan. Over the course of the season, her best friend Wallace, now a famous basketball star, shows up in Neptune for an episode. ... This would be a radical change. I'm not sure if I would like it, to be honest.
Freakemovie
by YackBacker
Mar 16th, 2007
05:47:23 PM
I agree 100% with your assessment of this season. They did shoot themselves in the foot- the stories were completely forgettable, and add to that, Veronica became truly unlikeable, which is a HUGE freakin' no-no for any form of entertainment. Whatever the case, Rob Thomas certainly didn't earn a fourth season based on what he and his writers delivered in this do-or-die situation. Really sad.
FBI
by Bob of the Shire
Mar 16th, 2007
06:06:45 PM
Just FYI, but the show was headed in that direction anyway. There are several hints of this in Season 3 and Sir Thomas has talked about the FBI being the ultimate destination of the show before. Jumping forward would be fine with me, as long as Mac and Keith are still in it. I've been wanting them to drop Wallace since Season 1 and if Piz, Parker, Logan, or Weevil got cut, I wouldn't mind too much. Actually, if they do this jump, I probably see Veronica and Logan being married by that point, and they can focus on FBI whatnot and avoid all the love drama bullshit.
Logan and Mac...
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Mar 16th, 2007
07:08:12 PM
Nah I can't see Veronica and Logan married in this fast-forward premise. I see Thomas essentially rebooting the series. In my speculated series premise above, the premiere would play out like the pilot for a new show. It would be about a new FBI agent lady who returns to her hometown, which has its share of secrets. She crosses paths with her bad-boy high school sweetheart (Logan), who will probably be wrapped up in some business shenanigans. Keith will be the sheriff. And as much as I love Mac, I can't see her factoring much into this new show: "Veronica Mars, FBI".
How to keep Mac
by Jim Jam Bongs
Mar 16th, 2007
07:17:27 PM
Have her working for Kane Software. Kane Software has a division that handles government contracts. The FBI uses Kane Software's services. So there you go. That's how Mac could be factored into this new format. I agree: Thomas is planning to reboot the whole show.
Don't You Wish Your Show Was Hot Like Me?
by The Selecter
Mar 17th, 2007
03:36:28 AM
Sorry, I had to. I like and enjoy the show, but RT needs to grow a real spine. All along, he has played CW's bitch and constantly remade the show and shuffled the cast in and out to please the network and their accountants.

Then just weeks ago, he was saying that there would be no closer episode or closure, and practically daring the network to cancel the show.

Things have kinda changed now, haven't they? No doubt Kristen Bell has a career ahead of her (hopefully not making crappy horror movies like her spiritual predecessor, Buffy), but is RT that afraid he'll never get another show made to have to kowtow to the heads of a second-rate "network"? I hope he has more pride than that.

VM got almost three seasons, and people should be thankful; I am. On a big network, it might not have lasted three episodes with the ratings it drew. Sad but true.
Isn't E! also the one that...
by mrfan
Mar 17th, 2007
07:42:32 PM
got everyones hopes for a season six of Angel by saying it wasn't cancelled?
Isn't E! also one of the reasons why...
by nemesisdarkside
Mar 17th, 2007
09:49:59 PM
Paris Hilton got so famous, so quick for doing nothing. ;P

Kristin Veitch is cool though.

Veronica Mars FBI
by nemesisdarkside
Mar 17th, 2007
09:59:09 PM
I'll REALLY miss Keith, Wallace and Mac if they are not in the show. More so than Logan and I love his character!

I was really looking forward to the last arc which was supposed to be Wallace/Mac based. I guess I just wanted to see the friendship of Veronica/Wallace/Mac explored more.

I thought the CW was going to be a good thing for VM. Season 3 hasn't been as good, but I've still enjoyed it. However, I feel the mystery-long arc format suits the show better than mini-arcs.

Oh well, I don't how to feel about all of this. Sword of Damocles anyone? :(

I don't KNOW how to feel...
by nemesisdarkside
Mar 17th, 2007
10:04:41 PM
I'll be the millionth hasty poster to complain about an edit function when I was too lazy to proof-read. ;D
Veronica Mars going all Silence of the Lambs. SWEET!
by The Outlander
Mar 18th, 2007
04:17:22 AM
Now all they need to find is Veronica's equivilent to Hanabel Lechter.
Leave the show as is.
by Megaladon
Mar 18th, 2007
07:55:38 AM
They must be making a mint on this show on DVD. Why mess with it?
First FBI Show Idea
by Itchy
Mar 18th, 2007
08:51:03 AM
Veronica comes to a prison to interview a mass murderer for clues how to catch another guy, and I throw cum on her face. Guest Starring Frankie Muniz as Hannibal Vector and Artie Lange as Director Jack Crawfish.
Kristin Veitch Sucks
by Spuncho
Mar 18th, 2007
08:57:31 AM
Her "sources" are the press releases we've all read. She just adds her own opinion to what we already know and then foists it upon us as a "scoop" of some sort.
WM Where?
by Mr_X
Mar 18th, 2007
10:56:18 AM
the fbi idea sounds cool, getting vm to come back to neptune to help solve a case also sounds cool. i would like keith to stick around and logan, the rest of the cast im afriad is dipensible. weevil poor weevil, what happened to you man?
God, please don't set the show in the FBI!
by johnnysunshine
Mar 18th, 2007
01:58:27 PM
They spent all season setting up the world. Jumping ahead three years would pretty much get rid of both the concept of the show and all the supporting characters people love. Maybe they won't get better ratings if they stick with what makes the show work, but totally changing it will only cause them to lose half the viewers that love the show. Just give us one more season with a good season-long arc - PLEASE! That's all I want from you CW. I'm sure there's nothing you've got in development that is better than this show. No, not even a second season of find the Pussycat Doll.
Frankly...
by CatVutt
Mar 18th, 2007
03:46:12 PM
Jumping years ahead could be the best thing that could happen to this show. Come up with a really solid season-long arc, jump in en media res so that your new characters have questionable motivations ala the first season, keep Keith and hopefully Wallace around in some respect, and I think it could be fantastic. Logan? I've kinda come to feel like they've run that storyline into the ground. He can show up for a guest spot ala Angel on Season 4 of Buffy.
I Like!
by arzbest
Mar 18th, 2007
06:24:55 PM
As a big fan of the show, I've gradually come to the realization that this show, as is, will never be a big hit. It still has that "Nancy Drew" aura (though undeserved) that may explain why it doesn't gain any ground in the ratings. So, I think "Veronica Mars FBI" can only show improved ratings in the world of three CSI's, three Law and Order's, NCIS, Criminal Minds, and 20 other similar shows. (....as long as the writing staff, Veronica, Keith, Mac, Wallace, and Logan are still around!) Who wouldn't want to see Kristen Bell kick ass and take no prisoners as an FBI agent? The line forms here! CW - go for it!
A long time ago ...
by heroic_duo
Mar 19th, 2007
12:04:17 PM
This used to be good A long time ago this show was so good But I Haven't liked it lately at all
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.