Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

I just used the T.A.R.D.I.S...
by Billyeveryteen
Dec 1st, 2006
12:04:37 AM
To be First.
So does Torchwood still suck?
by Alonzo Mosely
Dec 1st, 2006
01:28:48 AM
I watched the first four and they were horrible, wondered if it got any better...
Touch wood
by mulberry
Dec 1st, 2006
02:25:21 AM
Torchwood still gives the impression that its main target audience is chubby, middle aged welsh gay men with a lifelong interest in sci-fi. There are the beginnings of suggestions of a series story arc. Main problem is that the episodes themselves are badly paced (slow first 35 mins, then rush to resolution), with cringeworthy dialogue and little in the way of interesting characters. The endings seem to revolve around suddenly concocting an out-of-context 'will this mean I am as bad as the enemy I am fighting' moral dilemma, which usually split the team jack vs the rest, he shouts a bit, tells them he's right and dispatches baddy of week. No team cohesion, or any sense that the Torchwood organisation is anything but a bunch of over-funded incompetents. In wales. Aliesbian last week was good.
Torturewood
by kwisatzhaderach
Dec 1st, 2006
03:10:05 AM
It's one of the worst pieces of television i've seen in my life. Really. I'm not exaggerating. It is woeful.
If its so bad Lemming
by themanlikedave
Dec 1st, 2006
05:10:55 AM
why do you and you taff mates still watch it every week?
lemming and mulberry..
by batjack
Dec 1st, 2006
05:13:30 AM
... what they said! I'm also from Cardiff.. right in Torchwood ground central ...and I spend most Thursday nights in the pub with the boys taking the piss out of it. What it seems to me is, that its unfinished; it always needs another draught, and that it seems more to be based around the gay sex theme than the actual supposed thriller / sf elements of the show. It's a shame as the show has so much potential. The viewing figures are huge (must be all those bloody repeats) so it's bound to be picked up. Gotta go: they're filming Dr Who down the road so I've got to move my car. Nos da.
Aliesbian
by mulberry
Dec 1st, 2006
05:21:49 AM
In case I was unclear: Aliesbian=Alien Lesbian. Sounds OK when said, looks stupid written down. (I hereby copyright the word)
Okay, this has turned into a torchwood talkbalk ...
by Dalius
Dec 1st, 2006
08:56:36 AM
... so here's my two-pennies worth : Overall, I think it's a fun series with some great dialogue and some clever sci-fi ideas. In terms of implementation though, some episodes work better than others. My one complaint is that when they said each episode would give one of the characters a chance to come to the fore, what they meant was each episode would give one of the characters a chance to overact shamefully. Gwen especially seems to have got the wide-eyed rabbit-caught-in-headlights look down perfect. The writers also seem to have set themselves a challenge to see how many perfect innocent same-sex kisses they can get in 13 episodes. Doing well so far !!! P.S. Nice interview Gaspode !
loved this two-parter...
by lynxpro
Dec 1st, 2006
11:05:53 AM
Although it isn't really *Alien* or *Aliens*...more like a mix between *The Prince of Darkness* and *Event Horizon* with some touches of *The Black Hole*. SciFi should have shown the two-parter as a movie on Halloween.
TorchWould
by Smashing
Dec 1st, 2006
11:41:00 AM
I love Torchwood, it is funny and a little subversive, all the detractors have admitted they still watch so what does that say about them?
Smashing
by mulberry
Dec 1st, 2006
11:55:37 AM
that we're really desperate.
Dalius
by Thomas Cromwell
Dec 1st, 2006
12:01:49 PM
I agree with you about the stupid amount of homosexual references/kisses/shags/ in the show. Philoctetes (or was it Maria?) in that last episode would have worked just as well as a man and Gwen didn't need to snog that girl in episode 2. Its probably in RTD's contract as exec producer (if there isn't any gay references I'm off boyo) But still, at least Torchwood is better than Robin Hood with its silly costumes and anachronistic chracters (black nuns and Arab women in 1192 England)
Thomas Cromwell
by batjack
Dec 1st, 2006
01:37:41 PM
Actually there probably were Black nuns and Arab women in the UK in those times: Crusaders married Arab women on their travels and Black people were here at least six hundred years before the bloody Anglo Saxons.. But anyway, Robin Hood is indeed, shit. Am I the only one who thinks that Gisborne would have been a much better Robin (and Actor) than the yoof they picked?
batjack
by Thomas Cromwell
Dec 1st, 2006
02:49:16 PM
Sir, I stand corrected on England's multicultural history, and yes Richard Armitage is a good actor. He was excellent alongside Shirley Henderson in 'Frozen' (best recent film to be made in Britain)
Not interested in Torchwood!
by skydemon
Dec 1st, 2006
03:20:58 PM
Sounds like crap to me. The Impossible Planet was an excellent chapter, I can’t wait for the second part tonight. One little gripe, what the hell with this Doctor Who series DVD sets priced in the stratosphere??
"The Satan Pit" -- **** (out of 5)
by SpyGuy
Dec 1st, 2006
03:42:23 PM
Although Sci Fi earns even more demerits for interrupting a two-parter with a cheesy TV movie on Thanksgiving, "The Satan Pit" is well worth the wait.

Sadly, next week brings the unholy abomination called "Love & Monsters," so do yourself a favor and watch your SPACED or LIFE ON MARS bootleg DVDs instead. You'll be glad you did.

disagree with Spyguy...
by lynxpro
Dec 1st, 2006
05:39:27 PM
If you have a TiVo, record next week's episode and/or have your TV on next week but don't feel like you have to watch it. The ratings need to stay up. But yeah, episodes 10 and 11 suck. 12 and 13 which are the two-part season finale rock. In fact, they rock so hard that you forget RTD penned them.
As everyone is answering my questions...
by Alonzo Mosely
Dec 1st, 2006
07:41:13 PM
When does series 2 of Life on Mars start showing on British TV? SO I can be ready to fire up the old torrentmobile...
TomBodet is a tool...
by lynxpro
Dec 2nd, 2006
02:40:23 PM
Really, do you watch any of these shows or do you continue to spout your defective opinions instead? Go back to watching VR-5, ya gimp.
Alonzo...
by slapshot
Dec 2nd, 2006
03:22:19 PM
I've got Life on Mars Series 2 on order from Amazon UK with a release date of March 19. Assuming the same 8 episodes as before, it'll have to be on the air Feb. at the latest. Anyone know if Torchwood or Who Series 3 has been picked up by the SciFi channel? Be kinda nice to get the next Christmas special on Christmas here, as opposed to next October or whatever... (And don't believe the haters: "Love and Monsters" is a GREAT episode. Unless you hate ELO...)
Thanks Slapshot
by Alonzo Mosely
Dec 2nd, 2006
04:07:35 PM
Me and the old woman enjoyed the hell out of the first season of Life on Mars... Me especially, as a Brit relocated to Yank Land, it brought back fond memories of watching The Sweeney as a kid... Git yer trousers on, your nicked my son...
"He (Torchwood) runs through a door"?
by SpyGuy
Dec 2nd, 2006
10:23:31 PM
Of COURSE he does.

See, kids, TomBodet is a prime example of why you shouldn't do drugs. If you get stoned, you'll fuck somebody and TomBodet will be the result in nine months. Remember, friends don't let friends create retard babies like TomBodet.

Tom Bidet-The One Trick Pony
by Kenny8
Dec 4th, 2006
03:58:18 AM
Too fuckin lame for words
Who author Craig Hinton dies...
by Finklestone
Dec 4th, 2006
09:51:24 AM
... his books were crap though, so it's no big loss really.
Torchwood will probably end up on BBCA...
by lynxpro
Dec 4th, 2006
11:32:32 AM
I don't know how many episodes of *Afterlife* were made, but I can definitely see *Torchwood* being sandwiched inbetween *Doctor Who* and *Hex* for BBC America's "Scifi Saturday" programming block. Wha, nobody is mentioning that Patrick Stewart's *The 11th Hour* premieres tonight (Monday) on BBCA here in the States?
The 11th Hour
by Finklestone
Dec 4th, 2006
11:42:10 AM
The 11th Hour was sadly pretty awful - not Torchwood awful, obviously, but awful all the same.
stay tuned...
by lynxpro
Dec 5th, 2006
01:43:02 PM
Army of Ghosts/Doomsday rock. You can skip the two episodes inbetween, but if you are a Nielsen family member or have a TiVo, set the TiVo to record the next skippable episodes but keep your tv on (and turned on by your TiVo's remote control). That way it will report that you watched them [live]. The show needs ratings/aggregate viewing data.
Complete Alien Ripoff
by P2H
Dec 5th, 2006
04:49:53 PM
I liked a lot about this episode, but it was a complete rip-off from the movie Alien. The monster picking them off one by one. The tunnel sequence - even with the commander directing them and the Ood chasing...WTF was that? Also anyone happen to notice that the Ood were a complete ripoff from Dungeons & Dragons Mindflayers. Just sayin'. But I still liked some of what they did here. I really do wish all Dr. Who were two 1 hour shows each week, so we can watch a complete story rather than a rushed one.
P2H
by lynxpro
Dec 6th, 2006
06:41:34 PM
If you thought it ripped off *Alien*, then you need to turn in your movie geek credential card. Its closer to *Event Horizon* and *The Prince of Darkness* than it ever comes close to being *Alien*. Geez.
Alien??
by Kenny8
Dec 6th, 2006
06:47:04 PM
Yeah, much closer to "Event Horizon", to be sure...and like Alien wasn't "influenced" by anything. "monster picking them off one by one" was hardly original in "Alien" In fact Doctor Who covered that forty years ago.
Picking of one by one
by Kamikaze Skeleton
Dec 7th, 2006
03:30:11 AM
...not just Alien doing it 30 years ago, Doctor who doing it 40 years ago, The creature form the black lagoon did it 50 years ago. People getting picked off one by one is pretty much ubiquitious through the history of scary stories. And they've been around as long as we've had society. So don't go around with the heavy ahdned "ripp off" stick smacking a show around that doesn't deserve a rip off smacking.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.