Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Talkbacks

first?
by landster
Nov 15th, 2006
06:12:30 PM
.
This is too geeky...
by squiddude
Nov 15th, 2006
06:23:36 PM
Even for THIS site.
Cold be hand and heart and bone?
by cyberskunk
Nov 15th, 2006
06:29:36 PM
"Cold be hand and heart and bone. Cold be travelers far from home" is a twist on a song that a barrow wight gave in _The Fellowship of the Ring_.

I found it...

"Cold be hand and heart and bone, and cold be sleep under stone: never more to wake on stony bed, never, till the Sun fails and the Moon is dead. In the black wind the stars shall die, and still on gold here let them lie, till the Dark Lord lifts his hand over dead sea and withered land.

Too geeky...lol
by Rupee88
Nov 15th, 2006
07:30:12 PM
Yeah, when he asked him if he FANTASIZED the music for The Hobbit, and Shore laughed, I wonder if he was laughing at the question.
geeky? Whatever, that music moves me
by Pipple
Nov 15th, 2006
07:33:31 PM
I'll buy this.
Ok then.
by vivavitalogy
Nov 15th, 2006
07:47:02 PM
"It’s easily one of the more notable commercial releases in the history of film music." Says you.
the music is great, but...
by jrbarker
Nov 15th, 2006
07:53:48 PM
...you would have to be a huge LOTR fan to plunk down 75 bucks for this set, as well done as it probably is.
(laughing)
by Neo Technic
Nov 15th, 2006
08:25:34 PM
Hahahaha...fuck, we need to gert that Hobit movie out now before important characters die. And another subject, who is seriously going to buy this? This has to cost like $35-$50. Guess if you need a soundtrack for your epic D+D battles. Nerds.
the unused music is the highlight of the album
by mikey mike
Nov 15th, 2006
08:33:10 PM
all the original stuff like that got cut out are back in the album and it's a treat. especially on the "Gandalf the White" track and the last 58 secs. of the "Nazgul Attack" cue. hope there's a future DVD release that will have all the music back in place. and dammit scorekeeper when will you review it
Scorekeeper, you lucky bastard!
by Godardwhowhatnow
Nov 15th, 2006
09:44:41 PM
The complete recording for Fellowship is great. I can't wait for TT and ROTK.
$75 bucks for a four disc set is a wee bit pricey
by mortsleam
Nov 15th, 2006
11:09:42 PM
I'd love to have all of the music for these movies, but I just can't buy CDs anymore. iTunes hath ruined me. There has to be someone that I know that is an even bigger LOTR geek than I am that would buy this and burn copies for me. Hmmm...
Hobbit movie!
by werideatdusk
Nov 15th, 2006
11:10:23 PM
How I yearn for thou!
scorekeeper is...
by Seph_J
Nov 16th, 2006
12:50:41 AM
...by far the best contributer to this site. Long may he continue to take this as seriously as he does. And the lord of the rings music truly is the greatest score ever written.
Scorekeeper, you lucky bastard!
by soladeo1
Nov 16th, 2006
12:50:43 AM
I know ScoreKeeper.... I went to high school with ScoreKeeper.... I was the best man at his wedding.... Yes, indeed, the ScoreKeeper is one lucky bastard.....
lost ark soundtrack would be MY precious...
by Acne Scarface
Nov 16th, 2006
01:20:06 AM
if only it were reissued.
brilliant releases
by Evil Hobbit
Nov 16th, 2006
05:18:23 AM
but I have one little tiny nitpick; why the hell doesn't the package colors match the color of the extended en now limited edition releases? It is fellowship green, towers red, king blue. Now the fellowship comes out and it's red. Now we get the towers and it's blue. I mean, King will be green then? Why? This looks so stupid on my shelf. It's bitching, but it annoys me. Such a superb release and then the colors doesn't match the dvd releases. Either they should have sticked with red for all the complete recordings or they should have made the colors match with there dvd releases.
Jackson better make The Hobbit
by Fridge
Nov 16th, 2006
06:38:51 AM
Or I'll be one sad panda.
Jackson better NOT make The Hobbit
by The Decider
Nov 16th, 2006
08:56:35 AM
He hardly understood LotR, and it sounds like he understands The Hobbit even less.
Shore's music...
by Thomas Cromwell
Nov 16th, 2006
11:04:59 AM
...gives me goose pimples, especially the Rohan theme with the Norwegian fiddle.
Wish he had asked about Kong
by DufusyteII
Nov 16th, 2006
11:59:03 AM
"Do you have any comments on King Kong05?" Shore: "Kong05 was a disappointing film and I'm happy in retrospect to have had nothing to do with it." (I made that up, but it's my sentiments, and probably Shore's as well.) Now, if PJ does the Hobbit, which I agree is a dubious proposition, considering his very disappointing treatment of Kong, I just hope PJ does not turn it into a satirical lampoon like he did Kong05, and I hope PJ would have the good sense to keep Shore on as the composer AND OBEY ALL OF SHORE's ARTISTIC IDEAS. I recall PJ dumped Shore from Kong05 due to artisit differences; well we now can see that Shore probably had better artistic ideas for Kong05 than PJ did. So on the Hobbit, PJ must obey Shore on all artisitic ideas. And Shore should fire PJ from the Hobbit two weeks before the deadline and bring on a different Director.
Howard Shore kicks Elfman's repetitive ass.
by ZeroCorpse
Nov 16th, 2006
01:44:23 PM
LOTR had an amazing, moving, non-gimmicky score that aided the film, rather than taking it over. Kudos to Shore for doing what a composer must do: Make a movie complete.
Question about the Complete Recordings
by chrth
Nov 16th, 2006
05:40:03 PM
Can you listen to it like it's a soundtrack? In other words, do the tracks follow one another like the 1-disc soundtrack, or do they have several tracks in a row of different music from the same scene?
Chrth:
by Korassa
Nov 16th, 2006
06:14:25 PM
Yes, all the tracks on the set are in the order they are heard (or would be heard, in the case of unused cues) in the film. Ditto with the FOTR set. These sets are utterly magnificent, and worth every damn penny.
why do you idiots keep confusing Elfman with Zimmer
by mikey mike
Nov 16th, 2006
08:06:10 PM
and zero corpse do yourself a favor and either find out what really happened on spider-man 2 in regards to the music or shut up. go listen to hans zimmer copy paste his music
Korassa: thanks
by chrth
Nov 16th, 2006
08:11:13 PM
To mortsleam and Evil Hobbit
by ScoreKeeper
Nov 16th, 2006
10:46:14 PM
mortsleam-If it helps, the complete recordings ARE available on iTunes for only $40. It's not as cheap as getting a burned copy from a friend but it's far more legal. Evil Hobbit-I agree with your complaint about the color discrepencies from the DVD box sets. It is an ultra picky thing but hey, consistency would've been nice.
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.