Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Capone -VS- NACHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO LIBRE!!


Hey everyone. Capone in Chicago here to tell you that we have a problem.

We're well into the summer movie season, with at least one major release hitting theatres every week (this week, it's more like three semi-majors). My point is, nothing is shaping up to be as good as I want it to be, and it's not because my expectations are astronomically high.

On paper, this was supposed to be the summer that blew all others away. But nothing that has been released by a major studio so far has really lit a fire under my ass to the point where I want to rally my troops and proclaim, "Go forth, one and all, and spend your hard-earned dollars on this one. See it twice or three times."

While I certainly had good things to say about the latest installments of the Mission: Impossible and X-Men franchises, they haven't leveled me. The latest and perhaps most frustrating and disappointing is Nacho Libre. My heart is officially resting comfortably in a local hospital after being trampled on by star Jack Black and director Jared Hess (Napoleon Dynamite).

I didn't need Nacho Libre to be the most outrageous and hysterical film of the year. I suspected that despite what the studio promotions department would have you believe that director Hess would never make a film that was a simple comedy. I saw his last film many weeks before it opened and immediately wrote about it; I think I may have been a founding member of the "Napoleon Dynamite is the greatest thing since sliced bread" club. Debate it all you want, but for the better part of 2004, that film ruled the minds of many a film geek.

Nacho Libre offers the same gentle soul of Napoleon, but now it feels like the mold has been reused. Setting this film in Mexico, making Jack Black a monk with a passion for Mexican wrestling, casting himself as the greatest luchadore in the nation, does not make the films all that different. Both are PG rated and have a child-like innocence to them that is both endearing and frustrating.

As much as I like Napoleon Dynamite, I think Jack Black is something just shy of a god. But there's too much of familiar Jack Black routine here: the weird scrunched-up devil face, the contorted eyebrow dance, and the scat singing that makes his Tenacious D performances so perfect are totally out of place here. Yes, Black gets a chance to sing a couple songs in Nacho Libre, and it completely took me out of the film.

Nacho the monk works at a dingy orphanage, where he cooks and serves warmed-over gruel to this poor, dirty orphans. He warns them that watching wrestling is against god. "Thou shalt not wrestle thy neighbor" he reminds them, while secretly plotting his entry into the arena, where the masked wrestlers are some of Mexico's biggest stars.

He recruits as his tag-team partner, the spindly street urchin Esqueleto (Hector Jimenez), whose deadpan delivery and blank expression (occasionally punctuated by the toothiest grin since Jaws) is the most like the characters in Napoleon Dynamite. That's probably why I liked what he does in this film more than anything else about it. The pair don't fare so well in the ring, but they show promise and the popularity among wrestling fans begins to grow.

Nacho has a not-so-secret crush on the newest employee at his monastery, the drop-dead gorgeous nun played by celebrated Mexican actress Ana de la Reguera. Their harmless flirtation borders on charming, but I just couldn't get interested in those scenes because Hess seems determined to race us through them just as they were getting in the way of the comedy.

It's tough to believe that Mike White (whose winning script for School of Rock managed to make a kids movie equally interesting for adults) had a hand in this work, which relies way too much on poop and fart jokes, and never misses a chance to highlight Black's bulging belly or ass straining the molecular fabric of his wrestling tights.

There are momentary flashes of very funny stuff, but I think I laughed out loud on average about once every 15-20 minutes, not good considering the film barely cracks 90 minutes. I'll give Hess and White credit: I don't think they're going for big laughs all that often, but what we're left with isn't particularly interesting.

At its core, Nacho Libre is about chasing a dream, even if it means leaving behind the life you've been living since you were a child and perhaps even losing the one person who loves you for what you are.

Right now, the dream I'm chasing is a truly great summer release, because Nacho Libre was a massive let down for me. By the time you read this, I'll have seen Superman Returns and A Scanner Darkly, probably the two films I've most been looking forward to this summer. I'm not allowed to talk about those two movies just yet, but if you talk to me over the weekend and I'm in a foul mood, consider that my early review.


Capone







AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

First?!
by DwightSchrute
Jun 16th, 2006
09:38:03 AM
And Second??
by DwightSchrute
Jun 16th, 2006
09:41:22 AM
So?......
by AlgertMopper
Jun 16th, 2006
09:43:15 AM
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
by Redrockmullet
Jun 16th, 2006
09:52:16 AM
Jack Black is the sexiest tomboy beanpole on the planet
by Atticus Finch
Jun 16th, 2006
09:53:25 AM
hmmmm.....
by occams_razor
Jun 16th, 2006
09:53:44 AM
A SCANNER DARKLY isn't very good?
by abcdefz7
Jun 16th, 2006
10:07:52 AM
Holy shit!
by DocPazuzu
Jun 16th, 2006
10:22:22 AM
So, next year, will Jack Black challenge his critics...
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 16th, 2006
10:28:31 AM
Don't animated films count?
by half vader
Jun 16th, 2006
10:31:17 AM
nice to see some nacho reviews
by Holodigm
Jun 16th, 2006
10:37:01 AM
my bungole hurts too
by half vader
Jun 16th, 2006
10:51:33 AM
You can change your password...
by brycemonkey
Jun 16th, 2006
11:01:57 AM
http://tinyurl.com/qbfve
by brycemonkey
Jun 16th, 2006
11:03:22 AM
What's with this site's obsession with Nacho Libre?
by Johnny Wishbone
Jun 16th, 2006
11:29:27 AM
yes, but did the film hug you?
by stvnhthr
Jun 16th, 2006
11:35:10 AM
"the gentle soul of Napoleon Dynamite"?
by Bryan
Jun 16th, 2006
11:36:47 AM
Jack Scmack
by bigboxer
Jun 16th, 2006
11:47:13 AM
I'm waiting on the sequel: Nacho Bellgrande
by Capt. Murphy
Jun 16th, 2006
11:56:38 AM
No, I'm not listening
by quadrupletree
Jun 16th, 2006
12:05:16 PM
Hey Doc!
by Mr Nice Gaius
Jun 16th, 2006
12:36:38 PM
How could any sane person be excited about...
by JohnGalt06
Jun 16th, 2006
12:51:38 PM
FInally saw Superman Returns...
by slone13
Jun 16th, 2006
01:19:23 PM
Welcome back, Fett.
by moondoggy2u
Jun 16th, 2006
01:27:25 PM
`course, back then I was Midnight Rambler
by moondoggy2u
Jun 16th, 2006
01:28:22 PM
FETT
by Mr Nice Gaius
Jun 16th, 2006
02:25:51 PM
41% on Rotten Tomatoes.....
by godhatesyou
Jun 16th, 2006
03:22:35 PM
moldy
by scrnwrtr
Jun 16th, 2006
03:39:15 PM
Napoleon Dynamite ?
by godhatesyou
Jun 16th, 2006
03:52:19 PM
you people
by HarryVagima
Jun 16th, 2006
03:57:29 PM
Its 35% on Rotten Tomatoes now!
by godhatesyou
Jun 16th, 2006
03:58:56 PM
Saw it, liked it....
by Big Bad Clone
Jun 16th, 2006
04:18:01 PM
I bet the same thing happens with 'Snakes on a plane'
by godhatesyou
Jun 16th, 2006
04:32:40 PM
wait a second...there was another fett?
by tango fett
Jun 16th, 2006
04:35:06 PM
mo mutha fuckin snakes.. on mo muthafuckin planes!
by white owl
Jun 16th, 2006
04:46:20 PM
I bet this movie stiffs
by zekmoe
Jun 16th, 2006
04:57:48 PM
AICN made this move.
by godhatesyou
Jun 16th, 2006
05:05:03 PM
Anyone who judges a film based on "rotten tomatoes"...
by slone13
Jun 16th, 2006
05:06:41 PM
So, will Harry deep six that animated gif now?
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 16th, 2006
06:46:06 PM
substance vs style
by maxwell's hammer
Jun 16th, 2006
08:31:47 PM
I smiled most of the way through it
by Firebird
Jun 16th, 2006
08:41:30 PM
Nope
by WolfmanNards
Jun 16th, 2006
11:00:45 PM

by Sabbage
Jun 17th, 2006
02:23:03 PM
slone13.
by godhatesyou
Jun 17th, 2006
03:56:50 PM
I thought it was damn funny
by Reverendz
Jun 17th, 2006
07:53:38 PM
Anybody who likes this movie is gay.
by chickychow
Jun 17th, 2006
08:58:20 PM
say what?
by Reverendz
Jun 18th, 2006
12:54:53 AM
So NACHO LIBRE is mediocre as well? Jeez.
by Orbots Commander
Jun 18th, 2006
08:34:23 AM
Ta Bryce...
by TELF
Jun 18th, 2006
01:42:45 PM
capone being wrong
by REDLEAF
Jun 18th, 2006
02:48:25 PM
I saw this twice
by clockpolitiks
Jun 18th, 2006
03:27:37 PM
I saw Nacho Libre.
by mrfan
Jun 18th, 2006
11:25:22 PM
No problem TELF...
by brycemonkey
Jun 19th, 2006
08:32:52 AM

by Sabbage
Jun 19th, 2006
03:04:00 PM
Yeah thanks Bryce
by half vader
Jun 20th, 2006
05:16:25 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.