Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Herc

The Contender 1.1 FAQ

What’s it called?
“Random Acts of Courage.”

What does TV Guide say?
“Sixteen middleweights contend for a $1-million payday in this boxing tournament produced by Mark Burnett (“Survivor,” “The Apprentice”) and Sylvester Stallone, and hosted by Stallone and Sugar Ray Leonard. The format: the fighters are divided into two teams, who face off each episode in a contest of physical strength and mental acuity. The winner chooses its fighter – and the opponent. Each episode culminates with the match. Part 1 also introduces the contestants.

Does the contestant who recently committed suicide, Philadelphia’s Najai Turpin, lose tonight’s match?
Turpin is not one of the two contestants in the opener. In fact, I don’t think Turpin utters a word during the entire first 90 minutes.

Not one word? Upon whom does the first episode focus?
The two contestants who go head-to-head in the fight finale, and the two fighters who play pivotal roles in “the contest of physical strength and mental acuity.”

Any hints on the nature of the mid-show contest?
It’s set on a mile-long uphill course just below the world-famous Hollywood sign. It involves markedly more physical strength than mental acuity, although the tiny amount of mental acuity required actually costs the losing team the contest.

Do the promos deceive me? Is former champion Sugar Ray Leonard even smaller than notoriously tiny actor Sylvester Stallone?
He is. In fact, it’s amazing that none of the contestants weigh more than 158 pounds. I think I read recently that the average weight for an American woman is now 160 pounds.

What else is TV Guide not telling us?
Boxing icon Jackie Kallen, whom Meg Ryan played in “Against the Ropes,” is briefly introduced at the top of the show, then vanishes completely. Also? At least two of the 16 fighters – Ishi Smith and Alfonzo Gomez – have fought each other in the past. Smith is responsible for one of Gomez’ only two losses!

Is there a Smith-Gomez rematch this week??
Not this week. And the two are not likely to face off anytime soon, as they’re both on the “West” team.

The big news?
Shockingly, we witness almost no interpersonal conflict between these young boxers. The closest we get to heated words coming during a brief but very public conversation between two of the four boxers we get to know a bit this week: Smith and a Lebanon-born pretty-boy named Ahmed. These words come during a press conference, and it wouldn’t surprise me a bit if off-camera “Contender” producers prodded Smith to instigate the verbal face-off. In any event, it’s an too-brief highlight.

Do Smith and Ahmed come to blows this week?
Neither is in the climactic match.

Who is in the climactic match this week?
That would be telling. I will say their records going in are 10-2 and 22-0.

Does the climactic fight end in a knockout?
It does not.

What’s good?
The mid-show challenge was fun and fairly “Survivor”-like (if not “Fear Factor”-like) in its Rube Goldberg complexity. Also, I normally couldn’t care less about the outcome of a boxing match, but the show did invest me in the outcome of the final battle.

What’s not so good?
A fundamental difference between this and Burnett’s other elimination shows is that there are no hot young women competing. (Even the WWE was smart enough to balance out the genders for its similar “Tough Enough” reality series). Also? The contestants seem to have been chosen, perhaps laudably, more for their fighting ability rather than their personalities - but these boxers, it turns out, are a fairly dull lot when they’re not trading blows. Also also? Stallone’s an okay host, but Leonard is pretty much charisma-free, “inspiring” the contestants with eye-rolling clichés like, “What’s going to determine who wins is this (points at his heart) and this (points at head). If you want it, go for it.” Yeah, thanks, Sugar Ray.

How does it end, spoiler-boy?
“I’ve been fighting since I was five years old,” says the loser, as footage of him exiting the gym one last time unspools. “Where do I go from here?”

Herc’s rating for “The Contender” 1.1?
***

The Hercules T. Strong Rating System:
***** better than we deserve
**** better than most motion pictures
*** actually worth your valuable time
** as horrible as most stuff on TV
* makes you quietly pray for bulletins

But what matters Herc’s opinion? The Hollywood Reporter says:

… "The Con" breaks from the gate looking very much like a contender itself, boasting all the requisite trappings (human drama, underdogs, competitive fire, driving soundtrack) to make for appointment viewing. Of course, I thought the same thing about "Next Great Champ" and it went belly-up halfway through. …

Variety says:

… Mark Burnett has fashioned a winner out of "The Contender," bringing a humanity to the sweet science that has been long lost. More than "The Apprentice" with boxing gloves, "The Contender""The Contender" is warm and enveloping, a collection of stories about struggle, community, family and human spirit. …

Entertainment Weekly gives it a “B” and says:

… Mark Burnett's latest reality experiment has all the necessary ingredients: big personalities, big dreams, big production values, and, of course, people beating the crap out of each other. …

9:30 p.m. Monday. NBC.

Note that NBC is airing three new episodes of “The Contender” this week, on Monday, Thursday and Sunday. Those using TiVo may want to note that CNBC is repeating the episodes as it does with “The Apprentice.”

Because of the CNBC scheduling, I’ll also remind reality-show fans that “Contender” airs opposite new episodes of at least three other unscripted series: ABC’s “Boss Swap” and “Supernanny,” and the season premiere of MTV’s “Real World/Road Rules Challenge.”

I am – Hercules!!





Looking for bumper stickers, plush toys and girls’ underwear covered with cute cartoon double-amputees? Visit The Herc Store!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Last
by Abelman007
Mar 7th, 2005
01:55:53 AM
Spike TV's manly men reality show is better
by BigDogg
Mar 7th, 2005
02:25:58 AM
At the end of every show Stalone should yell to the loser: "I AM
by Aust1n
Mar 7th, 2005
02:29:34 AM
BigDogg is right...
by blahblahface
Mar 7th, 2005
03:35:34 AM
As long as it's not a vote-off show, it can't be that bad
by Big Bad Clone
Mar 7th, 2005
08:18:05 AM
thank GOD, a reality show I might actually watch...
by TV CASUALTY
Mar 7th, 2005
10:23:23 AM
"But what matter
by symphy
Mar 7th, 2005
11:04:39 AM
Average American woman is 160 lbs?
by Gheorghe Zamfir
Mar 7th, 2005
01:25:38 PM
Yah, but the first half hour is up against 24. Therefore, missi
by Tall_Boy
Mar 7th, 2005
01:59:45 PM
the average american woman weighs 160 pounds ...
by Toe Jam
Mar 7th, 2005
02:40:36 PM
LOVE ultimate fighter
by darth sars
Mar 7th, 2005
03:02:57 PM
Fascintinating. My only question is:
by mortsleam
Mar 7th, 2005
03:05:52 PM
Mark Burnett (and his ilk) are cancers on the ass of humanity..
by Jimmy Jazz
Mar 7th, 2005
03:36:41 PM
it's not even broadcast in high definition ...
by Toe Jam
Mar 7th, 2005
03:37:22 PM
Mark Burnett (and his ilk) are cancers on the ass of humanity..
by Jimmy Jazz
Mar 7th, 2005
03:39:05 PM
Whoops....
by Jimmy Jazz
Mar 7th, 2005
03:40:47 PM
Hulk Bauer?
by Big Jim
Mar 7th, 2005
05:26:57 PM
Explanation for 160 pounds
by JackBristow
Mar 7th, 2005
07:25:48 PM
Fight
by ciardi
Mar 7th, 2005
10:55:44 PM
I'm assuming full command of this post and turning it into a 24
by MaxCalifornia.
Mar 8th, 2005
01:53:49 AM
Great show
by Darth TJ Mackey
Mar 8th, 2005
03:15:11 AM
Also, Hans Zimmer is doing the music
by Darth TJ Mackey
Mar 8th, 2005
06:48:37 PM
The ads are so ghey...
by Mad_Radhu
Mar 8th, 2005
07:21:30 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.