Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

New DUNE Trailer Up, and a Bit Of A Review

El Cosmico here, I'm actually in an extreme hurry as I write this, so bear with me. Or don't . Doesn't matter to me.

Anyway, there's a new trailer up at the DUNE website, you can find it at: http://www.scifi.com/dune/events.html, it looks good to me.

That trailer will be showing in about two weeks in theatres. Anyway, I came across a tape, which some of you asked me about because Harry made a few...choice comments about it.

I'm not really even sure where it came from, or quite what it was. On it, about 45 minutes of clips from the upcoming DUNE mini-series. Random clips. In no special order, at least not that I could tell. Harry didn't care for it. Here are my thoughts.

First, the material was unfinished, and in small segments. I'm not sure for what purpose it was made, or which, if any of the scenes were finished.

One of the things you're going to need to do if you're going to enjoy this series is put the Lynch movie out of your mind. Wipe it. Forget it. Don't bring that baggage with you, or you'll be sorry.

Why? Because in spite of the problems with the Lynch film, the LOOK of the Lynch film is distinctive and wonderful, at least in my opinion. So, anything that differs with that look will naturally disturb your mind. Unless you put that Lynch film out of your mind.

A few other things to think about here...Patrick Stewart was Gurney in the Lynch movie. Would YOU want to be the actor put up against Stewart's scenes? It's inevitable, every time you look at the new fellow (forgive me, I don't recall his name), you're going to see and hear echoes of one of the finest actors of our age, Mr. Stewart. Not an easy thing to live up to.

That being said, I think they could have made a better casting choice for Gurney, but the fault, in my opinion, is only half his.

The sets in this series, I still believe, are very interesting, elaborate, in many cases really very well done. I liked a lot of what I saw. I also liked, with a few exceptions, the costume designs.

Many of the characters were well done, but again, they suffer from comparison to their equivalents in the Lynch film. The Baron, of course is one of these, as is the Duchess Atreides, and while William Hurt does a FINE job as the Duke, again, it's inevitable, I hear Prochnow's German accent, and somehow I miss it.

Now, Herbert didn't write the Duke with a German accent. Here, as with so many things, it's a question of expectation. Not of expectation of quality, because there is, I believe, a lot of quality in the scenes that I saw. What I'm talking about is expectation of specific methods of performance and content.

This will be a problem for many viewers, unless they make a sincere effort to watch this mini-series as a work on its own. As a work on its own, I consider the scenes I've seen to be significantly above average television. Good, but not outstanding, and not excellent.

At times, though, I disagreed with the choices being made, the most significant being portrayal of the members of the Guild. To be fair, I don't think anyone could ever have hoped to top the Guild Navigator in Lynch's film. Unfortunately, however, that doesn't excuse the very limited (only a few seconds) portrayal that I saw, which, I must say, I didn't care for at all.

In other words, what I've seen is a mixed bag. Highly mixed. Mixed and mixed and then mixed some more again. After that, it appears that mixture was added. Finally, the whole thing was finished up with a large measure of mixing. Then, it seems that someone snuck in and secretly mixed a bit more.

What was I talking about? Oh yeah, I need to go. I'm pressed for time. I've got shenanigans to be up to. Bourgeois business. I just wanted to answer the emails you folks have been sending me...the frantic ones asking "What was ON THAT TAPE?" Well, folks, lots of stuff was on that tape. Some of it was really good. Some lukewarm. Some bad. I don't know what's going to make the final cut. I do know that even if this show is as mixed as the tape I have, I think it will be worth watching for sci-fi fans. I also know that if you can't get the Lynch film out of your head while watching this, you're asking for trouble. Anyway, go check out the trailer, look at the pictures they have for you there. I'm sure we'll have more on this as we continue to be pulled through this terrible, inevitable, one-way dimension of time.

Hasta El Kwisatz Haderach,

-El Cosmico

elcosmico@aintitcool.com

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

so what if its different?
by bluecelt
Oct 25th, 2000
08:46:52 PM
The trailer...
by The Gline
Oct 25th, 2000
10:00:50 PM
Lynch vs Herbert
by kungfuwaynewho
Oct 26th, 2000
12:51:23 AM
Cast-away
by Quadrahelix
Oct 26th, 2000
01:04:13 AM
Dune
by SunsetMan
Oct 26th, 2000
03:29:08 AM
Guys, I saw some dailies and nearly fell asleep
by nightsir
Oct 26th, 2000
04:19:00 AM
Lynch slippage
by Milo_357
Oct 26th, 2000
06:43:31 AM
Why?
by Rand Race
Oct 26th, 2000
09:12:16 AM
The Lynch film was utter crap.
by Baldur_Boy
Oct 26th, 2000
11:47:32 AM
Lynch's Dune was unfairly crucified
by Fatal Discharge
Oct 26th, 2000
12:06:59 PM
one way dimension of time?
by B A Fett
Oct 26th, 2000
12:14:46 PM
Lynch
by Chaplan
Oct 26th, 2000
01:45:12 PM
Kinda hard to get Lynch's Dune out of our minds when you pepper
by CranialLeak
Oct 26th, 2000
02:08:44 PM
DUNE books-movies
by Lurk71
Oct 26th, 2000
02:37:02 PM
By The Way...NO RAIN!!!!
by Lurk71
Oct 26th, 2000
02:40:21 PM
everybody seems to be forgetting the...
by adoraboy00
Oct 26th, 2000
04:06:08 PM
The sleeper must awaken.
by Deathstar
Oct 26th, 2000
06:23:35 PM
Looking Forward
by StormHunter
Oct 27th, 2000
03:20:31 PM
'thopters
by flanner
Oct 28th, 2000
12:17:09 AM
Hope Duncan Idaho is in it more this time.
by Andy Travis
Oct 28th, 2000
07:15:33 AM
Piss on Lynch's version
by the annoyed one
Oct 28th, 2000
09:14:15 PM
Watch it anyway...
by nightsir
Oct 29th, 2000
04:50:51 PM
The Lynch film is extremely faithful to the book.
by LSHB
Oct 31st, 2000
12:26:38 PM
Yeah unclefucka...
by Skyway Moaters
Oct 31st, 2000
05:39:50 PM
Tally sheet for Lynch's DUNE....
by Skyway Moaters
Nov 1st, 2000
01:31:24 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.