Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Ridley Scott Loses His Damn Fool Mind!!

Hey, everyone. "Moriarty" here. Just thought I'd bring something to your attention that the estimable Garth Franklin ran over on Dark Horizons this morning.

Seems Ridley Scott can't leave well enough alone. When BLADE RUNNER was released in 1982, the thing was a critical and financial disaster, and it's only been through constant rehab that the film has been accepted as a classic, an overlooked masterpiece. A big part of the film's restored appeal comes from the release of Ridley's directors cut of the film, with no voice-over by Harrison Ford. That version of the film also contained some material that strongly alluded to the fact that Harrison Ford's character, Rick Deckard, might be a replicant, just like those he is chasing.

Now, the new material in the film to me puts a pretty definite cap on the question, but it's handled with enough grace and a light enough touch that it is possible that Deckard is not a replicant. Unlikely, but possible. Either way, the ending left it free for fanboys to argue the point with the same vigor that you argue about what's in the briefcase in PULP FICTION. Point is, you don't know, and you shouldn't know. Not for sure.

And now Ridley Scott's gone and put an answer on it. Rotten pratt. The article that Garth quoted can be found here if you're interested. The Channel 4 documentary they're talking about with Ridley Scott sounds like something we'd better see when Warner Bros. does their giant DVD edition of the film later this year. I've talked to someone who's actually working on the restoration of the film, and they're just warming up for what should be a fairly complex process.

Too bad in his eagerness to go back and discuss his classic film, Scott felt the need to say, yes, Deckard is a replicant. I still say it's up for grabs, and I'm sure you'll say much the same in TALK BACK. Anyway... it's worth taking a look at for fans.

"Moriarty" out.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

the Pulp Briefcase (or, what would Dick say?)
by tensticks
Jul 10th, 2000
07:18:40 AM
What do you mean it's still up for grabs??
by Splinter
Jul 10th, 2000
07:22:00 AM
Yea, the documentaries being shown after the film.
by Mad Dog
Jul 10th, 2000
07:23:39 AM
Whats in The Pulp Brief Case ***SPOLIER***
by Meat Takeshi
Jul 10th, 2000
07:24:15 AM
Relax. It still is a mystery
by gsolo
Jul 10th, 2000
07:26:32 AM
film as art?
by 41672
Jul 10th, 2000
07:37:52 AM
Yup, Garth really fucked me up today....
by NUXX
Jul 10th, 2000
07:38:27 AM
Re: Pulp Briefcase....
by NUXX
Jul 10th, 2000
07:42:09 AM
This is hardly news.
by cozmicrob
Jul 10th, 2000
07:45:25 AM
Pulp Fiction briefcase
by Jarek
Jul 10th, 2000
07:46:30 AM
Is Blade runner all that good??
by McBane
Jul 10th, 2000
07:53:04 AM
Hitchcocks word I believe - macguffin
by Mad Dog
Jul 10th, 2000
07:56:00 AM
Heh...Deckard's a Boomer...
by Typhoon
Jul 10th, 2000
08:05:00 AM
This is GOOD news...
by X-Mole
Jul 10th, 2000
08:06:28 AM
what's realy in the pulp suitcase
by kingpin
Jul 10th, 2000
08:22:49 AM
As a fellow Brit to Ridley...
by otter60
Jul 10th, 2000
08:33:50 AM
MAD DOG speaks the truth
by Mundane Noodle
Jul 10th, 2000
08:36:01 AM
briefcase
by X-Mole
Jul 10th, 2000
08:38:02 AM
Of course he's a replicant-read the book, moron!
by TheGooch
Jul 10th, 2000
08:46:55 AM
The idea of the briefcase came from "Kiss Me Deadly."
by Uncapie
Jul 10th, 2000
08:46:59 AM
Ridley has been saying this for years.
by jetset-jimbo
Jul 10th, 2000
08:56:56 AM
Why is it that Harrison Ford hates being known for Blade Runner
by Houdini25
Jul 10th, 2000
08:58:40 AM
on the 6th replicant
by X-Mole
Jul 10th, 2000
09:04:01 AM
Scott of the Sahara...
by oh-Dawg
Jul 10th, 2000
09:12:00 AM
My point of view
by spider-ham
Jul 10th, 2000
09:16:14 AM
The 6th Replicant is.......
by Mr Bastardos
Jul 10th, 2000
09:17:04 AM
he's one
by ONARA SAN
Jul 10th, 2000
09:20:01 AM
The 6th Replicant is.......
by Mr Bastardos
Jul 10th, 2000
09:31:36 AM
who is Keyzer Soze?
by vassilis
Jul 10th, 2000
09:32:31 AM
It was in Do Andriods Dream Of Electric Sheep?...
by Syd Mead
Jul 10th, 2000
09:37:05 AM
Well, Mark Kermode's doing it.. remember that this is the geek c
by X-Mole
Jul 10th, 2000
09:54:20 AM
Thank you, Vassilis....
by faesforce
Jul 10th, 2000
09:58:50 AM
Did I Not Make Myself Clear?
by Moriarty
Jul 10th, 2000
10:00:54 AM
ahem
by X-Mole
Jul 10th, 2000
10:07:33 AM
This is news?
by abulafia24
Jul 10th, 2000
10:26:49 AM
Apologies Moriarty...
by Splinter
Jul 10th, 2000
10:37:45 AM
Blade Runner book
by MagnoliaMan
Jul 10th, 2000
10:41:23 AM
His old new guys Fords version VS Ridleys
by Norm3
Jul 10th, 2000
10:48:41 AM
Can someone please dumb it down for me?
by BraveCapt.
Jul 10th, 2000
10:53:10 AM
STILL A MASTERPIECE
by JamesPrater
Jul 10th, 2000
10:59:41 AM
"Dumbing down"...
by mbeemer
Jul 10th, 2000
11:12:49 AM
Great to look at, but YYYAAAWWWNNNN!
by OtNife
Jul 10th, 2000
11:21:18 AM
Best Dressed Chicken in Town
by Dr Alimantado
Jul 10th, 2000
11:21:44 AM
Give the guy a break.
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
11:27:01 AM
About the whole unicorn motif...
by Toe Jam
Jul 10th, 2000
11:31:08 AM
To: TheGooch
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
11:40:17 AM
Alternate unicorn interpretation.
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
11:44:33 AM
ju foking cacaroch..
by Dash Reindeer
Jul 10th, 2000
11:46:37 AM
Deckard was a pussy
by Afro_Dogwhelk
Jul 10th, 2000
11:56:25 AM
Deckard - a fragile replicant?
by Mr M
Jul 10th, 2000
11:56:45 AM
Slashdot discusstion thread.
by Asmodeus
Jul 10th, 2000
12:10:53 PM
IM NOT GONA BUY THIS FUNKING MOVIE AGAIN
by Stimpson J Cat
Jul 10th, 2000
12:13:14 PM
Embarrassed by their own movies...
by Achilles
Jul 10th, 2000
12:22:14 PM
Mr. M has a point...
by SCOTT1458
Jul 10th, 2000
12:38:12 PM
Actually, Quinten said ...
by CrayolaBoy
Jul 10th, 2000
12:40:25 PM
Use a bit of logic here...
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
12:48:36 PM
Ford, Scott, and Eyes
by WizardX
Jul 10th, 2000
12:50:10 PM
What a bunch of pissy children...
by thepete
Jul 10th, 2000
12:53:50 PM
Ridley Scott is a liar
by Celedhring
Jul 10th, 2000
01:08:39 PM
Original Ending
by Oso
Jul 10th, 2000
01:33:55 PM
Deckard is not a replicant
by yt
Jul 10th, 2000
01:40:49 PM
You all got it wrong...
by Fleshworld
Jul 10th, 2000
01:48:11 PM
A fun little theory for the Pulp Fiction case...
by regulator
Jul 10th, 2000
01:51:46 PM
we are missing the main issue here
by ol' painless
Jul 10th, 2000
02:08:53 PM
Deckard's wussiness
by ThereIsNoSpoon
Jul 10th, 2000
02:31:49 PM
Other clues and the 6th replicant.
by Ivan_Mtl
Jul 10th, 2000
03:02:02 PM
reply to vassilis and jetset jimbo
by Dragonfire
Jul 10th, 2000
03:12:49 PM
Thereisnospoon: There is INSTINCT, and there is AWARENESS
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
03:18:34 PM
deckard did retire replicants
by Dragonfire
Jul 10th, 2000
03:19:14 PM
Missing the point
by All Thumbs
Jul 10th, 2000
03:35:34 PM
Ridley Scott's opinion...
by brokentusk
Jul 10th, 2000
03:45:18 PM
Only a certain number of people knew when mr. Scott revealed thi
by sprocket-bot
Jul 10th, 2000
04:11:42 PM
I'll have an egg MacGuffin, please... I couldn't resist...
by mini maul
Jul 10th, 2000
04:27:57 PM
IBLIS and the Usual Suspects Deniers
by Anton_Sirius
Jul 10th, 2000
04:35:47 PM
The greatest trick the devil pulled was convincing the world he
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
04:56:22 PM
Please Direct All Complaints...
by Anton_Sirius
Jul 10th, 2000
05:05:20 PM
Missing the point ...
by ClitSmurf
Jul 10th, 2000
05:20:38 PM
No voice-over by Harisson Ford
by rEEferHEAD
Jul 10th, 2000
05:29:51 PM
The unfortunately named ClitSmurf is right!
by Zeno
Jul 10th, 2000
06:05:07 PM
Superninja - good point
by ThereIsNoSpoon
Jul 10th, 2000
06:14:33 PM
Oh, and Zeno -
by ThereIsNoSpoon
Jul 10th, 2000
06:23:59 PM
Thereisnospoon: You're missing my point.
by superninja
Jul 10th, 2000
06:39:47 PM
Actually right after he said that...
by JackBurton
Jul 10th, 2000
06:46:00 PM
Well, read the damn book, you damn fools!
by 18Buddahs
Jul 10th, 2000
06:48:20 PM
Blade Runner - Unbagged Cat
by Pogo
Jul 10th, 2000
07:28:18 PM
WHAT IS NOT IN THE BRIEFCASE
by GFK
Jul 10th, 2000
07:31:58 PM
Deac Speaks...
by Deacon
Jul 10th, 2000
07:39:28 PM
Superninja - ?!?!? and hey 18 buddhas-
by ThereIsNoSpoon
Jul 10th, 2000
07:44:42 PM
There may be no spoon, but there is a knife, and you used it to
by Zeno
Jul 10th, 2000
07:51:28 PM
And before I can even click the post it button, you've already s
by Zeno
Jul 10th, 2000
08:04:16 PM
Pulp Fiction
by Taxjockey
Jul 10th, 2000
08:18:54 PM
Old News
by Shaft9876
Jul 10th, 2000
08:48:23 PM
Not even the director knows for sure...
by nothingman
Jul 10th, 2000
09:08:26 PM
blade runner blues
by 2211
Jul 10th, 2000
09:13:36 PM
I don't get it?
by Movie Guy
Jul 10th, 2000
09:18:09 PM
The sixth replicant...
by seraphim@gci.net
Jul 10th, 2000
09:54:38 PM
Anton
by mini maul
Jul 10th, 2000
10:38:28 PM
2211..good call
by Anduin
Jul 10th, 2000
10:46:28 PM
does tarantino dream of plastic sheep?
by tensticks
Jul 10th, 2000
10:46:46 PM
HEY Jimmer Negamanee...!
by Bono
Jul 10th, 2000
11:01:51 PM
As if fanboys have a lack of shit to argue about...
by MajorY2Kaos
Jul 10th, 2000
11:05:08 PM
You wanna know what was in the Pulp fiction briefcase?
by TheGinger Twit
Jul 10th, 2000
11:11:06 PM
RIDLEY SCOTT IS A REPLICANT!!!!!
by VictorC
Jul 10th, 2000
11:31:07 PM
Deckard's a human
by CaptBlack
Jul 10th, 2000
11:45:31 PM
Outer Limits: The Man with the Glass Hand
by XeroChance
Jul 10th, 2000
11:45:55 PM
The Sequel Will End The Controversy
by Pagan God
Jul 11th, 2000
12:19:22 AM
soze confirmation + unicorn
by vassilis
Jul 11th, 2000
01:31:27 AM
Pulp Fiction
by djtrauma
Jul 11th, 2000
02:16:52 AM
Since no one's mentioned Ford's Voice Over's in this pic I will:
by Bari Umenema
Jul 11th, 2000
02:39:58 AM
Here at the end....
by NUXX
Jul 11th, 2000
03:30:24 AM
constant "rehab?"
by Flambit
Jul 11th, 2000
06:03:46 AM
Don't eat with talkbackers
by Tom1234
Jul 11th, 2000
07:57:48 AM
Flambit
by Shaft9876
Jul 11th, 2000
08:24:01 AM
Don't Eat With Talkbackers Part II: The Quickening
by Zeno
Jul 11th, 2000
09:41:57 AM
Anyone seen the Limited Edition DVD box set?
by G'Kar
Jul 11th, 2000
10:39:22 AM
he say you buraidarunna...
by Metatron
Jul 11th, 2000
11:08:34 AM
Philip K. Dick
by flave
Jul 11th, 2000
12:43:55 PM
All of you.....get a life!
by Fandude
Jul 11th, 2000
12:51:43 PM
Thereisnospoon: It's all speculative, I agree.
by superninja
Jul 11th, 2000
01:11:58 PM
Superninja and Zeno
by ThereIsNoSpoon
Jul 11th, 2000
01:41:41 PM
Hello, McFly
by Anton_Sirius
Jul 11th, 2000
02:42:47 PM
Thereisnospoon
by superninja
Jul 11th, 2000
03:38:09 PM
Bad move, Ridley..
by Kid Z
Jul 11th, 2000
05:33:42 PM
I was at the infamous test screening
by echack
Jul 11th, 2000
06:19:24 PM
Sincere response: Wow Echack, that's actually pretty cool. Stan
by Zeno
Jul 11th, 2000
07:24:12 PM
This article is bogus!
by SoonerSean
Jul 11th, 2000
07:35:35 PM
Vassilas...another clue for you to ponder...
by Pseudo
Jul 12th, 2000
06:23:30 AM
Whoa There, Son, Them's Fightin' Words
by Anton_Sirius
Jul 12th, 2000
11:19:24 AM
Blade Runner
by wackdoodle
Jul 12th, 2000
03:41:14 PM
IT'S HIS SOUL!!!!!!!
by rectus
Jul 12th, 2000
06:45:41 PM
Hey buddy, c'mere a minute. Yeah, you.
by Zeno
Jul 12th, 2000
10:23:17 PM
"based on the novel"
by bigjon5354
Jul 17th, 2000
06:37:41 PM
Blade Runner react
by aldo2damax
Jul 18th, 2000
01:28:34 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.