Cool News
The Kidd Vs. PROMISED LAND

PROMISED LAND easily could have fallen the way of being nothing more than a preachy environmental message against the evils of fracking at a time when it’s abundantly clear that corporations are more soulless than ever before, shoving people to the bottom of their list of priorities in favor of numerous items about their bottom lines. However, in the crafty hands of director Gus Van Sant, using the likeability of Matt Damon as his most effective tool, PROMISED LAND surprises by using the vehicle of this natural gas extraction technique to tell an engaging and effective story about a man capable of redemption at every turn after his job working for such a company has, in many respects, turned him into something he never envisioned himself as – a bad guy.
Damon plays Steve Butler, the top salesperson for a natural gas drilling company, sent in to close another town, securing the drilling rights for his employers at a fraction of the price point that other teams have been dishing out. These farming communities in Middle America recognize him as one of their own, having grown up in similar surroundings during his younger days, and, as a result, they’re more likely to buy the story that he’s selling… the one that involves them sitting on an untapped fortune that could make them millionaires. That may not be anywhere close to the truth, but it’s the only thing they can believe, as it’s really the only chance for any type of economic recovery to come upon these struggling towns where shops like Rob’s Guns, Groceries, Guitars and Gas are a staple.
Steve has one more job to do before moving onto his promotion as the new VP of Land Management, which, of course lines him up for his most difficult opposition yet, as he and his partner (Frances McDormand) square off against an informed science teacher (Hal Holbrook) and a one-man environmental group (John Krasinski), who hope to raise enough awareness about the environmental dangers of fracking enough to send natural gas packing, unable to buy their small town, no matter the price. Stuck in the middle is a prospective love interest named Alice (the lovely Rosemarie DeWitt), whose constantly flirtatious chemistry with Damon starts to widen the cracks in Steve, showing him as a compassionate guy who does care what others think of him rather than a stone cold corporate shill who only cares about getting them to sign on the line that is dotted. He’s not the bad guy that some might perceive him to be, peddling a product that has raped the land and killed off the environment in other towns in the past. In his mind, if those cases were true, then he’d know about them. His company would pass along that vital information. They wouldn’t have him in the dark about such matters that would ruin Anytown, U.S.A. He may be a killer, but he’s an innocent killer, adding further complexity to the character. He knows what he’s selling to these people is bullshit, knowing full well that the likelihood of them seeing the reaches he’s dangling out there in front of them is next to none, yet he chooses to look past the idea that the very company he is working for is incapable of any wrongdoing. In a lesser film, you might question the smarts of Steve, as he seems to lack common sense in some pretty vital areas, but there is still a boyish charm to Damon that has you fully accepting his skewed innocence, never doubting that maybe he just chooses to believe what he wants to believe, in light of the incredible success such an occupation has afforded him to date.
This is another strong performance by Damon, aided by having the perfect opponent in Krasinski’s Dustin Noble. Krasinski comes to town, representing a grassroots environmental group, willing to do whatever to spread the word on fracking, ending the cycle of town after town buying into the lies and decimating their collective ways of life. Noble is actually able to top the affability of Steve, drawing more and more supporters to his cause, making Steve’s task all the more difficult. Krasinski (who co-wrote the script with Damon) adds a passion to the film, turning the argument about dollars and cents into one about people, and watching him get the better of Damon one occasion after another really turns up the stakes in PROMISED LAND, bringing out the win-at-all-costs nature of this corporate wolf who still insists he’s not a bad guy – he may not be his job, but it certainly does bring out the worst in him.
A clever twist late in the story serves more as a “Gotcha!” moment than anything else, as it sends PROMISED LAND’s third act into some familiar and predictable territory as it quickly starts heading for a bit of a clichéd resolution. At the moment, it really turns the movie on its head, but it can’t maintain its path of uncertainty and not knowing how Steve’s mission will turn out when it shakes things up in such a way that it only has one way to go. It is a brilliant idea that does work within the film, but PROMISED LAND does have to pay the small price of no longer keeping you on your toes in order to execute it.
PROMISED LAND is a good little film that definitely warrants a watch. Damon continues to be at his best, a level he rarely falls beneath, and I think you’ll find yourself surprised at how quickly you’re drawn into its story. This is a really quality movie to spend a couple of hours with, I promise.
-Billy Donnelly
"The Infamous Billy The Kidd"
Follow me on Twitter.

Readers Talkback
comments powered by Disqus-
+ Expand All
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 1:35 p.m. CST
For a second I thought The Kidd was reviewing that old Gerald McRaney tv series
by tangcameo
-
Pay money to be preached at by Hollywood hypocrites who are stupid enough to believe that corporations, as Kidd says, are "soulish." This movie is devoid of facts in regard to fracking. However, it is vogue to be a mindless environmentalist in Hollywood right now.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 1:39 p.m. CST
George Clooney made a clever statement against gun ownership for trustworthy Americans...
by Chris Moody
...shortly before he was led out by seven armed bodyguards. Go figure.
-
When time to recognize shameless left wing propaganda it is.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 1:51 p.m. CST
*It is a brilliant idea that does work within the film, but PROMISED LAND does have to pay the small price of no longer keeping you on your toes in order to execute it.*
by Corman
This sentence can mean like 15 different things depending on how you read it.
-
right? Right wing jackasses.
-
We need to start escalating fracking asap. Otherwise we'll be energy dependent on other nations and economically even more fucked. Fracking will help ensure our energy security, add economic growth and provide jobs. The global climate is doomed, nothing is going to reverse it now, and it's very much every nation for themselves. All that matters is that we somehow stop ourselves from going under before China and Russia do. As long as we outlive China and Russia, we've won. God bless America.
-
I thought it was the Kiefer Sutherland movie.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 1:56 p.m. CST
Kidd, regardless of how any of us in the talkback may feel about your "VS" M.O. I happy that you are sticking to your guns...
by ray a
...(pun intended) and not bowing to the pressure to stop using it.
-
Pass.
-
That'll put asses in the seats
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:04 p.m. CST
Damon and Krasinski wrote this. This is supposed to be Krasinksi's big break to prove he can last in Hollywood after The Office vanishes off the radar
by Bobo_Vision
Damon was originally going to direct but couldn't because of scheduling conflicts so he got his buddy Van Sant to do it and the 11th hour. I think Damon and Krasinski may have met during the Handsome Men's Club sketch on Jimmy Kimmel, but I could be wrong. However, now Krasinski has joined the Damon/Affleck/Clooney/Pitt buddy network, which means he will have a career for a good while in tinsel town.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:06 p.m. CST
Oh....this TB is political....so all the old farts with no lives will be posting over ten posts in here.
by Bobo_Vision
Cya.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:06 p.m. CST
JK costarred with Clooney in that football movie no one saw
by TresEquis
About leather helmets and the like. He's part of the cabal now.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:10 p.m. CST
This is the movie that lied and got caught, so it changed it's story. No thanks.
by fanboy71
http://blog.heritage.org/2012/09/27/matt- damons-promised-land-twists -the-fracking-facts/
-
because welfare moms create jobs and hire 99% of the people in this country!
-
Both Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and the Environmental Protection Agency found no evidence of contamination in the case of Dimock, PA, the likely inspiration for the new film.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:20 p.m. CST
I read your review Kidd, but I'm following bobo_vision the frack outta here.
by Deceased Fan
Peace.
-
I'm so tired of this 'who killed the electric car' faggoty and anti-fracking nonsense. Now that electric cars are here, why aren't all the electric cars on the road? It was supposed to be some great idea killed by big oil, right? Same dumb logic applies to films like this.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 2:38 p.m. CST
fanboy71 you do know that corporations often payoff the epa and that people who used to work at the epa….
by Jt
working for corporations that do polluting, and vice versa. It's called influence peddling. Any body with a brain can tell that the government is owned by corporations.
-
and the purchases of those kinds of cars are increasing. But keep on living in your fantasy world.
-
soulless, life sucking, dead behind the eyes people, but hey - people.
-
Does all the fracking awaken some of the Great Old Ones from their eternal slumber and they devour us all? How about the Mole Man and his Moloid hordes? The Earth is hollow and full of dinosaurs? MATT DAAAAAAAMOOOOON!
-
a long-time family friend told me a few months ago fracking has been going on on his rural property for like 25 years. no damage whatsoever. he even had the water checked himself, and it was high quality/pure. he's not worried about fracking at all. yet another naive hollywood prop-fest most americans won't bother with... but gullible lefties will no doubt love it.
-
at people like detached that make stories up to comfort themselves.
-
In case anyone is interested, this film was partially financed by the UAE. A member of OPEC who would love to keep the USA from becoming energy independent. But I'm sure the drones will believe this is right wing propaganda as we continue down our path to becoming a third world nation. Hope everyone had a Merry Christmas!!
-
For a new generation!
-
Naming his character Dustin Noble? In a movie about nobly standing up to the fracking industry? Which kicks up a lot of dust/pollutants into the ecosystem? Hardy har har
-
That, sir, was fucking perfect. Bam! Made my day.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:12 p.m. CST
Damn! Gerry Anderson, creator of 'Thunderbirds' etc. has died...
by Cervantes
-
The entire premise is bunk. It's funded by a bunch of Arabs who would benefit if the U.S. cut natural gas production. It's complete total 100% fantasy funded by terrorist supporting scum.
-
Matt Daaaaaamon's Team America marionette, that is?
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:22 p.m. CST
Becomes a weird gorefest when Damon himself undergoes fracking to prove it's safe
by spacehog
Hope I didn't spoil the twist. I guess it's either that or the deathbed marriage of Damon and Krasinski.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:24 p.m. CST
rightwingers have really lost it, now they claim arabs are funding independent hollywood movies
by Jt
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:26 p.m. CST
@bobo_vision re: Old farts. Famous quote, "If you're not a liberal at twenty you have no heart, if you're not a conservative at forty you have no brain."
by AlienFanatic
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:29 p.m. CST
rightwingers you do know that we get more oil from Venezuela, than from all the arab nations combined
by Jt
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:33 p.m. CST
conservative at forty = sellout, who changed their political beliefs based off of how much money they make
by Jt
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:34 p.m. CST
Famous quote "It's not true that all conservatives are stupid, but it is true that most stupid people are conservative"
by Jt
-
The government would rather you believe that it does. As was stated above, we get little oil from the ME and our repeated invasions of Iraq hasn't exactly cheapened gas prices.
-
Maybe you should research this film (and fracking) a little bit. Then when you spew your liberal talking points you can be in on the joke. The shocking twist of this film is that JK is is working deep undercover for the oil industry to smear fracking opponents. That "twist" came from the facts of the film coming to light, and the film company either having to scrap the film all together because it was complete horse shit, or coming up with some way to salvage it.
-
Of course let us not forget that this bit of offal is financed by the UAE, which stands to loose big money unless Matt Damon can convince people to forgo clean natural gas. The movie is misleading and displays an ignorance of what hydraulic fracking is that would almost be laughable. On the other hand enough morons voted to reelect Obama.
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 3:59 p.m. CST
Fraking good? Fraking bad? I just love the attitude "The global climate is doomed, nothing is going to reverse it now, and it's very much every nation for themselves. All that matters is that we somehow stop ourselves from going under before China and Rus
by openthepodbaydoorshal
Why does the image of Slim Pickens yehaain' on the back of a nuclear warhead pop in my mind?
-
This man was a legend and we need a talkback
-
After the recent embarrassment of ignoring Larry Hagman's passing, one thing I've wondered is if the folks here have a policy of no obituaries at all, anymore. I doubt it; it's more than 99.999999999% likely due to laziness and general unprofessional indifference, but even if they did have said policy in effect, it isn't like Harry would deign to tell US about it... getting pertinent information from Harry is like trying to push a wet rope uphill. 3 deaths of very well-known and popular celebrities and/or artists in the last two days, and the only mentions are by talkbackers. Funny how all those other sites seem to have somebody on the ball.... IF we hear anything, at all, from SOMEBODY here, about ANY of these deaths, I have very little doubt it will include a snide excuse or two about: it was the holidays, we wanted to get X person's obituary juuuuust right, you all whine too much, etc. And they, or any talkbacker here, are free to call what I'm saying here whining- that's fine, fair enough; I'm just trying to point out the general sloth and baffling silence that seems to pervade the contributors here on this one subject. So what's the deal, once and for all, Harry and Co.- no obituaries, just your hand-picked favorites, or what? It's not like obituaries don't generate hits, so what's the deal? I'm even fine with the Docback-style rules about decorum in obit talkbacks- but really, what gives? Harry? Quint? Herc? Anyone??
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 6:09 p.m. CST
I liked this better when it had Melissa Gilbert and the Bean Tractor company.
by Raptor Jesus
All these remakes.
-
Fracking poisons the environment!! Fracking causes earthquakes!! Fracking creates Republicans!!
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 7:07 p.m. CST
wait til the big energy companies figure out a way to charge us by the minute for sunlight.
by chainsaw autotune
the denial of solar power shows what disgusting abominations big energy companies really are.
-
Big shots come in and make big promises to the town's hillbillies and poor folk...hire out of town cheap Mexicans exclusively for the jobs...leave town six months later with poorer water quality...cheap Mexicans stay in the town and smoke crack all day.
-
Yeah, I'll drink to that. Where the hell is Sexyback?
-
Having we all taken a break from the KIDD Vs hate? Just checking.
-
where's genderbenderblenderbibbdybobbdyboo? I miss that nutty wacky so-and-so! So much fun!
-
Dec. 26, 2012, 9:11 p.m. CST
Gerry Anderson made me believe that the future was going to be fantastic.
by elgato73
And that everything was going to awesome with nuclear powered airplanes and spaceships. Then the future came to be and everything changed. The review about Promised Land really brings this idea about the future being fantastic into full view. Fracking and what it does to the environment is so far away from what Anderson envisioned the future to be it makes me fucking sick. RIP sir. Sorry if the future was such a fucking let down.
-
Matt Damon would kick the Kidd's ass in less than 5 minutes. I'd watch that on Pay-per-view!
-
...ya there may be something wrong. And fracking companies do admit fracking causes minor earthquakes/tremors (Questerre in Canada for example). But too many frogs in too many slowly boiling pots have swallowed the tripe slowly fed to them and now spout the buzzwords. I think we're already screwed. We're Wiley E Coyote and we've already run off the cliff. Some of us are looking down and some of us think that if we refuse to we'll be just fine.
-
For what it's worth...
-
that THE CHOPPAH and Genderbenderblenderbanger finally met cute in real life, were legally married in Vermont, and that CHOPPAH is fulfilling a lifelong dream of running a dinner theater that performs only stage adaptations of the films of Stanley Kubrick, while GB continues to be a fairly well known syndicated sex and relationships advice columnist.
-
Complaining about the 'vs' is so silly, you guys are ridiculous and will complain about anything. Admit it, you just don't like Kidd for some other retarded reason and you're just looking for an excuse to complain about anything he posts. Kidd's reviews are just about the only thing left on this site worth reading, and all you guys do is bitch about his so-called adversarial stance. Dur.
-
OPEC funded this garbage. Tells you all you need to know about this movie. But we get it. Liberal hand wringing eco propaganda is "cool" so we must give it a good review, regardless if it's based on lies and funded by overseas oil companies. Matt Damon is a clown. A meat puppet for the agenda of foreign oil corporations. Shame on AICN for propping up this garbage.
-
...funded Zero Dark Thirty and The Help and Men In Black 3 and The Beaver and The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel. If they'd funded a Uwe Boll movie, or a documentary about Nickelback, THEN I'd be shaking in my boots. *eyes roll, so fast I'm gettin' whiplash*
-
Dec. 27, 2012, 6:32 a.m. CST
i'm still rolling my eyes - this time at django's revenge...
by Detached
nice to know you claim i'm "making up stories" about someone i've known for nearly 30 years. sorry, but it's true- there's been fracking on his rural land for decades, with no problem at all. just whining that something is made up (as if you would have any way whatever to know) is hardly a rebuttal. but then, when the facts are against you, i guess all you can do is just make things up yourself out of thin air.
-
Dec. 27, 2012, 7:36 a.m. CST
Funny. Environmentalist were originally the ones pushing fracking.
by OutsideChance
Back then they were about it reducing greenhouse gas. Then they heard the urban legend about flaming groundwater and decided they didn't like it. It really is a religion with these people: faith, superstitiution and a rigid insistence on imposing 'morality' into policy arguments.
-
Dec. 27, 2012, 8:41 a.m. CST
Have you all heard about the fracking operation in PA that's only a mile away from a nuclear power plant?
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Yeah...
-
I believe he went full-bore Alex Jones and disappeared in a doomsday prepper shelter. Either that or his wife finally had enough of his online antics interrupting their married life...
-
After all...this thread is typical of not only our AICN political discourse lately but all political discourse in the states. its just pointless and mindlessly angry. All it takes is one person claiming it's a conspiracy by badguys and viola, effectively a non-issue for us to never be concerned about and certainly never discuss nor debate. We can't even discuss it cause, if you disagree, you're obviously an unwitting shill for any number of shadowy agents with any number of ill-intentions for things you hold dear. As opposed to, you know, people with a different opinion based on the facts That and the issue that none of you has a monopoly on those facts. Professor Falken was right you know. Abundantly so, I might add.
-
Are you stupid? On drugs? Or, are you just "special?"
-
Dec. 27, 2012, 5:54 p.m. CST
Nice try, Matt Damon, but you can never top Argo! Ohhh Argo!! Jizz jizz jizz!
by Fries Against
-
Dec. 27, 2012, 6:02 p.m. CST
If only I WAS an unwitting shill for any number of shadowy agents
by Monroville
Then maybe I could retire while I'm still young enough to enjoy it. And I concur with someone's statement above about how we should have learned all we need to know about the perils of frakking with Dr. Baltar. Too much frakking on the job can lead to the end of your civilization.
-
Dec. 28, 2012, 1:53 a.m. CST
The Kidd v/s correct comma usage, and third grade grammar skills
by ParagonComplex
Correct comma usage, and third grade grammar skills gets its ass handed to it. I haven't seen writing this bad since I taught middle school English. Hell, they would kick The Kidd's ass. I still bet money he's a teenager with a relative that writes for AICN. It'd explain everything.
-
Dec. 28, 2012, 3:29 a.m. CST
@mrnicegaius And in Canada there's a fracking company that wants to frack right next to...
by tangcameo
...the water supply for the city of Calgary, Alberta. Just over a million people.
-
Dec. 28, 2012, 3:32 a.m. CST
I'm waiting for them to introduce a newer, safer technique called...
by tangcameo
...felgercarbing!
-
Wow, that's kinda nuts. Especially when you consider that despite what the partisan shills say, they still don't know the long term seismological effects of the process.
-
just saying a fact. I'm running a gas heater to stay warm right now so I'm biased : )
-
Dec. 29, 2012, 2:56 a.m. CST
Spacehog, did you just reference Kafka's "The Penal Colony"? If so, that is fascinateing.
by ChaunceyGardiner
-
Every action has a consequence, either intentional or not- And in the trailers for this, damn, Frances is looking Fargoed & Frakked! And trailer = seen the movie. ;-)
-
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/opedcolumnists/for_his_next_escape_x46uFSONrAaCey67ZzZV0I
-
Dec. 30, 2012, 1:59 p.m. CST
So this movie tries to be the "Local Hero" of the 2010s?
by AsimovLives
It's a noble ambition, that.
Top Talkbacks
- Microsoft's Reveal Of The Next XBOX Is Upon Us, And Streaming Here!! -- 230 total posts 230 posts
- Has STAR WARS EPISODE VII Landed Its First Non-OT Cast Member? -- 454 total posts 156 posts
- The New WOLVERINE Trailer Brings Forth More Jean Grey!! -- 150 total posts 150 posts
- Harry dives into STAR TREK INTO DARKNESS' spoilers to reveal the truth behind the blockbuster we're seeing! -- 1214 total posts 113 posts
- Steven Seagal might be joining THE EXPENDABLES 3!! -- 254 total posts 101 posts
- So which character is going to be the villain in GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY!?! -- 70 total posts 70 posts
- Harry's 21st Picks & Peeks of 2013 has MEDIUM COOL, THE LAST STAND, THE BURNING, BATMAN, MIYAZAKI Blus and more!!! -- 52 total posts 52 posts
- Nordling Reviews STAR TREK INTO DARKNESS! Spoilers Abound! You Are Warned! -- 1352 total posts 46 posts
-
That’s Larry David??
HBO’s Promo For
CLEAR HISTORY!! -- 27 total posts 27 posts - John Ary's Video Review Of The New CAPTAIN AMERICA (1990) Blu-ray!! -- 196 total posts 24 posts

