Cool News
The Kidd Vs. CLOUD ATLAS

I wish I knew where to begin when talking about CLOUD ATLAS. The big screen adaptation of David Mitchell’s novel from the Wachowskis and Tom Tykwer is just so much movie, following at times six different story arcs, that it’s damn near impossible to do any of it justice without ripping off a 50-page thesis. However, what I can tell you is that CLOUD ATLAS is no ordinary film. This is a profound experience with big thought-provoking ideas that challenges you to consider each one of our places in the world and how it affects everyone around us, whether during the present time or way off in the future. On an intellectual level, this is the film that PROMETHEUS wishes it was in trying to raise unanswered questions that force us to ponder the nature of our very existence, and, much more than films like THE TREE OF LIFE or THE FOUNTAIN, which attempt to do something similar, CLOUD ATLAS succeeds at being both visually stunning and emotionally engaging, drawing you in with interesting characters whose motivations are easy to understand and connecting with you on the very simple premise that all of humanity is linked together in some form or another. CLOUD ATLAS is an incredibly ambitious film that doesn’t need to be seen more than once for you to comprehend it, but you’re going to want to absorb every last frame again and again in the hopes that you take in something new upon each subsequent viewing for a richer and even more satisfying appreciation of ideas and art.
Where the Wachowskis examined mankind’s purpose throughout THE MATRIX Trilogy, CLOUD ATLAS goes even deeper in pondering our existence, raising the premise that our ordinary and simple lives may not even be our own, as we are bound to others – past, present and future – in such a way that the fact that we ever set foot on this earth will have a ripple effect on the world for eternity. Mind equals blown, and that’s just scratching the metaphysical surface as CLOUD ATLAS brings about inquiries into religion, philosophy, déjà vu, fate, destiny, karma, freedom, cosmic forces as it bends genres, incorporating elements of science fiction, romance, action-adventure, comedy, mystery, drama, conspiracy films, films of redemption, good old fashioned capers and revolution. There really is something for everyone in this epic piece of storytelling, and, for most of you, you’ll find yourself compelled by just about everything CLOUD ATLAS offers.
It’s almost expected to get something amazing to the eye from the Wachowskis and Tykwer, and CLOUD ATLAS certainly doesn’t fall short on that challenge, as the three directors do a truly unbelievable job in creating six different living, breathing worlds in which this wide array of souls lives, but without the ability to also create characters we can identify, it merely be another film of all style, no substance. However, using Mitchell’s novel as a blueprint, the trio who also penned the script are able to construct this set of personalities that represent what it is to be human – our flaws, our weaknesses, our vulnerabilities, our love, our passion, our greed, our fears, etc. They are the vehicles by which meaningful ideas are delivered, and with an impressive collection of actors and actresses – Tom Hanks, Halle Berry, Jim Broadbent, Hugo Weaving, Jim Sturgess, Doona Bae, Ben Whishaw, James D’Arcy, Zhou Xun, Keith David, David Gyasi, Susan Sarandon and Hugh Grant – all in roles unlike anything you’ve seen them do before, CLOUD ATLAS is able to take huge risks in essentially combining six fully realized stories into one cohesive film.

I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention the superb editing job done by Alexander Berner, who seamlessly pieces together these various story arcs. There is a great deal to bring together, and yet Berner is able to keep each story moving, while cutting back and forth between the other timelines at play, never losing you once in what’s going on and always keeping you locked in on the characters at hand. Multiple stories match beats at the same time, as if they’re on the same trajectory, and to cut those highs and lows simultaneously is really a thing of beauty. The score, which also shifts in sound between the numerous stories and the genres they toy with, is another rewarding piece of the puzzle. Johnny Klimek, Reinhold Heil and Tom Tykwer’s music, which I was compelled to listen to now, as I write this, is an impressive collection of musical stylings that accentuate the brilliance of the film and the enormity of its scope. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself wanting to grab a copy upon leaving the theatre, because the music of CLOUD ATLAS truly is some powerful stuff.
I get that CLOUD ATLAS isn’t going to be for everyone, but, if you’re a lover of cinema, this is one you absolutely must see. For all the bitching we do collectively about the state of movies these days, whether it’s the constant bombardment of sequels or reboots or prequels, here we have an incredibly ambitious and brave film that tries to do something innovative and different. That’s the type of film that should be celebrated, and as a film fan, even if it winds up not floating your boat, I am fairly certain you can at least find some degree of appreciation for the type of film Tykwer and the Wachowskis attempted to make. CLOUD ATLAS worked for me on a number of different levels, and the more I think about it, the more I love it. This is a film I urge you to check out. Movies like this don’t come around often anymore.
-Billy Donnelly
"The Infamous Billy The Kidd"
Follow me on Twitter.

Readers Talkback
comments powered by Disqus-
+ Expand All
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 1:37 a.m. CST
This film is gonna lead to some heavy discussion over the next few months.
by Randy
Some will hate it and some will love it.
-
Inquiring minds want to know.
-
It's written all over it. How can anyone NOT see this BS for what it is?
-
LSD? Mushrooms? MDMA? PCP?
-
I have to wonder if there's much of an appetite for films like this. I hope it does well but I have a feeling that a lot of filmgoers will scratch their heads and pass it by. Don't know when it's coming in the UK but there's been zero in the way of promotion so far. Tom Hanks is usually a draw but anything which smacks of 'sci-fi' (which I know this isn't but....) is likely to be a turn-off. I haven't read the book but I am intrigued by the reviews I've read so far and really want to see this on the big screen. Let's hope it lasts more than a week.
-
...and I'm still intrigued. The book could never be literally translated to the screen, and I don't think that's what they are going for. It looks like it will capture the spirit of the book, while still finding its own thesis, which is fine with me. Consider my butt in the theater at 11am sharp.
-
Wouldn't that be awesome?
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 2:21 a.m. CST
Also, this poster totally looks like the STAR WARS EPISODE II: ATTACK OF THE CLONES poster
by gruemanlives
-
*I'll grant that the film has many layers. All of them are terrible. * *insipid, TV-esque in its limited visual imagination, and dramatically incoherent* *Cloud Atlas, surely the most incoherent waste of time and money on screen this year. * Kidd, you say that if youre a lover of cinema this is a must see so how do you explain the slating this film is getting from the majority of the press? Are those professional reviewers not lovers of cinema?
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 3:08 a.m. CST
I never read the book and knew nothing about the subject matter but the trailers captured my interest.
by Chris
-
And I totally agree with the Kidd on this. I dug what it had to say about humanity love and what we are doing here and what's important and that individuals make a difference and that there's more to the relationships in your life than you might think. On top of that it's a well done and emotional piece of cinema. Will the make up and bits and pieces not work for everyone? Sure. But the people who this strikes a chord with will love it. The sonmi story (future pre apocalypse) really floored me emotionally.
-
If you are on of those people who likes to believe in all sorts of "woo" involving interpersonal connections and have this grand ideal of how beautiful everything would be if we would just "stop fighting man, and just be beautiful" then you are gonna love this. I'm a hard boiled ,long time, life beaten skeptic of everything that can't be backed up with evidence. so I thought it was a preachy bore.... visuals are amazing, score is very very good, performances are,overall, well done. It just smelled like I had just been told that my "chakras" were out of balance with a 57 yr old fat kindergarten teach and everything would be right with the world if I just went to her and made that happen." oh, and paid the asshle who told me this $1200
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 4:09 a.m. CST
I desperatly want to see this movie but its relased in fucking february in the uk
by rakesh patel
just rediculous in this day and age.
-
He's posting the same thing in all the CLOUD ATLAS reviews. Very childish but I guess he needs the attention.
-
So what if the majority of reviewers are not giving the same assessment of this movie. That proves nothing. One thing I do know is that besides Kidd, the one other reviewer that I trust and respect, even if I don't always agree with, is Roger Ebert and he gave it 4 stars. Yeah, now I know the primary response by you or others will be to find reason to dismiss Ebert but based on the reasoning he brings to his reviews and his overall body of work, I think its more logical to dismiss you.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 5:17 a.m. CST
Cobra's pissed because this is a movie about people influencing other people
by IAmTommyWiseau
And Cobra's life is completely insignificant.
-
You were able to convey the essence of this movie without feeling the need to simply tell us the story and plot points. Some movies can be explained but occasionally we get that gem of a movie that simply must be experienced. The fact of the matter is that not everybody is ready for a movie like Cloud Atlas but perhaps one day if and when they are this movie and those like it will be waiting for them. Sometimes a movie is much more than a movie and it can be a vehicle for our imagination and intellect if we would only free our minds from the conventional contraints we normally impose on movies.
-
Big praise. Big letdowns. No inbetween. This is polarizing on a whole 'other level. It being released in february in the UK should tell you something about what WB thinks about it. What this means for a Wachowski JL... Who knows?
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 5:42 a.m. CST
Won't get to see it for at least another week, but I'm still excited
by WerePlatypus
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 6:34 a.m. CST
Lets all throw the talkback off track and talk about the new Conan some more.
by Fries Against
-
that it's going to be one of those that, if a negative opinion is expressed about it, the criitcism will met with "You just don't get it".
-
Ha! No im not a lemming - in fact quite the opposite, I prefer the QED approach. Question everything done. So when the Kidd states that *if youre a lover of cinema this is an absolute must see.*.. why then do the majority of professional reviewers say its awful? Thus I question the Kidd and ask him to explain. Are those professional reviewers not lovers of cinema? ps. fuck you tommywiseau, you're named after the most insignificant carbuncle on the ass of the industry.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 7:53 a.m. CST
Soon to be double packed with What Dreams May Come in the Walmart $5 bin.
by adeceasedfan
-
Oh, to be young and simple-minded enough to be profoundly moved by sophomoric philosophical meanderings (what the Wachowskis do best). Whoa... and have you ever realized that 'DOG' spelled backwards is 'GOD'?
-
But is it really?
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 8:16 a.m. CST
consider each one of our places in the world and how it affects everyone around us
by brobdingnag
More collectivist propaganda from Hollywood. There is no 'we.' There is you, and I, and others. The idea of we is the idea of enslavement of the individual. There is enough of that going on in the real world, I don't need it in my entertainment.
-
I'm furiously skeptical. On the one hand, I really want to see how they're able to weave six stories into one. On the other hand, it seems like it might be a little TOO above everyone's heads, to the point of being pretentious. Guess I'll have to see it and find out.
-
I enjoyed Speed Racer. I loved Neo's discussion with the architect in Matrix Reloaded. Not a huge fan of V for Vendetta, but I might like it better if I watched it again. I'm not expecting to have my world rocked. But you never know.
-
Which was absolute garbage, IMHO. I will also like it better than What Dreams Will Come, which was actually an alternate take on Patch Adams, only that time, everybody died.
-
I would rather see this try and fail 90% of the movies that shoved out at use, made to a release date. as for reviewers, I will guarantee the lana wachowski's change of sex influences at least 10% of reviews, professional or otherwise. Especially in coutries that have a heavy religious bent (like Italy, for example)
-
Never read the damn thing. If they can make a movie out of this, they can sure as hell make House of Leaves.
-
No time traveling today? BTW I would love a Patch Adams alternate cut where everybody dies.
-
I'd like a cloud atlas style reworking of PATCH ADAMS where we get to see Patch as a dr during the the American Civil War, working as a clown in the Russian state circus, and then Patch in the future operating on Bicentennial Man... that sort of shit. All interconnected timeframes in a Patch Adams Patchwork. MAKE IT HAPPEN!
-
I might just make my own edit using random Robin Williams footage from PATCH ADAMS, BICENTENNIAL MAN, WHAT DREAMS MAY COME, GOOD MORNING VIETNAM and that one where he works in a photo booth and whacks off over the pics. Cut all those scenes together and pretend it's just PATCH ADAMS living alternate cloud atlas lives. Who wants to come over to the Dojo for a movie night and check out the premiere? Its gonna be deep.
-
Just don't cut any of my scenes. A weeks worth of extra work whittled down to a crowd shot. Boo Tom Shadyac. I'm a STAR! Tie my shoe!
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:12 a.m. CST
BIG SURPRISE Cobra-kai is down on something?! Cobra-kai coming off as pretentious, Cobra-kai thinking he knows better then EVERYONE on AICN. Yeah, big surprise. Lighten up dude, you'll live longer.
by peter
For the record, this is Kidd's OPINION!! as with ALL FREAKING REVIEWERS ON THE PLANET!! O.P.I.N.I.O.N. Definition of opinion: noun "A view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge" You're 1st post is typical of people on this site who think they have the most important thing to say. Again, for the record, I don't not like you Cobra, sometimes you say interesting stuff. But more often then not, you're spouting off negative shit about some reviewer like you could do better. It comes across like you wish you had a job writing for AICN. A review (usually a film) is always based on personal taste. so yeah, relaxxxxxx, you have to relax when you make the crank call.
-
Do you have Prince Albert in the can?
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:22 a.m. CST
macheesmo3: yeah but like.. The supernatural is real. So with that knowledge moving forward. How can you say that this movie isn't right on the money?
by UltraTron
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:23 a.m. CST
Downtalking The Fountain only disqualifies a review in my eyes.
by MariusXe
Brilliant movie.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:23 a.m. CST
Yes as much as I'd like to not believe in it because frankly the enormity of first-hand proof of the supernatural is quite scary.. It does exist.
by UltraTron
-
Movies like this don’t come around often anymore
-
That LOL was in regards to the crank call line. You can settle your differences in the arena. Full contact.
-
adeceasedfan, im still just reeling from the fact that you were in PATCH ADAMS! If I was a deceased fan that's something i'd want on my headstone.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:43 a.m. CST
Lemme guess: The mind-blending ideas that really make you think can be boiled down to:
by Royston Lodge
Wouldn't it be great if everyone was nice to each other for a change? It's just a guess, but I find that when I'm told any piece of fiction is really 'profound', or 'mind-expanding', or whatever, the message can almost always be boiled down to that one sentence.
-
And I shall be laid to rest with a foam clown nose. Open casket of course.
-
The supernatural is real because of the amount of first hand experience? You mean because of the amount you experienced? Because of the amount of stories of other people's experiences? That makes no sense. At all.
-
I was a bit too wordy. I should have said what you said.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 10:23 a.m. CST
What if Brad Bird directed this new Conan movie if Milius is unavailable/unwilling?
by albert comin
We know thayt Brid can direct big live action movies and do it with style.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 10:42 a.m. CST
Yeah I know it's crazy everyone but trust me. There's a god. My friends and I proved it with standard scientific method. We were all shocked. Like seeing is believing and we saw some shit. No religion. No
by UltraTron
man-made lies. Real supernatural or technology beyond our capabilities indistinguishable from magic shit.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 10:50 a.m. CST
Learn online how to do things like prove you have left your body. You can leave your body and prove it so that when you return you have the proof
by UltraTron
-
Wasn't interested in this in the slightest until I read your review. Very cool. Looking forward to checking it out now. But, I must say: All the (collective) bitching about 'Prometheus' is completely unwarranted. I *finally* was able to see it recently, and I absolutely loved it. Loved the story. Loved the acting. Loved all the long, epic shots--especially at the beginning. It definitely feels like the first 'Alien' in tone, and I loved that too. Sure, there were a few things lacking in a couple areas, but you can say that about any movie, really. And, now that a sequel is pretty much happening, all those who hated the "unanswered questions" will be able to get some of the answers they were seeking (hopefully). But I digress. Thanks again for the review. I've been hesitant to watch anything the Wachowskis make since the 3rd 'Matrix' and onward. So, I'm glad to see Kidd praise 'Cloud Atlas'. I hope it's a return to form for the "brothers" (hehe, I couldn't resist).
-
CLOUD ATLAS is hit & miss, but you should watch it anyway. It's always engaging & interesting, and provides a lot to think on and discuss. Despite its flaws, there's just so much it brings to the table. Regardless of your opinion of it, it deserves to be experienced. (In this way, one might compare it to Prometheus). It is true that I was disappointed by it, in a large part because of the misleading trailer which promised a very different (and better) film from the one I saw, and also because some distracting elements present. BUT the film we got is a lavish and daring 3-hour, high-concept, decently budgeted, R-rated film that is unlike anything that's come before it, and isn't a sequel/remake. This demands our attention. Support studios and filmmakers who make high-risk, big-budget grown-up films with your dollars, or get more like Jack & Jill: Human Centipede.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 11:58 a.m. CST
@impetus: Thanks for your input. I'm definitely looking forward to this now
by Kremzeek
-
I haven't really been that intrigued, based on the trailers I've seen. It LOOKS nice, but I don't know if I'm really all that excited by the story. To be honest, the trailers give me almost no sense of what the story actually IS. But, it's the Wachowskis and Tom Hanks, therefore it's guaranteed to top the box office.
-
First off, this is perhaps the one possitive review from the Kidd I have read in a long time, so I know something's up. I am keenly aware the Wachowskis tend to have a collectivist philosophy toward things, so I am wary of buying into the (apparent) subtext of the film. That said though, I remain intrigued by some of the ideas and visuals put forth, so I just might see this.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 4:44 p.m. CST
CLOUD ATLAS seems like it's trying way to hard to be deep but the problem is people aren't deep anymore and deep isn't cool.
by MENTALDOMINANCE
What the kids call deep today is shallow. The movie still looks chok full of obvious CGI and an overbearing score... Like they're cramming it in our face and saying "THIS IS EPIC LOOK AT US WOO HOO!!!" I'll reserve judgement till I see it but it does not look good at all to me... The 5 minute trailer was cringe worthy.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 4:44 p.m. CST
EPIC means more than the sum of it's parts. PEople today don't get this.
by MENTALDOMINANCE
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 4:45 p.m. CST
You can't just throw a ton of stuff from prior "epic" movies and trick people to enjoying it... Well, you can I guess... Society is dumbed down.
by MENTALDOMINANCE
-
I got six.
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 8:55 p.m. CST
This review is so terribly written it makes my heart pound.
by ParagonComplex
Hey, Kidd, are you related to one of the AICN writers? That's the only way I could see you getting this writing job. Stop using so many damn unnecessary commas amongst other things. Good fucking god, I could write you under a bus. How the hell do I get a job writing on AICN so I can show you how it's done? I am tempted to go through this abysmal atrocity line by line and correct all of your mistakes. You seriously need a damned editor. Not even trying to be an asshole here. You probably really are a kid, and if you take constructive criticism, take English class more seriously, and practice you could have potential. Until then: anata wa mada mada da ne desuyo
-
Oct. 26, 2012, 9:59 p.m. CST
I really enjoyed the movie, for me it was my favorite movie of the year so far
by Dreamwriter
The different stories were all interesting, and the editing interwove them perfectly. It was great how the scene would change like you would expect from any movie while a character voice over is going on and suddenly you realize it's changed to a different set of characters in a different time period, but it's so smooth you don't notice it at first. But you are still able to follow the stories. And they really are very different stories, that would fit different genres, and for the most part they don't really have anything directly to do with each other.
-
I just could not see how all this shit was supposed to be tied together. I have literally no idea what the connection between all the various timelines was supposed to be, apart from being very distracting because the same actors keep showing up.
-
.. hey look over there, what's that!?
-
This is gonna be a bad blasting zone! Remember that last one, we lost Billy?
-
Oct. 27, 2012, 10:43 a.m. CST
So you're saying I should see Silent Hill: Revelation instead?
by Jonathan
Gotcha. >_<
-
Oct. 27, 2012, 12:04 p.m. CST
Saw Cloud Atlas yesterday. Wasn't disappointed. Wasn't amazed like I was during 1st viewing of 'The Matrix'...
by peter
yes yes, before you all start shouting and bitching, I fully understand that both are separate films. Anyway, I enjoyed it. It definitely was not boring. It didn't feel like almost 3 hours. It was entertaining. It was very original, clever. I loved seeing actors I'm well accustomed with playing different roles to what we are used to seeing. I didn't get any life changing thoughts flood my mind. I still couldn't really tell you what it was about if you asked. I loved the different segments and the way they interwove. I loved the different makeup styles. The futuristic story was probably my favorite. I wish Lana (larry with no penis) and Andy created more futuristic films similar to The Matrix. I actually wish they revisited another Matrix trilogy with a new cast. I don't care that the Matrix sequels were shitty in Nordlings mind. He can suck my balls for all I care. But I digress, the Cloud Atlas was an original, entertaining piece of cinema which I would happily see again. My wife is not a fan of 'R' rated films, she is sensitive and very visual and has nightmares for weeks if films are too gratuitous but I think this film wasn't too crazy in that area. So I may take her to see this. Go see it. It's unlike anything else out there. Leave your "THIS IS GOING TO BE THE MOST LIFE CHANGING, THOUGHT PROVOKING FILM IN THE HISTORY OF CINEMA" expectations at the door. Simply go, watch enjoy. That's my 2 cents worth for anyone who gives a crap.
-
The Kidd vs. PATCH ADAMS. PATCH ADAMS wins.
-
Oct. 27, 2012, 12:31 p.m. CST
cobra, do you have some kind of vendetta against the kidd?? cause you seem to always be riding his ass?
by peter
-
No. Not hate for the Kidd. Just love. Love for Patch Adams.
-
Maybe I'm wrong......the whole subjunctive thing is confusing.....
-
*Just love. Love for Patch Adams* LMFAO!!!
-
Cat... K--A--T. I'm outta here I know there's two T's.
Top Talkbacks
- PROMETHEUS 2 now has a writer!!! -- 636 total posts 469 posts
- John Ary's Video Review Of WORLD WAR Z!! -- 217 total posts 217 posts
- Harry's 25th Picks & Peeks of 2013!!! With THINGS TO COME, OCTAMAN, Bette Davis, STOKER, HOWLING, LIFEFORCE & more! -- 215 total posts 215 posts
- Ryan Reynolds No Longer the HIGHLANDER -- 320 total posts 205 posts
- David S. Goyer And Mr. Beaks Talk MAN OF STEEL Spoilers! DA VINCI'S DEMONS,100 BULLETS And JUSTICE LEAGUE Also Discussed! -- 494 total posts 188 posts
- Behold A Nifty New Poster For Disney's THE BLACK HOLE (1979)!! -- 157 total posts 157 posts
- SIN CITY 2: A DAME TO KILL FOR delayed to next year. NOOOOOO!!!!! -- 155 total posts 123 posts
- Father Geek says MAN OF STEEL is pretty much the best Superhero Movie ever made and I'm not gonna argue! -- 1849 total posts 115 posts
- We have the first trailer for Disney Animation's next film, FROZEN right here!!! -- 96 total posts 96 posts
- Sony has announced release dates for both THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 3 and THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 4!!! -- 221 total posts 85 posts

