AICN COMICS REVIEWS: Week Four of DC’s #0 Issues! In stores TODAY!!!
|Issue #||Release Date:||Vol.#11|
(Click title to go directly to the review)
BATMAN INC. #0
I, VAMPIRE #0
JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK #0
THE SAVAGE HAWKMAN #0
BATMAN: THE DARK KNIGHT #0
TEEN TITANS #0
THE FURY OF FIRESTORM #0
ALL STAR WESTERN #0
RED LANTERNS #0
BATMAN INCORPORATED #0Writers: Grant Morrison and Chris Burnham
Artist: Frazer Irving
Reviewer: Matt Adler
BATMAN INCORPORATED has probably been my favorite series of the New 52. I love the light-hearted approach it takes to the Batman mythos in contrast to the relentlessly grim tone of the other Bat-books. I’ve said as much in our podcasts, but some of my fellow podcasters take issue with the very concept of the book, and dislike the notion of a team of international Batmen. I’ve countered by saying that isn’t really the focus of the book, and that it’s really more of a continuation of Morrison’s BATMAN AND ROBIN than anything else.
Well, I can’t make that argument with this issue. It focuses pretty much exclusively on how Batman recruited the various members of Batman Incorporated, giving particular attention to Australia’s Dark Ranger and the UK’s Knight and Squire. The theme of the story is that even Batman needs help, and the threat of Leviathan, Talia Al Ghul’s secret organization, is the reason. Unfortunately, none of these international Batmen have much personality; a few of them even descend into stereotypes. Even Dark Ranger never rises above the cliché of the reluctant hero who’s hung up his costume because his partner got killed.
Frazer Irving’s art is gorgeous, of course, and he apparently handles everything from pencils to colors, but it’s a radical departure from Chris Burnham’s frenetic pop style, with its murky tones and painterly feel. There were moments in this issue that I enjoyed, such as Bruce’s none too subtle threat to his Board of Directors, which he uses to coerce them into supporting his crazy Batman Incorporated venture. But unlike most of the issues in the series thus far, it never really comes together to provide you with a feeling of excitement, or wanting to know what comes next. A rare miss for Morrison.
Matt Adler is a writer/journalist, currently writing for AICN among other outlets. He’s been reading comics for 20 years, writing about them for 7, and spends way, way, too much time thinking about them, which means he really has no choice but to figure out how to make a living out of them. He welcomes all feedback.
THE FLASH #0Writers: Francis Manapul & Brian Buccellato
Art: Francis Manapul (art), Brian Buccellato & Ian Herring (colors)
Reviewer: Johnny Destructo
My dearest Wally West,
It breaks my heart that you and I had to go our separate ways. I know that it wasn't something you wanted, and I'm damn sure it wasn't something I wanted, or was even prepared to deal with. Even though at first, I wasn't sure I even wanted to be with you, eventually you wormed your snide and spoiled way into my heart. I thought people might look at us funny, drawn to each other just because of the sameness of our hair color. But damn them all, we are Firecrotches for life, bound by our burning Dark Phoenix short & curlies. Besides, after a while, I just stopped caring. I became proud to carry you with me. Let the people on the buses and subways gawk all they wanted, you and I were meant to be together, my most Scarlet of Speedsters.
Over the course of our relationship, you and I both grew up from (if you'll excuse the phrase) impulse kids into responsible adults, but still living in the shadow of others. We fought for ourselves, you and I, and we persevered. But then I watched helplessly as you ruined your life with terrible, terrible children. Oh, how I wanted to go back in time and ret-con them into a sloppy mess on the dirty concrete of a back-alley abortion clinic. Not just for ME, my love, but for you as well! You were changing, I could feel it. No longer was our connection as boundless as it had once seemed. And then, I could see lightning on the horizon in the guise of Geoff Johns. He had done right by you previously, and oh the times we had, the three of us. He got you just as much as I did. Good lord, as the memories wash over me, so to do the tears of regret.
Just as you were letting him go and racing from under his shadow, Johns used dark magicks to bring back your Uncle Barry.
But that wasn't enough. As time went by and you faded out of the spotlight, Barry took center stage. My heart couldn't handle it. I composed many a suicide note while struggling to remain interested in that blonde-haired bow-tie wearing bollocks-licker. Not even Geoff Johns, who had worked miracles on you before, could make me love this re-youth-enated bastard. Don't look for a dictionary, my love…it isn't a word.
Once the New 52 started, I tried again to give a good gosh darn about Barry, but holy cats was he a dry character. I loved some of the things that the new writer/artist had done with Barry's powers. The running on the rotating blades of a helicopter? The super-quick thinking that allowed him to foresee every possibility? Hell, my favorite scene was when Barry got so tied up concentrating on possibilities that he got shot in the head! Brilliant! But alas, having interesting things happen to a character doesn't make him interesting, and I fell behind. I've missed the past 7 or 8 issues of the book, a title that used to give me such glee when it was just you and me.
And that brings us to this newest issue. It's a retelling of that blonde bastard's origin, and I was prepared to hate it. To show DC the hate that it showed me, by squashing our love, my dear Wallace. Squashed it like a bug on the face shield of that unforgivably bad Jay Garrick costume we've had to look at in Earth 2.
But, I didn't hate it. I realized, after I started to let my mile-high emotional walls down, that maybe there was something interesting about Barry after all. We harkened back the obligatory five years, and I got to watch the classic scene in which Barry received his powers. The same one that he would eventually and irresponsibly recreate, allowing you to become a Flash as well. But the moment's fire is dramatically fueled by the fact that Barry is in the middle of throwing his equipment through a window when he is touched by the speed-giving light. He's frustrated, you see. Emotional, even. A state that I'm not used to seeing from ol’ Crew-Cut. He's been trying for years to uncover the mystery behind his mother's death, and hopefully get his supposedly framed father out of prison. I was then taken on a whirlwind of flashbacks as Barry lay in a coma. It seems that he's Lt. Frye's "golden boy" because Frye is like a father to Barry. Well, you know…a "not in prison for the murder of his mother" type of father. We also see the origin of Barry's lame-ass bow tie. I don't care what the Dr. Who fan-shirt says: Bow Ties are NOT cool. So sayeth the geek with the GI Joe tattoo! It also seems that Barry's mother and father were on the brink of divorce because of another man, who I'm going to assume is the aforementioned Lt. Frye.
Another interesting point that I noticed about Barry's upbringing is that his doting and loving mother was always telling him to slow down, to take his time and think things through, and then his father would come in and literally hurry the boy up. "We've gotta go." "Be back before dinner". There's an interesting dichotomy at work here, a pushing and pulling within Barry that I hope is explored further, but at least it adds an interesting layer the character.
I also love the scene where Barry first employs his superspeed. In the original, um…origin, Barry was running to get a cab and runs past it. This scene is far more personal, as he was in his coma, dreaming when it happened. In the dream, he was coming home to find his mother had been killed and was trying to run past the cops to his mother's body when he apparently went sleep-running. He awoke to find that he had run to East Africa by accident. A far cooler scene, if you ask me.
And that's the thing, Wally. This origin story is filled to the brim with emotional beats that invested me in the character in a way that I wasn't expecting. Now, I do remember that some of this is ground already worn down by Geoff Johns, the mother-murder story. It turned out that his mom was killed by Reverse-Flash, and that Barry's attempts at saving her created the Flashpoint Universe, and in turn created the entire New 52. I'm curious to see if Manapul will be using that same villain as the cause, or if this is going to start heading in the direction of a true mystery, not one that I'm just re-reading for the sake of it. Either way, for the first time, I think I'm actually interested in finding out.
I hope this doesn't hurt you to read, my red-headed rapscallion. But as much as I love you, and will love you…I'm starting to wonder if there isn't a brighter future ahead. I know you'll be back someday; of course you will. I have undying hope. Just as Barry returned, so shall you.
I'll be waiting for you, one bated breath at a time. But until then, I hope you don't mind if I hang out with Barry awhile. He might be a pretty cool dude.
Yours in the speed-force,
P.S. I still wear those Flash underoos you gave me, and think of you fondly when I do.
JD can be found hosting the PopTards Podcast, drawing a weekly webcomic, discussing movies, comics and other flimflam over at www.poptardsgo.com, graphically designing/illustrating for a living, and Booking his Face off over here. Follow his twitter @poptardsgo. His talkback name is PopTard_JD. He is also now co-hosting another Comic Book discussion show on Party934.com alongside Bohdi Zen. They discuss comics and play music, check it out live every Saturday from 4-5pm.
I, VAMPIRE #0Writer: Joshua Hale Fialkov
Art: Andrea Sorrentino
Reviewer: Optimous Douche
As we reach the end of zero month, or as some have dubbed it “New 52 Course Correction,” two clear categories of books have arisen: there’s definitive prequels and what I have cynically dubbed issues 13.
My mortal perception of linear time made it hard to grapple with the fact not all zeroes must precede the events of issue one. I hit some books with reviewer abuse because of this prejudice. But as we now reach the end of this event, I had an epiphany or moment of forgiveness to see the merits in both approaches in moving the New DCU into Year 2. Which is honestly all DC ever promised; prequel was a badge stitched on by fans.
Or at least I did before reading I, VAMPIRE…
I, VAMPIRE is a case where I really wanted to see an issue 13, but instead it clearly fits into the prequel category of my zero month taxonomy. Make no mistake, Fialkov and Sorrentino deliver the goods in this story of Andrew Bennett before he became the world’s nicest vampire, but I don’t know if I discovered enough surprises to say I absolutely needed this story.
In a time when manly men could wear lace and women were still wenches, Lord Bennett lives in the shadows of a love that must not be named. No, not bestiality. Well…maybe bestiality if you consider banging the help the same as schtupping a golden retriever. I know some blue bloods do, so I won’t judge. That’s right, folks, the blood lust Mary, who is soooo superior with her belief that vampires are a leg up on humanity, was once a common little cinder girl and Andrew her Lord in waiting. Mary and Andrew’s love has been forever doomed, which has been one of the most compelling elements of this series to date. In modern times it is ideology that separates them, while in this time of yore it was class.
I guess my beef with this zero offering (if you can call it that) is that I kind of guessed what was going to happen. Once I realized we were in elder days, when Bennett rode into the night to get some Mary play in a stable or broom closet (wherever you go to bang the help), I wasn’t exactly shocked to see his run-in with Cain, his maker and the original vampire.
Mary is basically a non-entity in this issue, which is a shame. I have found her to be a compelling antagonist and would have liked some of her life thoughts before she entered the unlife.
Again, Fialkov made the verbal parlay engaging. Bennett never cowers, and Cain shows admiration for Bennett’s courage, much the same way I find it cute when our live lobsters try to escape the sink. And Sorrentino, good God can Sorrentino draw. His talent has been one of the biggest surprises of the New 52, and I can’t wait to see more work thrown his way.
Optimous has successfully blackmailed fellow @$$Hole BottleImp into being his artist on Average Joe. Look for Imp's forced labor on Optimous brain child in mid-2012 from COM.X. Friend Optimous on FaceBook to get Average Joe updates and because ceiling cat says it's the right thing to do.
JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK #0Writer: Jeff Lemire
Artist: Lee Garbett
Reviewer: Matt Adler
John Constantine is one of those characters who’s a very distinctive archetype, but can wear on you pretty quickly when he’s written as nothing more than a sum of clichés. I tried JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK when Peter Milligan was writing it, and it didn’t work for me, for that among other reasons. Jeff Lemire took over the book with issue #9, and this is the first issue of his run that I’ve tried. Would his take warm me up to the series?
The book starts off with John Constantine arriving in New York “some time ago”; Constantine’s style of dress (which I got a kick out of) suggests the late ‘70s/early ‘80s punk rock era, but that probably doesn’t fit with current DC continuity. He’s an ambitious young turk, already having gleaned all he can about magic in his home country, and eager to move to the next level, which he believes he will find in NYC.
We’re introduced to Nick Necro, “New York City’s greatest mage”, who seems certainly marked for death given that he doesn’t seem to be around in the present time. Zatanna is introduced at the same time, and Constantine’s love at first sight reaction to her is pretty amusing given his usually cynical portrayal.
The issue serves as a good intro into the DC’s occult world, and explains succinctly the mission that Constantine and Zatanna will find themselves on as part of JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK. As I said, it’s no surprise that Nick Necro, who becomes a mentor in the ways of magic to both Constantine and Zatanna, bites the dust, but the how and why is the interesting thing.
But perhaps the most compelling aspect of this issue is what it reveals about Constantine. Although we’re at first led to believe the issue intends to show us a softer, gentler side under that cynical exterior, what’s really revealed is an even darker side; someone who knows what he wants and is willing to do just about anything to get it. What that will mean for this series going forward is something I’m eager to find out.
THE SAVAGE HAWKMAN #0Writer: Rob Liefeld (plot/script) & Mark Poulton (script)
Art: Joe Bennett
Reviewer: Ambush Bug
Call me crazy, but I didn’t hate this Liefeld-penned issue of HAWKMAN, which looks to be shedding some light on the clouded history of our amnesiac winged hero of the DCU. I don’t regularly follow this book, though I am an admirer of Geoff Johns’ run on the book. Hawkman seems to be a character that is interesting to look at but hard to write other than a lost love story that Johns did so well. Here, Liefeld and Poulton try to simplify the story, tossing out the reincarnation stuff and focusing on the intergalactic righter of wrongs pastiche.
I’m not going to call this the most original story. It’s a bit reminiscent of space operas such as FLASH GORDON, mixed with some Camelot and surprisingly DEXTER (specifically the last season) as Carter and Shayera appear to be adopted siblings. For a character who has had such a problem in the past for having so many continuity glitches, one would think a concerted effort to really solidify an origin would be taken with this new 52 re-launch/boot/tread. Here, though, with Carter being adopted, things are left unclear if he is Thanagarian or something else (possibly from Earth? Who knows?).
What I do know is that looking at Joe Bennett’s panels is a treat. He’s such a talented artist and makes one almost look past all of the missed and glossed over opportunities for action that this issue is riddled with.
As much as some of the other DC 0 books, I feel Hawkman’s origin should be so much bigger than a single issue. Here it seems cramped with huge important chunks missing. Still, it’s not an awful book and at least offers enough interesting story fodder up for other writers to elaborate on.
Ambush Bug is Mark L. Miller, original @$$Hole/wordslinger/reviewer/co-editor of AICN Comics for over ten years. He has written comics such as MUSCLES & FIGHTS, MUSCLES & FRIGHTS, VINCENT PRICE PRESENTS TINGLERS & WITCHFINDER GENERAL, THE DEATHSPORT GAMES, WONDERLAND ANNUAL 2010 & NANNY & HANK (soon to be made into a feature film from Uptown 6 Films). He is also a regular writer for FAMOUS MONSTERS OF FILMLAND & has co-written their first ever comic book LUNA: ORDER OF THE WEREWOLF (to be released in late 2012 as an 100-pg original graphic novel). Mark has just announced his new comic book miniseries GRIMM FAIRY TALES PRESENTS THE JUNGLE BOOK from Zenescope Entertainment to be released March-August 2012. Also look for Mark's exciting arc on GRIMM FAIRY TALES #76-80 which begins in August 2012.
AQUAMAN #0Writer: Geoff Johns
Artists: Ivan Reis and Joe Prado
Reviewer: Matt Adler
AQUAMAN is not a series I have been following. My problem with Aquaman is not with his character, but with his setting. When I checked out the first issue, it was set almost entirely on dry land, in our mundane world. If I’m going to read a series about a superhero from a fabled underwater realm, I want that underwater realm to be as much of a character in the story as he is. I want to see lost royal houses, magic, medieval intrigue, the whole works. Otherwise, he’s just another superhero.
This zero issue starts off yet again in our world, six years prior, with a young Arthur Curry coming to terms with the media discovering his Atlantean heritage. That just doesn’t interest me.
However, it does pick up towards the end, when Arthur meets a refugee from Atlantis living among the humans, who convinces him to return to Atlantis and claim his birthright. Atlantis itself only turns up on the last page, but it’s an exciting sight to behold. If that is what the series’ focus has turned to, I may have to check it out again.
SUPERMAN #0Writer: Scott Lobdell
Artist: Kenneth Rockafort
Publisher: DC Comics
Reviewer: Optimous Douche
My favorite part of this issue was when Starfire came out of the water, dropped to all fours, and became an alien finger-cuff for Clark and Jimmy…oh, wait, wrong book. Hopefully, though, I pissed off at least three Mommy bloggers by invoking the sacred Starfire name.
H8Rs are going to hate. I could claim that this rendition of SUPERMAN was handed down to us by the ghost hands of Siegel, Shuster and Donner. That it completely retells the Man of Steel’s origin in a way never conceived and there would STILL be a collective yawn from the cynical comic cavalcade out there. So you know what, I’m not even going to try.
Some stories are simply timeless…like Superman, Batman, Jesus and Jeffrey Dahmer. And no matter how many times I read them, I always appreciate a fresh voice delivering the expected outcome. So it was with great gusto I ripped into this issue of SUPERMAN with a familiar, but wholly new, Kryptonian costumed figure bursting out of the cover.
I’ll also admit this creative team lives outside “50 Shades of Gray” in the comic community. People either love or hate these guys, no middle ground. Personally, I love them. RED HOOD AND THE OUTLAWS is one of my top five in the new DCU, and I couldn’t wait to read their unique take on a title that, let’s be honest, has been anything but stellar since relaunch.
Did they deliver? Absolutely! LobRocster take us to the days before the destruction of Krypton. But gone are the cool scientific minds of yore, where everyone on the Big K had a rod up their ass and spoke like they taught Elizabethan poetry. Yes, Krypton is more scientifically advanced, but at the same time they retain a level of,dare I say, humanity that has been absent in almost every past iteration of the planet that was.
Jor-El is a wunderkind scientist, but has a rebellious streak that feels truly edgy. Like Cartman he “does what he wants” all with a wink, nod and middle finger aimed at the authoriti of Krypton. In past iterations the Kryptonian science council treated Jor’s sky is falling (or, to be more accurate, the planet is exploding) findings as the ravings of a madman. In the world of zero the council no longer dismisses Jor-El’s words, but rather does everything in their power to get him to shut the fuck up. It’s a cloak and dagger reflection of real world politics and authority figures that all comics should strive for, regardless of canon from 100 years ago.
This hunt leads me seamlessly to Lara-El, Supes’ mom. BEST RENDITION EVER. She was always so January Jones in past iterations, basically window dressing with tits. In place simply because the writer HAD to have a vagina to get the story going. No more: Lobdell gives her a sense of purpose, a kick ass Ying to Jor’s scientific Yang. She’s also a scientist, but learned her craft at the Kryptonian Military Academy. To see Jor and Lar work in concert with her as the muscle and his Ozymandias-like foresight of enemy movements was a role reversal I find in many more couples these days – The Optimous house included.
As much as I loved the post ‘WORLD OF” titles that followed CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS, Lobdell has given these two more personality in one issue than the entire WORLD OF KRYPTON series. The beautiful dichotomy he presents as the two fight the science council and prepare for Armageddon has given a layer to SUPERMAN’S biological parents never seen.
I was honestly pissed this issue ended so quickly, I only hope and pray that issue 13 builds off this zero instead of zipping us back to the current continuity mess Kal has been suffering for the last 12 issues.
Regardless of my wishes or where the title goes tomorrow, and regardless of your personal feelings on LobRocster as a creative team, they WILL bring something different to the tale and for that all comic fans should be grateful.
VOODOO #0Writer: Joshua Williamson
Art: Sami Basri
Reviewer: Matt Adler
You know those little character blurbs in comics that are supposedly to briefly sum up and introduce you to the character? Like Superman’s might be, “Sent as an infant from a doomed planet, Clark Kent was raised by a kindly Midwestern couple, and now fights for Truth, Justice, and the American Way as…. SUPERMAN!” Well, when your character’s blurb contains, as Voodoo does, the phrase “…the hybrid clone of the human Priscilla Kitaen is a human-alien shapeshifter…” you may want to stop and consider if you’re on the right track.
Another New 52 series that is apparently heavily tied into the Wildstorm mythos, but to no interesting effect. There’s also echoes of SUPERBOY #0 here, with the protagonist trapped in a tank by monstrous beings intent on using our hero for their own evil ends. But Superboy showed us some personality, some sense of where they were taking him as a character, which is what made that book interesting. The girl who escapes from the tank here is a complete cipher, and then it’s revealed the book isn’t even about her, it’s about her CLONE, who is naturally assigned the cover identity of a stripper by her alien masters.
Sami Basri does a nice job on the art, but it can’t save what is ultimately a boring and cliché story.
BATMAN: THE DARK KNIGHT #0Writer: Gregg Hurwitz
Art: Mico Suayan & Juan Jose Ryp (pencils), Vincente Cifuentes & Sonia Oback (ink)
Reviewer: Ambush Bug
I’ve been skipping this book because I felt it to be pretty unnecessary. It seems David Finch wanted to do his own book and dammit if DC didn’t need to hit that magic 52 number, so they said what the hell. Problem is, keeping up with a monthly schedule is often difficult for an artist as detailed as Finch and though I don’t know for sure, it appears that he at least is taking a break this month (if not off the book completely), which allows MOON KNIGHT writer Gregg Hurwitz to slide in.
The story isn’t groundbreaking. A young and angry Bruce Wayne sets out to track down his parent’s killer convinced they are at the heart of a conspiracy reaching the highest levels of government and the lowest levels of crime. Hurwitz does a good job with a little space in showing us a determined but green Wayne who leapt to conclusions because of his emotional involvement. This makes for an interesting slice of life story in the day in the life of Bruce Wayne before donning the cowl.
What makes this issue stand out is the art provided by Mico Suayan & Juan Jose Ryp. Both artists offer up a textured and dense style of artistry, mastering shape and form and presenting them in interesting ways. Though I find Finch’s artwork to be somewhat Jim Lee-esque, BATMAN: THE DARK KNIGHT has established itself as a series featuring top talent artists doing Batman stories that may not be the most dense, but look good. This issue continues the tradition with a stronger tale than what I have sampled from this series. Though I still think this book is a prime example of a need to trim the fat from the Batman books, this was a decent one due to a sound story and some exemplary artwork.
TEEN TITANS #0Writer: Scott Lobdell
Artist: Tyler Kirkham
Reviewer: Matt Adler
The cover lists Brett Booth as the penciller, but it’s actually Tyler Kirkham. I don’t know if this was a last minute change or not, but Kirkham does an excellent job on this issue, with dynamic layouts, detailed illustrations, and a great rendition of Batman. This was a pleasant surprise, as I had not been as enamored with his art when I checked out an issue of GREEN LANTERN: NEW GUARDIANS. Maybe the more down-to-earth stuff is a better fit for him.
Anyway, as you can probably guess by the inclusion of Batman, this is more of a Red Robin story than a Teen Titans story. Which is OK, because Tim Drake’s role in the Robin pantheon has really needed some straightening out since the New 52 began. To sum up, he was Batman’s partner, briefly, but he was not technically a Robin since he chose to be known as Red Robin.
If you find technicalities like that irritating, well, I sympathize. For me, it doesn’t really solve the problem that has Batman going through four young boys in the span of five years. It’s just plain weird, especially given how much is made in this issue of Batman’s reluctance to put these kids in harm’s way. Personally, I think they should have just bitten the bullet and eliminated both Jason Todd and Tim Drake from continuity. That way you’ve got one Robin who’s graduated in Dick Grayson, and then the current Robin in Damian. I know this would piss off a lot of people, particularly Tim Drake fans, but if you’re going to reboot your continuity to make it simpler, you’ve got to break a few eggs.
Given what he’s got to work with here, Lobdell makes it work as best as possible. He captures Tim’s detective skills excellently, showing him just on the verge of discovering Batman’s secret identity, and causing Batman all sorts of hassles, necessitating Batman to step in and try to slow him down. How he actually winds up becoming Batman’s partner may be controversial for some; Tim’s efforts to get Batman’s attention have him running afoul of the Penguin, which leads to his parents being placed in witness protection and Batman adopting him.
Is it a stretch? I guess, yeah, but as I said, I think the whole “4 Robins in 5 years” scenario is a stretch, so some contortions to make it fit are understandable. Continuity issues aside, this was a fast paced and enjoyable read, which is more than you can say for a lot of comics these days.
THE FURY OF FIRESTORM #0Writer: Joe Harris
Art: Yildray Cinar (pencils), Marlo Alquiza (inks)
Reviewer: Ambush Bug
It’s déjà vu all over again. As I flipped through this book, I couldn’t help but feel as if I had read this story before. Turns out, upon excavating the first issue of FURY OF FIRESTORM released one year ago, that feeling was solidified when I realized this is pretty much the exact same story Gail Simone told with issue #1.
Basically, the issue establishes that stuff has happened in the last year of this title I don’t normally follow, but none of it happens here. A threat shows up just as Jason Rusch and his opposite number Ronnie Raymond trade insults to one another for being the typical high school stereotype: Rusch being the science nerd, Raymond being the athlete. Both don’t get along, though their relationship is somewhat closer. Still, a lot of time establishing their differences is made and then a big bad shows up, forcing the two to discard their differences in order to work together to face down the menace.
Which is exactly what happened in issue one of FURY OF FIRESTORM last year!
Somewhere along the way, I think an editor should have noticed that this book has the same story structure as the first issue and said something. But alas, that didn’t happen. So if you liked the first issue of FURY OF FIRESTORM last year and want more of the same, get issue #0 and see how little things change in twelve months.
TALON #0Writers: Scott Snyder and James Tynion IV
Artist: Guillem March
Reviewer: Matt Adler
I’m the rare person who hasn’t been following Scott Snyder’s acclaimed Court of Owls saga, which stretches back to before the New 52. I’ve dipped in here and there, but for some reason I just wasn’t drawn in. So it seemed like an interesting to challenge to see if Talon, a new book spun off from that storyline, could succeed in capturing my attention where the main storyline didn’t.
I think one of the problems I had with the Court of Owls issues I’d read was that I felt I was on mystery overload. I never got a real sense of who these people were and what their motivation was. TALON #0 solves that by taking us behind the scenes into the Court of Owls’ recruitment process from the point of view of Calvin Rose, a Talon who has gone renegade and tried to escape his former life. Calvin is an escape artist by trade (maybe someone should introduce him to Mister Miracle?) who as a child escaped an abusive home to join Haley’s Circus, the same outfit that Dick Grayson was once a part of, where he is discovered by the Court of Owls and drawn into their fold. The bio page at the back of this issue suggests that Haley’s Circus is the main recruiting ground for the Court of Owls; if that’s so, I find that curious—a circus may be a good place to find escape artists, which seems to be the talent the Court most wants Calvin for, but it’s a strange place to look for assassins, who make up the bulk of the Owls’ Talon army.
In any event, Calvin does join, but soon has compunctions about the dirty deeds the Owls wish him to perform. While we’ve certainly seen the tale of a protagonist who turns against his evil masters and joins the side of the angels before, the connections to a conspiracy involving the larger Batman mythos, and the escape artist angle, give this take an added flavoring, and Calvin Rose is an interesting and sympathetic character. After a couple of years with the Court of Owls being portrayed as an untouchable, mysterious organization masterminding the chaos in Batman’s world with impunity, it’s interesting now to see a series where there is an element they clearly DON’T have under control. That, more than anything, is what has grabbed my attention.
ALL STAR WESTERN #0Writer: Jimmy Palmiotti & Justin Gray
Reviewer: Johnny Destructo
Hellfire and tarnation, what is it that keeps me from reading this book? I've heard whispers and exclamations that this book is rad, from those I respect, and yet I can't seem to get off my duff and read this book more often. Is it that I don't have the money? Hell no, I work in a comic shop and can read them for free! Is it that I just hate Westerns? 10 years ago, I would have said yes. But my journey from Asian cinema into Akira Kurosawa into Spaghetti Westerns has left me a fan of the broken leather and sand-modded, haggard faces of the old west heroes. Just not enough hours in the day, is what it boils down to. Well, it looks like I'm going to just have to create more, because this books seems well worth it.
Now I'll admit that while I've enjoyed the occasional Hexposition (thangyewvurrymuch), I was slightly bored by the first couple issues of the New 52 ASW. I wasn't feeling Hex's new Chatty-Cathy partner, or his time in Gotham city. I suppose I felt that, like the almighty Pee Wee Herman, Hex was "a loner, Dottie...a rebel". But that was just me being a sullen amber-stuck grouch, fearing the changes brought by the updated landscape of the New Five-Two.
That doesn't apply here though. I can't say that my previously stated views on the subject were worn down and given new light through this issue, because none of that is IN this issue. This does what the Zero issues SHOULD be doing, going back and telling the origin of the book and its characters.
No Chatty-Katherine or Gotham City here (ok except for the last vignette). Herein, we have a tale worthy of any western film. In fact...something like this SHOULD have been given to us in place of the terrible Jonah Hex movie that we got in 2010. (Holy hell on a horse saddle, that was only two years ago? That wretched thing felt like forever ago. Anyhoo.) This story is not THAT. We are witness to Woodson Hex, being totally bad-ass and protecting his wife as she gives birth to their scarless baby boy, Jonah. (Ok...so he wasn't born like that. Got it). But the bad-ass Woodson deteriorates from the drink over the years into a wife-throttling coward and things do not go well for the family, as you would expect.
We are then taken on a journey as Jonah endures hardship after hardship after hardship. Abused. Betrayed. Abandoned, time and time again. Even sustaining some terrible scarring, but even THAT is not enough. We then are slogged through even more Hexcessive tribulations until he is outcast from his adoptive family and into his face is finally burned The Mark Of The Demon. Man, insult to injury for this fella. It just ain't right.
But as painful as it was to experience along with ole Hex, it was a damnably pleasurable ride.
Saddle-sores and all, this book is gravel, grit, n'guts and it's holding me at gun-point to read some more.
RED LANTERNS #0Writer: Pete Milligan
Art: Ardian Syaf
Reviewer: Matt Adler
This book takes a lot of flak, and reading it now, I can see why. It’s certainly not that Peter Milligan is a bad writer, and Ardian Syaf does a capable job on the art. No, the problem is in the concept itself. The Red Lanterns are fine as villains for Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps; some of the most interesting villains are the obsessive, single-minded types that define the raging Red Lanterns. But why on Earth anyone thought that concept was enough to support its own series is beyond me.
To make matters worse, this is an origin issue for Atrocitus, and we already know what we need to know about the character. His whole planet got killed because of some poor choices by the Guardians, and now he wants revennnnnnge! Nevertheless, we are treated to an extended rendition of his origin, complete with scenes of his ridiculously human-like family getting slaughtered, and him hooking up with the demonic Five Inversions.
Sometimes, oftentimes, less is more. The Five Inversions were interesting when Alan Moore first tossed the idea out because he didn’t tell us everything about them. He didn’t even show us all five. He just suggested certain things, and left it up to our imaginations to fill in the blanks, which made the idea all the creepier. But now that DC has decided to strip mine every last detail of that back-up story written 30 years ago, all the mystery is gone. They still look cool, but they’re demystified, and we’re even treated to the ridiculous spectacle of Atrocitus MATING with one of them.
I guess this is the nature of company-owned comics; anything worth doing is worth beating to death. Anyway, all it amounts to is a tedious and pointless exercise in continuity mining, and in the end, it forgets to give us a reason to follow a book about a bunch of angry aliens who go around killing everyone.
Proofs, co-edits & common sense provided by Sleazy G
Find out what are BLACK MASK STUDIOS and OCCUPY COMICS here and on Facebook here!
Want more in all things Geek?
Check out PoptardsGo and on Facebook here!
Get your copy of highly-anticipated anthology TOME by 44FLOOD today on their Kickstarter!
Check out AICN COMICS on Facebook and Comixpedia.org!
Readers Talkbackcomments powered by Disqus
+ Expand All
Sept. 26, 2012, 9:52 a.m. CST
I'm tooo coooool AintICool.com
Sept. 26, 2012, 9:59 a.m. CST
I use to love comic books when there were consequences, when story lines were taken seriously, when if someone got married, the editors didn't say "just kidding" and have some representation of the Devil hit the reset button to make the hero a perpetually pathetic 22 year old living in his old aunt's house. Now we have DC pulling this shit. With the T-Shirt Superman, no wait - the Hoodie Emo Superman, No wait - the metalic bodysuit Superman, No wait - the whatever jerk you around, stick your finger up the fans' assess and take your $4 bucks afterward Superman. Well I'm not buying that shit. Thank you and don't forget to feed the cat.
Sept. 26, 2012, 10:28 a.m. CST
It's the only New 52 series I give a damn about, and that's just to see how this Constantine differs from the 50 year old one in Hellblazer.
Sept. 26, 2012, 11:23 a.m. CST
in 5 years the totally authentic exclusively definitive prime of all prime dc reboots will start at #00.
Sept. 26, 2012, 11:55 a.m. CST
And even Jonah Hex (Team-Up featuring BATMAN) is a shadow of it's former self.
Sept. 26, 2012, 12:14 p.m. CST
....why does everyone insist on this pretense that at some point in the past comic books were high art? <p> is it just nostalgia or is there something fundamentally wrong where fan boys just can't seem to bring themselves to admit that since the very beginning comic books have been nothing but soap operas with spandex? <p> maybe it's not fair just to pin this on nostalgic comic book fans, because it seems to be a problem with *GEEK CULTURE* in general. it's the same mind set that seems to think the original Total Recall was a work of quality and the re-boot was awful. <p> take a deep breath everyone, and come to the realization that it's ALL just pop culture nonsense. by it's very definition pop culture is supposed to be disposable. i just wonder at what point did everyone forget that?
Sept. 26, 2012, 12:32 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
It's ok to like some junk food. I do all the time. Moderation is the key. Not to say that only comics are junk food. Actual books are too. Chabon and Toni Morrison can try and lie and tell you they are deep but they are not. Nothing really is except maybe your religious views (debatable depending on the person) and your relationships with others (debatable depending on the person again). In the end, I don't care what comics do. I'll probably find something I like cause I like the format. It's not gonna ruin my day. Too much other stuff going on.
Sept. 26, 2012, 12:33 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
Seriously, both are really fun. Lots of bright colors and silliness. Totally a good way to get a cheer up.
Sept. 26, 2012, 12:34 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
Outside of Soldier of Orange he's practically a Troma film maker.
Sept. 26, 2012, 1:04 p.m. CST
have you read issue 0? it was good!
Sept. 26, 2012, 1:11 p.m. CST
.....they started the whole, *only old retro stuff is cool (and even then only in an ironic way)* and the * i liked them before they sold out* mentality. <p> i mean, even something like WATCHMEN, which is arguably the gold standard for comic book storytelling , when you look at it objectively, is nothing more than a rehashed telling of an old episode of the OUTER LIMITS thrown into a blender with the old Charlton Comics characters and served in a cracked and dirty glass. <p> don't get me wrong, i love Watchemen as much as the next fan boy, but i sure a hell ain't trying to pretend it's any more or less than what it is. and i sure as hell ain't gonna pretend that crappy comic started and ended with the NEW52. <P> personally, i'm not into those types of shortcuts to actual thinking.
Sept. 26, 2012, 1:37 p.m. CST
....the invention of Damian Wayne has made Jason Todd and Tim Drake obsolete and it's really a shame DC let possible fan reaction dictate the inclusion of those chracters into the re-boot.
Sept. 26, 2012, 2:37 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
Just like how crap like The Killing Joke is in continuity still because quite simply Johns needs somewhere to get ideas from. Same with all the Steve Englehart Green Lantern stuff.
Sept. 26, 2012, 2:37 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
That book is almost always good.
Sept. 26, 2012, 3:10 p.m. CST
Sept. 26, 2012, 3:11 p.m. CST
on the other hand, I read issue one of Prophet and couldn't bring myself to read the second..I guess I'll have to give it another shot at some point
Sept. 26, 2012, 3:48 p.m. CST
by Homer Sexual
Nothing on gods green earth can make me believe Barry Allen is interesting. Just about the definition of a white bread character. Sad to read that VooDoo ends blandly because it really was initially one of the best and most unusual of the new 52 Talon has a very ridiculous costume so no thanks
Sept. 26, 2012, 4:07 p.m. CST
Poptard_JD, Geoff Johns simply does stories he read as a kid that he found in a bargain bin with more of 90s vibe...
by Greg Nielsen
It's why his books can be both nostalgic and stupid Millar level violent at the same time. His Green Lantern run is based on a throw away annual by Alan Moore and the Manhunters and Guardians of the Universe as total d-bags he got from Englehart. I mean why even bring back New Guardians which was Englehart's completely whacked out pet project that he even abandoned after 1 or 2 issues (can't remember). Aquaman...Peter David's run. I don't need to say more. He's in control of the DC Universe right now and they had the chance to go in and basically cut themselves free and do something new. Johns doesn't know how to do that. He even decided half fistedly jam in Wildstorm cause DC wasn't 90s enough for him yet. It's what he is. Seriously, for the life of me I don't get the appeal of Johns. I can understand why people wouldn't like Prophet. Makes total sense to me. I just can't honestly see what good there is in Johns. Every time I read one of his books I cringe at the dialogue while waiting for a hand to get cut off. Oh and he's responsible for the Carol Ferris stripper attire that is now a new goofy jump suit. Bravo Johns.
Sept. 26, 2012, 4:08 p.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
Seriously where are my Before Watchmen issue 0 issues. I'd buy it in a heartbeat btw.
Sept. 26, 2012, 6:26 p.m. CST
They look God freaking awful. Like so awful even those z-level x-men related teams would reject them for membership. WTF? Are they from the Wildstorm universe or something? <p> I shall call them generic bio-armor girl and big purple brick hand boy. I bet their actual codenames are probably worse than that.
Sept. 26, 2012, 7:34 p.m. CST
...they sure as hell weren't in this issue, and I'm not reading that book regularly.
Sept. 26, 2012, 10:20 p.m. CST
by Jawsh Murdock
I really don't understand the mentality behind people saying that Tim Drake wasn't really a Robin in the nu52 just because he chose to slightly alter the Robin name out of respect to the Robin who had come before him. Tim still wore the cape and had the "R" on his chest while sidekicking for Batman. Therefore, he was a "Robin." There are other changes that fairly substantial, but this isn't one of them. The only thing it does is take away Tim's "breaking out" moment where he switches from being Robin to becoming Red Robin ala Dick becoming Nightwing.
Sept. 26, 2012, 11:50 p.m. CST
It's DC. Lobdell and Didio have stated that because he was "Red Robin" he doesn't technically count as a Robin, so in their view Batman has only had 3 Robins.
Sept. 27, 2012, 8 a.m. CST
I think it was the BATMAN 0 back-up the one where Tim Drake, you know Red Robin was being chastised for being the school douche.... We then slide over to Jason Todd, and Dick Grayson and all three see the Bat Signal in the sky.. 3 + 1 =4
Sept. 27, 2012, 8:44 a.m. CST
by R Howell
The Adler reviews are HANDS DOWN the LAZIEST and joyless reviews of any of the Assholes. I HATE when a reviewer makes broad, sweeping declarations about a subject they admit they aren't interested in and barely know anything about. While I can see where the #0 issues would be a good place for someone who is either not familiar or not a huge fan of the comics to jump into the story (at least for reviewing purposes) I am not sure if Adler's effort is up to the task.
Sept. 27, 2012, 8:46 a.m. CST
But, they're even retconning their own New 52 stories... http://www.bleedingcool.com/2012/09/16/retconning-robin-out-of-teen-titans-1/
Sept. 27, 2012, 9:10 a.m. CST
Sorry you don't like my reviews. I didn't "hate" any of the books; I find it odd that you would say that, given that I only gave negative reviews to 3 out of the 7 books I reviewed this week (Aquaman I was on the fence with). The rest I very much enjoyed. As for the rest of your comment... what broad, sweeping generalizations did I make? I also didn't say that I "never read" the books... I am regularly following Batman Inc, and I have dipped in here and there with Aquaman, the Court of Owls stuff, Teen Titans, and JLD. The only books I haven't read before were Red Lanterns and Voodoo, and the former I am at least familiar with based on Geoff Johns' work. As to why I reviewed them... contrary to your assertion, I'm very interested in what DC is doing with the New 52, and for most of the books I reviewed here, I was very interested to see what they would do with the 0 issues (the two I wasn't too keen on, nobody else wanted to review!). I don't know what is supposedly "lazy" about these reviews, and if you're looking for "joy" as a requirement of reviews, you don't really want reviews, you want someone who already loves the books and is going cheerlead. If a comic causes me joy, I will say so, but the notion that a review is flawed because it lacks joy misses the point of reviewing. My sense is that I gave a bad review to a book you're enjoying. That shouldn't bother you, because my opinion doesn't override yours; if you like something, keep on enjoying it and don't worry about what I say.
Sept. 27, 2012, 9:20 a.m. CST
by Greg Nielsen
Besides, I'd rather read a funny review of something that irked someone than a boring review of nothing but praise.
Sept. 27, 2012, 9:27 a.m. CST
by Homer Sexual
Honestly, if DC had started the New 52 with these zero issues, I would be buying very few. The best one was Amethyst, to me. Demon Knights was the only ongoing title that I thought benefitted from the 0 issue. Some of them were clearly so bad (Jonah Hex just retold stuff anyone who isn't new, knows, and Suicide Squad looked terrible) that I passed this month on half a dozen titles I would normally buy.
Sept. 27, 2012, 9:28 a.m. CST
That counts, right?
Sept. 27, 2012, 9:56 a.m. CST
Yeah, that first one is blortch. Like there's a difference to people between Robin the Boy Wonder and Red Robin The Boy Wonder? what? He was a Robin. The one further down the page makes sense though, I remember reading that and going, oh OK, so there WAS a TT before this team..interesting. but then...NOPE.
Sept. 27, 2012, 10:54 a.m. CST
Jor-El is a wunderkind scientist, but has a rebellious streak that feels truly edgy. Like Cartman he “does what he wants” all with a wink, nod and middle finger aimed at the authoriti of Krypton
Sept. 27, 2012, 10:57 a.m. CST
Go figure. Maybe next time.
Sept. 27, 2012, 11:23 a.m. CST
Particularly with the 'if he doesn't read the books' comment. Half the time, half these guys never even bother reading the books they're supposed to review for the broadcast. As far as the written reviews go, when did 'you have to be a preexisting fan to critique' become a rule? Isn't one of the points of determining the quality of writing and artwork gauging whether or not it's well done enough to captivate a new reader? Optimus left me shaking my head several times this week. Usually it's in an amused way, but this time was just disappointment. You pointedly made you feelings clear on the concept and book of Team 7 last week, and how it had no point. With the creator guesting, you didn't follow up on this at all. Were you just being politely silent? Were you in a bad mood last week? Did he say something to change your mind? Was it a combination of two or more things? I was left with 'guh-wuh?' On I side note, I would have given just about anything to ask about the DC conversation (if any) and decision over Amanda Waller's weight portrayal. That would be comedy in motion. Let the the phrase 'mommy blogger' go. You've used it 7 times now, for something that took place over a year ago. It makes you look sadly bitter, beating a dead horse. You and the industry, as usual, 'won'. Isn't that enough? 'Vagina racist' made me laugh myself to tears. Seriously, thank you for that. I've been having a bad week, and needed a moment like that. It's in my vocabulary now. Bug came off as weirdly-hostile to Womanthology: Space. I found that very interesting.
Sept. 27, 2012, 11:51 a.m. CST
I couldn't get a damn word in edge-wise. I try very hard not to talk over the other chaps, it makes JD's life hell in the editing sweet. So, I wait until people are done talking. But if the conversation has moved on I let my point go for the fluidity of the show. There's no Optimous in team work. I've only used Mommy Blogger 7 times??? Fuck. I'm 23 behind quota for end of year. Need to step-up in Q4.
Sept. 27, 2012, 11:53 a.m. CST
Please finish, I'm intrigued to where you were going.
Sept. 27, 2012, 12:23 p.m. CST
**Half the time, half these guys never even bother reading the books they're supposed to review for the broadcast.** Haha, I'm not sure if that's supposed to be in my defense or not! In all seriousness, I try to read all the books, and if I haven't gotten to one, I generally keep my mouth shut about it. I probably didn't weigh in as much as I should have during the Justin Jordan segment, but I got distracted by someone messaging me with a disturbing comics rumor that thankfully turned out not to be true.
Sept. 27, 2012, 2:26 p.m. CST
Feeling a little under the weather today, so just the abbreviated version... Agreed with your assessment of the Superman issue. Thought that was a good description of Joe-El's personality - and in particular I like that Lobdell gives Joe-El a personality not unlike the original Siegel Superman. Also, don't know what you do for a living, but it's obvious that you have a substantive background in writing. Not that I don't appreciate the effort from all the @$$holes, but the contrast is pretty obvious most days. Although JD's diatribe about Wally West was good for a larf. Just sayin'.
Sept. 27, 2012, 2:27 p.m. CST
Edit button, anyone?
Sept. 27, 2012, 3:50 p.m. CST
And I'm a corporate writing whore... I've been doing B2B marketing for 15 years. I have my own Graphic Novel coming out next year though, with art by BottleImp. Com.X is publishing us. Soooo...if you like my schtuff, maybe you likee the graphic novel.
Sept. 27, 2012, 4:03 p.m. CST
...kittens are ALWAYS relevant. Because, kittens.
Sept. 27, 2012, 10:36 p.m. CST
Congrats, man - be sure to let us know when your comic comes out; I'm especially jazzed that it's digital, since that's my format of choice; in any case, I'll be sure to get a copy, just 'cuz.
- Sony has hired a writer for BAD BOYS 3, plus updates on the MEN IN BLACK and GHOSTBUSTERS franchises!! -- 202 total posts 122 posts
- WORLD WAR Z 2 is a go and Paramount has found a director to helm the sequel. -- 120 total posts 49 posts
- Ohmygod Ohmygod, you guys! The Godzilla trailer! -- 602 total posts 45 posts
- Trailer for LEGENDS OF OZ: DOROTHY'S RETURN! -- 116 total posts 42 posts
- ‘That Seat Is Taken!!’ The Return Of AGENTS OF SHIELD!! ANARCHY, MOONSHINERS & INCOME Finales!! Galactic Pioneers On FUTURESCAPE!! New TROPHY, AWKWARD, STORAGE, NCIS, LOSER, VOICE, FIRE, TOSH!! Tom Hanks On KIMMEL!! Michelle Dockery On FALLON!! Lizzy Caplan On CHELSEA!! Herc’s Tuesday TV Talkback!! -- 58 total posts 17 posts
- Jason Momoa to potentially play Doomsday in the upcoming BATMAN/SUPERMAN film!?!? -- 549 total posts 15 posts
- Nordling Recaps BNAT 15! -- 202 total posts 13 posts
- The Trailer For The Wachowskis' JUPITER ASCENDING! -- 323 total posts 13 posts
- Ben Whishaw to Play Freddie Mercury! Dexter Fletcher on Board to Direct! -- 99 total posts 11 posts
- A sequel to JACK REACHER is on the way! -- 203 total posts 10 posts