Ain't It Cool News (
Movie News

Quint finds Michael Stephenson's The American Scream to be a warm, emotional and touching documentary about scaring the shit out of people!

Ahoy, squirts! Quint here with my thoughts on one of my favorite films I’ve discovered at this year’s Fantastic Fest: Michael Stephenson’s The American Scream.

On the surface the documentary is just about people who like putting on little spookshow tours every Halloween to entertain their communities, but just like with his previous effort BEST WORST MOVIE, Stephenson delves deeper into the individuals making these elaborate trick or treat destinations, peeling back the layers until we have an honest, raw look at what makes them tick as human beings.

The guys, who call themselves Haunters, aren’t all that socially awkward (at least most of them) and aren’t all stereotypical horror nerds with 20 pounds of piercings in their face, tat sleeves and heavy metal tees. The three focuses of the doc are all devoted family men, even if the particular build up of their families aren’t exactly the same.

The lead family are the Bariteaus, with daddy Victor, his wife and two daughters all involved in turning their New England house into a haunted house every October. Victor’s the driving force, but he’s got some powerful allies… some more reluctant than others. His wife is supportive, but clearly doesn’t have the same passion as her husband. His youngest daughter also seems to be reluctant to take part.



However his eldest daughter is so very onboard that it would be creepy if she wasn’t so suburbanly innocent. In fact, this girl made me want to have kids just so I could maybe one day have a daughter to share in my geeky obsession with Halloween with.

And yes, I adore Halloween. I always have. Most kids prefer Christmas because of all the presents, but even as a tyke I leaned towards the horror holiday. Don’t get me wrong, I love the atmosphere of the holiday season, love the feeling of warmth that Christmas brings, but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t love Halloween more. In fact, even typing the word “Halloween” makes me smile.

Pumpkin carving, dressing up, watching non-stop horror movies, orange and black colors everywhere, kids trick ‘r treating, the leaves changing colors… I just love it.

So, yes I was admittedly an easy target for this film, but as I mentioned as much as Halloween serves as the background it’s really a film about family unity and passion. It could have just as easily been about Christmas decorating or wood carving or paper mache tee-pee building and been just as emotionally resonant.

”Haunting” is a family bonding experience and all three families featured have made it a yearly ritual. Whether it’s the more normal Bariteaus or the Souzas who take a more “everything and the kitchen sink” approach to haunting or the comical father-son (and, no shit, part time clown) duo of Matthew and Richard Brodeur who spend the movie lovingly bickering at each other in thick Massachusetts accents there’s a theme that envelopes the movie that is unmistakable: love. Love for family, love for creating, love for their community and love of the holiday. For a movie about planning how to scare the shit out of people The American Scream has a big heart that it wears proudly on its sleeve.

And that’s the talent of Michael Stephenson. With both Best Worst Movie and The American Scream he’s been able to cut right to the heart of his participants. He shows them as people in a way that highlights their flaws and makes us love them for it all.

I recently bought a house (my first) and was already planning on establishing my Halloween dominance in the neighborhood, but seeing this movie has really inspired me to up my game. I don’t quite have the time or talent to build my own haunted house add-on like they do in the movie, but I’m definitely doing more than some pumpkins, lights and paper witches hanging from tree-branches, that’s for sure.

I believe this doc is airing a couple of days before Halloween on the Chiller Network and I have no idea if it’s getting any theatrical play before then but that’d be really awesome of them to put it out across the country in the weeks leading up to Halloween. It definitely put me in the mood and I bet it would have a similar effect for crowds all over the place.

I really loved this doc and it’s already in the running for favorite of the fest for me. It also didn’t hurt that one of the Haunters featured built a haunted house in the empty storefront next door to the Alamo and they made up some fake story about vomit being cleaned up outside the main entrance and herded us all through the back exit door, which lead us all straight through the haunted house.

As usual, Tim League and the Alamo folks have outdone themselves as consummate showmen. Today was a blast and I can’t wait to see what tomorrow has in store.



Make sure to follow me on Twitter to get my live reactions as I dive headfirst into Fantastic Fest!

-Eric Vespe
Follow Me On Twitter

Readers Talkback
comments powered by Disqus
    + Expand All
  • Sept. 24, 2012, 8:44 a.m. CST

    Loved Best Wost Movie

    by john

    It's on ChillTV or whatever that channel is that my girlfriend gets, and every time its on, I have to watch at least a little of it. Out of all subcultural docs these past few years (Winnebago Man, Shut Up Little Man, etc) this was not only the best one, but the only good one. I'll watch any doc this guy makes.

  • Sept. 24, 2012, 10:53 a.m. CST

    Now that's a cool poster!

    by BenBraddock

  • Sept. 24, 2012, 11:33 a.m. CST

    That poster.

    by FieldmanNo.1

    If the film is a fraction as good as that beautiful poster then I am in. Actually I am in. Me and the wife love a good feature length doc and it looks like it's about our kind of people.

  • Sept. 24, 2012, 12:37 p.m. CST


    by elmstreetkid

    Stephenson proved himself a terrifically skilled filmmaker with Best Worst Movie. it was funny, it was surprisingly touching and it was impeccably made. i look forward to this!

  • This doc is right up my street. Really looking forward to seeing it and seeing the haunted house creations.

  • Sept. 24, 2012, 4:08 p.m. CST

    Very cool. I started as a Home Haunter and have now been pro for 14 years...

    by Mephisto the Great

    I was such a fan of Disneyland, I wanted to create the same experience of unleashed creativity. We started a little "home haunt" until we had a few hundred people going through it in 1998. We decided to start a yearly show for profit, and eventually I became the director of a non-profit event with over 300 staff members. As odd as this hobby might be, it led me to a nice career. Making people cry and wet themselves, as sick and wrong as it is, also works too. :)

  • Sept. 24, 2012, 4:42 p.m. CST

    Best Worst Movie was good, it used to be streaming on Netfix...

    by Jason Adkins

    I'll have to try to find this.

  • Any other night and people just call the cops. :(

  • Oct. 7, 2012, 12:17 a.m. CST

    People who trick up their houses for Xmas are rad too

    by FeralAngel

    Every year, HGTV broadcasts holiday specials revolving around people who go all out when decking their houses for Xmas and Halloween. It's amazing how much time and how much money these people are willing to spend, and how effective their efforts are. I think it's great. That's how communities are built: people trying to make themselves and their neighbors happier with a little harmless fun. Wish I had a house to trick up for All Hallow's Eve. Sucks sometimes to live in an apartment.