Film4 FrightFest 2012: Karen Oughton falls head over heels in love with AMERICAN MARY!!
The Twisted Twins, Jen and Sylvia Soska, blazed on to the horror scene in 2009 with their debut feature, DEAD HOOKER IN A TRUNK. This year, the “gore~gorgeous” girls offered a trailer for AMERICAN MARY featuring Katharine Isabelle (GINGER SNAPS) as Mary Mason, a sexy medical student who becomes embroiled in the world of underground surgery. Babes, boobs and blood in other words? Don’t believe a second of it. This feature is life-changing. A deadly serious, funny, inventive piece about how we create ourselves. If I was writing my Sight & Sound critics’ poll list now, it would be different.
Isabelle’s Mary Mason is stone-cold broke. We find her alone, talking to her bird in her brown-hued apartment and in lecture halls where she is attempting to concentrate and ignore calls from the student loan company. Mary is desperate to do well, is fiercely intelligent and actually apologises to the lecturer whose class she disrupted. She knows that she is killing her chances with the weight of her worries. We follow the dejected girl to a strip joint for an audition that is depressingly funny and ultimately very sad. About to leave, she consents to carrying out an emergency operation on one of the joint's messed-up clients for quick cash, before coming face-to-face with the world of body modification and people who are not as they appear to be.
If there is any justice, this film will be seen by millions.
The heart of AMERICAN MARY is its honesty. Isabelle is absolutely unrecognisable as Mary, an everywoman who is trying to live with varying interpretations of the almost impossible ideals of the modern (American) dream. She smashes it to pieces and starts again when life forces her to. She is by turns needy, shocked, fierce and utterly at peace as she slices her way through the world. One particular scene shows her sashaying into a room after a difficult encounter and, frankly, if goddesses lived, Mary is what they would look like: pure power. It is quite awe-inspiring. Isabelle doesn’t break character once, somehow managing a rather patient comedy of manners alongside absolute psychosis. You are not watching Isabelle playing Mary – she is showing you herself creating Mary as Mary finds different ways of being.
Other key players in the cast also bring the film alive and prevent it from becoming a character piece. These people understand their material, such as Tristan Risk, a burlesque performer and here the utterly believable Beatress. Beatress has become her own Betty Boop. An amalgamation of old-style glamour, a sharp understanding of sexuality, friendliness, spunk and a playfully snappy streak, she is what fits her and feels good, from her hair to the way she lovingly calls her friend a cunt in high, girlish tones.
In contrast, Paula Lindberg as Ruby RealGirl brings a delicate frankness to her character that is rather heartbreaking and gorgeously romantic. Similar can be said for Twan Holliday as Lance Delgreggo, as a bouncer who brings a smile of safety to Mary’s face with a milkshake. These are realistic representations of people comfortable with their differences in a world where people pretend they know who they are.
For this effort to come together is due to the Twisted Twins. Look closely and you will see how everything about the film is placed consciously. From the complementary green dress that makes Mary’s wide eyes and hair ‘pop’ so perfectly at a party, to the prosthetic make-up that contains Beatress’ smile, the art team render the world perfectly. The Twins, along with Brian Pearson, also have an amazing eye for cinematography, enabling the audience to see the characters from their own perspectives, from each others’ perspectives and self-reflexively from the perspectives of a horror audiences with the expectations offered by the titillating Twins’ branding.
The script is in many places absolutely superb. It is authentic in a way often only seen in the rarest of documentaries. Tonally it is caught somewhere between the banter of friends in a rough and ready workplace and the emotional nakedness of trusting someone with something huge from the start. It's also very much a tool filmically and helps those unfamiliar with the body modification scene by providing them some guidance for the emotions the characters are experiencing. They are dislocated from standard ideas of core identity and are at the same time formed from them – watch out for the accents and speaking styles along the way.
Of course, there are some aspects of the film that people may dislike. The story can get confusing owing to its complexity and because the characters do not always act the way we expect them to. Indeed, it can be argued that there are radically different ways to interpret the film, depending on how you notice and feel about the details. Many will recognise its craftsmanship or applaud its independent backstory while perhaps secretly considering it sick as it tackles very unusual subjects in a respectful (and occasionally slightly naive) way. Others may simply want it to be something that it isn’t or go further than it does: whilst teasing fashionable sub-cultures (there is a light, fun five-minute segment), it doesn’t revel in them. You are unlikely, honestly, to know quite how you feel (and you will feel) at the end.
AMERICAN MARY is the most emotionally accurate, bravest, best-made horror film I have ever seen, particularly given the Twisted Twins' current position within the industry. It is sexy, revolting, empowering and overwhelming all at once without ever feeling exploitative. It is the Twisted Twins’ story and they are asking you come to them on mutual terms. Watch Mary, enjoy her and face your own desires.
Dr Karen Oughton
Follow Doc Karen on Twitter!
Readers Talkbackcomments powered by Disqus
+ Expand All
Aug. 29, 2012, 10:18 a.m. CST
by Read and Shut Up
...and it sounds like it steers clear of the torture-porn bullshit. Could be one to watch, figuratively and literally.
Aug. 29, 2012, 11:09 a.m. CST
Yeah, this is a really great flick. I think the reviewer is overstating the artistic merits a bit (not that it doesn't have them), but this was an incredibly entertaining and engaging romp with some great performances.
Aug. 29, 2012, 12:50 p.m. CST
This, ANTIVIRAL and BEYOND THE BLACK RAINBOW are my biggest hopes for 2012.
Aug. 29, 2012, 3:35 p.m. CST
by Nice Marmot
Or the dreaded porn of the torturous variety . .
Aug. 29, 2012, 5:42 p.m. CST
Gotta call it for what it is. The hyperbole in this review is utterly absurd. Having already had the misfortune of seeing the first film from this annoying fangirl duo, I'm not in any hurry to catch this, particularly after the dull trailer.
Aug. 29, 2012, 6:02 p.m. CST
by Chris Reynolds
There are shocking moments and a disturbing atmosphere to the film, but there are none of the protracted scenes of torture that you would see in a Saw or Hostel film. If you want an idea of the style and level of violence and horror in the film, it's probably closest to fellow Canadian David Cronenberg's work. There is a big shout-out to "Dead Ringers", and American Mary would definitely fit in to the body horror category that Cronenberg worked so much in. I was there at Frightfest and this film got a really good reaction. In conversations this film was always coming up in people's lists of favourites of the festival. And the Soska sisters and Katherine Isabelle came to a bar afterwards with the festival regulars and hung out with us - they're really cool and deserve your support. For the record, my ranking of all the films I saw at Frighfest from most to least favourite: Maniac American Mary Sleep Tight Sinister Cockneys vs Zombies V/H/S Tulpa [REC]³ Génesis The Captured Bird (short) Tower Block Berberian Sound Studio Nightbreed: The Cabal Cut Stitches Lot254 (short) Metal Creepers (short) The Seasoning House Alexis (short) The Halloween Kid (short) Cargols! Un Jour Sang (short) Tokophobia (short) The Possession Paura 3D My Brother's Keeper (short) Hidden in the Woods After Under the Bed Chained
Aug. 29, 2012, 6:21 p.m. CST
by Karen Oughton
Messiahman, I know where you're coming from - I was there myself on seeing the trailer. I, too, saw Dead Hooker and aside from being impressed that the the film had been made at all, it wasn't my personal cup of tea. American Mary is a completely different beastie and the trailer doesn't anywhere near do it justice. Give it a go and if you still hate it, fair dos :-)
Aug. 29, 2012, 6:32 p.m. CST
by Chris Reynolds
Dr Karen Oughton is definitely not a plant because I met her at the bar afterwards and spoke to her, and I noticed no signs either of leaves or of large wads of studio cash overflowing from her pockets. For what it's worth I've seen Dead Hooker in a Trunk and I agree that it's mostly terrible. American Mary represents a massive leap over the DHIAT in terms of quality, acting and storytelling.
Aug. 29, 2012, 6:42 p.m. CST
Fair enough. I’ll eventually getting around to seeing it, since I don’t feel an accurate opinion can be made blindly, but I’m frankly dubious due to my reaction to their earlier work. What I question here is your assertion that it’s the “most emotionally accurate, bravest, best-made horror film” you’ve ever seen. No offense, but this seems like precisely the sort of kneejerk, over-the-top review that can be found for many films all over the web. When people put forth these sorts of exclamations, my first thought tends to be “if that’s the case, it doesn’t sound like they’ve seen that much.” In a genre that has brought us genuinely groundbreaking cinema from Argento, Carpenter, Cronenberg, Friedkin, Hooper, Miike et al, I tend to doubt a low-budget Canadian effort that from all accounts plays as a series of disconnected vignettes with little to no structure trumps them all. Particularly when it seems obviously derivative of several of the filmmakers I just listed.
Aug. 29, 2012, 7:03 p.m. CST
Also fun seeing her at the after-party, eh? :P
Aug. 30, 2012, 2:16 p.m. CST
by Karen Oughton
I don't blame you for a second. I'm still rather gobsmacked, to be honest. The thing is that the emotional honesty comes from the actors (who really do get this stuff), the script and the direction and I doubt it would have been much greater had they had mega wads to play with. I worked as a councillor for a few years and have spent time with these communities and the lines just really ring true. Make of it what you will :-) Thanks for your comments, by the way.
- Is this our first look at The Thing from Josh Trank's FANTASTIC FOUR reboot!?! -- 133 total posts 118 posts
- "The walrus is far more evolved than any man I've ever known...present company included." Trailer for Kevin Smith's TUSK has arrived! -- 63 total posts 54 posts
- Nordling Reviews GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY! -- 50 total posts 50 posts
- SDCC '14: James Gunn to write and direct the GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY sequel!! -- 96 total posts 44 posts
- Capone believes HERCULES does a Rock-solid job demystifying and reinforcing the myth!!! -- 44 total posts 44 posts
- Capone can't decide if Luc Besson's LUCY is a dumb movie about smart people or a smart movie about dumb people. Whatever it is, he still mostly digs it!!! -- 32 total posts 32 posts
- UPDATED! Has Marvel's DOCTOR STRANGE Casting Search Gone To Phoenix? -- 268 total posts 31 posts
- Footage of discarded concept art, interviews with Tim Burton and Kevin Smith, and Nicolas Cage in flight in this trailer for THE DEATH OF SUPERMAN LIVES! -- 124 total posts 28 posts
- Patrick Wilson drops out of ANT-MAN!! -- 112 total posts 24 posts
- Learn Which STAR TREK Icon Joins GAME OF THRONES Next Season!! (Hint: Not Nimoy!!) -- 20 total posts 20 posts