Cool News
Alexandra DuPont Offers Yet Another Fawning, Blurb-ready, Jeffrey-Lyons-esque Hagiography/Review of U-571
WOW!!! What can Father Geek say? This is an excellent, entertaining REVIEW. Outstanding effort Alexandra, keep it up.
Alexandra DuPont Offers Yet Another Fawning, Blurb-ready,
Jeffrey-Lyons-eque Hagiography/Review of U-571 -- Only This Time in the
Form of a Memo to Director Jonathan Mostow, for Novelty's Sake
*****
April 19, 2000
To: Director Jonathan Mostow
From: Alexandra DuPont
Re: Your Sophomore (though Hardly Sophomoric) Effort, "U-571" (and yes,
I know it's actually your third film, but let's not count "Beverly Hills
Bodysnatchers," shall we?)
CC: AICN Staff and Devoted Readers
*****
Mr. Mostow:
Knowing that you're a reader of this site (or that you've at least
grasped the value of working with AICN rather than dismissing it as
"that pack of meddling kids"), I'd like to avail myself of the
opportunity to address you directly re: your WWII sub thriller, "U-571."
Hey. Excellent job, man.
Now, then. I have a few questions:
*****
QUESTION ONE: How is it that you've made two films for Dino DeLaurentis
['Orca,' 1976's 'King Kong'] that resolutely fail to suck?
I'll hazard an answer: You have a pop-thriller sensibility that Dino
knows not to mess with. With "Breakdown," you crafted a film that was
equal parts "Duel" and "Deliverance"; for those readers who haven't seen
"Breakdown," imagine "Frantic," only with Kurt Russell and not boring
and substituting trailer trash for the French.
*****
QUESTION TWO: Why -- given the fact that your movie was guaranteed to be
somewhat suspenseful by virtue of being set on a submarine -- did you
bother to give it a taut, compelling storyline?
You're a cheeky monkey, Mostow. You KNEW going into this project that
submarines are a sort of "suspense guarantee" -- that the sounds of
pressure-induced creaking and depth-charge explosions in magnificent,
ear-piercing THX, plus the claustrophobic sets and the close-ups of
sweaty faces, would probably be enough to sell tickets in today's
thrill-ride film culture. I mean, for pity's sake -- even "Crimson
Tide," which, no offense, had fairly cartoony bookending scenes, got
gripping once it went underwater.
But you've bothered to craft a plot-intensive story that, while not
breaking any new ground thematically or anything, maintains its internal
logic and pretty much never lets up. In retrospect, all the war-film
clichés are in place:
(1) The young XO (an excellent, lean Matthew McConaughey), passed up for
promotion because he's green, thrown into extraordinary circumstances
that test his leadership mettle;
(2) The old mission-gone-horribly-wrong narrative saw;
(3) The anachronistic WWII dialogue, featuring such zingers as "We'll
bushwhack 'em real good," and which the cast, particularly McConaughey,
sells beautifully;
(4) The stock characters: the salty-dog chief (Harvey Keitel), the weary
and wise skipper (Bill Paxton), the scary intelligence mofo (David
Keith), the greenhorn, the guy who chokes under pressure, the Doubting
Thomas, the wild-card prisoner, the wiseacre mess steward....
But you keep tossing these story elements and characters at us so fast
and furious that there's nary a second to say, "Hey, he lifted that from
'Das Boot.'" I'm a "whisperer" at films -- I like to comment in my
companion's ear as the tale progresses, much to that companion's dismay
I'm sure -- but I couldn't tear myself away to do that with "U-571." (Of
course, given that my hammer, anvil and stirrups are now permanently
damaged by your Megadeth-concert-esque sound effects, my companion
probably wouldn't have heard me anyway. I mean, really: I felt like Pete
Townsend afterward.)
I guess my only criticism here would be that those few moments that the
film slowed down to develop character were welcome, and I would have
liked more of them. I'm thinking particularly of a scene in which
Keitel's Chief lectures McConaughey on leadership after the fit hits the
shan: "The skipper always knows what to do, whether he does or not."
(BTW, if "U-571" tanks, which I rather doubt it will, you might consider
making it the centerpiece of a corporate-leadership workshop series.)
*****
QUESTION THREE: So is Jack Noseworthy -- the silliest-named talented
actor working today -- one of your "ensemble" players now or what?
*****
QUESTION FOUR: Have you anticipated the other criticisms that will be
leveled at you by film snobs? If not, do please allow me: I really
really dug "U-571," Mr. Mostow, but following is some flak you may
catch, along with my suggested responses:
CRITICISM: "It was no 'Das Boot.'"
MY SUGGESTED RESPONSE: After hurling something unmentionable at the
questioner, laugh and add, "Well, of COURSE it isn't -- Wolfgang
Petersen made a thoughtful character piece and I've made a WWII thrill
ride. My sincere hope is that this film will inspire young, foolish Joe
Sixpack to go buy the four-hour Director's Cut DVD of 'Das Boot.' Which
of course it won't, so they'll have to settle for my extremely
entertaining Cliff's Notes version."
CRITICISM: "Where the hell did Jon Bon Jovi disappear to during that
attack sequence, only to never be seen for the rest of the movie?"
MY SUGGESTED RESPONSE: "Well, he's a cowboy, on a steel horse he rides,
and he's wanted -- dead or alive."
CRITICISM: "It's too damn noisy."
MY SUGGESTED RESPONSE: "Huh?"
CRITICISM: "Richard Marvin's score is kind of overbearing -- I felt like
I was being told how to feel a lot of the time."
MY SUGGESTED RESPONSE: "Mea culpa. You're absolutely right -- as with
'Saving Private Ryan,' my film would have been even more intense with
almost no score whatsoever. I'm really sorry."
CRITICISM: "This story isn't historically accurate."
MY SUGGESTED RESPONSE: For this one -- which will dog you for the next
year or so as pot-bellied military re-enacters and Anglophile history
buffs harass you around the globe -- I'd urge you to memorize the
well-deserved coda at the end of your film: "God bless the HMS Bulldog
and HMS Aubretia (1941), the HMS Petard (1942), and U.S. Navy Task Force
22.3 (1944). It's fiction, folks."
Warmest possible regards, congratulations on your labor of love, and
don't pull a John McTiernan and make poopy movies after this one,
Alexandra DuPont
dupont@dvdjournal.com
P.S. You may be happy to hear, Mr. Mostow, that the rotund fellow behind
me was so caught up in "U-571" that he kept yelling "Boom!" and "Whoa!"
and "Oh hahahaha!" every time something or someone blew up. I personally
wanted to club this fellow with a Fungo bat, but I suspect it's a
compliment to your efforts.
-
+ Expand All
-
Great review Alexandra, It looks like this film will be as good as Das Boot! GET-PSYCHOTIC! :p
-
Apr 19, 2000 2:59:13 PM CDT
A.DuP. here: I was wondering if I'd need to clear that up: Yes,
by alexandra dupont
But Mostrow made "Breakdown," produced by Dino, which, eerily, given Dino's track record, nevertheless fails to suck. Mostrow did NOT direct the 1976 "King Kong," oh heavens no. Sorry for the confusion; this is what happens when I write at oh-God-thirty. *** And Amazing Larry: Yes, I actually liked the film. But as you've written criticism, you know how unbelievably dull it can be to write a positive review. So I wrote a "memo." But you're absolutely right -- I totally took the long way 'round.
-
I too got to watch U-571 during a screening. As Harry said in his review, its an "action sub movie"; just like Mostow's last movie "Breakdown" he uses plenty of clihes but keeps the movie going so fast, with so many ingenious action sequences, you hardly notice. Like most World War II movies, there are stock characters aplenty, the script had some bad dialogue, the score was unnessesarily bombastic, and an early scene introducing the main American characters is slow, but don't let that stop you from seeing it.My university paper calls the movie "shallow", but the movie isnt about the evils of war or some great moral truth. It's about the director thinking up some impossible challenge the crew must go through (that sub crew goes through hell, I assure you; Mostow is a sadist toward them). Simply put, its "trills, chills, and spills". And, oh yes, watch it in a big theatre with a really good surround sound system. You friggin feel everything, depth charges and all.
-
...Alexandra DuPont - even with your hammer, anvil and stirrups. Are you single?
-
C'mon, anybody watched "Death Wish" lately? Now that's just yummy. DeLaurentiis may be laughed at now (and I once parked my car in his parking space at his old 8670 Wilshire office so that everybody thought De Laurentiis drove a total wreck), but "Death Wish" is the bomb.
-
Now "Mandingo," that's a classic.
-
.... if we're talking DeLaurentiis, you can't forget TAI-PAN: the movie that made Bryan Brown a star.
-
Apr 19, 2000 5:19:03 PM CDT
Near as I could tell, this was supposed to be military fiction -
by alexandra dupont
As I mentioned in my review, there's a coda at the end of the film that mentions the MULTIPLE real missions -- three of them British -- that resulted in the retrieval of Enigma boxes from the Nazis. I don't think the filmmakers were trying to rewrite history, personally; I think they were just trying to make entertainment. "Saving Private Ryan" has sort of made historical accuracy the vogue right now, but I tend to keep in mind that (a) many classic war films are about as fact-based as "U-571," i.e. not very, and (b) Nobody will care in 100 years anyway -- they'll just appreciate it as good (or bad) drama. BTW, this is written with all due respect to your miltary service, Stormbringer. (P.S. The African-American gentleman is the mess steward, and his presence on the sub is well accounted for.)
-
any woman who can invoke the name of the great mctiernan, recognise the contradiction of a cool actor having a bogus name (sorry, mr noseworthy, i'm all for being proud of your heritage, but you really should have changed it before heading for hollywood), show enough restraint not to forcibly silence the talkative fat guy behind her and dig a thoroughly retro but totally effective sub movie has my undying devotion. forgive me for being a shallow male, ms dupont, but you look like that anna paquin picture at the new cameron crowe site, don't you? you do, don't you? go on, tell me you do. please. i'm tommy five-tone and i'm waiting for your call.
-
According to one thing I read from Bon Jovi, he said that there was a sceene filmed where it showed his entire head being blown off during that attack. However, it ended up on the cutting room floor... That's why you never see where his character disappeared to...
-
Is it just me or does everyone think that just because an AICN spy can write a review without misspelling anything that they must be a studio plant? I appreciate a reviewer who doesn't sound like an illiterate, typing-in-all-lowercase, overhyping teenage dipshit. Hire this woman.
-
I've been waiting for another great sub film since Crimson Tide. Sounds like this could be a contender. Since they seem to have a lot of cliches though I hope it's a little tongue-in-cheek. Good job on the review, DuPont. We shall watch your career with great interest.
-
I happened to be listening to that EXACT line from 'Wanted Dead or Alive' as I read it in the review. That's some freaky karma, baby. Yeah, I still listen to that album. Man, I feel old right now.
-
Apr 19, 2000 6:15:30 PM CDT
oh, amazing larry, know you not the simple joy of submission?
by tommy five-tone
hell, after a hard day at work, sometimes all five-tone wants is to crack open a cold beer, smoke a bit fatty and talk some shit with a like-minded companion. if that companion turns out to be the lovely polexia-lookalike ms dupont, so be it. (alexandra dupont, anna paquin - hell, their NAMES even sound alike. except not really.) think i'm being a lowly dog? hell, brother, sometimes there's nothing wrong with ceding a little control. and like kurt cobain once said, if you can't find a partner, use a wooden chair. (i have no idea what i mean by that.)
-
okay, not completely, but the scenes without action are just way to cheesy, and the actors really seemed to no want to be saying these lines, as if they could tell just how stupid they were gonna sound... other than that, it was a decent action movie.
-
Ya know, I'll have to go see this movie now, because I've spent so much time and effort telling anyone who'll listen just how much Matthew McConaughey sucks. Now I'm hearing that he can really act??? I'll believe that when I see it. And if *you* don't believe *me*, dear readers, just rent A Time to Kill.
-
OK, so "King Kong" has a certain '70's value to it. It's goofy, but not awful. But Orca?? A neat idea, perhaps, but man it didn't work. Whereas "Jaws" made the nation terrified of water for decades, "Orca" just made people laugh. This, in spite of the fact that a grown orca could kick the biggest great white's ass all over the Pacific.
-
Check out this post by Mostow himself to AICN re: historical accuracy. http://www.aint-it-cool-news.com/display.cgi?id=5113 and then you can stop yer whining and let the rest of us enjoy a decent film. S'aright?
-
I read an article about this movie qouting Bon Jovi himself saying that he was dissapointed that a scene where it shows his entire head being blown off was left on the cutting room floor. I bet everyone can guess the reason he gave for it being cut: the damn MPAA. It would not pass a PG-13 rating so it was cut. Once again the MPAA screws us!
-
If yer not paying Ms. Dupont, you should be! She reeks of talent!
-
After reading Mongo Moriarty's overlong ridiculous review of Rollerball, it's nice to read a cleverly written, insightful epistle on a film that I'm now ready to see. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
-
Matthew McConaughey is a cancer upon Hollywood, quite possibly deserving of death by guillotine (though having him drawn and quartered has a certain appeal as well). In a quirky defense of him, however, I should note that *everything* about "A Time to Kill" was dreck, so his crappiness didn't stand out so much in that. "Contact" is a another matter. A movie I really, really enjoy, but every time that pretty-boy McConaughey steps into camera, he all but brings the whole thing crashing down. Bah! Oh well, McConaughey did have one legit role - his small part in "Lone Star". Now that was a pretty fascinating movie, period.
-
Ms. DuPont might write like some kind of elitist highbrow, but take her raves on ear-numbing entertainment with a brick of salt.
She's got some skeletons in her closet: she once wrote a similarly enthusiatic review of WILLOW, for god's sake.
Methinks she's trying to use her clout at AICN to snag a date with the director (who, it appears, may not find her "noseworthy." There's no way that guy is getting cast on talent alone). -
A. D. is seriously looking to be the "it" girl of AICN, and I for one am glad. No more Mongo-ate-my-ass-at-henchmen-camp-so-I-took-the-time-machine-to-George-Lucas-house-and-shit-it's-annoying-to-type-a-dash-after-every-word nonsense. You know what I mean? Nice review, nice questions.
-
not the kind of movie you want to eat a pot brownie and watch.....
I was so pummeled into submission..
bummed Harvey did not show his cock! -
Actually, when they first attempted to write the sub-guys as Brits, not only couldn't they find enough actors to pull the accent off, but the sophistication of the dialect ruined the testosterone factor.
It was simply a matter of convenience. (My take on it folks:) -
Mc Conoghy playing the bongos(Nude.) in the sub with Kirk Douglas and Harvey Keitel singing and dancing both nude to the tune of "Salty the Seal" from "20,000 Leagues Under the Sea."
-
He does!
Readers Talkback
User Login
Top Talkbacks
- Whitney Houston 1963 - 2012 -- 419 total posts 209 posts
- WTF HOLLYWOOD: SOLARBABIES -- 131 total posts 129 posts
- Herc’s Seen Tonight’s Return Of THE WALKING DEAD!! Discuss Also DOWNTON ABBEY, FEAR FACTOR, PAN AM, ONCE, SIMPSONS, DYNAMITE, LUCK, SHAMELESS, BAIT CAR, THE GRAMMYS And More!! Sunday Is Sweeps Day 11!! -- 123 total posts 122 posts
- New JUDGE DREDD post production footage pops up -- 124 total posts 58 posts
- There's a STAR TREK video game that is going to lead into JJ's STAR TREK 2 apparently... -- 191 total posts 47 posts
- Avid Comic Reader Hercules Does Battle With Tedium During Kevin Smith’s COMIC BOOK MEN! -- 43 total posts 43 posts
- If the Behind the Scenes Pics of the Day drops her pen, pick it up, but don’t look at her legs or else it will be on your record. -- 60 total posts 42 posts
- I am The Behind the Scenes Pics of the Day! No, I’m the Behind the Scenes Pic of the Day! -- 27 total posts 27 posts
- To Commemorate The 3D Release Of STAR WARS EPISODE I: THE PHANTOM MENACE, George Lucas Wants You To Know...Greedo Shoots First!! -- 506 total posts 26 posts
- HANNA's Saoirse Ronan to boss around seven little people -- 77 total posts 24 posts