… at the very least, right away, 100 times more fun than AMC's 2009 reimagining of "The Prisoner," and also 100 times less pretentious. … a modest production that nevertheless generates a good bit of energy and benefits from sympathetic casting, decent dialogue and keeping things ambiguous. It should resonate with any child, or former child, who has ever been told, "We're only doing this for your own good," or felt himself to be a lonely weirdo caught between the unquestioning herd and the bullying elites. Which is to say, me, you, and just about everybody.The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette says:
… wastes a lot of time with aimless Ian but the program eventually kicks into gear when Ian finds three friends who are also confused and trying to escape from the school, whose location remains a mystery even as the first episode ends. … ends on an intriguing note and the show offers reason for young viewers to come back for more, which is exactly what a pilot episode should do.Variety says:
High-school students often feel like prisoners anyway, so there's something inherently clever about the premise … the show harbors enough mystery to invite further visits, and even with minimal production values ought to possess some appeal beyond just kids to older siblings and parents, provided they can be lured behind the gates. … It's too early to declare victory just yet, of course, but "Tower Prep" appears to have the right lesson plan for the task at hand. And based simply on the needs of a network still getting its feet wet in a new genre, the show passes its first test with flying colors.8 p.m. Tuesday. Cartoon Network