… tells its story incredibly well, but it just may not be a story everyone wants to follow. Some will hear its music and some won't. But if you do, this could be the rare TV show that makes you dance. …Entertainment Weekly says:
… Hoo boy, are you going to have fun watching this. … The artistic achievement of Treme is that it blends bluntness with the nuances of gorgeous music.The New York Times says:
… The effort to get New Orleans “right,” to do justice to the city’s charm, its jazz tradition, and now its post-Katrina martyrdom, is at times so palpable it is off-putting, a self-consciousness that teeters on the edge of righteousness. … Fortunately “Treme” has a sense of humor, and most of all a binding love of jazz. …The Los Angeles Times says:
… many feared that "Treme" would be Simon's "John From Cincinnati," a show drowning in quirkiness and creative freedom. But the otherworldliness of the city is balanced by characters that manage to be both place-specific and universal. … There are moments in the first three episodes when some of these characters seem a bit too formulaic -- Zahn in particular walks a fine line between being that lovable irritant and parodying him -- but their familiarity keeps "Treme" from tipping into all color, no substance. …The Chicago Tribune says:
… Scattered throughout this sometimes frustrating series are scenes that will make you love the city even if you've never been there … The attention to detail in "Treme" is admirable, but at times (especially during the extensive yet enjoyable musical sequences) it's hard not to wonder if the series' creators may have been better off creating a documentary about the city's musical scene. …The Washington Post says:
… an engrossing, storm-torn and lovelorn New Orleans drama … Three episodes in, I'm willing to say "Treme" (the title is two syllables; it rhymes with away) has the potential to be better than "The Wire." … soon, people at parties will start saying that "Treme" is the only television show they ever watch.The San Francisco Chronicle says:
… A Simon story always unfolds slowly, but there's enormous payoff in the density. From the first three episodes of "Treme," it's clear that Simon and Overmyer, who has lived in New Orleans on and off for more than 20 years, have set out to make this an authentic portrayal of the cultural stew and the varied peoples of the city. …The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette says:
… It's a languidly paced series -- too slow in Sunday's 82-minute premiere but less pokey in subsequent episodes … As in "The Wire," executive producers David Simon and Eric Overmyer are not preoccupied with making sure viewers understand everything they see on screen. Their goal is to paint a realistic portrait on a broad canvas -- but they don't provide a study guide. There will be moments of confusion for viewers and anyone who plans to watch will just have to accept that as the price of admission. …The Newark Star Ledger says:
… may lack the obvious narrative engine that the cops vs. drug dealers narrative gave "The Wire," but it's already a smart, engaging, moving and funny series, one that in many ways is more accessible than its predecessor. …The Boston Herald says:
… Unlike “The Wire,” the pacing is lazy. Many of the moments seem authentic, but to paraphrase director Alfred Hitchcock: A good show is life minus the boring parts. … Simon has assembled an impressive cast here. Surely he can find more for them to do onscreen than listen to tunes. Good music is no substitute for story.The Boston Globe says:
… I hardly know where to begin: with the seamless acting, the outrageously good music, the sensuous cinematography? This is the kind of TV that viewers ask for but rarely get, driven by characters who are more than the sum of one or two qualities and who harbor depths that are revealed slowly, subtly, and authentically. …The Hollywood Reporter says:
… It's all done so masterfully that by the third installment, "Treme" has the old-shoe feeling of a series that has been on for years, not weeks. Still, those first three episodes do move slowly, and if there's a sour note to be sounded it's that it takes awhile for the series to find its centerpoint. The well-rounded, well-written, charming characters are united behind a climactic incident that has since passed, and with an absence of shared conflict, they're left as a collection of loose threads, short stories of color and light -- but not so much focus. …Variety says:
… Rich, textured and too leisurely in its gait, "Treme" won't be to everyone's taste, but by episode three, a hardy band will be hopelessly hooked. … If you're not enamored of jazz, "Treme's" extended musical interludes will play like something of a slog, and keeping track of the disparate stories is nettlesome at first. Fortunately, the talent on display -- particularly Goodman, Alexander, and "Wire" alums Pierce (a New Orleans native) and Peters -- is such that watching them read the phone book would be superior to much of what's on TV. …10 p.m. Sunday. HBO.