Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

One Reader Raves About Gus Van Sant's MILK!!

Hey, everyone. ”Moriarty” here.

I'm working on my review of MILK right now, and it's interesting... as Oscar season heats up, and as I'm mainlining movies all week every week, it seems like some of them are sticking with me. MILK is one of those, and I look forward to seeing what happens with it in terms of the national dialogue when it comes out later this week.

For now, check out this enthusiastic review from "Mr. Sideshow":

Gus Van Sant’s “Milk” is one of the most perfectly timed films I’ve ever seen. Its release date and its subject matter are insanely prescient, so much so that it seems pre-ordained. It also happens to be a masterpiece.

The film chronicles the life of Harvey Milk, the first openly gay man elected to public office. His life was previously chronicled in the Oscar-winning documentary “The Times of Harvey Milk” and his is a remarkable story. A deeply closeted Wall Street banker, Harvey moves to San Francisco soon after his 40th birthday and becomes a central figure in the gay rights movement. He recognizes the need for organization and for displaying kindness and decency instead of anger and rancor in pushing the movement forward. Eventually, he rises in rank from community organizer to elected office (sound familiar?) and, as City Supervisor, moves to fight Proposition 6, a California state measure that would remove the rights of homosexuals across the state (again, sound familiar?). I won’t tell you how it ends in case you don’t already know but I will say that the timeliness of the film’s themes is astounding throughout.

I should note that part of my opinion of the film was shaped by the reality of the situation our nation faces at this moment. As I drove to the screening, I was slowed by traffic due to the protests in West Hollywood against the passing of Proposition 8, a ban on gay marriage, a right Californians have held for six months. As I was watching the protest scenes in “Milk” and knowing that the same thing was happening now, less than a mile away, I got chills and felt a little ashamed. Ashamed that I wasn’t out there with them, protesting not for myself, since I have the right to wed whomever I choose, but for my roommate, for my brother, and for my countless friends who just had their rights snatched away, their state rights removed by a church-based movement. This is the same prejudice Harvey Milk was fighting and it is the same fight that is happening today, right now, 30 years later.

They couldn’t have known things would explode in this way, right on the eve of the film’s release. They simply set out to make the best, most honest film they could about the life of an important spokesman for civil rights. Boy, did they succeed. Gus Van Sant has always been a fascinating director. He’s made excellent mainstream films like “Good Will Hunting” but also smaller, more experimental, yet no less powerful films like “Elephant” (worth checking out if you haven’t, it won the Palme D’Or at Cannes ). Granted, he also did the extremely ill-conceived shot-for-shot remake of ‘Psycho’ but, however you may feel about the film, you can’t deny it took balls to attempt. ‘Milk’ is, to me, his best and most assured film. It’s thematically consistent, funny and yes, powerful. The film makes use of intercutting period documentary footage throughout. Sometimes coupling this with a low grade film stock (they use 16mm and possibly even 8mm in places) and handheld camera work affords the film a breathtaking sense of authenticity and the kind of experimental improvisation you often see in the works of early filmmakers (see the shallow focus love scene). It’s exhilarating to watch.

Every single major actor in this film puts out Oscar-caliber work. Emile Hirsch, Diego Luna, and James Franco are all stellar. Josh Brolin, in particular, is devastating in his role of Dan White, a fellow Supervisor who struggles to come to grips with his stance in the ever-evolving moral landscape of his city. There is one scene with a very drunk Dan White confronting Harvey that is a doozy. I won’t ruin it for you but watch for it. You won’t soon forget it.

Then there’s Sean Penn as Harvey Milk. In the coming months, you are going to hear a lot about this performance, all the way up to Oscar night, where he will be favored to win. Mark my words. It is as impressive a transformative performance as Daniel Day-Lewis’s Oscar-winning role from last year. Outside of acting, Sean Penn has a soft-spoken, demure voice and way of presenting himself. He often speaks in a low, near-monotone and never reveals what cards he’s holding. The person in this film is not Sean Penn. It is another soul entirely. It would be easy to turn a portrayal of Harvey into a flamboyant caricature but Sean Penn presents a very honest and believable person who wears his heart on his sleeve and isn’t afraid to stand for what’s right, hitting every note perfectly. You simply have to see it and after you do, check out Penn’s Oscar-winning performance in ‘ Mystic River ’. Talk about range. You won’t believe it’s the same actor.

The bottom line is that people should see ‘Milk’. You’ve probably already decided whether or not this film is for you and that’s fine. I don’t think it’s going to change an evangelical’s stance on homosexuality and, due to the subject matter and sex scenes, extreme homophobes need not apply. The message for them will unfortunately get lost in their juvenile revulsion to the subject.

Then, who is it for, you may ask. I don’t think the film exists to convert people (if it does, of course, all the better). Rather, I think the film is for those out there who already support the cause, who believe in a brighter future and who have faith that people are good at heart and that, in order for our society to move forward, inequality and discrimination can not persist. Harvey was a man whose primary message was hope (again, sound familiar?) and the film shares that vision. This is a film that should inspire people to go out to these protests, make their opinions heard and show that they are not afraid to be who they are. Harvey believed this, saying, “if a bullet should enter my brain, let it destroy every closet door.” That was thirty years ago and here we are, still protesting, still fighting, and still hoping. You have to start somewhere though and hope’s not bad. In the words of Harvey , “You gotta give them hope.”

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Got Milk?
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Nov 24th, 2008
08:41:41 PM
Once the ball gets rolling this talkback is
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Nov 24th, 2008
08:49:53 PM
Sean Penn is a douche
by BeerEngineer
Nov 24th, 2008
08:58:09 PM
BeerEngineer is right. Chris Rock makes
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Nov 24th, 2008
09:13:59 PM
The Twinkie Defense
by ExcaliburFfolkes
Nov 24th, 2008
09:33:26 PM
Milk: It Does A Body Good.
by markjamesmurphy
Nov 24th, 2008
09:48:42 PM
Brokeback was robbed.
by jimmay
Nov 24th, 2008
09:57:18 PM
sounds gay
by watch_the_world_burn
Nov 24th, 2008
09:59:04 PM
Got Plant More Like...
by TroutMaskReplicant
Nov 24th, 2008
10:05:09 PM
troutmask
by stupidmop
Nov 24th, 2008
10:12:40 PM
That's so gay...
by Fa Fa Fooey
Nov 24th, 2008
10:21:12 PM
"Their juvenile revulsion to the subject". Uh no.
by Fa Fa Fooey
Nov 24th, 2008
10:25:19 PM
Yet I'll bet Fa Fa Fooey thinks lesbians kick ass
by jimmay
Nov 24th, 2008
10:36:14 PM
GOTilk
by gotilk
Nov 24th, 2008
10:37:03 PM
hahaha
by rainbowtrout1265
Nov 24th, 2008
10:43:36 PM
You betcha, Jimmaaay...
by Fa Fa Fooey
Nov 24th, 2008
10:50:31 PM
two guys together is gross and disgusting
by rainbowtrout1265
Nov 24th, 2008
10:51:31 PM
Will any critic dare give Milk a negative review?
by rainbowtrout1265
Nov 24th, 2008
10:56:46 PM
Free speech doesn't free anyone from being mocked.
by jimmay
Nov 24th, 2008
11:12:21 PM
Trout: Critics are about as likely to...
by Flummage
Nov 24th, 2008
11:15:03 PM
i hate conservative america
by The_Squid
Nov 24th, 2008
11:15:06 PM
Closet gays hate out in the open gays
by spectrebeeyatch
Nov 24th, 2008
11:35:33 PM
Milk, Mayor Moscone and Jim Jones.
by uberman
Nov 24th, 2008
11:37:56 PM
Jimmaaay...
by Fa Fa Fooey
Nov 24th, 2008
11:48:56 PM
I hate the term 'National Dialogue'
by jimmy_009
Nov 24th, 2008
11:57:58 PM
Yeah!!! Yet another gay movie.
by mrtwig48
Nov 25th, 2008
12:08:16 AM
Penn can do anything.
by AnnoyYou
Nov 25th, 2008
02:55:33 AM
Continued.
by AnnoyYou
Nov 25th, 2008
02:57:27 AM
i heard there are a bunch of "prosthetics" in this movie
by Toe Jam
Nov 25th, 2008
03:24:28 AM
A Gay Man named Milk.
by Stalkeye
Nov 25th, 2008
03:48:17 AM
A gay person
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
06:41:18 AM
Why all the hate?
by flaggdrama
Nov 25th, 2008
06:55:41 AM
Another AICN contentious issue!
by I_am_not_the_droid_you_are_loo king_for
Nov 25th, 2008
07:41:54 AM
One last thing... Gay or Straight...
by I_am_not_the_droid_you_are_loo king_for
Nov 25th, 2008
07:44:25 AM
Yeah but no one asked you
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
07:45:10 AM
Back on topic to the movie
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
07:46:57 AM
Nope, no one did, but just like you...
by I_am_not_the_droid_you_are_loo king_for
Nov 25th, 2008
07:47:10 AM
But it's Shia
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
07:48:15 AM
Well that's one
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
07:49:46 AM
Reviews minus a political agenda? No way...
by rainbowtrout1265
Nov 25th, 2008
07:58:59 AM
Keep reaching for that rainbow!
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
08:01:33 AM
It is perfectly timed
by filmcoyote
Nov 25th, 2008
08:07:43 AM
The Reason I Won't See This Movie
by davida4348
Nov 25th, 2008
08:11:22 AM
This review is hard to read after..
by Aeghast
Nov 25th, 2008
11:15:30 AM
The end of the review is worse!
by Aeghast
Nov 25th, 2008
11:18:29 AM
The best way to convert homophobes...
by Tocksick
Nov 25th, 2008
11:21:37 AM
What happened to the Mr. Beeks Interview with Van Sant Page?
by ExcaliburFfolkes
Nov 25th, 2008
11:23:18 AM
should have called this-- MOTHER'S MILK.
by DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD
Nov 25th, 2008
12:05:46 PM
The review is too "plantastic"...
by BadWaldo s Revenge
Nov 25th, 2008
01:29:41 PM
fa fa food for thought
by weebay
Nov 25th, 2008
01:47:29 PM
Today's word - Overcompensating
by Ninja Nerd
Nov 25th, 2008
02:39:09 PM
Ninja Nerd
by pleasebanme
Nov 25th, 2008
07:10:26 PM
I have clairvoyance
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Nov 25th, 2008
07:57:45 PM
DANNYGLOVERS_DICKBLOOD
by watch_the_world_burn
Nov 25th, 2008
08:43:16 PM
Binks
by The Brains
Nov 25th, 2008
09:10:00 PM
The Brains, yeah, it wasn't much of a stretch
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Nov 25th, 2008
09:47:15 PM
Fa Fa Fooey
by s0nicdeathmonkey
Nov 26th, 2008
12:55:46 AM
Got Milk?
by Orcus
Nov 26th, 2008
02:05:06 PM
Aw crap!
by Orcus
Nov 26th, 2008
02:05:35 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.