Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Ed Zwick's WW2 flick DEFIANCE starring Daniel Craig, Jamie Bell and Liev Schreiber screens!

Ahoy, squirts! Quint here with a couple of reviews from a recent test screening of Edward Zwick's DEFIANCE. The film screened in Colorado and we had not one, but two spies in the audience, both dug it and both end up calling it "a great movie."

I'll let the spies explain themselves! Enjoy and beware of spoilers!

Hey Harry. Last night I saw a test screening for Defiance in Westminster, Colorado. Defiance is the true story of three Jewish brothers who hide a community of Jews in the Belarussian forest during WWII. It stars Daniel Craig, Liev Schreiber, and Jamie Bell as the three brothers. It was directed by Edward Zwick (Glory, Blood Diamond).

There, now that we have the basics out of the way let's get to what was good and bad...

The Good:

-Zwick does a marvelous job with the pacing and style of the movie. The timing is appropriate, giving the viewer enough action, while still making time to portray the truly abysmal conditions that these people lived in. There is one scene in particular, which has members of the forest camp celebrating a wedding in a snow storm cross cut with the rebel fighters ambushing a Nazi convoy.

-Daniel Craig and Liev Schreiber give great performances as men who are thrust into leading all of these people. They are believable as brothers who have a long history and their struggle with what they must do is amazing to watch. The power struggle between the two of them, with Schreiber as the younger brother who must accept his older brother's position of authority, is perfect sibling rivalry, but taken to a level that is so much more. The fear they feel hiding in the forest, the rage they have at the murder of their loved ones, the responsibility of protecting, and feeding, all of these people in the forest, grates on these men, and leads to an inevitable break, with Schreiber running off to fight with the Russian army.

-The story: Seeing how it is based on a true story, who knows how much really happened, but if half of what these poor people had to live through was true, then it truly is an amazing tale. The constant hunting by the Nazis, the survival through the harsh winters, escapes, ambushes, Russians, and tanks. It is thoroughly engrossing, and quite entertaining.

The Bad:

-For some reason, filmmakers feel the need to cram romantic interests into every possible place in films. I was alright with Craig's and Bell's love interests in the film, especially after the epilogue confirmed that they actually met and married the women they fall in love with in the film. But Schreiber's love interest feels forced, and very awkward. Here is a man who has just lost his wife and daughter, and not two scenes later, is groping some woman. It does not forward the plot, it does not forward either character, it is simply fluff. And it's unnecessary.

-The climax: Most of the climactic battle sequence is great. There is actually one point where I wondered, "Can't these people catch a flipping break?", and not in the way that it was unbelievable what was happening. It was just that they were in a horrible situation. But then something very disappointing happens. It turns all Hollywood on us. In a very deus ex machina sort of move, the estranged brother returns at the last possible moment, when all hope is lost, to save his brother, and a happy family reunion ensues. That said, I don't know if this is actually how the events went down, but it seemed a little set up, for how hard the rest of the movie had been for those living in the forest.

The Verdict: This is a great movie. Parts of it reminded me of The Wind that Shakes the Barley. The performances by the lead characters is strong and believable, the direction is powerful and guided, and the story is well told and incredible. An amazing film overall.

Cheers,
~Wimpy

This second one is shorter, but slightly more enthusiastic!

So, Somebody came up to me on the street in Westminster, Colorado and dropped some tickets on me to see a new movie starring Daniel Craig. I thought he completely kicked ass in the last James Bond flick and I'm counting down the days for the next one. Anyway, this movie was called, "Defiance," and I kinda groaned inside when I realized it was about WWII – not that I've got anything against serious movies but I usually think these kind of things are better off on The History Channel.

Well, I was wrong. This movie rocked me with all the right elements for me to claim it as a wonderful piece of work. It's the story of these three Jewish brothers who escape into the woods when the Nazis come into Poland. At first they only want to save their own ass but then they start fighting back and end up saving thousands of others. Three times in the movie I felt choked up and got pretty embarrassed, but then I looked over and saw my girlfriend was crying too. So that's a score for me...

The important thing about this film? It's all TRUE! I definitely believe that this is different from the usual Holocaust films because it shares a gripping story about the other side of the horror that I don't think we really knew much about. Daniel Craig is totally different in this than Casino Royale. He's still major bad ass, though. Jamie Bell is in it, too, and he's even better in this than he was in Jumper. Need I say much about Liev? He's a true force in this. Also, there is some incredibly hot girl whose name I don't know...

At the end the whole audience was cheering and clapping. No shit. I don't know how this one doesn't end up nominated for lots of Oscars. We shall see!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Yuk at shoehorned romance and family dilemmas
by palimpsest
Jun 22nd, 2008
04:40:33 PM
I hope it doesn't go all ROBIN HOOD: PRINCE OF JEWS
by palimpsest
Jun 22nd, 2008
04:42:51 PM
I haven't even heard of this
by kungfuhustler84
Jun 22nd, 2008
04:43:31 PM
release date's mid December
by palimpsest
Jun 22nd, 2008
04:45:51 PM
I'm with Bodet.
by DocPazuzu
Jun 22nd, 2008
05:16:16 PM
wow!
by themovieslave
Jun 22nd, 2008
05:42:18 PM
Trailer for this was lacking
by barnaby jones
Jun 22nd, 2008
05:44:13 PM
Zwick is an amazing direcotr. This movie could be "Glory"ous
by Proman1984
Jun 22nd, 2008
05:54:57 PM
Guees Hollywood doesn't realize there was a war with Japan
by picardsucks
Jun 22nd, 2008
05:57:52 PM
Step 1: Jews vs. Nazis...Step 2: ?
by c4andmore
Jun 22nd, 2008
06:17:27 PM
dude made Last Samurai
by theredtoad
Jun 22nd, 2008
06:17:44 PM
SoylentMean
by Holodigm
Jun 22nd, 2008
06:26:27 PM
Tom Cruise is the Last Samurai?
by Han Cholo
Jun 22nd, 2008
07:01:55 PM
SoylentMean, I said game
by Holodigm
Jun 22nd, 2008
07:03:12 PM
Oh wait......
by Han Cholo
Jun 22nd, 2008
07:04:28 PM
Anyone who says...
by Manatee
Jun 22nd, 2008
07:58:34 PM
Proof that Jews will never let us forget about WW2
by ganymede3010
Jun 22nd, 2008
09:13:53 PM
Craig, Schreiber and Bell, BROTHERS?
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
09:33:12 PM
"only good thing in Sum Of All Fears"
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
09:34:20 PM
"Munich is such a badass movie"
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
09:36:13 PM
I love Snow Falling On Cedars
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
10:15:30 PM
Who DOESN'T like Jerry Goldsmith?
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
10:44:22 PM
Watched The Sand Pebbles recently...
by Nasty In The Pasty
Jun 22nd, 2008
11:17:14 PM
Fucking Plants
by Stollentroll
Jun 23rd, 2008
12:00:41 AM
Ed Zwick is like Salieri in Amadeus
by m_reporter
Jun 23rd, 2008
03:04:13 AM
excuse my ignorance
by chuffsterUK
Jun 23rd, 2008
05:24:25 AM
Zwick wicky
by damnimgood
Jun 23rd, 2008
06:54:40 AM
I want to see this
by CherryValance
Jun 23rd, 2008
08:32:49 AM
God will someone please just give Ed Zwick
by Series7
Jun 23rd, 2008
12:10:59 PM
the second review screams 'plant!'
by Ray Gamma
Jun 23rd, 2008
01:38:22 PM
Funny that Craug plays a Jew AGAIN
by Mattyboy122
Jun 23rd, 2008
03:32:50 PM
Craig, oops
by Mattyboy122
Jun 23rd, 2008
04:11:34 PM
"not that I've got anything against serious movies..
by depalma25
Jun 23rd, 2008
07:00:19 PM
Three Things
by TheGreatHomsar
Jun 23rd, 2008
08:29:17 PM
FREE XIPHOS!
by just pillow talk
Jun 23rd, 2008
09:40:54 PM
ganymede3010
by spire_walk
Jun 24th, 2008
06:06:03 PM
ganymede3010 "Slavery is worse than genocide."
by spire_walk
Jun 24th, 2008
06:11:33 PM
Remember Naliboki
by szopen
Oct 1st, 2008
03:31:20 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.