Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

A Review Of Anthony Minghella’s Final Directorial Effort: The Movie-Length Pilot For HBO’s NO. 1 LADIES DETECTIVE AGENCY!!

I am – Hercules!!


Only days before Anthony Minghella’s untimely death, HBO ordered 13 hours of “The No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency,” about the only female-led private investigation agency solving mysteries in Botswana.

Based on the novel by Alexander McCall Smith, the series’ 2-hour pilot (not part of the 13-episode order) was directed by Minghella (“The English Patient,” “The Talented Mr. Ripley,” “Cold Mountain”) from a screenplay by Minghella and Richard Curtis (“Notting Hill,” “Bridget Jones’ Diary,” “Love Actually”). It stars Idris Elba, who played Stringer Bell on “The Wire,” and singer Jill Scott.

Here’s “Nev” with our first review:

Anthony Minghella’s final piece of direction is a 1 hour and 45 minute long adaptation of the first of Alexander McCall Smith’s series of books about Precious Ramotswe, founder of the titular ‘The No.1 Ladies Detective Agency’. The books are themselves quite slim volumes but packed full of imagination and colour, evoking the very heart and soul of Africa , the characters and music of a nation filled with history, tradition and intelligence. Minghella and co-screenwriter Richard Curtis have successfully translated this from the page to the screen, and have crafted a beautiful, rich and multicoloured texture, showing a modern Botswana - a country still very much in touch with and influenced by its ancient culture, but also of industry and modernity - a view rarely seen in programmes about Africa, which tend to concentrate on the wildlife, or the politics.

In a perfect piece of casting, the beautiful soul singer Jill Scott plays Precious Ramotswe, a ‘traditionally built’ African woman who has suffered through an abusive marriage and the loss of a child, but has emerged from the experience with a new confidence, a calmness and a strength of purpose. After the death of her father, and against the advice of her father’s slightly dodgy lawyer, she sells his legacy of 100 cows and sets herself up on the outskirts of a small town as Botswana ’s No.1. Ladies Detective Agency. After a slow start during which she employs a secretary, Mme Makutsi – some fine comic relief in the form of Anika Noni Rose (Dreamgirls) – the clients soon start to drift in, and during the course of this first 105 minutes she takes on a cheating husband, a scam artist pretending to be someone’s dead father, and on a slightly darker note, a missing child. There is also time to lay the foundations of a possible romance with the local garage proprietor, JLB Matakoni, nicely played by Lucien Msamati.

All concerned with the show seem to be deeply in love with the project and the setting. The actors and supporting actors are uniformly excellent, and although the script veers perilously close to cloying sentiment at times, it somehow never steps over that line - as you would hope from experienced hands like Minghella and Curtis (and as much an attribute to the source novels, I suspect). The whole endeavour is suffused with an infectious enthusiasm and an attention to detail that is a joy to watch. ‘The No.1 Ladies Detective Agency’ is an exquisite, if bittersweet, final verse in the life of its talented director.


Ultra-Cheap Buffy & Angel!!

$19.99: Individual Season Sets!!

$69.99: All Five “Angel Seasons!! ($14/Season!!)

$99.99: All Seven “Buffy” Seasons!! ($14.29/Season!!)





$13.95 HD Spartacus!!
Bargain HD Kubrick!!

HD-DVD
$15.99 A Clockwork Orange
$15.99 Eyes Wide Shut
$15.99 Full Metal Jacket
$15.99 The Shining
$13.95 Spartacus
$15.99 2001: A Space Odyssey

BLU-RAY
$19.95 A Clockwork Orange
$19.95 Eyes Wide Shut
$18.95 Full Metal Jacket
$19.95 The Shining
$18.95 2001: A Space Odyssey

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Read the first book for class...
by Massage...Bored
Mar 25th, 2008
11:46:12 AM
A nice effort
by Aloy
Mar 25th, 2008
12:07:08 PM
The Guardian thought it kinda sucked:
by newc0253
Mar 25th, 2008
12:13:52 PM
It WAS twee, quaint and shallow...
by prbt
Mar 25th, 2008
12:23:43 PM
ZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz... ......
by Ashok0
Mar 25th, 2008
12:32:25 PM
It was okay
by ChorleyFM
Mar 25th, 2008
12:33:41 PM
shame that Mingella went out with 'comfort telly'
by newc0253
Mar 25th, 2008
12:48:57 PM
those books are condescending
by gobofraggleuk
Mar 25th, 2008
12:55:15 PM
and...
by gobofraggleuk
Mar 25th, 2008
12:57:35 PM
First episode: Who stole my yak?
by cutest_of_borg
Mar 25th, 2008
01:10:28 PM
That's nice, HBO.....
by OBSD
Mar 25th, 2008
01:10:31 PM
2nd episode: Call me Bwana
by cutest_of_borg
Mar 25th, 2008
01:11:29 PM
3rd episode: I've Got a Lovely Bunch of Monkeypox
by cutest_of_borg
Mar 25th, 2008
01:12:41 PM
It beat the pants off the Pratchett adaptation...
by palimpsest
Mar 25th, 2008
01:52:57 PM
The title makes it sound like a Chick-Lit adaptation
by Quin the Eskimo
Mar 25th, 2008
01:57:26 PM
More Terry Pratchett
by palimpsest
Mar 25th, 2008
02:01:30 PM
Ladies Detective Agency?
by Napoleon Park
Mar 25th, 2008
02:16:23 PM
HBO pickup Journeyman so we can see some nude
by captboulder
Mar 25th, 2008
02:36:15 PM
And apparently got a time machine, Napoleon
by elab49
Mar 25th, 2008
02:59:30 PM
Napoleon Park...
by palimpsest
Mar 25th, 2008
03:05:54 PM
gobofraggleuk:
by prbt
Mar 25th, 2008
03:06:25 PM
Miss Marple in Africa...
by Sledge Hammer
Mar 25th, 2008
03:42:00 PM
What's wrong with lightweight fare if it's smart and well crafte
by Rev. Slappy
Mar 25th, 2008
04:11:22 PM
Not Miss Marple
by elab49
Mar 25th, 2008
05:43:49 PM
I'd disagree with your 2 categories
by elab49
Mar 25th, 2008
05:47:18 PM
I thought traditionally built african women were stick thin
by Mysterious Yobo
Mar 25th, 2008
05:48:22 PM
I liked it
by kuryakin
Mar 25th, 2008
06:34:54 PM
When's Carnivale coming back?
by Drath
Mar 25th, 2008
06:41:29 PM
Anyone else miss The Wire like a close relative?
by Boxcutter
Mar 25th, 2008
09:35:03 PM
Get over it.
by Prespez
Mar 25th, 2008
10:29:27 PM
Well...that seemed planty.
by buffywrestling
Mar 25th, 2008
11:48:53 PM
AICN TBers Unite
by Stevie Grant
Mar 25th, 2008
11:59:55 PM
Some of us are in the UK and DID watch it Pres
by elab49
Mar 26th, 2008
03:21:10 AM
Fifth Case...Dead Nigerian Prince
by Hagakure
Mar 26th, 2008
07:47:05 AM
just bring back tales from the crypt hbo
by theonecalledshoe
Mar 26th, 2008
08:31:01 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.