Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

An Enthusiastic Review Of U2-3D!

Hey, everyone. ”Moriarty” here.

And I couldn’t agree more. I’ve seen this once already, and I’m seeing it again on Saturday before I write about it. I’ll just say that it is overwhelming, and one of the most remarkable sensory experiences I’ve had in recent memory.

But enough from me. Today’s spy has a lot to say, and he says it pretty darn well:

Hey, guys--

I've never submitted a review to your site before, but since I didn't see anything posted in the last couple of days since I saw U2 3D in person, I decided that my fellow movie geeks needed to know about this movie.

Thanks to some really cool friends with connections, I was able to get in to see the first advance screening of U2 3D, which was held at the Chinese Theatre here in Hollywood. (This was in one of the six newer theaters, not the original Grauman's movie palace.) It felt interesting being probably the only U2 fan in the audience, which was comprised mostly of those who worked on the film, or studio execs, DOPs and post house people who were interested in experiencing what we were promised was a breakthrough in 3D technology.

It was. U2 3D is the most amazing 3D experience I've ever had. Ever.

Yes, I have to be honest... U2 is my favorite band. But even if you hate U2 as much as Henry Rollins does (and even as a die-hard U2 fan, his rant against the band is one of the funniest things I've ever heard), I still think it's worth experiencing this film, because the 3D technology used here is going to be the wave of the future that James Cameron and other directors will implement in their upcoming movies. Seeing U2 3D has only made me more eager to see Avatar.

What makes U2 3D so impressive is that it does what prior 3D productions have been unable to do--to fully convince you that you are within a real physical space with real depth. The problem with prior 3D movies is that you're always aware that your eyes are being "tricked" into a three-dimensional experience--there's just something that's a bit "off" about it. Either there is a feeling that the depth is being created by a series of flat planes, one behind the other, or the perception of 3D is shattered whenever you move your head too much, once again reminding you that you're wearing glasses and looking at a screen.

In U2 3D, there are none of those issues. There just aren't. It feels that immediate and that real. And honestly, I don't understand how the technology works so well. The glasses themselves don't look like they have any special filters or colors. They're just slightly opaque. And when you take them off, the screen only looks slightly blurry. But yet, you put them on, and the experience is all-encompassing. National Geographic had something to do with the making of the film, so perhaps they developed the technology with the other production entities associated with the movie. According to the Q&A session after the film, the 3D technology was still being developed even as the film was being edited in post-production, so that's how new it is. And if it's this good now, imagine what it will become when Cameron gets his hands on this.

Okay, so that's the excited techno-geek side of me talking. But how was the movie... as a movie?

If you've followed U2 for the entirety of their career like I have, it's been obvious that the band has been searching to create the perfect in-concert document which captures who they truly are as a live act. The creation of Rattle and Hum was due to the band being embarrassed by their antics in Under a Blood Red Sky. Rattle and Hum was fairly decent, insofar as a movie is concerned. But it was more of a travelogue and less of a live concert experience. Since then, U2 has released a slew of live concerts on DVD, the best of which I think is Elevation: Live from Boston, thanks to some great directing and use of various and interesting camera angles (which you can watch isolated in their entirety if you want--a nice bonus).

In terms of performance and musical selection, I'm still partial to the Elevation DVD, but their performance here is still balls-to-the-wall, and because U2 3D is so all-encompassing, it's just an entirely different experience, and as a result, far more rewarding. The concert itself was filmed on the recent Vertigo Tour primarily in Latin America, and the energy of the audience is that much more intense. There's a moment at the end of the film where Bono and Larry Mullen, Jr. share a bit of small talk (which we can't hear) but it's clearly in reference to how amazed they are at the audience reaction. In fact, there's a point at the end of "With or Without You" that Bono breaks into a big smile, clearly taken aback by how loud and in unison the audience is.

One thing I should point out. This is not merely a document of a concert. There is a really artistic mixture of camera angles throughout, and the film pushes into some really cutting-edge creativity on "The Fly," as words and letters rain down from the sky--in front of and behind the band members. That sequence alone is worth the price of admission. After the film was over, it was revealed that although the director was a novice, she comes from an artistic background in sculpting, so she already thinks in a three-dimensional way, which the film's DOP admitted was the right approach to the material.

Having seen the Vertigo Tour in person, I remember the emphasis on social change, human rights and the ONE campaign. U2 3D instead focuses on the music and the interplay between band and audience, and I think that was a wise move. Look, I love what Bono has to say sometimes, but even I appreciate the fact that they turned down his Messiah Meter™ to about 1 on a scale of 10 for this film. He has a few words to share with the audience, but it's short, sweet and makes the point without being overly ponderous. The "Coexist" theme overall is pushed a little too hard, though, especially over the ending credits. But that's a minor complaint. The message itself is still valid.

If you're a die-hard U2 fan, you will absolutely go nuts over this film and will want to re-experience it over and over. If you're not a die-hard U2 fan, but like some of their music, you'll still enjoy U2 3D, as the music selection is pretty familiar, even to casual listeners. And if you can't stand U2 but love technology, I still think there's plenty here to appreciate from a filmmaking standpoint. And as I've said repeatedly, the 3D experience is unlike anything I've ever experienced.

If you see fit to use this, sign me as The Refugee.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

First first
by Jersquall
Jan 18th, 2008
03:45:31 AM
Redfist
by Jersquall
Jan 18th, 2008
03:48:52 AM
What?
by Sovikos
Jan 18th, 2008
03:54:19 AM
U2-3D NOT A NEW STAR WARS DROID SPECIAL!
by Sovikos
Jan 18th, 2008
03:54:47 AM
What if you can't stand U2
by seppukudkurosawa
Jan 18th, 2008
03:59:07 AM
Delusions of Grandeur
by Jersquall
Jan 18th, 2008
04:00:24 AM
Rollins
by MaxTheSilent
Jan 18th, 2008
04:21:00 AM
And 3D is horse-s**t.
by MaxTheSilent
Jan 18th, 2008
04:22:32 AM
Is this RealD?
by topaz4206
Jan 18th, 2008
04:23:45 AM
They're embarrassed by Under a Blood Red Sky?
by Riley Martin
Jan 18th, 2008
05:05:44 AM
r2 and c3po finally had a baby!
by ironic_name
Jan 18th, 2008
05:55:34 AM
I'm confused, as usual...
by cornponious
Jan 18th, 2008
06:05:31 AM
Plant!
by theBigE
Jan 18th, 2008
06:09:37 AM
Bono
by HornOrSilk
Jan 18th, 2008
06:28:38 AM
U2 are great...but remember Rattle & Hum?
by HarryBlackPotter
Jan 18th, 2008
06:47:42 AM
My U2 fanatacism has waned
by Abominable Snowcone
Jan 18th, 2008
07:20:56 AM
Too bad U2 aren't a good band.
by messi
Jan 18th, 2008
07:25:47 AM
I hate U2!
by disfigurehead
Jan 18th, 2008
07:32:05 AM
Who
by peytonallen
Jan 18th, 2008
07:53:12 AM
Henry Rollins? Wow. What a talent he is. Wrong Turn 2 anyone?
by HarryBlackPotter
Jan 18th, 2008
08:02:52 AM
I guess I should wait for HENRY ROLLINS 3D instead then...
by SpyGuy
Jan 18th, 2008
08:22:10 AM
3D will never work until they get rid of the glasses
by Orionsangels
Jan 18th, 2008
08:34:33 AM
Yeah, gimmick...
by gotilk
Jan 18th, 2008
08:35:45 AM
i'm with spyguy
by LegoKenobi
Jan 18th, 2008
08:42:05 AM
U2 is great
by Itchy
Jan 18th, 2008
09:01:05 AM
New Year's Day...
by Ghostball
Jan 18th, 2008
09:11:34 AM
Ultimate Critique on u2?....
by The Great Took
Jan 18th, 2008
09:21:22 AM
Catch U2 3D at Sundance Film Festival Saturday January 19
by BadWaldo s Revenge
Jan 18th, 2008
09:22:06 AM
Ultimate Critique on U2...Part 2
by The Great Took
Jan 18th, 2008
09:29:16 AM
Ultimate...Oh for F***s Sake
by The Great Took
Jan 18th, 2008
09:31:20 AM
saying U2 is your favorite band is like
by FleshMachine
Jan 18th, 2008
09:43:20 AM
I Saw Them 7 Times On That Tour
by Birdys Piano Teacher
Jan 18th, 2008
09:50:36 AM
Glovedone, the more you say U2 "sucks," the more idiotic you bec
by SpyGuy
Jan 18th, 2008
10:02:29 AM
how old are some of the TBers here
by Bloo
Jan 18th, 2008
10:02:42 AM
Bono weighs 70 Courics!
by Frodo T. Baggins
Jan 18th, 2008
10:02:57 AM
And predictably, out come the haters . . .
by gruntybear
Jan 18th, 2008
10:08:29 AM
How About the Set-List?
by DKT
Jan 18th, 2008
10:17:59 AM
"And predictably, out come the haters"
by seppukudkurosawa
Jan 18th, 2008
10:37:27 AM
Yes it's RealD
by tack
Jan 18th, 2008
10:59:10 AM
U2 sucks...shoulda been MOTLEY CRUE in 3D
by JeffManSixtyFo
Jan 18th, 2008
11:06:02 AM
Saul Williams does an awesome U2 cover
by s0nicdeathmonkey
Jan 18th, 2008
11:20:00 AM
I'd rather see Friday the 13th part III in 3-D
by Pound Sand
Jan 18th, 2008
11:50:56 AM
Beowolf sucked ass but the 3D was great.
by alucardvsdracula
Jan 18th, 2008
11:59:17 AM
Love U2
by eXcommunicated
Jan 18th, 2008
12:00:30 PM
Henry Rollins is a sad moron.
by alucardvsdracula
Jan 18th, 2008
12:06:07 PM
just tell me one thing...
by quadrupletree
Jan 18th, 2008
12:19:01 PM
I've found...
by slone13
Jan 18th, 2008
12:36:46 PM
I rest my case
by slone13
Jan 18th, 2008
12:52:50 PM
I love Rollins and U2...
by TELF
Jan 18th, 2008
01:40:36 PM
Can't wait...
by iRovr
Jan 18th, 2008
01:59:16 PM
gotilk, the difference you don't have to wear anything...
by Orionsangels
Jan 18th, 2008
02:17:36 PM
So how will this work on DVD?
by Abominable Snowcone
Jan 18th, 2008
02:17:56 PM
Not coming to DVD...
by Lazarus Long
Jan 18th, 2008
02:47:16 PM
Playing in IMAX, too!
by Zardoz
Jan 18th, 2008
03:03:46 PM
Strictly Personal Opinion
by Jaka
Jan 18th, 2008
04:07:48 PM
They did a prequel about R2-D2's cousin?
by Grammaton Cleric Binks
Jan 18th, 2008
04:54:02 PM
Actually, TVs With the Chip Necessary For This 3D are Coming Out
by Birdys Piano Teacher
Jan 18th, 2008
05:01:32 PM
FUCK BONO
by MattmanReturns
Jan 18th, 2008
05:37:41 PM
Amy Winehouse Put It Best When She Said...
by LaserPants
Jan 18th, 2008
07:03:09 PM
Let's All Take Advice from Amy Winehouse
by Birdys Piano Teacher
Jan 18th, 2008
08:10:43 PM
Any Crackwhore Winehouse
by skywalkerfamily
Jan 18th, 2008
08:37:40 PM
Lazarus Long
by Lazarus Long
Jan 18th, 2008
08:56:26 PM
yeah, I can't stand people who try to save lives..
by ironic_name
Jan 18th, 2008
08:57:46 PM
What Have I Done?
by LaserPants
Jan 18th, 2008
09:55:04 PM
I'm Irish and...
by EvilGeek1
Jan 18th, 2008
10:49:05 PM
indeed, fuck you!
by ironic_name
Jan 18th, 2008
10:59:24 PM
U2 was great in the 90's
by skywalkerfamily
Jan 18th, 2008
11:38:33 PM
EvilGeek1 - You're about as Irish as Lucky Charms
by HarryBlackPotter
Jan 19th, 2008
04:33:58 AM
Oh I Get It
by LaserPants
Jan 19th, 2008
06:15:39 AM
Uhhh Rollins sang on My War
by messi
Jan 19th, 2008
08:54:01 AM
Bono is a shitbox and U2 suck balls
by EvilGeek1
Jan 19th, 2008
09:03:02 AM
3D Tech used: 3ality and RealD
by Ted Striker
Jan 19th, 2008
12:02:31 PM
I'm waiting for Backstreet Boys 3D, dammit!!!
by MrMysteryGuest
Jan 19th, 2008
10:03:49 PM
3D... meh
by FlipTheFrog
Jan 20th, 2008
01:10:29 PM
HiDef 3D Release Someday?
by Partyslammer
Jan 20th, 2008
04:21:32 PM
3D done right is great
by tack
Jan 25th, 2008
10:50:10 AM
I just saw this tonight and it rules!
by Dogmatic
Jan 27th, 2008
08:36:43 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.