Logo

Cool News

Hercules Picks The 10 Best Scripted Hourlongs Of 2007!!

Published at:  Jan 02, 2008 9:21:09 PM CST

SPOILER ALERT !!

I am – Hercules!!


Scripted Hourlongs:

10) BROTHERHOOD (Showtime). The best crime drama on television this side of “The Wire.” Season two saw Michael the gangster’s brutality undiminished, even as he was dealing with seizures resulting from the brain damage sustained last season. Tommy played very dirty with the Latino voters. Eileen went back to work. Mary Rose got loaded. Thuggish cousin Colin from Ireland arrived. Decco Giggs the drunk state cop went to work for mob boss Freddie Cork. Out-of-town talent did some whacking. Tall, skinny Janel Moloney cavorted nakedly. A lot.

9) ROME (HBO). I preferred 2007’s second season of “Rome” to the excellent first; the later season’s plot zips along like rocketships, owing to what I’d guess was an abbreviated episode order from HBO. (It makes my temples throb to think that ten times as many people were watching “Desperate Housewives” Sunday nights at 9 p.m.) Indelible characters abounded: Octavian, Pullo, Vorenus, Brutus, Cicero, Atia, Timon, Octavia, Jocasta, Gaia, Niobe, Posca, Caesarion and most especially James Purefoy’s Antony.

8) HEROES (NBC). Its second season doesn’t help its ranking, but neither does it obliterate the stellar string of first-season episodes that aired between January and May, among them “Fallout,” “Godsend,” “The Fix,” “Distractions,” “Run!” “Unexpected,” “Parasite,” “.07,” “Five Years Gone” and especially “Company Man.”

7) MAD MEN (AMC). Don Draper glared menacingly at his hapless kid brother. Betty Draper got busy with a shotgun. Roger Sterling played horsie in his undies. Joan Holloway displayed her behind. Midge Daniels fucked a beatnick. Rachel Menken fell in lust. Pete Daniels sold a story. Peggy Olsen got fat. Whoever’s manning the green light over at the channel formally known as American Movie Classics deserves a big giant raise. The channel’s next new series, due later this month from Vince Gilligan (“The X-Files”), is about a dying chemistry teacher; can’t wait.

6) THE SOPRANOS (HBO). It’s difficult to believe fans wouldn’t love 2007’s final nine episodes, which saw the violent demise of more established “Sopranos” characters than any other. The ending was maybe one of the ten best ever in the history of TV. Had someone another, better idea?

5) TELL ME YOU LOVE ME (HBO). Insightful, alluring, well-considered, ground-breaking and fearless in its depiction of intimacy. HBO’s finest series this side of “The Wire” is the year’s second-best new show and mesmerizes with the most honest scripted look at the American bedroom ever offered for a screen of any size. Brims with suspense and makes you think.

4) PUSHING DAISIES (ABC). A romantic comedy for the ages. The funniest show, perhaps, to be waylaid by the inconvenient if necessary writer’s strike. It boasts both Bryan Fuller’s wit and Kristen Chenoweth’s breasts and Paul Reubens as a ratty man with supersmell. Private detective Emerson Cod is one of the most inspired comic creations in TV history.

3) LOST (ABC). The best season of an amazing show. Yes, there were horrible episodes in 2007, episodes that even Bai Ling’s comely hinder couldn’t redeem. But in the meantime Locke rediscovered his testes, and there was a deceptive Ukranian and giant invisible fence and a pretty fertility doctor and Richard Alpert and Jacob. The season finale even got me to give a shit about Hurley for the first time since season one.

2) VERONICA MARS (The CW). Always a fan, I never loved “Veronica” harder than during its final handful of episodes. A despondent Logan had to babysit Dick’s brand new sister-in-law, then beat on a Russian gangster’s son. Sheriff Lamb suffered misadventure. Vinnie Van Lowe’s ambitions grew. Mac Met Max. Paul Rudd rocked out. The title character tracked down a Comic-Con hooker, got tossed in stir, tussled with teaching assistant Tim Foyle, double-dog-dared paintballers, took her FBI exam, and took on the Hearst version of Skull & Bones. Many objected to the ending, which featured Veronica exiting from a polling booth into the Southern California rain, but it suited the series’ noir sensibility brilliantly. More pain came to fans in October with the release of the season-three DVD, which included a fabulous 20-minute mini-pilot for the series’ didn’t-happen fast-forward fourth season, set immediately after Ms. Mars’ graduation from the FBI academy. Fuck your bottom line; I am very very upset this show went away, Mr. Moonves.

1) BATTLESTAR GALACTICA (SciFi). Only 11 hours of the series aired in 2007, beginning with “Rapture” and ending with “Razor.” The algae planet’s sun went supernova, Tyrol welcomed Baltar back to the fleet and a rogue D’Anna got to meet the final five. “Dirty Hands,” the class-struggle episode written by Jane Espenson, may be the series’ best stand-alone episode since season one. The three-episode arc that concludes season three (it deals with the introduction of wily kleptomaniac Romo Lampkin and the trial of Gaius Baltar) is phenomenal, capped by the reveal of four more Cylons. And vipers rocketing into battle to “All Along the Watchtower.” A song that, candidly, always belonged in outer space. Supercool on every level.


Sitcoms:
10) King of the Hill (Fox)
9) 30 Rock (NBC)
8) Flight of the Conchords (HBO)
7) Weeds (Showtime)
6) Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO)
5) Lucy, The Daughter of the Devil (CN)
4) The Sarah Silverman Program (CC)
3) The Office (NBC)
2) Andy Barker, P.I. (NBC)
1) South Park (CC)



Reality Shows:
10) WifeSwap (ABC)
9) Kid Nation (CBS)
8) The Amazing Race (CBS)
7) A Shot At Love (VH1/MTV)
6) The Real World (MTV)
5) My Life On the D-List (Bravo)
4) Survivor (CBS)
3) The Real World/Road Rules Challenge (MTV)
2) The Bad Girls Club (Oxygen)
1) Big Brother (CBS)



Chat Shows:
10) Iconoclasts (Sundance)
9) Sit Down Comedy With David Steinberg (TVL)
8) The Charlie Rose Show (PBS)
7) The Late Late Show With Craig Ferguson
6) Jimmy Kimmel Live (ABC)
5) The Late Show With David Letterman (CBS)
4) Late Night With Conan O’Brien (NBC)
3) The Colbert Report (CC)
2) The Daily Show With Jon Stewart (CC)
1) The Howard Stern Show (On Demand)





$29.99 (50% Off!!) Lost: Seasons One And Two!!




Sony has organized a 2Fer sale. Buy two or more and you could get:
* MTV’s complete 2003 “Spider-Man” series for $9.50,
* the complete series of the “The Tick” for $11,
* “Soap” season-sets for $11 each,
* “All in the Family” season sets for $11 each
* “Newsradio” season-sets for $14.75 each,
* “Seinfeld” season-sets for $18 each, and
* “Not Just The Best of The Larry Sanders Show” for $18.75.

Find 171 titles in the 2Fer Sale HERE!!



    + Expand All

    Readers Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:10:04 AM CST

    So nice to see King of the Hill get some love.

    by bungion boy

    One of the funniest and most consistent shows on tv. I don't know a lot of people who watch it and I don't know how it gets renewed every year, but I'm so glad it does. So well written. However, Herc, I'm always surprised to see Weeds make any list. For all its excellent actors and creative characters, I think it's one of the most overrated shows on tv. I feel that they've taken a great show that should have been about a family, rather than all the crazy adventures they have, and turned it into something too over the top to be taken seriously. Or even to be taken comedically. I don't buy any of the relationships or storylines anymore on the show. The drug dealing aspect should have been a backdrop and not the centerpiece. I love Parker, and have great affection for Nealon, and several other cast members. I just think that they've pushed it too far. I know a lot of people love it though. There's worse on tv so I can't blame them too much. Nice lists overall though, Herc.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:29:59 AM CST

    Starting to fall in love with Lost

    by spifftacular squirrel girl

    Although I'm watching it a bit backwards by watching all of Season 3 first. I have seen episodes throughout all 3 seasons but this is the first time I'm really going to watch on a regular basis.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:29:59 AM CST

    No Journeyman or Chuck = DIE

    by polyh3dron

    How can you leave those shows off when that piece of shit Heroes show is up there? The last Heroes episode invalidated any merit the previous episodes held to me.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:30:38 AM CST

    Also, no "Life" = FAIL

    by polyh3dron

    That show is f'n AMAZING.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:31:35 AM CST

    And no How I Met Your Mother?

    by spifftacular squirrel girl

    For shame, Herc. A show that isn't only damn funny but has sporadic Buffy/Angel/Firefly actors appear? How'd that miss the list? Especially for you? ;)

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:33:03 AM CST

    FINALLY

    by errockk

    gotta keep that love for lost! best tv show on today!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:41:29 AM CST

    What about Blah Dee Blah Blah?

    by tonagan

    Whine whine whine. Just thought I'd get that out of the way.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:43:36 AM CST

    Dexter?!?

    by jbs0209

    WTF?
    How does Dexter not make the list?
    Are you high!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:44:44 AM CST

    No Love for Dexter?

    by z 008

    thats pretty much all i have to say

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:45:21 AM CST

    no dexter?

    by nidx

    u cannot state best without seeing this show

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:50:55 AM CST

    Finally! Some lovin' for Tell Me You Love Me

    by jivetalker

    No one believes me that it really is a great freakin show! My girlfriend forced me to watch it against my will, and now I'm hooked. It's pretty much the best thing HBO has done since The Wire. TMYLM has gotten such a chilly reception though, which I blame entirely on MTV for raising generations of audience members to approach media with the maturity level and attention spans of fifth graders. I mean, come one. What's not to love about a well-scripted, brilliantly acted show that features beautifully shot, extremely graphic sex scenes?? Where I come from, that's called quality, friends.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:54:57 AM CST

    "Tell Me Your Problems"... seriously?

    by benjaminelial

    I'm willing to concede that every list is totally a personal thing but Tell Me You Love Me is one of the most excessive, painfully melodromatic heaps of shit on TV and everything Battlestar ran this season was unequivocally bad. Couple these picks (especially Battlestar at #1) with the omission of both Life and Dexter... come on man.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:59:03 AM CST

    Kind Nation was the bomb...

    by docbosch

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:04:40 AM CST

    What about ANY OTHER SHOW NOT ON THIS LIST???

    by docbosch

    How come ANY OTHER SHOW NOT ON THIS LIST is not on this list? I mean, come on, you rank SOME SHOW I DON'T LIKE, yet you fail to include ANY OTHER SHOW NOT ON THIS LIST, which i happen to enjoy. What do you think this is, something based on your personal opinion?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:06:27 AM CST

    Dexter not making a lot of critics' lists.

    by mose schrute

    I wonder why. Well at least Dexter won a shitload of Emmys over its first two seasons to make up for not making many critics' Top Tens.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:10:53 AM CST

    Dexter

    by peter venkman

    Wow. Not having Dexter on a list of top ten greatest shows is like not having ALF on a list of Top Ten Shows Starring ALF.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:19:26 AM CST

    Good list...

    by executor

    ...the only change I'd make is to echo the above and add Dexter instead of Tell Me You Love Me. Tried to watch but it never resonated for me. Other than the hot Burger King girl naked.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:20:56 AM CST

    No Dexter????

    by photoboy

    C'mon man, it was absolutely riveting this year, I've not been so anxious to see the next episode of a TV show in years. Dexter has been seriously undervalued by the critics this year.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:35:40 AM CST

    Fuck yeah, BSG is still the BEST show on TV

    by han cholo

    I can almost guarantee that the rest of the episodes will raise the bar for television drama. Moore has had a long break inbetween seasons so I'm expecting to see some revolutionary television when BSG returns.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:38:42 AM CST

    Dexter is rubbish

    by bobwalnut

    Why does he have to keep underlining how odd, weird and "not-like-us" he is every frickin' 10 minutes? Wouldn't a well-written show let us infer that from the action / dialogue?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:41:36 AM CST

    Which column would "The Soup" go under?

    by spifftacular squirrel girl

    Not sure if there's another program that makes me laugh more than this one.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:57:53 AM CST

    Are there two shows called DEXTER?

    by splungiest

    The only one I know by that name is pretentious, poorly written Showtime swill about a serial killer. Where does the good DEXTER air and what's it about?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:00:59 AM CST

    No Dr Who? Torchwood? Life on Mars? IT Crowd? Primeval?

    by nzguy

    You're slipping Herc, how can you say the episode Blink (from Dr Who) doesn't deserve to be on that list?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:02:10 AM CST

    Herc, thanks for leaving off Dexter.

    by whoanecron

    And thanks to all the other critics too for leaving it off as well. And thanks to all the Emmys for voting it no awards. While Dexter wins few accolades, it's still incredibly overrated.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:23:25 AM CST

    The Office has been complete rubbish...

    by coup

    Desperate Housewives should replace that in your list.
    I still don't think one good ep of Heroes, yes, there's only been one, Company Man, warrants it being on that list. Dexter could easily slot in, even though it hasn't been AS good this season.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:23:53 AM CST

    Haven't seen Mad Men or Pushing Daisies yet

    by newc0253

    otherwise i concur, although I wonder whether House doesn't also deserve a place on the list somewhere.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:28:58 AM CST

    Dexter is at the top of Kristin's list

    by thick mcrunfast

    That's Kristin of "Watch with Kristin" on E!. Can't say I'm surprised at Herc's lousy list - he's really just in it for the screeners and the absurdly long and posted-way-too-often DVD spam list complete with the code for Amazon referral points in the URL. Once Dexter gets some face time on CBS this year, you'll see the HBO snobs fall in line finally. It's undeniably a great show, and I'd say the morons who go out of their way to criticize it here proves that.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:36:11 AM CST

    um... Dexter best show on TV...

    by youignorantgeeks

    My brother asked me if I really watched it, I said of course, he asked how it was.. and that subject heading is how I described it after thinking about it. IT IS THE BEST SHOW ON TV... and its not on this list?!!?!?!? Also How I Met Your Mother is best comedy on TV... yet also not on list!??!!?!?! hahaha yea ok there... And the Sopranos Final Shot was one of THE WORST Final shots in history. Deal with it.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:36:19 AM CST

    no dexter

    by palewook

    i call horseshit.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:43:31 AM CST

    Kristin from E! loves Seventh Heaven and One Tree too.

    by mcgowanleg

    So her endorsement, while unsurprising, does not compel me to watch more episodes of that crapfest Dexter

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:51:13 AM CST

    Decent list ....

    by itchy

    but I'd put Sopranos higher. The final 6 were pretty fantastic, especially Soprano's Home Movies. Looking back, it really is the best TV I've ever seen.

    Lost and Heroes both continue to show they are fabulous shows when moving towards a definate plot event, but otherwise tend to get bogged down. If the first episodes of Heroes were as good as the last three this year, no one would be bitching on here.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:00:01 AM CST

    Take THAT, Kristen Bell hatas!

    by pennsy

    :)

    2 shows in Herc's top 10. A very good list, although I don't get the Brotherhood love. My personal top 10 had VM and BSG 2 and 1 as well.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:08:31 AM CST

    Don't sweat no How I Met Your Mother, guys...

    by pennsy

    The list is for the 10 best scripted *hour-long* shows. Maybe Herc will give us the 10 best 30-minute ones later this week. HIMYM is TV's best comedy, yes.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:13:55 AM CST

    Strike that, I didnm

    by pennsy

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:15:05 AM CST

    Strike that, I didn't see the 30-minute list until now...

    by pennsy

    Damn Herc, no HIMYM, but Lucy, Daughter of the Devil??? WTF?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:43:24 AM CST

    BSG... one show to rule them all

    by razorback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:49:39 AM CST

    The top 10 is worth shit without the Shield, Herc

    by toby___wong

    What an awesome season it was. Supernatural season 2 was also awesome and its finale was the best finale of any show on tv.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:55:00 AM CST

    Sniff - no Journeyman

    by theycallmemrglass

    Sniff again. Journeyman RIP - at least I think that is the current scenario, right. "Company Man" episode is my favourite episode of any series. To those who have read Harry Potter and the Deathly hallows, (SPOILER WARNING) - doesnt Company Man (ie Noah bennet) strike a a similarity to Professor Snape in terms of character plot twist?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:05:08 AM CST

    Talking about great endings

    by theycallmemrglass

    It will be nice to see a top 10 of greatest endings. The only great endings I can think of are for 3 British shows The Office, Extras, and Life on Mars. Does that say something about the difference between US TV networks (go f*ck yourselves and watch what we give you and have the right to pull the plug when we want even if it was the happiness of your life) and BBC (We want your yr licence fee so will do our best but allow us to f**k up now and again)

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:14:55 AM CST

    Les Moonves must suffer

    by drath

    He's cancelled a lot of shows with passionate followings. Star Trek Enterprise and Joan of Arcadia were both axed too soon. Where was this ape when Star Trek Voyager was sucking for seven long years? He should be banished to Viacom's most remote and smelliest office and never heard from again.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:17:49 AM CST

    No Journeyman? No Jounrneyman really????

    by mr_x

    sorry but one or two good eps of heroes does not make a season. JOurneyman was constantly better herc, and some love for dexter should not have gone amiss. really disappointed with the lack of journeyman

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:21:56 AM CST

    no house either?

    by mr_x

    this season has been the best yet

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:23:46 AM CST

    No jericho???? Thank god for that

    by theycallmemrglass

    They totally ruined that shows potential. The black dude was the most interesting character though.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:27:54 AM CST

    Oh and Black Adder Goes Forth

    by theycallmemrglass

    Greatest ending in the world. Friends had a lovely if not spectacular ending. What other great endings are there? I will like to watch the series if I havent seen them.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:30:58 AM CST

    Good year for TV.

    by series7

    People are shitting there pants about ever overrated movie coming out right now. I think this year TV was fucking amazing. And I don't even get HBO or Showtime. I don't think there has ever been a year with show after show just nailing it. Granted I don't agree with Herc (Heroes, really I can't even fucking tell you what the second half of the first season was about, and I was way into that show but I hate it still?). And 30 Rock > Office, this season of 30 rock was the funniest thing on tv/movies, the Office was just painting by numbers (minus those horrible not sure if its a comedy or melodrama hour longs). Also I really like Pushing Daisies, but the premiss is starting to wear thin and I don't see it sticking around much longer. Also wheres any FX love? Weren't you plowing through pairs of undies because of your uncontroable bowels about the show Damages? I didn't really care for the show, but someone on this site was trying to get us to watch it every week? Who was that? Plus the soup needs to go in there somewhere, Chat Shows maybe? Its funny how one man is funnier then the entire staff at Best Week Ever. Someone get Doug Benson a better job.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:53:54 AM CST

    Bionic Woman quite rightly was not mentioned

    by theycallmemrglass

    But its watchable, just not very exciting. yet it garners more viewers than Journeyman. It tells me that TV Network Marketing is more powerful than word of mouth which saddens me. I started watching Journeyman simply through word of morth. Oh well.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:05:22 AM CST

    INSTANT FAIL because of lack of Dexter... Heroes? Seriously?

    by turketron

    Come on now. You can put Heroes up there (which I do make it a point to watch every episode of, but feel that for the most part, it's really weak) but don't even have a breath about Dexter? Something's wrong here. If you're going to mention shows that "had some good episodes" such as Heroes, you should list Supernatural. And Lost would beat BSG, I'd say there were a lot more great episodes in the tail end of season 3 than in BSG's third season. To each his own I guess...

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:06:46 AM CST

    My list (not that anyone gives a shit)...

    by sledge hammer

    ...mainly I'm just posting this because frankly I have nothing better to do. I don't agree with much of Herc's list, or Herc's taste in general, but he's still entitled to his own opinions all the same. Anyways...My top 10 in no particular order (because I'm not quite *that* bored):
    The ShieldDexterLostHouseLife On MarsBattlestar GalacticaRomeWeeds24The UnitDoctor Who
    fave new shows:The RichesCalifornicationJourneymanDamagesBurn NoticeJekyll
    Still enjoying:
    EntourageDrawn TogetherSouth ParkIt's Always Sunny In PhiladelphiaRescue MeHustlePrison BreakBig LoveThe IT CrowdTop GearHeroesMythbustersMy Name Is Earl

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:12:18 AM CST

    No Dexter invalidates the list.

    by sid 8.0

    Call me selfish if you want but it was the best show of 2007. No Unit either just adds to the omissions list.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:21:58 AM CST

    Looking at some other posts makes me...

    by sid 8.0

    realize There are quite a few others that weren't on the list. Damages, Rescue Me, Always Sunny, and How I Met Your Mother were just fooking hilarious. Add Supernatural,and L&O SVU too. Of the new shows only Life and Journeyman very sad to see that one go.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:23:43 AM CST

    I still need to check out Life...

    by sledge hammer

    Given all the praise it's been getting. Give me something new to watch anyways...

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:24:29 AM CST

    I disagree.

    by catvutt

    The list is supposedly the Ten Best Scripted Hourlongs of 2007, and that INCLUDES those rancid Season Two Heroes episodes, so no way should it be Top Ten. JOURNEYMAN, FAMMIT!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:31:21 AM CST

    Dexter

    by toshiro-solo

    is good, but it ain't that good. This list looks about right to me. I think I've said it before, but after some Wire, the "police procedural" aspects of Dexter are kind of laughable. Everything that focuses on the title character is gold, but much of the rest falls flat for me.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:41:22 AM CST

    bsg wasnt #1, sorry

    by palewook

    the lame last episode were everyone was a cylon and half the episode dialog lifted from "along the watchtower' wasn't brilliant. it was just a half hearted attempt to make something profound that wasn't.

    i'm a cylon, she's a cylon, wouldn't you like to be a cylon too..

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:42:09 AM CST

    WTF

    by greg39

    What the hell is up with all the Journeyman love? That show was pure formulaic drivel at its worst. Every episode was exactly the same, just rename the charcters. And if you're going to talk about Tell Me you Love Me, don't talk the sex scenes. You guys sound like Geeks in heat, and idea of most of you naked, kind of makes me sick.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:45:35 AM CST

    All crap. So bad that IRON CHEF AMERICA blows them away.

    by uncle stan

    and I'm sure that it's only partially scripted.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:11:09 AM CST

    Recently started watching Mad Men (Spoilers)...

    by danielkurland

    And I am astounded at these wonderful monologues that each character has in an episode. Pete Campbell's speech about hunting a deer, and how his wife should properly act is one of the best things I've seen. Don has also had a lot of fantastic ones, unfortunately I can't think of any offhand.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:12:01 AM CST

    No idea Brotherhood had...

    by danielkurland

    Janel Moloney naked. I WILL watch it now.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:15:41 AM CST

    Glad to see HIMYM appreciation..

    by danielkurland

    An incredibly funny, well acted show, that pays tremendous attention to coninuity. And King of the Hill is leagues better than Simpsons/Family Guy, etc. at this point, and they've been having a great season, and actually taking risks (killed a pivotal character) whereas Simpsons would have reset it all by the end. Glad to see I'm not the only one finding value in it.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:17:54 AM CST

    Andy Barker at 2 and 30 Rock at 9?!

    by fart_master_flex

    Seriously, it is your list so you can do whatever you want. But for my money, nothing made me laugh more than 30 Rock in 2007. All I have to say is Jack and Tracey's therapy session is hands down the scene of the year. It is Baldwin's Emmy moment fo' sho'.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:22:47 AM CST

    Oh yeah

    by spank

    Everyone has their favs I suppose- Sad Herc, that you have ALL that time to watch "reality" shows and little if any time to watch a little more QUALITY tv. You missed shows like Jeckyl, Journeyman, Dr. Who, Daqmages, Torchwood, Life On Mars, heck evem Reaper- guess you're lucky you have all those pay channels so you can stay up on all the HBO s-sh-s-stuff (I cancelled my sub when they cancelled Deadwood- and they're gonna have to pick up their quality BIG TIME before I pay for them again!). If you were judging shows on THIS YEAR'S performance I'm sure it would be a different list. Mad Men, Veronica, well, not ALL of your choices are off, but seriously (SERIOUSLY!) Lost??? This last season??? Heroes at least had some of their first season shows this year- but really, with the lackluster performance of their second, SOMEBODY aught to be ashamed! Anyone else figure out that Lost is actually Never-Neverland from Barrie's book? Look it up, and Herc, PLEASE start paying attention to some of the more QUALITY shows and less to the quality HYPE! Thanks buddy.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:25:54 AM CST

    Sopranos??

    by spank

    Really?? again, THIS YEAR??? I admit I didn't watch it and figured all the acolades this year were from their overall performance, but still, the BEST???

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:27:32 AM CST

    KingKirby Has His Say!!

    by kingkirby

    10) BROTHERHOOD (Showtime). Don't have Showtime, don't care.
    9) ROME (HBO). I agree...I wish HBO would stop truncating some of it's best written and involving series (Carnivale, Deadwood, Rome).
    8) HEROES (NBC). There was a lot of wheel-spinning when season 2 kicked off, but I think the ship righted itself quite admirably by the end of the strike-shortened season.
    7) MAD MEN (AMC). Man, that redheaded vixen has a sweet ass! Oh, and this was a welcome surprise on what was once one of my favorite basic cable channels...before they started adding commercials, and before they started considering trash like "Catwoman" an American Movie Classic. Eww, I just threw up in my mouth a little.
    6) THE SOPRANOS (HBO). After stringing us along for WAAAAY too long, it started seeming like everything (and everyone) must go. An infuruating and, upon reflection, very cool ending. Didn't everyone scream when the screen went black, thinking their cable went out? With the end of "The Sopranos," to a certain degree...it did.
    5) TELL ME YOU LOVE ME (HBO). Guess you have to have been in an intimate relationship (which is hard for some internet geeks like me), I found it boring. Blah blah blah...let's do it...blah blah blah...why don't you want to do it...blah blah blah...dear God please don't show the old couple do it. Blah indeed.
    4) PUSHING DAISIES (ABC). My pick just ahead of JOURNEYMAN as my favorite show of the year. Has there ever been a relationship on TV as tantalizingly as the one between The Pie Maker and Chuck? Just one touch? Nope, it'll take you away for ever. Can't I even pet my dog once? Nope...it'll kill him, too. Oh, and Kristin Chenowyth, the petite pixie, has a voice, and a rack, to die for...no pun intended.
    3) LOST (ABC). Agreed.
    2) VERONICA MARS (The CW). Not with you in the least. Everytime I tried to watch this miscalculated abortion of a show, I kept asking myself what the hell does Herc see in this mess. Okay, Bell is cute, but she just always came off as a slutty drag to me, who's precious little witticisms seemed too forced to be believed as actually coming from her. Sorry.
    1) BATTLESTAR GALACTICA (SciFi). I declare shenanagans on you! Oh Gods, what a boring show. So much bullshit about clones and cylons that look like people and Cylons that look like RoboCop2. With bad writing, bad acting, and "Stargate" level direction, this stinkball really is what SciFi has become...hell, they even show "professional" wrestling now, for shit sake.
    But then again, my list would have included "Chuck" and "Reaper," so what do I know? The King has spoken.



    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:32:22 AM CST

    Damages and Journeyman

    by pviii

    for shame Herc, for shame.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:55:09 AM CST

    Dexter

    by ian216a

    Got over my new years eve hangover yesterday by watching all of the second season for the first time in one day. From the first episode I was completely engrossed in it. It's amazing how sympathic they get you to feel towards a self-proclaimed monster. I just don't understand how anyone here can accuse it of having "bad writing", which is a particularly inelegant phrase in itself. One of the funniest deliveries I've heard in ages was Doakes responding to whether he was going to meet a suspect with back-up. "Oh yeah. All kinds of back-up. Helicopters and shit." I'll miss that motherfucking cock-sucker. It wasn't completely faultless though. Jamie Murray as Lyla could really annoy with her overemphasised pronunciation. Probably just noticable because she was outclassed by the rest of the cast. nb. Anyone have Debbie Morgan's phone number?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 10:23:39 AM CST

    Shield, Dexter, Sunny In Philly

    by wash

    Some of the best shows, period. SHAME, Herc!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 10:36:08 AM CST

    oh yeah, Sunny too

    by pviii

    re: for shame.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 10:44:38 AM CST

    Howard Stern? really???

    by jccalhoun

    I used to watch his show on E just to see the blurry boobs so I guess I can understand the appeal of watching his show but the best talk show? really? I suppose watching him get women to take their clothes off is better than listening to it on the radio which I've never understood the appeal of.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 10:45:33 AM CST

    The Shield

    by supersize

    Where the fock is the Shield yo?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 10:59:26 AM CST

    my list

    by addyadam

    1) Lost
    2) The Office
    3) BSG
    4) South Park
    5) Heroes

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:10:09 AM CST

    Let's not turn Andy Barker into Freaks & Geeks

    by garbageman33

    In other words, let's not rememember it as a classic show axed well before its time. Andy Barker was amusing in small doses. Nothing more, nothing less.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:17:37 AM CST

    BSG: Exodus Part II

    by zooch

    Was the best hour of scripted television I've seen this year, and I'm huge fan of Lost's Season 3 finale, but Exodus was just slightly better.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:21:03 AM CST

    30 ROCK sucks

    by thegreatwhatzit

    And, no, it's not an imperiled "cult" sitcom a la ARRESTED DEVELOPMENT. It's an ego venue that slipping into erosion (little wonder that it's a blip on the Nielsen radar).

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:36:59 AM CST

    Herc, after a bajillion talkbackers begging you

    by smackfu

    to watch Dexter for 2 years now, you still haven't watched the series? I know, you've seen an episode or 2, but really, that's like talking to someone who refuses to watch Sopranos, saying 'I saw an episode once and it didn't do it for me'. Season 1 was good in introducing us to Dexter and fleshing him out, but Season 2 was a lot more slick and involving, watching a serial killer cop be put on the task force to investigate his own crimes. Great season.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:48:53 AM CST

    Ashok0

    by toshiro-solo

    I agree - it's about DEXTER. And when it's focusing on Dex the killer, it's great TV. When it's focusing on his dayjob (which it does sometimes, and when it does, it IS a police procedural, which is why the Wire comparison isn't totally out of left field) and the people he works with, it loses much of it's magic for me. I think the character is great, though.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:56:48 AM CST

    I don't get BSG...

    by danielkurland

    After all the praise here, I watched it. I've watched the entire series and it really just falls flat for me. I'm not the biggest science fiction fan, so that might be it, but I can usually put that behind me when the writing is particularly strong. The only episode I've really enjoyed of the show, on like a masterful level, was "Downloaded". But to see all you guys constantly praising it, I feel bad that I'm not "getting" it.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:01:55 PM CST

    My list of hourlongs

    by zer0cool2k2

    Not by quality, but by how soon I have to watch after Tivoing:
    1. BSG
    2. Mad Men
    3. Journeyman
    4. Damages
    5. The Shield
    6. Rescue Me
    7. Heroes
    8. The Sopranos
    9. Pushing Daisies
    10.Chuck
    11. Veronica Mars

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:09:43 PM CST

    DanielKurlend, re: BSG

    by zer0cool2k2

    If you don't "get" BSg, obviously you just aren't intelligent enough to grasp Ron moore's cerebral mastery of the television medium, or to follow the parallels drawn between that universe and our own current plight!
    That's what I'm supposed to do in Talkback, right? Bash anyone who disagrees that my favorite show is the greatest of all time!
    Actually, i just wanted to say thanks for giving BSG a shot before just declaring "it sucks". Hey, every show isn't for every viewer. just kidding before, as I'm sure you are quite intelligent and capable of forming your own opinions.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:25:54 PM CST

    dexter=overrated

    by heroic_duo

    Sorry, but it's pretty hammy and poorly written.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:27:16 PM CST

    Hey Herc...

    by jordo

    Did you ever get around to watching It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia? Absolutely hilarious.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:33:12 PM CST

    the love for how i met your mother

    by mr_x

    i dont get it. honestly i thought Kitchen Confidential was absolutely hilarious it just ot better and better ( for those that managed to get the whole season on torrent) and on at the same time but of cause Fox had to go fuck it up and cancel it.

    I cant belive this season of house is not on there. It's been unmissable tv these seaosn with the " survivor" eps, just bloody brilliant. the journeyman omission is sad, it was the best show this season, and had me glued to the tv

    SAVE JOURNEYMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    BSG.. apart from the exodus, kinda dragged on

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 12:46:31 PM CST

    No Dexter? Seriously man get your head out of your a**.

    by der-rabe

    Well, perhaps too much 'reality' TV can ruin your brain.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 1:02:15 PM CST

    House

    by series7

    This start of this season started really cheesy but got better toward the end. Like the first 3 or 4 medical mysteries were really lame. Once he got rid of pretty much everyone it got better. Hopefully it'll kick it up when it returns.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 1:13:30 PM CST

    Andy Barker will always be awful

    by tallboy66

    Seriously, that show was garbage and simply Not. Funny. And I'm a huge Late Night w/ Conan fan. Heroes was pretty great, but I find it kind of telling that the best Heroes episode, "Company Man", was a flippin' Lost rip-off.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 1:28:57 PM CST

    can someone please explain the bell love

    by slappy jones

    sure she is pretty in a forgettable bland way and she is not a bad actress but why why why do people go on about her as if she is the greatest actress to have walked the earth? did anyone actually see her on heroes??

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 1:33:51 PM CST

    20 minute VM mini-pilot?

    by reinhold

    Does that mean that the DVD features a longer mini-pilot than what's no YouTube (which I think was about 12 minutes)?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 1:42:55 PM CST

    House should be on there

    by king sweyn forkbeard

    The Reality show/job interview thing was an absolutely inspired idea. Sure, the show is formulaic, but when Laurie gets lines as good as he does then who cares?

    Also a shocking omission for Dexter too.

    Reply to Talkback

  • hotness - and leave it at that - is a disservice to her. She's smart, funny, the lady can sing and dance (Reefer Madness, anyone?), and she's been on shows that AICN'ers love (Deadwood, The Shield, VM). She has at least 2 possible Emmy submission tapes for Best Supporting Actress on Heroes (for Four Months Ago and Cautionary Tales; maybe a third for the season finale Powerless). She's the BEST thing about Gossip Girl and should be a lead-pipe stone cold mortal lock to get a Best Voiceover in a Series Emmy nomination this summer.

    And then there's the little stuff like being kind and tres' nice to her fans when she goes to sci-fi/comic book conventions. I've seen it first-hand. She's somebody who's going to be getting million dollar movie paydays sooner than later, yet she comes across as a regular Jane. Straying offtopic, yes, but that's also part of her irresistible charm. And the lot of you, whether you want to admit it or not, would give one of each limb for the chance to go out with her. :)

    reinhold, I think Herc with the 20-minute pilot was looking at that extra on the S3 Veronica DVD where Rob Thomas explained just how his pitch for the Season That Never Will Be came about. That took about 5 minutes. The micro-pilot is actually on the bonus disc twice.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 2:03:01 PM CST

    Node32774

    by zer0cool2k2

    Lost would have made my Top 10, (Possibly top 5), based on quality alone, but I repeatedly found myself waiting until I had a backlog of 2 or 3 eps before I started watching it. Now in all honesty, I kept five or six episodes of VM, and watched them over a weekend after the finale aired, simply because i knew when it was over, it was over.

    Reply to Talkback

  • So here goes: 1. BSG; 2. Veronica Mars; 3. How I Met Your Mother; 4. Friday Night Lights; 5. Lost; 6. Mad Men; 7. Planet Earth (just for its sheer scope and ambition); 8. CSI (ok, sue me ;) ); 9. Pushing Daisies and 10. The Office.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 2:38:52 PM CST

    Where's the gods damn Law & Order talkback??

    by pennsy

  • Jan 02, 2008 2:41:10 PM CST

    Pretty sure...

    by dignan26

    that these lists contain pretty much every show on television.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 2:51:34 PM CST

    Ashok0, HIMYM is no Arrested Development.

    by beastie

    It's mildy funny for a laugh-track sitcom. There are a lot of lame jokes that are made hilarious solely on the delivery by Neil Patrick Harris. I don't go out of my way to watch it, but if I happen to catch it, it's not painful like 2 and a Half Men.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:01:26 PM CST

    no Dexter on list = completely invalidated opinions

    by thebaxter

    anyone who purports to know enough about TV to put together a top ten list, and then doesn't include Dexter on that list, basically looks like a moron. easily the most consistently entertaining and well-written show this year. BSG and Lost, as great as they are, missed the target sometimes, but Dexter never did. anyone slagging off the show here obviously stopped watching during or after the first season, which was admittedly a little sloppy. but the 2nd season was pretty close to perfect, and all the flaws of the first season were completely missing from episode 2.1 onwards.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:12:18 PM CST

    Ashok0, HIMYM is a subversive laugh-track sitcom.

    by lenny nero

    It's character-based and focuses on a kind of Gen-X/Gen-Y postmodern mentality. While it does have a laugh track, it is not filmed before an audience due to the complicated back-and-forth nature of the plots. The humor is realistic and not sitcom-stupid, the conflicts come from real-life honesty and it's also probably the most romantic sitcom in many a year. It's the kind of comedy that just makes you feel good, one that doesn't exist in the fantasy worlds of gag-awkward plot-gag that have sullied the land of television comedy.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:56:35 PM CST

    Howard Stern/Kristen Bell

    by thegreatwhatzit

    Stern is as antiquated as his jokes; I suspect his ego is bruised because he's drifted completely out of the limelight. How about THE HIGH PITCH ERIC SHOW? It could be the most surreal hour in TV history (and likely to be picked-up for a second episode). Kristen Bell is hot; unlike Pam Anderson and other the other plastic bimbos, Bell adheres to the French venue--ALL natural (Bardot, Adjani, Deneuve, Marceau, Beart, et al...they're France's only worthy exports).

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:57:19 PM CST

    More Whine?

    by wickedmonster

    REAPER, TWO AND A HALF MEN, THE BIG BANG THEORY, THE SOUP...Come on, man. TaaHM doesn't win emmys for nothing.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 3:59:05 PM CST

    Oh I forgot.

    by wickedmonster

    RULES OF ENGAGEMENT...and THE BOONDOCKS. I can't go to sleep on Mondays without watching these.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:02:32 PM CST

    Kristen Bell is dating dax shepard

    by pviii

    obviously everyone's favorite blonde is a dumb blonde as well.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:11:18 PM CST

    I love New York 2 & Howard Stern

    by montypigeon

    This was better than A shot at love by a long way. Also, Howard Sterns show contained the best interview on television this year with Robert Duvall but does not belong at #1.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:13:56 PM CST

    Friday Night Lights???

    by my pretty pony

    How could that show not be on the list??? Regarding that Veronica Mars season 4 pitch--I didn't think it was very good. It was really just okay. I mean, that thing was riddled w/ cliches--guy she slept w/ over the summer and never thought she'd see again shows up and catches her off guard, cocky & good-looking young FBI agent who gives her a hard time at first (we can already see the sparks flying!)--boring love triangle, anyone? Then there's the other female newbie, presumed bitchy at first, who will more than likely become V's new BFF after she saves her life and V discovers that there's more to her than originally thought. And those are just a few of the standout cliches. Not to mention, none of the regular supporting cast was a part of it. Would season 4 have been all about Veronica & a bunch of new people we don't even care about w/ the occasional appearance by her father (maybe)?? It would've sucked and I don't blame The CW for passing on it. I doubt it would've attracted any new viewers and it probably would've turned off what little viewers it did have.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:58:28 PM CST

    This season of Survivor

    by jabbayoda

    was one of the best in a long time. Really back to form. No separations by race or gender...no fucking couches...no goddamned returning contestants. A solid cast, and, really, the most deserving person won. That makes 3 seasons in a row on Survivor when the winner was really the most deserving. Anyway, I like Dexter.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 4:58:37 PM CST

    House?

    by dartofharkness

    No House? Also, Heroes never really seems to live up to it's potential or hype. Not that it's bad, just never as good as it could be.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 5:45:43 PM CST

    Anybody who says 30 Rock sucks, blows,

    by skimn

    or whatever, has their head squarely up their anus. If Alec Baldwin's "therapy" scene with Tracy Morgan is not one of the funniest 90 seconds of television this year, then nothing is. You got a problem with Tina Fey? Fine. Don't watch the show, and shut the fuck up.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 6:31:55 PM CST

    charlie rose

    by jackdonkey

    i like charlie rose, but when he interviewed John Edwards all he did was keep asking questions in a way to get the answers he wanted, like "how do you think they should judge when a teacher should be rewarded?" and john edwards wisely said "I don't think it's about getting rewarded" I'm sure my quotes are way off but I lost a lot of respect for charlie rose with that interview.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:02:43 PM CST

    However...

    by karuma

    ...from a dissenting view, a question? Why do people that watch a lot of TV think they know what the best of is? Kristin puts out a list, Ausiello, Hercules, and every other Tom, Dick, and Ebert who has the access to a public forum or gets paid for it puts out a list. What makes yours (and theirs)so special is only one thing, it is yours and no one else's. From the other posters replies it is evident that you either a. Rock, or b. Suck, however, neither is the case. You have your opinion, we have ours and as far as that goes..here is Karuma's list of the ten (with one to grow on) best scripted hourlongs (In no Particular Order)...Life on Mars, Veronica Mars, Pushing Daisies, BSG, Mad Men, Dexter, Nip/Tuck, The Unit, Burn Notice, Monk, and The Closer. And for the 10 best comedies, Corner Gas, Big, Bang Theory, Two and a Half Men, Flight of the Conchords, Entourage, 30 Rock, The Office, My Name is Earl, and Sarah Silverman. As for Reality shows, only two are of any interest at all, Survivor and Kid Nation and for chat, Inside the Actors Studio is far and away the most entertaining and informative.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:34:30 PM CST

    No Mancow?

    by dazzler69

    He has the best radio show.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 7:36:42 PM CST

    You'd have to pay me to say Heroes was up there

    by performingmonkey

    Watching it felt like punishment every week. I know what you'll say, 'well why the fuck watch it?' I carried on watching because I'm sick of people saying to me I didn't give a show a chance. All three seasons of both Lost and Galactica IMO have obliterated most other hourlongs. I was worried for both shows before their 3rd seasons started but fuck yes we got the goods, they delivered, Lost definitely giving it's best season, Galactica still packing a hefty punch despite there being absolutely no chance of matching the sublime season 1. If Lost keeps up the standard it has a shot at the title of Greatest-Show-Ever (no, Sopranos isn't, although it's certainly up there)

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:01:32 PM CST

    WGA will picket the Golden Globes...

    by pennsy

    The show's last-ditch effort at a waiver failed today: http://tinyurl.com/2r6gtd.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:03:06 PM CST

    John From Cincinnati

    by boast

    you haters will realize this someday.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:11:12 PM CST

    So You Think You Can Dance

    by chester_desmond

    That was the best reality show by far in 2007. Very underrated. And Wade Robson is a genius:

    Example #1: http://tinyurl.com/2dtujw
    Example #2: http://tinyurl.com/2ftj2q

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:12:17 PM CST

    Sopranos ending wasn't that great

    by sick fixx

    Writers are getting entirely too lazy with the 'blank canvas' approach. Why should we as viewers have to write every ending with our own imaginations? If we want to use our imaginations, we'll go write or paint. We are investing time in someone else's vision. We deserve pay offs.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:20:44 PM CST

    the intentional eschewing of anything Prison Break here

    by sick fixx

    is ridiculous. I don't even care that it's not on the list of some fellow fan who happens to run a website. But it should at least have its own talkback since it has captured the same audience that follows 24, Lost, Nip/Tuck and Sopranos.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:32:16 PM CST

    Friday Night Lights

    by my pretty pony

    is about so much more than football. It's all about the characters. It's well-written, well-acted, and compelling. I can't even fully explain why I love this show so much, there's just something about it. You just have to watch it and see for yourself. I couldn't care less about football and I love this show.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:51:56 PM CST

    "South Park" is still on?

    by burnhollywood

    That used to be kinda funny. Like, ten years ago.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 8:57:18 PM CST

    Damages Damages Damages

    by holodigm

    Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages Damages

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:00:00 PM CST

    No Black Donnelly's??

    by bigmick

    I know the show got cancelled, but man the 6 episodes that aired and the rest that are out on dvd are much better than half the shows Herc listed up there. It was much better than Brotherhood or Pushing Daisies. It's a real shame this show had to go the same way as Journeyman, but than again NBC is pretty good at fucking themselves

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:05:24 PM CST

    Doctor Who "Blink"

    by wolfpupnx

    would be my pick by a mile. Possibly the finest hourlong piece of television I've yet witnessed (IMHO at least).

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 9:22:34 PM CST

    Herc is to Dexter, as Harry is to BSG...

    by billyeveryteen

    Two "experts" ridgidly ignoring some of the best media in their fields.Obtuse fucktards.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:16:24 PM CST

    South Park was funnier 10 years ago?...

    by danielkurland

    I'm not the person at all to start arguments in talkbacks, but this is one of the stupider things that had been said. And it particularly annoys me, because a good deal of people who don't watch South Park, and just want to insult it, use this argument. South Park has only been on 11 years, and this comparison would mean that you thought it was funny when the show started out, and is now, worse, or perhaps tired, in quality. The same people that say this tend to say that the show is entirely toilet humor and juvenile material. This IS primarily what the show was when it started, and I DIDN'T like the show then. It was merely shocking, because a cartoon, was being so vulgar. That is not the same South Park that exists at all. Yes, they sometimes do revert to this, but the show now is one of the most socially relevant, cultural satire that is currently being produced. The show is winning Emmys now, it's winning Peabodys (that gasp, BSG also has won!), it has a lot to say, and it is doing so in some incredibly creative means and parallels. So I'm tired of the people condemning this show to be what it was when it started, or that it was funnier when it started. South Park is one of the smartest shows (sometimes it chooses not to be) on television.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 02, 2008 11:19:45 PM CST

    The Sopranos ending wasn't lazy writing...

    by danielkurland

    It was subtle. The ending of what will happedn is hinted at throughout the entire episode, and the commentary in prior episodes about what "death will be like", in my opinion, completely told you what was going to happen, it just wanted to to figure it out. What's great is the myriad of events and breakdowns that would have happened after the final scene, and how wonderful it would be to see all of that, but we won't.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 1:34:20 AM CST

    Why the second class status to the comedy series?

    by rev. slappy

    30 Rock and The Office are better most scripted on hours.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 4:03:17 AM CST

    zombiehunt and writers

    by necgray

    First of all, Mori isn't the webmaster hereabouts. He's one guy with one voice. Second, while writers aren't emphasized as much as directors or visuals on this site, many stories DO, in fact, talk about the writer. It just so happens that in a lot of cases the writer is also the director because many movie geeks, and I suspect this is true of Harry in particular, are fans of the "auteur" theory of film. So if the site is run by guys who prefer "auteur" theory, of course the directors are going to be emphasized more. I don't particularly recall you being an anti-WGA poster, zombiehunt, but then again those assholes all seem to run together into one long bullshit parade.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 4:36:40 AM CST

    Ditto Dexter

    by elab49

    And anyone things Lost is anything other than badly written dross is delusional. I realise some people tied their standards to is season 1 when it was watchable but, seriously, get over the pride thing - you got conned, admit it and move on.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 5:43:56 AM CST

    Where's "The Shield"?!

    by the tao of joe

    I know I say this every time Herc drops his top ten list, but where is it?! Anyone who actually watched the last two seasons can't deny that it's a better show than at least 5 of the ones that made Herc's list.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 6:27:07 AM CST

    No Journeyman :-(

    by br1947

    At least BSG and Pushing Daisies made the list. I gotta disagree with Lost however. Lost SHOULD be a good show, but the damned thing is way too streched out. This whole past season should have been 3-4 episodes.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 8:10:14 AM CST

    why not enjoy something new for NEW YEAR?

    by kily2007

    Hey! so nice discussion , BUT NEW YEAR is coming, how to celetrate the wonderful days? you love to try something new? http://interracialsingleonline.com you will be surprised there...

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 9:10:58 AM CST

    Consider me surprised....

    by airstrike

    that there are actually 10 scripted hourlongs still on television.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 9:22:10 AM CST

    Have to agree with DanielKurland re: BSG

    by mthrndr

    I watched the first two full seasons. Maybe the show picks up after that, maybe not. But based on those seasons I don't get the love. To me it was a plodding, Baltar/Blonde cylon, Baltar/Blonde cylon, oh look another character we trusted is a cylon, and look! some people suspect and they're not doing anything about it! Oh, here come the cylons again! Another betrayal! now a dude is stuck on caprica and the cylons are playing with him! I just lost interest. I loved firefly, ST:TNG, but this? no, just can't do it. I gave up after the 5th time baltar betrayed the humans and began having sex with air.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 10:34:42 AM CST

    no, it was the recent one

    by mthrndr

    It got so that every time baltar came on screen I hit the fast forward and just read the damn subtitles, to get through it quicker. I'm thinking I prefer scifi shows with more of a one-off, one adventure per episode narrative style, with just a little exposition and mythology expansion thrown in. At this point, the only full-on serialized show that I watch is Lost. I gave up on Jericho, Heroes, and others because they were too slow moving.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 10:37:16 AM CST

    Veronica Mars FBI looked so much coler than

    by crichtonastronut

    about 90% of what aired this season. And I liked the college year, way better college transition than Buffy.

    BSG had some misses this past season but started awsome with the Exodus storyline and ended on high note, especially with the forshadowing from Razor. As for Shark Jumping. Everyone said that last year with thefast forward and again the follow up was awesome. I got faith in the man. Razor itself proves he's still got the skills and hasn't burned out on this world.

    Can't wait for the next season.

    Gotta agree with some of theother posts though. You really need to see Dexter and you've defenitly got to watch How I Met Your Mother.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 11:33:40 AM CST

    I'm not saying BSG is bad..

    by danielkurland

    It's just I don't like it. That doesn't mean I'm an idiot, or therefore every other show I watch is garbage. I'd say every show I'm watching is rather smart and intelligent, but BSG just wasn't my thing. I can't help that. I think I did a lot more than most people would though by actually watching three seasons of a show, that I'm only marginally enjoying ENTIRELY because of what you people have said. It's not like I've just watched random episodes and said "this isn't for me". I know the characters, I know the stories. I thought Baltar's trial WAS interesting this season, but ultimately, it was all the filler episodes that bored me and took me out of it. There are plenty of moments on the show I've enjoyed, I'm not saying the opposite. But it was just not something I was really looking forward to watching when the third season was on (and I watched the first two seasons in about two days total).Now I know this next season is supposed to be entirely canon, so I hope I enjoy it a lot more (and I will be watching it), but just because I don't like ONE show (I love Dexter, Lost, Mad Men, Sopranos, Weeds, Curb...) that you guys love should be acceptable. There's tons of fucking people who won't even give Veronica Mars a shot because of the name of the show. Those are close minded people. Those are people worthy of scrutiny. But a show as genred as BSG, I think it's understandable if some people aren't crazy about it.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 11:35:46 AM CST

    mthrndr...

    by danielkurland

    I agree with you on BSG, but to abandon some shows for being slow, but sticking with Lost? I'm a huge supporter of Lost, but I definitely think it's more about the characters and situations, and I'm fully expecting not to get answers immediately on it. I would say it's a very slow show in terms of reveals (although they do reveal plenty).

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 11:45:33 AM CST

    The Real World

    by the alienist

    Thanks, Herc, for that. Sydney may be the greatest season of RW EVER, definitely the best since the drinkfuckpuke seasons began. It was so great it almost seemed scripted (but obviously wasn't). The Evil Blond, the good but sometimes annoying young Muslim chick, the COOLEST guy to every inhabit the RW fishbowl, the jerk guy who you still sorta like .... some of the episodes were so compelling I actually cared about RW kids for the first time in eight years.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 1:43:10 PM CST

    Although I respect Battlestar Galactica being #1

    by dirkangerreloaded23

    the lack of Damages, Journeyman, The Shield, Dexter & or even 30 Rock or the Office are practically criminal in they're exclusion. No offense but Pushing Daisies just completely lost me after the second episode. Way to fucking "quirky" for my tastes; & Tell Me You Love Me = never even heard of that show b4. Ever.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 1:55:02 PM CST

    My fav 10

    by potch

    Notice I said... my fav... these may not be the best shows on tv, but they're the ones I find to be the most fun....

    hour-longs:
    Dexter
    Heroes
    Supernatural
    Smallville
    4400
    Pushing Daisies
    Bones
    One Tree Hill (Yes I like it, so flame me)
    Veronica Mars

    30 Min: ( i don't have ten of these)
    How I Met Your Mother
    Weeds
    2 1/2 Men
    Big Bang Theory
    Samantha Who
    South Park
    Ugly betty

    Other shows I enjoyed in 07: Drive, The End of the OC, Reaper, Beauty and the Geek, Kyle XY, Greek

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 2:19:27 PM CST

    THE SHIELD is too good to be on that list.

    by dr.bulber

    it wouldnt be caught dead anywhere near battlestar dramaqueenica.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 2:40:50 PM CST

    Everything has sucked this year except Dexter

    by domi'sinnerchild

    EVERYTHING. I'm talking the new seasons that started in 2007, so the second half of last season's shows (because there was a lot of quality there). I seriously think the writer's strike started a year ago. Dexter was the only show I looked forward to this year and I actually had low expectations for it because I didn't think there was anywhere to go with the character after Season 1.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 3:59:25 PM CST

    BSG - Yes! Sopranos can Suck My Ba...

    by ejcarter9

    Sopranos was the biggest let-down ever perpetrated by Man, second only to Jesus' little-known "pull-my-finger" gag.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 4:05:28 PM CST

    DirkAnger, look at the other lists on Herc's story.

    by lenny nero

    Yar, thar be sitcoms!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 4:07:00 PM CST

    And Ashok0, are you implying...

    by lenny nero

    ...that anything that is not serialized is a form of television spoonfeeding the audience? I can name about 500 shows dating back to the origin of television to now that are not serialized but are brilliant, respected and loved. Just because BSG isn't a one-off one-adventure-a-week kind of thing doesn't make it automatically superior to anything and everything.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 5:17:30 PM CST

    Supernatural

    by my pretty pony

    Another unique, well-written and well-acted hour-long that never gets the attention it deserves.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 6:42:58 PM CST

    Ashok0, I'm making a point about the history of television.

    by lenny nero

    Not just recent shows. I mean look at any decade and it puts the argument that "serialized is better" to complete shame. It's just one manner of storytelling, no better or worse than any other form.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 10:03:21 PM CST

    Greatest Endings of All Times

    by tigger11

    Forever Knight, in fact the last 5 or 6 episodes is a great sendoff to a series that didnt live up to its potential. I also am going to have to vote with the wheres Dexter crowd here.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 10:10:28 PM CST

    South Park was funnier when it WAS toilet humor...

    by burnhollywood

    Screw anybody who thinks a cartoon comedy should be "socially relevent", whether it's the guffawing right (South Park) or cackling left (The Simpsons)...these are the same bores who think that their "Bush/Cheney" bumper stickers are winning the War On Terror or that their "Free Tibet" decals made a difference in some Chinese guy's existence. B-grade comedy plus Z-grade political insight makes for one itchy finger on the channel remote.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 10:15:04 PM CST

    And, on an unrelated note...

    by burnhollywood

    ...Who even WATCHES that phony, "reality TV" bullshit, let alone be able to grade ten of those turds by shape and smell? Herc, buy a fucking clue.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 03, 2008 11:49:10 PM CST

    stern fans are morons, dexter is great

    by angrykirby.tk

    while I fucking hated the last episode of dex season 2 with it's cheap, kill dokes making lyla into a killer so dex has someone to kill, wrap up bullshit. every other episode this season was amazing.

    and howard blows. o and a party rock

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 12:54:13 AM CST

    Thanks for the DEXTER S2 spoiler

    by mace tofu

    I was waiting for season 2 of Dexter on DVD to catch up, just watched season 1 again on New Years day. Great

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 6:35:57 AM CST

    How I Met Your Mother...

    by chunker

    Is a show that could and should be corny and extremely sappy, like the others of its kind. But it always surprises with its clever writing and how "real" it is at times. It doesn't fall to the cliches (well...maybe a few times) like other shows do. And the way they navigate away from that pit, is seamless and unforced.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 8:50:08 AM CST

    yawwwn

    by slkboxrman

    looks like another 'tard that actually thought "black donnellys" was a good show.....i always laugh..... shows left out which i think should be on it have been mentioned, but ill run em down....."supernatural", "prison break", "journeyman"...how bout "the riches" and "life".... as for comedies...."how i met your mother" should be there...talk shows....i forgot if letterman was on there, but he should be #1.....consistently funny for as long as ive been watching him..

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 8:55:15 AM CST

    oh i forgot

    by slkboxrman

    and left out was also "stargate:atlantis" i dont care what anyone says....it still is one of the best shows on TV..... the special effects are tight and i look foward to watching the new episodes whenever they come....but then again i am a stargate whore...loved the movie, still hoping for the next spinoff....and the SG-1 movie "ark of truth" or whatever it was called was awesome and a nice end to the ori arc left over from season 10

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 3:17:06 PM CST

    zombiehunt and writers, again

    by necgray

    I don't know how I made your point for you, but you're welcome, I guess. Whatever. You know, Jon Stewart is a member of the WGA and fully supports them, so I don't know why you would bother to use him as an example. You're also wrong about contributing to a script. By your logic, any actor who ad-libs would have to have the ad-lib written down by a WGA member. And that's just not the case. All directors are expected to have input on the written word. Now if there are major changes made that are written down and that contradict the original writer, that's when it becomes a problem. But how often do you think that happens? I forgot, too, that you're one of these "today's TV is crap blah blah blah" types. I don't know if it's jealousy of some kind or if you're just someone who likes to bitch to hear his own voice, but either way I think you're in the vast minority. The fact that there are rabid fans of Lost, Heroes, Dexter, BSG, The Office, 30 Rock, Desperate Housewives, etc etc posting here tells me that TV writing is doing okay for itself. And the primary reason you don't hear about writers is because it's not glamorous. Writers are not considered by Joe Q Public to be the most interesting member of the creative team on a film. Primarily the actors and director are of interest. This is to say nothing of the obvious, which you're apparently ignoring and seems fairly obvious to me: there is a strike on. Duh. Why would there be any news about "writer X is writing movie X" when most Hollywood writers are WGA members and thus not currently working? Seems pretty logical to me. But even if they weren't striking, again, writers aren't considered that interesting to your average viewer. And AICN, while fairly well informed about the industry, is still a fan website. Fans who mostly don't care about writers. The exceptions are obviously guys like me. But that's an exception. So now that I've addressed all your points, do you care to counter me with more windbag proclamations or can we move on to other posts? Am I going to have to come back here and continue posting? Because I get really tired of trying to reason with you people.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 04, 2008 4:47:35 PM CST

    My Favorite 15 Shows Of 2007 (Alphabetical Order)

    by barry_woodward

    30 Rock, Battlestar Galactica, Big Love, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Dexter, How I Met Your Mother, Lost, Mad Men, The Office, One Tree Hill, Pushing Daisies, The Shield, The Sopranos, South Park, Veronica Mars

    Reply to Talkback

  • Jan 05, 2008 2:25:15 AM CST

    Ash0ko, X-Files was first and foremost a one-off series.

    by lenny nero

    With a different adventure almost every week. That they occasionally tied into a greater story does not mean it's hand-to-God serialized. If you're really looking for something in the same vein--Monster of the Week--but kept a more linear basis for its multiple seasons, you list Buffy as a good example.

    Now for me to consult my list of great television shows. Oh, by the way, only two shows on your list dates back earlier than the mid-80s, which in a way supports my point.

    And don't think I'm trying to say that serialized shows suck. Good God, no. I love them as much as you. But the point I'm trying to make is that serialization doesn't automatically dictate quality, and that incredible shows, both dramatic and comedic, can come from anywhere in any form. To deny that is to deny the power of the written word.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Feb 15, 2010 3:16:11 AM CST

    VomoKIc

    by tmveqk

    FPoepvDz VomoKIc

    Reply to Talkback

  • Feb 15, 2010 3:16:42 AM CST

    dVCPCxA

    by tmveqk

    wHpWasG dVCPCxA

    Reply to Talkback

User Login

Forgot password? Retrieve it here

or register as new user

Quick Talkback Form

Please login to post talkback