Logo

Cool News

Maria Von Trapp and Nordling chime in on BNAT 9

Published at:  Dec 11, 2007 12:38:33 PM CST

Hey folks, Harry here... I'm so glad to be finished with what has been the single most difficult BUTT-NUMB-A-THON to program ever for me. At one point, it was easily the most spectacular line-up I had set-up... Until this past evil week. In years past - nabbing films like V FOR VENDETTA and 300 - it really comes down to pure luck... is the film finished in time. This year, a great many of the films that many of you were guessing where actually committed, but in the final hours before BNAT - one particular film was forced to pull out 30 hours before the show went underway... due to over 100 visual fx shots not being delivered by an effects company on Monday for insertion into their digital print. Another was rushing its post to try to get there - but frankly it came down to the fact that the film just wasn't ready till December 18th. That said - I loved BNAT this year... In particular - CHARLIE WILSON'S WAR, TRICK R TREAT, of course SWEENEY TODD and in particular - the discovery of the fest was MONGOL. However - the 15 minutes from Pixar's WALL*E was unbelievably great. The character animation was simply brilliant - the expression and the sheer beauty of the film is going to blow people away. Here's Maria...




BNAT,

Happy birthday Harry! Thanks for including Liesl and I in another fun BNAT.

This year, one of biggest highlight of BNAT was sitting in the NEW Alamo with OLD friends and getting to enjoy Harry's birthday party with the finest group of movie geeks I will ever know. It just makes me happy to see movies, old and new, with these people.

But enough of mushy stuff...

We just returned from the Monday special BNAT extension screening of Son of Rambow. This is very sweet film, balanced with humor and nostalgia for being a kid in love with movies and yearning to make them. High recommendations for Son of Rambow-- this is our second viewing, and we'll see it when it is released. Liesl will have her review coming tomorrow sometime...she has a strong emotional connection with the film.

As for my favs this year...well, although I really, really enjoyed it, Sweeney Todd is not in my top 3, although it comes in a close 4th. Liesl has a different list, I'm sure as she loved, loved, loved Trick or Treat.

My top films are a tie for 1st: The Great McGinty and Mongol, both were prime examples of character studies within great stories. Mongol was visually stunning and has at its core a touching and unusual love story. The Great McGinty had unforgettable dialog that made me wish that everyone still talked like tough New Yorkers in movies from the 30s and 40s. Yeah, swell.

Speaking of great dialog, my next favorite movie was Charlie Wilson's War. This movie was loaded with earthy wit and smooth Texas-isms from Tom Hanks' Charlie Wilson and unrelentingly difficult truths delivered in ironically funny deadpan by Phillip Seymour Hoffman's Gust Avrakotos. Phillip pulls off a performance that is so good, it wasn't until I was halfway through the movie that I realized who the actor was. Throughout this movie, I found several thoughts coming up...Gandhi's "An eye for an eye, making the whole world blind." quote and the (Star Trek) Federation's Prime Directive of non-interference. Sadly, not only does this movie bring to light, with painful hindsight, events that helped the Taliban rise to power, but also may give rise to thought provoking questions about current events and politics. But you need to see the movie cause you'll get no spoilers from me.

Sweeney Todd is pretty awesome. I was just a tad disappointed with Helena Bonham Carter's performance. She either hasn't a very strong voice and wasn't ready to take any risks with her songs and, consequently, I didn't believe her character as much as I should have. But, on the other hand, Johnny Depp and Alan Rickman can, at this point, do no wrong in my eyes. In spite of my only slight disappointment in Mrs. Lovett, there is no way this dark and gruesome movie can fail. The Burton/Depp team has a huge following of teenage girls who will be loyal to this combination whether the movie merits or not. Fortunately for them and everyone else, Sweeney Todd does merit, if you can "stomach" the subject matter, and once again, I am ever so pleased to be a vegetarian and wouldn't touch the savory meat pie the drafthouse served. However, I can see how those poor geeks around me ate it, with it's fragrant and flaky crust, it smelled and looked delectable.

And the last movie on my top list was Trick or Treat: a treat for traditional horror fans everywhere. If you like movies like Creepshow, this campy but artistically beautiful homage to the B horror movie, will leave you with a post Halloween chocoholic satiation and a smile on your face.

Now I also loved The Lonely are Brave and Pickup on South Street and would not likely have seen those movies if I had not been at BNAT...and that, besides it being Harry's birthday, is what BNAT is what the celebration is about. Seeing unusual, old and new movies and being reminded over and over that movies are an almost endless treasure to discover even if you are a geek.

-Maria Von Trapp




And now here's Nordling...





Hey everyone, Nordling here, feeling a bit punchy but otherwise pretty good, reporting in on BNAT 9. BNAT this year was a bit of a mixed bag. The swag was godlike great (thank you so much Harry) and there were several amazing films... and then there weren't. But it ended on a high note, so let me get right to it!

THE GREAT MCGINTY - Preston Sturges' first film, about a low-life redeemed by the love of a good woman, was fantastic. I had never seen it before and I thought it was wonderful, with dialogue so sharp as to cut diamonds.

CHARLIE WILSON'S WAR - A very inteligent topical film about the arming of Afghanistan in the 1980s to fight against the Communists. Tom Hanks is excellent as usual, as was Julia Roberts in a smaller than advertised role, and Philip Seymour Hoffman steals the film, as par for the course.

PICK UP ON SOUTH STREET - Samuel Fuller's classic Cold War thriller was wonderful on the big screen. Richard Widmark plays a pickpocket who manages to steal some top secret film that could endanger America. It's witty and thrilling.

MONGOL - Of all the movies that played BNAT this year, this is the one I want to write about the most. It, like OLDBOY from BNAT 2003, has the real potential to find a wider audience. The first in an epic trilogy from Russian filmmaker Sergei Bodrov, MONGOL tells the origins of Genghis Khan from his humble beginning as a child to the leader of a vast army. I've always bugged Harry to play a Kurosawa film at BNAT, and this one was as close as they come. It's epic in scale but isn't afraid to get intimate at a moment's notice. Any film geek worth their salt should make a real effort to find this when it opens wide next year.

The short clips of WALL-E are the best thing I saw at BNAT. WALL-E touching the rings of Saturn made me cry. I expect this will be the best film of 2008, from the short clips alone.

THE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES - Vincent Price does the best neck-acting of any actor ever. Wonderful print for a fun film. Beats SAW's ass, at any rate.

SWEENEY TODD - I was surprised to find out later how divisive this film is among the BNAT crowd. For me, it was rapturous. Johnny Depp channels David Bowie, Helena Bonham Cater's singing's a bit weak but she carries through, and Tim Burton was pretty much born to direct this film. I came away from it very impressed, as this is Burton's best film since ED WOOD.

LONELY ARE THE BRAVE - A fine performance by Kirk Douglas, and a pristine print.

THE POUGHKEEPSIE TAPES - Utter crap. I hear that the marketing department is ramping up on this one, much like BLAIR WITCH, to push this as some sort of "real" documentary about a serial killer in the Northeast who videotapes his murders. Don't buy it. Eli Roth gets too much shit for HOSTEL, in my opinion, because for one thing, HOSTEL's a good movie, with more going on under the surface than people might care to admit. This one has nothing going on except a half-ass effort to try to frighten you. Plus, you'd think a serial killer would update his video gear over the years instead of making crappy fluttering tapes. I actively started rooting against the filmmakers' careers when they brought in the Girl Scouts, for no fucking reason than to try to inflict pain on the audience. I fully expect these guys to be serving me fries by the end of the week. Yeah, I'm a little pissed about it. The best horror has the power to inform, to come to a deeper understanding about yourself through fear, and to have a little fun scaring yourself. This has none of that. Avoid.

TEEN LUST - At this point in the morning, bleached blonde naked titty retards (hey, it all blended in to me) was what the doctor had ordered.

Watching a guy's asshole operated on while listening to Chuck Mangione = priceless.

FAREWELL UNCLE TOM - The most offensive film I've ever seen. Glad I saw it, won't ever see it again. "BECAUSE YOU ARE WHITE!" is my new catchphrase of the year, though.

TRICK R TREAT - Fun, fun, fun. This is how I like my horror, you can guiltlessly scream and laugh at what you're seeing, and I will happily rewatch this film every Halloween. An anthology film directed and written by Michael Dougherty, I really admired how each story touched on the others, and Brian Cox was a blast to watch. Very recommended.

Thanks again to Harry, Tim League, Father Geek, Moriarty, Massawyrm, Quint, Jeff Mahler, Eli Roth, and the rest of the crew for another blast at BNAT. Although some of the events surrounding BNAT this year weren't the best (a lot of cars had their windows broken this year surrouning the Ritz parking lot), this event makes my gay happy and able to endure the rest of my drudgery year. Next year - BNAT X! Have Cartuna do a DEEP THROAT poster!

Nordling


    + Expand All

    Readers Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 12:44:25 PM CST

    Still sounds super cool

    by mukhtabi

    Sometimes you just wish you had better luck. Back to scrounging for food stamps and shreds of coolness in an otherwise dismal and depressing life.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 12:51:56 PM CST

    why 12-18?

    by holodigm

    is that having anything to do with 1-18?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 12:52:35 PM CST

    Nordling

    by jimmyandthetermites

    Thanks for the hospitality (and the moral support) while I was there. It was great meeting you and I'll look forward to next year (fingers crossed).

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 12:59:33 PM CST

    No problem, JimmyandtheTermites

    by nordling

    Happy to meet you.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:02:14 PM CST

    Johny

    by zarles

    Jealous much?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:09:29 PM CST

    Does anyone care?

    by magnum opus

    I mean, anyone who wasn't actually there? Seriously...

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:10:07 PM CST

    Nordling - POUGHKEEPSIE

    by lonegun

    Thanks for the word on THE POUGHKEEPSIE TAPES. I saw a trailer for it at THE MIST. It looked like nothing more than two hours of people being pointlessly, brutally terrorized. I will avoid. TRICK R TREAT, on the other hand, sounds like a blast.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:20:27 PM CST

    Harry, any reason you can't mention the movies...

    by abin sur

    ...that pulled out by name? I think we all know what they were, but are you under a legal arrangement not to say?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:24:05 PM CST

    Too bad it didn't all work out

    by mel gibsteinberg

    Sounds like fate was against you my friend, and yet you still managed to pull together a pretty fun event, from what it sounds like. I think the unfortunate thing is that expectations are always so high for this event, that topping past years becomes a herculean task. One day I'd like to throw my ring in the hat and fly out there to Austin, but for now it's interesting to hear the feedback.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:26:11 PM CST

    Agree with Abin Sur

    by mel gibsteinberg

    What wasn't shown? The FX deal sounded like Cloverfield, and I think the other one was Rambo, but I could be wrong. I Am Legend doesn't seem like something Harry would want to show, but maybe I am wrong. Also, I was hoping to hear about a special trailer for Indy, with some wishes from the Beard or Jones. Guess it wasn't to be.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:40:33 PM CST

    broken windows eh?

    by reynard muldrake

    Missing prints? That's what happens when you call it "BIG TROUBLE in buttnumbathon". A curse. BNAT X should be called: Citizen Butt Numb a Thon.

    Oh and "It, like OLDBOY from BNAT 2003, has the real potential to find a wider audience" - key word being POTENTIAL...I don't remember OLDBOY pullin' in the bank...unless it's virally on DVD. And just hope that people don't confuse/get tired of Mongol cuz of "10,000 BC" or whatever that piece of Emmerich crap is called. Thanks for the updates though, sounds like a fun time!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 1:51:27 PM CST

    Abin Sur

    by headgeek

    Courtesy. However, I'd say they were the top two choices for most of the folks that submitted. I was more bummed about this year's BNAT at start time, than any other in history. I'd worked my ass off - and to have films cancel in the final week is the most painful and agonizing thing as a programmer - that said - we'll still be doing events with the titles - just stand alone events - and the films will be exactly where the filmmakers want them to be -

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:00:25 PM CST

    You read that wrong, RodHolt

    by garbageman33

    They don't hate the Poughkeepsie Tapes. They hate you. Probably because you're a douche.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:03:16 PM CST

    What the hell are you talking about Rod

    by mel gibsteinberg

    There have been multiple reviews, on this site, that explain why this movie sounds so terrible? What more do you need them to say, IT'S GODDAMM SHIT! Isn't that enough?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:04:07 PM CST

    Can you say Cloverfield and Rambo?

    by rubiks doob

    They pulled out faster than

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:08:25 PM CST

    ptapes warning

    by rougetapis

    I've seen it; I knew it was fictional; I quite enjoyed it. All I can say is this, though: MGM is making a HUUUUUGE mistake if they think they will gain fans by marketing this as 'real'. People don't like being duped, and they don't like seeing actual snuff films (which is essentially what this would be if it was 'real'.) There's a huge risk of BWP-style backlash x 1000. DON'T DO IT!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:13:02 PM CST

    Rubiks Doob...yesssss???

    by mel gibsteinberg

    Pulled out faster than...? Couldn't come up with something current? Hot? or Hot and Current?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:17:55 PM CST

    standalone events!!

    by mcjakeg

    So now there will be Alamo events for Rambo, etc? awesome!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:21:11 PM CST

    Thanks Harry...

    by abin sur

    Sorry you guys couldn't see Indy 4 and Justice League! I'm sorry, I mean American Heroes.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:33:07 PM CST

    Cloverfield and Rambo

    by gah

    Is the word on the street.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:34:11 PM CST

    Pulled out faster than...

    by dwide shrewd

    Tom Cruise... realizing he's with a woman.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:35:11 PM CST

    Pulled out faster than...

    by dwide shrewd

    K-Fed... because he never has.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 2:42:08 PM CST

    Oh, and Harry?

    by abin sur

    Can you do some of those future events in Atlanta? I hate having to bug Nick at CHUD for tickets to early screenings. ;)

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 3:13:47 PM CST

    Thank God

    by mel gibsteinberg

    Rod Holt, that douche, is finally gone!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 3:58:07 PM CST

    Carpenter and Russell

    by vwantsrevenge

    Again, why was this BNAT title a reference to Carpenter's movie, but you didn't screen anything by him, with Russell, or the like? That sucks man. And I hate to tell you big fella (soon to be thinner fella), but HD-DVD is going to lose when WB announces it's backing Blu-Ray in January at CES.
    And yes, I own, or have owned, three HD-DVD players, so don't think I'm stumping for BD.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 4:16:34 PM CST

    I ain't about to get involved in a format war discussion.

    by nordling

    I didn't get a free Blu-Ray player this weekend, that's for damn sure, so I'm definitely not qualified to add anything to the debate. I can't wait to hook up my HD-DVD.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 4:42:27 PM CST

    Faster than-

    by rubiks doob

    Use your f-ing imagination. That fast...

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 5:08:12 PM CST

    Next Year....

    by konkrete590

    I will try getting in again next year. Sounds like a fun time. Can't wait until Fantastic Fest next year when I will be driving in from Tampa again for the best week of the year.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 5:14:30 PM CST

    And to everyone that got the HDDVD player

    by konkrete590

    Stardust, Eastern Promises, and Pan's Labrinth come out before the end of the year. Can't wait to get all three in HD!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 5:59:34 PM CST

    Fuck Hostel!

    by atticus finch

    What a boring line-up this year. Its funny to see Harry try to make excuses, though.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 6:36:06 PM CST

    I'm sorry BNAT was a disaster.

    by jrbarker

    Hopefully next year will be better and easier.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 7:21:08 PM CST

    Can't Wait

    by hjd2703

    I was disapointed that I did'nt get into BNAT through stnd-by, but I'm really hoping you do the Rambo and Cloverfield shows at the Drafthouse. I would thank you forever Harry.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 11, 2007 8:51:03 PM CST

    'Two little geek Jews whining', huh?

    by rodneyoz

    As a Jew who unfortunately seems to share your first name, I'm wondering what it takes to have an account cancelled.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 9:30:19 AM CST

    hardly a disaster...

    by grendy

    I had a great time, met lots of new peeps, saw some folks I only get to see once a year, give Tim and Kerrie a gift from us girls in Team BANDIT... and was able to show out a bit with my new ink. I got some great swag, and somehow (thanks to aromatherapy wake-em-up smelly stuff, and some b-vitamin spray) only slept like maybe 10-15 minutes. For a girl who doesn't do caffeine, that is a record for me.
    I loved that we had meat pies during TODD, it made it a 4D experience! Plus, tasty! Kudos to Tim and Kerrie's staff, chefs and waiters, who were even less obtrusive, if possible.
    I said to someone at work here in Atlanta, before leaving, (while trying to describe the wacky that is BNAT) that it is like ' my Superbowl, my World Series and my Monster Truck Pull at all once.' I think that's pretty accurate.
    Plus! - It was me that started the clap-a-long to "Feelin' Good" and having 200 people clapping and laughing at the horror on screen with mouths open in shock was definitely a highlight for me.
    I hope I get to come next year, 'cause Big Red sure knows how to throw a nice party.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 10:01:48 AM CST

    Yes I'm Jealous

    by kingkirby

    I admit it...every year I read these things and am green with envy, because every year I WANT TO BE THERE, and every year I know I'm not going to be able to afford the trip to Austin (a place that I am dying to visit SOMETIME in my life), so I don't even put my name in for consideration. Having said all of that, this year's fun times didn't sound as fun as previous years. I AM dying to see Wall-E (even a 15 min preview) and seeing Dr. Phibes with a group of moviephiles would have been great, but for the most part, everything else sounded just...eh. Don't get me wrong though, I'm still jealous...and when time comes around next year, I will hem and haw and then not enter my name again...and remain envious. So says the King, Baby.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 1:45:47 PM CST

    Hey Grendy

    by seagrass

    I work in Atlanta too...what do you do for a living?

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 1:48:47 PM CST

    I think I saw you in L5P once, Grendy

    by seagrass

    How interesting.

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 3:36:20 PM CST

    KingKirby

    by grendy

    dude... i work at a co-op, a non-profit theatre and a boutique-y place in a vaguely snobby neighborhood. i bust ass for a long time to be able to afford this with the rent on my place and the bills now that i haven't had a roomate in a year. it kinda sucks sometimes, but it is a priority for me to make it to austin for harry's birthday party/moviefuntime bonanza. hell man, i started scouting plane tix in august, knowing that october is the time to submit, and this gave me a concrete goal to try and save up for. i don't know your situation, but i don't think i've ever met anyone who's gone to BNAT and said 'well, that was a waste of my money and time. ' Hells bells, we had people from Sweden, England and France there this year! It was like a WWII high school reunion! 'cept without those Nazi-jockboys ruining everything. Okay... I digress. My point, please, if you want to go, save yer $$. I cashed out a year's worth of change I had saved, paid for my new tattoo and still have some $$ to take to austin with me. That allowed me to buy some folks dinner and lunch who had gotten their windshield smashed out that day, and being able to help them out was grand. For those who said it wasn't good, I disagree. I didn't see the P-Tapes however, I was out in the street dealing with this drunk guy and his smashed-open head and the EMT's. Long story.
    Seagrass... the co-op in L5P is where I work. I am at ext. 113. Come in and ask for me when you're in the 'hood next time. I'd love to meet-n-greet!

    Reply to Talkback

  • Dec 12, 2007 4:43:14 PM CST

    In a perfect world

    by kingkirby

    Thanks Grendy, for rubbing it in (wink). This year was particularly hard with travelling to LA for Celebration IV in May and San Diego for Comic Con in July, and the assorted merchandise at both. Between those and paying off student loans and house payments and a bunch of Sideshow Collectibles (damn you Sideshow!), it certainly wasn't in the cards for this year. I will never say never, however. Atlanta, huh? Another place I hope to visit some year for DragonCon . But if I haven't been able to stretch my pennies to get to Austin from Phoenix, Atlanta is definitely on the backburner! Glad you had a good time, though.

    Reply to Talkback

User Login

Forgot password? Retrieve it here

or register as new user

Quick Talkback Form

Please login to post talkback