Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

TIN MAN SciFi Miniseries:
Is It Missing Brains Or Heart??

I am – Hercules!!

A sci-fi version of “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz” -- from the producers of SciFi’s “Flash Gordon” and the veteran TV writing team of Craig W. Van Sickle and Steve Long Mitchell (“The Pretender,” “She Spies”) – “Tin Man” is a six-hour miniseries about a hot Kansas waitress who finds herself transported to an alternate dimension called “The O.Z.” It stars Zooey Deschanel as “DG,” Kathleen Robertson (who looks a lot like a brunette Kristen Bell) as the witchy “Azkadelia,” Richard Dreyfuss as the wizardly “Mystic Man,” Raoul Trujillo as the furry and cowardly “Raw,” Alan Cumming as the brains-challenged “Glitch,” and Neal McDonough as the hard-hearted title character.

The reviews are not the greatest. Why SciFi continues to greenlight stuff like “Tin Man” and “Flash Gordon” instead of Ron Moore’s “Galactica” prequel “Caprica” or a sequel to the superb “Lost Room” quite vexes the imagination. (For the record, if anybody decides to stick the arresting Deschanel in “Caprica” or “The Other Lost Room,” you’ll hear no complaints from these quarters.)

Entertainment Weekly gives “Tin Man” a “C-plus” and says:

… Robertson's heaving bodice is her most expressive aspect; this miniseries needed a villain with a wicked sense of humor, but she and the rest of Tin Man are dour and punitive. There's violence and torture courtesy of Azkadellia's Nazi-like ''Longcoat'' brigade. And there's the overworked theme of abandonment …

TV Guide says:

… more of a lavishly quirky curiosity than a keeper. …

USA Today gives it two and a half stars (out of four) and says:

… Ambitious and intriguing though it may be, Tin Man is simply too long, too grim and too determined to impose a Lord of the Rings universe-saving quest on top of a simpler, gentler story. No offense to Kansas, but any Oz film that makes you long for Dorothy to get back to that farm is a film in serious need of lightening up.

The New York Times says:

… A big, sonorous dungeons-and-dragons affair that seems at every moment to call attention to its epicness, “Tin Man” would have benefited above all from more minimizing. It runs over three nights and is too long by a few hours. …

The Los Angeles Times says:

… To say that "Tin Man" is not as good as its near-perfect models is not to damn it, even faintly. Like Sci Fi's "Flash Gordon" update -- which the Halmis also produce and which it resembles far more than it does "The Wizard of Oz" -- it's a good-looking, entertaining fantasy adventure, with a cast that is easy to spend time with. I can see where Deschanel's sleepy delivery (quite like her sister Emily's, over on Fox's "Bones") might not work on everyone, but I find her excellent company, and Alan Cumming is sweet in the Ray Bolger mode as the Scarecrow-substitute, Glitch. …

The Washington Post says:

… If the filmmakers had themselves a heap of fun putting this mishmosh together, that doesn't come through in the finished work. The pacing is largely funereal, with characters such as that meanie-Queenie not having much to do but stand around posing. In the crucial role of DG, however, Zooey Deschanel (daughter of gifted director and cinematographer Caleb Deschanel) is saucy and captivating and has seductively expressive eyes. …

The Chicago Tribune says:

… "Tin Man's" heart is in the right place, even if the execution of the story evokes, from time to time, creakiness of the metal man's limbs. Among the more winning aspects about this fanciful mini-series are its propulsive plot and the way it rearranges key elements of Baum's tale. If it's not as complex or slickly executed as the most ambitious cable fare, "Tin Man," which arrives as the TV season heads into its rerun-filled doldrums, provides a colorful, imaginative, popcorn-friendly serial -- with all the flying monkeys you could ever want. …

The Chicago Sun-Times says:

… The dialogue is utilitarian, except when it's "Dungeons and Dragons" cliche, like: "We're travelers of the realms seeking a warm meal and a cold cup of grog. ... May your hearth be warm." Puke. The actors look rushed to stay on production schedule. The direction and camera shots are workaday. The pace of "Tin Man" reminds me of tortured, role-playing video games … at six hours, it feels four hours too long. So if you're interested, record it and watch it on fast-forward. You can hit pause for the evil flying monkey boobs.

The San Diego Union-Tribune says:

… the only magical thing about “Tin Man” is its amazing ability to make six hours pass like six days. … Neither the scripts nor the colorless directing do the actresses any favors, but without an empathetic heroine to love and a fire-breathing villainess to loathe, “Tin Man” is just a rattletrap special-effects vehicle on its way to nowhere. Feel free to let it wheeze on down the road without you.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer says:

… As long as we get a good time out of it, darkness is a welcome guest and the first night of this miniseries keeps that end of the bargain, starting with our introduction to DG (Zooey Deschanel). … Night two, the tale loses its spirited humor and tumbles into the minutiae of DG's obscure past. "Tin Man" is an example of what happens when a story that should be told in two nights, and four hours, is stretched out to three and six. …

The San Jose Mercury News says:

… there is a distinct lack of emotional oomph emanating from this dark, disjointed and humorless miniseries, which too often seems preoccupied with special-effects magic and oh-aren't-we-clever twists on Baum's characters. As a result, you might want to take a pass on this particular Oz fest. …

The Knoxville News Sentinel says:

… can never truly stand on its own. In attempting to do something different with a classic, "Tin Man" has virtually lost its soul. The miniseries has no fun with its situation and no spark of playfulness. Instead, it's merely stark, moody and cold. And when that can be said of "Oz," then why bother?…

The Boston Globe says:

… a dour retelling of the L. Frank Baum story, and it just keeps sinking further and further into pointless thematic complexity and visual density. A test of viewer endurance, this effects-bound miniseries is a hollow tin man in need of a beating heart.

The Hollywood Reporter says:

… while the preening and the chewed scenery from the cast are at times glorious to behold, there is no substance to wrap our heads around, no one to really root for. It's just a peculiar, occasionally arresting and wholly funky attempt to bring a measure of contemporary fantasy/sci-fi hip to a tale we want to be neither hip nor self-aware. But trust me that the thing is every ounce a thinly veiled "Wizard of Oz" update. If it only had a brain, a heart and the nerve. …

Variety says:

… a bit of a mess. Sci Fi has done well with minis in December, but despite the intriguing concept three consecutive nights of this adventure falls several Yellow Bricks shy of a load. … does weave in an endless assortment of puns and knowing asides, including a few that appear directly aimed at Friends of Dorothy. Ultimately, though, that's small compensation for embarking on this extended journey. … if it only had a brain.

9 p.m. Sunday, Monday & Tuesday. SciFi.









$19.99!!!!

67% OFF!!



WARNER BROS.' EVER-EVOLVING TV SALE!!
$10.99 Extras 1.x-2.x (63% OFF!!)
$13.99 Curb Your Enthusiasm 4.x (65% OFF!!
$13.99 Entourage 1.x (65% OFF)
$14.99 Smallville 1.x-5.x (75% OFF!!)
$14.99 Veronica Mars 1.x-2.x (75% OFF!!)
$14.99 The West Wing 2.x/4.x/5.x (75% OFF!!)
$17.99 Nip/Tuck 1.x-2.x (70% OFF!!)
$19.99 Carnivale 1.x-2.x (67% OFF!!)
$19.99 ER 6.x-7.x (60% OFF!!)
$19.99 From The Earth To The Moon (67% OFF!!)
$19.99 Six Feet Under 1.x-5.x (67% OFF!!)
$21.99 The Sopranos 3.x (63% OFF!!)
$21.99 The Wire 1.x (63% OFF!!)
$23.99 Gilmore Girls 1.x-6.x (60% OFF!!)


Justice League:

New Frontier!!!!

$13.99 One-Disc Edition!!
$16.99 Two-Disc Edition!!
$19.99 HD-DVD or Blu-ray!!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Longcoat Brigrade?
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
02:35:48 AM
2ND!
by closeencounter
Dec 2nd, 2007
02:46:39 AM
I MEAN 3RD!!
by closeencounter
Dec 2nd, 2007
02:47:04 AM
Remember
by Purgatori
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:03:26 AM
FLYING MONKEYS WITH BOOBS
by duchuvney_post_x
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:47:02 AM
SCI-FI NEEDS TO SORT ITSELF OUT!
by IAmMrMonkey!
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:48:30 AM
Herc is asking for a flame war.
by LordEnigma
Dec 2nd, 2007
04:08:13 AM
Hot Kansas waitress teleports to prison OZ
by Aloy
Dec 2nd, 2007
04:10:51 AM
I'll check it out if only for the cast
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
04:18:43 AM
Oh there are flying monkyes... with boobs...
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:00:18 AM
ouch, what a waste
by newc0253
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:07:05 AM
The O.Z.?
by Son of Hades
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:12:02 AM
rom the producers of SciFi’s “Flash Gordon”
by palewook
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:32:44 AM
Snowpuff to defend SciFi channel???
by snowpuff
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:40:11 AM
"a little more fun and silly?"
by newc0253
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:07:27 AM
I SUPPORT ZOOEY ON MY LAP!
by chrth
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:08:30 AM
hellboy 2 theater lobby poster
by palewook
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:18:32 AM
"Heaving bodice", eh?
by tonagan
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:31:08 AM
'Superb' Lost Room?
by NudeandAroused
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:33:31 AM
Lost Room was real good
by optimus122
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:38:51 AM
How disappointing.
by The Visco Kid
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:56:02 AM
Lost Room was surprisingly good.
by rbatty024
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:33:09 AM
Lost Room is exactly what SciFi should be doing more of..
by commiepinko
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:21:49 AM
Hey I know! How about BS Season 3 on DVD for the Holidays!
by Stormwatcher
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:23:46 AM
Wow those reviews are bad.
by Omar B
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:34:20 AM
Poor Richard Dreyfuss
by rsswope
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:39:59 AM
Richard Dreyfus was in "TIN MEN" with Danny DeVito.
by Uncapie
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:45:05 AM
"Welcome to the O.Z, btich!"
by biggerjohn
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:51:22 AM
Should have remade The Wiz
by Anakin Whoopass
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:05:10 AM
Sci-Fi has lost its way
by Magma Suit
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:16:09 AM
I saw this...
by Boxcutter
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:20:35 PM
from the producers of SciFi’s “Flash Gordon”
by INWOsuxRED
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:23:10 PM
I record Flash Gordon...
by chromedome
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:42:14 PM
SciFi doesn't "re-imagine"
by chromedome
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:43:49 PM
de-image
by INWOsuxRED
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:45:26 PM
grog THIS, scifi!
by chromedome
Dec 2nd, 2007
12:53:50 PM
Missing brains? Heart? How about some BALLS?!
by Uncapie
Dec 2nd, 2007
01:30:08 PM
Didnt Sci-Fi get rid of MST3K?
by canvasseamonkey
Dec 2nd, 2007
01:36:03 PM
Lost Room was good.
by veritasses
Dec 2nd, 2007
02:51:29 PM
Get Zooey back to WEEDS
by crayon
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:34:58 PM
Richard Dreyfuss belts-out the classic song,
by thegreatwhatzit
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:36:31 PM
Yes, Sci-Fi dumped MST3K...
by thegreatwhatzit
Dec 2nd, 2007
03:40:23 PM
Eureka and Flash Gordon
by oisin5199
Dec 2nd, 2007
04:00:41 PM
Purgatori & 'Invisible Man
by Genre_Boy
Dec 2nd, 2007
04:30:48 PM
Scifi's Flash Gordon is the worst series to ever grace my TV!
by Orionsangels
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:06:46 PM
Why do people make stupid shit like this?
by spaceworlder
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:57:00 PM
Bring back The Lost Room!!!
by Kasch
Dec 2nd, 2007
05:59:14 PM
Lost Room, Flash and Tin man
by NudeandAroused
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:11:52 PM
I liked Lost Room!
by snowpuff
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:20:23 PM
Scifi channel doesn't run scifi?
by i.baronvladimir
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:30:29 PM
The Lost Room was NOT garbage!
by IAmMrMonkey!
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:34:28 PM
I only have one question
by WYLD STALLYNS RULES
Dec 2nd, 2007
06:48:46 PM
GOD DAMN IT
by brokenheadstuff
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:23:55 PM
My favorite Sci Fi Channel film was "Braveheart!"
by Uncapie
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:25:29 PM
brokenheadstuff
by WYLD STALLYNS RULES
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:53:59 PM
why doesn't
by redshirt
Dec 2nd, 2007
07:59:04 PM
Annnnndddd... I'm out.
by ZeroCorpse
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:17:25 PM
Lost Room
by Mr_X
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:17:37 PM
NudeandAroused
by Mr_X
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:23:39 PM
SciFi blows...
by SG7
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:24:29 PM
physios = physics
by Mr_X
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:24:31 PM
Why does everything have to ripoff Star Wars...
by TheRealSeveren
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:24:47 PM
I'm trying to watch this...
by Almega
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:28:20 PM
Lost Room
by Gislef_crow
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:30:03 PM
Is Zooey stoned or...
by localhero12
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:42:19 PM
Boring
by IronSpidey
Dec 2nd, 2007
08:43:24 PM
Looks like garbage.
by Mister Man
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:06:08 PM
Sci Fi is dead, that's why it's clinging to Galactica like a pro
by performingmonkey
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:21:52 PM
Tivo Season Pass Manager-->
by SifoDyasJr.
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:35:52 PM
Speaking of Dark Oz MOvies
by Aquatarkusman
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:41:28 PM
Who are the Flash Gordon people blackmailing?
by jccalhoun
Dec 2nd, 2007
09:54:38 PM
Alan Cumming turns into Nightcrawler in Part 2?
by localhero12
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:06:08 PM
I HEART Kathleen Robertson...
by Abin Sur
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:08:05 PM
SO WHAT YER SAYING IS TIN MAN IS NOT AWESOME?
by Pennsy
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:10:04 PM
yikes
by DeadPanWalking
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:26:14 PM
I wish Zooey was in RESTAURANT AT THE END OF THE UNIVERSE...
by SpyGuy
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:41:08 PM
I'd rather read 'Wicked' again
by DOGSOUP
Dec 2nd, 2007
10:54:37 PM
Anyone else think the music was from stargate?
by jccalhoun
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:02:48 PM
I like "Wicked" the musical AND the book
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:07:45 PM
I missed seeing this tonight, did I just dodge a bullet?
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:09:59 PM
I hate singing narrative.
by DOGSOUP
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:23:12 PM
redshirt
by INWOsuxRED
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:25:11 PM
How much better is Space compared to Sci-Fi?
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 2nd, 2007
11:28:29 PM
it ok, but no Return to Oz
by BMacSmith
Dec 3rd, 2007
12:02:13 AM
I DVR'd it and fell asleep during the replay
by Squashua
Dec 3rd, 2007
12:25:27 AM
Return to Oz
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 3rd, 2007
01:08:47 AM
if anyone should be allowed to remake the wizard of oz....
by GavinVanDraven
Dec 3rd, 2007
01:32:03 AM
Return to Oz review
by NomoredirtyjokespleaseweareYan ks
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:22:19 AM
Return to Oz is good though.....
by NomoredirtyjokespleaseweareYan ks
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:24:21 AM
thanks NomoredirtyjokespleaseweareYan ks
by Spifftacular Squirrel Girl
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:31:37 AM
I'm not sure if Tin Man sucked or not
by MattmanReturns
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:43:33 AM
If S-F wanted to just waste some money
by The Selecter
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:47:54 AM
can they make each yellow brick as boring as possible?
by duchuvney_post_x
Dec 3rd, 2007
03:42:28 AM
Why does Sci-Fi keep giving money to these ass clowns!
by Batutta
Dec 3rd, 2007
08:39:45 AM
"Why SciFi continues to greenlight stuff...
by Kid Z
Dec 3rd, 2007
09:19:06 AM
I enjoyed it
by lonecow
Dec 3rd, 2007
09:32:18 AM
It was good
by BossGuy
Dec 3rd, 2007
10:09:05 AM
Dear SciFi
by Neil Peart
Dec 3rd, 2007
10:35:43 AM
It was called Tin Man......why?
by ToughGuyRizzo
Dec 3rd, 2007
11:37:24 AM
The reason why it was called Tin Man...
by jccalhoun
Dec 3rd, 2007
12:42:46 PM
Dear Sci Fi, All I want fo Christmas...
by Stark Industries
Dec 3rd, 2007
12:49:47 PM
I'll wait for the DVD... Maybe it will be
by Stark Industries
Dec 3rd, 2007
12:54:37 PM
Lost Room
by PVIII
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:02:01 PM
Butchered in Post Production
by MGTHEDJ
Dec 3rd, 2007
02:47:43 PM
Jccalhoun
by ToughGuyRizzo
Dec 3rd, 2007
08:41:24 PM
There's one thing the Wizard didn't have to give THIS Tin Man
by Mister Man
Dec 3rd, 2007
10:37:27 PM
Zooey Deschanel’s acting is complete ass.
by Masteel
Dec 3rd, 2007
10:48:02 PM
It sucks.
by Freddie Mercury
Dec 3rd, 2007
11:10:55 PM
And Ghosthunters.
by Freddie Mercury
Dec 3rd, 2007
11:11:43 PM
They find lots of things.....
by Ka Dargo
Dec 4th, 2007
12:03:35 AM
tinman ratings
by palewook
Dec 4th, 2007
06:18:01 PM
Other than Galactica, is there anything on Sci-Fi...
by conspiracy
Dec 4th, 2007
06:33:05 PM
jccalhoun, i was actually just thinking that
by The Dude Abides
Dec 4th, 2007
06:42:30 PM
Even I was mislead into this....
by localhero12
Dec 4th, 2007
09:29:58 PM
Meant "Even though I was..."
by localhero12
Dec 4th, 2007
09:32:15 PM
is she going to creat a portal?
by The Dude Abides
Dec 4th, 2007
09:49:45 PM
After seeing all 3 parts, I gotta say......
by zillabeast
Dec 5th, 2007
12:05:46 AM
Good ideas, noty so well executed. Sounds like most of what
by CrichtonAstronut
Dec 5th, 2007
11:57:56 AM
It wasn't just that the concept for Flash Gordon had been done b
by CrichtonAstronut
Dec 5th, 2007
12:02:54 PM
They lost the plot when they cancelled Farscape!
by Gremlin517
Dec 5th, 2007
02:47:24 PM
After seeing all 6 hours
by MGTHEDJ
Dec 5th, 2007
07:38:08 PM
Sci Fi is losing it.
by Blackguard
Dec 5th, 2007
11:07:53 PM
Farscape...
by MaelstromZa
Dec 6th, 2007
04:40:42 AM
I Liked it.
by Mundungus
Dec 8th, 2007
02:18:24 AM
Why you ask?
by Mundungus
Dec 8th, 2007
02:43:27 AM
WHY?
by homer65
Dec 8th, 2007
05:14:07 PM
Worth watching
by Dazzler69
Dec 10th, 2007
07:11:48 AM
This is the network that brings you...
by impossibledreamers
Dec 18th, 2007
09:57:35 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.