Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Harry boards the 3:10 TO YUMA and it's headed for Hell!!!

When you take a month and a half off – travel the country – I can’t tell you how hard it is to get back into the mode of writing about film. Don’t get me wrong, I love writing about film, it’s just for the last month and a half, I got used to doing other things first, choosing to plan things first, drive a few hundred miles first, go get my tuxedo first, etc, etc etc…

Well, on the final day of the Rolling Roadshow trip – Yoko and I pulled into Austin at about 4:47am - that day we’d left Atlanta, driven to Texarkana to watch SMOKEY & THE BANDIT – then decided we didn’t want to sleep in another hotel for as long as we could help it. So we drove from Texarkana to Austin. Then, about 40 miles out of Austin, Quint messages me that I’m making it just in time for 3:10 TO YUMA the next day at 3pm.

Talk about jumping right back into the heat of things. And with a movie I was dying to see. So we got home, unpacked – played with our Nazi dog – each took showers then passed way the hell out. Woke up the next day to have lunch at our favorite restaurant then head to the Alamo South for 3:10 TO YUMA.

This was the first film back from the “not a Honeymoon” trip – first press screening as a married man – and there was something awesome about it being a rougher than a burlap sack, rugged as Jack Palance’s face sort of western.

If studios want to know why Westerns, as a genre, haven’t been huge moneymakers for the past few decades – it’s a pretty simple thing to put a finger on.

With the PC-ification of the United States history – it is next to impossible to make anyone but the United States itself, the bad guy. Can’t have blood-thirsty Indians, guns are bad evil things, you must show that it takes forever to get anywhere in the old west on horseback. So the films are all about how wonderful wide open spaces are, how beautiful nature is – and not at all how badass it was to fucking be a gun slinging six-shooter in the old west that was filled with certain death.

The Western has been a toothless, clawless old hag of a genre for way too long. This is our SAMURAI movies – and the swords cut, the blood flies and the heroes are quiet men whose actions speak louder than words.

3:10 TO YUMA by James Mangold is exactly the sort of Western I have wanted to see get made for a very long time. Just a gritty western world filled with men that’d kill ya faster than they would see ya. A Western filled with cowards and men of principle. Men with a code and men with no code.

I’m tired of the aging decaying West. I want that mythical west were actions were turned into Penny Dreadfuls with lurid acts on every cover. When 50 miles was a quick horse ride – and stagecoaches had gattlin’ guns.

Elmore Leonard’s 3:10 TO YUMA was, for me, always a variation upon HIGH NOON. It was all about an impending deadline that could not be escaped. A situation where no man was your friend… and all men knew you were a walking tombstone. It’s a Kobayashi Maru sort of fucked situation. You can’t win, there’s no Kirk way out of rewriting the game – it was simply fucking an impossible shit situation.

That’s 3:10 TO YUMA. It doesn’t feel that bad for most of it. Taking a prisoner to a train. But the closer you get, the harder it gets. And then there’s one point where something happens that just makes everyone around you turn yellow. What is fascinating at that point is what keeps your hero, the hero. What is he holding on to? Why not give up? Usually in film, it’s because the writer wrote him to be a hero. There’s nothing more to it than that, but here… here Bale isn’t a hero. He’s never been a hero. In his oldest son’s eyes, he’s a coward – worse, he’s a cripple turned coward – scared of risks, terrified to do anything. Here – Bale is watching his son at that precipice – between good and evil and his own life doesn’t add up to a sack of manure, but if that life can be laid down as fertilizer for his son’s to bloom from, then fighting isn’t an option, it’s the only path in front of him.

James Mangold has created a modern classic western. I love the Glenn Ford and Van Heflin version – but it doesn’t have the grit of this. This film is just mean. The cast overall is vastly superior to the original. It isn’t just Bale and Crowe – it’s everyone else. But for me – the real stand out is Ben Foster.

Who?

Warren Worthington III – The Angel from X3. In that film, his character had shit to do. Here – he’s Russell Crowe’s second. His number one man on his team of badasses. In a million years, I never would have thought that the actor that played the Angel in Brett Hackner’s X3 would be worth spitting at, but in 3:10 TO YUMA – he is – THE SHIT! His Charlie Prince is just awesome. He’s death on a horse. He is that loyal sidekick that isn’t lame in the slightest. He’s loyal unto death – and is the face of determined badassness.

I’m about to write up THE ASSASSINATION OF JESSE JAMES BY THE COWARD ROBERT FORD – and these two films couldn’t be further apart in any way – other than quality. They’re both brilliant westerns – but don’t resemble each other in the slightest. That is what rules about The Western. They’re about totally different themes, totally different film styles. In 3:10 TO YUMA – you have a western score that makes you want to throw away the keys to your gas-guzzler and mount up.

This is the best kind of remake, one filled with passion, excitement and exemplary performances from top to bottom. This is my favorite kickass western since THE OUTLAW JOSEY WALES – note the word – “since”. It really is that good!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Yes!!
by BetaRayBill07
Sep 4th, 2007
03:52:31 PM
Oh Sorry, by the way...
by BetaRayBill07
Sep 4th, 2007
03:56:53 PM
Con Panel was great
by powervideo
Sep 4th, 2007
03:57:46 PM
First review in two months
by feckdrinkarse
Sep 4th, 2007
04:06:20 PM
Unforgiven?
by monkeymafia
Sep 4th, 2007
04:08:20 PM
Best film of the year thus far
by Liberty Valance
Sep 4th, 2007
04:11:12 PM
Sounds great.
by LoneGun
Sep 4th, 2007
04:23:51 PM
Russell Crowe shoots Ben Foster to save Christian Bale
by Garbageman33
Sep 4th, 2007
04:28:57 PM
headed for hell???
by ketchuplover
Sep 4th, 2007
04:29:48 PM
A Harry "review"
by Lando Griffin
Sep 4th, 2007
04:30:02 PM
PC America? Ruined Westerns?
by Guy Gaduois
Sep 4th, 2007
04:35:32 PM
Saw the sneak preview on sunday.
by Bullet_time_Facehugger
Sep 4th, 2007
04:41:14 PM
Ben Foster Who?
by Yum Yum Gibson
Sep 4th, 2007
05:11:02 PM
Agree about Ben Foster
by buffywrestling
Sep 4th, 2007
05:25:49 PM
2 reviews in one day!!!!
by Turd Furgeson
Sep 4th, 2007
06:05:23 PM
I had to come back
by abner pepper
Sep 4th, 2007
06:18:09 PM
I didn't even know Foster was in this
by CherryValance
Sep 4th, 2007
06:25:42 PM
how bout since Dead Man
by fish tacos
Sep 4th, 2007
06:45:44 PM
You'd doubt Ben Foster?
by Darkman
Sep 4th, 2007
06:58:45 PM
Home, Home on the Range
by Ace of Wands
Sep 4th, 2007
07:03:55 PM
Ben Foster was good in Alpha Dog
by StreetTrash
Sep 4th, 2007
07:19:58 PM
Hey Harry Knowles....
by The Real McClane
Sep 4th, 2007
07:52:13 PM
Credit where credit is due
by Shad0wfax
Sep 4th, 2007
08:10:11 PM
Thought it was predictable
by The Funketeer
Sep 4th, 2007
08:16:38 PM
Harry, we know who Ben Foster is.
by Lenny Nero
Sep 4th, 2007
09:21:38 PM
What was wrong with Dances with Wolves?
by J-Dizzle
Sep 4th, 2007
10:20:00 PM
Was it excellent, or was I just starved?
by Pabodie
Sep 4th, 2007
10:32:16 PM
Could have been better...
by scrivener
Sep 4th, 2007
10:38:20 PM
did Harry not see Hostage?
by Holodigm
Sep 4th, 2007
10:49:27 PM
He was great in Alpha Dog!
by Midol Boy
Sep 4th, 2007
11:06:45 PM
Nitpick much, scrivener?
by Liberty Valance
Sep 4th, 2007
11:56:15 PM
PC-fication my arse!
by Steve T
Sep 5th, 2007
03:31:21 AM
the problem wasn't the PC-ification of history
by gobofraggleuk
Sep 5th, 2007
09:20:06 AM
Holy shit...
by PirateEmery
Sep 5th, 2007
11:01:23 AM
Should have been PG-13.
by PirateEmery
Sep 5th, 2007
11:04:31 AM
Return to form?
by mozman
Sep 5th, 2007
11:37:23 AM
And that's how I like my westerns, gobofraggleuk.
by Blue_Demon
Sep 5th, 2007
11:41:27 AM
Totally agree Shad0wfax
by Swiss Trev
Sep 5th, 2007
12:34:11 PM
Totally agree Shad0wfax
by Swiss Trev
Sep 5th, 2007
12:34:36 PM
hmmm...DeadWood, DeadWood....
by Swiss Trev
Sep 5th, 2007
12:35:52 PM
Ben Foster
by The Funketeer
Sep 5th, 2007
12:49:23 PM
Yeah, but samurais are so much cooler than
by comedian_x
Sep 5th, 2007
12:57:30 PM
Double Feature
by Fineus Fog
Sep 5th, 2007
04:24:34 PM
Remake Magnificent Seven next
by Raymar
Sep 5th, 2007
09:29:21 PM
Raymar
by Strabo
Sep 5th, 2007
10:29:24 PM
Interview with "3:10 to Yuma" co-star Logan Lerman
by pacino33
Sep 5th, 2007
11:08:16 PM
Ben Foster has been an underappreciated actor for YEARS
by ShiftyEyedDog2
Sep 6th, 2007
03:31:52 PM
scrivener
by jfp2007
Sep 7th, 2007
06:21:35 AM
hell yeah
by cahcat
Sep 7th, 2007
12:55:45 PM
I didn't get the same vibe that you did
by CherryValance
Sep 7th, 2007
03:54:34 PM
I was with this movie guys..buttttttttt..(*(SPOILER! !*)
by Rich Malone
Sep 8th, 2007
02:31:03 AM
gaps in logic
by alcester
Sep 9th, 2007
09:48:44 AM
I remember Ben Foster in Freaks and Geeks
by JOHNRCASHFAN
Sep 9th, 2007
07:46:46 PM
PC my ass...it's called the truth.
by Bronx Cheer
Sep 9th, 2007
08:43:08 PM
@rich malone
by at0mic-r0ach
Sep 9th, 2007
11:03:53 PM
Two Thirds Classic, One Third Heavily Flawed
by Roboteer
Sep 11th, 2007
07:44:45 AM
Great Performances Overcome Lame Ending
by Dresh
Sep 11th, 2007
04:35:48 PM
Agree with Rich Malone
by tcbonline
Sep 11th, 2007
04:41:04 PM
Gosh, Harry...
by theJackalope
Sep 11th, 2007
05:44:59 PM
Showers
by neptunesblood
Sep 11th, 2007
11:31:28 PM
3:10 to Yuma is flawed but still very good
by Rupee88
Sep 12th, 2007
03:23:48 PM
Not regrettable, but not great
by strosmer
Sep 12th, 2007
07:59:21 PM
Too bad!
by MaxDembo1
Sep 13th, 2007
03:09:58 AM
Garbageman33 is a fuking kunt
by Bishop6
Sep 13th, 2007
09:55:25 AM
the ending makes total sense
by CherryValance
Sep 13th, 2007
10:43:14 PM
Strangest. Cameo. Ever.
by WYLD STALLYNS RULES
Sep 14th, 2007
12:58:35 AM
I'm sorry, I also had major problems with the ending.
by Daddylonghead
Sep 15th, 2007
02:14:58 AM
Question about Ebert's review.
by Daddylonghead
Sep 15th, 2007
02:22:28 AM
Well I was always partial to...
by Big Dan
Sep 15th, 2007
10:13:39 AM
Explaining The Ending (Heavy Spoilers!)
by Cranston-Is-The-Shadow
Sep 15th, 2007
10:08:16 PM
Big Fat Homosexual Movie Nerds Gush Over Christian Bale
by Bill Maher
Sep 16th, 2007
10:47:15 AM
Thank you, CherryValance
by one9deuce
Sep 21st, 2007
06:15:15 PM
Just saw it a moment ago
by StarBlitzer
Sep 24th, 2007
11:50:33 PM
Daddylonghead
by Proevad
Sep 27th, 2007
07:46:24 PM
The mysterious ending explained
by MattmanReturns
Sep 28th, 2007
01:30:10 AM
And Crowe's last line in the movie
by MattmanReturns
Sep 28th, 2007
01:38:29 AM
That's what I thought, MattmannReurns
by Daddylonghead
Sep 29th, 2007
11:23:21 AM
There was a big clue in the beginning
by MattmanReturns
Sep 29th, 2007
04:56:16 PM
3:10 to Yuma and breach and Clayton
by emeraldboy
Oct 1st, 2007
12:03:44 PM
A REAL WESTERN!
by williamD
Oct 20th, 2007
06:54:10 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.