Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

An Early Reaction To Joe Wright’s ATONEMENT! McAvoy and Knightley and Redgrave, Oh My!

Hey, everyone. ”Moriarty” here.

Second films are important these days for directors because that’s where you start to define yourself. Are you a one-trick pony? Do you have something to say from film to film, with a real voice? I wasn’t crazy about Joe Wright’s PRIDE & PREJUDICE, but many people were. This time out, he’s working from a more contemporary piece of fiction, adapting the Ian McEwan novel that is, honestly, one of those books that is so much about the use of language as it is the story and the characters that it seems unadaptable to me. I think Wright’s going to really have to step up his game as a filmmaker to do justice to this novel.

And to be fair, much of what I’m hearing so far is that people like what they’re seeing. Like this guy, for example...

Hey Harry

Greetings from rainy Britain!

The summer's gloom has been lifted by the new movie 'Atonement' - director Joe Wright's next movie after the successful 'Pride and Prejudice'. I saw a preview yesterday at the Picture House in Stratford upon Avon. The new movie is released on 7th September in the UK and 7th December in the US.

I guess from your site you have seen the trailer so you will have a little feel for what it's about. It's based on Ian McEwan's novel of 2001 and spans three time periods. The first is set at an English country house in 1935 when a servant's son Robbie Turner played by James McAvoy (Last King of Scotland) has an affair with the daughter of the house Cecilia (Keira Knightley) and then is wrongly accused by Cecilia's sister Briony of assaulting a younger girl and ends up in prison. We move forward to 1940 France and the defeated British Army's struggle to evacuate from Dunkirk and Robbie's adventures as a soldier. Vanessa Redgrave plays the older version of Briony at the end in 1999.

I cannot explain in words just what a fine piece of film-making this is. I was moved, I laughed but most of all gripped by a wonderful story brilliantly played by a superb ensemble cast. The highlight for me is the 5 minute tracking shot following Robbie and his mates along the beach at Dunkirk. It's one of the most powerful scenes I have ever seen and I cried - not something I regularly do in the cinema being a grumpy 51 year old Brit!! I'm crying now just thinking about it.

I managed to get on the set last summer when they were filming the country house scenes near where I work. You can see the house here.

Hope this is of interest. Maybe you have already received positive reports from other people who saw the preview. I'm going again on Tuesday next week and it's opening the Venice film Festival on 29th August.

This site has some great stuff about the movie so check it out.

People are talking about Oscars for this one so hope they right as Joe and his crew deserve some reward.

Best wishes,
Tim King
Shrewsbury UK

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

IAM IN IT
by connor187
Aug 26th, 2007
06:15:08 AM
AND FIRST IT SEEMS...
by connor187
Aug 26th, 2007
06:15:50 AM
About that tracking shot....
by connor187
Aug 26th, 2007
06:33:38 AM
Could've seen this on Thursday
by barnaby jones
Aug 26th, 2007
06:44:23 AM
Keira Knightley
by kwisatzhaderach
Aug 26th, 2007
07:51:47 AM
the trailer
by Diablo77
Aug 26th, 2007
08:32:12 AM
That tracking shot...
by the_con
Aug 26th, 2007
08:56:32 AM
Ye Olde Plante
by FlipTheFrog
Aug 26th, 2007
09:25:27 AM
Right-o, jolly old Plant, wot?
by InspectorDoppler
Aug 26th, 2007
09:45:29 AM
Me... a plant?
by the_con
Aug 26th, 2007
10:04:06 AM
PRIDE AND PREJUDICE was great.
by Blue Meanie 1138
Aug 26th, 2007
11:03:09 AM
Keira Knightley has chosen HD-DVD, and here's why:
by Pound Sand
Aug 26th, 2007
11:10:13 AM
Those of you shouting PLANT .....
by barnaby jones
Aug 26th, 2007
12:02:10 PM
kwisatzhaderach
by Thomas Cromwell
Aug 26th, 2007
12:20:57 PM
You know you're probably going to make it .............
by Riccardogogo
Aug 26th, 2007
12:56:11 PM
"You'll love the tracking shot" - the guy IN THE MOVIE!
by BMacSmith
Aug 26th, 2007
01:01:18 PM
This movie will be intriguing for me to see how...
by Vamp-AICNchat
Aug 26th, 2007
02:46:12 PM
Does Kiera get naked or no?!?!?!
by blue1622
Aug 26th, 2007
02:56:22 PM
I'd Really Like To See That...
by skoobyx
Aug 26th, 2007
06:40:46 PM
oh i would
by occula
Aug 26th, 2007
07:10:23 PM
Can't Act For Shit
by albermarle
Aug 26th, 2007
09:36:44 PM
This sounds like a press agent review...
by AnnoyYou
Aug 26th, 2007
10:04:32 PM
Keira Knightly: a fine piece of ass who can act
by BrowncoatJedi
Aug 27th, 2007
12:08:44 AM
Pride and Prejudice
by Abhimanyu
Aug 27th, 2007
12:47:06 AM
Yeah, I'll watch this.
by Jakes Nel
Aug 27th, 2007
06:25:22 AM
Keira
by Fromin
Aug 27th, 2007
12:06:51 PM
Looking Forward to This One
by anabanana
Aug 27th, 2007
12:42:57 PM
Empire online has the info on said shot.
by connor187
Aug 27th, 2007
02:31:59 PM
I'm also in this film
by jackalcack
Aug 27th, 2007
03:05:40 PM
i must have sex with this girl
by El Borak
Aug 27th, 2007
09:05:20 PM
Can't wait to see ATONEMENT.
by LoneGun
Aug 28th, 2007
08:31:10 AM
Oh giant overgrown PLANT
by Cat_Corporation
Aug 28th, 2007
10:33:24 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.