Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Memflix chimes in on HARRY POTTER AND THE ORDER OF THE PHOENIX!!!

Ahoy, squirts! Quint here. Memflix here sent this in a couple days ago, but the internet gods tried to kill it with some messed up text switcheroo in the email. We defeated them, though and now Memflix's words can be shouted from the mountaintops! Enjoy!

This is Memflix returning with a look at “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.” It has been close to impossible these days to see a film before it opens (understandably so). However, a theater outside my former employer’s chain let me attend a screening. (Thanks!)

I don’t usually do this, but since the trailers in front of “Phoenix,” were all new with the exception of one, I wanted to give my thoughts.

In front of the film were looks at “Get Smart” and “10,000 B.C.,” as well as a “Fred Claus” Trailer 1 (a teaser was released late last year).

The year-early look at “Claus,” made the combination of Paul Giamatti and Vince Vaughn as Santa Claus and his brother, respectively, look promising. This second look takes all the promise and flushes it down the drain. Not a snicker, not a guffaw, nothing remotely resembling laughter was expressed on my face. The premise of Santa Claus as a ‘prodigal’ son of sorts seems to have been thrown out for cheap infantile humor. ‘Fred Claus’ was teetering on my ‘must-see list,’ but Trailer 1 checked it of (don’t worry, not going to make a Xmas list metaphor).

A teaser trailer for Roland Emmerich’s “10,000 B.C.” was featured. Since it opens in about 7 months, it gets points for revealing a bit more than a tagline, but the praise ends there. They show brief glimpses of men and women fighting in the titular time period amidst pyramids and Woolly mammoths. The action is nothing new. However, for me, what is new is seeing Woolly mammoths help raise the pyramids. I am not a historian, but I don’t ever recall learning that those two were around at the same time. Even if they were, having those two pieces of ancient history together was distracting to say the least. During the teaser, I kept my eyes peeled for the incredibly sensual and mysteriously gorgeous Camilla Belle. Unfortunately, she was absent. I was just happy I only had to sit through a minute of this tripe.

There was one good preview and that was for “Get Smart.” It was goofy, but Carell nabbed the role of Smart. I really felt like a kid busting a gut at the innocent idiocy of Maxwell Smart.

All right, on to the feature presentation. If you haven’t read the books, there is a brief spoiler at the end, but it is marked.

At the end of book 4, “Harry Potter & the Goblet of Fire,” I was filled with excitement and anticipation for book 5. The end set up the beginnings of a war, not with two, but 3 sides. All four books casually grew up with the initial intended audience. The series was turning into a freight train of pounding intensity. However, for me the book “The Order of the Phoenix” didn’t deliver on the promise of a war of triangular proportions. Instead, what I got was a heaping amount of adolescent angst, and in my opinion a poorly constructed last act.

I am more than pleased to report that the movie knew just how to deal with Harry’s anger and frustration, as well as to carve out a satisfactory end to book 5’s tale.

There has been a lot said and written about hiring a new film director to helm this particular movie. David Yates did a great job and in my opinion, “The Order of the Phoenix” is the best film in the series with the exception being “Prisoner of Azkaban.” However, what the series needed and what it got was a fresh new perspective in screenwriter Michael Goldenberg. I’m not knocking Kloves' imagining of the first four, but having seen “Order,” you can look back at “Goblet” and see that Kloves’ writing and plotting was beginning to get a bit tired and stale.

Goldenberg turned what was a somewhat disappointing book into a carefully honed fantasy film that can stand alone from the previous four, as it’s own film. Credit is due to Yates as well, for navigating through the script with precision and respect.

Potter fans may be put off by how much was left out, but for someone who has enjoyed the books without infatuation and one who wants to see a better movie than a better book, “The Order of the Phoenix” delivered.

All that Harry was dealing with concerning the aftermath of “Goblet” was carefully understated, as opposed to the books throat-cramming description.

There are two sequences in particular that pretty much made the movie for me. In order to help the Order of the Phoenix, the adults rebelling against the ministry of magic and Voldemort (can’t say, ‘He who-must-not-be-named’ anymore, because only the characters still filled with fear say anything but the dark lord’s name), Harry, Ron and Hermione form their own band of fighters for the cause, Dumbledore’s Army. The set-up for the formation of the army was great, but the sequence showing Potter training the group was one of the best mainstream montage sequences I have seen in quite awhile. The training was intercut with the new Defense Against the Dark Arts villain, Dolores Umbridge (played with penetrating, goosbump-raising creepiness by Imelda Staunton) trying to expose the new army, and with a series of realistically portrayed shots of the burgeoning potential teenage love story of Cho and Harry. This entire montage was carefully placed in the middle, which for the previous films have been the weakest point.

The last sequence that particularly thrilled me was the battle between the Army and Voldemort’s followers, the Death Eaters. I briefly skimmed through a review or two that somewhat chastised the film’s ending for being too abrupt.

It didn’t feel abrupt to me. The special effects that accompany the fight were exquisite, and like nothing I’d seen from the previous films, furthering the proof that Goldenberg and especially Yates for his execution have crafted a stand alone commendable fantasy film. In “Goblet,” we briefly saw how the Death Eaters could appear out of nowhere as if a sandstorm was blowing them through. That effect was expanded on with an amazing amount of detail.

There is only one part of the film that didn’t satisfy me (*this next bit has a large spoiler for anyone who hasn’t read the book!).

In the book, it is apparent that Sirius Black sees Harry as an extension of his deceased best friend, Harry’s father James. Nothing through the film’s first two acts suggested this was going to be a thematic element. However, in the end without explanation, while fighting alongside Harry against the Death Eaters, Sirius calls Harry, James. In the middle of the fight after he said it, Harry looked confused and Sirius is killed. Since Yates is taking on “Half-Blood Prince,” maybe he’s planning on expounding on why Black said what he did, but that one word “James,” interrupted the flow of the breathe-taking battle. Even though I had read the book and knew why he was saying it, up until that moment I was made to forget that particular part. The fact that it was shoved in, didn’t seem like it was something they initially planned to explore, it seemed like Goldenberg and Yates said to themselves as they were filming, “Shit! We forgot that Black doesn’t look at Harry the way Harry looks at him! Wait, I got it! Make Black say ‘James.’ That’ll explain everything!”

(End Spoilers) That part aside, “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,” was an astonishing achievement, a worthy addition, and a spectacular directorial debut for David Yates. As I mentioned earlier, the darker, “Prisoner of Azkaban” is the only film that “Order of the Phoenix” is second to. I believe it is because of Cuaron’s vision of the wizarding world that has paved the ground for this and what I can only imagine will be another great film, Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Sounds like the last one...
by Heckles
Jul 11th, 2007
05:20:26 PM
2nd!
by Clabog592
Jul 11th, 2007
05:26:25 PM
I liked Goblet better myself...
by Redrockmullet
Jul 11th, 2007
05:29:26 PM
nailed it
by Turd Furgeson
Jul 11th, 2007
05:31:00 PM
Heckles. Your post sounds like your last one.
by Frijole
Jul 11th, 2007
05:34:03 PM
Redrockmullet
by Turd Furgeson
Jul 11th, 2007
05:38:30 PM
Memflix died for our sins.
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
05:38:48 PM
he says "James" in the book too
by BigDude
Jul 11th, 2007
05:41:09 PM
Woolly mammoths have the power of 10,000 slaves
by Mace Tofu
Jul 11th, 2007
05:41:12 PM
How is the TROLL 2 Rifftrax?
by Frijole
Jul 11th, 2007
05:43:53 PM
Bigdude, you suck at reading:
by raw_bean
Jul 11th, 2007
05:51:41 PM
Hey Memflix...
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 11th, 2007
05:53:03 PM
I like S.N.L.'s version of H.P.
by Sappers Forward
Jul 11th, 2007
05:53:05 PM
We need and "edit" feature
by Sappers Forward
Jul 11th, 2007
05:55:26 PM
Memflix missed something
by darthzombie
Jul 11th, 2007
05:55:29 PM
Harry Potter XXXMCLVIII
by Quake II
Jul 11th, 2007
06:04:10 PM
darthzombie
by Vic Twenty
Jul 11th, 2007
06:04:22 PM
Only a dick...
by Vic Twenty
Jul 11th, 2007
06:06:31 PM
this is great but...
by tmeadows34
Jul 11th, 2007
06:15:15 PM
nevermind...
by tmeadows34
Jul 11th, 2007
06:16:51 PM
tmeadows... what's "lame"? not casting Halle?
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
06:21:29 PM
So much better than Goblet!
by all
Jul 11th, 2007
06:25:29 PM
Hermine DIES!!!
by motormouth_4_20
Jul 11th, 2007
06:38:33 PM
Scarlett Johansson strapped in the Excessive Machine
by Mace Tofu
Jul 11th, 2007
06:47:32 PM
Emma Watson
by tHEmOOG
Jul 11th, 2007
06:47:53 PM
These movies could have been SO bad by now
by performingmonkey
Jul 11th, 2007
07:06:39 PM
Mammoth + Pyramid
by Alientoast
Jul 11th, 2007
07:12:01 PM
Gus Van Rant what you want to hear is she's in Cashback
by Puddleglum
Jul 11th, 2007
07:14:06 PM
Just to clear things up
by Puddleglum
Jul 11th, 2007
07:14:57 PM
hmmm
by Halfbreedqueen
Jul 11th, 2007
07:21:27 PM
Scarlett Johansen as Barbarella? Oh please.
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
07:30:58 PM
Indiana Jones:
by Forestal
Jul 11th, 2007
07:36:50 PM
Quick Question re: Adults caring about Harry Potter
by Gwai L0
Jul 11th, 2007
07:39:45 PM
CHECK OUT THE BRIEF INDY FOOTAGE...
by Reynard Muldrake
Jul 11th, 2007
07:48:58 PM
and by brief footage...
by Reynard Muldrake
Jul 11th, 2007
07:49:24 PM
briefs footage of Indy? Alert MrBadWonka!
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
07:52:37 PM
hahahaha
by Reynard Muldrake
Jul 11th, 2007
07:55:13 PM
There is only one Barbarella...
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 11th, 2007
07:57:46 PM
Diora Baird = fake'uns = no thanks
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
08:02:34 PM
Daddylonghead = INCORRECT
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 11th, 2007
08:05:14 PM
Kinda disappointed...(Spoilers)
by RetroActive
Jul 11th, 2007
08:09:48 PM
Daddylonghead/Gaius
by RetroActive
Jul 11th, 2007
08:18:55 PM
RetroActive
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 11th, 2007
08:24:19 PM
I agree Retro,
by jae683
Jul 11th, 2007
08:25:28 PM
RAW BEAN - ???
by BigDude
Jul 11th, 2007
08:45:46 PM
Sorry, but I don't use Wikipedia for info on titties.
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
08:50:10 PM
and all joking aside
by Daddylonghead
Jul 11th, 2007
08:55:06 PM
Haven't seen it yet! Have to wait.
by Kayti
Jul 11th, 2007
09:13:36 PM
Memflix good to see you back...
by mr dark
Jul 11th, 2007
09:21:46 PM
it's the best
by TAF
Jul 11th, 2007
09:27:23 PM
Daddylonghead - all kidding aside...
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 11th, 2007
09:45:08 PM
The problem with Memflix's reviews:
by Playkins
Jul 11th, 2007
09:59:42 PM
I thought it was the best movie of them all
by THE FAN
Jul 11th, 2007
10:03:24 PM
Not to bring up that INDY clip again...
by Reynard Muldrake
Jul 11th, 2007
10:22:41 PM
Spoiler for The Deathly Hallows
by lost.rules
Jul 11th, 2007
10:35:09 PM
Phoenixmagi.... ummm no....
by Russman
Jul 11th, 2007
10:41:28 PM
nitpicking
by Wall Ball Champion
Jul 11th, 2007
10:56:07 PM
Wall Ball Champion
by Turd Furgeson
Jul 11th, 2007
11:12:53 PM
Actually, no, he doesn't.
by melusina
Jul 12th, 2007
12:04:27 AM
'Kloves’ writing tired and stale'
by Sepulchrave
Jul 12th, 2007
01:14:19 AM
Oldman is so likeable as Sirius. He really should
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
01:34:04 AM
Know what I liked about this movie? That they resisted
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
01:36:36 AM
finally, another movies that seems to 'deliver'
by just pillow talk
Jul 12th, 2007
06:49:14 AM
This movie seemed like it was made for kids with ADD
by jae683
Jul 12th, 2007
07:44:10 AM
I can imagine the next one will be sixty minutes long.
by jae683
Jul 12th, 2007
07:54:11 AM
breathe-taking?
by henrydalton
Jul 12th, 2007
08:02:41 AM
hmmm... Memflix!!! ...
by jimmy rabbitte
Jul 12th, 2007
09:42:24 AM
Even ROCKY had a Montage!
by pokadoo
Jul 12th, 2007
10:43:17 AM
Definately did not Deliver....
by DevilDog2007
Jul 12th, 2007
11:10:49 AM
The montages
by Frijole
Jul 12th, 2007
11:12:23 AM
Oops! mispelled oppinion in my other comment...
by DevilDog2007
Jul 12th, 2007
11:12:29 AM
I don't mind montages
by jae683
Jul 12th, 2007
11:45:39 AM
I wasn't a fan of Grawp's design either.
by Frijole
Jul 12th, 2007
11:48:20 AM
Pyramids 10,000 BC
by berserkrl
Jul 12th, 2007
12:41:10 PM
Memflix, you're a fucking idiot
by DannyOcean01
Jul 12th, 2007
01:02:43 PM
Memflix you tool
by NachoNegro
Jul 12th, 2007
01:17:37 PM
I didn't like Grawp or the animated mail at Privet
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
02:21:42 PM
More similar to Pyramids than Ziggurats but
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
02:24:12 PM
nacho and yobo
by memflix
Jul 12th, 2007
02:26:34 PM
So, Memflix...
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
02:43:48 PM
I found you gaius
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
02:47:14 PM
YOU KNOW an ant semitic troll?
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
02:49:46 PM
You found me, LORDRANDO?
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
02:50:47 PM
FOUND YOU AGAIN
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:01:50 PM
chiming in
by pervy elf fancier
Jul 12th, 2007
03:06:05 PM
LORDRANDO
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
03:12:23 PM
People discussing Harry Potter
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:12:52 PM
NIce
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:14:14 PM
FUCK YOU=GAIUS
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:16:06 PM
LORDRANDO - You're a lively one, aren't you?
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
03:30:05 PM
TRUCE
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:34:09 PM
Truce = Finis
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
03:36:44 PM
VALETE GAIUS! SALVETE!
by LORDRANDO
Jul 12th, 2007
03:37:45 PM
I loved the film
by RokurGepta
Jul 12th, 2007
03:49:09 PM
Mammoths and Memflix
by Frankenbastard
Jul 12th, 2007
03:54:24 PM
roamed even
by Frankenbastard
Jul 12th, 2007
03:56:05 PM
disagree
by deadshot07
Jul 12th, 2007
03:58:55 PM
I seriously doubt the only thing wrong with this is...
by FILMFUNK
Jul 12th, 2007
04:48:07 PM
He calls him James to honor his father, come on
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
05:13:38 PM
jae683
by pervy elf fancier
Jul 12th, 2007
05:18:10 PM
and as for this james thing
by pervy elf fancier
Jul 12th, 2007
05:21:59 PM
They had Nation of Islam doing security at the
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
05:22:57 PM
The film is not frenetic the entire way through.
by superninja
Jul 12th, 2007
05:36:25 PM
Potter Book 7 Spolier
by Russman
Jul 12th, 2007
05:36:55 PM
Gaius what is your obsession with ZFisk?
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 12th, 2007
05:51:44 PM
I enjoyed it
by disfigurehead
Jul 12th, 2007
06:03:48 PM
BringingSexyBack
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
07:07:25 PM
TomBodet
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 12th, 2007
07:09:35 PM
Nipples on a Mammoth = Flames on a Pyramid's Ass
by sleeptones
Jul 12th, 2007
07:12:28 PM
Harry Potter is overated.
by krushjudgement
Jul 12th, 2007
07:43:16 PM
Seriously and
by krushjudgement
Jul 12th, 2007
07:44:35 PM
Sirius' James comment
by oisin5199
Jul 13th, 2007
12:33:52 AM
Amazing!
by Dangerousapple
Jul 13th, 2007
05:04:23 AM
< p >
by Dangerousapple
Jul 13th, 2007
05:05:24 AM
Will be watching this tonight
by SUPERJIM
Jul 13th, 2007
05:22:14 AM
Knobhead bollocks
by yodalovesyou
Jul 13th, 2007
05:45:12 AM
RE: yodalovesyou
by Dangerousapple
Jul 13th, 2007
06:09:37 AM
Gaius
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 13th, 2007
07:07:41 AM
BSB
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 13th, 2007
08:31:51 AM
Gaius
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 13th, 2007
09:30:01 AM
BSB
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 13th, 2007
09:39:17 AM
Gaius: What's pathetic and sad is your witch hunt
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 13th, 2007
09:46:36 AM
And I'm "jumping to the defense of someone"
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 13th, 2007
09:50:31 AM
Wow, BSB.
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 13th, 2007
10:09:28 AM
Entertaining, not a classic, not a waste of time
by TrueLies
Jul 13th, 2007
10:13:42 AM
Muggles is not a swear word
by buffywrestling
Jul 13th, 2007
12:54:55 PM
Gaius, I don't want a flame war with you
by BringingSexyBack
Jul 13th, 2007
01:13:58 PM
You're smarter than this, BSB.
by Mr. Nice Gaius
Jul 13th, 2007
02:27:55 PM
Calling Harry James was set up
by Mundungus
Jul 16th, 2007
02:37:00 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.