Cool News
Our First Review Of THE KITE RUNNER!
Hey, everyone. ”Moriarty” here.
This book was fairly beloved when it came out a few years ago, and this script was one of the best-reviewed in town. So has Marc Forster delivered on all that promise? I guarantee this is going to be pushed as one of this year’s players when awards season rolls around.
Will it be worth all that energy? Let’s see what our spy has to say...
Hey guys,
I've never sent in a review before, but I love the site and I figure there are a number of people out there who are interested in hearing about Marc Forster's latest endeavor The Kite Runner (especially considering the popularity of the book). I caught a test screening at the Pacific Theater in Pasadena earlier this evening, with Mr. Forster himself in attendance. Before the flick started, a lady informed us that what we were about to watch was a 'work in progress' and that we were the first audience anywhere to see the film, which of course made us all feel like really important people. And then the lights went down and the Dreamworks logo came up.
First off, let me point out that I have never read the Khaled Hosseini novel, but don't fault me for this, as I'm sure I represent a sizeable portion of the population (and besides, I have enough trouble keeping up to date with all of these Harry Potter books). As such, I have no idea how close the film is to the original source material, and therefore I will limit myself to discussing the movie on its own terms, and not the adaptation of the story. And how is it, you ask? As a 'work in progress' it was actually quite good. I won't go into details on the plot, but it might be helpful if I provide a little context for those who don't know the story.
Amir and Hassan are childhood friends, growing up in Kabul, Afghanistan during the late 1970s. Amir belongs to a rather well-to-do family, for whom Hassan's family works (they are of a lower class). Amir is well educated and likes to write stories, and he and Hassan prove to be quite deft at flying kites around the city. We follow them for perhaps the first third of the movie, at which point the story goes on to chronicle Amir's life as he grows older, focusing on the mistakes and choices he makes, and so on. Unfortunately the second half of the film is not nearly as strong as the first, but more on that later.
I must say that the actors playing the two kids during this first third are outstanding. They've never done anything else (according to IMDB), but Forster is able to pull out some first-rate performances from them. Amir's father (referred to as Baba in the film) is also excellent, and I was generally pleased to see such strong work from an almost entirely unknown cast. I think people will find that the most recognizable face belongs to that gun-wielding shopkeeper from Crash, who plays a very different character here.
The majority of the film follows Amir as a grown man, where he is played wonderfully by Khalid Abdalla, who most will remember as the terrorist that piloted United 93 in Paul Greengrass's exceptional film. He does very well in the lead role and brings a great range of emotions from which to draw upon. In fact, it is largely due to his performance that the second half does not get completely outshined by the first. The problem, from my perspective, lies in the pacing. In the beginning, Forster does a grand job of introducing us to all of the characters and showing us the lifestyle and flavor of 1978 Kabul (the scenery throughout is superb). We get to spend time with Amir and Hassan through several beautifully staged scenes, and the movie feels almost perfect for the first act. The second act, showing Amir's new life in the States, is well done, but could probably benefit by being drawn out a bit more. It feels like several scenes just breeze by, and aren't given the time they need in order to resonate. The same goes for the third act, in which Amir travels back to Kabul. This is the most problematic sequence, due in most part to all of the issues and emotions that are raised (I won't go into spoiler territory), and it seems like the audience is rushed through it all as quickly as possible. The editors even employed the use of jump cuts to speed up certain scenes, which was totally unnecessary. I feel as though the third act needed a little bit more room to breath, especially given how important it is. The film would probably benefit from an additional 10 or 15 minutes spliced back in. As it is now, it runs almost exactly 2 hours in length.
The only other real quibble I had was in regards to the music in some of the scenes. However, it was a temp score, so hopefully it'll all be smoothed out in the final product. The screenplay by David Benioff (who penned the awesome 25th Hour, as well as the lackluster Troy) I'm pleased to say is one of the film's strengths, as is the cinematography. The kite flying sequences, in particular, are riveting in the manner in which they're shot and will likely impress a lot of viewers (I'm not even sure if the effects were entirely finished in these scenes, but I still enjoyed them).
I've never been a huge fan of Marc Forster, but I certainly consider him to be a competent and reliable filmmaker. Monster's Ball and Finding Neverland were certainly well done for what they were; however, I found Stranger Than Fiction to be a little disappointing, and I think most consider Stay to be kinda forgettable. I would rate this film on par with the first two, and maybe even a little higher since the story itself is so absorbing. I don't think it will be getting any Oscars next February, but I'm willing to bet it will open to strong reviews.
On a side note, I have to applaud the filmmakers for shooting this picture almost entirely in Farsi. I'm sure there were discussions revolving around having the cast speak English with Afghan accents for all of us simple-minded Americans, but I'm so glad that they went with the real language and opted for subtitles instead. It really does make a big difference in one's appreciation of the film, which I found to be very good when all was said and done. However, I would like to hear the opinion of someone familiar with the book. Hope I didn't ramble on too long.
If you use this, call me Himal.
-
+ Expand All
-
The Kite Runner will own your asses!
-
Kites rock.
-
Not first!
-
I just read the review and IT WILL NOT own your asses. My apologies.
-
I want to remain in possesion of my own ass.....
-
I don't trust anyone that writes this:"And then the lights went down and the Dreamworks logo came up." and then this:"I found Stranger Than Fiction to be a little disappointing"he's either a plant, or has no taste. or both? parsley?
-
...to Child Anal Rape? If this occurs in a movie, you'd think that it would make it into a review.
I'm willing to bet 'Plant'. -
... I honestly wouldn't see a movie involving THAT. Talk about all the "good" parts of the book = plant.
-
I read this book a few years ago with a reading group, and our opinion of the novel was about the same as this review...it does a wonderful job of setting everything up, but then the end falls apart and devolves into a lot of melodramatic treacle, some of which even manages to strain credibility. The sentiment of this book is in the right place, but the execution is a little off once you get past the first 100 pages. I may give the movie a chance...depends on what kind of buzz i hear.
-
i really liked "Stay". Thought it was the second best movie of 2005, behine Brokeback. Sure I will get railed for both of those.
-
Broke my heart and I actually thought the second half with its ambiguous downer ending was better than the first half. Excellent novel.
-
Maybe there's something I don't know, but why would they be speaking Farsi in a movie about Afghans? In all honesty, someone educate me, but I thought they spoke Pushtu or whatever in Afghanistan.
-
Afghans speak Farsi. According to Wikipedia (usually accurate at this kind of stuff) so do 62 million people. It's based on the ancient language of Persians, so if you're going to the middle east it's a good idea to learn Farsi.
-
according to wikipedia, i'm king of the polar bears. but yes, the two main languages in Afghanistan are both Persian dialects, hardly surprising given that Afghanistan is next door to Iran. also, the book is great and deserves a wide audience. hope the movie does it justice.
-
I read the book last summer, and it's one of the best books I've ever read. I was so moved by this story that it brought me to tears in places, and I'm not a guy who cries easily.
This is my most anticipated film of 2007. -
Im not sure what level of involvement he had in the screenplay with Hosseini but his hand in this is interesting.Fuckin guy is Golden.25th Hour, Stay , TROY..Im pumped he wrote the Wolverine script..gonna be somethin
-
and I have serious doubts that this could be a frontrunner for any awards if the first and thirds act (presumably if the first act is amir as a kid and the third is him going back to Afghanastan). Because these two sections of the book are what made reading it most, thrilling. And from the sounds from this review, and if it does in fact go two hours then its gonna suck hard especially if key scenes are taken out.
-
Kite Runner was a great book, and I hope the film is just as good. This is the first, Ihave actually heard that it has been turned into a film, and if it sticks to the book, I really can't see it failing much as a film
-
this movie will be lucky to get to a million if it's in farsi.
-
Since someone asked and nobody has it right . . . Afghans speak a lot of different languages and dialects. The two main languages are Dari and Pashto, which are distinct from one another. However, a lot of Afghans use the terms Dari, Farsi, and Persian interchangeably. Then you get wacky stuff like Uzbek, Turkmen, Nuristani, Pamiri, etc sprinkled here and there. Afghanistan is a real patchwork of languages and ethnicities.
-
Fuck,...I think I fell asleep just reading this review. I hope the movie knocks me out just as fast. Dream world, here I come!
-
the book was a stunner. i learned so much about the fascinating, rich culture of afghanistan in this book -- stuff i've never seen mentioned anywhere else.
-
I am anxiously awaiting the release of this movie. Unfortunately, the date has been pushed back six weeks in an attempt to secure the safety of the young child actors in the film. Hosseini’s story is moving, and I am confident that Marc Forster’s translation of the narrative into cinema is faithful to the author’s message. Check out the site Kite Runner Movie and look for the movie in theaters in mid December.
-
Check Em out they're awesome
Kite Runner – I don't want to forget anymore
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=865f114e-5b78-4ed3-ba02-9771d591ae38
Kite Runner – My Son the College Grad
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=bad1bafe-9eeb-49c1-865f-2d200ab848e0
Kite Runner – I hear it's Somebody's Birthday
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=6475b2bb-9b0e-4739-b467-6b09eec09987
Kite Runner – What Do You See?
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=b6ad9d7d-c445-4930-8267-88a649906157
The Kite Runner – There is a Way To Be Good Again, Amir
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=645de229-1454-45d3-903a-eefaa5dee76b
Kite Runner – For You a Thousand Times Over
http://www.iklipz.com/MovieDetail.aspx?MovieID=8c966354-7ca3-4c63-a2e1-942f2da7e64d
Readers Talkback
User Login
Top Talkbacks
- Whitney Houston 1963 - 2012 -- 325 total posts 322 posts
- New JUDGE DREDD post production footage pops up -- 106 total posts 106 posts
- HANNA's Saoirse Ronan to boss around seven little people -- 63 total posts 60 posts
- Does ‘SNL’ Rhyme With ‘Deschanel’?? Learn Which SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE Vet Hosts After Sexy Zooey!! -- 74 total posts 58 posts
- There's a STAR TREK video game that is going to lead into JJ's STAR TREK 2 apparently... -- 159 total posts 51 posts
- If the Behind the Scenes Pics of the Day drops her pen, pick it up, but don’t look at her legs or else it will be on your record. -- 47 total posts 41 posts
- AVENGERS enemy revealed as pink boardgame pieces... You might suffer some form of elation... SPOILERS!!! -- 161 total posts 34 posts
- To Commemorate The 3D Release Of STAR WARS EPISODE I: THE PHANTOM MENACE, George Lucas Wants You To Know...Greedo Shoots First!! -- 488 total posts 33 posts
- Friday Brings SWEEPS DAY NINE!! Gab Here About Tonight’s FRINGE!! Plus Einstein on TIM, Wiig On PORTLANDIA, MAHER, CLONE, GIFTED, GRIMM, SPARTACUS, SUPERNATURAL, GOLD RUSH And More!! -- 121 total posts 23 posts
- Here's The Red Band Trailer For Drafthouse Films' THE FP! -- 70 total posts 20 posts