Cool News
Part 3 of Moriarty's Look at Future Supernatural Hollywood Films... THE SIN EATER
Well, as you can see the world of the supernatural is our next forward step in film. Perhaps it's signaling a step past the teen slasher state that we are in, and a move into a more richly fun world of hauntings and ghosts... But... here's the man with his finger on the dead pulse of it all... Moriarty
Hey, Head Geek...
"Moriarty" here.
As the haunting of the Moriarty Labs continues, I am gradually coming
to believe that it is my fault. I have spent my life, after all, as
an Evil Genius, and perhaps there is a price to pay for that. Could
it be that all the Evil I've done is catching up with me? If so, then
perhaps it's time for me to call in William Eden, the Sin Eater.
Before I go into further detail about Eden and his role in Brian
Helgeland's new film, allow me to offer up an apology to the fine
folks at Tippett Studios. When I got e-mail concerning the FX work on
HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSE, I recognized a few of the names of the people
who wrote me as former ILM staffers. I was not aware that they had
changed studios, and so I credited the wrong people with the FX work
on De Bont's new film. Let me set the record straight. The work that
I've heard so much about is being done by Tippett Studios, and I'm
sure it's going to be excellent. It's rare for me to hear this much
positive buzz from inside a production, and it's a good sign.
Now, as I was saying, Brian Helgeland is currently in production on
his second film as a director, following the currently in-release
PAYBACK, and it looks like he's continuing to push the envelope of
mainstream darkness in films. Like his script for LA CONFIDENTIAL,
this film refuses to allow us to categorize the characters as "good"
or "bad," instead presenting us with some complicated moral and
ethical issues wrapped up in one of the most accurate treatments of
the tenets of the Catholic faith that I've ever encountered in a
screenplay.
The mood of the film is set right off the bat by a classroom debate in
which the hypothetical murder of Hitler is used as an example of how
sticky the whole "good"/"bad" debate can get. Alex Bernier, the
professor of the class, challenges his students by asking what they
would do if they were able to meet Hitler before his rise to power.
Would they kill him, knowing what he would eventually do? Alex argues
that "As soon as men decide that all means are permitted to fight
evil, then their good becomes indistinguishable from the evil that
they set out to destroy." If murder is wrong, shouldn't that apply no
matter what? If Hitler were at an ATM machine and someone were to
kill him for his money, would the robber be a good person because of
the suffering they prevented? How about if Hitler killed himself?
Would that make him a good person?
It's not until after class that we learn that Alex is actually a
Catholic priest who occasionally serves as a consultant for the
Washington, D.C. police. When he's called into a crime scene, we also
meet Lucy Sinclair, a cop who tried to kill herself after a
particularly brutal case a few years earlier. Alex was involved in
that case, and he and Lucy are familiar with each other. The crime
scene they're at is the office of the French Ambassador, who has been
found dead at his desk with Aramaic letters carved into himself. Alex
lies and says he can't help at all with what the characters might
mean. It's obvious he's afraid, though.
He's got good reason to be, too. William Eden, a mysterious figure,
haunts the first half of this film. His meeting with the French
Ambassador starts the film. We see him visit a hospital nursery and
seemingly inhale the souls of sleeping children. Throughout these
early scenes, we're given very little clue as to the nature of Eden.
The Catholic Church is central to this film, something which may
isolate some viewers. I'm personally fascinated by the evolution of
dogma over the centuries, and Helgeland has played with the doctrines
in such a clever way that I found myself totally absorbed as the
script changes gears and heads to Vatican City where we meet Father
Dominic, Alex's former teacher. He's tormented by spirits, haunted by
the past, and Alex only makes things worse by sending Dominic the
ancient lettering to translate. Dominic summons Alex to Rome, saying
he can't just give him the translation over the phone, that it's far
more complicated than that.
As Alex works to solve the mystery from a theological standpoint, Lucy
works to solve it from a secular one, using forensics and science.
When fingerprints from the murder scene turn up as matching those
found at the scene of a 1918 murder in Brooklyn, Lucy finds that her
science may not be enough, and that the fragile sanity she's worked so
hard to rebuild may be tested more than she ever expected.
The way Helgeland brings these characters together and the way he
builds the suspense in the script is excellent. I'm not sure if
Catholicism actually maintains a belief in the Sin Eater, but it's
fascinating because of the way it ties into the whole notion of no
simple good or bad. Catholics believe that extra ecclesiam nulla
salus, or "there is no salvation outside the church." The Sin Eater
goes directly against that belief, serving as the one person who is
able to offer salvation to the wicked, absolving their sins without
the involvement of a priest. The Sin Eater is the one who the truly
evil turn to in their last efforts to get into Heaven.
Nothing I've said takes place after page 16 of the script, so I really
wouldn't call any of this major spoilers. I won't detail any more of
the story, since part of what makes it so wonderful is the horrible
feeling of dread that builds gradually throughout the entire story.
This isn't a horror film that depends on big shocks dropped at regular
moments. Instead, this is along the lines of THE EXORCIST or
ROSEMARY'S BABY or ANGEL HEART, a film that earns its scares honestly,
drawing us into a world in which these things are real, in which the
intangibles of faith become tangible, and in which what you don't
believe can hurt you.
A big part of this film's success will depend on casting, and I must
admit that I'm in the dark about what sort of cast Helgeland has put
together for the film. Antonio Banderas was rumored to be involved as
Eden, but I haven't heard that officially. I pictured Eden as older,
with a more vaguely European presence, but Banderas might be able to
pull it off. The casting of Alex and Lucy is just as important,
though. These are people with a great deal of pain in their pasts,
and Helgeland needs great actors, not movie stars, to make them feel
real. If everything comes together properly, this may well be one of
the smartest theological thrillers ever made. It takes the ideas it
presents seriously, and it respects its audience to be scared by
what's inside them more than any external spook or specter.
There's a chance I may abbreviate this series to six parts instead of
seven depending on the availability of certain materials. Tomorrow
I'll either be reviewing A STIR OF ECHOES or LOST SOULS. Either way,
we're down to what I consider the cream of the crop of Hollywood's
efforts in the supernatural right now.
Of course, we've still got that last surprise to discuss, don't we?
Until then...
"Moriarty" out.
-
+ Expand All
-
Sounds cool. Lets hope that shithole section of L.A. doesnt fuck it up. Does anyone remember The Dead Zone scene in which Christopher Walken said "If you could kill Hitler, would you?" This article reminded me of that. Im very interested in what this film has to say about the Church and right/wrong. Many extreme Catholics nowadaze have a really fucked up view of right and wrong. Some quote the bible when murdering abortion doctors saying they are doing God's will, totally ignoring the fact that vigilantism is completelu forbidden by the Bible, because God is the only true judge. The hate crimes that plague our newspaper covers are also mostly inspired by religion. Or at least thats what they defend their actions with: "It was God's Will!" I'm not saying at all that religion is bad--I think it promotes me good things--but I also think its about time that Hollywood had the balls to address some of these issues. Who is gonna ever make a film... let me start over... Who is ever going to FINANCE a film about the Church vs. Abortion? I'd pay to see it. It's a fucked up time were living in. I dont pretend to know which side is right, but I do know that their has been a dark side to Christianity for hundreds of years. I'd like to see a filmmaker expose it without bashing the good side of religion.
-
In George Carlin's latest HBO special he commented that we will have terriosm as long as we have Muslim extremists, christian extremists, Jewish extremists, and guys from Montanta...I felt like saying Amen Brother. L'Auter in regards to your post about a movie dealing with the church vs Abortion there's a book out, been out for a couple of years now I think it was published in 94 or 95 by Charles Colson about a pastor from Washington DC that runs a pro-life orgnazation that slowly turns into a anti-abortion terriost group before his eyes and how he is powerless to stop it and who the actions of others effected him. It's called Gideon's Torch and I don't know if it could be made into a movie but it was a powerful book
-
Catholic dogma also contains a corollary to "outside the Church, there is no salvation",
of which the short version is:
unbaptized people who mean well & try to do the right thing are "honorary members" of the Church and as such can be saved. Since Catholics believe that sin is something that you voluntarily do (a rape victim is not a sinner), people who do bad things and don't repent go to hell, be they Catholic or not. And no, Catholics don't always practice what they preach - do liberals? Or conservatives?
Or Baptists or Trekkies?
Re: Sin Eater, well I'd have to see it (or read the script) to figure out who'd find it offensive. It's based on a dark,
pretentious comic book, which is to say that it's bound to be a crummy (in terms of quality) movie. Blech. I'd rather see Joel Schumacher remake Dracula with the Dawson's Creek cast (Joel, if you're reading this DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT IT) -
I hope this film isn't as boring, as this guy writes.
-
The movie sounds very interesting, and I am not a big horror fan. I get the impression, (specifically because of the mention of not only killing Hitler, but of Hitler committing suicide, it seems to impy.. uh, I won't just blindly guess) that the plot will involve a lot of very grey areas that might lead to very intellegent moral questions as well as entertaining. I hope the final product is as promising as the discription. About the discussion though- specifically the 10 comandments, a little clarification- I read Hebrew; there is no "Though shalt not kill" (at least not in those 10)- The term used is "murder" ("retzakh"), self defence would obviously not be included. Bearing false witness is not just lying, and, political scandals aside, I don't think that many people have the opportunity. As for stealing, stepping a little out of literal translation, I have often seen that explained as kidnapping- not that stealing is not otherwise forbidden, but just plain stealing doesn't fit in with the severity infractions of the other commandments may incur. I also know a little Aramaic- does anybody know the term used in the movie? My trusty dictionary can translate... probably.
-
hey, you're welcome to your opinion Taxi Driver, but since
there's been several long-winded posts at this forum you'd better be more specific about which one you found boring! -
As a Spaniard, he is a European presence. OK, so he hasn't done anything of note recently, but he was muy Euro in Almodovar's films and was the only properly cast male vampire in the horrendous "Interview" flick. If he'd get a haircut and lose 40 pounds, he could pull this off.
-
Interesting that casting Banderas as a vampire who in the book is only about 15 years old or so, is considered the only "proper " casting in the movie
Readers Talkback
User Login
Top Talkbacks
- Whitney Houston 1963 - 2012 -- 209 total posts 207 posts
- AVENGERS enemy revealed as pink boardgame pieces... You might suffer some form of elation... SPOILERS!!! -- 160 total posts 97 posts
- There's a STAR TREK video game that is going to lead into JJ's STAR TREK 2 apparently... -- 144 total posts 77 posts
- Here's The Red Band Trailer For Drafthouse Films' THE FP! -- 68 total posts 68 posts
- New JUDGE DREDD post production footage pops up -- 67 total posts 67 posts
- Does ‘SNL’ Rhyme With ‘Deschanel’?? Learn Which SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE Vet Hosts After Sexy Zooey!! -- 64 total posts 60 posts
- To Commemorate The 3D Release Of STAR WARS EPISODE I: THE PHANTOM MENACE, George Lucas Wants You To Know...Greedo Shoots First!! -- 480 total posts 55 posts
- HANNA's Saoirse Ronan to boss around seven little people -- 53 total posts 50 posts
- Friday Brings SWEEPS DAY NINE!! Gab Here About Tonight’s FRINGE!! Plus Einstein on TIM, Wiig On PORTLANDIA, MAHER, CLONE, GIFTED, GRIMM, SPARTACUS, SUPERNATURAL, GOLD RUSH And More!! -- 118 total posts 32 posts
- SPACE 2099!! -- 182 total posts 27 posts