Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Dear Paramount, RE: Brian Helgeland's Director's Cut of PAYBACK: STRAIGHT UP. From Harry Knowles.

Dear Paramount,

Harry Knowles here. I’ve just seen Brian Helgeland’s cut of PAYBACK. Nearly 9 years ago I saw this cut. I very much remember the fights and rumors that flew around when he was booted from the project and the reshoots came to pass.

Tonight, Brian screened his cut here in Austin to thunderous applause. Not only that, but Brian’s Q&A was legendary, detailing the patience of Job as the entire executive teams at Warner Bros. & Paramount changed, leaving not a single decision maker in place to stop him getting a chance to finally finish the film his way. I applaud the fact that the current Paramount Executive team saw merit in allowing Helgeland to finally finishing his cut. The result is spectacular.

Finally, the film I was crazy about is done.

PAYBACK: STRAIGHT UP – The Director’s Cut isn’t some minor adjustment to sell DVDs – it is a complete overhaul. No Kris Kristofferson, no kidnapped son sub-plot, no boxing match and not any pulled punches. This is a mean sucker punch, gutter dirty, pissed off piece of pulp art! Mel is not “the likable superstar” in this film. He beats the shit out of Deborah Kara Unger in this version, he is straight to the point, no cookie cutter bullshit. This is the way a Parker novel by Donald Westlake should be handled.

The film is leaner and meaner. There are no explosions and needless tacked on gore. This is brutal and hard-nosed… Oh, and IMMENSELY SATISFYING!!!

Here’s the problem though. At this point, according to Helgeland at the screening, the film will most likely end up going to DVD in February or March – with a minor dump into a few theaters here or there.

I completely get how this film from 7 years ago isn’t a big priority. It was a tiny, small budget film from a prior regime – that did its business on DVD. Also – the investment in allowing Brian to finish this cut is also minuscule. I, also completely get that if you just hit this straight to DVD, you’ll make a killing, theoretically.

However, PAYBACK isn’t one of the great Mel Gibson movies in most people’s eyes. It was that Mel flick he did before LETHAL WEAPON 4. The one where he didn’t fight Jet Li. Well… To really get the audience’s attention – I think you’ve got to get this film back on to screens.

This is a radically different film. Better music, better editing, better storytelling and just flat out a great film.

I don’t expect PARAMOUNT to make it a big release. Frankly, I don’t think that would work. However, I really think handing the film over to PARAMOUNT VANTAGE would be an ideal way to treat this tiny crime film the way it ought to be treated, with a team that would help it in a limited release, that built upon the critical acclaim that this cut would receive by critics everywhere.

Word would build and build about this version of the film.

This would also help Paramount to gain the reputation as an artist friendly studio. Helgeland has been punched around too often. First on this film, then manhandled by Tom Rothman on SINEATER – another film that we’ll have to wait however long it takes before Mr. “I don’t make movies, I make Audiences” is running things over there.

Be the heroes of this film’s long ascent out of darkness. It isn’t everyday that a great film emerges from the manhandling of an oppressive regime as the wonderful film it once was. Let folks see the best 70s crime film since the 70s on the big screen like it has never been seen.

Start in 8 cities and let it grow. This is a film that has absolutely earned its second chance. It crawled out of its premature burial to get finished what should have been done ages ago. Now it deserves its days and nights on a theater near everyone out there that has wanted to see a film that earns every second it plays.

And as for all you dear readers. I know Mel isn’t the most popular guy right now, but this isn’t about Mel Gibson, it’s about Brian Helgeland, the writer of L.A. CONFIDENTIAL and his lean mean crime film that didn’t pull a punch. This isn’t a bloated tale with 3 subplots too many. This isn’t a film to make your bladder burst. This is a quick pulpy ride that kicks ass all over it’s fictional play-ground. I truly hope you get the opportunity to see this on the big screen, I did tonight – and I never thought I would. It’s been worth the wait!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Cool...
by binarybender
Oct 21st, 2006
02:43:26 AM
What's with all these Director's cuts?
by Photoman
Oct 21st, 2006
02:49:08 AM
WOW!
by Sinisterjim
Oct 21st, 2006
02:58:23 AM
Dear Harry, RE: Mel Gibson
by indiephantom
Oct 21st, 2006
02:59:22 AM
Long live Mel Gibson!
by JackPumpkinhead
Oct 21st, 2006
03:08:42 AM
The rumours are true?
by Franklin T Marmoset
Oct 21st, 2006
03:20:28 AM
What's the problem?
by jabbathegriffin
Oct 21st, 2006
03:45:01 AM
jabbathegriffin
by Killah_Mate
Oct 21st, 2006
04:06:51 AM
That's good news
by Vern
Oct 21st, 2006
04:14:51 AM
I remember hearing about this awhile ago.
by WONKABAR
Oct 21st, 2006
04:20:32 AM
Thanks a lot, Harry...
by TopHat
Oct 21st, 2006
04:24:35 AM
I don't care...
by Azlam Orlandu
Oct 21st, 2006
04:46:56 AM
Sound as a Pound
by DirkD13"
Oct 21st, 2006
05:00:32 AM
I can't understand...
by Kizeesh
Oct 21st, 2006
05:01:01 AM
TopHat, Lizeesh....
by WONKABAR
Oct 21st, 2006
05:20:11 AM
FINALLY!!!! I can't believe I'm going to get to see thi
by Daddylonghead
Oct 21st, 2006
05:35:57 AM
I enjoyed Gibson's version...
by LeiaDown&FuckHer
Oct 21st, 2006
06:17:44 AM
Never cared enough to watch Payback, but I
by CreasyBear
Oct 21st, 2006
07:48:26 AM
Never cared enough to watch Payback, but I
by CreasyBear
Oct 21st, 2006
07:50:47 AM
Regarding my computer's double-post:
by CreasyBear
Oct 21st, 2006
07:52:06 AM
How about writing to Dimension
by alanmck_666
Oct 21st, 2006
08:16:22 AM
What's the point?
by reluctantsnob
Oct 21st, 2006
09:08:11 AM
Man I've been around this site for a long time...
by RenoNevada2000
Oct 21st, 2006
09:58:04 AM
MEL SHOOTS FIRST!!!
by BannedOnTheRun
Oct 21st, 2006
10:12:12 AM
Lay off Mel
by Jumping Windows
Oct 21st, 2006
10:31:11 AM
"That's pure Alligator! That is just MEAN, man!"
by uss cygnus
Oct 21st, 2006
10:36:08 AM
I Must Agree, Where's The Review?
by Ill Clinton
Oct 21st, 2006
10:52:01 AM
Did someone say Tom Rothman???
by Shermdawg
Oct 21st, 2006
11:25:29 AM
Now where is my MULHOLLAND FALLS director's cut?
by godoffireinhell
Oct 21st, 2006
11:50:07 AM
Two Legolases, no Aragorn.
by Mgmax
Oct 21st, 2006
12:11:51 PM
But will there ever be a franchise?
by The Dum Guy
Oct 21st, 2006
12:21:42 PM
And the REAL reason the Muslims are so pissed off...
by Angry White baby
Oct 21st, 2006
12:21:50 PM
Angry White baby:
by The Dum Guy
Oct 21st, 2006
12:25:10 PM
Amen & Amen
by BDT
Oct 21st, 2006
12:45:07 PM
DID THEY AXE THE VOICE OVER??!?!
by jackinitraw
Oct 21st, 2006
01:07:12 PM
I like the theatrical cut.
by FluffyUnbound
Oct 21st, 2006
01:16:31 PM
I like the original
by El Scorcho
Oct 21st, 2006
03:57:41 PM
Payback
by emeraldboy
Oct 21st, 2006
04:24:51 PM
So, Mel hates Jews, SO FUCKING WHAT?
by MattCG
Oct 21st, 2006
04:51:33 PM
MattCG, conseling is available...
by Alonzo Mosely
Oct 21st, 2006
05:51:28 PM
ANGUS Director's Cut !!!
by Rex Manning
Oct 21st, 2006
06:15:15 PM
small film...?
by s0nicdeathmonkey
Oct 21st, 2006
06:28:16 PM
also, bladder buster?
by s0nicdeathmonkey
Oct 21st, 2006
06:28:48 PM
one major difference
by Vern
Oct 21st, 2006
10:19:46 PM
Was this the movie where (spoiler)
by BankyFan
Oct 21st, 2006
10:26:21 PM
It doesn't matter how they release it...
by Chief Redcock
Oct 21st, 2006
11:12:43 PM
saw it last night at AFF
by hank quinlan
Oct 22nd, 2006
03:21:18 AM
While licking Brian Hegelend's balls in this thread
by Shivv
Oct 22nd, 2006
05:13:01 AM
Excellent news,...
by Uga
Oct 22nd, 2006
08:24:49 AM
About two weeks ago in the town of Maden Bargen
by emeraldboy
Oct 22nd, 2006
08:30:39 AM
Re: About two weeks ago in the town of Maden Bargen
by MovieFan06
Oct 22nd, 2006
10:31:27 AM
You stupid fucking girls...
by morgenes
Oct 22nd, 2006
11:35:53 AM
Somepeople are using Gibbo's I hate jews thing as a
by emeraldboy
Oct 22nd, 2006
12:04:11 PM
An addendum to my last post
by Chief Redcock
Oct 22nd, 2006
02:29:37 PM
Gibson doesn't hate Jews...
by Alonzo Mosely
Oct 22nd, 2006
03:40:44 PM
i thought mosely wrote 'genitiles'
by skaul80
Oct 22nd, 2006
06:59:39 PM
From the writer of "Nightmare 4: Dream Warriors."
by Uncapie
Oct 22nd, 2006
10:38:43 PM
Mel beats the shit out of the Jews who now hate him!
by Bari Umenema
Oct 22nd, 2006
10:43:24 PM
Wow...
by Paul T. Ryan
Oct 22nd, 2006
11:20:41 PM
I never knew...
by thebearovingian
Oct 22nd, 2006
11:44:47 PM
morgenes it was a young girl that Polanski fiddled with
by Regicidal_Maniac
Oct 23rd, 2006
12:01:22 AM
Wait a minute, Sally Kellerman?
by Vern
Oct 23rd, 2006
01:20:30 AM
Never write while drunk and eating a sandwich
by Regicidal_Maniac
Oct 23rd, 2006
01:33:51 AM
DAMN YOU ROTHMAN!!!!!
by Doc_Strange
Oct 23rd, 2006
01:55:15 AM
If you're gonna hate on a religious sect......
by Doc_Strange
Oct 23rd, 2006
02:04:53 AM
Wow. People are still on the Joo thing?
by jackinitraw
Oct 23rd, 2006
09:25:48 AM
Scooby Doo and the case of the disappearing post
by jackinitraw
Oct 23rd, 2006
09:36:31 AM
aintitbrokenwebsite.com!
by jackinitraw
Oct 23rd, 2006
09:40:41 AM
Lucy Liu + Dominatrix gear = Really sexy.
by nemesisdarkside
Oct 23rd, 2006
11:04:21 AM
It is an issue
by logic33
Oct 23rd, 2006
03:04:00 PM
Point Blank
by Buzz Maverik
Oct 23rd, 2006
03:09:03 PM
More studio execs should be so ballsy....
by Monkey_King
Oct 23rd, 2006
04:28:25 PM
The name Richard Stanley rings a few bells, huh?!?!
by Monkey_King
Oct 23rd, 2006
04:34:11 PM
The name Richard Stanley rings a few bells, huh?!?!
by Monkey_King
Oct 23rd, 2006
04:34:31 PM
Hey Mel Haters!
by JefferyLebowski
Oct 23rd, 2006
06:09:30 PM
Hey Mel Haters!
by JefferyLebowski
Oct 23rd, 2006
06:10:08 PM
Hey Mel Haters!
by JefferyLebowski
Oct 23rd, 2006
06:14:08 PM
Fluffy- again mostly in agreement
by 900LBGorilla
Oct 23rd, 2006
06:14:45 PM
Nice rant on hate Matt G Call out the Hating Haters
by 900LBGorilla
Oct 23rd, 2006
08:00:38 PM
Fluffy- again mostly in agreement- post eaten?
by 900LBGorilla
Oct 23rd, 2006
08:42:19 PM
Fluffy- again mostly in agreement- post eaten?
by 900LBGorilla
Oct 23rd, 2006
08:43:01 PM
Wow- lag city
by 900LBGorilla
Oct 23rd, 2006
09:18:48 PM
13th Warrior
by Kizeesh
Oct 23rd, 2006
09:26:58 PM
100% with you fluffy
by WONKABAR
Oct 24th, 2006
05:45:42 AM
Most films one day
by emeraldboy
Oct 24th, 2006
06:16:43 AM
This site's TB section is becoming
by emeraldboy
Oct 24th, 2006
06:19:16 AM
I found the original cut highly entertaining...
by DoctorWho?
Oct 24th, 2006
04:27:07 PM
Re: Jumping Windows
by ErrantNight
Oct 25th, 2006
04:34:45 AM
Is it true Mel goves someone a kerb sandwich in this?
by Bill Fairbanks
Oct 27th, 2006
07:39:53 AM
Regicidal_Maniac has a . . .
by Almost_Human
Oct 27th, 2006
03:55:11 PM
I really like the original
by TheWacoKid
Oct 27th, 2006
07:27:16 PM
I always liked Payback
by LordSoth
Oct 28th, 2006
04:06:55 AM
Re: BAnkyfan.
by Gilkuliehe
Oct 28th, 2006
06:35:03 PM
Oh and bossprym
by Gilkuliehe
Oct 28th, 2006
06:37:53 PM
Hey, Monkey_King
by slapshot
Oct 29th, 2006
11:45:51 PM
I don't want to care.....
by shellfishh
Nov 1st, 2006
02:48:58 PM
Passion of Christ was anti-Semitic?
by Maniaq
Nov 6th, 2006
10:35:24 PM
COOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by jamie sonil
Nov 8th, 2006
12:30:42 AM
COOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !! !!!!!!!!!!!!!
by jamie sonil
Nov 8th, 2006
12:31:12 AM
I am not racist Maniaq.
by deadguy76
Nov 10th, 2006
05:12:22 AM
Republican Favor the Rich
by kevinwillis.net
Nov 21st, 2006
06:58:26 AM
I don't even think I know what "Payback" is.
by Cotton McKnight
Dec 11th, 2006
07:34:20 PM
On DVD soon
by 24200124
Dec 24th, 2006
12:18:36 AM
Richard Stark -- not Donald Westlake
by theJackalope
Dec 30th, 2006
08:55:43 PM
Last...
by Quintus_Arrius
Mar 9th, 2007
10:28:16 PM
this is a test
by Sublimefn87
Mar 29th, 2007
06:29:28 PM
Good review hARRY
by LeviDTinker
Apr 22nd, 2007
08:53:43 PM
Indeed, I am last!
by Quintus_Arrius
May 16th, 2007
06:39:12 AM
Orcus...
by Quintus_Arrius
May 16th, 2007
07:50:59 AM
Still hear!
by Quintus_Arrius
May 20th, 2007
02:59:06 PM
indeed that should be hair....
by Quintus_Arrius
May 20th, 2007
03:06:19 PM
no, no, my bad...
by Quintus_Arrius
May 20th, 2007
03:07:25 PM
I think so..
by Quintus_Arrius
May 21st, 2007
01:59:57 PM
was eric bana in payback?
by egomeme
May 9th, 2009
10:34:24 AM
Heh?
by Orcus
May 11th, 2009
09:05:18 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.