Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Herc Declares 30 ROCK The
Best New Sitcom On Network TV!!

I am – Hercules!!

Is true! There’s not another new sitcom on any of the networks I like as much as “30 Rock.”

From screenwriter-actress Tina Fey (“Mean Girls,” “Saturday Night Live”), it’s about a sketch-show showrunner (Fey) who finds herself paired with a batshit-crazy movie star (Tracy Morgan) by an amiable but meddling new NBC executive (Alec Baldwin).

While it had its laughs, the pilot sent to critics early in the summer was far too odd and confusing for its own good. The revised pilot airing tonight keeps all which worked but leaves out that which derailed - and substitutes a much better ending.

But what matters Herc’s opinion?

USA Today gives it three (out of four) stars and says:

… what matters most tonight is that 30 Rock probably will make you laugh, no small achievement in a season in which too few shows are even trying. …

The New York Times says:

… Ms. Fey has some amusing, seditious lines as Liz Lemon, the put-upon creator of “The Girlie Show,” but for the most part she and other cast members slumber until Mr. Baldwin takes over as Jack Donaghy, their new network boss. …

The Los Angeles Times says:

… It would be confusing opinion with fact to definitively call any series "the best show of the fall season," but I can state unequivocally and without fear of contradiction that "30 Rock" — one of two new NBC shows set backstage at a broadcast-live sketch comedy — is my favorite. I feel an almost proprietary desire to see it succeed, and given the high mortality rate of such newborns, I light this small candle against its demise. …

The Chicago Tribune says:

… “30 Rock” is less than the sum of its parts, and, as an entry in the single-camera comedy sweepstakes, it fails to show either the inspired inventiveness of “Arrested Development” or provide the surprisingly perceptive character studies of “The Office.”…

The Washington Post says:

… Fey is a clever writer with a wicked wit, but as an actress, she tends to vanish into her own scenes. Even so, there are plenty of laughs on the premiere, and it's the kind of quality show worth rooting for. …

Variety says:

… Baldwin and co-star Tracy Morgan do yield a chuckle or two, but a "Saturday Night Live" pedigree won't be enough to anchor this "Rock" unless it gets consistently funnier, and fast. …

The Hollywood Reporter says:

… There are a couple of rough patches in the pilot, including maybe too much time for the scene at the strip club, an unplanned stop as Liz struggles to get Tracy to the studio. But these are minor quibbles with what is arguably the best comedy this fall and NBC's best hope for the night. …

8 p.m. Wednesday. NBC.









What book about Stanley Kubrick could possibly be worth $200? How about The Stanley Kubrick Archives??



Alan Moore's Lost Girls!!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

thought it was great...
by mthrndr
Oct 11th, 2006
08:26:24 AM
I hope she got a new writer for this sitcom
by Itchy
Oct 11th, 2006
09:04:23 AM
I laughed hard the entire show
by SifoDyasJr.
Oct 11th, 2006
09:23:01 AM
A Lot Better Than I Thought It Would Be...
by MortGuffman
Oct 11th, 2006
09:27:02 AM
question: does it not feel too much like Studio 60?
by newc0253
Oct 11th, 2006
09:45:43 AM
Dratch doesn't add much
by ghj
Oct 11th, 2006
10:13:25 AM
No way it is better than The Office
by Elmore Rigby
Oct 11th, 2006
10:20:44 AM
Mort, the thing is...
by FluffyUnbound
Oct 11th, 2006
10:21:15 AM
Funny
by Spuncho
Oct 11th, 2006
10:30:34 AM
If the West WIng is any indication...
by Childe Roland
Oct 11th, 2006
10:39:19 AM
Not even close to the best sitcom on t.v.
by JonQuixote
Oct 11th, 2006
10:39:43 AM
I ordered "Lost Girls" over a month ago...
by fattyaaron
Oct 11th, 2006
10:54:05 AM
"It's not HBO. It's TV."
by JohnGalt06
Oct 11th, 2006
11:09:36 AM
Really? Better than Two and a Half Men?
by GenericGeek
Oct 11th, 2006
11:37:46 AM
Herc has long been the AICN idiot critic
by stlfilmwire
Oct 11th, 2006
11:42:30 AM
By the way...
by stlfilmwire
Oct 11th, 2006
11:44:33 AM
No, Tina Fey is not funny. Never has been.
by Heckles
Oct 11th, 2006
11:45:52 AM
Herc, Would it be any good without Alec?
by The Cabin Boy
Oct 11th, 2006
11:55:48 AM
whoop-dee-doo
by TheBaxter
Oct 11th, 2006
12:12:38 PM
Really?
by Lando Griffin
Oct 11th, 2006
12:46:14 PM
Baldwin
by Powers Boothe
Oct 11th, 2006
01:20:29 PM
Get rid of "Earl" and put this before the Office...
by DanielKurland
Oct 11th, 2006
01:44:16 PM
Wow, that's a pretty big diss to The Office, Herc
by wash
Oct 11th, 2006
02:21:37 PM
seriously?
by punto
Oct 11th, 2006
02:48:23 PM
Right now I am imagining Tina...
by mrfan
Oct 11th, 2006
03:37:29 PM
Better than 'Scrubs' and 'The Office' ?
by Prior Walter
Oct 11th, 2006
03:39:26 PM
I find it hard to believe
by StealthBeagle
Oct 11th, 2006
05:02:15 PM
To reiterate: Better than The Office? Fuck you, Herc.
by eppdude
Oct 11th, 2006
06:19:47 PM
Better than British Office? No way. US Office? Hell yea
by mthrndr
Oct 11th, 2006
06:59:24 PM
Best?
by NudeandAroused
Oct 11th, 2006
07:07:13 PM
You know Herc,
by DarkWater
Oct 11th, 2006
07:08:59 PM
cat throwing
by v1cious
Oct 11th, 2006
07:26:30 PM
Seriously?
by NudeandAroused
Oct 11th, 2006
07:31:04 PM
ok first ep
by waggy
Oct 11th, 2006
07:34:13 PM
I enjoyed it...
by DanielKurland
Oct 11th, 2006
07:39:40 PM
Best sitcom on TV....
by CTU Mole
Oct 11th, 2006
07:42:47 PM
Not Good
by sethworld
Oct 11th, 2006
07:54:39 PM
Hate to do it....
by shellfishh
Oct 11th, 2006
08:11:25 PM
Not bad at all.
by CatVutt
Oct 11th, 2006
08:15:40 PM
Jimmy James: Macho Business Donkey Wrestler
by shellfishh
Oct 11th, 2006
08:27:18 PM
you people are weird
by LouGossetPhillip
Oct 11th, 2006
08:31:08 PM
Meh...
by obiwayne
Oct 11th, 2006
08:41:30 PM
Anyone notice they were shooting Fey on one side?
by BigTuna
Oct 11th, 2006
08:48:56 PM
I'M A JEDI! I'M A JEDI!!!
by RaveX
Oct 11th, 2006
08:49:43 PM
Dear Hollywood: Get over yourselves!
by Larry of Arabia
Oct 11th, 2006
09:07:38 PM
and Comic Book Guy comes out and says
by CTU Mole
Oct 11th, 2006
09:41:21 PM
The commercial for the tri-convection oven was good.
by kabong
Oct 11th, 2006
09:52:48 PM
3rd Rock is better
by Gorrister
Oct 11th, 2006
10:04:15 PM
I am confused
by limus
Oct 11th, 2006
11:09:54 PM
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia ...
by kilpack
Oct 11th, 2006
11:54:32 PM
gah?
by dykstrafan
Oct 12th, 2006
12:08:40 AM
sigh
by dykstrafan
Oct 12th, 2006
12:09:57 AM
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia is....
by ArmyofChud
Oct 12th, 2006
12:13:15 AM
limus.
by CatVutt
Oct 12th, 2006
12:14:12 AM
Rachel Dratch
by ArmyofChud
Oct 12th, 2006
12:16:33 AM
Two and a Half Men
by ArmyofChud
Oct 12th, 2006
12:17:30 AM
I am willing to keep uning in but that episode was
by Lando Griffin
Oct 12th, 2006
12:20:20 AM
Two and a Half Men.
by CatVutt
Oct 12th, 2006
12:31:26 AM
Tina Fey for 22 minutes!!
by AshesOfDonnie
Oct 12th, 2006
01:09:43 AM
"Bake a turkey in 22 minutes"
by Napoleon Park
Oct 12th, 2006
05:17:13 AM
Anyway, screw this...
by abiggerboat
Oct 12th, 2006
06:14:41 AM
The Wacky Sax Music Has Got to Go
by tonagan
Oct 12th, 2006
06:48:19 AM
GE commercial
by Barndorfer
Oct 12th, 2006
07:22:59 AM
It did make me laugh...
by godric
Oct 12th, 2006
08:07:01 AM
Too early to call it the best sitcom...
by jbum
Oct 12th, 2006
08:27:43 AM
We're we watching the same TV show??
by Vitiare
Oct 12th, 2006
08:42:56 AM
Herc is Clearly Just Trying to get his quote on the TV.
by stlfilmwire
Oct 12th, 2006
08:54:23 AM
why the fuck is there no talk back for venture bros?
by JeanLuc Dickhard
Oct 12th, 2006
09:47:58 AM
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia is amazing...
by DanielKurland
Oct 12th, 2006
09:49:18 AM
whaaaaaa
by purplemonkeydw
Oct 12th, 2006
11:30:17 AM
just marginally entertaining
by Rupee88
Oct 12th, 2006
12:08:22 PM
SheTV
by Bungion Boy
Oct 12th, 2006
12:49:59 PM
FluffyUnbound...My Comparison Was Based...
by MortGuffman
Oct 12th, 2006
01:12:01 PM
if this is the best sitcom on tv...
by bouncing1
Oct 12th, 2006
01:31:54 PM
Am I the only one . . .
by Ban This User
Oct 12th, 2006
01:38:46 PM
Not Bad!
by Mr Stiffy
Oct 12th, 2006
04:24:34 PM
Didn't even smile once. Glib substituted for wit.
by Mr.NiceGuy
Oct 12th, 2006
04:35:15 PM
"Glib substituted for wit".
by CatVutt
Oct 12th, 2006
04:47:37 PM
The One Thing that is absolutely for sure
by nalapou
Oct 12th, 2006
07:10:36 PM
The not-ready-for-prime-time players?
by hulk_beanpoll
Oct 12th, 2006
11:38:23 PM
Always Sunny
by Spuncho
Oct 13th, 2006
01:25:26 AM
Tonights Office episode blew Herc's proclaimed
by Lando Griffin
Oct 13th, 2006
08:58:59 AM
Sunny in Philly beats 30 Rock like a circus monkey
by 2for2true
Oct 13th, 2006
10:09:49 AM
Yay for all the The Office love!
by mraig
Oct 13th, 2006
10:11:37 AM
Best Sitcom On Network TV, Herc ?
by Toby___Wong
Oct 13th, 2006
01:19:15 PM
Tracey Morgan is the best thing on 30 Rock
by wash
Oct 13th, 2006
03:17:21 PM
it was a shockingly incredible pilot...
by beamish13
Oct 13th, 2006
03:51:16 PM
beamish I pray that was sarcasm
by Lando Griffin
Oct 13th, 2006
05:34:22 PM
Wow. Talk about not living up to the hype
by lettersoftransit
Oct 14th, 2006
12:45:21 PM
it's all about Baldwin
by emu47
Oct 14th, 2006
02:23:10 PM
That Pilot Was Painful
by Anton_Sirius
Oct 14th, 2006
09:56:34 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.