Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Harry visits THE DEPARTED twice this week!

Finally! Finally a remake that doesn’t make me think of the original classic upon which it was based. Scorsese’s THE DEPARTED is to INFERNAL AFFAIRS what THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN is to SEVEN SAMURAI. It is its own film, in its own culture, time and period. The characters are not English speaking substitutes for the original brilliant Hong Kong cast, they are their own characters. That said – INFERNAL AFFAIRS was never on the level with SEVEN SAMURAI – and THE DEPARTED, while absolutely wonderful… is not THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN – didn’t have to be, it’s THE DEPARTED.

Now – I’m not going to regurgitate the plot and the twists. Anyone that spoils that sort of thing on this film should have their kneecaps blown out. I’ve seen the film twice now, once at a press screening… and tonight, opening night, with a packed Austin audience at the Galaxy Highland 10. I was taking Yoko, as she didn’t make the earlier screening and frankly – I was just using her as my excuse to see it again. I think next, I’ll take my sister – cuz I know she hasn’t seen it yet and this is a “must see” film.

This isn’t a GOODFELLAS or a CASINO. Nor is this a MEAN STREETS type of Scorsese. In an odd way… I saw it as his ANGELS WITH DIRTY FACES. His Michael Curtiz Pop Americana Cops and Robbers flick. This is Scorsese, not ripping open the soul of crime to show the moral decay eating away at the criminal’s conscience. Rather, this is the game. The Game of Cops & Robbers. The back and forth. As the film goes on, you can see Scorsese throwing his hands up in the air and screaming, “What the fuck, Let’s have some Bloody Fucking Fun!”

I haven’t seen Scorsese having this much fun since Deniro’s Max Cady hit the screen with Juliette Lewis. And this time out, it’s Nicholson doing his take on the Cagney-esque madman / genius crook. Literally, “the rock star” as Alec Baldwin calls his character. This is Scorsese’s Big Top. Three Rings. The Cops, The Robbers and The Rats. All performing magnificently. In an odd way, this is the perfect capper for Scorsese’s DiCaprio trilogy of GANGS OF NEW YORK, THE AVIATOR and now this film.

It’s the best of those three, by leaps and bounds. Gangs never worked for me, AVIATOR dazzled but was in the end, it was missing something. Something Scorsese was missing. It was a great film, just not a great Scorsese film. Cinematically it was flat out a marvel, but it was always a fantasy to me, never fully anchored to our reality. In fact, that was the point of the film. Very much a confection.

With THE DEPARTED – it is not only a tasty film, but cinematically, aurally and performance wise it’s fantastic. It’s a heightened universe where cops and robbers have the most amazing personalities, charisma and poise. However, the nastiest of shit that can happen in the real world happens to them. It’s great. It’s the blending of the pop and the art into the showiest Scorsese, that still FEELS Scorsese that we’ve seen to date.

I’m gonna wrap this up, there’s been so much that’s been written on AICN about THE DEPARTED in the last few days, that to go on and on would seem like such a hard sale. But before I can go… I’ve got to point out one geek thing that Scorsese did that completely made me giddy. Marty did a couple of Iris outs and ins that – well… They were just absolutely awesome to see on the big screen in a modern film.

And... for this film, the title says it all... For the past year or so, I've hated the title. Having seen the film - It is absolutely the only title that would work.

Go see THE DEPARTED this weekend. It’s worth every penny.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

first
by babyAlligators
Oct 7th, 2006
03:35:02 AM
my first first ever
by babyAlligators
Oct 7th, 2006
03:36:55 AM
"I think next, I’ll take my sister"
by Windowlicker74
Oct 7th, 2006
03:42:32 AM
Film of the year - hands down
by kwisatzhaderach
Oct 7th, 2006
03:44:27 AM
It kicked my ass once and I'm going back for more
by antonphd
Oct 7th, 2006
03:49:28 AM
Film of the year - hands down
by kwisatzhaderach
Oct 7th, 2006
03:50:03 AM
This film had so many problems
by mpfanatic
Oct 7th, 2006
04:03:09 AM
No lover of cinema has any excuse to miss this
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 7th, 2006
04:08:41 AM
No lover of cinema has any excuse to miss this
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 7th, 2006
04:09:08 AM
No lover of cinema has any excuse to miss this
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 7th, 2006
04:09:42 AM
Blame my dumbass computer for the triple post
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 7th, 2006
04:11:47 AM
The fire alarm went off about a 3rd into the flick...
by donkeypark
Oct 7th, 2006
04:38:36 AM
The fire alarm went off about a 3rd into the flick...
by donkeypark
Oct 7th, 2006
04:38:45 AM
Brilliant film
by Dickie Greenleaf
Oct 7th, 2006
05:12:09 AM
It's not "The Departed"!
by JackPumpkinhead
Oct 7th, 2006
05:24:27 AM
I would see it but
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:24:21 AM
Yeah, I'm seeing it again tonight too...
by DanielKurland
Oct 7th, 2006
06:31:01 AM
I would see this film but....
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:35:06 AM
I would see this film but....
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:35:56 AM
kwisatzhaderach, since you mentioned Miami Vice...
by DanielKurland
Oct 7th, 2006
06:36:09 AM
I would see this film but....
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:36:45 AM
was the 300 trailer attached?
by c4andmore
Oct 7th, 2006
06:44:20 AM
According to Ch4 news last night
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:49:45 AM
According to Ch4 news last night
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:50:25 AM
According to Ch4 news last night
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:50:43 AM
According to Ch4 news last night
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
06:50:44 AM
Yes, the 300 trailer was attached...
by DanielKurland
Oct 7th, 2006
08:00:18 AM
emeraldboy: Easy on the "enter" key, my friend.
by CreasyBear
Oct 7th, 2006
08:39:28 AM
Saw it last night, best film I've seen all year
by Da Coach
Oct 7th, 2006
08:53:13 AM
emeraldboy: Easy on the "enter" key, my friend.
by CreasyBear
Oct 7th, 2006
09:00:16 AM
Great until the end **SPOILERS**
by Ace Hunter
Oct 7th, 2006
09:03:56 AM
Ah, the irony is thick.
by CreasyBear
Oct 7th, 2006
09:04:29 AM
But did you buy any gum on the way to the theater?
by JohnGalt06
Oct 7th, 2006
09:07:18 AM
really liked the ending -- best remake ever???
by reckni
Oct 7th, 2006
10:15:45 AM
This is scorsese's heater but......
by samuraiyao
Oct 7th, 2006
10:19:07 AM
will scorsese finally get his oscar?
by OhDaesu
Oct 7th, 2006
10:56:48 AM
Brilliant performances and dialogue but
by pandamaster83
Oct 7th, 2006
01:05:57 PM
too mich c-cider...oh shit
by SuperJAMF
Oct 7th, 2006
02:04:50 PM
Entertaining but overall too cartoony and nihilistic
by BillEmic
Oct 7th, 2006
02:25:37 PM
Should have called this movie "The Retarded"
by Mr. Waturi
Oct 7th, 2006
02:41:10 PM
Allow me to correct earlier comments I have made
by Harry Weinstein
Oct 7th, 2006
02:50:14 PM
I saw little miss sunshine...
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
03:09:34 PM
regarding Marty...
by emeraldboy
Oct 7th, 2006
03:12:21 PM
I know why Franky does it...
by BDT
Oct 7th, 2006
04:14:33 PM
Damn you Michael Bay
by MCMLXXVI
Oct 7th, 2006
05:58:00 PM
Better than Infernal Affairs
by barnaby jones
Oct 7th, 2006
07:12:57 PM
Yackbacker, I know what you mean
by BillEmic
Oct 7th, 2006
08:41:31 PM
Mark Whalberg
by antonphd
Oct 7th, 2006
10:30:55 PM
I myself cannot see
by Skankardly
Oct 7th, 2006
10:54:42 PM
The deceptions are so two-faced
by BDT
Oct 7th, 2006
11:35:29 PM
that's antidepressants
by BDT
Oct 7th, 2006
11:37:41 PM
Did anyone else..
by CondomWrapper
Oct 8th, 2006
01:50:07 AM
There was a lot of laughter in my theater too.
by Orbots Commander
Oct 8th, 2006
02:36:04 AM
Good, not great. Gangsof New York was better...
by HappyHamster
Oct 8th, 2006
04:35:05 AM
Yep
by pandamaster83
Oct 8th, 2006
06:44:39 AM
Scorsese is overrated
by Toby___Wong
Oct 8th, 2006
08:52:42 AM
Saw It Opening Night. Pretty Good, But Way Over Rated
by The Ender
Oct 8th, 2006
09:32:04 AM
Time will not be kind to this movie
by Riverman
Oct 8th, 2006
12:09:34 PM
When you have talkbackers saying shit like.....
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 8th, 2006
12:35:42 PM
Lots of fun, but fuck me what a ridiculous last shot.
by Fenton Meiks
Oct 8th, 2006
12:49:34 PM
I wanna know how zombie solutions...
by BDT
Oct 8th, 2006
02:09:32 PM
Too much"The Departed"on front page=FLAMES ON OPTIMUS
by GibsonUSA
Oct 8th, 2006
03:58:17 PM
It wasn't that the deaths were sudden
by pandamaster83
Oct 8th, 2006
04:36:27 PM
Did you guys not lik the ending to Resevior Dogs?
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 8th, 2006
05:40:20 PM
Yackbacker
by Fenton Meiks
Oct 8th, 2006
05:48:24 PM
I can't relax, it's genetic
by Fenton Meiks
Oct 8th, 2006
06:08:58 PM
You're right, that is hilarious now I think about it.
by Fenton Meiks
Oct 8th, 2006
06:42:41 PM
Actually, THE ISLAND is good for about 1/2 its run.
by Orbots Commander
Oct 8th, 2006
08:14:25 PM
THE ISLAND is cartoony nihilism
by BillEmic
Oct 8th, 2006
09:11:33 PM
Michael Bay Is The Suck
by The Ender
Oct 8th, 2006
09:33:19 PM
Micheal Bay would make a great 2nd unit director
by Orbots Commander
Oct 8th, 2006
09:43:48 PM
DEPARTED was a GOOD MOVIE
by uberman
Oct 9th, 2006
01:09:36 AM
i almost barfed
by Bob C. Cock
Oct 9th, 2006
02:04:32 AM
Oh please Snuffles. He's at 92% at rottentomatoes
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 9th, 2006
02:46:09 AM
Did you guys not like Kill Bill 2 or Inside Man?
by pandamaster83
Oct 9th, 2006
06:48:01 AM
A Couple of Issues
by William Munny
Oct 9th, 2006
08:56:23 AM
Gangs of New York
by Itchy
Oct 9th, 2006
09:57:21 AM
Wow Pandamaster
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 9th, 2006
11:01:31 AM
Baldwin
by GopherTrace
Oct 9th, 2006
11:03:19 AM
The Departed/Resevoir Dogs
by BillEmic
Oct 9th, 2006
11:58:37 AM
IndustryKiller, don't be so aggressive
by pandamaster83
Oct 9th, 2006
12:16:45 PM
Elevator Scene
by SeanMiller
Oct 9th, 2006
01:01:05 PM
Wildly Overrated (SPOILERS)
by Powers Boothe
Oct 9th, 2006
01:10:01 PM
ending question
by sternumman
Oct 9th, 2006
02:51:02 PM
Thanks Harry Weinstein...
by Childe Roland
Oct 9th, 2006
02:54:15 PM
Apparently I swear gratuitously...
by Childe Roland
Oct 9th, 2006
02:58:19 PM
It's a date, Snuffles.
by Childe Roland
Oct 9th, 2006
04:01:24 PM
Powers Boothe is right.
by Orbots Commander
Oct 9th, 2006
04:58:20 PM
Perfect Closing Song...
by jazzbox2
Oct 9th, 2006
05:11:21 PM
Why the elevator scene works...
by DanielKurland
Oct 9th, 2006
05:28:39 PM
It's like the south park episode
by pandamaster83
Oct 9th, 2006
06:23:27 PM
Snuffles: Bob Butler is the worst critic in the US
by Barry Egan
Oct 9th, 2006
07:31:58 PM
92% is great. But 95% is better.
by Garbageman33
Oct 9th, 2006
08:29:38 PM
Saw it tonight.
by mrfan
Oct 9th, 2006
10:36:06 PM
AWESOME BOSTON DRAMA
by homemovies539x
Oct 10th, 2006
12:29:16 AM
Who's version of comfortably numb was it?
by pandamaster83
Oct 10th, 2006
06:53:25 AM
Snuffles: I live in Kansas City
by Barry Egan
Oct 10th, 2006
09:20:06 AM
Slightly better than IA with a worse ending
by King_Midas
Oct 10th, 2006
09:59:29 AM
Dirk Digglah
by GopherTrace
Oct 10th, 2006
10:48:21 AM
The Derparted is the no 1 film this weekend and
by emeraldboy
Oct 10th, 2006
11:45:09 AM
Comparing IA and The Departed is futile
by Garbageman33
Oct 10th, 2006
11:49:32 AM
Spoilers My problem with the ending
by hammerbutt
Oct 10th, 2006
12:53:14 PM
Damn Hammerbutt *spoilers*
by IndustryKiller!
Oct 11th, 2006
03:08:14 AM
Hammerbut
by King_Midas
Oct 11th, 2006
08:07:11 AM
King_Midas
by hammerbutt
Oct 11th, 2006
09:29:51 AM
YOU PEOLE ARE ASSHOLES!!
by williamD
Oct 11th, 2006
08:35:41 PM
YOU PEOLE ARE ASSHOLES!!
by williamD
Oct 11th, 2006
08:35:46 PM
Loved it, but... (SPOILERS)
by PushTheButton
Oct 11th, 2006
10:30:24 PM
CF, Casino, AOI, Kundun, BOTD, GONY, Aviator >
by UnChienAndalou
Oct 11th, 2006
11:29:45 PM
Scorsese and Irises
by Havok2000
Oct 12th, 2006
08:11:01 AM
William Munny and PushTheButton -
by Moa Kaka
Oct 12th, 2006
06:01:21 PM
I need to see it again...
by Chief Redcock
Oct 12th, 2006
06:08:56 PM
The Defarted Parody
by JDP23
Oct 12th, 2006
06:59:13 PM
Defarted link
by JDP23
Oct 12th, 2006
07:00:23 PM
Father?
by NudeandAroused
Oct 12th, 2006
08:03:02 PM
*SPOILER*
by Spuncho
Oct 13th, 2006
01:00:48 PM
THE INDEFENSIBLE!
by GLADIATOR MONKEY
Oct 13th, 2006
05:03:45 PM
It's not that Amercians can't handle endings...
by readingwriter
Oct 13th, 2006
10:58:49 PM
not a great movie...
by jinamina
Oct 14th, 2006
04:36:27 AM
Res Dogs wasn't a serious examination of violence
by readingwriter
Oct 15th, 2006
01:44:51 AM
The line that needs to be said at every workplace...
by DarthSnoogans
Oct 16th, 2006
11:43:58 AM
FINALLY!!!
by MaulRat
Oct 16th, 2006
10:08:52 PM
Question about Scorsese vs. Tarantino...
by Garbageman33
Oct 18th, 2006
09:49:57 AM
Losers
by hugmeplease
Oct 19th, 2006
12:24:59 AM
Losers
by hugmeplease
Oct 19th, 2006
12:25:21 AM
Always nice when the guy insulting others
by Garbageman33
Oct 19th, 2006
01:15:06 PM
loved it
by gleepglop
Oct 23rd, 2006
03:45:38 PM
loved it
by gleepglop
Oct 23rd, 2006
03:53:49 PM
Next time share more
by LustHog
Oct 25th, 2006
12:28:38 AM
Comfortably Numb
by Kentucky Colonel
Oct 30th, 2006
09:28:32 AM
Vera Farminga
by Kentucky Colonel
Oct 30th, 2006
09:29:26 AM
Comfortably Numb part II
by Kentucky Colonel
Oct 30th, 2006
09:38:07 AM
It'll win Best Picture but shouldn't
by Lago
Nov 2nd, 2006
05:54:38 PM
My first posting
by Chilly
Nov 3rd, 2006
04:54:07 AM
Great but would have loved to have had Pesci as Frank -
by workshed
Nov 10th, 2006
10:02:40 PM
Laughably Overrated
by 2Utah2
Feb 13th, 2007
03:05:47 AM
My favourite Scorcese film
by emeraldboy
Mar 1st, 2007
07:29:16 AM
indeed...
by Quintus_Arrius
Mar 9th, 2007
10:26:31 PM
IT'S ABOUT FUCKING TIME!
by williamD
May 14th, 2007
07:54:55 PM
Last...
by Quintus_Arrius
May 16th, 2007
06:25:24 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.