Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Quint has seen the RETURN of SUPERMAN!!!

Ahoy, squirts! Quint here. I just got out of the preview screening of SUPERMAN RETURNS here in Wellington. I know I'm a bit tardy, but I think I'm just making it in under the wire.

I'm not going to go very in-depth. You've read so many reviews already and a lot of you have seen the flick at a midnight showing by now, but I wanted to go on record with my immediate thoughts.

First off, if it wasn't for Richard Donner's SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE I might not exist. How many people can say that? On my parent's first date they went to see SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE opening weekend. Less than 3 years later I burst onto the scene. Thank God the movie didn't suck, eh? Who knows where I'd be, if anywhere at all.

I grew up with the movies, of course. I loved the first and second SUPERMAN movies, but even as a kid I couldn't get behind SUPERMAN 3 and 4, despite my well-bred love of Christopher Reeve in the role. I'm even at the point where Otis and Luther's campy relationship in the films doesn't bug me. I can see Hackman's torment at having to surround himself with idiots. The barbs he throws at Otis (not to mention fists) really reveals his distemper at these guys. So, what bugs a lot of fans doesn't bug me.

My thoughts on SUPERMAN RETURNS may contain spoilers... some quite heavy, but by now I think if you're reading this chances are you've seen the return of the big blue boy scout. But a fair warning for the rest of you guys.

I was pumped for this movie and really walked away happy, but I see some rough edges in the story and some of the development. Some stuff that doesn't make a lot of sense, some stuff that makes sense, but didn't quite work for me. But on the whole, the movie rocked.

That was in no small thanks to Brandon Routh. Like many of you, I scrutinized that first pic of him in the suit and like many of you I thought he looked too young. He looked like a male model. The symbol on his chest was too small. The red was too burgandy. Then at Comic-Con last year I saw some footage of Routh in action. I was relieved a bit, but not wholly convinced. I think his voice is what turned me around in the early footage. He sounded like a man, not a boy. And he sounded a whole bunch like Christopher Reeve.

I knew it'd take seeing the film, all the sequences in context for me to really get behind him in the role of Superman. He must have been nervous. Not only because he was filling some very large red boots, but as an actor if he blew this opportunity, he'd be gone. None of that shows in his portrayal of the Man of Steel. He's confident, yet very natural in front of the camera. He's the find of the series and I think we can expect some great work in the future, in Metropolis and beyond.

Kevin Spacey as Lex is a genius bit of casting and the one part of the movie I was most looking forward to. And he does make a great Luthor who spends the majority of the film bald, thank the movie gods. However, I think the script is least kind to his character. His whole plan is to create a new country based on the crystal technology he nabs from the fortress of solitude. This country will literally bury most of America under water. There are a few problems here... Firstly, when the crystals form they make giant, black uncomfortable looking jagged rocks. Not quite the beach-front property eager citizens will plop down big bucks for.

Also, if he destroys most of America he should be smart enough to know that a change that sudden in world economics will have a great affect, sending the world's economy into a tailspin. The only part of his plan that makes any sense is using this alien technology and weaponry to establish his country as a power player. But we never see any of these weapons, just the mass-creating crystals.

I may be alone in thinking this, but I honestly think Gene Hackman's Lex was more sinister. He wasn't as successful, for sure. This Lex really has Superman dead to rights and the way he makes his new continent a Superman-free zone is pretty ingenious. Let me rephrase my previous statement. I think the Extended cut of Richard Donner's SUPERMAN shows Lex as a more sinister man. When he finds out what Ms. Teschmacher does, he's going to feed that back-stabbing bitch to the lions. Here, he just kind of looks annoyed.

Kate Bosworth is adorable. I predicted she'd be a big star back in the RULES OF ATTRACTION days and I'm happy to see her establishing herself. She's great as Lois.

The biggest surprise of the film, for me, was how they handled Lois and her son. Mega spoilers here.

By now most everybody knows that the kid is Superman's. I thought this was going to be pretty ridiculous onscreen, played like MUMMY RETURNS or the most recent ZORRO movie, with the kid jumping around and saving the day.

Singer and Co. handle the mystery of the child and his relation to Superman very well, with a nice, subtle touch. I love Lex putting the pieces together. I love the final speech Superman gives. The real heart of the movie is the relationship drama between Lois, Jason (the kid), Richard White (James Marsden) and Superman. I love that the kid never starts flying around doing crazy shit. That sold him being the son of Superman to me. I saw him as a child, not a cartoon.

John Ottman's score is very nice. I loved his score for H20 and thought he did a fantastic job adapting John Carpenter's HALLOWEEN theme there. He does an even better job creating his own themes and mixing them into John Williams' work. Well done.

When Superman is on his rescue craze I was turned into a kid again. The shots of Superman saving someone, placing them gently on the ground and flying off without slowing down had my jaw on the floor. That was the Superman I wanted to see. I loved that the danger seemed to be real. Metal crumples, glass shatters. Superman doesn't just step in and nab an airplane out of the air and deliver it untouched to the ground. And bonus points for Singer and Co. for frequent and badass usage of laser vision.

I hope on the next film they don't spend as much time winking at the camera and copying point by point the original film's structure and characters. On one hand I loved that it was the world I know, the Metropolis I know, but on the other I think they relied too heavily on the original films, spending way too much time referencing them. Parker Posey IS Ms. Teshmacher. Luthor's plan is more ambitious (and more successful), but essentially the same thing he tried before, just a differnt way of going about it. I guess that's why I really dug the family story with Lois, Jason, Richard and Superman so much because it was the only part of the story that wasn't done before.

I know that sounds whiny and like I'm mixed on the movie. I really am not. I enjoyed the film, was awed by the action, really felt for the characters. I think this is a great set-up movie. I really want to see Singer attack the sequel. I want to see the X2 to SUPERMAN RETURNS' X-Men.

So, what did the rest of you think? I know there's a talkback set-up already, but feel free to discuss below. Thanks to WB for helping me see the flick early while here in Wellington, thanks to Kate at Village Roadshow and thanks to Tim at the Reading Cinema.

-Quint
quint@aintitcool.com





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

FIRST!
by solartaco3
Jun 28th, 2006
07:14:42 AM
hey Quint
by Bobo_Vision
Jun 28th, 2006
07:15:43 AM
"badass usage of laser vision"
by tripp5
Jun 28th, 2006
07:23:49 AM

by RangerLee
Jun 28th, 2006
07:26:19 AM
LOVED IT!
by Snookeroo
Jun 28th, 2006
07:26:34 AM
Imax 3D... yup.
by Monknee
Jun 28th, 2006
07:27:48 AM
The movie is a solid B+ effort...
by Uga
Jun 28th, 2006
07:29:35 AM
Why do people still act like Superman 2 is any good?
by zacdilone
Jun 28th, 2006
07:32:31 AM
Bit of a gyp
by DannyOcean01
Jun 28th, 2006
07:38:40 AM
After watching the new Spider-Man trailer...
by Lone Fox
Jun 28th, 2006
07:41:23 AM
1 and 2
by Monknee
Jun 28th, 2006
07:43:56 AM
MELTING OWL & UNSOCIABLE HAMMER
by Shermdawg
Jun 28th, 2006
07:56:52 AM
I thought I was alone in thinking S2 doesn't hold up
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 28th, 2006
07:59:49 AM
So you're from some...
by Kid Z
Jun 28th, 2006
08:08:47 AM
Eddie the dog from Frasier has died.
by BilboRing
Jun 28th, 2006
08:24:27 AM
Sounds Like Moriarty Didn't Like It
by BilboRing
Jun 28th, 2006
08:26:59 AM
x2 was fucking awful
by angrykirby.com
Jun 28th, 2006
08:32:47 AM
I agree with Quint
by Purgatori
Jun 28th, 2006
09:00:26 AM
I can't wait!!!
by vwvoyager
Jun 28th, 2006
09:02:21 AM
saw it last night...
by tango fett
Jun 28th, 2006
09:03:33 AM
I swear to G-d, Zod had better not be in the next one
by moondoggy2u
Jun 28th, 2006
09:06:55 AM
my sympathy go to the owners of moose
by RangerLee
Jun 28th, 2006
09:09:45 AM
Superman 2 DOESN'T Hold Up and ISN'T Very Good...
by hipcheck13
Jun 28th, 2006
09:23:40 AM
MORE COOL NEWS
by BilboRing
Jun 28th, 2006
09:27:54 AM
Laser vision?
by IndyCollector
Jun 28th, 2006
09:30:20 AM
I Like Him (My View)
by repus3000
Jun 28th, 2006
09:30:48 AM
Repus
by moondoggy2u
Jun 28th, 2006
09:42:26 AM
Anyone else have the TRANSFORMERS teaser???
by McGsStepson
Jun 28th, 2006
10:02:18 AM
Glad to see...
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
10:10:46 AM
Lex's continent
by beelkay
Jun 28th, 2006
10:20:48 AM
"I know it sounds whiny, like I'm mixed on the movie.."
by JackPumpkinhead
Jun 28th, 2006
10:21:42 AM
Childe, you do know about the new Donner S2? &Moondoggy
by half vader
Jun 28th, 2006
10:24:40 AM
"Make him look heterosexual, fer chrissakes!"
by moondoggy2u
Jun 28th, 2006
10:25:56 AM
I never knew there was such love for Superman
by cerebulon
Jun 28th, 2006
10:33:13 AM
Gay... Not Gay...
by ZeroCorpse
Jun 28th, 2006
10:33:18 AM
Larry The Cable Guy--- WOULDN'T wear...
by ZeroCorpse
Jun 28th, 2006
10:35:27 AM
Request # 2
by repus3000
Jun 28th, 2006
10:44:58 AM
Parker Posey is WHO???
by aicmb
Jun 28th, 2006
10:53:07 AM
Parker Posey is WHO???
by aicmb
Jun 28th, 2006
10:53:52 AM
Next movie = New Krypton and the threat it poses with..
by Solomon Kane
Jun 28th, 2006
10:56:24 AM
Superman Retires
by NegativeTwo
Jun 28th, 2006
11:04:18 AM
Superman II was a huge letdown 20-some years ago
by Snookeroo
Jun 28th, 2006
11:07:08 AM
Superman 3 still had some great stuff
by oisin5199
Jun 28th, 2006
11:13:34 AM
Loved it
by Buck Turgidson
Jun 28th, 2006
11:15:17 AM
Superman Dies
by AlwaysThere
Jun 28th, 2006
11:30:51 AM
cerebulon, far from 2-D.
by LordEnigma
Jun 28th, 2006
11:38:51 AM
Dude, someone take off the icon!
by mish87
Jun 28th, 2006
11:40:51 AM
just say what everyone thinks PLEASE!
by jezza
Jun 28th, 2006
12:00:07 PM
Minority Report: SUPERMAN 1 was Boooorrrrriiiiing....
by uberman
Jun 28th, 2006
12:10:35 PM
That animated icon is fucking WEAK
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 28th, 2006
12:15:07 PM
LoneFox is right...
by abominate
Jun 28th, 2006
01:29:54 PM
shame on
by cocolopez
Jun 28th, 2006
01:37:59 PM
now if
by cocolopez
Jun 28th, 2006
01:41:13 PM
Sorry Superman fans,
by mrfan
Jun 28th, 2006
01:51:12 PM
It sucked because the 'women' in it were not like this
by zfisk
Jun 28th, 2006
01:53:39 PM
Vader, I'd heard about the "Donner" cut...
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
01:59:21 PM
Supes is a Deadbeat Dad
by abominate
Jun 28th, 2006
02:00:04 PM
Preciate guys.
by JuggFuckler
Jun 28th, 2006
02:05:13 PM
I hope Lois takes him to court.
by mrfan
Jun 28th, 2006
02:06:28 PM
for making supes father a kid, SINGER IS AN IDIOT
by zfisk
Jun 28th, 2006
02:08:16 PM
the movie was awesome
by BALTIMOREJACK
Jun 28th, 2006
02:22:04 PM
This week on Montel Williams - Daddy DNA testing!
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 28th, 2006
02:23:50 PM
YOKO KNOWLES!!!!!!!!!
by 2Girth2Ferguson
Jun 28th, 2006
02:27:43 PM
I've complained about the icon, others have too...
by Doctor_Sin
Jun 28th, 2006
02:32:58 PM
No shit Doctor Sin!
by FordPerfect
Jun 28th, 2006
02:45:24 PM
While I appreciate your outrage, 2Girth...
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
03:02:13 PM
The kid will be forgotten in a sequel
by Rupee88
Jun 28th, 2006
03:06:41 PM
Ha!
by Mr Nice Gaius
Jun 28th, 2006
03:23:07 PM
I have to say that the AICN animation is pretty gross
by moondoggy2u
Jun 28th, 2006
03:26:42 PM
George Reeve I know,
by 2Girth2Ferguson
Jun 28th, 2006
03:40:23 PM
RIght, 2Girth....
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
04:09:39 PM
Just got back from seeing it
by El Cimarron
Jun 28th, 2006
04:14:43 PM
And while we're on the animation...
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
04:16:59 PM
The kid solution
by zacdilone
Jun 28th, 2006
04:23:14 PM
Robin Williams as The Joker...
by flanaganagain
Jun 28th, 2006
04:26:20 PM
AMEN YackBacker!
by Dragoon_jefy
Jun 28th, 2006
05:13:57 PM
That pic in the corner is HERCULES'S avatar, dressed up
by George Newman
Jun 28th, 2006
05:23:06 PM
Robin Williams as The Joker would suck ass
by I Dunno
Jun 28th, 2006
05:37:43 PM
Robin Williams is on crack
by zacdilone
Jun 28th, 2006
05:38:12 PM
Ho ho 2Girth doesn't know what the word "Hero" means
by half vader
Jun 28th, 2006
05:45:29 PM
spacey:"NONONO YOURE NOT SEEING THE BIG PICTURE HERE.."
by zfisk
Jun 28th, 2006
05:52:14 PM
Kate Bosworth was miscast
by Oceanlizard
Jun 28th, 2006
05:59:38 PM
Williams as the Joker at this point...
by Childe Roland
Jun 28th, 2006
06:01:21 PM
the movie needed this chick to be lois
by zfisk
Jun 28th, 2006
06:03:01 PM
For the inevitable sequel, bring on Darkseid!
by Red Raider
Jun 28th, 2006
06:41:50 PM
adrien brody or josh lucas for joker
by slappy jones
Jun 28th, 2006
07:04:33 PM
Crispin Glover is the no brainer
by I Dunno
Jun 28th, 2006
07:20:46 PM
pfff...Eccleston pwns all those suggestions
by lynxpro
Jun 28th, 2006
07:22:02 PM
Well lynxpro, at least you're not given to hyperbole
by I Dunno
Jun 28th, 2006
07:40:09 PM
QUINT FIGHT UWE BOLL!!
by wolack22
Jun 28th, 2006
08:03:24 PM
Kate Bosworth is hot.
by Mr Brownstone
Jun 28th, 2006
09:00:49 PM
zfisk
by allfunandgames
Jun 28th, 2006
09:16:48 PM
ENTWIRE: WEINER BROS. and zfisk to produce'doucheman 2'
by zfisk
Jun 28th, 2006
09:40:16 PM
First off, if it wasn't for Richard Donner's SUPERMAN:
by decfx
Jun 28th, 2006
09:42:09 PM
I hate children
by The Dum Guy
Jun 28th, 2006
11:05:41 PM
Just posting this sucker on this site, too.
by moondoggy2u
Jun 28th, 2006
11:28:39 PM
I want to see Ratner's Superman
by Agro
Jun 29th, 2006
01:54:48 AM
SUPERMAN 2
by thepuppydog
Jun 29th, 2006
02:14:15 AM
It's "Luthor" dammit!
by grendel824
Jun 29th, 2006
03:39:52 AM
I'm I paranoid or anti-Semitic?
by concernedviewer
Jun 29th, 2006
03:47:17 AM
FIST!
by CuervoJones
Jun 29th, 2006
05:05:05 AM
Gayest superhero: Captain America
by CuervoJones
Jun 29th, 2006
05:17:10 AM
You're nuts if you think Cap is gay.
by Shermdawg
Jun 29th, 2006
05:53:38 AM
"hearing John Williams in THX again" by repus3000
by JRo
Jun 29th, 2006
07:10:53 AM
Nice review, I agree with almost all of it.
by minderbinder
Jun 29th, 2006
09:18:32 AM
Well...
by GEORGEFNLUCAS
Jun 29th, 2006
09:21:16 AM
Well...
by GEORGEFNLUCAS
Jun 29th, 2006
09:21:21 AM
Robin Williams is best suited as the Ventriloquist.
by JDanielP
Jun 29th, 2006
10:05:28 AM
"Fucked-up European understanding"
by half vader
Jun 29th, 2006
12:13:24 PM
Superman Returns
by geministyle10
Jun 29th, 2006
03:21:00 PM
to I Dunno
by lynxpro
Jun 29th, 2006
05:04:31 PM
Half-Vader
by GEORGEFNLUCAS
Jun 30th, 2006
11:28:34 AM
Yes you're right the Salkinds are fucking insane.
by half vader
Jun 30th, 2006
12:07:43 PM
don't equate Britain with the other Euro hasbeens
by lynxpro
Jun 30th, 2006
07:12:41 PM
We are now friends, Half-Vader...
by GEORGEFNLUCAS
Jul 2nd, 2006
05:35:39 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.