Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

HD-DVD DAY ONE BRINGS SERENITY NOW!! Herc's Super-Unimpressive Extra-Puny HDTV Cellar!!

I am – Hercules!!

Questions, we get HDTV questions.

I see little difference between a TV picture and an HDTV picture! Why would I replace my beautiful DVD collection with this bogus new HD-DVD format?
Why, indeed? If you really can’t see a significant difference between TV and HDTV, save your money, friend. In fact, the really good news for you and those like you is that HD-DVD is already driving the cost of old-school DVD way downward. Best movies ever, super-cheap on DVD. Want a new DVD copy of “2001: A Space Odyssey”? $8.99. “The Godfather”? $13.99. “Jaws” (Widescreen 25th Anniversary Edition)? $10.58. “The Wrath of Khan” (Director’s Edition)? $8.36. Pretty sweet for everyone, this HD-DVD era, if you were to ask me!

But do you, Mighty Hercules, see a significant difference between TV and HDTV?
Some will tell you HD is the most important development to hit TV since color. I’m with them. Going from the standard definition format (used for VHS, Laserdisc and DVD) to high definition is like getting your first prescription eyeglasses, or wiping a thick layer of dust from your window. VCRs and DVD players are modern miracles, no question. But once you spend a little time with an HD signal, you really get a sense of how much visual information is lost in the transition from 35mm to standard definition. HD lets you read EVERYTHING on Professor Charles Xavier’s classroom chalkboard, not just the stuff written in really big letters.

Can I play my old DVDs on the HD-DVD player?
I’m told yes, but keep in mind that Homeland Security does not force you to turn in your old DVD player when you buy an HD-DVD (or Blu-ray) player. My HDTV set has multiple inputs that allow me to pipe in DVD and HD signals simultaneously. Chances are, yours does too.



Won’t the HD-disc format, like the laserdisc format before it, almost certainly fail to catch on with the mainstream?
I give HD-DVD much better odds than laserdisc, which truthfully didn’t represent anywhere near as dramatic an upgrade in picture quality. Also? The calendar below demonstrates that new HD-DVDs are priced about the same as regular DVDs, offering a lot more visual bang for the buck. Good-size HDTV sets are down to $700. And the HD-DVD players rolling out into the marketplace this week and next cost only $500, which is about what the early DVD players cost. (I’m less certain about the prospects of the rival Blu-ray format rolling out this autumn. Blu-ray players are expected to sell for $1,000 per unit, and the Blu-ray discs, one hears, are expected to sell for more than their HD-DVD counterparts.)



But aren’t Blu-ray discs better for video games?
I don’t know from video games. But unless the Blu-ray videogame players play movies in HD, this strikes me as an unrelated issue.

Alright already! I must go now to buy a skinny HDTV to hook up my HD-DVD player so I can play these HD-DVDs I so covet. Do I go with plasma or LCD?
I’ve spent many an hour at Circuit City, squinting at monitors and pondering this very question. Here’s a helpful recent article that compares and contrasts the formats.



Should “Serenity” be my first HD-DVD purchase ever?
I’ve heard worse ideas! It’s got that script by Joss Whedon (he wrote the exciting cartoon about the talking toys you know!) and space battles by the Zoic special effects people. If, like me, you’ve seen the new “Battlestar Galactica” on the Universal HD Channel, you know how spectacular those Zoic space battles look in HD. Much better than the space battles in “Phantom of the Opera”!!

Speaking of which, here’s what else you have to choose from at this, the dawn of the HD-DVD era:


Herc’s Puny HD-DVD Calendar

April 18
Chronos $16.99




The Last Samurai $19.98




Million Dollar Baby $19.98




The Phantom of the Opera $19.98




Serenity $24.49 <--- NEW!!

April 25




Apollo 13 $24.49 <--- NEW!!




Doom $24.49 <--- NEW!!

May 9




Assault on Precinct 13 $23.99 <--- NEW!!




Cinderella Man $23.99 <--- NEW!!




Jarhead $23.99 <--- NEW!!

May 23




The Bourne Supremacy $23.99 <--- NEW!!




The Chronicles of Riddick $23.99 <--- NEW!!




Van Helsing $23.99 <--- NEW!!




U-571 $23.99 <--- NEW!!





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback

Blu Ray and PS3
by OhDaesu
Apr 18th, 2006
01:38:06 AM
ohDaesu
by dogsbottom
Apr 18th, 2006
01:47:53 AM
Got mine...
by CMBat
Apr 18th, 2006
01:52:14 AM
I hope Blu-Ray wins
by Rupee88
Apr 18th, 2006
01:55:02 AM
Nope, sorry, as long as Metal Gear and...
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
02:00:04 AM
Those prices are still fairly steep, but shit,
by iamnicksaicnsn
Apr 18th, 2006
02:19:10 AM
Plasma or LCD?...Neither!
by Ktak
Apr 18th, 2006
02:50:15 AM
iamnicksaicnsn
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
03:33:05 AM
These 1st gen HD-DVD players only output 1080i
by half vader
Apr 18th, 2006
03:37:42 AM
Sherm, you from Canada?
by Pdid
Apr 18th, 2006
03:39:45 AM
Pdid, I remember N64 games costing over $60
by vikingkitty
Apr 18th, 2006
05:03:03 AM
I won't be getting HD-DVD any time soon...
by vroom socko
Apr 18th, 2006
05:06:02 AM
Anyone who buys one this week
by ChorleyFM
Apr 18th, 2006
05:06:16 AM
"buy a skinny HDTV"
by newc0253
Apr 18th, 2006
05:21:29 AM
"if you can afford $1000 for a goddamn tv set"
by newc0253
Apr 18th, 2006
05:24:55 AM
Renting is only cheaper if
by ChorleyFM
Apr 18th, 2006
05:38:34 AM
You Aren't Wrong, vikingkitty
by Incomplete Gamer
Apr 18th, 2006
06:43:04 AM
I just tracked down my receipts. yes, I still got 'em.
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
06:47:13 AM
Buying is only cheaper if
by newc0253
Apr 18th, 2006
06:59:51 AM
GTA would be PS3 exclusive for 6 months/to a year
by RealDoubleJ
Apr 18th, 2006
07:05:28 AM
most expensive videogame? Street Fighter 3
by RealDoubleJ
Apr 18th, 2006
07:07:22 AM
"TV" picture does NOT include EDTV
by rogerconnery
Apr 18th, 2006
07:15:50 AM
Hey, don't knock early adopters!
by Ktak
Apr 18th, 2006
07:30:24 AM
RealDoubleJ, do you mean Super Street Fighter II?
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
07:49:15 AM
Street Fighter 3
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
07:52:08 AM
* "it didn't come out 'til like 1997" (in arcades)
by Shermdawg
Apr 18th, 2006
07:53:34 AM
Please buy lots of these
by VibroCount
Apr 18th, 2006
08:30:59 AM
All you people buying Plasma or LCD...
by Razorback
Apr 18th, 2006
08:59:09 AM
HD DVD really tightens up a movie's script too
by HypeEndsHere
Apr 18th, 2006
09:09:17 AM
Damn, Herc is a smarmy prick
by I Dunno
Apr 18th, 2006
09:14:47 AM
I can't wait for the PS3 to come out
by Big Jim
Apr 18th, 2006
09:35:53 AM
VAN HELSING in HD! LOL, what's next?
by Orbots Commander
Apr 18th, 2006
10:16:09 AM
Street fighter III = Street fighter Alpha
by Krigan
Apr 18th, 2006
11:12:26 AM
HDDVD!?
by stlfilmwire
Apr 18th, 2006
11:13:01 AM
My opinion
by moviemaniac-7
Apr 18th, 2006
11:16:45 AM
EVERYONE LISTEN TO HALF VADER...
by McLuvin
Apr 18th, 2006
11:17:32 AM
Anyone buying Van Helsing in HD needs fucking shot.
by Grando
Apr 18th, 2006
11:23:47 AM
Blu-Ray movies actually cost THE SAME.
by MrFloppy
Apr 18th, 2006
12:00:51 PM
I remember paying 90 bucks for Donkey Kong Country 2
by Chicken2nite
Apr 18th, 2006
12:05:58 PM
shit in HD, great.
by quadrupletree
Apr 18th, 2006
12:06:44 PM
dude, 1080i is still 1080
by Chicken2nite
Apr 18th, 2006
12:09:52 PM
just wait for apple to come out with a set top box...
by Chicken2nite
Apr 18th, 2006
12:18:13 PM
blue-ray migth take over
by joevfx
Apr 18th, 2006
12:31:10 PM
Dvd Only Took Off When It Became Affordable To Poor
by flamingrunt
Apr 18th, 2006
12:41:51 PM
The PS3
by Koyaanisqatsi
Apr 18th, 2006
01:24:04 PM
Don't buy ANY of this CRAP!
by Strabo
Apr 18th, 2006
01:25:35 PM
I go where the Metal Gear goes..
by Neo Zeed
Apr 18th, 2006
01:39:38 PM
i forgot
by Koyaanisqatsi
Apr 18th, 2006
01:59:00 PM
Holy crap!
by quadrupletree
Apr 18th, 2006
02:19:41 PM
1080i vs 1080p is irrelevant for film..
by ulcer
Apr 18th, 2006
03:51:25 PM
Just say HELL NO.
by Harry Weinstein
Apr 18th, 2006
03:55:20 PM
Plasma TV next year
by Jack Burton
Apr 18th, 2006
05:28:32 PM
Metal GEAR
by RezE11even
Apr 18th, 2006
06:05:21 PM
The HDCP truly does sucketh...
by Johnno
Apr 18th, 2006
06:32:12 PM
Oh and I'm betting PS3 will be $499.99 US
by Johnno
Apr 18th, 2006
06:48:02 PM
Wow
by moogu2
Apr 18th, 2006
06:55:23 PM
Embarassing Flashback
by proper
Apr 18th, 2006
07:40:46 PM
The Toshibas won't play DVD+R
by geekzapoppin
Apr 18th, 2006
08:12:20 PM
Blu-ray and DVDs ... PS3 will play movies
by 2
Apr 18th, 2006
08:12:34 PM
Big Jim, you're my hero
by chrth
Apr 18th, 2006
09:11:12 PM
PS3 question
by Hercules
Apr 18th, 2006
09:19:36 PM
"if you can afford $1000 for a goddamn tv set"
by Voice O. Reason
Apr 18th, 2006
10:02:18 PM
Hercules
by Johnno
Apr 19th, 2006
12:06:31 AM
Plus we ought to consider teh future bringin 3D-TV
by Johnno
Apr 19th, 2006
12:10:16 AM
HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray = Betamax vs. VHS
by Col. Klink
Apr 19th, 2006
01:32:37 AM
Why a $1000 Blu-ray player?
by Ktak
Apr 19th, 2006
02:28:45 AM
My Mum & Dad haven't got a DVD Player
by Rex Manning
Apr 19th, 2006
02:36:07 AM
I'll get interested
by Lezbo Milk
Apr 19th, 2006
02:49:31 AM
My Mum & Dad haven't got a tv
by newc0253
Apr 19th, 2006
03:06:31 AM
So far it looks like only crap is available on HD-DVD
by Trazadone
Apr 19th, 2006
06:46:43 AM
correction
by Koyaanisqatsi
Apr 19th, 2006
08:08:59 AM
Blu ray will find support on the pc market to be sure
by Chicken2nite
Apr 19th, 2006
09:09:49 AM
Titles likely to launch with Blu-Ray...
by Johnno
Apr 19th, 2006
09:13:06 AM
But aren
by MinasTirithII
Apr 19th, 2006
11:02:50 AM
But aren
by Johnno
Apr 19th, 2006
11:36:13 AM
You are right, Col. Klink
by moviemaniac-7
Apr 19th, 2006
01:53:21 PM
This is why PHANTOM was one of the first HD-DVDS
by Kraken
Apr 19th, 2006
05:06:46 PM
Dammit, Kraken, you beat me to it
by chrth
Apr 19th, 2006
05:58:21 PM
Why you dissin' laserdisc?
by Mgmax
Apr 19th, 2006
09:57:52 PM
Dammit, Kraken, you beat me to it part II
by Tall_Boy
Apr 19th, 2006
10:59:51 PM
Bravo, Mgmax!
by Ktak
Apr 20th, 2006
12:38:29 AM
Both formats may "win"
by Rupee88
Apr 20th, 2006
07:47:46 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.