Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

ROTTERDAM: Elaine sings the praises of Shunji Iwai's HANA & ALICE and Koreeda's NOBODY KNOWS!!

Hey folks, Harry here with Elaine in Rotterdam to fill us in on two incredibly great sounding movies as described in her usual eloquent and intelligent style. I am so happy with the coverage we've been getting out of Rotterdam - the films have sounded wonderful and hopefully we'll see some of these titles programmed at fests around the U.S. for our domestic readers to get a chance to appreciate. Outstanding job, Elaine! Here she is...

34th ROTTERDAM INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL

As the festival draws to a close, more and more prizes are being awarded. The two latest awards to have been handed out are the Amnesty International Award for best film dealing with a human-rights subject and the Moviezone Youth Award. The former went to Hassan Yektapanah's "Story Undone", a documentary-like feature on a group of people trying to flee Iran; the latter was awarded to Gregg Araki's "Mysterious Skin", a brave, powerful, and brilliantly written and acted drama about two sexually abused boys who grow up to be pretty fucked-up young men. I haven't seen the former, but the latter is excellent - very much worth seeking out.

Still to be announced: the winners of the Tiger Awards (Rotterdam's recgonition of first- or second-time directors) and the Audience Award. A day before the end of the festival, Susanne Bier's "Brothers" is still the favourite for the latter distinction, followed by Bahman Ghobadi's "Turtles Can Fly" (an Iranian film I will review later) and "The Edukators".

So what have I got for you today? Well, er, reviews of two Japanese flicks by festival favourites Hirokazu Koreeda and Shunji Iwai. Neither will score very highly on Harry's Cult-O-Meter, but don't let that keep you from giving them a chance - they're brilliant films, wonderfully atmospheric, poignant and well acted, which will please real film fans more than anything Japan's cult directors could churn out.

Film number one, "Hana and Alice" is the latest by Shunji Iwai, Japan's grand master of lyricism. Ostensibly about a silly teenage friendship, but really about so much more than that, it's the kind of film which has you smiling for minutes on end because it's so charmingly silly, and occasionally causes you either to laugh out loud or to get a lump in your throat because it's simply so... beautiful. There aren't too many films which achieve that effect, so savour it.

The second film is Hirokazu Koreeda's "Nobody Knows", a melancholy adaptation of a true story in which an irresponsible mother walks out on her four kids aged 5-12, who are then left to fend for themselves. It's a far cry from Takashi Miike and his wild, violent brethren, but it's moving as hell, and shocking in a superb, understated manner.

Enjoy. I'll be back later with reviews of films both cool and utterly uncool.

HANA AND ALICE (Hana to Aris)

(Written and directed by Shunji Iwai)

In his previous film, the stunningly beautiful "All About Lily Chou-Chou" (2001), Shunji Iwai explored the dark excesses of Japanese high-school life: bullying, extortion, rape and prostitution. In his latest, "Hana and Alice", he returns to the subject of troubled schoolgirls, but with an entirely different result. Where "All About Lily Chou-Chou" was a dark and haunting mood piece, "Hana and Alice" is a quirky comedy full of brilliant little touches and a lot of very infectious charm. It veers from silliness to genuine poignancy, and comes highly recommended to those who like their films with a bit of heart and poetry.

"Hana and Alice" is the story of two silly teenage girls called, um, Hana and Alice. Well, actually they're called Hana and Tetsuko, but that doesn't matter. What does matter is that one day, the girls, who have been best friends for as long as they can remember, spot a couple of guys on the train whom they rather fancy. One of them is a tall Eurasian; the other is a quiet, geeky boy who is always seen reading. Hana (a great, bossy Anne Suzuki) quickly develops a crush on the quiet boy, and starts following him around, even going so far as to take his pictures on the sly. One day, the boy has an accident. Not paying any attention to where he's going, he walks into a garage door and knocks himself out. When he comes to, he is so confused that Hana smells her chance. She asks the boy (who is called Masashi) if he remembers her, and when he says no, she tells him she is his girlfriend. She is so convincing that Masashi believes her, and blames his not remembering her on amnesia caused by the blow to his head.

So far, so "While You Were Sleeping", but that's pretty much where the comparison ends. Unlike Sandra Bullock, Hana doesn't have to deal with sceptical relatives of the boy; Masashi (a loner whose family never even enters the story) seems convinced that she is telling the truth, and duly tries to pierce together the past he can't remember. In order keep up her charade, Hana enlists Alice's help; she is to play Masashi's ex-girlfriend, whom he dumped in order to be with Hana. There are a few problems, though. For one thing, Alice (superbly played by Yu Aoi, who also excelled in "All About Lily Chou-Chou") is a spectacularly bad actress; for another, Masashi actually seems to prefer her to Hana, to the point where he wonders why he ever traded her in for Hana. Thus the stage is set for a complicated love triangle, an increasingly elaborate deception and considerable tension between Hana and Alice, who gradually forget they're supposed to be best friends and throw themselves into their favourite hobbies: dancing and acting.

"Hana and Alice" evolved from a few short films Iwai shot for KitKat. This is a fact which can be detected in the final product; the film occasionally has a disjointed feeling, as if Iwai wasn't sure where to put his popular set-pieces. It could also be argued that he changes his focus too much. Rather than concentrating on the love triangle and its effects on the girls' friendship, Iwai switches back and forth between his protagonists and throws in several subplots centring on family life and dreams of becoming famous. Yet it's hard to blame him for making a few detours every now and then, for not only do the subplots provide a wealth of background information on both girls, but they also feature some of the funniest and most moving scenes in the film. One of these is obviously one of the original KitKat scenes; I'd like to know whether the other ones were, as well.

To me, the standout storyline (one of the funniest things I've seen in the whole festival) is the one in which shy Alice decides to become an actress. What follows is a series of unbelievably bad auditions which baffles casting directors all over Tokyo and makes the viewer like kind, dreamy Alice even more. Yu Aoi is superb here; I've seldom seen a good actress play a bad one with more conviction. She is also very good in the subplot concerning her absentee father, which not only features the funniest (and truest) exposition on fountain pens in the history of cinema, but some of the best writing and direction of which Iwai is capable - which is to say, very good indeed.

In the end, "Hana and Alice" is a poignant meditation on friendship, loneliness, unrequited love, honesty and teenage dreams and obsessions, which wears its lyricism on its sleeve and is all the better for it. Like many Iwai films, it features great, atmospheric visuals (beautifully poetic images of flowers, dreamy landscapes and dancing girls) as well as very funny, unexpected absurd touches. Needless to say, it also features Japanese characters speaking Chinese, a butterfly motif and lots of romantic music (composed by Iwai himself), because no Iwai film would be complete without those.

.....................................................

NOBODY KNOWS (Daremo shiranai)

(Written and directed by Hiokazu Koreeda)

A childish-looking single mother moves into a new flat and introduces her 12-year-old son Akira to her new landlord. After a polite chat, mother and son go back to their own flat, where they open up two big suitcases. Out come two children: a boy and a girl, Akira's younger siblings, who are told to be very, very quiet, because if anyone finds out they're in the apartment, the family will be kicked out, like they have before. A few hours later, a fourth child shows up: 11-year-old Kyoko, who has waited in the street until it was dark before making her way to the new flat. She is informed that this is the last time she's been out; from now on, she has to stay inside to keep the little ones quiet while her mother is out working, so as not to alert the neighbours to the presence of the kids. Only Akira is allowed to go out; after all, someone has to do the family shopping.

The above would make plenty of material for a good film, but in "Nobody Knows", there's more to it. You see, it turns out that the mother has a habit of disappearing. Leaving the children some money, she vanishes for weeks on end, and when she comes back, she offers neither an apology nor an explanation for her absence. She just gives her kids some presents, explains patiently why they can't go to school like normal children, and tells them to bear their fate as well as they can. And then she disappears for good, never to return, leaving the kids to fend for themselves on a supply of money which is bound to run out very soon.

Loosely based on a true story which rocked Japan in the late 1980s, "Nobody Knows" is a tale of adult selfishness and children's resilience. It's the story of Akira, a boy forced to become a father of three at an age when most kids only think of playing games and skiving off school. Akira makes a brilliant surrogate father to his siblings. He finds them food, buys them chocolates when they're feeling low and keeps up morale by telling them their mother will soon return, even if he is by no means sure of this himself. He even gives them presents ostensibly sent by their mother, so that they won't hate her for abandoning them for such a long time. But he's only twelve years old, and like most 12-year-olds, he has more on his mind than just being a sweet older brother.

More than a just a harrowing family drama, "Nobody Knows" is a coming-of-age drama, which in Akira gets an appealing hero: a 12-year-old who knows the well-being of his younger siblings depends on him, but also wants to be a normal teenager who hangs out with friends, plays video games, tries to be cool and dreams of becoming a baseball star. The problem is that Akira doesn't actually have any friends, because he doesn't go to school and is too busy scoring food for his siblings to hang out and do the things kids his age do. But he really wants to be a normal teenager, he really does, and in the discrepancy between his dreams and his actual circumstances lies half of the drama.

"Nobody Knows" is a marvellously directed film. It was shot chronologically over the course of a year, and it shows. Not only do the children get dirtier and more obviously neglected as the film progresses, but they actually visibly grow older. It is obvious Koreeda established an atmosphere of great trust with his young cast, because the scenes shot in the tiny Tokyo apartment where seventy per cent of the action takes place ooze naturalness. Even the smaller children, one of whom was apparently quite hard to instruct, come across as completely natural. In doing so, they infuse the incredible story with some recognisability. We all know children like the ones depicted in the film; they may lead extraordinary lives, but at the end of the day they're ordinary kids, who react to their bizarre circumstances the way every child would. In showing us these children in a fly-on-the-wall manner, Koreeda not only tells an amazing story of juvenile resilience, but effectively presents us with a chronicle of childhood in general. It never gets sentimental or truly shocking, but with its quiet, documentary-like approach, it packs an emotional punch rarely seen in Western cinema.

There is some superb acting in the film. Yuya Yagira was awarded the top acting prize at Cannes for his incredibly realistic depiction of Akira, and rightly so; he does a brilliant job capturing the boy trapped between childhood and adulthood, between responsibility and escapism. Ayu Kitaura is equally good as his frustrated 11-year-old sister Kyoko, who dreams of becoming a pianist but only has a toy piano to practise on. Hiei Kimura and Momoko Shimizu are cute as hell as the younger children, and TV personality You (who actually functioned as a kind of second director on the set) is so cringe-inducingly irresponsible and selfish as the mother that you regularly want to smack her to beat some sense into her. It's actually a relief when she buggers off for good, because as hard as life may be for the children without a loving parent, you get the feeling they're better off without her, because she is such an unwholesome presence in their lives.

"Nobody Knows" is a near-perfect drama. If it has any flaws, they're in its length (at 141 minutes, it feels a tad long; the second act could have done with some judicious editing) and in the fact that the kids are just a little too cute and well-behaved to be completely realistic. Don't get me wrong, they're perfectly natural, and often completely adorable, but even so, you sometimes wish for an equally natural tantrum or crying fit to get the whole spectrum of children's behaviour. These are minor flaws, though; what remains is a powerful, masterful film that stays with you for a long time.

Elaine

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

am i the first?
by DarthBakpao
Feb 5th, 2005
06:14:39 AM
ZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzz..........Nob ody cares.
by Swarmy
Feb 5th, 2005
07:30:25 AM
...
by Gluecifer
Feb 5th, 2005
08:10:42 AM
nobody knows
by talbuckin
Feb 5th, 2005
10:46:03 AM
nobody knows is playing the nyc now
by Acne Scarface
Feb 5th, 2005
10:57:13 AM

by Mafu
Feb 5th, 2005
11:22:21 AM
These reports are becoming a very cruel kind of torture
by mortsleam
Feb 5th, 2005
11:38:32 AM
I'm with mort on this one.
by raw_bean
Feb 5th, 2005
02:11:29 PM
you know what we call as stupid movies?
by DarthBakpao
Feb 5th, 2005
09:37:34 PM
Shunji Iwai
by Shan
Feb 5th, 2005
10:19:20 PM
Whatre you 2 ninnys blubbering about, Mort, bean...
by Skyway Moaters
Feb 6th, 2005
03:34:18 AM
To Swarmy
by RoomOnFire
Feb 6th, 2005
01:45:39 PM
Does this bear any relation to...
by Christopher3
Feb 7th, 2005
10:12:37 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.