Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

AICN COMICS: BILL JEMAS vs. PETER DAVID!! THE MARVEL vs. CAPTAIN MARVEL!!

Hey, everyone. "Moriarty" here with some Rumblings From The Lab.

Why is it that guys in the comics world don't just disagree or argue? They feud. They war. And in this case, they compete in the most public manner possible. Both Bill Jemas and Peter David are men who have riled up fans and other professionals in the past, and now they're going head to head with the fate of a character at stake. Check this out:

Hi Gang. My favorite columnist and yours, Marvel President Bill Jemas recently entered the ongoing Peter David/Joe Quesada debate on what to do about the series, Captain Marvel. About a month ago, it looked like Captain Marvel, along with Black Panther and Spider-Girl, was getting canceled. Responding to fan support and a suggestion made by a fan in Bill's 'Don't Ask' Column, Marvel decided to increase the price of the books by 25 cents. While the Spider-Girl and Black Panther camps were relatively quiet about the decision, Peter David publicly criticized Marvel's decision to raise the price of the book. An online debate between David and Marvel Editor in Chief Joe Quesada ensued, holding the interest of comic book fans for several weeks until it was ultimately decided that none of the books would get an increase in price and they would still be spared from cancellation, at least for another year.

But we didn't get to hear what Bill Jemas thought about all of this until late last week. The Marvel President came up with a most democratic solution to the situation, as reported by Michael Sangiacomo of Newsarama….

The Marvel universe is a big place, but there's only enough room for one guy named "Marvel."

Marvel Comics President Bill Jemas could simply anger loyal fans and cancel Captain Marvel, a comic which sells poorly and replace it with his own new character The Marvel.

But where's the sport in that?

Instead, Jemas and Captain Marvel author Peter David will play Survivor.

Jemas will write six months worth of The Marvel which will go on sale beginning in September. That month Peter David, with some assistance from Marvel Editor-in-Chief Joe Quesada, will release the first of the best half-dozen issues of Captain Marvel that he can write.

After six months, the comic that sold the most copies wins. The losing comic gets cancelled.

Is it a stunt?

Sure, but it's also an interesting way to settle a very public controversy.

Jemas has some strong ideas about what makes a comic successful and he said that David is not following those suggestions. Jemas' response is to do it himself. He believes if an untried writer like himself can score bigger numbers by following his suggestions, than David will have to admit there must be something to that approach.

"I have helped springboard some comics into being, like X-Force and Ultimate Spider-Man, but someone else did the writing and the scripting," Jemas said. "This will be the first time I have conceived of a series and did all the writing myself."

The battle began last month when Marvel announced plans to raise the price of Captain Marvel by 25 cents ($2.50 to $2.75 in Cap's case). Jemas said the logic was that the fans would pay the extra quarter and Marvel could continue to publish it.

"We thought it would make a certain number of people happy if we kept publishing the book," he said. "It would be a quarter more, big deal."

David was outraged. He publicly chastised his bosses for not supporting his comic with advertising. He said he would cut his own pay to make up the difference if Marvel would leave the price at $2.50.

"Everyone is missing the point," Jemas said. "Peter is a talented writer maybe two or three issues of the year, but the rest is just inside jokes for fans who have been reading his stuff for 20 years. He's just feeding off his old work. I feel that he needs to make his stories accessible to new readers or it's doomed."

To Get the Full Story on 'The Marvel' and the rest of Bill Jemas comments, you can find the original article, in its entirety: RIGHT HERE!!

Thanks again to Andrew of Gray Haven Magazine.com for the article.

"Moriarty" out.





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Peter David vs Bill Jemas
by liquidlen
Apr 2nd, 2002
11:56:00 AM
umm yeah
by mstryoda
Apr 2nd, 2002
11:59:15 AM
Old News and Dirty Fascists
by NexusKnight
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:11:52 PM
Isn't this just a popularity contest between Jemas and David
by Chilli Kramer
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:28:35 PM
IT WAS ONE THING WHEN IT WAS A SO-CALLED "FIGHT"...NOW IT JUST S
by Big Dumb Ape
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:35:27 PM
ill buy THE MARVEL because jemas is cool
by THE PROFESSOR
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:41:04 PM
Where's Peter David's role in this?
by Kimota42
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:44:30 PM
Marvel Shouldn't Even Have A Character Called CAPTAIN MARVEL
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:44:43 PM
Won't the interest factor alone, skew the results?
by RenoNevada2000
Apr 2nd, 2002
12:54:12 PM
Marvel President Bill Jemas Here With A Message For Our Stockhol
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:01:04 PM
it's a ruse
by rev_skarekroe
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:04:11 PM
The Proposal For THE MARVEL by Market Resear--...Bill Jemas.
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:07:44 PM
last week's news...
by cncoyle
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:22:33 PM
Writing The First Issue Of THE MARVEL...
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:38:04 PM
Why is anyone even here...
by ZakChase
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:41:11 PM
Ruined Spider-Man novelization
by gilker
Apr 2nd, 2002
01:46:53 PM
Art For THE MARVEL...
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:12:39 PM
"No, Bill, You Cannot Change Your Name To Kevin Smith!"
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:14:14 PM
Re: "Marvel Shouldn't Even Have A Character Called CAPTAIN M
by Strawhenge
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:21:11 PM
Peter David's got to go
by Judge Mental
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:23:25 PM
Peter David's got to go
by Judge Mental
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:23:58 PM
Bug on Comics
by Ambush Bug
Apr 2nd, 2002
02:31:31 PM
Bug
by Strawhenge
Apr 2nd, 2002
03:18:33 PM
buzz, the real way to give some "edge" to a character...
by DEVIL
Apr 2nd, 2002
03:39:37 PM
Have Captain Marvel join the Avengers
by dickfitz
Apr 2nd, 2002
04:05:16 PM
Captain Marvel to Relaunch with a new #1
by GrayHaven
Apr 2nd, 2002
04:32:32 PM
I'll buy David's comic cuz I've been a fan of his ST
by Tall_Boy
Apr 2nd, 2002
04:41:15 PM
Strawhenge
by Ambush Bug
Apr 2nd, 2002
04:45:13 PM
Another public PISSING match by Marvels Cheif MORON!
by RickSlamu2
Apr 2nd, 2002
05:01:06 PM
Elektra, and the stupid fued
by WritersCramp
Apr 2nd, 2002
05:09:37 PM
Writers Cramp, Miller Brought Elektra Back & Killed Her Off In E
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
06:05:09 PM
Also, D.E.V.I.L. And Ambush Bug Are Right.
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
06:10:18 PM
Anybody Read That THE ULTIMATES Book? Art Looks Cool.
by Buzz Maverik
Apr 2nd, 2002
06:15:20 PM
Bug - Re: continuity revision
by Strawhenge
Apr 2nd, 2002
07:20:07 PM
Ultimate Spider-Man...
by Jack Ryder
Apr 2nd, 2002
07:31:50 PM
Peter David is gonna kick Bill Jemas' ass
by holidill
Apr 2nd, 2002
08:57:16 PM
Peter David writes Young Justice and Supergirl (who incidentally
by Village Idiot
Apr 2nd, 2002
10:20:10 PM
I hope Peter David beats the $#!+ out of Jemas
by KingKrypton
Apr 2nd, 2002
10:49:33 PM
have the anti-David's ever read Supergirl?
by cncoyle
Apr 2nd, 2002
10:55:31 PM
I just realized something...
by cncoyle
Apr 2nd, 2002
11:05:34 PM
Peter David is the fucking man
by TheMatarife
Apr 3rd, 2002
01:42:51 AM
Just My Two Cents...
by Spelunker Gregg
Apr 3rd, 2002
01:54:35 AM
Just My Two Cents...Again...
by Spelunker Gregg
Apr 3rd, 2002
02:04:07 AM
Peter David.
by rabid_republican
Apr 4th, 2002
11:46:30 AM
This just in-
by RenoNevada2000
Apr 4th, 2002
12:52:01 PM
This just in-
by RenoNevada2000
Apr 4th, 2002
12:52:33 PM
Ellis warned us about all of you...
by Facefighter
Apr 5th, 2002
12:57:29 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.