Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

ROCK STAR reviews by Frosty Skywalker and Moe Green....

Hey folks, Harry here.... Frosty Skywalker and Moe Green checks in with looks at ROCK STAR, which... has a great trailer in theaters right now... Has Wahlberg made another winner? From all accounts it seems to work.... but people seem to have wanted it to be 'harder' than it was. Check it out....

Hi Harry, Frosty Skywalker again. Saw Rock Star tonight, the new Mark Wahlberg flick with Jennifer Aniston.....

Do not think I hated Rock Star, I enjoyed the movie, I thought Mark Wahlberg was good as Chris, a devoted hard core "Steel Dragon" fan. Steel Dragon is the make believe band in Rock Star, whose singer is kicked out and is replaced by a tribute band's singer, i.e. Mark Wahlberg. Once in the band, we see what life is like from the inside of a major metal band in the late 80's. The film basically starts in 1985 and goes until a few years after that.

So here is my thought, if you go for Rated R, really go for it. The only real problem with Rock Star is it is PG-13, except with some breasts. That is the only thing. Breasts. Unfortuantely they are not Jennifer Aniston's, but groupies and random women. Now you might be thinking, well this is a test print, and there will be changes....not this time. I saw the final print, complete with credits, all music and dialogue perfect.

Rock Star wants to be a date movie for women, and a dream fantasy for men, and what have we all learned about movies? If you try and capture both audiences, the adult male fan, and the date crowd, you walk in the middle of the road and you end up never capturing either.

That is my beef with this film being rated R. There were so many other roads they could have showed, and they only opened doors and then walked on. If the film was rated PG-13, I guess I could have lived with the choices more, but once you go R, I expect a greater level of detail. Also the film was about one hour and forty five minutes, and during the end credits they show scenes and dialogue from all parts of the film, and they showed deleted scenes. Maybe if the film was two hours....I don't know....I kept trying to think what would have made this film great? What would have pushed it over the bump from just good? And it comes back to choices. If they had chosen a dirtier path, maybe that would have been enough. Once you throw in the possibility of Rock Star being a date movie, you lose the respect you are trying to capture from the metal market. The film is just too PG. The film screams for more sex and drugs.

They show the sunset strip in Hollywood in the late 80's, we all know what went down there. Most of us have seen Behind the Music on Guns 'N Roses....no wait that is the one I am waiting for....most of us have heard the stories, the drugs, the sex....in Rock Star we do see one scene on the strip, and yes there is drugs and some sex, but that is it. Once I got a taste of that life in the movie I started falling in, the movie was finding it's form and then BOOM! back to PG land.

I did not hate the movie, and I did not love the movie. I thought that Rock Star was right in the middle.

Frosty Skywalker

p.s. If you want a quick smile while watching the film, when Mark Wahlberg shows up at the home of Steel Dragon's guitarist he is looking at guitars and memorabilia, one of the pictures on the wall is of Derek Smalls (Spinal Tap) and either the whole band of Steel Dragon, or just the guitarist, either way a great reference

And here's Moe Green....

Harry

Went to the test screening tonight of Rockstar in Glendale. Man, who do you and your readers go to so many of those. What a pain in the ass, getting in line early, things to fill out, rules, grouchy dopes who run 'em. I thought I should write this before I forget what I saw. I don't reckon it with still with me long, because the movie is pretty forgettable. If you've seen the preview you know the whole story. The 1980's Marky Mark a dreamy eyed kid (basically the same character he plays at the start of Boogie Nights, without the dick) in a hair band cover band. That famous band fires the lead singer and they hire MM to take his place, he deals with fame, etc.

The best part and they gave it away in the ad was he buys the Batmobile. For the first half, I had a smile on my face, cute stuff, nice fantasy come true. But slowly it gets bogged down in seriousness, concerning his girl friend (the not at all attractive Jennifer Annistin - I can't believe so many guys dig her). Eventually he has to chose between the shallowness of fame and groupie chicks or the "gee-wiz' neat-o-ness of his high school love. I was bummed out over the fact that he ends up with her and not groupies and drugs. The movie has no visual style. I was more urban in the 80's, so I missed the Hairband thing (I was in to Prince and the Beastie Boys) but I have been educated with VH1's Behind the Music and I know there was much more hedonism going on then in this movie. So like Almost Famous it's so lite, there is not much of a coolness factor. And the music sucks. And there are a lot of long songs, original ones, they are very boring to listen too. The cast is adequate, though you don't get to know many of the supporting characters. And the end is rushed upon us, it makes no sense (he has an appithany!!). Bottom line: it's kinda cute. It's not very funny (I found myself wishing it were funnier and forcing myself to laugh, in desperation). It's not that cool or sharp or perceptive. Basically when I wake up tomorrow all I'll remember is the Batmobile.

From LA

MOE GREEN

Reporting

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

first
by dmodog
Jul 7th, 2001
09:25:27 PM
um
by skoolbus
Jul 7th, 2001
09:36:03 PM
Has this thing been on the shelf long?
by SethShandor
Jul 7th, 2001
09:41:58 PM
thanks DICK.
by DirtyWetSack
Jul 7th, 2001
09:45:00 PM
No
by MaxCalifornia.
Jul 7th, 2001
09:46:54 PM
Can I have an appithany too?
by cds
Jul 7th, 2001
09:49:11 PM
Behind the Music
by SaigonWhore
Jul 7th, 2001
09:49:12 PM
This is the "true" story of Judas Priest
by moondoggm
Jul 8th, 2001
12:03:50 AM
Priest has distanced itself from Marky's Rock Star
by darthpsychotic
Jul 8th, 2001
12:49:15 AM
"It's better to burn out, then to FADE away!"
by reb55_0
Jul 8th, 2001
01:03:41 AM
A quick English Lesson
by The_Devil
Jul 8th, 2001
01:45:27 AM
Dammit!
by The_Devil
Jul 8th, 2001
01:49:55 AM
Is that a stick in your arse?
by SaigonWhore
Jul 8th, 2001
02:29:04 AM
Im juz hear four de typos
by Huneybee
Jul 8th, 2001
03:34:44 AM
"you walk in the middle of the road"????
by The Grin
Jul 8th, 2001
07:20:09 AM
I thought they were taking a more of a comedy
by ArchDiver
Jul 8th, 2001
07:48:02 AM
lame reviewers. this movie is going to be good.
by madkinski
Jul 8th, 2001
09:24:31 AM
nobody seems to mention this is based on what happened in Judas
by bumetalman
Jul 8th, 2001
10:05:49 AM
Obvious Halford Bashing In This Movie
by cineman74
Jul 8th, 2001
10:54:27 AM
Rock Star . . .the Trixster of movies
by ElvisTCB
Jul 8th, 2001
11:22:35 AM
someone actually compared this movie to "Almost Famous"? Say wh
by Smugbug
Jul 8th, 2001
11:48:35 AM
Ratings
by andreasingo
Jul 8th, 2001
12:36:40 PM
Rock Star IS BETTER THAN ALMOST FAMOUS
by 33.3rpm
Jul 8th, 2001
05:06:22 PM
the Replacements
by PLACEMATSFAN
Jul 8th, 2001
09:23:52 PM
Screaming For Vengance!
by GEEKBASHER v3.0
Jul 9th, 2001
07:26:33 AM
appithany, epiphany
by Panthalassa
Jul 9th, 2001
01:54:04 PM
excuse me
by jonny android
Jul 9th, 2001
02:50:50 PM
LSD: I suspect Van Halen shut down The Pleasure Dome for good.
by darthpsychotic
Jul 9th, 2001
09:13:42 PM
Ahhhh, these talkbacks
by GadgetBoy
Jul 10th, 2001
01:46:59 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.